{"id":189913,"date":"2008-03-20T00:00:00","date_gmt":"2008-03-19T18:30:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008"},"modified":"2019-03-10T20:07:50","modified_gmt":"2019-03-10T14:37:50","slug":"subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","title":{"rendered":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008"},"content":{"rendered":"
Karnataka High Court<\/div>\n
Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008<\/div>\n
Author: V.G.Sabhahit<\/div>\n
ll 11:: man noun or Iumumuu xr  * \n\nDATED um um 2o\"'mv or  A}  E  L\n\n1-an uonrnun  %&  jg \u00ab  E E E\n\nR.F.A.No.aos;;99E\"   V\nBETWEEN:   E\n\n1 SUBRAYAMN    \" '\n\nAGED ABOUT 53 YEA'RS;~.4  \n\nS.\/0.LA'l'E NARAYANA,'-, E\n\nKANOOR vj{L1,AaE, \n\n\\.'I!2!'.;JPE.\u00a2'F'E';5;\u00a7JL!!{',~.  ,   \nKona.uu..__  \"     APPELLANT\n\n(By S11:--T-NTR;!{Gi\u00a5i:\u00a7PKTj}:iY:V' \"  )\n\nAND : \n\n1    , \nV .AGED'}'aB0'FJ'F 55. YEARS,\n\n,  s;~a.:.A.'r;=;AA e_I..'.9..'a;*.'.\u00a2\".-'.54\n\n R.fD.HOR'PlCI'i'i'i\ufb01IRE FARM\n miyimi\ufb01rab,\n\"  ..\u00a7_(c\u00a7I)AGU.\n\n2}  M.:N}KN\ufb01{N111AIAH,\n 51' YEARS.\n5,1  .|\\!.A.R.A.Y.A.!\\!A\nBRAHMAGIRI PAI,\n\nV  II.llI\"ll'l'.I I;-r\\r\\Ar-ul\n2 l\\1'\\I'1Jl\\, I\\.\\JIJl'I.\\J'L-V.\n\n'  Ni.N.LINGAPPA,\n\n\n\n2\"!\n\n49 VFMRS,\n\nSi 0.LA'TE NFhR\ufb01'Y'\ufb01\ufb01F\\,\nOPPSYNDICATE BANK,\nTHHWHMWH,\n\nKODAGU.\n\n4. \nS[0.LA'!'E NARAYANA; \n47   \"\nKALLUFIANFI,\nVIRA.JPETTALUK,~._ -   \nKODAGU.   M   '*.\u00bb;vR'ESPONDENTS\n\n(av sen: G 3 KANE! IR m\ufb02\ufb01an :1;   J1. ~ \n\n\"I'\\l_ll\u00a2'.\\. tin  ii'?!  it 11\u00a2 a... ti \"mv:.r.r*~ Anninovn mu\nI \"IE,    L', I: '9' ~_':' '.1! '.' I1'..Jr\\II'I:,I ' fl\n\nJUDGMEN3?' Ants.\u00bb !)ECl~E_F__.'E~~. A33. 10.98 PASSED IN\n\nn.s:.r~io.aoisfa6--ii.r;ii  rm (--;\u00ab.~%-wi. .iiinGF;_, (5-'i\ufb01.i')I'v'.')\nWRAJPET,.'DECREE-lN\u20ac} THE sutmvpon mnrmon AND\nSEPARA'l'E_ Possaasio\ufb01... % \n\nmm; \u00abmin.  abs hearing and  for\n_\u00a711c1ga_Ln1cnt;'Lt_4l1isaVvdaa1_y_  'CO}1.l't delivered the ibllowing:\n\n.l'lII')\ufb02EI!I'I'\n.. ..\n...._....................................\n\n'Fifi. ]l'\\.\u00a3\n\n . \"_\"_\u00ab...__._n 1___ ...1__ .1__\u00a2-__ _I___4._ :___ 1\"': a n1_ __. \u00a21__\n'I  Dy THC ucl\ufb01nuanf\ufb02 111 'Ju35vIVOaU'J] 90 0 I1 -\n\n VViZ!:5a\u00a2yii__Jx{;ti'\u00a7c (Sr. 011.) Vimjpct. is din.-.c~.ted against the\n\njtldgmc\ufb01i  decree. dated 30.10.1993 wherein the suit\n\n    the puainu\ufb02a 3 and 4 has been doomed by holding\n\n\\_9-J*\n\n\n\nthat plainti\ufb02b 3 and 4 are entitled to 1\/3-vi shame  \n\nsuit schcduh pmpcrtisus.\n\n2. The essential facts of thtycagie  \n\nappeal with reference: to the  of     '\n\nt\ufb02almtutamas\ufb02n\ufb02owgz  _   vv\n\nPlainti\ufb02b 1 to 4   the \ufb01le.-. of \n. (.-_,q1;.) Vitttitnct  pom\ufb02on .n...d.\n;...,.....=.... 1:95  the pia'iti's.i'.\ufb01\"s and\n\nfor mean:     pmperuca' . Schcsciuie\n\npmpctrtv   N_o,5\u00a7 in Sy.No.69\/69.\n\nt'*\n\nnine-rt-I-ed ~\n,-.--e_.-.,.. :1-._. V4J.II.:' p....... ....at ,.............., !.I&.I.V.I.\n\ndef-.':--a:;da\ufb02t are iii':-1 A acu\ufb01\ufb01t\n\n    pf iatc Narayana. The fitthcr of the pl'ainti\ufb02's\n\n was possessing md enjoying the\n\n  as his self-acquitted property. Namyann\n\n   daughters by name M.N.Gangam1na and\n\n who an: mam'ed and Inn' 'ng in their\n\n\\-D\n\n\\}\/J\n\n\n\nhusband's place. The father of the plaint\ufb02f and he \n\ndeveloped the schedule property and   t\n\nThe schedule property is   _\n\ntn\"l}n1In and nnnniruul ht! lulu Mn:-n1rnn';'.': \nJ 4\"oI-'V-1 I.\n\nVoIIuMu'&V-' I-Flul-I'-I\u00bb I-Y'-'I-'Inf.-In-I1-'Val 1'!-'V'-I-LI..'l.I-I.Ili.'_' 1-! V 91 -In-I-I ' 'nI'U'U' -I-I. I'-3-H-I-Ml '.'\n\nand he waits? inifnfuired the   snot\ncontributed anything temagds \ufb01ie  the\nlife time of mu:  of land in\nSy.No.69\/5 (9.   enjoyment and\nsince it   it yezfgi\u00e9ot granted in his name\nand the     land was contributed\n  kinds and other properties\nam .he    \"he is .1-.e \ufb01i-1'15: 9.\n\nA.'I__     _I__.4. I'I'I_.!._4_!JI_ 0'! ____'I A _____ _______I__!_._.\ntn\u00a2.\u00bb}Jv\u00a7I.\ufb02IliEu3 mu}-uemlutunt. ruuulma -3 anti -r wen: wvrlung\n\n   No.3 is retired from the Army in the\n\n plain\ufb01\ufb02 tetixed fmm the Army in the\n\n l9\n\n\n\ntrying to me the entire plnint schedule  \n\nincome thereof in wasting and    K \n\nhas been trvm__ ' g to cmea. -te false  \n\n'Iuu.-A- !.iv'L.'.n.I. Ann. 1'-In-5 I-I'!-uVI.=\n\n@m eLeI.I:here. En saith n H-I-I-t. the \n\nt}.ia:-fir \ufb01iie share iii the    is\nfurther avern.-xi that  1'  id \"t1}ieinnte the\ntherefrom. It  3 and 4 are\nentitled to ;1\"f\"\u00a7'.'i\"!'V    schedule properly\nwith the   pmmed to that I.-.\ufb01'ect\n\nand    ztieene pro\ufb01ts.\n\n_   4, 'm\u00bb: aiiit 1\u20acasA'ieeieted by the defendant by \ufb01ling the\n\n V'   relationship between the plaintiffs\n\n    was admitted. It is averted in the written\n\nStatement'  it is utter false to suggest that during the life\n\nI'-3-rung I;-F  rnflnnr nwnuruinn kn run!'-1-I nmi an-I-Int: II'. 1 (115-nn_'n~I\"\n'..Inl-I-\"a\"  -15.55' Il\".I.I'..'-I !.1..l.I.1JI.1.I..Il.1. W ,1. I\n\n SIy.I'io.69i5C2 and it' was in possession and\n\n  enjoyment. It is also false to suggest that the income derived\n\nW\n\nV'   ' 63.\";\n\n\n\nout of the said land was oont\ufb02buted towmds  \n\nfund. It is incorrect to suggest that all the   \n\n__v __.\n\ner.-.1!'-;a.t_u.1I.t1.tI'_11.-d. pmgertiee of late  ,_ \n\n4 4.  ' . \" ' '~\n' \"' \"IL  U muu\ufb01. '15 .I.I.u unto:  u.n.'-uuuu:-u\n\nEU U1. 7\n or fourth pinintiffs nor \"pinintii'r\".\nany amount to the oonsitngc\ufb01enitttbi; A' defendant\naloe put-up mnstntmioh  ;;_.1rhs of rupees\nand plaintiffs :11s1td':~tO  their vacations\nand spend    like a customer staying\nin a  w'*e V the mmringee\n\nx'-..'.!V..- .