{"id":190227,"date":"2010-12-14T00:00:00","date_gmt":"2010-12-13T18:30:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010"},"modified":"2016-05-01T14:15:18","modified_gmt":"2016-05-01T08:45:18","slug":"sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","title":{"rendered":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010"},"content":{"rendered":"
Karnataka High Court<\/div>\n
Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010<\/div>\n
Author: V.Jagannathan<\/div>\n
 \n\nus: THE men coum or KARNATAKA AT  ' v \nDated: 'I'}rm' the 148*' day of\u00bbIDe.<m  A     'V ' \n\nBEFORE'\n\nTHE HONBLE Iv!CR.JU\u00a3\u00e9'I_'ICE v; \n\nSRIKHAI-IADEVAI&_H ._    2 \nAGED A39 ':45  a10,LAfrE F{~.'1I.AIAH.\n\nsax  :3. \"  '\nAGED AFSOIJT 4-:2   .5\n3\/ 9 gm.  'W.-,. .\n\n  \n\n5:331;  am RAMESH PATEL.\n321%. R amew\ufb01ahg\n\n. -- AGED  YEARS,\n\n..  310 K' s \n\n% ~ la\n  _ 1\u00a7sa:7g::*\u00a3s'2=-'\u00a7(:~;r'1* 5; mass, 310 Ruzmaxaa.\n\n\" 29.\"\n\n22.\n\n51:1. mrrwnm,\n\n sxi \n .  50 YEAR9, 5] 0 PANCHAIAH.\n\nmi 1:: <3 PUR1%E3II.\n1.  AGED ABOUT as mass, 3\/ o :3 H aopazaowm.\n\n.  321v NAGARAJA,\n\nAGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, .'?:]O S VEERAPPA.\n\nSKI SURESII,\nAGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,\n8] O BO  GOWDA.\n\nSR1 B N HARSHATH,\nAGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, 8\/O [ATE B NARAYAHA.\n\n \n\n\n\n \n\n25'\n\n26.\n\n28.\n\n29.\n\n3\nSR1 P KUHAR,\n\nAGED ABOUT 34 YEARS, szo LATE K PAPAIAI-L. V  j f  _\n\nSR1 SYED  .\n\nAGED ABOUT 33 mass,\n\n3,? O SYED RAHAMATULIAH.\nSR! 1' 8 SHASHIDHAR,\n\nAGED ABOUT 45 mans, \nsxo T N snmmm smsm\n\nam? RAMACHANDRA,  \n\nAGEDABOUT 42 mans, 5"\/ '<:a.__  \n\nsun' crzrrrm \n\nAGED Aaotrr 43  \n\nsax z\u00a2x.1a.caa_nIs;i"ItU&:g;  -  "\nASEB  32  am \n\n'$121 L1; \n\nA4329  $10 somma.\nsRi'G.RAc3IiU,  " \n\n. % -AGED  37 \n\n~  $10 mTE"GTJRFIl\ufb01'URTHYACEiAR.\n\n% * 32.\n  T. 5:339 'm_=}c}gJ'r +3 mans. W\/O N RAGHU.\n\n.' :%3: ." \n\n aivnranurznnnz.\n\n31-2': 'f\u00a7\u00a3'j_3..i?EVANA3R)I}APPA.\nA.f3ED\u00ab-ABOUT 44 YEARS,\n\n" .s:~=;J LATE at R snmnm.\n\n'  E35.\n\n36.\n\nsh: B NATARAJ,\n\n AGED ABOUT 45 mama, ezo BEERAIAH.\n\nSE! C SHWARAH.\nAGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, 3\/0 CHOWDAFPA.\n\nSKI SRIHARI.\nAGEXJ ABOUT 3'? YEARS,\nSIG LATE V  IYEHGAR G R.\n\n\n\n Er-.\n\n \n\nQ\n\n37. am RAHAHZATULLA,    \nAGED ABOUT 34'1"EAR8, s;o M D PEER._.--a_ "    '\n\n33. smm\ufb01 ,    \nAGED Azaotrr 43 mama, s1f:z'Cii3tNna.1A_a._  _ V\n\n39. am mrcsmmrm mwm K Er, .\nAGED AEQUTMYEA33,  \n310 LATE NANJUNDEV   V\n\n40. SRIRRBDRAIAH.   '\nAGED ABOUT -:3  em \nALL THE PE1'ITIONER\ufb01I.vTQ'4Q KKK. " .\nwommm A3 amass DIVESEDNAESISTANTS,\nmm: c:;<U:\u00a7'r cm  -  "\n\n     \n   - ' _   ...PETZ'i'IONER3\n\n_ .   G f}\ufb014_&\u20ac:AVAK, nnvncnm.)\n\nx mm H~'\u00a7Iw".\u00aeLE THE CHIEF wanes,\n' a_za;Ic3~g coulrrop KARNATAKA,\nax-usuamnxan vzzsnm,\n\n  _ "--13AX(\u00a7g$1'.'{}RE~56G 001.\n\n" . 2:' Tf':;E'jKfGE caum' or KARHATAKA,\n\ng:*$"'?'\u00b0r-lP\\5"2.""',.~3"\n\n-   \n<\/pre>\n
.. BY THE REGISTRAR GENERAL.
\nEsm T snrvmmnm,
\nam mm B,
\nSR1 T HAHALINGAIAH.\n<\/p>\n
sm REVATHI as,
\nam B sum
\nsyrr nmmmmm 21 J,
\nam SUKARYA H.\n<\/p>\n
am vmvnvmm H K,
\nam NANDINI mo J V,<\/p>\n
 N-5 ha’ .wt’s.u’ ta no no la?
\n*4′ 9*’ ‘*3  an :4 9 5″: .5’-‘ .6 $3′ .3 365 f’-3 E?\u00bb 5 2-‘: :2 331 it: 1::<\/p>\n
use
\n5″\n<\/p>\n
-5.-r-Lu
\nP99<\/p>\n
4:-\n<\/p>\n
3*’<\/p>\n
am’ SAHPOORHAJ KARIsHE’I”iY,<\/p>\n
SET G S ROCIPASHREE,<\/p>\n
am’ smuzm 3,<\/p>\n
SHIT R CKA.NDR.I’\u00a3KALA.<\/p>\n
am KS MANGALA, V <\/p>\n
am H R <\/p>\n
am oovnmanmv R,   %<\/p>\n
sax HALANAIK 0,   3. V  ~   _
\nsm
\nszarr BEA-355311 K.-“‘  ‘   ‘  . VV  ”
\nSm VL  ”   1 V<\/p>\n
  *   <\/p>\n
ask:  g A<\/p>\n
$31 ‘;*3ATHI8’.’3f’riAI\u00a3\u20ac.
\nsRI”Kg5RI3N\u00a3\u00a2.K:\u00a7RA’*K E%.<\/p>\n
. — .5331 M\u00e9mquzzxn-I\u00b0s. ”
\n 38:  c,<\/p>\n
V *   V N.\n<\/p>\n
” SR1 \ufb01P  RATHOI),
\n.’ ~ am’ JSANDHYA,<\/p>\n
Em H nacmsaxmn,<\/p>\n
.” 4% am’ K vmammxsmn,
\n sax an-31> AKIL ALI.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 SYED HADEEM-\u00abUR-REIiAHAN,<\/p>\n
SR1 VABUDHA N,<\/p>\n
Sm VASANITI NAIK,<\/p>\n
EMT VEEFIA G B ,<\/p>\n
SR1 DORESWAHY A N,<\/p>\n
8131 SIIDDANAGOWSA NAGESHAPPA ANAJL<\/p>\n
45.\n<\/p>\n
46.
\n4?.\n<\/p>\n
SET RAJIIH K P’,<\/p>\n
SR1 BALAPPA ‘U’ EETAGERI.
\nSHT RAMAEAI NAIK,<\/p>\n
SHIT THEJASWINI 3 N,<\/p>\n
33113593013,  <\/p>\n
SR1 RAMESH P C.\n<\/p>\n
8111′!’ SULOCHAKA,
\nSKI M SHIVAKUHAR,
\nSE1′ SINDU MOLU,<\/p>\n
sax smnmmems\ufb01wnn   ” – .. A<\/p>\n
sum smmmm
\naura Ic SH.RUTm,.~-  _ jj ‘ V
\nsmvnmwg\ufb01mm, : =<\/p>\n
   %
\nam 2: LE   ” \u00a2 E’
\nsurmaadnaa<\/p>\n
1. ‘SET 3’ ‘myhmni;\n<\/p>\n
  3 BHARA*:’\u00a5:,’<\/p>\n
231:: Q agunmsvamm,<\/p>\n
 am’ Raxfmam Ii P,
\n” am v”iIAmsHRE3,<\/p>\n
“agrv Imrsammkrnv,<\/p>\n
 am N 1′ REVAHKA aowm,
\n 3221 menu as H,<\/p>\n
33!?!’ B P REKHA,<\/p>\n
SET 31 R PRASANNA KUIEARI,
\nSM’? H 3 PREETHI,<\/p>\n
SR1′. K R’ SURESHA,<\/p>\n
SR1 R 3 CHANDRA,<\/p>\n
SRIA R SRENATPL<\/p>\n
was an
\n.a~.u~\u00a3s-a$?–\u00b0?:’\u00a7.”~\u00ab’>’3’a’-:’:3~’a%E<\/p>\n
SRI D BADARINATH RAG.\n<\/p>\n
sax MANJUNATH BHAT,<\/p>\n
3121 K V samsa mom,<\/p>\n
am I-EALIJWALA BHARAMA spam,
\nam U mnmsa,   4
\nsm PRAKABH 2′, ‘
\nam’ SMITHA K,<\/p>\n
Sm KAVITHA 8,<\/p>\n
SR1 ammnan 3,<\/p>\n
ERIE 3 <\/p>\n
am SHREEI\u20acIVA3}\u00a7’,–  T ._  _ _ _
\nsmmmwm D s.,,__    A
\nSm’  ‘9’\u00bb   ”\n<\/p>\n
\n3RI”MALL}1vI’ATHAAhEUCi;3LLGAON,<\/p>\n
, % 31:1 31:1′-aaigxipain S MQWJLLI,
\n.\n<\/p>\n
sm sigma 23 nmnsmxnx.\n<\/p>\n
A ”  K R\u00bb
\n* SR1 s\ufb01msm.\n<\/p>\n
% 3:21 m=s;\u00a7:;~EsHA K 9,<\/p>\n
“am SUNIANDA c,<\/p>\n
4% sm yasnonm B,
\n SR1 smmu Nammnss smvxmm,<\/p>\n
KHV mAVAJ TEGGINAHARI,<\/p>\n
. SR1 REHUKARADHYA 3 N,<\/p>\n
SR1  A L8.X’AKOP}?A,,<\/p>\n
. SM’? PREHA S JADIMATH,
\n. SHIT SAROJA C M,<\/p>\n
SRI VEERABHADRAGOUD PATEL,<\/p>\n
V x ‘ 127.\n<\/p>\n
105.\n<\/p>\n
106.\n<\/p>\n
107.\n<\/p>\n
308.\n<\/p>\n
109.
\n111},\n<\/p>\n
111.\n<\/p>\n
112.\n<\/p>\n
113.\n<\/p>\n
114.\n<\/p>\n
115.\n<\/p>\n
116.<\/p>\n
I17.”\n<\/p>\n
 <,8\u00a7\u20aclT u % '<\/p>\n
I13.\n<\/p>\n
119.<\/p>\n
129.’<\/p>\n
_ V” ’12:.\n<\/p>\n
V  T123.\n<\/p>\n
“125.\n<\/p>\n
126:\n<\/p>\n
 129.<\/p>\n
130.<\/p>\n
am: azznm R <3,
\nSR3 SURESH MURKAL,<\/p>\n
SR1 RAMANJhNEYA H,<\/p>\n
3311'!' MAHIBOOBI.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 DAKBKINALKURTHY C,
\nan: mourmsa M,
\nam xmunszsmcumn >
\nan: snmxvasa  V’ ‘ ”\n<\/p>\n
snrr REKHA M.’  _
\namrrns aavrrrm,  V
\nsnrr as i;*I>,\u00a7:cH:;It11Er\u00a7.;<\/p>\n
M % ”\n<\/p>\n
 M   ‘
\nem R   ”\n<\/p>\n
sax K R’ 5\ufb02&$\u00a72\u00a7HWARAPPA,<\/p>\n
 9 3 PADMAVATHY,
\n”  G mo,
\n“‘s\u00a7\u00a71%r..vIg1AYA1.axcsHna1 Gumumm,
\n__3Ln \u20acxAvn*rIA EANDI,
\nam: FRASHAMHI,<\/p>\n
$31’: MANJUIA GU A HUBBALLI,
\nam <3 IAKSHHAHMA,<\/p>\n
snmr soumm,<\/p>\n
SET A T .A.PARR\ufb01,<\/p>\n
RESPOHDEIITS AT SL.Ho.3 TO 130<\/p>\n
ARE ALL HAJOR8, ALL ARE WORKEVG AS
\nFIRST DIVISION ASSISTAHTS,<\/p>\n
HIGH {ZDURT OF KARNATAKA,<\/p>\n
Bu\u00b0sNGALORE~5\u00e90 W1.\n<\/p>\n
 RESFQIVDENTS<\/p>\n
9<\/span><\/p>\n
( BYBASAVAPRABHU S PATEL, Sr. COUNSEL FOR R-1 & 3.
\nSR! 3 V PRAKASI-I, ADV. FOR 12-94, 96, 106, 121.
\nSR1 KARADIGUDDA N ll, ADV. FOR R-98, 99, 101,
\n104, I10&lll.)  <\/p>\n
THESE WRIT PETITIONS FEED pmvmc   V
\nTHE PROVISO as svaamrman AT SL.NQ,i\u00a75V..VvU*2\u00a7DER-     <\/p>\n
ccwuss No.4 xomzramma m'”mE\u00ab  19:?<\/p>\n
RECRUITMENT m TI-IE swan OF,FH'”;Ei’i.’. ?Div1s1._1j1c1=: ‘—-2 2:;o9 _.z\u00a7<1+,.:;'9.7.oi9,"'%<\/p>\n
CALLED Tm: HIGH comm'  {cGmptr1\u00e9:i$""c\u00a7P
\nsmvxcn: & RECRUYPMENT]   2009
\nASPER ANN-A, ETC. 7 '   <\/p>\n
m W;\u00a7'.Hqu.Ai 1 ?'–'\u00a7?:_:f'iI?\u00a7\ufb01"? _{:"'29; 0:<\/p>\n
1. ,– K sm1\u00a7mf.m<m '  , s
\n..  man ABo1_If:\u00a7-_\u00a7 YEARS, 510 sam KELIPAIAH.<\/p>\n
.A  \u00e9\ufb02nkrmm,<\/p>\n
" V _ mED'maam 33 YEARS,<\/p>\n
 %. 3-; R mmnnvmm.\n<\/p>\n
 xja’ \ufb02\u00e9;KIAPPA sax\/rw,
\n.A<3:ED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
\ns.;_e:: am AHNAPPA samw.<\/p>\n
 \u00bb\u00a2_. " M S VEERABHADRAJAH,<\/p>\n
" AGEE AQOUT 54 YEARS, $10 SR1 BKNANNA.<\/p>\n
95. U Jnvaxmaaa,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 43 YEAR3,
\nS} O SR1 U VENKA  ACHARYA.<\/p>\n
6. EAJEN}3RA S TIIASUL,
\nAGED ABGUT 43 YEARS,
\n810 SR1 DRUVA TILGUL.\n<\/p>\n
10<\/span><\/p>\n
M LINGARAJU,
\nAGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, SIG LATE MAIJAIAH.<\/p>\n
VYHANEKMANTHRAJU,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, 31:: 3231 YELLAIAH.   <\/p>\n
ANJANEYA REDEY,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 5’7 YEARS, 31:) 83; GOPAL’  ~<\/p>\n
JAYAPRABHU D,<\/p>\n
AGED mom so YEAR. SIC i?5Vi\u00a7G1R1MJV    * ‘<\/p>\n
MOHALIIIED GHOU8E,
\nAGED mom 57 mans. x V’ 4
\n3\/0 3:21 MOHALSMED s’.H4;}&;z.__ <\/p>\n
nvmmypn,  _
\nAGED mom 43 mags, am 1:31;; ngaamaa.<\/p>\n
:cJcwzn> { \u00a37 ‘
\n1″-;GED–AE’3L7T_V4*~&  –
\nSID SR1 K N <\/p>\n
. ‘AGED A13c’>U*:b~’51
\n. svnzs sm  DABAPPA.\n<\/p>\n
” ‘ Ax’-.v.’\u00ab._*g:::. A301}? 43 mans, 3\/o CHENRIGAPPPA.<\/p>\n
 AQED  40 YEARS,<\/p>\n
319 mm cnucxaxm aowm.\n<\/p>\n
J\u00e9\ufb01zaaanav,<\/p>\n
AGED AEOUT 59 ‘mans.\n<\/p>\n
V’ ” 3:0 3:21 DODDABARIGOWDA.<\/p>\n
‘ ” -’13.\n<\/p>\n
T 9. VIRUPAKSI-IAIAH.\n<\/p>\n
scam mom 43 mans,
\ns\/o LATE ammaanaamx.\n<\/p>\n
A ANAHEIJ,
\nAGED AROUT 3′? Y1,
\n8\/ G SR1 ARMUGAM.\n<\/p>\n
16?\n<\/p>\n
I1<\/p>\n
MALLA% GANGADHARAIAH,
\nAGED ABOUT 44 YEAR3,
\nW[O LATE GANCBKDHARAIAH B R.<\/p>\n
K HAGARAJA,
\nAGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
\nS} 0 SKI KARI HANUMANITIA.<\/p>\n
M mxsamnmvsmua,
\nAGED ABOUT 39 YEARS, V %
\nWm em MANJANNA.\n<\/p>\n
G GANESH, <\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 42      <\/p>\n
TR SREEHNASA,   ‘
\nAGED ABOUT 5:; mass, _  _
\n3,10 3121 ‘1’ s Raerinwmxm\ufb01gs   ” <\/p>\n
‘AGED  49  sxo sax  .\n<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 4.5 ‘1’F.\u00bb\ufb01S.R$,<\/p>\n
” P ‘.0 Am
\nM;-3.1:) ABOUT 32 mans,<\/p>\n
”  _ va,(\u00abQ..s3H; PI) nmrmmnn KUIEAR.<\/p>\n
” A,
\n\u00e9\u00a7GEi)”‘ABOUT 39 mans,<\/p>\n
k ., $32 sax B mxsanm KUMAR.<\/p>\n
 LOKESH,<\/p>\n
 AGED ABOUT 42 YEAR8, 810 SKI HAIIABEVAIAH.<\/p>\n
HEEKVANIHA,
\nAGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,<\/p>\n
8] O IATE GAHGADHARAPPA.
\nUDAYASHANKAR,<\/p>\n
AGEI) ABOUT 37 YEARS,<\/p>\n
Si 5 SR} H L SI-IEEHRGWXYAFPA.<\/p>\n
ALLTHE PEHTIONER8 ITO 31 ARE<\/p>\n
,’…\n<\/p>\n
3* \u00a331′.\n<\/p>\n
12<\/span><\/p>\n
‘WORKING A8 FIRST DNEION ASSISMNTS,
\nHIGH CGURT OF KARHPLTAKA,
\nEARGALORE.\n<\/p>\n
{BY am 3 G BBAGAVA!7;’A\u00a33\\(QC\u00a7)&T1}\u00a7; j  V’   <\/p>\n
\u00a32<\/p>\n
fr?!-Iv-rr~—>–na-m
\n:”‘S5\u00a7’r*W.’-19″~<\/p>\n
TI-IE HON”BLE rm: cr–:m*aJUs1*:<:E, V _
\nHIGH comrrop
\nDRALIBEDKAR VEEDHI,   "\n<\/p>\n
EANGA.LORE~56\u00a3:.\u00a7)01.  – <\/p>\n
THE HIGiI coux\u00e9r OF   _
\nmnenmnm, BY f;’;{2E._R1i'<_;-I3T:=.m2 <\/p>\n
':%%,\u00a7m1'G.H"R6maH;~.,.:'"' N<\/p>\n
am 13 x sum.-saA%% ';%.a.~ <\/p>\n
% _ sum 13  <\/p>\n
3121 c RAi}H$VE NDRA.\n<\/p>\n
‘\u00e9.1e1f’n;man9?A IEASAR,
\nV _  ‘5\u00a7:i&T”}3 G.\u20ac\u00a7YATHRI,
\nV’ “sVF;:–R \\22Ei!fICATARAJU,
\n__sm i;*IRUPnxsHAmH,
\n~~ _ Sm CHANDRAIEMA,<\/p>\n
532m B! Unmen,<\/p>\n
sax LOKESI-I NAYAK,
\n812} N mmsn,<\/p>\n
am B c wanna.\n<\/p>\n
am K I-I GURIIRM.\n<\/p>\n
am: maxnsa,<\/p>\n
am :3 3 cmwcrnm.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 NEEIAPPA BOVER,
\nam JAYAPRABHA,<\/p>\n
22.<\/p>\n
25.<\/p>\n
_.’L..\u00a2uwvaw ‘
\n‘\u00a79i~\u00bb9’*:~39*E*?”‘J$\u00a3’U-‘*\ufb01:\u00a2’!>”\\3$’~’$’3I’1<\/p>\n
 __41\u00a7 *
\n.’ . 42′;\n<\/p>\n
43.<\/p>\n
.3<\/p>\n
48.\n<\/p>\n
49.