\n\n.3 \n\nfn -in\"m\n....,\n\n\nrs\ni\nI\nI\n1\nE\nI\nI\nI\nJ\nI\n\n.._. \" -...' .1 ' \"  '\nt tin t \u00a7.I-112'-EI'1':'i'T.\"I\u00a3.\"\"-.}'.U ti-'..k'..1-r' advantage at' the aha:-.-at:-.\n\n!'i'V'!'5Ti.I\"'.I.\n\n w_ of the pihintift\"  an nppiication for gmnt of one acre\n\nA -\u00bbSy.Nt3.59fV5-G_:2 to Tahs\ufb02dar is denied. It is avermcl that\n\n   been allotted to the defendant on merits\n\n it  subject matter of the case and plainti\ufb02is have\n\n  I;0t._4_got'\"nny right. title or interest in the said land. it is\n\n averted that plainti\ufb02b have ac-quimd their\n\n\\..l.!.l.!. I. u\n\nI'\n\n.. .........a ' |._' ..'._ ..-...._.1' 1.:-\n1' 'V. _. -f:=:V1I::u {ans\n\n5\nE.\n\n'7. I have    for the\n\n.-.=.1.'*'-,...,\"....*=...'-t--{'.o&:-;r'.d.'\u00a33;*\u00a3* sand mo  1-:;:u..-- v--wt ap\"-*a.'i:-.3 for\n\nthe \"mu-po'\"'r:x'i=~:;;'1t\u00a7~_\"\u00a7?3'\u00a7   3 anu'\"\" 4. Roopotxietlts\n1 and   ooihnvcmd-Zddoofom the trial court have\nnot choose; \"to this court though they won-.\n\n with  \n\n  ootmoci appearing for the appI.-.iiant-\n\n:\"op1\u00a7:l1t1iit\"i\u00a7t1bt\u00a7:1_'itted that the mm court has mud. in holding\n\ntheit'*~thc--..ple.iti\ufb01\ufb01's 3 and 4 are entitled no 1\/aw share in suit\n\n   \ufb01pmpcrtios. The lmrncd counsel submitted that\n\n   on moon! including the cevidenoe of the defendant\n\nl ..\n\n\\\u00a7Lx\/\"5\n\n\n\n-In\n\ngun.\nIQ\u00bb\n\n. and his witnesses would ckarly show that item \nschedule is. sy.No.s9\/5r;:2 is the  --\nthe defendant. The said property has new  \nfavour of the defendant and  \n\nI_I_n.,_utliorised1y cultivating tngtsmn  and'i.:ti1ie._'~\ufb01athei- er  *\n\ntirue p'iainti.*!'s and defen_e1__t was  in pcvssessi\u00e9bn of the\n\nsaid land.  aTu*e\"\"t:9-t- e\ufb01ntmi  .\u00a7h.r.Le '.111, the said\nplain\ufb01\ufb02s  share in item\n  given up their share in favour\nof the  money in lieu of their share\n\n \"mg-.   without looking into the oral and\n\n   tuidutzed by the defendant has\n\n ._  th- iasttes  .5-.wI.I.. -1' t.._.  and\n\nthmr;:n.~.., the judgment and decree passed 'by' the tr'.:.=-11 ecu. .\n\n .. is  to be set aside and the suit is iiabie ts be\n\nit  dismissed.\n\n\n\ng-I\nI53\n\n'EL  the  counsel appmlin\ufb01' fhe\n\npiainti\ufb01a 3 and 4-respondents 3 and 4 i11.,   tn\u00e9e'ea\u00a7pp-;\u00a21 <\/pre>\n
submitted that plain\ufb01\ufb01b 1 and 2 __Who_ \u00e9hm\ufb01-..H”    ea, <\/p>\n
as CWs.1 and 2 have stated thaf’:4tht-5* <\/p>\n
claiming any share. Defendmet   ” L’<\/p>\n
1 and 2 are schedule   <\/p>\n
that plnin\ufb01\ufb02h have g5Vvt::11.Vfup ‘thc:{_irvV.-u;;.u__’\u00a7 .11: ea”.1i items I<\/p>\n
and 2 of the scl;edI.!_b  “+f4.1~ efenciant in<\/p>\n
IL-.1<\/p>\n
,1’ the ‘_3cw;’–.}\u00a3:i’vT\u00a7,\ufb01’VV.by4.4Vi’iaeit\u00a2 not been proved.<\/p>\n
E?\n<\/p>\n
‘  iof\u00e9.  that father of the
\n     _. _ was also in posses. sion of
\nitem  of ‘  also and the contention of<\/p>\n
the _  said pmperty \u00abcomprised in<\/p>\n
 *  .’Sy;-56.159\/SQ? is f\ufb01e”‘eeH’–tmqui1txl property of the defezgdzmt<\/p>\n
  “11\u00a2J:t”\u00ab.l;ieei1A~e._si;:.betan\ufb01ated and thezefoze. the trial ca-3″:-t<\/p>\n
h.-.=vea__   that t…e pl-.=.:’.’:tL\ufb01’s 3 and 4  entitied to<\/p>\n
113′” in a the aiii’- st’.-heciuie properties and<\/p>\n
A C the judgment and decme passed by the trial<\/p>\n
KSHJ5<\/p>\n
j.. 4…… …-.1..- :!__,g n-t Q ,0: interference in__ this<\/p>\n
$1′ dc!-:A’z’rn…_,in!=I.fjr_m_ in .,th_1’g appeal an.’-‘:<\/p>\n
an 1111…:-I…-. \u00ab>1-u. \ufb01nd-inn nf  I (‘,.(”.’!,’I_” a that  ~_
\nI ‘ ” n  [_l_|_Lr  “J5 ‘Li  ‘WIC ‘or<\/p>\n
pnopcrty was in possession
\nand defendant has to   I51-“JP’-“I1? 1’8
\nthe self-ncquimtl property   ‘-\n<\/p>\n
2) Whr_,5tl1e\u00a7 .’ thc;=._\ufb011:(iiiig”‘o:i:”  mutt that the
\n  ta ;pTrevp”-“_th~\u00a5jt p}m’:nti\ufb02’s have forfeited
\ntheir  taV%Aites;% pies;-1}+\u00abn-1gpfitnc schedule property is<\/p>\n
   of the  court that plain\ufb02\ufb02s
\n aze’~~:g;tit1cd’ to 113-6 sham each in all the suit<\/p>\n
 ‘    ,,\u00a25\u00a2am=  justi\ufb01ed?\n<\/p>\n
VA  Q-;u.l.AV’:_  \u00a3-…’I_….u.–ud- gaunt’ 1-Igrw—d vunnnprl bl!’
\n‘ 5!!  ucr um .I “am In an-M ‘-=’-=’-*~- 1-‘”””-”-“” J<\/p>\n
u-;;.,;  c:;9.._.. —  in this appeal?<\/p>\n
 .A and  the above points as bllowa:<\/p>\n
n1..1’:t_-;g __.w.-. proved that 59,3 AdfVt_he_V;5i.:1iIit sc!1ci1u1c k %<\/p>\n
Point No. 1: In the n\ufb02innative. %
\nPoint No.2: In the ni\ufb01rmative
\nF’oint No.3: In the   _<\/p>\n
‘I”I<\/p>\n
roint No.4: in the negative f-in’  4′<\/p>\n
11. POINTS No. 1 TO
\ntogether since they    “to avoid
\nrepetition. The Lnnbit of  flies in :1
\nnarrow comp;as\u00e9aAt.f1’he ot\ufb01tg  comprises of<\/p>\n
three items’!off\ufb01an\ufb02loittititeuin.    t\ufb02zuk<\/p>\n
‘By No \u00ab5o,m9 m-mm-r–v 1  S_-,’.No.59,’79 m. an-1:.’i””g<\/p>\n
G.-25 {iris  mt.-assuring 1 acme. The<\/p>\n
relation ahiong   is not in dispute. The plaintiff’s<\/p>\n
 =   the sons of Narayana. That having<\/p>\n
 ‘ Tdefence taken by the defendant it is also clear<\/p>\n
.  does not dispute that item 1105.1 and 2 of<\/p>\n
  property belong to the father of the plainti\ufb02is<\/p>\n
x V’ ..  the defendant and they are   pmperties.<\/p>\n
  i. in, the<\/p>\n
sqvvr an -q’-var<\/p>\n
3 and 4 have forfeited their right in respect of item’ pl’:<\/p>\n
of schedule pmpcny as they were paid  K  <\/p>\n
to which they are entitled. So  has pitem-3  <\/p>\n
g’_1’|I’IlI'{l’I’l’lI nrnmprlir in rvmnnnrnprl it  ifhn lY\\\ufb02i\ufb02!1i’.1\ufb02\ufb02 ‘<\/p>\n
‘ill. I V-II-‘|u’ Fl: Elk?’-‘5 I-J II-1′ \\’*I.ra.|’I\u00bb.’I.vJ. &&V’|c’I-E’ \\’ ‘.’V.!-Id ‘If. -l\\n”\u00abl.l<\/p>\n
._.’I_._ I…\n<\/p>\n
rattan’ nus that azm””‘1 fmirpc-1:.*t’y Wsaj:”e., .. 111 –1:cau”.”<arr'p:}';ai\u00e9%t; (if their<\/p>\n
father and in the abgca.'-nee of"ti1ti.: idefeiielant was
\ncultivating the said  L\u00e9oiitendod by the.
\ndefendant tpdtpppp  dint.-Q gpphdduic property
\n  Vtitfre\u00e9._:w;\u00a7s"iiot in possession of
\nhis \u00a3m2.~.er'ff ..h\u00ab:..";  'dtiiliitrated the said land
\n has been granted to him and<\/p>\n
'fn-iv, "inn;-1_ d'f'!'l'I"If nf an I') hand -nu I-uulgn nnirl<\/p>\n
'I'VE
\n1:-Hair'-.'u: 54.1.1.-I.n. – |\\.'.v–I\u00bb -I-I-I-I-I I J val: IJ'|–"!o<\/p>\n
the '.|"!' \ufb01.ne.._:11.:\n<\/p>\n
?’1’1 pr-.’rsr::ru’1i invtwtnirnt-. {Tu r’t ‘iii 0<\/p>\n
it :iE:\u20ac\u00a701I!t\u00a7’t)f–tii\u20ac. joint  Both the pm1ies-plaintiff’s :3 and<\/p>\n
 ‘.4: have lead defendant to substantiate their<\/p>\n
 ‘eontention. So far as plaintiffs 1 and 2 mt.-.<\/p>\n
H   Aperaiicuaiiied. they have been examined as Gwen]  2 by the<\/p>\n
U”\n<\/p>\n
court and they have. stated that the.-.y are. not ” <\/p>\n
any share in the schedule pmpertics.<\/p>\n
12. On behalf of the plajntix\ufb01. pkiintiif *:~1\u00a25;.3\u00a7’.Lii1g:appa.n;A<\/p>\n
is examined as PW, 1. He. hasttnitgtnt\u00e9ii-,tIie
\nin the plaint in his    titntcvj in
\nhis evidence that his   possession of\n<\/p>\n
-.11 t c: three      and land
\nconvnrted intp   was in Army and
\nhe     in the: year
\n1989.   in item Nos. 1 and 23 being<\/p>\n
g1’ante:dLin Kfatrnttrw  their: father. item No.3 has not been<\/p>\n
” V’   ‘fnvour\u00e9 6f’hVny person when the suit was \ufb01led.<\/p>\n
    am doing ooolie work. Their father died in<\/p>\n
. Irina a\ufb02cr the In :5 .nd. after tll.-1’.<\/p>\n
 of the piainti\ufb01a and   sisters am Inarricd.<\/p>\n
   has furthcx deposed in his evidence that all ofthcm have<\/p>\n
~33′<\/p>\n
cultivated the land and he has also contnlbuted  <\/p>\n
development of the land belonging to the  ‘  <\/p>\n
1’11 the suit schedule pmperty wat?t’J($5t1tstt11etecl\u00ab  <\/p>\n
1990 am 1;: has 3139 made t’11e”~.<\/p>\n
4.1.- ……’..1 |………–t, ..’.~.,.: ………:.:.._..;.a..’…”. .e.L~… .;;.;…+ .4-\n<\/p>\n
– 1.1 l..l!.’Ll\ufb02C–v_l.I.l.k.’!.>I. I1.’ wt. ‘I.u~.I,(u_: nu g.u.u.u. 1<\/p>\n
land comprised in item’  ‘wrist.
\nNo.4 and the  name of
\nhimself.  They have
\nsent notice to   suit as per Ex.P1.\n<\/p>\n
He    extract. Ex. P3-postal\n  of notice and he has\n\n   to P29.)-MO  \n\n<\/pre>\n
unbwglrurrlwannfh\ufb01nggf na1|11r1g__n rd-\\-I’ “\\l\u00a7Il”;’l’|l’I’ will-In-I’tnnr’ F111: l’3II’Il\\’I’I!’I’.’ can
\n‘\ufb02u-*:’*-W” -lu’Lu”\\-IuE’.’J-I-I.’-u’ 15- W-‘{u’v”-I J -I’-II ll-Wu’-V-I:-II -I-‘-“W-‘\\’-IVWu”ul ‘I-I’-‘ W.’-Ill’-“\u00bbIIl’ V?”-uhlulpls<\/p>\n
. i.’iIl,.EiC=!’_A!2E1i.JI1(e’y.vOIti\u20acI’ in the name of the defendant. it is<\/p>\n
 eIi\u00a2.ited”i\u00a7i~\u00bb’.t;i:2e;’:;’\u00a23ii::ss-examination that when his father died.<\/p>\n
fotirth  was aged 11 years. He does not kznow as to<\/p>\n
  whethe-r “his father was su\ufb02’ering from epilepsy and was ‘<\/p>\n
\\9’<\/p>\n
L.\n<\/p>\n
unable: to work. It is further elicited that he ”
\nupto 7.\u00bb. standard. He has denied the suggegtidnath\ufb01itll  L<\/p>\n
fa.t1_1c.1′ Lag diicmaclicd upon the stvif   l1czVd\u00e9ca_ <\/p>\n
‘Jun-inn-III I-‘n
\nI-‘.I..I’..’VV<\/p>\n
l.l.l.’CI- dale-. U11 un-\n<\/p>\n
favotlr of his father. it is  eii\u00e9i:ec;
\nexamination that it is 1::t;~tV t111a:=l”ti>’A.si?s_:tis’gVVgV;i,&.~.a_s.yt Vgmothcr
\nwas not well and she Jciticl  1 and 2
\nan-. residing   13-14 years.\n<\/p>\n
They have ndt   their
\nshare.    yer:  Ha.-. was mot:-.i.ving
\n _  __aftcr deduction while he was<\/p>\n
1092? He has<\/p>\n
i
\nE
\nS
\nE
\nI
\nII
\n5<\/span>
\nin
\nE<\/p>\n
V  ”   Vv  ihaf he is st:-.*d”\u00a7 “Ir arrrtirlt
\n  his mother and  and not towmtls
\nV  suit schedule lands and that since it
\nV iv –V   for his wife and mother go to and collect<\/p>\n
H K    order from Post O\ufb02im phc. was .-.u.-nding the<\/p>\n
V<\/p>\n
  aiatiuilt in the name.-. of the. defendant. He has dcnicd<\/p>\n
\\\/W’<\/p>\n
L.\n<\/p>\n
20<\/span><\/p>\n
suggestion that his with is not well and ”
\nsending the. amount to meet the expenses   ‘
\nhis wife and mothor. It is mum-sr  in; Q Ea-<\/p>\n
\\=._,_ minatirm thI3.t his with is w-1-r.’.;. -i’–_i  \u00bb.\\Ji!-:\u00a71vi’::,’:’t: ”<\/p>\n
uopuumom o 3 a W\ufb01ltl\ufb01\ufb01u He
\nBank of itiysou.-. at Htmstur. i-Sis”   in the
\nyear 1994 and she  the time of
\n It is__   ‘   wife is
\nworking    has denied the
\nsuggestion.     Army then.-. was :1
\n    a notiot;-. to attend the<\/p>\n
panchayathi; Hf:  t.ht.=.t the la:-_d_ i.- ::,n.I.r grnntmt<\/p>\n
-. _ no’… 1119-1.-In<\/p>\n
_A.–.\n<\/p>\n
3..   \u20ac_.l’.’__..I .._A.. _….’I is .2 _ -_ l_.’….._..I.I.’ _
\nI11 IIIIITIJUI ‘-J1 ILIC\u00bb ‘E-‘!,’+.’I.l.T-.l.l1.Ii.:I.l..I.I l.’I.l.l.l ll 1 [I C l.l.ll’I.l .lI.I.l.I.l|5C.’-ll 7.<\/p>\n
  have  objections for grant of iom: in<\/p>\n
   It is further elicited in his eman-<\/p>\n
3  _  he had sent a notice stating that land at<\/p>\n
” t 1* oto”;m-.m%%No.3:t should be onottod in favour otjploinmro :3 and 4<\/p>\n
  eatiti -the defendant and not cxcltmivcly in favour of the<\/p>\n
…X
\nvv<\/p>\n
defendant. It is further elicited in his cmss ” <\/p>\n
the land comprised in item Nos. 1 and 2 yieuase\u00e9o  M’ <\/p>\n
oo\ufb02bc and not 5-6 bags of oo\ufb02bc asi \u00a7i1gcgsi\u00a7d..; <\/p>\n
4-11′:-vii-pal -I i nwsng-nlrn inn\ufb01n is.-:1; 1″<\/p>\n
‘I.vJ.l’I.-.l.\\I.\ufb02t.I. J-ll. 11;’: V..\u00ab.u-st-ma Va!-l’I.Il.I.lq.|..l.u.nI|\u00a2I.I.ax-was ua.nn.~-u_. as<\/p>\n
0.
\ni3””” if”t’;’t, {ii .\n<\/p>\n
\ufb01t<\/p>\n
\ufb01o.3
\n He dies not  as ‘t.r=:>””1r.}.I*.VI.:t’:’\u00a74!c”liV’4’5.1r.._ti1\u00ab:-.ttiefezn-tiiant has
\nmade: an application :0.\u00bb    in ita.-.m
\nNo.3 on 12.8._9l.;:Viic   that since.