\n5!}.\n<\/p>\n
sin’ I’ 3) PREHAIATHA.\n<\/p>\n
3121 5 3 sumn,<\/p>\n
SR1 h!E’I’RI Hanunxnxuri-1A121a\u00bb;;””<\/p>\n
SKI JACi&TCH.\ufb01.NDRA H, ‘ A _
\n3:21 HA1wuAm*I-IE  L,
\nSm PADMAVATI-IY R,  ‘
\nSE1 3! S PRAKASH,<\/p>\n
am suvsam E4413; _
\n31-11 E D     ‘
\nSm’ R stsnm,  ”   ‘  ._ ‘ _
\n31213      \u00bb.\n<\/p>\n
sm\u00e9     ‘   ‘ ‘<\/p>\n
 335TAPRl*1B1i?#VAT\u00a5”?+   %
\n‘”51:r’seHAs’HnmIgt. ,, 4 ” <\/p>\n
smj \u00ab:3 H <\/p>\n
– . SR1 K”‘r..,rca:sHA\\?A, <\/p>\n
  H mun,
\n  imaavnmaswmar,
\n  GALPPHRAMRAJ nmzwv,<\/p>\n
emf gfimsumn,
\n%3RI’R3\\MEBH GURUPADAPPA KUDRI,<\/p>\n
” 3.3:: MAMATIM.\n<\/p>\n
  . am YASHWANTH FRABIIU’ R.\n<\/p>\n
 45.’
\n 4?.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 TANVEER RAZIQA,<\/p>\n
SMT AN'{H’AMA DEVI K N.\n<\/p>\n
3R1 i-{ARISE KUHAR,<\/p>\n
SR1 3 A Bi CHAGASHETIY,
\nSR1 SHIVALINGAIAH,<\/p>\n
SR1 HARIDAB KPLHATH,<\/p>\n
SMT SAVYPHA B K,<\/p>\n
3:4<\/p>\n
53. SMT LAKSI-IMIIA’I’HA K K,<\/p>\n
54. SHIT AI-IUPAMA V,<\/p>\n
55. am’ SHASHIKALA 13,<\/p>\n
am smxmm [21,<\/p>\n
am {JSHA 1-3 3,<\/p>\n
SET POORNIMA V K,<\/p>\n
Sm REKHA H R,<\/p>\n
Sm HEMALATI-{A 1*,
\nam KAVITHA 1\u00bb: H,
\nSR1 sovmmnasu ca 3,,<\/p>\n
am’ AARATHI I), V’
\n312:: G091 H I),<\/p>\n
am BHAGYA ‘1’,   4_<\/p>\n
U’: H’?\n<\/p>\n
s\u00ab~.9s\u00bb.=~t:93f-3′}-‘\u00b0’.55’=3’~<\/p>\n
66-  smr\u00a2\u00a2IsHREa:%\n<\/p>\n
57.  N  ” \u00a2\n<\/p>\n
68. a1&–‘.r__a :.I5.YAsii1\u00a7E13;”_;-
\n% %. RESPOHDERTS 3 T0 as ARE ALL manna,
\n. W\u20ac)RKINCi-A;SV_ 3333103 Asamwm,
\n‘ ?\ufb01;IGH..CGURT’UF KARIIATAKA.<\/p>\n
_vEaHG.\ufb013.GRE–560 001.<\/p>\n
” .  air   s PATIL, smmcn counam.<\/p>\n
FOR R–:t 6; 2.)<\/p>\n
 “I’1-IESE warr Pmmows mm) Pmmza ‘F0 QUASH<\/p>\n
”  PROVISO as suasmvmn AT sL.z\u00a2o.14 UNDER
\n COIAIIIIN 330.4 PERYAHTHVG TO THE METHOIJ OF
\nRmcxurrunnr TO THE canny: on smmcn Assxsmm in<\/p>\n
THE N0’1’IFIC.A’i’IC}N 110.1-ICZE 22 if 2909, DATEB 291′” JULY
\n2009, CALLED THE HIGH COURT OF’ ICARNATAXA SERVICE
\nICQNDITIONQ OF $ERVICE AND RECKUITKENT} (V
\nALENDMENTJ RULES, 2009 AS PER ANNEXUREFA, ETC.<\/p>\n
W.. I.\n<\/p>\n
5 — 4<\/p>\n
EETWE EN<\/p>\n
1.<\/p>\n
19.<\/p>\n
3!.\n<\/p>\n
SET J MAMATHA,
\nAGE:33 YEARS, B LINGARAJU.<\/p>\n
KUM PRIYA LJGONSALVEB,  _
\nA<}E':36 mans, mo H  '-\n<\/p>\n
vrmvaxa 9 V,  T .\n<\/p>\n
A.GE:35 mans, am B vssmmm, _<\/p>\n
Nos. 2 To 3 ARE  cxi\u00e9ctm ‘\u00a3331-;c”r:V,   <\/p>\n
nmmm, mm: sonar ‘eh
\nnmuewm.   _   * <\/p>\n
 A(}E:7-F9: $IO_.I.ATE l;i VG vnmmmvpa,
\nwemmwe  CIRCUIT–BENCH,<\/p>\n
mPAPA1a’m’,.\n<\/p>\n
‘ ” AGE:57″YISARS, E110 LATE MUHISHAMAPPA.<\/p>\n
.  Kb Q’ .. ….. “HE !
\n\u00bb{‘\u00a3\ufb023-3319?? SIO C H KL’R1′.SHH&8E7PTY.<\/p>\n
” “s\u00a7.4’r’r  Am Knzarmm,<\/p>\n
.;graE;.\u00a7_’-zj YEARS. W10 JAVEI3 KHAN.<\/p>\n
~ 5:25? If PREMAKUHARI.<\/p>\n
V\ufb01s(}E:42 YEARS, ‘W10 RAMESH T.<\/p>\n
EMT  HA G NEKAR,
\nA\u20ac}E:49 YEARS, W10 GURUPADAPEA NEXAR.<\/p>\n
SM?’ ROCPA 3 KULKARN1,
\nAGE:-‘$0 YEARS, ’33] 0 GOPAL.<\/p>\n
KUM RAHIhIIJ!\u00a7N’\u00a3.’?a.h,
\nA{‘}E:45 YEARS. D] O IEEHABOOBSAB.<\/p>\n
I2.\n<\/p>\n
14.<\/p>\n
17.<\/p>\n
“.2c.\n<\/p>\n
SET 9 M MANJUIA<\/p>\n
AGE:3\ufb01 YEARS. W10 1″ VISWANATH.
\nan’: X s JAYAPADMA I
\n5:33:55 YEARS, wgo J K <\/p>\n
snrrrcmmam,  _  ‘-\n<\/p>\n
.nc;z::3*2′ mags, won 2; 1::..1:_vApp,x,_ V<\/p>\n
smamma, _ _ _V
\nAGE:43 YEA.R8,.     1′ V
\nW10 3 1′ mxsxumamtagi,   n v
\nam” SB?-\u00a3ARAT\u00a7iAI.1E5-$1;-.. ‘V .  V
\nAGE;55_   ‘~ <\/p>\n
G s_.sz:\u00a7E4,eri\u00a7f:H;’ 1;
\nAG1E::40_\u00bbYE’ARS,.   ‘<\/p>\n
733:) E. 3″\n<\/p>\n
“m1=:;s<2 'agcegz <\/p>\n
s1\u00a7;':\u00ab2'o$.5 T6. is<\/p>\n
— , WORKZIWGAS SRJUSGHENTWRHERB,<\/p>\n
HIGH couRf1f__;_)_1? KARNATAKA, BAHGALORE.
\n\u00a5ss3a*r4$HyAMA1a,<\/p>\n
V _ “Ag;:E,:45_ 23433, We Joan vxcmn.<\/p>\n
 ,:=  V’
\n.g%xGE:43 YEARS, W10 SUIJHIR JO3HI.<\/p>\n
” yam M V 8}-IEEI.A,<\/p>\n
AGE:39 YEARS, W10 ANANTBA KUHAR.<\/p>\n
SET K G REKUKAE,
\nAGEH}. YEARS, WIO RAllE8Ii.<\/p>\n
K ERINIVASA HURTHY,
\nAGEM3 YEARS, S\/O LATE VA KEEHAVA LEURTHY.<\/p>\n
Shari’ K SUEATHI,
\nAGtE:32 YEARS, W\/’O LAKE 3 N KUKESHAN.<\/p>\n
26.<\/p>\n
2?.\n<\/p>\n
39.<\/p>\n
:7<\/p>\n
SET PANKAJA S.\n<\/p>\n
A’-‘.}E:30 YEARS, W] O GIREE K R.<\/p>\n
B A KRISHNAKUMAR,
\nAGE:3’Z YEARS, S] O A A.\n<\/p>\n
V  HHA,<\/p>\n
AGE:5O mares. s;o P3 3 Ynm.  .<\/p>\n
MAHENDRA KUMAR.\n<\/p>\n
AGEM-1 YEARS, SIO T KRISHNACHAR.<\/p>\n
smaamnmmmm
\nms:-:2 mans, D10 SUBRA}5AH”r’A, \u00e9 <\/p>\n
SHTYASHODAKL,   ”  1. _ _
\nAGE:34 mA12s,w\/oK;3_mAxJu_mnm.TV.v–.’…v<\/p>\n
3L.Nos. 19 To 29 ARE    T
\nJunanmmwnxrmemp   ‘<\/p>\n
 sL,\u00bb:\u00a7;’;%}c”:a._*iioR::\ufb01\u20acaAe.’s’rENoaRAPHER.<\/p>\n
‘HIGH CFQU E.’.’r\u00bb\u00a3>F.
\n _   <\/p>\n
‘.\u00b0’*S”‘:”‘!*’<\/p>\n
SE13 v mmmm, Anv. )<\/p>\n
Hz\ufb01ikmfz THE cam’ JUSTICE,
\nHIGH COURT 0? EARRATAKA,<\/p>\n
” E&H’GALORE. REP BY ITS<\/p>\n
REGISTRAR GESERAL.\n<\/p>\n
‘ ‘ man coum or mmmwmm,<\/p>\n
BAH(3\ufb01LOR.E, REP BY ITS
\nREGISTRAR GENERAL.\n<\/p>\n
H LAKBHIIEEIARAYARA,
\nJUAHITHA THEJZASWIRI,
\nYAHUNA K L;\n<\/p>\n
SHYLAJA R,<\/p>\n
I8<\/p>\n
7. VEENABM,<\/p>\n
3. mam c,  <\/p>\n
9. AHAKDH, I<\/p>\n
10. wumrmnn,<\/p>\n
11. mmrazc,<\/p>\n
12. mmmmua,<\/p>\n
13.  ” V
\n91393.3 TO      V
\n:’~3r.JL\u00a5DGMEK’I’ WRIYERS; ~   _
\nwasma in arm’ ‘C(}UR1′ \u00a72>_E’ <\/p>\n
:4.   5 ‘\n<\/p>\n
15.  ”  .’ ”\n<\/p>\n
13.   . ~<\/p>\n
19. <\/p>\n
29; ” 1gxALLIisttJ}zrtIss\u00a3;,<\/p>\n
21<\/span><\/p>\n
. i  2,;-:51  mo,
\n ~ 22. \u00ab. frvs  MUR’1*\u00a7iY,
\n‘  1:.-3. i”$’T:.’ffUKAMHA.<\/p>\n
.. “$.L.Raa. 14 T0 24 ARE MAJORB,
\n. WORKWG A3 AS8I8’I’Al\ufb02’ REGESTRARS,
\nHIGH COURT OF KARRATAKA.
\n RESPONDENTS<\/p>\n
IBYSRI I3A3AVAPRPLBHU S PATIL, 333101? C’-UUNSEL
\nFOR R~I & 2.3.\n<\/p>\n
BRIT 3 li\u00a3ADIi’AVACHAR, ADV. FOR R–‘? 5 11.
\nSE1 3 V’ !’?ARA8R\u00a3I”IA.N, ADV. FGR R46.)<\/p>\n
THESE WET!’ FE’I”I’l’I\u20ac3\ufb02B FILE}? PRAYIHG TC?
\nQUASHI DECIARE (12) THE I-I103 GGURT OF KARKATAKA
\nSERVICE [CONDITIONS OF SERVICE AND RECRU\ufb02’L$N’l’)<\/p>\n
19<\/span><\/p>\n
{I AnmNI)MEN’n RULES 2009 3: N011FIcATIQx;_”‘N\u00a7);\ufb01\u00a72::-\u00abV.
\n221\/09 m*n.2+.2.o9 PUBLISHED IN Kammragia  *
\nm*n.2a.2.o9 PROIKICED A3 AmzEx..1s,,~\u00a7;:}… Ti*HE~.::H:G:1:”
\nmovie”: 01? KARNATAKA 3ER?JidE3’\u00ab {coNi::r:fmi~;s;”‘t)F
\nsmwrcm AND  R\u00e9jmis
\nmrma; rzv Normcamcm -30.365″ 307f.2′(3{?f3:..}3Afj?ED <\/p>\n
12.5.2099 PIJBLISHED 11\u00bb:   um\u00bb
\n13.5.2ao-9 PRQDUCED  (an :1
\nAMENDMERT RULES}-._1″If Nc%’rIEf\u00a3\u20ac33\u00a5;I?i_1H~I_O.HCE 22112009
\nmmn 2s.5.2m9   anzwrm
\nmrr:31:: 23.5.3039   ’30 FAR AS THEY
\n  bugnmzcaanan To rmz: pears<\/p>\n
mif ” %’31’E:i;)G\u00e93g\u00e92a\ufb01:R\u00a7” A’19 “”‘\u00a3\u00a7L.No,2 1. JUDGEHENT
\n are :j;j.-1\u00a7o.,2\u00a7cs–,. _$E1~I’1oR JUDGEMENT wnrrsns AT
\nsL.N.._1\u00e9m IN’-I  RULES AND AT sL.Nc>s.39,
\n32 Armies II\u00bb: {rim  RULES AND ASST. REGISTRARS
\n ‘sL.Nc::. I\u00e9xygusnnnwm RULES IR ‘SCHEDULE III<\/p>\n
 4 AT mm mm m ma: nnarr mums, av<\/p>\n
‘ =   THE sum as UNGO!4IS’I’l’I’U’I’I0NAL,
\n.  VIRE3. nmcnmmamxv. VIOLATIVE
\n“-:2}?  I*;%ti~rtc1PLEs or NATURAL mama AND<\/p>\n
UNF;f7E?ORCEABLE IN LAW, ETC.<\/p>\n
A <\/p>\n
1. K BHXNJUNATH,<\/p>\n
BIO KENCKAIWA, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
\nWUHZKIHG AS FEON IN KARHATMM HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDIZKG3,<\/p>\n
II3R.E.R.A\ufb01EDK\ufb01.R VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
EANQALORE-560 {)9 I .\n<\/p>\n
20<\/span>
\nB SRIHIVAEA RAG PAWAR, _<\/p>\n
510 mm mm mo, AGED ABOUT 39    -.
\nwcmmcre A3 A’\u00a3”T’E!’fDER 111 KARHATAKA  .. j 3 ..,_ j ;_.v   _<\/p>\n
COURT. HIGH COURT BUILDIHGS,
\nDR.B.R.AMl”3EDKAR VEEI3HI.
\nBANGALORE-550 G01.\n<\/p>\n
A mxasnmn. MURPHY,   *~ ‘   _ ~
\n3\/ 0 AHJANAPPA, AGED ABOUT 4:: YEARS, ” ” ;
\nw(:>RmNGA.a PEON M’ KARNATAKA H193
\nHIGH COURT Bu\ufb01bmas, ”  .\n<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.Am5EDKAR VEEDEI, ‘<\/p>\n
BANQALORE-560.901.  \u00ab.  <\/p>\n
srmrmawnz – *    ‘   _
\nwe R wzmaooa  AGEI}~A\u00a3;~’sQ’UT–~3? mans,
\nwtrmxnwcsss swrsim-.:’3. Inimnmmxa man coum’,
\nHIGH QGQRT BU_IIJ\u00a7!I!\u00a7G~S,. ‘V  .. ‘
\nDR.a,t:Ar.EBEuKax unmnriz,<\/p>\n
mmALo\u00a3E%~sw%-ooI%;%   % ‘<\/p>\n
3\/ GB  AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,<\/p>\n
‘ \u00bb WOR}CING’A8 PEON IR’ KARKATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
HIGH CKDURT BIJILDRIGS,<\/p>\n
A  a.nR;:.=:.R.AuBr:DKAR VEEDI-II,
\n_ a.e;zz;m,exE-5ao om.<\/p>\n
1   THAB c,<\/p>\n
S.f’0 ‘\ufb02Ii ANHA, AGED ABOUT 4 1 YEARS,<\/p>\n
 ._  AS WATCHHAN B!’ KARRATAKA HIGH
\n,. COURT, HIGH COURT BUILDINGS,
\n= f)’R.B.R.A%EDXAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
BaANCH’&LOR.’E~56O WI.<\/p>\n
T K YO ,<\/p>\n
81 O KRI3HHAPPA, AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
\nWY3RHI’IGA.8 PEON IE KKRHATAKA. HIGH SOURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILIJING-8,<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.A1\u00a3BEDXAR VEEDHL<\/p>\n
BANGALORE560 001.\n<\/p>\n
E GOPAIAEHHA,<\/p>\n
SIG BORAIAH, AGED ABGUT 43 YEARS,
\nWORKING A5 PEON IN KARNATAKA HIGH CJOURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDINGQ,<\/p>\n
21<\/span><\/p>\n
DR.B.RAMBEDK&R VEEDHI,
\nBANGAL<}RE~560 001.\n<\/p>\n
BHDIWAKAR, <\/p>\n
szo LATE K v KAGAHAJ, new Aa<:iu*i*–3\u00a7YE.\u00a7R:\u00a7;-L :;_ AA
\nwonxnm A8 92:32: In i{ARNA'I,'AKA men mum,  <\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDIIIG-'B,
\nDR.B.R.A!$EDKAR
\nELANG.ALORE–560 om.  "<\/p>\n
K\\fJA<3:ANHA'!'Ii,'~~._   .' V <\/p>\n
3\/0 E 11 V'ENi\u20ac3%.T:'\u00a7.JmRAlln3LI\ufb01;}I;  j x % <\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 34 YEArcs..'-\ufb01x; _ . "0'as'$wEEPER IN
\nKARKATAEA HIGH <:.QUR'r_.A  "
\nHIGH mum BL;rn..1:;rm3.,'  Z
\nnn.a.s:.an;:.aEnx;xnivs:-Enax, '- <\/p>\n
av ,  'V<\/p>\n
V"310'MV*vENK3mSr\u00a7hppA;_\u00a3G\ufb01D ABOUT 37 YEARS,
\n WQRI\u00a7I{\\E4'3a  PEG?!'  I-HKRNATAKA HIGH COURT,
\n"HIGH COURTL\u00abBUvI1.I3\u00a71iGB,<\/p>\n
DE-1.B.R.A\u00a3!BEi}E.\ufb01LR..V'\u00a35EDHI,
\nB-AE'Qa\ufb02LLC)RE\u00a7~5\ufb010 mi.<\/p>\n
. C\u00a7iAHDRE8.I1EKAR R,<\/p>\n
' as; 01;:  AGED ABOUT 35 mans,
\n_wQRxmG A8 manor: :1: KARHATAKA HIGH courrr,
\nV _ '2~.1r_1z.";H*\u00ab~::T_:::':A–..r1='-:'.1* ammmes,<\/p>\n
. "aR..3.R..;uaaBEnxAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
BARQ._A.\u00a3ORE-560 001.<\/p>\n
8., 0 v1:’NxA:r mo. AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
\nwc:sxxm<3 as mom :1: KARKATAKA HIGH comm<\/p>\n
H  HIGH coma': Btmznmos.<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.Al{BEIDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBAIIGALORE-560 O01.\n<\/p>\n
 ,<\/p>\n
SjO  , AGE!) ABOUT ‘H YEARS,
\nWORKING A8 PEOH IN KFLRNATAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURT EUILDIHG3,<\/p>\n
I3R.E.R.\u00a3%EDK\u00a3R VEE\ufb01HI,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE560 em.\n<\/p>\n
1?.\n<\/p>\n
M SGHABHEKAR,
\n8\/0 H K HAHABEVA SWAHY.\n<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, <\/p>\n
wonxcumas PEGN IR mmrmram  Ga 4::.xc.fs’::.;:2\u20acV,’ ‘-  <\/p>\n
HIGH con:-rr BUILDINGS,  T ..
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEIDHL;
\naa.H<3a.LaRr3..5eo 991.;  <\/p>\n
K 3 SHIVARAJU,  "\n<\/p>\n
S} O {ATE SHIVANAR’JE(}O_WD1%;.._.
\nAGEDABOUT41  ‘ u V<\/p>\n
wonmm as PEOE  ‘HIGH covzrr,
\nHIGH COURT BUILD.I1i”f<}$,'    .
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDKA\u00a3!.VEEErH\u00a3, '
\nEiAN(3u\ufb01LQ1'i\u00a32\u00ab56j;) 091;  <\/p>\n
R 3'\u00a533'3<-'131x\ufb01~.-':V- .      ._ '<\/p>\n
131:1;  \u00a2 "GED P.BOI.iv'fI' 35 YEARS,<\/p>\n
  HIGH comm',<\/p>\n
V HIGE ..coum$'1jmG3_,
\n nR.B.R;;3mEDmR' WEEHL
\n"3A}I_GALORE'–56G pa :4'. <\/p>\n
sag  %% vA R-; '<\/p>\n
  . :31 o rmmacim\ufb01n\ufb01\ufb01 K, AGED ABGUT as mans,<\/p>\n
vva3Rrmv<ms__;\u00e91s::z av KARNATAKA men COURT,<\/p>\n
V  :..r:.tcmcouRT BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
 1;.”\n<\/p>\n
a , _ UR.5.R~.AMBEDEAR VEEDHI,
\n _ :sgmrG.1_Lc:RE_5ae om.<\/p>\n
 1:: R,
\n K RANGFLNATH, \u00a33313 ABQUT 40 YEARS,<\/p>\n
 .. WORKINGAS PEON IR KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS,
\nDR.B.R.A%EDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
H BAHGALORE~56O cm.\n<\/p>\n
A HEM mo,
\n3\/ o T ASHWATH HARhYA.N mo.<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 35 mm.\n<\/p>\n
woxxmc. as 1290:: m KARHATAKA HIGH comm’,
\nHIGH comer BUILDINGS.\n<\/p>\n
mz.B.12.aamEnr:Ax VEEDHI.<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
22.<\/p>\n
23<\/span>
\nJ MANJUAIUTHA,<\/p>\n
310 mm JAVARAEAH, AGED mom 31 YEARS,
\nWORKING A3 PEQN IN KARHATAK6. HIGH COIIKT:  .V  <\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDIHGS,
\nDR.B.R..AMBEDKAH VEEDHI.
\nEA.HGAI.ORE~56O GO 1 .\n<\/p>\n
RAVIKIIMRRRC, V<\/p>\n
we um; CHIKKA  ‘   4’ ‘<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 28 YEA%.\n<\/p>\n
woremara as more 11:  axe}:  1 <\/p>\n
HIGH CQURT BUILDIN{}$\u00a7”
\nI3R.B.R.A%EDEAR VEEIZIEI}
\n\ufb01A3ChkLORE~56Q 001.  ”\n<\/p>\n
Lnnxnsumapm. _     v _<\/p>\n
3\/ 0 mxsammn, A_(}’r3\ufb02\u00abr4E;Ot_1’T’3%i..YiE.&R8,
\nwmzm~IGVAs PEQN. IH–K\ufb01SR!\u00a73&TA’I\u20acABI{}H covrrr.
\nHIGHCOUi3TBII1I.Dl1i”Cr8-,’  –  ‘
\nDR.B.F;;AEF;E!:EnKAR ?U’F”E1)HI_,  ‘= <\/p>\n
S164-XARIGOWDA,’ jean ABOUT 41 make,<\/p>\n
  . WORK{N<3AS wmcnmn mr KARNATAKA HIGH<\/p>\n
COURT, HIGH Ci')Ul?1" BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
V  \u00e9z::.a.E..R.A1m\u00a3:bKA12 vmznm,<\/p>\n
_BAH\u00a34;i&L{3RE-560 001.<\/p>\n
3\/03: z\u00e9opaxa, AGED ABOUT 32 mans,
\nwekmla A8 men I15! KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
 . HIGH coum Bmwmas,<\/p>\n
'\u00a7}R.B.R.A&EDKPs.R VEEDI-II,
\nBAHGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
V D DEANJUHATH,<\/p>\n
Sf 0 DEVEGOWEIA, AGED ABGUT’ 32 YEARS,
\nWOREIIVG A8 PEON IR KARHATAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH CGIIRT BUILBZNGB,<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.A1’5!BEI)KAR VEEBHI,<\/p>\n
BARGALGRE-560 W1.\n<\/p>\n
RABIESH E K,
\nS} O DODDA HARIQOWDA,<\/p>\n
28.<\/p>\n
24<\/span><\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,<\/p>\n
woammas more IN KARNATAKA rzz<3;;;;":2.\u00a7::'U:szjfr_.' % ' '<\/p>\n
HIGH coum' BUILDINGS. V
\nDR.E.R.A3&l3EDKAR VEEDHL"
\n:E!.A.NCrALORE~56O 001. V<\/p>\n
HP3HAH'rHARA'LA1AH,,_  '  ;
\nsfo M 3 Pommmm. AQEQ ABOL'~'I__' 4'D_YE'AR$',"  "
\nWORKINGAS ATTENDER EN mmmmm HIGK
\nCGURT, IHGH COURT B{IILI}IHG$, '* .
\nnR.B.RAn:BEDEAR\u00abvEz\u00a3\u00a2DHL– _ V
\nBAHGALORE~56(5'-W1,   *  f . '-<\/p>\n
KSANANTH PADLLuimBHA,u.L ' V '-<\/p>\n
SID K  ' <\/p>\n
AGED A303?   swr-zrzpma m
\nKAR\u00ab'FPiTAKA E163 Pai\ufb01li\ufb01i'.  f *<\/p>\n
maze: C\u00a73t;R1'"EUII;l3f\u00a3NGE\u00a7,-'
\nL}1?\u00a7.B';1e"Ee-553935-?\u00a2_EPDEE\u00a3;\u00a5\u00a3_VE:E\u00a3)1?II,. <\/p>\n
1 '   1,<\/p>\n
sic vn=2UPAxsP..AmI;'AaEn ABOUT 39 YEARS,
\nwomen as PEOH. {N KARNATAKA HIGH comm',<\/p>\n
— \u00bb HIGH”ccUR’i’3Un.DmGa,<\/p>\n
I\u00a7R.B.R.AE\u00a3F3EDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
A’ 33n1mgxLoRm;56o 001.<\/p>\n
V _  no H,
\n. “2-am, ;.\u00bb=a..’rE’ zmmmn mo, AGE13 ABOUT 30 mans,<\/p>\n
wwoatmie A3 PEON Ill KARKATAKA HIGH court,
\nHIGH “COURT BUILDHIGS,<\/p>\n
 O. m.:z.B.R.aumE1>xAR vssmn,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
5 R I.AK8HlI[IR’ARAYANA,<\/p>\n
5\/ O LATE K  HNAP%,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 40 YEAR3, ‘WORKING A3 WATCHHAN IN
\nK’ARHA’\u00a3&I(J’i EIGH COHRT,<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT’ BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
DH.B.RJ9.%EDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
B&NGALORE~560 001.\n<\/p>\n
S I? RAGHU,
\nSi O EREGOWIJA, AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS,
\nWORIWWGAB PEGN IN KARNACCAKA HIGH COURT.<\/p>\n
36.<\/p>\n
39.<\/p>\n
2.’:\n<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS,
\nDR.B.R.AllBEDE.AR VEEDHI,\n<\/p>\n
3.-we.-\\LoRE-56o 001.   <\/p>\n
C RAMESSIPIA, <\/p>\n
310 caANHAIAH.AGEnABoi:T:a\u00a7YEARA”  ‘~. \u00ab. ”<\/p>\n
wonxmcms mow mVrKa,Rm’mK\u00a3 HIG?IC!;’}!.IRT, ;
\nKIGHCOUR’I’EU1LDI14It3–$,*~,_ ” u    ‘
\nDR.B.R.AB$EDKAR VEEI\u00a7\u00a7’II;’<\/p>\n
aanaamlwseo ooz.\n<\/p>\n
mo GAHGAIAH, AGE!) ABOUT_.-41″YE\ufb01Rf’:’o,
\nWORKINQAS SWEEPER JEKARKATKEQX HIGH coum’,
\nBIG}! <;:r,u1a1fBIz'_n,::n\u00a7g;s,"  '
\nDR.B.E.A1u;:3EDK\ufb011R1(EEDHI, '- <\/p>\n
   \u00bb<\/p>\n
____ H <\/p>\n
1 "31   39 YEARS,
\n  Bi! KARNATAIM HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURTLEUE{\u00bbB–Il\u00a7IQ8,<\/p>\n
DB,B.R.Al\u00a7BEDiiAR~–.VEEDHI,
\nBAKG_ALORE__–5t';Q GEM.<\/p>\n
, CHAND PF-.8.11A, _<\/p>\n
' i$;o'vnAs'rAGIR"sAa, AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
\n_tm:a;e,1c:zz<:GJas wxrcauam 111 xanmrmm HIGH
\nV _ '<:n,*;.*.1\u00a5:!,_  comm’ Btmnmcs,<\/p>\n
. “m\u00e9~.5.R msnssnxak VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
E.AR\u00a3?u_%LORE–560 00:.<\/p>\n
I. iianjmvanmmm,<\/p>\n
EHO VENKAT
\nAGED ABOUT 43 YEAR8,<\/p>\n
H 4′ WORKING A8 PEON IR KARNATAKA IIIGI-I COURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDEIGB,<\/p>\n
I3R.B.R.AEE3EDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBAHCE-.ALORE-5l5O 001.<\/p>\n
R GEETHA.\n<\/p>\n
I33} 0 I) K RAMACHAHDRA, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 PEOH IR’ KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH CGUR?’ BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
40.<\/p>\n
42.<\/p>\n
‘T 45.\n<\/p>\n
26<\/span><\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBANGALORE~560 001.\n<\/p>\n
RAMESHIK M N,
\n3,10  A, AGED ABOUT 3′? YEARS,<\/p>\n
wommqeas men IN KARRATAKA   “‘ <\/p>\n
HIGH CO’UR”I’ BUB.-DING5,
\nDR.B.R.AM.BEDKAR VEEDHI.<\/p>\n
BANIHXLORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
msanmm,   ‘  -. 1
\nsm VEERSI-IE’1″.{“{}, acme ABOUT 44  V<\/p>\n
woammas PEON INVI\u00a3ARNATAKA.__HI<}Hv-CGIJRT, <\/p>\n
HIGH mum' I3UILDIIiG8';  %<\/p>\n
DE.B.R.An\u00a3BEDKAR vEEp_HI,~ _  ._
\nBANGALGRE-5t5\u00a3) 4191.  *  <\/p>\n
mmx\u00e9nsgg.  %<\/p>\n
,-310  .a.G$':\u00e9  44 YEARS.<\/p>\n
 "varo1e2:12=:GA\u00a3;'m_Gz\u00a7 xx  HIGPI coum',
\n HIGH CGI,IK1"BU'iLDINI\u00a7AuRTA–\\:E.EDHI,<\/p>\n
BA_I\u00a7IGALCiRE%56\u00a3\u00a5 om;<\/p>\n
– \u00bb Las\ufb01z-mam;\n<\/p>\n
Mo K c  AGED mom :4 mas,<\/p>\n
‘  A3 more :1: KARNATAKA HIGH scum’,
\n_ H363 ‘CGURT EUILBING3.<\/p>\n
‘ T. ‘Q_R.B.R_.A;lIBEDI(.AR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
” ‘x?.,E1\u00a7(3AL\ufb02RE~560 om.<\/p>\n
 ma\ufb01a,
\n,2 o ABDUL $ATAR, AGED ABOUT 3: meme,<\/p>\n
” -az.:t::RmI-re A8 more IN KARNATAKA HIGE coumi.<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT EUILDENG8,
\n{)R.B.R.AHBEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBANGALORE-563 001.\n<\/p>\n
K CHA\ufb02BR% ,
\n3; 0 mm=Am1,AeE3:: mam 44 YEARS,
\nmama AS PEON \u00a38 KARHATAKA HIGH comm’,
\nHIGH coumr mntmmes,<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.Al\u00a7\u00a3BEDKAR vmnm.<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
48.<\/p>\n
49.<\/p>\n
27<\/span><\/p>\n
NAGAMMA,
\nWI (3 RARASl}\ufb02iA GGWDA,
\nAGED ABQUT 41 YEARS, <\/p>\n
wonmm A8 JAMEIJAR IN  25:13:}! bC{.)i J1i*V*I’, <\/p>\n
HIGH coum BUILBING3.   ~ T .. .
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBARGALORE–560 001.;\n<\/p>\n
MANJUNATHA K,  ”\n<\/p>\n
5\/0 LATE
\nAGED ABOUT  woaxane as CABLE
\nOPERATOR IN KARJ\u00e9:A’rA.m\u00bbHIGH%[coLtI?f,
\nHIGH COURT Bunmxas, *    . ”
\nDR.B.RAnmEDKAPV–vEVEDH1..L “<\/p>\n
mxmmmafsact oo: ‘ <\/p>\n
K 3  ” Q     H\u00bb
\n310 K  AEGUT +4 YEAR3,
\n A5; 1″1s.’QE’!._IIIi’  man COURT.<\/p>\n
V ‘ VHIGH–Q\u00a5\u00a3)UR’If Ergmgizwsa,
\n DR,B.R.\ufb01i3I\u00a7\u00a73EEKFxR VEE-‘D31.<\/p>\n
D \u00e9;1a\u00a7.s1I1\u00a7EvA,% ”\n<\/p>\n
  . 3\/ 0 1)’ Lmzmw. mo, AGED ABOUT 31 mans,<\/p>\n
WORIEINGJEQ PEDN IN’ KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
 mGH.coU1?r”‘sU1LnmGs,<\/p>\n
_DR.B.R*.~AMEEDKAR vmnm,<\/p>\n
 B5Hr;a;,o:aE-55o cm.\n<\/p>\n
A 3 v’\u00e9E1\u00e9”EmvAa mmrnv,<\/p>\n
31′ 0- VEHKOB R\ufb01\ufb01), AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS.<\/p>\n
.. WQRKING A8 PEOH IN KARNATAKA HIGH COURT.<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS.\n<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEIXII,<\/p>\n
 BANGALORE~560 001.\n<\/p>\n
E S SURIL KUHAR,<\/p>\n
3ft) 3 B S  AGED ABOUT 34 YEAR3,
\n‘WORBNG A8 PEOH IN KARHAEAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDINGS.\n<\/p>\n
}3R.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI.<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
smmmeam K.\n<\/p>\n
310 KARIGOWDA. AGED ABOUT 44 mm, 2′ ‘f ~<\/p>\n
womcmcas mnnmrmn IN xnmvcrnica
\nHIGH coum, HIGH comer BUILDING8,  —
\nm2.B.R.AmEI:m<AR VEEDHI. H
\nBAHGALORE\u00bb560 om.\n<\/p>\n
M 3\u00bb SHIUAKUMAR,<\/p>\n
5\/0 smnaammmn, AGED  41  = ”   <\/p>\n
wommco as WA’DGH19mN._Hf KARI_%TAI\u00a3.3 %
\nHIGH coum’, HIGH coUm~\u00ab1aUn.DB.vaa,A  A
\nraaaemmsnxaavmznm,’
\nBAN’GAL{)RE~56Q.001.   *<\/p>\n
HhRI8I-I 3.  ~
\n310 B  AGED
\nWORKING AS warcmgaxcz-m:
\nHIGH (_:\u00a3}.\u20ac1R.’i’, HIGH ccavnfr Eungnnms.
\nnrLB._1\u20ac.,A3g;$E_DIcA.R VEEDHL. ‘ <\/p>\n
3 v v1sHwA;ixArz:;%TkTA~+  & _ %<\/p>\n
5)’ Q B.VEf\u20ac1(A’rE3HA,’)1GED ABOUT 35 mans,
\nwommm ma 1=i’:*.<m_;2I mnmrmca HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
' \u00bb HIGH VCQUKF BUTLDING8,<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.Ah+EEDK-AR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
 !3.ARG:6LORE-560 001.<\/p>\n
. 3,! 1:: Emma, AGED mom 4 1 mass.<\/p>\n
WUSEKIHG A8 PEG]! IN KARHATAKA HIGH COURT.
\nE_\u00a7I(}\u00a7\u00a7'COURT BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
" . I}R.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI.<\/p>\n
\u00a7.5'iHGALORE~560 001.<\/p>\n
 mmmmmmm K R,<\/p>\n
I}! O  , AGED ABOUT 39 YEAE,
\nWOI\ufb02{HVGAS PEOR IN ICHRHIKTAKA IEIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COIERT BUEDWGE,<\/p>\n
DRJ33 .AhmEDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
FATHA KAWAZ KHAN,<\/p>\n
SIG R  D KHAN, AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,
\nWORBINGA8 WATCHMAN IN KARKATAKA<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT, HIGH COURT BUILDINGQ,<\/p>\n
59.<\/p>\n
29<\/span><\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
BANG.-ALORE560 O01.\n<\/p>\n
xczamvx,  \u00ab ‘_  .;  V
\n3,10 LATE RA..IANHA,AGED 1413011’? ft-3 ‘mans, ” <\/p>\n
wonmmns more IN  HIGH   <\/p>\n
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS, ” ._ ”
\nDR.B.R.A_l$EDKAR  V’
\nBAHGALGRE-560 001.  ”\n<\/p>\n
s VINAYAKA, 3  ‘ ” V<\/p>\n
sxo mm s MARI, .z; A.:\u00bb;Bot3*rj29
\nWORKING A8 PEON EN ICARlEA’1’.AKA_’HI<.}_H count.
\nHIGH coum BUIL!3H\u00a5GS,. A  %   = %
\nDR.B.R.&1!lEEDKj_AR vmnm,' % ~ <\/p>\n
BANeALo:\u00a7E\u00a25\u00a7o~.ece;;" "  — <\/p>\n
mo c;iE1\u00a22s,5;As;,'AGE:tm3oU'r 42 YEARS,<\/p>\n
  'moat m  HIGH comrr,
\n HIGH CGiJm"}3UILD\u00a7.!iGS-,
\n"DR~B.R.Anm.EDK.&R*1!EEDHI,<\/p>\n
BiA1\u20acG:ALO'RE'~'56Q_ ':'m_1';' '<\/p>\n
1. 8RE1\u00a7D.F\u00a7ARA’G Jr, <\/p>\n
Si O JAVAFAYAFPA, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,<\/p>\n
 awommce A3 ” mo “” ” N In xanmmxa men COURT,<\/p>\n
HEGH CQHRT }3UILI}ING5,<\/p>\n
2. “ag;a;’a,a2{\u00a3EsEDxAx vxsnm,
\nA “33A;3a.a;mE-550 em.<\/p>\n
 mmmv <3 11,
\ngo LATE MARISI-IETTY G.<\/p>\n
" AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS, wcmmicms warcxmn m<\/p>\n
KARHATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
1" \u00e9 HIGH ceum Bmnmcs.\n<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AhlBEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBAHGALORE-360 D01 .\n<\/p>\n
V  HRAWA,<\/p>\n
3\/ G VENKATESHAPPA, AGED ABOUT 40 YEAR8,
\nWDRICIING AS PEOH IN KAKNATAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
DR.B.IR.A%EDKAR VEEDW,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE–56O 001.\n<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
66.<\/p>\n
1.<\/p>\n
30<\/span><\/p>\n
JAGADEESH KUEAE<\/p>\n
8\/ O PADMANABHA BHAT, AGED ABOUT ‘Ki YEARS,
\nWCIRKIXG A8 PEON IN KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDINGS,  ‘-
\nDR.B.R.A\u00a3mEDKAR VEEDKI,<\/p>\n
BANGA.I.ORE–560 001.<\/p>\n
M sxnmsna (32.1,  ” V *-\n<\/p>\n
3[O LIIADEGOWDA, AGED ABOUT 41  _ ‘=,.  ‘<\/p>\n
wonmaas PEON 11: KARNATA.KA’HIQHvC;G13;2T;   <\/p>\n
HIGH coum BUILDINGS, , ,<\/p>\n
1:aR.B.RAnmE1)mR vmmrz. T A ‘ 1 M<\/p>\n
BANGAL{)RE–560 001. V <  *
\n A  PE'I'Ii'\u00a3Q_NERS<\/p>\n
{By Sri RABIJUNDA 339$; 3521:3193 c'i::3t; 1\u00a2rs:ELV1\u00bb?oR _
\n3:z:,.1gmm\u00a7;:z~..mw:a,_} ' <\/p>\n
"'rHE H(:=N\u00a5sVi;E.\u00a2I:$i\u00a7:'\u00a7i\u00a7.Is?r1cE,
\n31:33 COURT"Q'I?_KARIt'ATAKA,
\nHI("}H_ COURT zatixminos,<\/p>\n
' \u00bb DR.B.R.Al\u00a7EBEDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
B}-':K(}ALO'EE,fS6G 001,<\/p>\n
 E1-zap: svrrs REGISTRAR GENERAL.<\/p>\n
. ";..=z1'<?\u00bb;.=_1 e.;:.~UR*r op xnnmrnxca.<\/p>\n
HIGH; noun? aumnmea,
\n\u00a5;_';'Fc HR ALEEDKAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
" I. aanamoas-sac 001.\n<\/p>\n
5121 Menu M 1.,<\/p>\n
4′ 8×0 3121 B LINGEGOWBA,
\nAGED ABOUT 34 ‘new, Rm’: No.1′-5,<\/p>\n
224, RTPS COLGHY, 8 GAR,
\nRMCHHR DI3’1″RIC’.t’.<\/p>\n
his KHBORA,
\nDIG SR1 KK I\u00a3ACBAIAH,AGEIJA3OU’I’35YEARS,<\/p>\n
RIAT 30.124, EHETTAHALLE raczwa,
\nHm Ex’r’ErrsIoN, mmmmm COKVENT,
\nMAz.mIALLi TOWN. HARDYA DISTRECT.<\/p>\n
31<\/span><\/p>\n
SR1 SHIVANAKIAFTA B,<\/p>\n
AGED AEOUT 40 YEAR3,<\/p>\n
WDRKING A8 SEGONI) IJIVTIBIOH A38IB’IIAB’1′,
\nHIGH COURT OF’ KARNAT.BKA,<\/p>\n
DR 13 R AKBEDKAR VEEDKI,
\nBAHGALORE\u00ab-566 00 1 .\n<\/p>\n
SR1 R.&MALIING:\ufb01PPA K M,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, %
\nwoxxnm AS szcoxn DNI8It3N~A3Si_
\nHIGH comrr 0? KARRATAKA,  1,
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDK;AR vEEnm,=, L _ T
\nBsAN\u20ac3:ALORE~560 cm. , A ~<\/p>\n
3121 mnganm ‘1’ A.\n<\/p>\n
AGED mom 42 mans, ‘<\/p>\n
vmaxmc A3 smcorrn nrvizixnii-;xss1s?rA\u00a3wT,Av’ V’<\/p>\n
man COURT O’i?.__KR,mI~\u00a7T&.’Ch,” ._  ” A .