\nthe extent \u00abif .59    to himself and
\n  \ufb01by receiving amount of<\/p>\n
Rs.5o,(2oo.r-  Rs.50.000_I- in mapect of<\/p>\n
\u00bb    I and 2 of the schoduicr property. iic has<\/p>\n
  __tii\u00a7$”i\u00a7t1ggestian that himself and fourth plain\ufb02\ufb02<\/p>\n
 ‘  Rs.20.000\/- from him and executed received<\/p>\n
V.   naval’ thiit\ufb01oompmminc. entered into on 18.3.95 and balance:<\/p>\n
\\-\u00abN<\/p>\n
 of Rs.30.0D0\/- was paid for which he. 5 not<\/p>\n
\\_,9.J.\n<\/p>\n
i.  ‘i’..z-at  i’<\/p>\n
e.xeeuti91% the receipt and that plain\ufb01\ufb02  <\/p>\n
received Rs.30,000\/- subaecluently. The   <\/p>\n
E.\n<\/p>\n
_-t  in. his  — -_<\/p>\n
p1.ei_n_t1′!’ Next was   11;\n<\/p>\n
n’,
\n5 .\n<\/p>\n
,3
\nin <\/p>\n
the pa-.–.e-.5-.;-e.=.-.~.,gs on 12; :5: ia4:\u20ac-ufther ee:.~r:a: *=
\ncross-e.xumuu1′ tion that   ‘\ufb02out
\nfor granting item No.3  int  of the
\ndefendant after     the shame in
\nthe family    the suggestion
\nthat the la::nti”v- unauthorisedly and be
\nevicted\u00bb the  uuctiy  ‘unauthorised cultivation
\nof       of  <\/p>\n
to h….’–. has \ufb02ee est’.-“.5”-.;.,et*.<.*:*. that pk-u..–t:\ufb01's 1 and 2<\/p>\n
   tem $503.1 and 2': in favour of the<\/p>\n
\u00bbglefendunt, is further elicited in his emee-examination<\/p>\n
 't1tut,it Vvisttviiat  to suggest that himself and platnti\ufb02' No.4<\/p>\n
  their right in the family pmperties and they<\/p>\n
H   have given-up their right in respect of family pmpertiee by<\/p>\n
 the amount in lieu of the shale. It is further<\/p>\n
Hz\u00bb.\/"s
\n'I'D'<\/p>\n
elicited in his cI'0ss~ex\u00a3_unination that his  <\/p>\n
possession of the schedule land about 10-    '  <\/p>\n
death.\n<\/p>\n
13. PW.2 is plnintiif Nce.e4oagao1x{1;-e\ufb01e hae’v:eou\u00a7obo1eited  \u00bb<\/p>\n
the evidence of PW.1 and ”  {was also
\nsending the amount fttzgffotjltixragiouzi schedule lands<\/p>\n
.!1<\/p>\n
t11_-.t     <\/p>\n
:… :…1.. :   ,.–‘\ufb02.’~’
\n.l.l.l. m =  -i\u00a7..”‘l’T””‘ _ M<\/p>\n
1!.<\/p>\n
\n\nI511\n\nshame    Exs.r\"*.i'n'i and mi --\n<\/pre>\n
Ireeipfs   of Lu\ufb01kling material and he was
\nalso  the defendant for cultivation of<\/p>\n
the Aland  ._ thafv’*his iiiiother was receiving Re. l50l- per<\/p>\n
 V’  . mozogthi-.”oHe”o-has  moeipta as per Exe.P.’:\\-‘3 to 36. The
\n    item N03 has not been allotted to his
\n it poeeeeeiox; of  plnin\ufb01\ufb02’ No.3 and the<\/p>\n
‘ A   -1- ant’ I-11:: Inna: nnrnrniv;-Qt’ 1′-rt {fawn (‘I Q Inna\n<\/p>\n
– I. \\.- I 1 \\.’v\\.- -r. :\n<\/p>\n
Lu.|.\\.I. I..t.u.\u00ab u.1.I..I.I..I. veuyzsml nu. nu.-.:.u w u<\/p>\n
 ooliv\ufb01erted into a paddy innci and now there is a oo\ufb01ee piant<\/p>\n
   the said land. It is elicited that he cannot idcnuizy the<\/p>\n
\\)
\n\\r<\/p>\n
signature. in the sale. data cxccttted by plaintiff   K
\nper Ex.Dl3. It is further elicited that he. was    <\/p>\n
when his father died. He was smdS?5iig”in <\/p>\n
e:-.’pih.:p”y r-‘-2*’: hi” -“ether S’t.’\u00a2’;’\u00a5t’-‘i”-Z””\u00bb,- ‘\u00a7;a.”alysis. ‘3-is …;’;;”.-nltt-.:..-‘1<\/p>\n
that his wife is working   it \ufb01uthsi”
\nin his cmss-cxttminatioti   No.3 was a
\npaddy land. Hef1:ia_s   tttst land was being
\ncultivated Mr    that since thy.-.y
\ncould  it of water they had
\nleft    started cultivating the said
\nIn\ufb02d nndiiggndg-..  lb! g\ufb02lllt of  and that it<\/p>\n
t”‘i” t” ‘ ‘ “M” ‘*-“‘ No.3 1* ” “mt ‘ is<\/p>\n
 dei’~t=rudant”  in It .1:-r335; I iu;::.u 113… u.u.’u.<\/p>\n
\u00bb gmnttrd  absolutely as owner. it is furthc.-.r’ eeiicitc:-d in<\/p>\n
  __  ation that it is true that land comprised’ ‘ in<\/p>\n
 1’t”3t:Jt3’ ‘tvas allotted to the. defendant that they have<\/p>\n
   appeal before the Assistant Commissioner against<\/p>\n
‘  grant. It is furthcr elicited that it is not true to<\/p>\n
v’<\/p>\n
that tits fatty;-.:’*–g_\u00e9as stt\ufb01edng ” ._<\/p>\n
suggest that since he getmtezager extent of land  <\/p>\n
Re.50.000]- as per the compromise  V’  <\/p>\n
-..<-nw.n.= an. '9 '-\n<\/p>\n
t-vemm-I! :1.-zzipt for Ret30,l_)()t_),f-    <\/p>\n
. L . ‘. . . V  .. .’ ~.\n<\/p>\n
1113 1]g.l.!’l’ In .I.’\u00ab’.3!!1JUUt U1 IIC-LIV}. nu.-r:.?._ q3i._u.u 4::  G-..u. -..~~..u…’m,\u00bb<\/p>\n
pmpertiee. He has aieo    V\ufb01p\ufb01\ufb01’
\nfmm Rs.2D,000l– he   tt;iib9tlnt\ufb01ef’Rs;i\u00a7tO,fIX)\/ –
\nin etush from the aerendaist    their right
\nto claim theilj,   ef the schedule
\nproperties  property with the<\/p>\n
 cf the \u00e9tefeadiint.\n<\/p>\n
  and he has depeeed. in<\/p>\n
his  tltat   the plnin\ufb01\ufb01e and the defendant.<\/p>\n
. V.  =   the properties in possession of
\n  N.::a’av_ ‘ ‘, of plaintif\ufb01s and the defendant. Plmnurrs 3<\/p>\n
 and  have iv:-.tti\ufb011ed.. Lara-:1 vTw’.1′-E:i”Ji’i\ufb01u’:’a”.”: in items 1 mm’. a -…
\n theafnchedule property  30 to 40 bags of coffee seen. ’15<\/p>\n
  tfand paddy was grown by thther of plm’:_nti\ufb02’e and the<\/p>\n
\\1″\n<\/p>\n
defendant. It is elicited in his cm.-ms-cxmmilaation ” <\/p>\n
worldng as teacher in the school situated pyt\ufb01e gm Ear
\npisnri land ofitcm No.3 ofthe ucmgaitte % .,  <\/p>\n
I._aii.’I.I..n.te\u00a7. that pkmv\ufb01 3 9…?-.4. 4 I-“V\u00a7’._sL.v,-‘:12.-.1~.ts; -=~’-i~”v ti.-V ‘has. ”<\/p>\n
_’I-..\u00a3_..I LI..- A.’I.. ‘J. I.<\/p>\n
_.. .._.._4.:-._ .2, .”.L~ _: v.__- ‘ .:_|”.