\nnR.B.x.AuBEnK.a’R VEEDHL,’ * A
\naANGALQRE–5oop9’1.,_ V<\/p>\n
man A\u00a35{)U”i’ 35_
\nwcsama as sgcaan nrvmxozc assxsmm,<\/p>\n
* \u00bb HIGH {ZOURT OF KARNATAKA,<\/p>\n
E’.’~R.B.R.AB\u00a3BEDFAR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
 i.EsAHgALoR\u00a3.'”;56o 001.<\/p>\n
  –   3 3U.!JA.\n<\/p>\n
” EEG-EU 40 YWR3,<\/p>\n
 as smcorsrn nrwsron A8813″I?AN’I’,
\nA._EiIGI*\u00a7” CGUR1′ OF KARHATAICA.<\/p>\n
 O. 1aR,B.R.AmEnKAn vmnm,<\/p>\n
-EAH(FI.LORE\u00ab560 001.<\/p>\n
BR} GOPINATH B R,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 4′? YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 SECOND DNISIOH ASSISTANT,
\nHIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBANGALORE\u00bb-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
SET MAHSUR PASHA,<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 35 YT,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 SECOND DIVISION ASSETAETI’,
\nHIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,<\/p>\n
14.<\/p>\n
32<\/span><\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AMBEDI(AR VEEDHL
\nBANGALORE~56O 001.\n<\/p>\n
sm’ Gmnnnmmr 3,
\nAGED ABOUT 45 mm.\n<\/p>\n
woxexma AS snzcoxr: Dxvxszmi $S\u00e9:si”m fP.., \u00ab. ”
\nHIGH comers? Kanwcram, *   <\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AliIEEDE’AR wm\ufb01m,
\nBAHGALc)RE–56(3 001. ” ‘<\/p>\n
SMTHEMAP,   1’ <\/p>\n
AG-ED mom  ;  j _ ‘A
\nwoama A8 sscozm r>r\u00a2IsIo;mss1.9:ca2rr,
\nHIGH coum os.2:.aJ2mA*ra.KA,’   VA
\nBR-ammnnrznx  % ‘
\n ‘   <\/p>\n
  39  <\/span><\/p>\n
  53 3523935 nzvmion ASSISTANT.
\n HIGH CGEJRT
\n“‘DR.B.RAMBE.0XARA-SJEEDHI.<\/p>\n
BI.%gHGALeRE”\u00bb$tE\u00a3_3 mi;<\/p>\n
% .. am  <\/p>\n
AGED ABQUT  YEAR8,<\/p>\n
‘ awonmne ASSECOHD nzvrszon Assmram.
\n_ man com? or KARHATAKA,<\/p>\n
_ ‘n_R.n;na_A2,mEnmR vmmm,
\n“mzqmL.<3:eE.5eo om.\n<\/p>\n
.sI%1..\u00a7?21\u00a2I<ATEsH N,<\/p>\n
, EGED ABGUT 35 YEARS,
\nVWORKINGAB SECOND DIVISION }'s\u00a3818TA1'1'I',<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA.
\n\u00a33R.B.R.AMBEDK&R VEEDHL<\/p>\n
B.AN(M.E.ORE–~56O \u00a3301.<\/p>\n
SR1 JAYARABKU K,<\/p>\n
AGE]? ABOUT 34 Y%.\n<\/p>\n
WURKING A3 SECURE DIVISIQR ASSISTANT.
\nEIGI-I COURT 0}? KARNATAKA,
\nDR.B.R.AMIE3EI)KAR VEEIDIHI,
\nEANGALORE~56O O01.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 MANJUHA’I”\u00a7IA G.\n<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING as saconn I)IV’I3IDI\u00a7_A8Sg-IST;h2\u20ac’I_;.  ”<\/p>\n
HIGH courer 0? KARNATAJIA.
\nnR.B.R.AmaEm:AR vmsnm,
\nBANGALORE~5\ufb010 001. 4<\/p>\n
em: RAMAKRISHRA DVEZ,rV_  ‘
\nAGED ABOUT 33   * ~. _<\/p>\n
woaxmeas sscom pxwalcsrmf A88 ”  3<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT GF’\u00a7QAREATAK&, V
\nI3R,B.R.Ah[}3EDI~L\u00a7R VEEEEE,  n ”
\nBA\ufb02GA.LORE~560001.  <
\n3MT]E 1A1,\u00bb  _ ..\n<\/p>\n
A{;EI:_AB;)UT3c:+y1;;g’Rs. ‘  ”
\n SEC-.Qr’~i1:) Diviszm: ABSISTART.
\nHIGH  ABQUTEQ
\nwagxmc} as s.Ecc.>m:> DIVISION Asaxswazrr,<\/p>\n
– . HIGH SOURT OF KARNATAKA.<\/p>\n
m:z.B.RAm3EDr.m VEEDHI, ‘<\/p>\n
V  i.m{3ALoRE–55o om.\n<\/p>\n
 G.\n<\/p>\n
” ‘Ai}E_7f\u00a3 wow 35 mans,<\/p>\n
. “Ear V.\n<\/p>\n
F-I<\/p>\n
 A8 SECOND nrvxsmw ASSISTANT,
\n..i-iIx’2’*.H COURT OF KAI-EHATAKA.<\/p>\n
 ,. bR.B.RA\u00a7mEDKAR VEEDHI.
\n‘vP*.;ABGALORE-360 om.<\/p>\n
SR1 P  H K,<\/p>\n
AGED i\\BOUT 34 YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING A3 SECOND BIVISION ASSESTANT.
\nHIGH COURT OF’ KA.RRA’I’!LKA,
\nDR.B.R.AMBEBXAR VEEDHI,
\nBAR(3’a&LQRE–\u00bb’56O 001 .<\/p>\n
SR1 UEESI’! H 3,<\/p>\n
AGEB ABOUT 31 YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 SECOND DIVISIQN A88I8TAN’f’,
\nHIGH COURT OF KARNATAI-EA.<\/p>\n
2?.\n<\/p>\n
T 30.\n<\/p>\n
34<\/span><\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AhmEDKAR VEEDHI,
\nBANGALORE-566 001.\n<\/p>\n
SHT HC,<\/p>\n
AGEDABOUTHYEAR3.\n<\/p>\n
wonxmc A8 smcoxm nxvmzoze Assxsraxf
\nHIGH comm’ 011′ Hnzanarraxca,
\nDR.B.R.A1amEDKAR v.=3EmII,_
\nBANCBAIQRE-560 001. ‘<\/p>\n
am menu L, A
\nAGED mom 2 1 mans, ~ ._<\/p>\n
woamaas sacoxn H, ” – .%1oN”.aasw:\u00a7x:\u00a7*f;~\u00a7V”‘%  <\/p>\n
HIGH coum’ OF KARHATAKA, _ ‘- .
\nDR.Ei.R.Ah\u00a3B13}DI\u20acfLR vzsnnr;-.
\nBAIVIGALGRE-560 ’em.   _ . <\/p>\n
3M’;”3′.   .\n<\/p>\n
  23  <\/span><\/p>\n
  Assscqma nwisiom ASSISTANI’.
\n HIGH ccz\u00e9zmr 03′
\n‘DR.B.R.A3\u00a33EDK\ufb01R”EfE.EDPH,<\/p>\n
E\u00e9JiQALGRE=~569 mi;\n<\/p>\n
V ,, sM’ruirE$Yh~K, <\/p>\n
AGED Ascmfr  mas,<\/p>\n
‘ iwoaxme as smcoxm nrvmron ASSIBTANF,
\n_ H1631 team 0? KARHATAKA,<\/p>\n
T. 3:a_12.a;1?,.A:;aBEnxAR VEIZDHI,
\n” om.\n<\/p>\n
 DRAIQIIA O,<\/p>\n
.. AGED ABOUT 39 YEMIS,
\n‘W(>RKIN\u20ac3 A8 SECOND DIVISION $83-IBTANT,<\/p>\n
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKFL.
\nDR.B.R.AMBEDI’IAR VEEBHI,
\nBLARGALORESGO 001.\n<\/p>\n
SET PERT!-IEBHA K 3.\n<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,<\/p>\n
WORKING AB SEC-OED DIVISION ASSISTANT,
\nHIGH COURT OF KAKRATAKA,
\nDR.B.R.A%EI)KAR VEEDEI,
\nBANGf\\LORE-550 001.\n<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
32.<\/p>\n
33.<\/p>\n
  1 .\n<\/p>\n
 sm%sm  T  %<\/p>\n
am KANAKA N,
\nAGED ABOUT 40 mam,  . _ ,
\nwcmmm as smonn DIVISION nasmmz\u00abm
\nHIGH COURT OF 1mRm’z*A1c:s;” . .. T’
\nnR.B.RAmEnmR vmmaiz,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 001.\n<\/p>\n
8RIRAVI3HANKA.RB,’ _ <\/p>\n
AGED mom 32 AV  ~– ._  %
\nWORKING AS smozma Dwzsmi Aaaletmm,
\nHIGH coum cm  ”\n<\/p>\n
DR.B.R.AHBEDSEA$vt VE’_ED3\u00a3I, ”\n<\/p>\n
BANGALORE660 om. %     \"\n\nSR1 vuwr   _ A _\n\n<\/pre>\n
AGEn;ABmUT anwmxas,  A ‘  V.
\nwomcmc; s~Ecom:; D:’V1\u00a7\u00a7IOH, ASSISTANI’,
\nI-Ilcm c.-‘:mII\\2’r’–w<3F
\nDR.3..R';-:u\u00e9mE1:+mn"vrs3m:)\ufb01I,;<\/p>\n
Azmn ABQUTSQ
\nwoame as S..ECQi'ID DIVISION AS3i8TAN"i',<\/p>\n
* \u00bb HIGH Ci,OU'Ri' OF KARKATAKA.<\/p>\n
I3R.B.R.A\ufb01EB_EDF.'AR VEEDHI,<\/p>\n
'  s._nmx;ALoRE';'55o 001.<\/p>\n
"  xnmm.\n<\/p>\n
” ;.n_c:.sn  3 1 mm.\n<\/p>\n
mama as snconm nrvrsron A3SI.’3’PAH’I’,
\n.H1<2\u00abr:* coum' OF' xanmrmm,<\/p>\n
 O. DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHL
\naaxeazons-sac om.\n<\/p>\n
THE memrma mpmnmmnom,
\nI-KGH COURT 0′; KARHATAKA,
\nDR.B.R.Ahl.’BEDKAR vmznm,<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 O01.\n<\/p>\n
(BY SR1 BABAVAPRABHU 8 PATH\u00bb, SENIOR COUIESEL<\/p>\n
FORR–1,2&36.)<\/p>\n
36<\/span><\/p>\n
mass wrzrr PETTFIONS man PRAYmG.?f\u20acZ5  _
\nexam noses 3\/zoos annmmzea .v_;ir..,2o_i\u00a7;2{2c9′,~-T
\nonnsn no.Hc-E 3\/zoos  m’,5.\u00a7’.\u00e9’cx;1\u00a7  V
\nFAR as rr RELATES TC} REs.i?\u00a7:>1n:\u00bbE:;ei1*”T1\u00a7rt>..\u00e9t;- ‘(.’}i15?gL’.z_E1’vi*:;_
\n1ero.HcE amen-t BANIEALQRE n’r.vnA.6.12oo9T;x;z 3\u00a2’vQU}s.\u00e9;H% V<\/p>\n
me: ORDER N0.H<.'iE ~,mi.6;'3;'2bo9
\nALL PASSED BY THE R\u00a7\u00a7"$P\u00a7)HDEI\u20ac'i" …1sto.35; vmm
\nANNEXURE8~C, D, E  FTO  PETITION, ETC.
\nmg.g.\u00a7u..g79?~3es9\u00a7 1' 3V\u00a7Q%"v%',9.;4;T:  <\/p>\n
1.<\/p>\n
 ” 2:2<\/p>\n
3; o suazagswmpa.  4*; YEARS,<\/p>\n
. V   “3 E’1~m.Ie  m<\/p>\n
 ma.wA’r.-{am ‘}na:\u00ab1 ;::QuR1*,
\n“HIGH cou’R*r.B1m.1:a11ras.<\/p>\n
DR 3 R Aamm:>z;Aa.v’E’Enm.
\nBAHQALQRE-sac am.\n<\/p>\n
‘A H KODAND”\ufb01a.RAMA. K,
\n‘ 1.3,! O”–.E!U\ufb02I\u00a5AP?’A, AGED ABOUT 54 males,<\/p>\n
w<:RxmGAs SENIOR ASSISTANT IN<\/p>\n
'V "V _ " Kgatmrxga IHGH courr,
\n" EEIQH seam EUILDIHGS,<\/p>\n
DR 3'j_129'A:\u00a3aEnKAR VEEDHI,
\nEAl\u00a7GALORE~5\u20ac:0 cox.\n<\/p>\n
” ksmvmm K.\n<\/p>\n
3}’ O KEMPEGOWDA,<\/p>\n
\u00e9 ms!) ABOUT 54 mm,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 SENIOR ASEISTANF IR
\nKIHRKATAKA mm: COURT,<\/p>\n
HIGH C-OIERT BUILDINGS,<\/p>\n
DR \ufb02 R &BBEDKAR VEEBHI,
\nEA.KGAI.ORE—560 001.<\/p>\n
JAYARAMA HAYAKA 8,<\/p>\n
S10 SUBBANAYAEA<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 40 3%,<\/p>\n
WORKING A8 E?-EIVFIOR AS8I8TANT IN<\/p>\n
37<\/span><\/p>\n
ICFLRNATAKA HIGH COURT,<\/p>\n
PIIGH COURT BUILDING-8,<\/p>\n
me E R AMBEDKAR vmnnnw  V
\nBAHGAL\u20ac)RE–560 om. ”\n<\/p>\n
mtormrz mum P,
\nago X FAD ;\n<\/p>\n
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, “_  V
\nWORICENGAS SENIOR  Bin. ” ‘ ”
\nKARNAYAKA HIGH COURI’._”\u00bb, –.,<\/p>\n
mcm coum’ Butxuqmas, ‘  1′ V ” % ._<\/p>\n
BR B R AMBEDKAR VI:’.ED?i\u00a7II;.  *
\nBANCEALORE-560 0011. ” ‘
\nMKNJU1%’1’KA 3iHE’1,’1’YM.R;~v”‘V-. ‘ ”<\/p>\n
sfo l\u00a3 R 1?m~.;\u20acJ.f!. SHE-‘I’i”Y, ‘   ”
\nAGED  55  ”  g \u00bb<\/p>\n
 HIGH CD333?\u00bb ‘V<\/p>\n
 HIGH ..couR:’Eu11.p”mGs_,  ”
\n DR B R’15;;1g\u00a7I\u00a3\u00a3>K;*:.R’vE1BDHL
\n“aANGAZ.ORE+36G. ham.’ <\/p>\n
‘ \u00bb am cxmnmanaavama,<\/p>\n
AGED ABGUT  YEARS,<\/p>\n
‘  i..s3:om;1r\u00a2GA3″‘8Emon ASSISTANT Is’<\/p>\n
 mar: comm,<\/p>\n
A ” ” V _ “H1GH~Qo’;rRT numnmcs.
\n“;31:::..g 23, 2-.msr:nxa.R vmmnm.<\/p>\n
Bsmgaionm-5m 0-oz.\n<\/p>\n
4.’ .,  B R,<\/p>\n
E5,-“O 8 RAHAIAI-I,
\nAGED ABQUT 39 YEARS,<\/p>\n
1′ \u00ab wommas szmon ASBIBTAM’ RI<\/p>\n
IGFLRNATAKA HXGH COUKI’,
\nHIGH COURT BUILDINGS,
\nDR B R AJEEDXAR VEEDHI,
\nEs’..\ufb01.NG:ALORE~56O 001.<\/p>\n
ANTHORY KUHAR,<\/p>\n
3\/ 0 IIIIRUZJAYAPPA, AGE!) ABOUT 5 1 YEARS,
\nWORIQNG A\ufb01 SENIOR ABSWTAW H?
\nKARNATAKA HIGH CGURT,<\/p>\n
38<\/span><\/p>\n
HIGH COURT Bunmxaa,
\nDR B R Anmsnmn VEEDHI.\n<\/p>\n
BANGALORE-560 em.\n<\/p>\n
1:1. KAJA1il.’UNIRULL\ufb01ICI-IAN, ,  ..   – V
\nsgoanwnnuumnzsmn Anoufrss  – . \u00ab.
\nwomulmms smmaxnsagswawsm  A ..
\nKARHATAKA HIGH ooumf, ‘ . ‘<\/p>\n
HIGH COU1?I’BU1I.Dm’G8,*.._ ‘ _
\nDR B R AEEDKAR  ”\n<\/p>\n
BARGALORE–56\u00a3} 5:31.    _
\n ~ –  V    .A  PETITIONERS
\n{ BY 3121 HAN.J’lJHDA.REDDY,’ SEI+\ufb01QR.CC)UN8EL
\n ~._F’=!3R 55121 REEIBEN.-EAQOEE’. )<\/p>\n
15333<\/p>\n
1.  THE’Hs_:mBL}3 CHIEF JUSTICE,
\na_HIGH COURT <3F'i!.aiaUs'rAKA,<\/p>\n
HIGH ce;3UR'if\u00a3%UI1,D-11Ic38,<\/p>\n
DR. B R AliBEz')3E{.\ufb01R*~YEEDHI,
\nBAHGALOFRE-._~5\u20ac=0 G91,<\/p>\n
" " REP BY-\u00bbI.'hi"8'REGE$TRAR GENERAL.<\/p>\n
 _ "2;  *mE'%'gEG.4 ism """ "RA GENERAL.<\/p>\n
~ ._ ..:1:m1%c'::a_u12'r or KARIIATAKA,\n<\/p>\n
– _ i-z.1G:1’cc;zm sumnmes.
\n13.313 3: gumnnmn wsmnm.
\na_.+uxcmmar:-5ae om.\n<\/p>\n
 -V   REEPGNDEHTB<\/p>\n
( SR1 BABAVAPTRABHU 8 PATEL, 3EN1OR COUNSEL<\/p>\n
”  FORR~16s2.]<\/p>\n
THESE WRET PEFTHON3 FILED PRIEYING TO<\/p>\n
 DECIARE THAT THE HIGH GGURT OF KARHATAICA<\/p>\n
SERVICE (commons <31? SERVICE M5113 Rmcmrrrumrm
\n{:1 Anmnnnmwn RULES, was mmusxmn VIDE
\nNormcmnon NCLHCE 22112009 DT.29.'?.2009 (VEDE
\nANNEXURE–.A) is so FAR As rt REIATE8 To THE CADRE<\/p>\n
op saczncm amczns. as  _
\nUNCON8'I'I'I'U'I'IC)HAL AND COHSEQUEKFLY mm  _ '
\nwas aam AMENDMENT mr Igarkrgncn' (')"'1i"=_ $)I'v*._ "<\/p>\n
39<\/span><\/p>\n
CERTIORARI, ETC.\n<\/p>\n
 A
\n3&5:  ”\n<\/p>\n
1.<\/p>\n
am mmsn, V <\/p>\n
5; 0 ANNAPPA, At}:\u00a7z3.Aac;::%r <\/p>\n
sm R M mvnmmm\u00bb % if ”   .V ” ”\n<\/p>\n
am Lfg’\u00a3f$._J5E”JNIL3W;fsM!, 15631) 46 make.<\/p>\n
  ‘<\/p>\n
3; 0 ‘AGED  44 mus.\n<\/p>\n
 am  <\/p>\n
sat P 3: s1;~It31it\u00ab3<\u00a7wI)A,
\ns10–m'rE mmvmawm,<\/p>\n
% 1. was AEOUT 49 mm.\n<\/p>\n
_ ‘xi HUDDU MOHAN,
\n_ ’31 an ;m12Asn;Hn,naU12THv,
\n~ :x:3~I.1f:_r::  47 mm.<\/p>\n
331.
\n91 0 mzwneovhn<\/p>\n
_ ~ VAGEDABOUT51 .\n<\/p>\n
1 ‘ \u00a2 912: namxmvazan H,<\/p>\n
H S O LATE’ EGOWDA.\n<\/p>\n
‘ EANA8
\nAG D ABOUT 43 YEARS.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 L K SHIVAHNA,
\n3} O KADUVEGOWDA,
\nAGED ABQUT 39 YEAR$.\n<\/p>\n
40<\/span><\/p>\n
SR} G HUNIKREHNAPPA,
\nS,’ O H GAL A,
\nAGED ABOUT 36 YEARS.\n<\/p>\n
smnmmsmcmmo,    M
\n3:0 mxsrmamo, AGED AB\u00a73U’I’_\ufb01a   ‘ <\/p>\n
512: QHANAMAYAH K,  _
\nam LATE KRISHNA R\ufb01nxsxf,
\nAGED ABOUT 42  V’  5<\/p>\n
am RAVIKUMAR
\n$10 VEERAYYA, AQED  $2 <\/p>\n
31213 K mnarn  1 — ~
\n3; o 3 K ms’:\u00a7_:RA:sr9A c;:.:aurnp.1\u00a7,._
\narms  4o=:ma33.  A V  ..\n<\/p>\n
3121  ._ ‘ ‘<\/p>\n
 ‘3%;'”<::' 40 mans.\n<\/p>\n
8350  AGED ABOUT 41 YEAIE.<\/p>\n
~ . am \ufb01’K.1:iI8H.NAf”PA; :<\/p>\n
3;’ O  AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS.<\/p>\n
“$5151-mama KHAN,<\/p>\n
_ “:3; {>.raa;A:.;=:EL ULIA KHAN,
\nA “M’.’\u00a7I\u00a7D 5330? 37 mans.<\/p>\n
ALL  WORKING A3 EEECOND DIVISION ASSISTANT,<\/p>\n
 , 3?, THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,<\/p>\n
J 20.\n<\/p>\n
 1.<\/p>\n
.  SR1 K GQPAIA,<\/p>\n
Si O K P  , AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS.<\/p>\n
am: ALIHULIAH mm,
\n3; <3 mm ZIAULLAKHAN,
\nAGEI) mom 35 mm.\n<\/p>\n
SET ANEE8 FATEIMA.\n<\/p>\n
W] 0 MD AYEJATHU1-IA,
\nAGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.\n<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
22.<\/p>\n
24.<\/p>\n
2?.\n<\/p>\n
%:a:%<\/p>\n
ems SUNANDA. % T \ufb02<\/p>\n
9110 H 9 SHASBIKUMAR. AGED Aaoufl\ufb01  % ‘ ‘<\/p>\n
SMTPRRALINA,<\/p>\n
Wm H L LQKESH, AGED A.\u00e9zg3U’;*.3;>fivvi-:a;iaA3.’\\\\\\ .  ~ A’<\/p>\n
snrrn samsvamxaszm,     _ V;
\n310 R VISHWAPRA8ADi_\ufb01GED AB{)__U’\u00a3’_  ‘<\/p>\n
sax P
\ns; 0 N Pnnvanmgm, AGED–lLj3\u00a7}tIT 43 YEARS.<\/p>\n
am LEEIA idB,  ‘A ._
\nW19 H GVKAVEENKU *
\nman m3pz;’r 27 <\/p>\n
‘.4 <\/p>\n
am. g\ufb01anrmiv\ufb01, .\n<\/p>\n
3; cs  c;\n<\/p>\n
 sax  I
\n“:3; <7 BASAVAHYAFPA, AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS.<\/p>\n
s1irRoo\u00a7A1.A;\n<\/p>\n
— , S10 3 R\ufb01I%{f\u00e9A8WAMY, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS.<\/p>\n
;_SR1v R,
\n_ :5;.o4Ra4ANm M, AGED ABOUT 32 ‘mags.<\/p>\n
    mo,<\/p>\n
3; zzz\u00e9jzi  mo,
\n3-i”n’GEI} ABOUT 41 YEARS.<\/p>\n
” em? YASHODA,<\/p>\n
9170 K S HARASHIHAIAH,<\/p>\n
” ” AGED mom 4:: mm.\n<\/p>\n
ALL ARE ‘WORKIHG AS TYPIST, IN
\nTHE HIGH CGURT OF KARNATAKA,<\/p>\n
EAHGALORE~ I.\n<\/p>\n
. .. PETYFIOEER8<\/p>\n
( HY SR1 JAYAKUMARR, SENEOR COUNSEL
\nFOR SR1 DAYANAND S FATE. }<\/p>\n
‘:”” P {O in .-.1 9~:5a_.-‘gm w..=’S,=:’:<\/p>\n
42<\/span><\/p>\n
\u00a3’s_Ii.12_=<\/p>\n
33″.?’ :4 53″‘ P’<\/p>\n
fast
\n.~.<\/p>\n
THE HIGH {3OUR’I’ OF IQKRHATAKA,<\/p>\n
EANCSEALORE-550 O01.\n<\/p>\n
BY ITS REGISTRAR GENERAL.<\/p>\n
THE REGISTAR [ADBZINETRATIONL
\nTHE HIGH COURT OF KARKATAKA,<\/p>\n
BA’-‘dIOALORE~560 001.<\/p>\n
THE ETATE or
\nBY rrs CHIEF sncmzzrmzv, A<\/p>\n
vmrmm soumm, m 1,%% %* \u00bb = ” <\/p>\n
THE sram 09 <\/p>\n
BEPARPHEKP OF PERSGNHE’ . L11 D    ‘ <\/p>\n
AD \ufb02VE rempoamssf;-_ ”\n<\/p>\n
av rrs sncnzyxmme,  V’<\/p>\n
  ~ %
\n“am mmya.   ~ <\/p>\n
  M 3m mwamz H.\n<\/p>\n
 E>’3m%_3  ____ _. s<\/p>\n
., \u00a7\u00a7Ez[‘T*D I2fYAMANGALh H J,
\nT’   H,<\/p>\n
s_a\u00a2r\u00a7:-zbvavamx H K,<\/p>\n
{A Sm mnnm mo av.\n<\/p>\n
am aamoomm J KARISHETTY,<\/p>\n
\u00ab 5&1′! G S R{DOPASHREEp<\/p>\n
snrr SHA.L\ufb02’\u20aclI 3,<\/p>\n
324′: R CHANDRAKAIA,
\nSm K 5 1um\u00a2GA1.A,<\/p>\n
snrr H R cnzmnammm.\n<\/p>\n
sRI GOVIRDARAJU R.\n<\/p>\n
SRI HAIARAIEC 0,<\/p>\n
23.\n<\/p>\n
24.\n<\/p>\n
25.<\/p>\n
26.<\/p>\n
“” 4″” ~59 4*’ -F-v  4 f.’f~,..\u20ac*’ 31-r\ufb01 Q:–\u00ab.0 3′-4…V.9o :4 an 3* .3 3-4 av 2- 9 \ud83d\ude2e 53′ ?’a<\/p>\n
50.<\/p>\n
43<\/span><\/p>\n
am axxaummpm    <\/p>\n
SET BHARATHI K,<\/p>\n
snrr souameva B A.\n<\/p>\n
SHIT TANUJA RANI,<\/p>\n
SET LEELRVATHI 3,  <\/p>\n
9.121 M MADHUCHANDRAQ  <\/p>\n
sax EBATHIBH mm 1* c, <\/p>\n
sax  3,5″\n<\/p>\n
sm HANJUNATH 8} ‘ ‘ _ _<\/p>\n
Sm pnavmzn K;:maRfc,V ”  ‘ _
\nSHIT  A 1 =    2 <\/p>\n
sat at  4 ”\n<\/p>\n
smf  mayamx\ufb01xnn.\n<\/p>\n
M 4, 331 mp  3.1;”\n<\/p>\n
 _syE:\u00a7”1m3.z;=z:M.UR.xEHmaan,
\n v\ufb01snnmva N,<\/p>\n
s1a*i*Lj*;r:::=:z\u00a2A C. B,
\n31:1-ubanswamva N,<\/p>\n
”  SIDDAKAGOWDA NAGESHAPPA ANAJI.<\/p>\n
SMTRAIINIKP,<\/p>\n
‘ am BAIAPPA V BETAGERI,<\/p>\n
SEEK’ RAHAEAI NAIR,
\nSM’? ‘FHEJASWIIGI 3 N.\n<\/p>\n
SR1 RAGHU 3.3,<\/p>\n
SR1 RABIES}-I P C,<\/p>\n
SHIT SULOCHANA,
\nSR1 M SHIVAKUHAR,<\/p>\n
IL
\n5*’<\/p>\n
us
\n1″\n<\/p>\n
Ln
\n5*”\n<\/p>\n
an
\n.9′<\/p>\n
res?-‘\u00a7\u00a7~’\u00a73~’T\u00b07~’\u00a7’3’73r’3’s”\u00a7>-%$’3’a$&2&E3.’3-‘%”6\u00e9G’:3<\/p>\n
an
\n59<\/span><\/p>\n
{H
\n3″‘<\/p>\n
an
\nE9<\/p>\n
on
\nP’<\/p>\n
am snmu How.\n<\/p>\n
3121 smnazmamsuwsn G PATEL,
\nam 3  mm K.\n<\/p>\n
gm 3 K SHRUTHI,<\/p>\n
31:: Y nmxpxumaze.\n<\/p>\n
Sm’ R MANJULA,<\/p>\n
SET K M <\/p>\n
am YAsHoI>Ha <3, _<\/p>\n
am' 3 \u20ac'3AYA'1'HRI',VM ' '<\/p>\n
SHIT 3 Brmmmi;  – If V<\/p>\n
3121 cyst    2 <\/p>\n
mM\ufb01EmwmMwmUf'<\/p>\n
 \ufb01HVWwEmwEi %
\nsmvmwmmmmmm<\/p>\n
8RI _N 15 REv\u00e9;.i2\u00a2.a:'r-mwna,<\/p>\n
, SK: mm M Ii.\n<\/p>\n
2  B <\/p>\n
“3Im\u00a7 5a_ R pmsmna xumm,\n<\/p>\n
— I  PREETHI,<\/p>\n
arm; 15: 8U’RE3HA.\n<\/p>\n
\u00abgm :1′ s CHANDRA,<\/p>\n
” ..gjz<1A R $RIHATI-I.<\/p>\n
SR1 D BJRDARINATH R4350.<\/p>\n
SR1 MANJUHATH BEAT,<\/p>\n
SR1'. K V SATISH REIJIJY,<\/p>\n
SR1' HA.LI.J'WAI.A LEEARAMA APAYA,
\nSR1 U Ii! Hhli\ufb01f-I,<\/p>\n
SR1 PRAKASH '1',<\/p>\n
SET SMTRA K.\n<\/p>\n
SET KAVITHA S,<\/p>\n
85.<\/p>\n
\u20ac’Ia’\u00a2”G
\n:4 .=~s4r.4=-\u00a7-‘3s33′<':3$%$3~"<\/p>\n
~a
\n9\u00b0<\/p>\n
:90,
\n _1'\u00e9-1.\n<\/p>\n
 \u00ab._i”a’.:.\n<\/p>\n
1’95.\n<\/p>\n
. 106.”\n<\/p>\n
 V. ” ‘T132,
\n‘  165’;\n<\/p>\n
 109.<\/p>\n
‘ 110.\n<\/p>\n
111-\n<\/p>\n
112.\n<\/p>\n
113.\n<\/p>\n
114.<\/p>\n
am GIRIDHAR s, ‘<\/p>\n
SRIB s rmcmzzam,<\/p>\n
SR1 smzsmmvnsn,<\/p>\n
sm vxmrrm 1: 3,<\/p>\n
am HAMSA v,<\/p>\n
am mnuzaerxa 1.,<\/p>\n
am’ KALINI 12. \u00a7  _
\nsax MALLIiWATHi_lEU<3:HLGAC)'I\u20ac,V_  ' ~- . _
\nsm sarvmmxm 5  % '
\nSMT  G   ' ' .\n<\/p>\n
am’ cg-Fs\ufb01ajgm 3   V’
\nan; :\u00ab:.mn*qV_1_s; R, 4.;  ”  ‘ V .<\/p>\n
    _
\n.s:m sU1~jt3aJ\u00a7I1:}4A~<:,_:  VF  " <\/p>\n
em vAsHo13Hh.–B ;* ._ '
\nam  BHAVIKATII,<\/p>\n
:\u00a7}RI_1i'1'5;iUKARADHYA 3 I6',
\n,1  ngmigappa Laxaxopm,<\/p>\n
  3 JABIBIATH,
\nam sgaxwa C 1!,<\/p>\n
{sin vzsmmranaaeoun FATE.
\nam GEE'?!-IA R c.\n<\/p>\n
3121 QURESSH MURNAL.\n<\/p>\n
8-RI RAMA}?-JANEYA H,<\/p>\n
am arnnxacom,<\/p>\n
sax mmnmauurmv c,
\nSm Mourmrsn M,<\/p>\n
an: NARIJEESHKUHAR G B,
\nan: smrrmaa c,<\/p>\n
115.
\nI16.\n<\/p>\n
11?.\n<\/p>\n
I18.\n<\/p>\n
119.
\nI20.\n<\/p>\n
I21.\n<\/p>\n
122.
\nI23.\n<\/p>\n
124.
\nI25.\n<\/p>\n
126.\n<\/p>\n
127.<\/p>\n
am’ Rsma H,<\/p>\n
am R. 3 anvmm,
\nsnrr m K nmcnaum.\n<\/p>\n
snrr :3 mmvmn EM,
\n312: G at vmawmm,
\nSHIT Umm SALMA.\n<\/p>\n
Sm’ M DEVILKA,<\/p>\n
3141? R MALATHI,  .\n<\/p>\n
31:21 E R MAHESHWARAPPAQ <\/p>\n
am P 3 PAI3MA’Q_}’i’?I-IY\u00a2’_VA  \u00ab A’<\/p>\n
am’ VEEHA G and, A ‘ V   _
\nam’   ”\n<\/p>\n
am mawam         <\/p>\n
 am”  %<\/p>\n
.  mam;  HUBBALLI,\n<\/p>\n
– M 6-\n<\/p>\n
–. ., em? $OmEYA;-\n<\/p>\n
 3$;l\u00a3’1’__A T};m22,r..w;a.<\/p>\n
“*mE4R2raponnENrs AT 3L.No.5 To 132<\/span><\/p>\n
A ” ‘V V _ \ufb01\u00a2.LL”MA..IOR\u00a35, ALL ARE wcmmce as<\/p>\n
”  Dnimox A33I8’I’A.N’1’3,
\nHIGH. COURT’ or KARHATAKA.\n<\/p>\n
 001.<\/p>\n
”   RESPONDERTE<\/p>\n
  u ” ‘  ‘A =  (3? am maavapmamr 9 mm, BERIOR covnsm<\/p>\n
FOR R-1 80 2.\n<\/p>\n
‘ – sm 5 V PRAKASH. ADV. ma R-96, 93, ms, 123.<\/p>\n
am mmnraunm N M, mv. 903 R493. was. 112,
\n100, 101 & 123.}<\/p>\n
THESE WRIT PETITION8 FILED PRAYENG T0 QUASH<\/p>\n
THE NOTIFIGA’I’IOH H01-ICE 221]20\ufb029 DT.29.7.3{)09 mg
\nANNEXURE–B SO FAR IT RELATE3 TO ITEM 30. AT<\/p>\n
-$7<\/p>\n
SL.HO.15 i.o., paouomon or am; AND    ~
\ncmaan en mar amazon ASSITANT <1:-<:}1\u00ab_rc.:2~..1s2\u00a7m1':n".–..1:'\u00ab:'I.'.<:.  " –\u00ab ., <\/p>\n
THESE Plarrrrzons COMING crsj'  <\/p>\n
mar, THE comm' MADE it':-m:_mLLcwmG:
\n9——\u00a7R
\nA3 common   involved in all
\nthese  of by this<\/p>\n
common   .\n<\/p>\n
2.   challenge is to the
\n (by way of Amemimentn]
\naubsti\ufb01xtpd    Rakes of High Court of<\/p>\n
  of Service and Recruitment)<\/p>\n
_’  and thc petitioners are. \ufb01icved by the
\n .  qualificaticms by way af :1? in reapact<\/p>\n
{Sf aon\ufb01\u00e9 ‘c\u00e91t\u00a2gories of posts and law day-ea in raapect of<\/p>\n
 A.   of posts anti these changes bemg’
\n‘  ‘isiii\u00e9otittztecl by way of the amendments ts the existing
\n Ruhs:{rem’ui’\u00a3ment and hence the attack is directed<\/p>\n
against the proviso and the e.-xplanation to the amended<\/p>\n
Rules. },<\/p>\n
-18<\/p>\n
3. Writ Petition \ufb01es. I1???-1182712010 arc by the<\/p>\n
petifmnsara wlw joined the services of the Respr_:ii%\u00e9:x;t<\/p>\n
High Cam-t as Group ‘D’ Enztploycm and   _<\/p>\n
:9 Second Bivision Assistants\/’I’ypn’ ta  as ”    <\/p>\n
the post of First Division  <\/p>\n
aggrieved by the proviso V1;:2 tI1e420 O9   <\/p>\n
they have been required to’ al’   any
\nUnwem’ ity aaatahIist;g’\u00a7gi~.1y     forts:
\nthe next lmh’ at post of   <\/p>\n
4. +633-4722×2010 are by the:<\/p>\n
 Aaiiate\ufb01xj\ufb01qaxxd th:.-‘u- p1-emotion to the next post<\/p>\n
  =   Assistant (FDA) is under threat, as they<\/p>\n
   to poaews a dww \ufb01ram recognised<\/p>\n
 ,  Writ Petition Hos. 22155-$134\/2010 31% by the<\/p>\n
 Sttzmgraplwra. Judgment Writers and Scnior Judgment
\nWriters and the’n- grievance is that, the Sizanogmphars<\/p>\n
areaborcquiredtoposaeasadcgreefromarecow\ufb01od
\nUniversity to move 11:: the post of Judgment Write;-:1’ and<\/p>\n
49<\/span><\/p>\n
the Judgnacnt Writczrs, in turn, are to
\ndegrvae and 50 aka the  <\/p>\n
poascss law degree to move  :;n  ;’5\u00e9:\u00a7wt_i:-jf.:<\/p>\n
Assistant Rgistrar.\n<\/p>\n
5. Writ Petition \ufb01gs.  by the
\nSecond Division   ixmamuch as.
\nPetitionezu  8 Igwsistarlts and
\nPetitiongrrai ;\u00a7:%jts\u00e9   %MsLi\u00a7a they are am
\nposisegaa :49. $21 to the next post in the<\/p>\n
  35966-36032\/2009 are by the<\/p>\n
.’ ‘  \ufb01rm a recogxiaed Univemity tn wave
\non \ufb01fth: post of Second Division Assistant.<\/p>\n
‘%   Writ Petition Bios. 35*r97-36896\/2009 are by the<\/p>\n
 Senior Assistant: and they have to poazmss a dmree<\/p>\n
\ufb01vm a rewgnised Univmuity to be eligible for the post of<\/p>\n
Section O\ufb01iccrs. 3″; \/\n<\/p>\n
-“T7<\/p>\n
50<\/span><\/p>\n
9;. in Writ Petitions 1179’7-1132172010,  <\/p>\n
mus Rajesh is reported m be dead and   <\/p>\n
Sri.S.G.Bhagawan had \ufb01led  <\/p>\n
petition agents’ 1: him abapeu,   <\/p>\n
abatm against the mid Rasfiigfident [  ‘V<\/p>\n
19. In the batch \u00abpr  j%;>ggemon ‘ff-‘:A:s’\u00a7’ 4683-<\/p>\n
\n4722\/2910,  ms1gned'\nthe scrvkxgs    \ufb01om the\n\nservices\n\n<\/pre>\n
11.   elcmcmtmy facts, the<\/p>\n
 V’  _ A   In be rez\ufb01erned tn.<\/p>\n
  ‘:2~.%  batch of Writ Petitions mfermd to<\/p>\n
 petitinnen seek qua,uh1ng’ ofthe prams’ 0 as<\/p>\n
 \u00ab kjaubaaiumd at Sl.No.14- in Column No.4 of Notifica\ufb01on<\/p>\n
 HCE muzmg dated 29.07.2909, winch’ is at<\/p>\n
‘Tizk\ufb01-‘A’at2drefcrrodtoaatheHighCourtof<\/p>\n
Karnataalm (Sarvioe Canditimu) Er”! Amenclnsrimt Fades,
\n2009 and 81130 to quash Order No. HCE 307\/2009 dated<\/p>\n
18,8.2GO9 pranm\ufb01ng Resporuienm 3 to 58 as First<\/p>\n
51<\/span><\/p>\n
Division iiasiatanu as pct Annexure — ‘B’   <\/p>\n
Respondents 1 and 2 to mpaeitigr    V<\/p>\n
Pmzitioners also for promotion Af\ufb01at.    ‘<\/p>\n
13. In Writ Petition m%%%%221ss.;g:21%a4; sthe V<\/p>\n
petiticrtuars have V am mm
\nAmtmdment Rulna,    pubmmd in
\nthe    per A.nnexure-\n<\/p>\n
B) and me’  Him 307’\/2009 dated
\n  cake to quash the
\nNe\ufb01\ufb01ca\ufb01o\ufb01 2-mtj dated 28.5.2009 insofar as
\nthe   qualification to the posts of<\/p>\n
  Writers and Senior<\/p>\n
   neLu:f’ sought in to quash the promath nu<\/p>\n
‘  Reapondcnta 3 to 13 as per the Noti\ufb01cation at<\/p>\n
— ”   – ‘G’, ‘H’, ‘J’ and ‘K’.<\/p>\n
 15. The \ufb01zrthcr prayer sought in to declarc that<\/p>\n
stipulatioxz of competi\ufb01vu tent to the pout of Judgment
\nWrizscm and Senior Judit Writers ix: the Draft Rule:<\/p>\n
and to declare the quata restricted in Senior Judgment<\/p>\n
S2<\/p>\n
Writers to thc post of Assistant  <\/p>\n
and without any basis   <\/p>\n
promotion to the posts  Senior
\nJudgment Writers   on the basis<\/p>\n
sf  V .\n<\/p>\n
16.    2010, thc
\n  of the proviso to
\n  where the quali\ufb01cation of
\n  the proviso at $139.15<\/p>\n
.  No}? and ta quash tho order Ho.