\nucumu um an 531.’-nu 11 u.l.l:ll us:  1,<\/p>\n
l\ufb01fxfmn\ufb01g ntuf  f3 \ufb01’.’11j
\nIfhinti\ufb01s 3 and 4. It if:   elven.\n<\/p>\n
examination that ainoe’ l5_’   the date. of
\ndeposition Qua; cultivating
\nthe schedu\ufb01d   in-his moss-\n<\/p>\n
  Fv!\u00a7.\u20ac{\ufb01v\u00a7as- a..lbI;nnn land and plm’nti\ufb02’a
\nand dc;f\u00a2nd\u00a7\\nf,?\u00a7’v’~fg\u00a7;tfl:1:cr_ that land in the paddy<\/p>\n
1 mt He  1:1.-.;..z3″.!.2-.–g\u00a2.!.-25\u00a2;-.1.-n  pLn.;-r.!i*.’t’-.s 4% 91:4 5<\/p>\n
changes ma 3-‘<\/p>\n
. farfeiie\ufb01  \ufb02it)’ \ufb01e”: I ai\ufb02u at ‘f scheu\ufb01iie prrnpe\ufb01ir:-.1:<\/p>\n
   in their share in respect of the ache.-.d1fl:=<\/p>\n
 m”A.=D’|J\\Ill)’:i)’| I-nu-an A\ufb01l\ufb02d\ufb01\ufb01\ufb02 1′ his gnniplnuu-spun; I~ nud-
\n‘-Vt.’ I1 lIJ!.’VI..’I.l.I.’l.l’.l. HI-“\u00a7 KIX’ l I-I-Iv LIE C\u00abV.ll.l!7-.I.-“.71.: <\/p>\n
‘. i::.I:_  a resident’ of Kmmr viiiage. and he kn:-.w \ufb01ither of<\/p>\n
   and defendant-Nmtayan. Namyan was his muck-..<\/p>\n
\\..\u00ab.\u00ab><\/p>\n
27<\/span><\/p>\n
Namyan was in possession of the achedtll\ufb01  <\/p>\n
Sy.No.69-5C measuring 1 acre and was;   ” <\/p>\n
in posacs_ aion of Nmny_nna–\ufb01ithc\u00a2r \u00a7)f<\/p>\n
-1._.I-..1- _.._. ‘. .1… .__…..\u00a2. :..’..p.._;.’.<\/p>\n
maumuum \ufb011UpI’:”.i”i? ahmit 4:’) ya-Lg.\u00bb an — \u00a7..ll’.’-I!J_I’!_’3
\n 3 and 4   ” after
\nretirement and they   gmulopment of
\nthe schedule    k mm’ ation
\nthat he is     is furthc_-.r elicited
\nthat   ‘i4\u00a7.nd”\u00a7Qomp1is\u00a2d in item No.3
\ninto   next before the date of his<\/p>\n
he hm<\/p>\n
4.-1<\/p>\n
-1-nmi:-‘m;\u00bb; %:–3;4j9s;,  h.\u00a7\u00a7;\u20ac3 dc-.1Led. suggc-.;ti.L!n \u00a2I..:,.n.\u00a2<\/p>\n
‘5-I ‘Er ~.r v.r\u00a2.s-aw<\/p>\n
\u00a2 -1: |…_…I ________.-.___-u 2.. .u._._…_
\nI I 111111.! (.’~O!.Il.])l’1BM.7{l ll! lIl’.’\u00bbIl.I.<\/p>\n
% :j~ae.3 ofvAtE1\u00a2ai\u00e9”E1Ig:d11h pmpeny. He has admitted that piaintiff<\/p>\n
 N\u20ac_i3Ai”s’  Thithimnthi and plm’nti\ufb01’ No.4 is staying<\/p>\n
in i’ca11u%I\u00a7%ami<\/p>\n
 ,  .16. Defendant is cxammcx.1′ ‘ as E’J”w’.i and he has<\/p>\n
ijsitmuted the avermcnts made. in the written statement in<\/p>\n
his catamitmtion-in-chief and has stated that  <\/p>\n
of the schedule pmpcertics were in possessiafh   _ <\/p>\n
and item No.3 of the schedule.  is <\/p>\n
nnn-nnmhr If H . .\n<\/p>\n
 ‘J I I ‘ V’ E’? -C’D”f’ E Q ‘ 1.95’ ‘  ‘ V  -‘:HI ‘C:-LH-‘<\/p>\n
‘”‘-W P. $”””””‘l!*..!”..d .!”\u00a3.”‘ <\/p>\n
V 3″\n<\/p>\n
_ ‘I_..__._’l ._.___’I L<\/p>\n
i\ufb01t\u00e9 may Inna cl n-xea\ufb01-rtfw-s
\nland. His father was s1T1’.Ti;-x.Iing~A’i;1’$Vi3z:psy .\u00ab-liihcte.  yt-4:195\u00bb,
\n his mother
\nafter the  the;   was not well.\n<\/p>\n
Plaint\ufb02f .Nc\u00a7.3    No.4 was ngetl
\nnine.  t:g1tatej\u00a7\u00a3t\u00a2i\u00e9m~tl.tor  his father and after -the<\/p>\n
death mg  his mother-are looking .aft’er<\/p>\n
V he was:  in the land of others on contract hatsiq <\/p>\n
   to plain\ufb01ifs 3 and 4 and constructecl a<\/p>\n
-.’-9 H e.-rev-rl “41- \u00a7\u00a3’_…;”.”‘.,t’.’J=<\/p>\n
 hdltstz the scheadulc. property. Plaintiffs ‘3  -4’<\/p>\n
R   j-minted  they did not make. any <.\\on_tn'_bution for the<\/p>\n
' .Iht1ni1gc.ment of the. family lands or for the dam-.lopmcnt_ of<\/p>\n
Kr"\n<\/p>\n
_ ‘.1<\/p>\n
29<\/span><\/p>\n
the-. same. He has furthcr dcposcxl that
\nagmcd to mccivc amount of Rs.50.000\/-  jg:  <\/p>\n
shame in items 1 and 2 of the  <\/p>\n
an!” 91′  I’ 131′ IHIIIIH bun   \u00a2h\u20ac’;l’I”\u00a7’.Il’l’a”|ILlJ\u00a7l’I  has<\/p>\n
II-IBIS Yv’I.rI.Il\\I Iv V I.I.\\.-I.I.’_’_I\\l I-!J.\u00abII-..|ulI.- 1f’J|-PVI-IV-I ‘Fa”‘–‘ .’<\/p>\n
meager arnd that fh\ufb01\ufb01\ufb01h thejw.  tiave
\ncxecutcd document in  :4  hatu?c”not}c.-xcceutexi
\nany document. He has  receiving the
\namount tum;    and 4 have
\nmnsmmtc\ufb01\ufb01oaao  ‘ ttas allotted to them
\nas  been allotted land in
\n  ltouac in 20 cents of  out<\/p>\n
,,……..u ..  .,._..=. …….,<\/p>\n
of Rc.5Q;!3{,)f.3{.e  and ninama _9q pm. ..a..n<\/p>\n
oo12″‘i’aE\u00a7’t1u”‘(‘-\ufb01tiati the’-‘no’_i1sc.a\ufb01c’r mo”  Rs.5t’i.t\ufb021″”‘5i – 110’ In <\/p>\n
\u00bbA      in item Noo.1 and 2 of the <\/p>\n
  A   1 and 2 have executed an}: dead as<\/p>\n
Ex;:o13’7scning 50 cents of land which would fall to their<\/p>\n
  Aaham items 1 and 2 in his favour. Wife. of plain\ufb01\ufb02 No.3<\/p>\n
‘ snot wcll. his mother was also not well, the amount was<\/p>\n
KR’<\/p>\n
sent by plm’nti\ufb01’ No.3 to meet the expenses of  <\/p>\n
his wife and mother. Item No.3 is a   K  <\/p>\n
La\ufb01-\n<\/p>\n
–UJ’-I I<\/p>\n
In<\/p>\n
I- In vuunu-| urn It-r
\n. ..-an”. for ‘..-_.r.$ of -=*-if an<\/p>\n
F<\/p>\n
said land got cuitivatea
\nproperty is the self-ac:z1:1i1’ed.VAo-.(1And ii gmwn
\nwife: in item No.3 of .1…   {Ind plninti\ufb01s 3
\nand 4 have  acquisition of
\nthe said land   the said land and
\nthey have.    item No.3 of the
\n  the defendant. His fathcr had<\/p>\n
. VFW.’ mm<\/p>\n
not  item  of the s.I.cel-.–*…..1-.1-:2 paw–rhr r-mi<\/p>\n
plaizz\ufb01\ufb01o have not right in the  iieii i’v’o..’:’s of tho.<\/p>\n
\u00bb’ moasuring 1  He has produced<\/p>\n
 by plainti\ufb02’ No.3 for Rs.20.000\/-. He has<\/p>\n
piodtiooii tho me dead oxccutod by plointi\ufb02is 1 and 2 as per<\/p>\n
   E1;._l.) 13′”ond mocipt executed by plaint1’\ufb01’ No.4 on per Ex.D23<\/p>\n
   of their sham in the joint family properties. He has<\/p>\n
\\M<\/p>\n
  was in possession of      <\/p>\n
further deposed that he was getting land. of <\/p>\n
on vam basis and on contract basis and he woo’ _ V’ <\/p>\n
-11-; ‘_._nd. be.-.1on.gi.n_g to   D2-3′ <\/p>\n
land has not been men\ufb01ooe\ufb01.o.ph\/in,  .1?’  is
\nelicited in his cmsa-exrimjpatio\ufb01   was
\npttmhnsed by   He paid
\nRs.30,0()g’_    ‘has no receipt
\n  was present when
\nthe amount    the suggestion that he-.<\/p>\n
 the ‘.oi”th\u00a2 pllrposc of this case.<\/p>\n
5′    \u20ac ;3.IV) \u00a7  Am1a1ah’ has dcpmed in his<\/p>\n
  –  in\ufb02 9 that he knows the plmnti\ufb02s and<\/p>\n
  :tVI1_c.u their father Narayana. He.-. came. to<\/p>\n
we
\nIi<\/p>\n
V1.1 -.- -.-mun. rl can J -. .. ~ .-<\/p>\n
I’
\nI<\/p>\n
4.3 -..4..–1.:;,\u00a2.;1 ..t..m._\u00a2  m 59 .- ‘ ‘hf up 1950<\/p>\n
1<\/span><\/p>\n
.. .1
\n1 u. ‘2: (‘J-f \ufb02ii\ufb02<\/p>\n
9!