\n   at Armature — ‘I3’ <\/p>\n
 .  to 130 as First Division Assistants ml<\/p>\n
  the ms: of the  for promotion to<\/p>\n
 A.  post.\n<\/p>\n
 17. in Writ Petitiaon Nos. 3721347249\/2009, the relief<\/p>\n
sought in to quash Noti\ufb01cation No. I-ICE i221f2CO’9<\/p>\n
dated 29.7.2009 (Annexuro-B) so far as it patains no
\nSZ.Ho.15 i.e., promotion of Second Diw\ufb02nion Assistant<\/p>\n
3%”\n<\/p>\n
53<\/span><\/p>\n
and Typists to the cadre of First Division.  <\/p>\n
to quash the order of pmmo\ufb01or; at  \u00bbs\u00a5i”fa r asV_V K x<\/p>\n
it miates to promotion of Rap-o 11dc:.: 1ts.   . <\/p>\n
to d:rect’ Respondents-‘I   “”2 2 1’0   <\/p>\n
petitioners by
\nbamma. Anomer  its  Respondents-
\n; and   to the
\nzmjggf  and Typim.\n<\/p>\n
13. . mwrig  ices. 36797-36-SDGIQDOQ, the<\/p>\n
‘p\u00a7titir.~nara  vvavrelworldrxg as Senior Assistants seek a<\/p>\n
V   the $301: that the Axnendmerzt Rules
\n ‘%  Ne. HOE ‘22112009(A:mexure–<\/p>\n
an sg%;.~..%\u00abag it relates to the pmmotian to the cadre of<\/p>\n
 AA ; O\ufb01’:.<:m- as arbitrary, unconstitutional and to<\/p>\n
V' *  down the said amenximnnt.<\/p>\n
19. In ‘Writ Petition Hos. 35966~36032[2009, this<\/p>\n
pctitioncra, wm are workirg as Grcup ‘D’ Empicycea,
\nalso seek quasl\ufb01ng of Noti\ufb01cation \ufb01e. I-ICE 221\/T2009<\/p>\n
L\u00bb<\/p>\n
.\/<'<\/p>\n
54<\/span><\/p>\n
dated 24.2.2009 (as per Amm:-mo-A) so_.A4″fa1″:<\/p>\n
axnezndmsnt brought out at S1.1′{\u00a2r..19’i:1  u u<\/p>\n
refe4’r1ng’ m the post of  <\/p>\n
arbitrary,    of <\/p>\n
Orders No. HCE 3\/2oos %L\u00a2:aA\u00a7ad_A%\u00bb HCE
\n8\/21309 dataed  nag:  it relates tn
\nRespondent No.4   passed by<\/p>\n
\ufb02 . Rpm\ufb01e\ufb01i w\u00e9zaei I\u00bb, ‘E’ and *5″<\/p>\n
ans}:    2 and 36 to redo the
\n  Division Assistant by
\nooz:a”\u00a3::;j\u00e9:-sag  petitioners in tcarxns of 1973
\nE23119;  to the Anumimm: Rules of<\/p>\n
 ~.   have been: \ufb01led to the Writ Petitions by<\/p>\n
 1 and 2 and athar Rmpondents who have<\/p>\n
 A.  haw: not filed any objections in all these
\n%  except Respondnmtn 101, ms, ms, 112 and 113,<\/p>\n
 who have \ufb01led objection: in Writ Petitions 37228-<\/p>\n
37249; 2009. 3″\n<\/p>\n
.\/.2′<\/p>\n
$5<\/p>\n
21. I have heard Imrned oounad
\nparties and aha perused
\nRcapomenm 1 and 2, ma t’tr\u00a2tsgwg <\/p>\n
background, which nece:\u00a7;a’itgtaed””$Itt–   <\/p>\n
Amendment of 2009 by
\nin the proviso aid  and aiso the
\nrecords    gzgm-dad to tha
\n in queatitm. in
\nthese          <\/p>\n
  Has. 46834722] 2010<\/p>\n
 11797-“32:?}%;\u00a7o\u00a79, at the outset, submitted am. the<\/p>\n
 pf possessing a di by the petitioners,<\/p>\n
 ~.  cnterxo-‘ ‘n and before the 2009<\/p>\n
 were bx-cught in, the poaitian. earlier as per<\/p>\n
 A. ,  was that the petitiomra were not required to
\nA’   a a at qu&\u00a51\ufb01ca’ tison for  considered 133<\/p>\n
 the post of First Division Aasintant. As the promotion of<\/p>\n
these peti\ufb01ormm is new a\ufb02mted on account sf the
\nrcsquirerncnt of dwne quali\ufb01oatinn, the pctitkaners aim
\nlose in terms uf the mnnemry bene\ufb01ts, which wtxuid<\/p>\n
k
\n3*.’<\/p>\n
5\/<\/p>\n
36<\/span><\/p>\n
have accrued to them. had they beam prox2*A.;<;;;=.'<'vi
\n1973 Rules. He, therefore, suggmtpgd   "' V
\nbe considered far   Tia:\n<\/p>\n
Respondanta 1 and 2,
\nbe in force all these’ years   in<\/p>\n
the changes an pat  not open to
\nRespondmits .1  shall
\nnot be    it is argued
\nthat 3.’   from taking a
\n  which and prevailed
\nduri;:1gVVV:ti1eV  and odd. As such, the
\n    airuck dawn.\n<\/p>\n
   in the objection sfatemnnt 515:! by<\/p>\n
 .  and 2, it is submitted that the abjection<\/p>\n
 ‘xiii; silent, as m the ::nterm’ ‘n adopted in<\/p>\n
 _’%::\u00ab..:.’z read to the new mquiramem of degree being<\/p>\n
 insisted upon an th\u00a2 pctitionnm and, as auch, the right<\/p>\n
of the petitioner: to be canaide.-.red \ufb01at pramntion in<\/p>\n
talmn away.\n<\/p>\n
57′<\/p>\n
24. It is cmn argued by an S.G.Bkxagavani.A4’\u00a7:a:i <\/p>\n
raa.d1z::g’ ofthe explanation tn  ‘  “‘<\/p>\n
clear that the pcrmisaian ti:-.  u:;w:’\u00a2’p  <\/p>\n
examination 13 mt aumx\ufb01a\ufb01gz     2 L’<\/p>\n
requirczd to obtain ‘the  and.
\ntheere\ufb01are, uhm   of the
\nz’equ:r\u00a2men’ 1:  ttm grant
\nof   of the Chief
\nJustice:  or may not grant
\n  Rules are agaimt
\n 14  Constitution of India. By
\n   retrospective e\ufb01iact, the<\/p>\n
   promotion has been darned’ .<\/p>\n
V     counsel SriS.G,Bhagavan subxnittad<\/p>\n
.’ ‘   ‘ of power by the C1’&2fJuut.i:ce has to be<\/p>\n
vit.-xt’s’\u00a7\u00a7EL.iz1tba1?g,trtefthclawiaiddownbytP1eApex<\/p>\n
   in the cases reported in\ufb01m 1993 SC 935 as wall<\/p>\n
 an me 1993 so 1079.\n<\/p>\n
25. has rsgardu the principle of esmppel is cancaerned,
\nreliance Tm placed by the peu’tionera’ oounaei on the:
\ndecision reported in AIR i2{)i0 SC 3125. It 33 contended<\/p>\n
jg,\u00bb<\/p>\n
58<\/span><\/p>\n
that Raaponclento 1 and 2 caxmot turn    <\/p>\n
petzitisamra than bene\ufb01t ofgeuh1g;’pru:j1t:\u20acin\ufb01.t\u00a2’*tfje <\/p>\n
far the petmonm rims.r>\u00a7:a:e\u00a7ie\u00a7:_ej%\u00ab\u00a7i\u00a7g3.Vrzzzzss-s4;2o1o
\nargued   113 has a
\nlaw  and mm is no
\n\ufb01n   by the Judgznont
\n ma um degree by thcxxn and
\n mm and also havmg regard to the<\/p>\n
     my the Judgment Writers to get the<\/p>\n
K  ”   Apart\ufb01’ozntheabava,i1iI wnmzidad thatrmnyof
\n‘. ‘t.’rh\u00e9St%phm~oa:*eove:-theageof\ufb01oycarsazxditia
\n muintninthedny\ufb02n-timmtnnhtamahwdagzeemwd,<\/p>\n
msmntbuewmbemmxmbemem\ufb02n
\nqua.1&f:I::n prescribed and the object m be nchtavad,<\/p>\n
Er<\/p>\n
59<\/span><\/p>\n
and the proviso to the amnndad Rules.  <\/p>\n
mum: of Arts’ Ian 14 az\ufb01 16,of,__t:he  ”<\/p>\n
Irxiia.\n<\/p>\n
23. It is further
\ncounsel that time
\ninasmuch as the  sent to the
\nGovernor  the Governor
\nwithout;    thcrea\ufb01er. thc
\n    naught to be achiswod<\/p>\n
    subxnh aion made by learned semlor
\n nnl  is am, the Draft Rules were<\/p>\n
publ\ufb01aed in the Gazette and the preamble to the: Dm\ufb01<\/p>\n
  no published, reveal that the appmvnl of the
\n Gcvemor was obtainod. But, in the objectiom \ufb01led by
\nRespondents 1 and 32, it has chaarly been admitted that<\/p>\n
thcDraftRuiaaw<:renotapprowdbyth\u00a2Govm+mrand
\ntheyre-.majz1edon1yasDrafiRukas.<\/p>\n
\/3%:\n<\/p>\n
counsel s1-1. S.P.Shan1mr argutxl, that,  & ‘<\/p>\n
force, then, 1973 Ewes i\u00e9fgxzgl    .thE:a\u00e9 <\/p>\n
about the am\u00a2ndm\u00a2r’1f\u00a7f’tp  aeurmot but up\u00bb<\/p>\n
heldiniaw.\n<\/p>\n
31. It git”  senior coumeai<\/p>\n
   eanditiona cannot be
\na1te1{\u00a2dV_i::xnicif\u00a2\u00ab\u00a7ixr\u00a7\u00a7s;..:_:”B.\u00a3\u00e9reoser, met an the glam:<\/p>\n
 & gmmimg fm’..A.} %%%%% Egatthehw Wi\ufb01mutha .<\/p>\n
V     j*, as non-graduatna cannot obtain a law<\/p>\n
  the new Ruin, brought about by way of<\/p>\n
amexgiizncznta, therefore, are not in conformity with<\/p>\n
” , i\ufb01\ufb01\ufb01cleu :4, 15 and 21 ofthe Ccsnatitutian.<\/p>\n
 32. It is also aubmittcd by rm Learned senior cceumcl<\/p>\n
that,tl1e1’eisnadirect:-acruitmenttnthepoataof
\nAsaiatant Court O\ufb01ccr, Court O\ufb02ioe.-.1′ and Section
\nO\ufb01oeratxdnolawdagz-ee%a:simistaedupez1\ufb01:rthezsai:i<\/p>\n
61<\/span><\/p>\n
feeder posts and hcncc, requiring the  <\/p>\n
to chum the law degree is, mama,  M’ ‘<\/p>\n
ciiscriminatory.<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
33. The next argumcnt
\n3 to 24- have   which
\nthere\ufb01am,     in law, in
\nrespwtg\ufb01f  #3636 print to the coming
\nam   the old Rules of 1973
\n   ncw Rules. Und-at the-ac:
\n  and expiazmtian substituted<\/p>\n
‘    As such, they are liable to be
\n ~.  and the promcztion given to the:<\/p>\n
  Reliance was placed in support of the above<\/p>\n
 submiasions on ttm deciaitms reported in {zoom 1 sec<\/p>\n
505, (199731o sec. 419, AIR 3.991 so 295, (19a3)3 SOC<\/p>\n
234, (2003): me 161 and AIR 1990 Sr: +05.<\/p>\n
:1.\n<\/p>\n
k<\/p>\n
…p<\/p>\n
62<\/span><\/p>\n
35. Learned Setzim’ Counsel Sri  <\/p>\n
appearing for the    V<\/p>\n
2+9\/2009, whjia adopting tb\ufb01-.Aau}\u00a7\u00a71;:#ias\u00e9i<3_:'3i% <\/p>\n
learned counsel Sri    <\/p>\n
counsei Sri S.P.Shar_11oa.r,   ar\ufb01tzmmm
\nby contending as f\u00a7Iin_\u00a7isr.   <\/p>\n
35.  ;m   (2), the
\n viggg  proviaso to the maid
\n in   “touching upon the salaries,
\n ,0;  pension, the eondi&m of<\/p>\n
ss\u00e9ggvi\u00e9es, n\u00a7a\u00a3a\u00a21yH,__A\u00ab’.promo\ufb01or{ has got much more<\/p>\n
  the words used in the said<\/p>\n
 ~.  exhaustive but are enty z’ndi-native \u00a311<\/p>\n
  as promotion given in the employees also<\/p>\n
V  n   a bearing on sahuy allowaneca, etc. as such,
\n‘    Bing quBh\ufb01m’ V tion Ear pcramotion under the<\/p>\n
: amxdezd Rub wouid require the approval of the<\/p>\n
Gownsrrncar and, as no such approval has been obtained
\nfrom the Govecrnor, the Rulea 13%, therefore, cannot<\/p>\n
afand tha taut of law.\n<\/p>\n
‘W.\n<\/p>\n
4\/2,.\n<\/p>\n
\u00a33<\/p>\n
37′. Apart from the abova, it is
\nsenior counsel who is  <\/p>\n
xezmmsm Bar Council, that,  <\/p>\n
lax} dcsgree by me 1:34:-.11’t.it\u00a7ri:”;\u00ab*a.:.V’\u00a7*ssir(;I:cr<V\u00a7  . t'.a on
\nobtaining law   \u00a7'\u00a2mseV:ana the
\ne\ufb01giioiiity crimzrion.    in the case
\nof 1:332 pe\ufb01uaigm,  it will be well-
\nnigh  \ufb01g  to have a law degree
\n9123.,-~41:   the prescription of a
\n "by the judgment writcra is
\n the said proviso cannot be<\/p>\n
  accordance with the provisions of<\/p>\n
    Same" 2- Counsel Sri Na.z1]unda' Raddy in<\/p>\n
 of thc petitioners in Writ Petitions Nos. 3595:5-<\/p>\n
  VT%?$tEO32[ 2009 submitted that, as far as Gmup 'D'
\n empioyeas are canoe:-nod, as per the 1973 Ru]:-:3. 50% of<\/p>\n
theposm of5DA waste be filled upbydiract
\nrecm.itxam1t and 25% was ear-marlmd for Group 'D'<\/p>\n
emphyees, who had passed S.S.L.C. mcaminatrinn. But,<\/p>\n
-17:”\n<\/p>\n
64<\/span><\/p>\n
now. under the ammded Ru1m.wh51e  K<\/p>\n
by mm Recru1t.me1’1t’ ., in respect of    <\/p>\n
posscaaion of a dzgme by Gr\u00e9up\u00ab .   V<\/p>\n
irzaished.\n<\/p>\n
39. It is timwre a.t’g’ued     ” V<\/p>\n
quali\ufb01catzinn for  post   is 7*?!
\nStandard, the   % ‘whom are 7&1<\/p>\n
{Standard        dsagree within<\/p>\n
   the aznandad Rules
\n ”   __’um~ea’ acnnble, irratioml and<\/p>\n
bemg’ \u00e9V1 3 1V1\u00a7,,\u00a2aqzti1t1.AV’  the Rules will have to<\/p>\n
  of Cona\ufb01m\ufb01onal provisions am<\/p>\n
:%   the petitinnma to he cnorzsidm-ad for<\/p>\n
 ~.  the pact of Second Divhion Assistant<\/p>\n
 the petitioners have been made 12::<\/p>\n
 AA : in the very same post em Graup ‘I3’ cmpbyeea<\/p>\n
 ewerancl this in counter productive in respect ofthe<\/p>\n
 c\ufb01ciezncy efserviaoe. It is aiso argued by lcarncd senior<\/p>\n
caumel Sri Nazljunda Raddy that the pmucriptinn of a
\ndegree quali\ufb01cation is vioiative of Article 14 and hence
\nthe same 73 Liable to be struckdnwn.<\/p>\n
Jr<\/p>\n
65<\/span><\/p>\n
40. The learned senior mums} aha   <\/p>\n
reapect of the patitioners who <\/p>\n
who are no be promoted tn   <\/p>\n
that, the rcquirwt of    ” V<\/p>\n
Sa\ufb01mr Assistants is,a:ls\u00a23 tag,  iisspecxiof name
\nof the feeder poa\u00a7.. pre.-scribed.
\n‘*”‘=”‘\u00b0”‘-‘=  %obi$=*%%~*?*%E1?=t~%%A[J\u00a2\u00a2L&Fe has no
\nxmxus  is aha
\n   The a\ufb01aresaicl
\n to be supported by placing
\n reported in (200614 sec 517<\/p>\n
 (199426 <\/p>\n
‘   submm ion put forward by lcarne\u00e9
\n‘ A  Sri Hanjunda Raddy is that, Respnmlants<\/p>\n
3 ti:e.l\u00a7i~c1o not have neoaaaary quali\ufb01cation. Yet they are<\/p>\n
 .  and even: as per the amended Rulm of $5139,<\/p>\n
 their promotion cannot be sustained and if. 1973 Rubs<\/p>\n
are ccmsidered, the said respandents are juninzru no<\/p>\n
acme: of the peiritiasnaera. Thus, eithcr way, the<\/p>\n
66<\/span><\/p>\n
promotions to Respondents 3 to 9 cannot be sai4\u20ac1,’T’t\u00a7Tk2c<\/p>\n
in acccrdanoe with law.<\/p>\n
42. Learned sum’ r counsel Sri    ”  9 <\/p>\n
Rcspundcnta 1 and 2. at theiziijau\ufb01s\u00e9t; <\/p>\n
pewer of the Chief    <\/p>\n
respect of tm  wcl1 ;<:.s of
\nsex-vx:e' oftiw sta\ufb01niitbg    d that
\nArticle 229(2) of cm  it clear<\/p>\n
 power ts) frame the
\n   It is only where the<\/p>\n
'_  \u00a7f\u00a3y 'of  have got \ufb01nancial implications,
\n2 ,  af  approval uf the Gmernor\n<\/p>\n
 – ‘%t:s:2A%\u00a7:\u00a2\u00a3 otlurrwise. Therefore, it is arguccl that all<\/p>\n
   Emdl\ufb02entll brought to 1973 Rules are wi\ufb021m’<\/p>\n
 ~ V-tijxe  13o.wt:ra f the Chief Justice and the Chief Justice.-<\/p>\n
   get power In mm: the mmhod of me:-umme’ nt and<\/p>\n
TV to prwcribe quali\ufb01cations. In this contest. :11: rclevaxzt<\/p>\n
ru.lesreferredtoar:aRulas?,8aI1d 11.<\/p>\n
Jr<\/p>\n
67<\/span><\/p>\n
43. The next submission put forward is that. <\/p>\n
the High Court wanwd tn repeal tw  <\/p>\n
Draft Rules were scnt to the Governor,    b <\/p>\n
were returrad by the <\/p>\n
Rules have not seem the  of “t1′;”\u00e9*\u00bb.day  <\/p>\n
19′?3 Rules holds the
\nJustina has power  the 19′?’$ Rules,
\nthe Rules that are    I  the p1-mas’ 0<\/p>\n
cannot: be   vi}9′}\u00a3’ii\\r\u00a7’\u00e9f.ih;\u00a2_’C\u00a73\ufb01stimtion.<\/p>\n
-!4. ‘~._A’a’_ rage’ of approval being
\n   in respect uf prnznotions is<\/p>\n
V ti’2;e__\u00a71,1I)miaaion made by learned senior<\/p>\n
\u00bb  Basavaprrablrm Patil is that, no such<\/p>\n
    ed in rmpect of changa of semen’<\/p>\n
” A. , 513-hzaazaa” ion made by the lcamed senior counsel for<\/p>\n
 1 and 2 is that, jprasczription of <\/p>\n
T’ eaucat-ma; quali\ufb01cation is permissible: in crdar to<\/p>\n
exam: e\ufb01ciexzcy of service, and the High Court
\nthe Court of Recard, it in all ma mom nwmaary tn<\/p>\n
exmurethate\ufb01xziezxcyismainmirxedataliievelsmld itia<\/p>\n
\ufb01r<\/p>\n
68<\/span><\/p>\n
with thh objective that the requiramcnt of degree: in
\nrespect uf some of the categories uf the <\/p>\n
Iaw degree in respect cxf Senior Judgment  <\/p>\n
prescribed.\n<\/p>\n
45. Re\ufb01erring to the ab3’ectinnte},A:\ufb01le;a’..;fc11\u00e9 I<\/p>\n
caunael argucad that, in Vic-‘W-9f    L.<\/p>\n
ob3ec1:n’ ‘ us, there is   to ba
\nachieve’ cl and thc     q1’1AAah”‘\ufb01catinm<\/p>\n
E_   ..\n<\/p>\n
46.   ooumei for R-16 in<\/p>\n
 ‘:9, on his part, argued relying on<\/p>\n
% i . agcaatap  in (2oo3)2 sec 632 and 2003 AIR<\/p>\n
 the prwaucriptinn of csriterion for<\/p>\n
appointment eta, fall exclusively in the
\n AA  oftheemployer and power oftimjudiciaimv\u00e9ew
\nH  bc examined only if it ‘ms shown that the ruins<\/p>\n
 framzaxi are contrary tn the constitutional pros\ufb02ninm.<\/p>\n
47′. In the km: of the aformaid contentions put
\nfarwardazadtlmedecisianare\ufb01enndmhy thekmrzwd<\/p>\n
,
\n$
\nti<\/p>\n
s\u00a2nir counsel and the learned counsel
\nthe parties’ , the f:slbw1:ng’ poirxtsstrinae\u00e9  ‘ <\/p>\n
1.<\/p>\n
.. _ ‘ar’L*iti*a.r5r,<\/p>\n
69<\/span><\/p>\n
make Rules  %229{:z)k%’k4– 51″‘% Van
\nCcns\ufb01m\ufb01on ix; reapeqt\ufb01f  service:
\nof the High   \u00a2anVj\u00a7se,uaod no validata
\nunconstitutional ma  ” _ promotinuai
\n gr  .  a;;9n3mg\u00bbm the same<\/p>\n
 VI;   between prmcribing<\/p>\n
  and the object<\/p>\n
\u00b0.af.,Iug’ hm-_   ‘2<\/p>\n
.~       ‘ r1 \ufb01xed by the prov1so’ to the
\n  of 2009 is nmni\ufb01estly erramaoun,<\/p>\n
uxxxwmaonable, irrational and<\/p>\n
1  tory and thus vioiativae of .Art1:cIes’ 14<\/p>\n
 is of the Conat\ufb02tutican, when the right to
\n.. E;-omidercd for promnrtic-.n is held to be a<\/p>\n
Whether the requirenaznm menticncd in the
\ncaxpianation to the proviso an arbitrary,
\nuatzmsasonabie. impracticrabks and lacks rauenal
\nmxus B.1′);\u20ac1 hence viblative ofhrticlae 148516 ofthc:<\/p>\n
Constitu\ufb01on?\n<\/p>\n
at<\/p>\n
70<\/span><\/p>\n
5. In reapezct of tho vacancies in the:  <\/p>\n
posm which arose prior to the ”
\n2009, which Rule is app1ir; alJ\u00a7E\u00e9’4’r3fii’I7’3-t:1E#.:\u00a7\u00a7 gs;%s:-.:\u00bb3
\norameI1<:1edRu}mof2GG9?'*      <\/p>\n
5. Whether the  1731393′
\nretzuspective  ;&’a:; qf taking
\naway the    “Rules and
\nthus the    arhitrary,
\n   me am
\n  \u00a34” and 16 of the<\/p>\n
7.    given pursuant tn the
\n3  ” _ ma.  conacmancc with the well
\n_ _ est\u00a3cbi_ish\u00a2\u00e9%  of service jurispmdeme?<\/p>\n
.  _ gf    followed in bringug about the<\/p>\n
_  Rule-a af 2009 is in accordance with the
\n \ufb01e}; gazablmhed principles and procedurvsa
\n‘appfiicabk in rmpect ef bringing amcrnzlments tn<\/p>\n
*  pmmpm rules?\n<\/p>\n
%-w tHo.I:\n<\/p>\n
}48.Ast1’mRuIeuwhichareunxiercha1Iengevre1e<\/p>\n
framod by the Chief Justice by virtue of the power
\nconferred Lltid\ufb01l’ Article 229(2) of the Constitution, it is
\nnczoeaaazy to aramim the: said Article and the law laid<\/p>\n
_r…v’<\/p>\n
4<\/span><\/p>\n
71<\/span><\/p>\n
down by the Apwr Court in that regard. Afticia.  <\/p>\n
the Constitution of India reads az~\u00bbun;iAer;  H ”   \\’ *<\/p>\n
eff-fz’gh Cawts:\n<\/p>\n
(1) App\u00e9>*ix1\ufb01t1nE.r’1\u00a7s ‘A
\nsarvanm at’ a   \u00abmade by
\nthe: ChiefJuatjw–\u00a7>ffthe anon other
\nJudgg-,’  iof; he: may<\/p>\n
….   of the State<\/p>\n
    in such mass as
\n jibe rule rm persan not<\/p>\n
align-:13 r  in the court $115111 he<\/p>\n
5 \u00bb Lappdxntgati’ to \u00e9ny; o\ufb01oe commcted with the
\n ;_ oo’aujt  oomultation with the: State
\n  Cemmiuion.\n<\/p>\n
 Subject to thc provisions of any<\/p>\n
 made by the Legislature ofthac State, the<\/p>\n
z “s\u00a7:rnditiona sf service of o\ufb01’1eea-s and servants<\/p>\n
ofa\ufb02ighoourtahallbcsuchaamaybe
\nprescribed by mien made by the Chief
\nJmstice::ftIaeccur\u00a3c:rbyavan:xeo\u00a3l:na1’Judge
\nor o\ufb01oer of the court authorised by the Chief<\/p>\n
Jzmticetomaineruieafhrtkmpurpose:<\/p>\n
x\n<\/p>\n
 —\n<\/p>\n
__,..\n<\/p>\n
’32<\/p>\n
Provided am the rukzs made  H
\nthis clause ahail, ao \ufb01x: as they rcl\u00e9iftn
\nsalaries, allnwanxaes,  or
\nmm the appromlal of   <\/p>\n
49. Sub-clause :2)’ of   cx\u00e9m that
\nthe Chief Justice ivu”” by Rules
\nthe cot1di1:iona.;>f  ifzzf  :31′ um<\/p>\n
I-I:gh’  ‘__…  any law made by<\/p>\n
 “””  ” ling with the aformaic!