\nF:\n<\/p>\n
…. I1 ..\n<\/p>\n
.-JJJ. IV Ll<\/p>\n
 soli\u00e9\ufb02tlk properties and he ciied about 3?. to 3 years after<\/p>\n
‘(teeming to Kanur. Defendant was c-.u1tivatiI’1g the land of<\/p>\n
\\ \ufb01x<\/p>\n
V<\/p>\n
othc.-.113 on contract basis and item No.3 has  <\/p>\n
favour of the defendant. He. has further   K  <\/p>\n
 of his cxamination–in-chis.\u00e9fm’that ._iit..’-In-S N\u00a7j.:3 was <\/p>\n
nnianrvi Inna-I 4:-n1-I-in-r 1’1′ urns: Fnrns. ‘1’1rl’ ‘ N Iran ”
\n]_JI.l.l\ufb01\u00a5I.I.-l-I- Jl.!.|.l.’l..l.5 H.-1..I.I.J.u\\.-1. .|.L rrsuuv I.-L7-n,-.–.a-1-In.s.a|-L-__w.I.r –Vv g.<\/p>\n
_ Q..___”. __  ; ‘L _ -1’
\nI.\n<\/p>\n
VEII’isD1lB Lands info   1 ‘\ufb01e.'”—-i._ w 1_  c’a:,\u00a7-?w.\u00bbtur ‘E<\/p>\n
watcr he. had left it  \ufb02 ams~*’\u00e9i1dtivated
\nby Poovaiah for one   cultivated by
\nDcvaiah for f;gne.?.Qygear.   cultivation of
\nland for “9-__a.f    started cultivation
\nof item’   into a. co\ufb02he land and<\/p>\n
 =2;.n_ve=.  suit schedule pmpmy. He has<\/p>\n
f-._’.rt….-.-P. cl.-sages.” ‘hat 3}.-amt-.\ufb01’s  and 4  been pa.”<\/p>\n
\u00bb ‘mgrectttcd receipt in that ‘behalf’. It is elicited in<\/p>\n
  that it is not true to suggest that item<\/p>\n
N-ai\ufb01  the property acquired by the. defendant. It is<\/p>\n
 ‘*fr.11fthc-Vi \ufb01celicited that he does not know as to whether<\/p>\n
 3 and 4 have also ptuchascd the building<\/p>\n
\\3~’<\/p>\n
33<\/span><\/p>\n
materials for construction of the house in schedttls” <\/p>\n
is spec’.I\ufb01c’.’ ally elicited in his further close-exa.Vmm__f”   H<\/p>\n
in 1959 item No.3 of the scht\u00a7i’it.tle”‘Q1i\u00a7;Jear’t3tV:_”<\/p>\n
1…”: _._.._1 4-:___…_.1:.._’ 1.- I_n _u. |___’_._;;;. __ .1″ a.___-i ._ _”  ;1_..
\n3.111″ 1115.! IHUIEHIUI I-1 ‘ I51′. 1′    16111.1.’-(.1 H111′-<\/p>\n
  ‘l”‘”hen-. was    before<\/p>\n
amount was paid to   jt \u20acn:_ts agreed that
\nbalance amount of    to plninti\ufb02’s
\n3 and 4 tewtiidst\u00bb “~i_11::._:ite_r:1s 1 and 2 of the<\/p>\n
1d;  the brother-in–1aw of plainti\ufb02s<\/p>\n
and  11\u00a2  tlie husband of Poovnmma second<\/p>\n
 V’   sister of plaintiffs and defendant.<\/p>\n
  his examination-in-chief that after the<\/p>\n
‘, nnnnnm\ufb02nd I: (I’ll!
\n.,1.I.I.vln.-J. \\.\u00a7.’U’; L13 51.1-r’II’.\u00ab<\/p>\n
degatii 9!. d d  deiesdsnt managed the _:_=-_.i_l,v<\/p>\n
 the marriage of sisters. “i”‘nem was no cuiiivation<\/p>\n
   1 new 25 cents of land during the life time of Namynna<\/p>\n
\\j?~d~<\/p>\n
and mm was managed by the defendant  <\/p>\n
has put-up a house in item Nos. 1 and 2 of <\/p>\n
 by spending amount and   <\/p>\n
m1rn1irnrl nvnnnrtv !_1,_1_1_g.i_ i_p_ {mm in;   “__:_=..I}. <\/p>\n
gr.-.1-.te.:’. to the defe.-rntirunt -w-as
\nhas been convened by ~t.i;_\u00a2    and
\nthereafter to oo\ufb01ee      depo\ufb02\ufb01d that
\nplninti\ufb02b 3    their shale in
\nthe family   defendant and
\nthey  share and defendant
\npaid  ‘.3’iand 4. P1ainti\ufb01’ No.3 signed<\/p>\n
the receipt t._a1;\u20ac.i p.i.\u00ab:i.1.itit.’\u00a3’ 1;. net stoned. .11….  ..’.:..<\/p>\n
ef each shouki be paid to  3 and 4 in<\/p>\n
emit\u00bb: in the family properties. 1: is elicited in<\/p>\n
hie””‘*mue:e-t\ufb01emination that all the three items of the<\/p>\n
  : pmperties have a common fence. It is further<\/p>\n
   it: his ewes-examination that pktixiti\ufb02b 3 and 4<\/p>\n
\\o.Q_
\n\\;”‘V<\/p>\n
35<\/span><\/p>\n
when they were in Army, were sending amo11n.$.._t\u00a2..fi:\u00e9:Sf” <\/p>\n
mother and wife. He has denied suggestion  ‘<\/p>\n
was not in possession of item No.3 Mfhk.-L  <\/p>\n
If in Iv-H11-r nl-inifn\ufb02 -111 hi: n-nnu<\/p>\n
Q\n<\/p>\n
– -I-I-V -ELI} I-I-I”-‘bl ‘-‘I”0″”-0’-rl -I-5-I -I-ll-‘J VJ-I-V–“II? \u00a5”\u00a5’m””‘V<\/p>\n
between 13it.un’iifI\u00b0s 3 and 4 was \ufb02ag?” 11′.’-Cl, ‘mm ” to <\/p>\n
19. Dw.4-c.B.M;it:m\u00a7ga .Aia::sjv.%’Aj’ca\u00ab-,poaed in his<\/p>\n
–   T.\n<\/p>\n
_…. c-s..1…1-..=” E1.–‘….1.;-, 3:  _.’  ‘
\n3r.=vi.1. mun iii \u20ac’5\ufb01.l.].g.\ufb02j.t1;., Ki. ll! =_vu.:t<\/p>\n
deposed that V:mi1o:Vt i\u00a7,gV tl1c piaintiffs and the
\ndefcndafint di.\u00a7f\u00a71.s\u00a7i_fe _ in  of the schmlule
\npmpe.rty  \u00a321:-:s%   in the proceedings book<\/p>\n
maintained 11:-. ‘ hub  the same as per Ex.P33<\/p>\n
” ”  ..ci1t1-‘_sVr\u00e9i\u00e9i”itiarkuc! as Ex. mam) and $3.30)) is the:<\/p>\n
   defendant has paid Rs. 1,000 l- to the:<\/p>\n
t e ..in”nB.1.’!II’E’- f the Pmsidcnt of t1I.l’.’-<\/p>\n
 not mentioned in Ex.1″)3:3(a) extent of hand is also not<\/p>\n
xew<\/p>\n
mentioned. He has denied the suggestion ” <\/p>\n
pmeeedings took place.\n<\/p>\n
20. DW.5-Basavamju was  ~’<\/p>\n
Gmma Panclmyat, Kanur r;i1_d~.. Vxhals
\n that he knows .. the  and<\/p>\n
there was a  among’   and the<\/p>\n
w.-.-a-..–n.– 1: Vi …n.-.-.\u00bb w. -1-: ru”v\ufb01’-‘ow-d|.’, — – -. w. -an-rv -u. van-<\/p>\n
(1 . n\ufb02 _1_|_ Il7h’  II!’ 5  .   \ufb01nm<\/p>\n
‘pr\ufb01 P\u20acos.?3’_tif-iy  the pm\ufb01\ufb01y. it
\nis elicited  ‘:’tio11\ufb02;tiiat he does not know
\nthe   was no discussion
\nmgmdixlg   the panchnyat proceedings.