\n .V    same with Article’ 309 and<\/p>\n
fgxfticlsa  Juntioc M.Rama Join (as has<\/p>\n
  ‘Services under the State’ -198?’<\/p>\n
A  “_E:ii\u00a7\u00a3:s:\u00a7 1.,:.’at::.j\u00a7)s;ge-334, has observed thus:<\/p>\n
“‘  a comparison of Article: 309 with Articles
\n“@445 and 2:29, we: find that the two matters
\nvia, {i}  t and (ii) conditixarxs of
\nsewiztewhicharadeaitwithjointly i:x1Az’t’nr:1e
\n309 are separately dealt with under clause!\u00bb
\n(1) and :2) respectively of Articles 146 and\n<\/p>\n
229. The power of Parliament and Status:
\nlcgislature Tm c.:on\ufb01n\u00a2d to ragummg conditicns
\n\ufb02at’ am-xzizze and on matters relating to<\/p>\n
DJ M”\n<\/p>\n
,\/<\/p>\n
=4′, -.-\n<\/p>\n
73<\/span><\/p>\n
racmitmmt power is exciusivcly    <\/p>\n
the Chief Justice.’<\/p>\n
50. Therefore, the pew\u00bb or n*;e%%’star.\u00a2%A%[\u00a3\u00a2<\/p>\n
legxkhtinn in regard to   of * L’<\/p>\n
High Court stag’  been “on   Justice
\nand thus the   229(2) are to be
\nheld as subor:\u00a7i:Late:1eag\u00a7,\u00a7\\\u00a39;1i6n,”‘\u00bb__’      %V <\/p>\n
51. As;-;    the approval of the
\nsubmzk  ” ‘ion . sum’ r counscl Shri<\/p>\n
JayakL1mar   even in respect of promotions,<\/p>\n
“(if is 1′}.\u00a2O\u00a2’-O$8.1′}’. On the: other<\/p>\n
‘  senior mumel Sizri Baaava Prabhn Patil<\/p>\n
 ‘–   that the apprmml of the Governor<\/p>\n
    only in xmpect of those matters which are<\/p>\n
% ” * : mentinnod an the prtwiso to Arms 229(2)
\n  eventhe\ufb01p-ax Court, in the were ofM
\nT Vs. The Accountant General, Asssam as Nagaland,<\/p>\n
reported inAIF:’ 1971 SC 1350, has hefd that Ciause {1}
\nmad with Claum (Q1 of Amish 229 oonfm-a esgchzsixm<\/p>\n
power not only in the matter at’ appointzccuenta but aka<\/p>\n
\/&’:I”,–”’<\/p>\n
…\n<\/p>\n
74<\/span><\/p>\n
with regard to prescribing the conditions of <\/p>\n
o\ufb01cers and servants of a High Court by  <\/p>\n
Chief Juatioe: cf the Court. \ufb01gs is .3t1?.:;\u00a7\u00ab:\u00a7i:_:\u00a7 ‘any! ~ ”<\/p>\n
Iegisfatinn by the State Legnllatirgre hug ‘sa\ufb01zy in’ raw; <\/p>\n
conditiaena of service. In’ am: may gr
\neven the Qialatum cannot    pcswars
\normferrcd an the   fl). The
\napproval of     matter of
\nRages, is   as reiatt: no
\n   All anther rulm
\nin    af  do not require his
\n V  the approval of the<\/p>\n
GA rerun   {if prcmntions, therefhm, is not<\/p>\n
 _ “&\u00a7v’iaag&i.\u00ab’by  to Article 229 nor data the<\/p>\n
 the Apex Court can be construed as<\/p>\n
‘ A  permission cf the Govcrrmr man in mspcct<\/p>\n
of  relation to promstinn.<\/p>\n
H  Whcther the said power can be exercised by {lass<\/p>\n
 Chief Justice disregarding the constitutional proviaitms<\/p>\n
came up far consiciaration befom the Apex Court in the<\/p>\n
case of H_C.Putmswamy & \u00abothers Vs, Honfffe Chief<\/p>\n
HF<\/p>\n
75<\/span><\/p>\n
Justfae oficamazzzxa [AIR 1991 33.2951 and :2’1e%i;\u00e9x;5\u00a2::-;%<\/p>\n
Court has observed thus at paragx-aph–}.1:<\/p>\n
“The Judiciary is th.e~” ‘4 of
\ncxmstitutional principles \u00a7ar_I:1ic_Vh gi\ufb01r\u00e9  if-L  * AA
\nto me. maintenance; \u00a2f4ru1e”oAf’iaw.
\nwhich: far the pmtecti\u00a711\u00bb\u00a2f ii  S<\/p>\n
which are izxtggral  ~ of = Q81’ Maia} giiud
\npolitiacai   the most
\nvisibie actors in   ‘ justice.
\n   ‘aw mast pubmy
\n     of
\nju\u00a7:t;.ic\u00a2 i:\u00a7:_ “31:5tz{\u00a2\u00a3,:a\u00a2g\u00a2id:x:g\u00a7disputed cases. 1:<\/p>\n
1  mart than that. Any
\n~t::f’ the administration cf<\/p>\n
jiisti\u00e9e   must alas take acoount<\/p>\n
 V of the Atq\ufb01alityi of the Judges behaviour and
\n,A  _.”..;M&.&am mm “my my appear<\/p>\n
_  cznly minor aspects of the<\/p>\n
V’ ” 3*    ‘\u00e9xanian cf j11ntioe:, but collectively they<\/p>\n
.. not trivial. They constitute, in uur
\n” \ufb01ispitaion, & subatantiai part of the mosaic<\/p>\n
w\ufb01ch reprwents the ardinary mania
\nperception af what the Courts are and haw
\nthe judges gr: about their weric. The Chief
\nJustice is thtt prime fares in the High Court.
\nArticie 229 of the Constitntinn provides that
\nappointmrant of o\ufb01:em and servants: nf the<\/p>\n
fry-\n<\/p>\n
\/p.\n<\/p>\n
.75<\/p>\n
High Ceurt shall be made by the
\nJustice or such other Judge at omocr cf  ”
\nCourt as may be d:recnad’ by
\nJustice. The abject of
\nsecure the indepazzdmzcefpf
\nwhich canrzot he  n V’
\nunless the authoritjf-_V ti2..V_ap}:$diz1t
\nstat?’ with complete  ov\u00e9ir  in
\nmm in the cm\u00bb; au%sn1f>e.% mm as
\nimperativg   ”  ” ‘ absolute<\/p>\n
 the High<\/p>\n
t 0111<\/p>\n
  W . \ufb01e must<\/p>\n
o’g=;;__a1   ‘ Wcrrki of ggw, not Q the<\/p>\n
  Q: mag’ gmaghm. He has
\n  dpty  that in carrying out the
\n  functiom, he is actuated by<\/p>\n
H   and vaiuaw as those of the<\/p>\n
_c_.n;l_1’g’ Weneedhardlyaay\ufb02mt\ufb02maewln
\nare expected to omwe the conduct of others
\nmust rzeoeaaarily maintain a Ivighcr standard
\nof ethical and intellectual rectitudc. The<\/p>\n
‘A<\/p>\n
J\/’.”\n<\/p>\n
77<\/span><\/p>\n
public expoctationa do not seem to be <\/p>\n
53. A Dam’ ‘ ion Bcmh of   k<\/p>\n
Chamegaruuia Vs. High Cfourtizyf  <\/p>\n
Kat 4633), relying an ths: decv\u00e9piori    *<\/p>\n
has held that, mm 2: chgfxezk  _    with
\nmgard tr; the    not in
\nacxnordance with  the records
\nshould     have been<\/p>\n
 % h Chandra Vs Regixmal<\/p>\n
 (AIR 1993 s.c:. 9353,<\/p>\n
  held that, every wide power, the<\/p>\n
\u00bbA  has far-reemhixag rapercusaion. has<\/p>\n
%’ \u00bb magma on it. :1: should he axeztised to<\/p>\n
 purpose sf the Act, In xagzaxation mama<\/p>\n
 ‘A s   ben\ufb02t ami oommzm good, the I-espomih\ufb02ity<\/p>\n
 graver. It dsmandn purpaseful approach. The<\/p>\n
: migraine of discretion should be ahjeciive. Test of<\/p>\n
reasonableness \u00a33 morc strict \ufb01lm gublic fungm’ :3<\/p>\n
 ea-ha  f<\/p>\n
‘P8<\/p>\n
It;aa’naanddeciaio w’htoucht.heoo___o<\/p>\n
m iusticc. Tn__at which 3 xtvgt fair  _<\/p>\n
mzmganable. Ami wgt Q” g g <\/p>\n
5;; g;mtra_g{ ggg\ufb01 Q is ;@a  :_-Itfelees.’  A’<\/p>\n
bona\ufb01de and in good faith’
\ngain or bem\ufb01t to the  s2 ipu1d be\n<\/p>\n
55. In the   \ufb01at<\/p>\n
Rcg?;s~F?L*21’\u00a7A: ‘ a1 and another (AIR<\/p>\n
1993 s.%c.w2Vd;\u00a73,%% m\u00a7k?V\u00a7p-g’cam while dealing with<\/p>\n
Articic .91; has observed that the<\/p>\n
‘A   ‘iai{‘\u00a3:3__s1_.1\u00a3pI’s’ \ufb01g; angl not heat and the rclevant<\/p>\n
 \u00ab.  which is as unxier:\n<\/p>\n
” _  pointed out above. under the
\n“constitutional acheazue, Chief Justice is the
\nsupreme authority and tha ether Judg\ufb01, so
\nfar as o\ufb01oers and servants ofthv: High Court
\nare conzammed. have no role to piay an the
\nadn:1iz1ia1:-ative sicie. some judges,
\nundoubtedly, will became Chief Justice in<\/p>\n
’29<\/p>\n
their own turn one day, but it is
\nunder constitutional dincipiine that
\nin tranquility. Judges have been
\n ‘I’he}’ have
\n“km:-mite” who have no \ufb02ew 5;:
\nhaving shed a: \ufb02nnugh    M’
\nmission 73 to supply  not izmit. <\/p>\n
is nrzoaasary 89 that lama: d\u00a7e\u00e9i:~e.to..i-1m<\/p>\n
the High Court. \u00e9\u00a7:*Jn\ufb02\u00a71st_:*si\ufb02e_:2  not sprout
\nbefore time.\n<\/p>\n
56. It is  in law that
\nwhile   authority to {ram
\n as well as cxmdititnns of
\n   Justice is, however, subject
\ntax the   in Article 229(2) itself and
\n    to be wmrcisexi keeping in View the<\/p>\n
‘  as expressed by the Apex Court in the<\/p>\n
”  A  came as Wei} as by that Division Bench of<\/p>\n
  in Chazmegowde\ufb01s case. In other wards, the<\/p>\n
 AA   canmt be us-ad to va}.1da’ tc unoonatitutional<\/p>\n
  ‘ ‘ tinn in prazno\ufb01on chances of persom heionging<\/p>\n
 no the 3\u00a3iI1′}\u00a3.5 aateagory.<\/p>\n
;’
\ny
\nu!<\/p>\n
Point No.3 2<\/span><\/p>\n
57. The next point to he considered is   <\/p>\n
the rational nexus betwe\u00a2;x…..  \u00b0’<\/p>\n
quah\ufb01ca’ \ufb02an] Law Degree, as   <\/p>\n
af SD53, FDAa,  <\/p>\n
Senior Judgment
\nBefore I proceed to  it. is necessary
\nat thi\ufb01  to    stood in the
\nHigh    to be met
\n   _tl%eVVVV\u00a7a\u00a7mendcad Rubs of 2009.
\n and amendments tn\n<\/p>\n
2.;   gubg\ufb01mpea \u00a35  of the eariitzr mathod. gr<\/p>\n
   ._::.  ef the pe\ufb01tionczrs harm’ , with<\/p>\n
  Hot-1\ufb01r.:a’ tion 1’vIo.HCE 221\/2009 dated<\/p>\n
‘A  \ufb01ub\ufb01ahcd in the Gazette, are as under:<\/p>\n
..  HIGH COURT 0:? KARNATAKA SERVICE
\n(connmons op semen AND RECRUITMENT’)
\nzvAm:2IDMEN’I1 RULES, 2009.<\/p>\n
: Method of Recruitxnent to the posts of First Division<\/p>\n
assistants fmm Sec.-o\ufb01 Division Assistants and Typiats:<\/p>\n
A
\n‘E<\/p>\n
291\/<\/p>\n
Existingme\ufb02zod H __ %
\n$1.No. Cadre Name of Recnzitneznt auhastiizrzgted in ti2e”;a1’aLce’v.
\nof  “cf\n<\/p>\n
1. Tc: tha Carin: By   Emmi tile
\nof First from the camireg. [cadres  SEA;
\nHavana’ ‘ ‘ \ufb02 SD53 ‘9.n\u00a2’:._ ‘Iypu’ ta’: _ 5x:,Vthe”:&’ir1oV’ef
\nAssistants Typist! in the 15:4 f6~\u00a53DAs @111!” 4 L’<\/p>\n
snag  4<\/p>\n
Typdsbsl  pp
\n,.puauihl:;~— _  <\/p>\n
*i’t’sa5LT’%f\ufb01:.”3*’=*~’–\u00ab’5:-.’1,+’\u00ab 5:1″-
\n}r3,”veu.*Ii\u00a2a’ to the<\/p>\n
 o\ufb01r._2i5Jn of the<\/p>\n
  <\u00a7t1;z::ur.. rm\ufb01rc: wha<\/p>\n
became<\/p>\n
.' gmam of that<\/p>\n
cn\u00e9fc  to this
\n'-data an W'hi1Z'h the
\nfarmer o\ufb02icial
\nbecame a
\nmember
\nhisfher cadre.\n<\/p>\n
ratio “of ‘w #5:\u00bb? (6-\n<\/p>\n
*11sL–\u00ab.a-‘6.\u00bb
\nabove  ”\n<\/p>\n
nlugl}. not he <\/p>\n
jgarmnbtina;\n<\/p>\n
“s:a\u00a3\u00a7re” of A <\/p>\n
~   Afusiat-.\n<\/p>\n
of<\/p>\n
‘iimistia\ufb01 ._
\ngxnsdfizig; Prcvided that,
\ns.21″%ia1 of one of the
\nabove:  ntadrcm shall<\/p>\n
\ufb01at has gimm pxumaizimz<\/p>\n
ta’ ~.\u00a3hc cadre of First
\n Assistants}
\n Clntku, enriicr to
\n promcrtinn sf the
\nn\ufb01cials sf the other
\ncadre who had became<\/p>\n
‘..’.””….’.,”1′. ‘ate \ufb01”u..u.r.”””1’:i.”
\nbecame: a. mcmbur of<\/p>\n
hinfhcr aadm.\n<\/p>\n
Pravidmi they nha\ufb02
\npossess a Degrcc fmxn
\nany Univ ”\n<\/p>\n
eatah\ufb01ahed by I\u00bb&W in
\nIndia and Certi\ufb01cate
\nCourse in Computer
\nApgxlicatim.\n<\/p>\n
Excpianaiziom: 1. The
\npresent member: who<\/p>\n
are warldng .1: First;\n<\/p>\n
Biviniaaz Assistants and
\nwho \u00abin not panic” that
\nzwquirnd quali\ufb01cation,
\nshall qualify themselves
\nwithout a\ufb02’ectin.g the
\nregular wurk, with prior
\npersnkueion cf Hank}:\n<\/p>\n
the Ch.iarfJus\ufb01ca, wirhizi
\na period of \ufb01e years,
\nfairing which they nhnil
\nam: he cntiticd fez
\n\ufb01uthm pmmatinn.\n<\/p>\n
35<\/span><\/p>\n
V —-a)_5phca\ufb01n::g;.: ,  it-35111:: work, with 33110:-<\/p>\n
  ‘ Viicrt; be e.-xxeitled \ufb01n-
\nQwg\ufb01\ufb01cntiatm\u00e9  further prmnotian.
\n  Tim permission is not
\n” _  automatic, but subject
\n “L. “-.v,_M:sst Iaave to the imsereut of \ufb01e
\n”  SSLC Enntimtinn. Such
\n‘.fca;iL_p’.z1cttd\u00a7Iythu tnlncawaytixcxightl of
\n the uczmior nmplnyccu<\/p>\n
both. am the p1’eacriBed;–‘ “–wg: rt3v”rzIAed
\nBasis of a Test that they..\u00aba3;a1I._p’a\u00a73esg
\ncondmsted far the Bcgrnc
\npurpnae, dim rccngnisagi  .9: ‘<\/p>\n
and agrarian:  4’ 1,
\nrccocrda,  an; ‘pxcamt
\npreacrihccl: or  ” are   \ufb01aia’<\/p>\n
(he) 83  tin’ .;1o’t_ gm\u00e9\u00e9eaa the”
\nmcn\ufb01hneht ” by r1?equ1’r’e\u00a21″ qgzal\ufb01catzion,
\naelgctinn_____ ” shun”  vthemaeiven
\n ”  ‘fen-‘*.w-itixout “a.\ufb01’e\u00a2t:iz1g the<\/p>\n
ha1u!ingV___i*   of Horufblc
\ncanipgfiiivc ‘ teat  C-hicf Justice, within
\n ‘ zyf\u00e9nxiod nf \ufb01ve yeazs,\n<\/p>\n
– ‘ ‘    which they $11311<\/p>\n
Sccondnry and does not confer the
\nvEduca1:inn Bnarti umiuc larixr\ufb02cgcu an the
\nof equivalmzt junior en\u00bb:.p}.oyees. The
\nExamim\ufb01nn qua\ufb01cation nixfsaizzeci
\nwithout fallowing the
\nNote: Pzeferencc above norm: wtmkl not
\nw\ufb02 Ere given to be taken into
\nthen: who an-. cunxidemtion, til} they
\ngrauiustnu. Must come within thn zone of<\/p>\n
have paused: cannidcra\ufb01on.<\/p>\n
$3. I. ’11:: senior Abte: 1) For seaming
\ngratis minimum quali\ufb01cafurn
\naxamina\ufb01on in prescribed fa:-this cadre
\nEnainh withfn s\ufb01ptuated time.<\/p>\n
Shnrthnnd in the permission may be
\n\ufb01rnteluu; $1’ Hbera\ufb01y granteti.<\/p>\n
The Pro\ufb01ciency 2) The pe\ufb01oci af time
\nGrade pmacribcd for
\n,Exam*mnt:ima %m  quai\ufb01xrn\ufb01nn<\/p>\n
wei\ufb01ht   ” . ‘ <\/p>\n
 at;-3 whee} F<\/p>\n
94<\/span><\/p>\n
Method of recnzitxmerlt to the: posts <3!" Second
\nAssistants from Group 'Dw\ufb01icials,   L' 5 "<\/p>\n
I Exiatingmethod  .:=\u00a5g;:V"*jm.  <\/p>\n
81.No. Cadre of Rct:nu’hm:n’t’  .qu.b.~_n:in;tc&*
\n _ ‘I5:  *’*’~’!=*}._=0d… 1″”
\n.1″  _ t  <\/p>\n
1. To the cadre {a)5G’Abyd1’\ufb01:\u00a2t
\naf Secnmi xmru\ufb01mcgt by 1*t:crnitx:h’.\u00a3::i.1′:  I<\/p>\n
Baum’ ‘ ‘ n sczicctioal     for ‘
\nAsaisfanm calling  ” far apvplicaiibn  and
\napplinating.   3 th:\n<\/p>\n
V ‘i\u00a3’L. ‘ .  ”  .3pp}ica.n’!:\ufb01.  ‘I31:
\n1m=~Bna–nu.3. . V  VA  quali\ufb01natinn
\n     giirect reemitutent
\nquali\ufb01patinn’ fa:  a degree in
\n 1:” ”  Scixmsefmtslcommeme<\/p>\n
 [Eiusimaa Manapment
\n. he ‘cg d.eg’_ee.\u00a2f a’ “of a mcamised
\nzgtmgagsajnczti  \u00bb Ullivcatxity with
\n af55% in T11: agrcgtz \ufb02ax
\n  carxtiidatx: bclbn\ufb01ing in
\n for Gencral catngatry and B.