\nIt is j\ufb01ttthellr tliatlilo pmeeedings took place in the<\/p>\n
 V’   and mine ‘is deposing falsely.<\/p>\n
 .fl,A2l1.l’l’.ow.l54sanesh was working as soA., in Talulc<\/p>\n
 has pmduc-4.-d the papers pertcdning to item<\/p>\n
V.  I\\'<.r..3_  the schedule property as per Ex.D35 and got<\/p>\n
   Ex.o35(a) to (r ). It is elicited in his cross-<\/p>\n
\\s..3,;\n<\/p>\n
\\.\/”‘.\n<\/p>\n
\u00abI<\/p>\n
exalzniaation that defendant had given an ”  –
\ngrant of land on 29.6.1990 and plaintiffs 3   d<\/p>\n
for gmn_ t of land in favour of the de\u00a3\u00a2’:\u00a7&!ane.e.\u00a7 H, we <\/p>\n
HI<\/p>\n
\ufb02u: an nan-r Rx n.’-l\ufb01\ufb02ul if in   I’\\II’.”!’.h’!.Ig’. <\/p>\n
encmached by plaain\ufb01iffags 111: deteutidnt and
\nland in item No.3 was   and was
\nfound to be in_  ;m2. is the sale
\ndeed execttgetidd’ “I  of _plaint1’\ufb02’
\nNo.3 and  ttptheir share 50 cents in the<\/p>\n
scheddk  by plnin\ufb01\ufb02s 1 and 2 as the<\/p>\n
q._-aw.-a.-‘-u-v 1.. 3… _. -our -II-no—-‘<\/p>\n
slm-.:e wh.’k}–h_ “in vlrlms-age-22 Exsg\ufb02l\u00e9 -.nd  am<\/p>\n
th”. ruzc\ufb01cu\ufb01li’ 77” to have he-.-‘.’.n exen\ufb01iitai Err” ‘”ic.”uu”””‘*m:.e. iii<\/p>\n
 VAE:xe.D  survey numbers have not been stated and<\/p>\n
d”‘i?1\u00e9L’dD;%3V’ir\u00a7h_x19t’ by defendant No.4 and revenue stamp I<\/p>\n
is   cancelled and Ex.Dl4 beam .-ngnn’ tune of<\/p>\n
..  No.3 and said that Re.20.000]- has been <\/p>\n
\\:U’<\/p>\n
.r<\/p>\n
O<\/p>\n
\ufb01om the defendant. In the said receipt also. of <\/p>\n
the survey number and the land is not mentioo\u00e9ntl. ‘  <\/p>\n
22. It is elm’: on appreciation  <\/p>\n
on record. that though the   .:'{hot  *<\/p>\n
Nomyan-father of the   was in<\/p>\n
possession of items  5.2  No.3 of the<\/p>\n
property. fh-:2  _ho.s’p”o’$ ‘. –ib-‘tcoi\ufb01.a\u20acu-d. _ 11 the other<\/p>\n
hand. the    of the defendant
\nmust{hm_re_A  tI\u00a7ot.’VV_1end comprised in item No.3 of
\nSy.No.tfi9[S!3  was also in possession of<\/p>\n
Noxoyaoa-&io..:fother of  plninti\ufb01b and defendant as DW2<\/p>\n
% kA  – naammm in 1ii”a’L”‘e:v\u00a3amin:ttion-in-chief itself in pom-7 of<\/p>\n
    item No.3 was a poioari property 4-_-arlier.<\/p>\n
‘A -.wae ,.fo:”oetl:=.:-.11 9.2.. N-..-._I,r.,oo. oonverted. it mto _po.d.dy<\/p>\n
 woo} in possession of item No.3 of  pmpe\ufb01y<\/p>\n
‘   fsinoe 1959 and he had grown mgi in the said land.<\/p>\n
or<\/p>\n
 , (i\ufb01f6I%\u00a7\u00a3’iaIi’i “i””nc further’ of the defendant that tn:<\/p>\n
The contention of the defendant that land comprises!’  ” <\/p>\n
No.3 of Sy.No.69l5C1 mcasurine 1   <\/span><\/p>\n
 7 ion of Narayana has not  ‘s:1bs_tat1t..it1_’tsci..<\/p>\n
1.1.! I VI<\/p>\n
-‘””-.-“m’ *-‘…a.-.’.-.:-. M DWs.1 9.3:! 2 as  tl-gs  * ‘<\/p>\n
 on beiisif of the  tfist._iafi\u00e9’i_:  BIT”V-ifl\ufb01
\ncultivated by one poov-mil andiittitttittafsndtt\ufb01t”‘tItspasscd
\ninto the land and staitsii  said land
\nand the land is     his own right
\nhas also    the cvidc.-\u00abnee. of
\nPWs.1    witncsscs as mfen\ufb02ed
\nto  is   which is oonobomtccl by<\/p>\n
+1-. –‘-‘-vi’-V’-‘~.-2 VA  .’;.””-.1.’-V;-:.A’3″-.=;~”t’J” ‘3’ “‘.'”=..’:-.:’.’.-.m M’ **-.*m’ at’ the<\/p>\n
  VA    item No.3 was granted to him and he has<\/p>\n
 s\ufb01zotitityiiof Rs.3.489]- out of his own income has<\/p>\n
  substantiated though he has stated in his<\/p>\n
H  cezrtiiisnc\u00e9\u00e9’ ‘that he was cultivating the land of othms on B.<\/p>\n
it   basis and was lmvixig his own income-.. Hf: has<\/p>\n
\\_3-..,\/’s<\/p>\n
nowhere stated in his evidence that the ” <\/p>\n
for giant of item No.3 of the schedule pmpeny5e.ej;.iejiexieure ei L<\/p>\n
was gait! out of his separate  iii”  <\/p>\n
-1
\nV’; q.-vs.-w.r.-.-uu 1.14;’: _1.r4uI– Inna\u00bb.-<\/p>\n
d . .._-.  area
\nin favourof the ciefei1dant_ant1.Afhee.   favour
\nof the defendant was    of the unit.
\n011 the other’.Vhai1ci.  upemeal of the
\nmaterial on   2 have left the
\nvillage    and plaintiffs 3 and
\n4   the defendant who wee in<\/p>\n
tr: 1.4-la-u.ra mu-Io-v.~n I. I- I-U.Iql’lol 5. \\ -I.aI ‘J1!-I<\/p>\n
 ieiiow  any independent income of  own to pay<\/p>\n
 of land. The material on record shows<\/p>\n
V it . that”*the..’ land was in poeeeeeion of father of plainti\ufb02i!<\/p>\n
   defendant in 1959 itself and thexefoie. it ie clear that<\/p>\n
   of the trial court that item No.3 is akin property<\/p>\n
I-9.\n<\/p>\n
vv<\/p>\n
1. hernn _’__I_ 1111-run-rrl t  <\/p>\n
which was in possession of \ufb01ithsr of ”
\ndefendant has railed to pmve that it is his   ‘<\/p>\n
promrty is justified. So far as theinntis 11._0l’Ii1Jl’i\u00a3iIAi:V:I_ii’!\u00b03_ii.  <\/p>\n
N03,] and 2 \u00a3 the: sci’…-.dnL=
\ndefendant tttimits fhaf fhey   is
\nNaraynnn. He also admits’   in the
\nsaid pmpcrtics.  1 and 2
\ncxscttted at     their share.-. in
\nitem Nos.1     It is the fuxthcr
\n(-_-113g-_ of    3 and 4 have also
\nrorreited.1theirvtd;gt5tVd\u00bb .3: their share in respect of<\/p>\n
V  4. $5554.’ \\. – 1.:-a. $.71.-Lu. ‘J I..u..r ‘Aug ‘.555 -u.–..–u.I. 5-J<\/p>\n
Hint-n3 ‘I 983   t\\1’fI’I’\\ll1″fIf nu \ufb02u-Ir nmwn\ufb02 In<\/p>\n
x   jzigtaving  to the meager extent of land
\n1 as their share. The said contention is not<\/p>\n
‘V V’ .V at  sttlistttiitiatsd. It is also clear from the perusal of the
\n  salt.-. deed produced by the defendant as per<\/p>\n
  ‘\u00a3r.it’;tt\u00bbi3 dated 28.4.1976 that said sale deed is not exeettted<\/p>\n
\\nL
\n\\,M.2=<\/p>\n
PR<\/p>\n
exclusively in favour of the defendant and that  <\/p>\n
executed by plaintiff’s I and 2 in favour of  <\/p>\n
second son of Natayan and not   of<\/p>\n
t .\n<\/p>\n
defendant. ‘.”.Le tune.-1 snug’! has I–I3!-l.1.lJ,I’ mm. a<\/p>\n
__-1-….. 2 __ 4′:41;~~;n 4.-  +”—”~– “’19 ‘L’<\/p>\n
E\ufb01ti 4 arid fi\u00e9f\u00e9unan 13 cf:  to
\nschedule properties as” :4  2  ‘ettamhted
\nbefore the court as CWs}l  stated that
\nthey are not__    share in the
\nschedule  thew\ufb01nding of the mat
\ncourt that  .3   am entitled to
\n113v-I inf  is justi\ufb02cd. In any View<\/p>\n
an<\/p>\n
the.-.-\n<\/p>\n
j!<\/p>\n
v M’.\n<\/p>\n
\ufb01lter,  lpLht_’l*..fs 1 and 2 h:w-  -.v-Mr–n<\/p>\n
is .\u00bbT’::’\\HS;’ and   have stated that they are not<\/p>\n
 any share of the schedule properties and<\/p>\n
   confer any title in favour of the defendant<\/p>\n
in  the sham of plaintiff’s 1 and 2 exclusively in<\/p>\n
    their share in items I and 2 of the seheclule<\/p>\n
l  It is clear that the said document is not helpful to<\/p>\n
l L
\nWV’!<\/p>\n
43<\/span><\/p>\n
the defendant to contend in the present ease. ” <\/p>\n
case of the defendant that plaintiffs 3 mt 4 HI”l\u00a33tt’1i:11\u00a7:VA_1′!:E.xgnEE4.i’>l(J   1: 111<\/p>\n
items 1 and 2 of the  Rtt.5\ufb01g0f3(j]- each
\nand not att.2o.ooo\/- t\\a1’1t:l.t_”0t’t:l~t’=rt:t’:.ft)1r__-its production of<\/p>\n
Exs.D 14 an 2:}   the defendant<\/p>\n
gji’ “I1″‘~<\/p>\n
to contend gfhttf 4 tttttu,-. tottt-mt their right in<\/p>\n
IE8-p\u00a3’A’.’-‘.l’=’~Dfv   2 of the achcdtlle.<\/p>\n
pmpefty as it   that any relinqttishment of<\/p>\n
thetjc _its’\u00ab.n-9 ‘~–sft1ch document in the. present case and<\/p>\n
 ‘t1Att\u00a7’;1’_t.’.’fA'()VVI.Et.tV”_”_v\u00bbit  clear that am defendant lttttt rtt\ufb02ttt to<\/p>\n
sut$t:\u00bb*ttz1t::t’1′.ct’t’t*;}’: the. contention that plain\ufb01\ufb02s 3 and 4 have<\/p>\n
  f’O?\u00a3f_’t’.itc!ti”i” ‘their. right in mapcct of itttntts 1 and :2 of the<\/p>\n
t  property and acootthngly. the lands mmprmt-d’ in<\/p>\n
wt’<\/p>\n
45<\/span><\/p>\n
items 1 and 2 of the schedule property have to
\njoint family properties in which plain\ufb01\ufb01s 3   <\/p>\n
dcfegdant have got. thceir   ‘.   ‘ vVr:sn T<\/p>\n
nnnonnncgini-inc’ :1′. ‘HQ th’\u00a7l’\\IIQ_ Q3″ vunfgviigl  , ‘ 2-u ‘ ‘
\nC’!’kFlG\\.’.H-‘1.’-I-W-‘ul-I ‘J1. I-I-1’-‘ C-‘IJHPVW-P C’.-1-I’-I Jr’~’L”‘o”-lL\u00a2~!-  -I-Wuv’-“-7.3′-l~ 4|’-If-‘TS SW1!”<\/p>\n
mlived at the oonciusion \ufb011’\u00a3’\u20ac’;!:VV..62iE:i’I:I1V.\u00a2.ii’l1.1_Vf  to
\nstlbstantintc that plain%ii!i\u00a7 3  mt.-.ir right
\nin Inspect of their shan\u00e9f   \u00ab;_>_._f the scho.-.du’lc
\npmperty whigen    prgapemes and mm
\nplainti\ufb01s have”  cf the said property is
\nalso \ufb02deramziant has failed to prove
\nthat p1V;mn::rgk3 ‘;s;n;\u00a2:::\u00a7  t11ci_’r right i_11  of<\/p>\n
-‘ I -I-I-an 2  0 Ar {’31: an}:-A1115 -r\\-can-tn-Ill-Ir ‘l’I-In
\nI315′-uL’ ‘an! L,’-L’-I-‘I53 . L1-L5-\u00ae.ls ‘-9’ ‘.13 ‘I-II.’ 3\\.’.I..I’–‘-I’.I\u00a3\\.I IL!!!’-‘I ‘Jr I ll’.-<\/p>\n
 , ‘_     to file.  matcrini
\n  __thc \ufb01nding arrived at by the trial court
\n be su\ufb02’cring from error appamnt on the<\/p>\n
V –V    so as to cal1’for-intertbrence in this appeal.<\/p>\n
 {answer the points for detctmitmtiaon and pom<\/p>\n
”   ftillowing older:\n<\/p>\n
The appeal is dismissed with costs. The   ” <\/p>\n
decree passed by the Court of  Judge   K <\/p>\n
in 0.S.No.80_l96 is con\ufb01rmed.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Karnataka High Court Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 Author: V.G.Sabhahit ll 11:: man noun or Iumumuu xr * DATED um um 2o”‘mv or A} E L 1-an uonrnun %& jg \u00ab E E E R.F.A.No.aos;;99E” V BETWEEN: E 1 SUBRAYAMN ” ‘ AGED ABOUT 53 YEA’RS;~.4 S.\/0.LA’l’E NARAYANA,’-, […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_lmt_disableupdate":"","_lmt_disable":"","_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[8,20],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-189913","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-high-court","category-karnataka-high-court"],"yoast_head":"\nSubraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India<\/title>\n<meta name=\"robots\" content=\"index, follow, max-snippet:-1, max-image-preview:large, max-video-preview:-1\" \/>\n<link rel=\"canonical\" href=\"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:locale\" content=\"en_US\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:type\" content=\"article\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:title\" content=\"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:url\" content=\"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:site_name\" content=\"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:publisher\" content=\"https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:published_time\" content=\"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:modified_time\" content=\"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:image\" content=\"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg?fit=512%2C512&ssl=1\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:width\" content=\"512\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:height\" content=\"512\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:type\" content=\"image\/jpeg\" \/>\n<meta name=\"author\" content=\"Legal India Admin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:card\" content=\"summary_large_image\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:creator\" content=\"@legaliadmin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:site\" content=\"@Legal_india\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:label1\" content=\"Written by\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data1\" content=\"Legal India Admin\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:label2\" content=\"Est. reading time\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data2\" content=\"34 minutes\" \/>\n<script type=\"application\/ld+json\" class=\"yoast-schema-graph\">{\"@context\":\"https:\\\/\\\/schema.org\",\"@graph\":[{\"@type\":\"Article\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#article\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\"},\"author\":{\"name\":\"Legal India Admin\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea\"},\"headline\":\"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008\",\"datePublished\":\"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00\",\"mainEntityOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\"},\"wordCount\":5385,\"commentCount\":0,\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\"},\"articleSection\":[\"High Court\",\"Karnataka High Court\"],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"CommentAction\",\"name\":\"Comment\",\"target\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#respond\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"WebPage\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\",\"name\":\"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#website\"},\"datePublished\":\"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00\",\"breadcrumb\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#breadcrumb\"},\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"ReadAction\",\"target\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"BreadcrumbList\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#breadcrumb\",\"itemListElement\":[{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":1,\"name\":\"Home\",\"item\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":2,\"name\":\"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008\"}]},{\"@type\":\"WebSite\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#website\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\",\"name\":\"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"description\":\"Search and read the latest judgements, orders, and rulings from the Supreme Court of India and all High Courts. A comprehensive database for lawyers, advocates, and law students.\",\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\"},\"alternateName\":\"Free judgements of Supreme Court & High Court of India | Legal India\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"SearchAction\",\"target\":{\"@type\":\"EntryPoint\",\"urlTemplate\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/?s={search_term_string}\"},\"query-input\":{\"@type\":\"PropertyValueSpecification\",\"valueRequired\":true,\"valueName\":\"search_term_string\"}}],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\"},{\"@type\":\"Organization\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\",\"name\":\"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"alternateName\":\"Legal India\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\",\"logo\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/sites\\\/5\\\/2025\\\/09\\\/legal-india-icon.jpg\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/sites\\\/5\\\/2025\\\/09\\\/legal-india-icon.jpg\",\"width\":512,\"height\":512,\"caption\":\"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.facebook.com\\\/LegalindiaCom\\\/\",\"https:\\\/\\\/x.com\\\/Legal_india\"]},{\"@type\":\"Person\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea\",\"name\":\"Legal India Admin\",\"image\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"caption\":\"Legal India Admin\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\",\"https:\\\/\\\/x.com\\\/legaliadmin\"],\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/author\\\/legal-india-admin\"}]}<\/script>\n<!-- \/ Yoast SEO plugin. -->","yoast_head_json":{"title":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","robots":{"index":"index","follow":"follow","max-snippet":"max-snippet:-1","max-image-preview":"max-image-preview:large","max-video-preview":"max-video-preview:-1"},"canonical":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","og_locale":"en_US","og_type":"article","og_title":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","og_url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","og_site_name":"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","article_publisher":"https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/","article_published_time":"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00","article_modified_time":"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00","og_image":[{"width":512,"height":512,"url":"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg?fit=512%2C512&ssl=1","type":"image\/jpeg"}],"author":"Legal India Admin","twitter_card":"summary_large_image","twitter_creator":"@legaliadmin","twitter_site":"@Legal_india","twitter_misc":{"Written by":"Legal India Admin","Est. reading time":"34 minutes"},"schema":{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"Article","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#article","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008"},"author":{"name":"Legal India Admin","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/person\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea"},"headline":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008","datePublished":"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00","dateModified":"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00","mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008"},"wordCount":5385,"commentCount":0,"publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization"},"articleSection":["High Court","Karnataka High Court"],"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"CommentAction","name":"Comment","target":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#respond"]}]},{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008","name":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#website"},"datePublished":"2008-03-19T18:30:00+00:00","dateModified":"2019-03-10T14:37:50+00:00","breadcrumb":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#breadcrumb"},"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008"]}]},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/subraya-m-n-vs-vittala-mn-and-ors-on-20-march-2008#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Subraya M N vs Vittala Mn And Ors on 20 March, 2008"}]},{"@type":"WebSite","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#website","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/","name":"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","description":"Search and read the latest judgements, orders, and rulings from the Supreme Court of India and all High Courts. A comprehensive database for lawyers, advocates, and law students.","publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization"},"alternateName":"Free judgements of Supreme Court & High Court of India | Legal India","potentialAction":[{"@type":"SearchAction","target":{"@type":"EntryPoint","urlTemplate":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/?s={search_term_string}"},"query-input":{"@type":"PropertyValueSpecification","valueRequired":true,"valueName":"search_term_string"}}],"inLanguage":"en-US"},{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization","name":"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","alternateName":"Legal India","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg","contentUrl":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg","width":512,"height":512,"caption":"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/","https:\/\/x.com\/Legal_india"]},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/person\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea","name":"Legal India Admin","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","url":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","contentUrl":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","caption":"Legal India Admin"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com","https:\/\/x.com\/legaliadmin"],"url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/author\/legal-india-admin"}]}},"modified_by":null,"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_likes_enabled":true,"jetpack-related-posts":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/189913","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=189913"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/189913\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=189913"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=189913"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=189913"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}