\nL  minimum of 45% mark:\n<\/p>\n
”  .  in in the aggregate to
\n‘ %\u00bb\u20ac3e’r:era1 Category Ss\ufb01eclule Caste mz\u00e9
\n2’ \u00abmi minimum cf S\u00a2heduie’I’r1″heo.<\/p>\n
A ‘4S%mau-ksinthe
\n agyegnm ta (la) 30% promxxtsinn an
\n“”” ” Schulnk: Cumin: the basin of ueniMity-
\nami Schedule cum–mc.zit from the
\nT\ufb01hca. cadre uf Group I}
\na\ufb01iciain working in thc
\n{b} 25% High Caurt<\/p>\n
atinn an the Entah\ufb01xhmcnt and who
\niii! of In.-niorit.3’~ have passed tiegraee
\ncunmneztil: from examination: of
\nthe cadre of recognised Umiremziy
\nGroup D o\ufb02ialn andwhohavepnttinnot
\nworlcing in the less than two years of
\nHkh Court service.\n<\/p>\n
Eatnblinhmcnt
\nand whet hm: Explanatimzz 3.. “I’h.v.-.
\npaused degree: pcrcacmt mcmhem who
\nexamination txf are warking an Scctmd
\nrecognised Divininn \ufb01sainmntx and
\nUgive\ufb02\ufb02f and who do not passes: the<\/p>\n
,, ?\n<\/p>\n
95<\/span><\/p>\n
‘~ \u00bb a1.1a’:;_n.’I$}e<\/p>\n
 D a\ufb01ciala<\/p>\n
who have put in
\nnot less than one
\nyear nfsrxzvicc.\n<\/p>\n
(#3) 25% by
\nprumutinn  thn.\n<\/p>\n
basin of <\/p>\n
cum-mcni:\n<\/p>\n
the cadre faf<\/p>\n
we:-ki.-ng. u in the’<\/p>\n
Esuhlkhmeat ‘<\/p>\n
   whii *1.a;a\u00bbu\u00e9”\n<\/p>\n
‘ ‘ &_I;t1Vi’w;:.Ia:it- _<\/p>\n
 ma,<\/p>\n
 ha:-ave”  in’
\n. 372311;: cfuqnice’.\n<\/p>\n
:d:Tifalnyeanmcy\u00a3 <\/p>\n
 \u00ablag \ufb01ned<\/p>\n
ti};  gnfohib\ufb01om
\nwant cf<\/p>\n
  cndxcz cf<\/p>\n
poncsaizxg dcgtcc
\nquu\ufb01\ufb01ca\ufb01nn, the
\nsame shall he<\/p>\n
\ufb01led up by
\nzrrmnotina
\nsuitable
\ncanslzinute fmm
\n\ufb02u cadre mi”\n<\/p>\n
Gmnp D o\ufb01cinh
\npaucming SSLC
\n01′ aquhaknt
\nqlzai\ufb01cntiau.\n<\/p>\n
(e) If any vacancy<\/p>\n
requimri
\n81143  jth.e\ufb011″$j%’1?k’9
\nwithout  \ufb01sh:\n<\/p>\n
re:gu]ar’#am’rIi\u00a3,’A’:=.z.i\ufb01:  V’
\n  Hou’bIc–, V<\/p>\n
9… pa-128333 –r1f’fn’: <\/p>\n
‘\u00a3a;Hn\u00a7\u00bb._which r}:.s,,4.’3,v..a1i.iaa;J1<\/p>\n
 M<\/p>\n
‘:52: _’ is met
\nautoms\ufb01\u00bb. !:~5v.1: subject<\/p>\n
to the \u00a7ntei’\u00a2st of the<\/p>\n
Iwltitution. Such
\npgz\ufb01-inaiau shall nut
\n war tbs light of
\n uankar cmpinyec.-.u
\n cine: not ccrnfnr the<\/p>\n
‘ “undue privileges on the
\n‘ junior employees. The<\/p>\n
quali\ufb01caiio-:n obtained
\nwithout \ufb01o\ufb02nwing the
\nabove um-ma wmzixi not
\nbe when into
\ncunxidcrniitm, till they
\ncame within the 20116: of
\ncansidcratiszn.\n<\/p>\n
Note: 1) Fur securing
\nminimum qunli\ufb01zmtian
\npreacr\ufb02aed for this cadre
\nwn:hm’ ‘ stigma’ latex! time.
\nthe penniuion may he
\nBibs.-rally granted.\n<\/p>\n
2) The perfect of time
\nprescribed \ufb01n” ucctuiaag
\nnsinimuna qzxali\ufb01ca\ufb01zn
\n(La. five years) starts
\nfzmn the chm: of<\/p>\n
meant for Group 3] If no e\ufb01gihie
\nD a\ufb01cialn cannot candidate is available
\nhe\ufb01\ufb01cdupby\ufb01ar pmomntinn, such
\nprmna\ufb02nn for vacant post may be \ufb02ied
\nwmt of nzitahle up by threat
\ncandiciat: the recxuimzcnt.<\/p>\n
531;: shall he<\/p>\n
99<\/span><\/p>\n
Enzethnd of
\nrecmiunent to
\n‘tbs: past af
\nSection o\ufb01ccr
\n\u00a3P1’otocaI}.\n<\/p>\n
53. In \u00a3114: objeotsnn ata’ecmen1\u20ac.V\ufb011\u00a7\u00a7\u00a7\u00a2i”<\/p>\n
Respondents 1 and    me
\nprascription of   in with
\na View to imprrowz  ar the High
\nCourt and    it is an the:\n<\/p>\n
mom    <\/p>\n
  by the learned
\n ‘the: patitioncrs as well as
\n Rporldenns 1 and 2 anti
\n   racorda that arc produced for<\/p>\n
  __by the learned senior counaei for the<\/p>\n
 .  and 2, there appae:-3 to bc rm specific<\/p>\n
   gum’ an to why Degree is insisted in<\/p>\n
 A.  of peracns, who art: in Group-D, SBA. FDA,
\n”  \ufb01t:\u00a71mg1\u00b0aphers and Judgment Writers, \u00a301′ them ‘ho move<\/p>\n
 to the higher poet arm) likewise, no specific reasons arc<\/p>\n
\u00a3ur1:I*x:omingautnwhytheLawDagrmis irmisted upon
\nthe Seniors” Judwm: Writers.<\/p>\n
100<\/span><\/p>\n
60. The nature ofjoh or the duties a85igI1ed:?.\u20ac3- A’ <\/p>\n
categories cf mpkayeea, which are   _  <\/p>\n
by the learned senior murmel  <\/p>\n
by placing relevant documg:r_1m %%au\ufb01\u00a2s<"a\u00a3 'V <\/p>\n
the Gmup~D employees  tha:; \u00a2\u00a3T  'the
\noi\ufb01oe neat and   to
\nand SUM are   organize
\nthe     of \ufb01les
\nand,   and F1335, the
\n the job of the: case:\n<\/p>\n
“a\u00e9ia   upon them.\n<\/p>\n
6;.  “–‘;i’ap}ne:-5, Judgment ‘Writers and<\/p>\n
  are coneexnccl, they are<\/p>\n
‘ \ufb01t\ufb01fh the work stenography which werk is<\/p>\n
” X  i-imam by the Hon’bl\u00a2 Judges, apart from<\/p>\n
 tappah and files. The \u00e9utim of the Court<\/p>\n
   ar\ufb01 Assistant Court C2\ufb023.cra are that of<\/p>\n
  the case files aocor\u00e9ing to the cause list, to<\/p>\n
note the stage: of thc case according tn the court<\/p>\n
p1~omedingsandieaepaiIthe}awbooksthataz~era\u00a2:eived<\/p>\n
101<\/span><\/p>\n
for that: conduct of proccadings. The: Section <\/p>\n
required to scrutinize the \ufb01les submitted  .<\/p>\n
worker as par the promdure pr\u00a7a\u00a7:r_ibcd._9 ‘V’1″}i;\u00a7 ” ” V<\/p>\n
charge of on: or mom awficz;  t.\u00a5.:\u00a72s\u00e9.g;=2?x1_ti;1\u00a7’ of , V *<\/p>\n
the \ufb01les suhn\ufb01tted by the   ‘ In
\nthe letters on flfxc _<\/p>\n
52′. F’rom”   V’ \u00absf  the aforesaid
\ncategorigzzu’ \ufb01rimt’  at the \ufb01rat glazzce,
\nis  of.Vw\u00a7$r1\u00e9\ufb01 d-:.~m”\u00a7by the aforemcntirmed
\no\ufb01crlais} *  not  ‘ 1.\n<\/p>\n
 _v    the a.rg11menm, it was also
\n  ‘same times the Sims ml} dz: the work of<\/p>\n
V  the work of Seninr Assistants and<\/p>\n
 in turn, will aha do {ha work of<\/p>\n
  L11<:ewu' " e, the Stenographexm work in<\/p>\n
 x  'p1'a_oc Q): Judgment wntm and Judgment Writers do the<\/p>\n
 af Senna' 1' Judgment Writers. Some Semh r<\/p>\n
 Judgment Writeera are also assgnaed to look aftcr the<\/p>\n
work of Assistant Registmra.<\/p>\n
102<\/span>\n<\/p>\n
64. Thus, what ?n clear from the nature of \ufb01mrk<\/p>\n
asa\ufb01gncd to the various categories of am}? is t.b,\ufb01i\u00a7 ” <\/p>\n
the wnrk ef same category of o\ufb01ciala is   ‘<\/p>\n
by the other cataegary of empbye\u00e9i It th\ufb02ag  L. <\/p>\n
even without possessing    <\/p>\n
new prescribed under V-Ruisgs,’-vy\u00e9rl\ufb01
\nCourt has gone oxzr’ of
\nco\ufb02liflg into force,   -greaent Rulca
\nare of the     Half deczadas<\/p>\n
the   1;, eate5g <sfi\u00a2$ ' " 'arf ';Vata.\ufb02' have gone on
\npoasesa\u00a3\u00a2a_V%'by   prescribed under 1973 Rum<\/p>\n
 even  have been given to Group-D<\/p>\n
\u00bbA  up to the Aasistant Registrar category in<\/p>\n
2  <\/span><\/p>\n
  above state of a\ufb01?a.1m’ , can it be aaid that<\/p>\n
” ”  a mama between the objective sought to be<\/p>\n
  and prescription of higher qua\ufb01\ufb01catimm 31.3.,<\/p>\n
 DegreeorLawDegrae,a.athecaaemaybe.ashasmw<\/p>\n
beer1danehytheamendmantF.’u}asof2{}C}9. Inthia<\/p>\n
Pl<\/p>\n
\/jg.\n<\/p>\n
V3<\/p>\n
103<\/span><\/p>\n
oommction, it ia relevant to refar to the Ap\u00a2:r_4G::{uf_’t’aVV<\/p>\n
decision in the case of Fbod Carporaztian ofzaa\u00e9ri  _<\/p>\n
P:-axaash Sharmaand otI:ers(AI1i’V19\u00a3?8    _  ”  <\/p>\n
56. mg Apex Court in thy: afs “re.;1ic;_i\ufb01\u00a2n\u00e9t\u00a7~v_Ac&.A’ ac, <\/p>\n
going thmugh the job  gr
\nof employ:-zm. foun\u00e9  \ufb01x: pcffd\ufb01neciviby the
\npmom hoiding AG  -with the same
\nwar}: as  to    AG II and
\nthe  aha expected
\nto  Ai’~.’:w– and thus thn dutim
\n   Teiephrme Gperatom as
\nwell  III  to be similar. Taldng note of
\n    were also per\ufb01anznzing same<\/p>\n
‘A  ‘:1:1.;tie}\u00ab:gsVA\u00aboi*:G:-atduatca, the Apex Court, themfore, held<\/p>\n
 2   nt incorporating \ufb01ve years of service’<\/p>\n
  critmia for non Graduates. as the<\/p>\n
 ~  made by the Amandmant, is vinlative of<\/p>\n
 clause. The Apex court also referred to<\/p>\n
‘ varm’usdecinin:nix1thismnnectm’nandru\u00a3adt1mtthe<\/p>\n
amendments to the Regx\ufb02ationa making a di\ufb01hren\ufb01ation
\nbetween Graduates and mw\ufb01raduahe\ufb01 in the matter of<\/p>\n
j,\u00bb<\/p>\n
,9<\/p>\n
104<\/span><\/p>\n
promotions of the pests of AG–I and AG-II <\/p>\n
equality clause and are, therefaxe,    <\/p>\n
5?. It is to be merxtisaned  ”<\/p>\n
ans not graduatasflaw graduat\u00e9za\u00bb, <\/p>\n
work of tha posts hnld  af1&~  to
\nwhich airaady      not
\ngive any irzadicatioti  ii’?  ‘4 work, or
\nshmmgraphy   :1? is
\n     eacparience itself
\n  In than rqard,
\n $1′  in the case of Bmsaxerza<\/p>\n
Vs.   ”  Commzttee,’ rcportcd in AIR<\/p>\n
  be lcolraw into. The Apex Court<\/p>\n
\u00bbA   t1\u00a7&.facte of tha case: before it, that the perscna<\/p>\n
5f  aix years as Seniaor and Junior Draftsman,<\/p>\n
 ”   to be conuidcred \u00a301′ pmzzztotion to the past or!’<\/p>\n
‘  ‘H\u00e9ad Draftsman. In the course of tha said decision it<\/p>\n
 was held that it would be umeasombfa to hold that in<\/p>\n
addition to this aonsideraable experience, one: must aka<\/p>\n
have the diploma q_’_Lm]5.\ufb01::a::ionT prescribed and therefore<\/p>\n
%<\/p>\n
105<\/span><\/p>\n
A it was not mnaistcnt and cohcrcnt with the <\/p>\n
and im abject.\n<\/p>\n
68. The afarementjunad decisi\u00a7$1m :.=:g’reg<\/p>\n
case: on hand inasmuch a.s, f\u00e9r\ufb01mr  ‘f\ufb01ie <\/p>\n
persons holding the posts affsmu\ufb01  9.53,  and
\nScrrinr Assistants   f<:'z\u00ab' i1L-.:'t'Vt;  highs:
\ncadre of pasta and  'pf  has nut
\nin any way  \u00a311e kiigfwr post,
\n   Judgment Writers and
\ndug xia   dictation given by the Judge,<\/p>\n
 A   the dra\ufb01 or fair copy for the<\/p>\n
V   Judge. In other wards, Stenographers<\/p>\n
'A  Jtid\ufb01aen'.  t 'Writcrs and scams' 1' Judgmsnt Writam,<\/p>\n
 Degree] Law Degree qual\ufb01catzion are<\/p>\n
 ,  tkxzir dutias all these years and possession<\/p>\n
afsaiddegreeswou1dmakencdi\ufb01'ere1me,ao\u00a3aranthe<\/p>\n
core work to be diaclmrgod by the St\u00a2nog'aphers and<\/p>\n
Judgment W1-\ufb01terts and Senior Judgment Writers is<\/p>\n
%\/<\/p>\n
V';\n<\/p>\n
U36<\/p>\n
conaartxed. It may be proper for a Reaaarch <\/p>\n
tn: have a Law Degree becauaa the nature of   .<\/p>\n
said Rmcarch Assistant mqu1rea’   _tx5″i,a* \u00ablff _of.: ” <\/p>\n
the argumenm addressed by  <\/p>\n
court and look ta thy: deiisigna
\ndeaasiona in the light at” the ~  men.    or
\nhcr, to enable     render
\niudgmmta at tha   %$te=wgra:=1=ers,
\nJudit    Writers are not
\ndoing   Assistant and,
\n   a Law Degree has no
\n naught to be achieved and<\/p>\n
    In this connection, it may<\/p>\n
 _   on; of  to rcrfar to the: nature at” work of<\/p>\n
  Judgment Writers and Senior Judgment<\/p>\n
 have been rcfarrod at paragaph 1.4 in<\/p>\n
W.P.\u00a7\u00a7_\u00a3as. @155\u00bb 135\/seem and it is rightly mm: in the<\/p>\n
  paragraph that awmgraphy is a skill or talent
\n ?aequired,iznpmvisedarxciperfectedbya}nyman,aided<\/p>\n
and assistcd by basic knowledge of grammar and<\/p>\n
control over mcabt\ufb02ary, ability tn cuzmmxct sentences<\/p>\n
107<\/span><\/p>\n
i.c, syntax, command over Language, uxzmlatacij
\neduxzational qu.a3.1f’ mations. The art, <\/p>\n
paascsacd by tht: Stemgraphera_,haa_ no  ‘A V’<\/p>\n
all}? 5\u00a21’W’~’\ufb01” jlxrisI1I*udera’;ue and:      <\/p>\n
will maka a gcrson a goe?i_’S;mmgra\u00a72i:er  Aeju-:\u00a3,gm\u00e9nt
\nWriter or Senior V W:7.J.”l’.i\u00a2_E\u00bb3’z’,   the<\/p>\n
educational       <\/p>\n
‘?’O. It       it has been
\nthe  the authtar of
\n  atar\u00a2’VSt<;nographcra, Judgment
\nW"  _ wrimm Paasessing any
\n3.91.41:   ;":\u00bb1\u00a7t they are: turning out
\n  taking dictation \ufb02awlessly and<\/p>\n
  __thn xnatxerial into draft or fair eopy, to<\/p>\n
 ~.   such, the averments made in paragraph<\/p>\n
il\ufb01 of\ufb01formentioned Writ Pctiticns carry substance<\/p>\n
 AA  they have not been mntroverted by<\/p>\n
 2 r2a\u00a7po:x:1enm 1 and 2 in their -zrbjectiom. Therefore,<\/p>\n
 r'aqEun~.-gxzxsent of Degree quali\ufb01cation Easing obtained by<\/p>\n
Group 'E', SBA, FDA, Senior Asaistant, Stenographers
\nand Judpent Writers and Dgee of Law being insisted<\/p>\n
\/3".\/r<\/p>\n
1123<\/span><\/p>\n
on the Senior Jucl\ufb01t Writers has no bearing<\/p>\n
whatauever in rmpects of the work to be turmd <\/p>\n
the reapeotiw. cawgories f employees.<\/p>\n
71. The: Apex Court, in the cage Uf-T,R  <\/p>\n
V9. Twnilwadtx Water Supp!y <\/p>\n
in (1994):: sec: 232, hask’ia.\u00a2xa%%%r1:a\u00a3%wru1ekk\u00a2V1\u00a7sa;i\ufb01s:a2a\u00a2n
\nbased on higher eauqa.:sana;%qL5;fa1i5;cgu<or;  .pen~;ajasib1\u00a2
\nbut total rmtriotixm   go as to block<\/p>\n
the chances sf   held that<\/p>\n
   hiator:ca' 1
\neauaatsbn_V%and%'s\u00a2\u00e9ia1  have be be kept in rnmd'<\/p>\n
  he in consonanxze with Article: 14,<\/p>\n
\u00bb  2.5 a;A:vxi.\u00a7\u00a3!.:bf__L\u00a71c Constitution oflndia. mm Apex Court<\/p>\n
 ,  of the a\ufb01uresaid decision ml dawn the<\/p>\n
  legal propositions with regard to thc<\/p>\n
 x m;;uc3:;t\u00a7;na1 quahr xtation being a basis of cIassif"u':aticr2<\/p>\n
'   to promotion in pubic sarvice:<\/p>\n
'{1} Higher aducational quali\ufb01cation is a
\npermissible basis of ciasm\ufb01nzation,<\/p>\n
I09<\/p>\n
aeoeptabiliq-,r of which win dcpezzd an <\/p>\n
facts andcircsumstamm ofcach caac;  "
\n(2) Higher educational   '<\/p>\n
the basis mt only for      '
\naha far rentrx:t1ng' ' the     <\/p>\n
{3} Restriction placer}:
\nthe extent of   the
\nchanccs of prqrxaotiot;—\u00ab Ta. tiagide this,
\nextent of rastrLc\u00e9:s_n%L_a1:g1; 'i2ami"a1ac to he
\nlacked into  –"'whs3th.ei' it is
\n .iRea\u00a7s-min-_fi’_:_\u00bb._;1f\u00a7ia\u00a7Vj’ are being<\/p>\n
72.    rewards placed for my
\n   are assigned as tn why the<\/p>\n
    Gmup ‘D’, SBA, FDA,<\/p>\n
  A  Writcra and LL.B. Degree
\n  Y Seninr Judgment ‘Wribars. Acctordingly,
\n  consideration is answered he-lding that<\/p>\n
 of higher quali\ufb01cations under the amended<\/p>\n
   explanation has no nexus with the abject<\/p>\n
  to be achieved.\n<\/p>\n
13.9<\/p>\n
Pbint 130.3:\n<\/p>\n
’23. The next point to be answered in  _<\/p>\n
crit\u00a2nc’ n \ufb01xed by the provbo tog;   .i’~L. ” ‘V<\/p>\n
53009 is mnniibstly aerrornaous,  <\/p>\n
discriminatory and thus vi-$j_t.e:?.ijre \u00a2:%mm.=.%4  mi? A<\/p>\n
74. It. is the cont\u00bb-mtiggn
\nappearing for the   as Well
\nas lcarnadjwjz\u00e9rhjei  the right to
\nbe mmnade\u00e9ga    a\ufb01ecned by the
\n  jrherefore, the question
\n  he as to whether the right
\nto be  is fundamental right. and<\/p>\n
  is asacmd.\n<\/p>\n
V  V’    dispute that in Case of all the Gmup ‘D’<\/p>\n
 sum, FDAs, Senior Assistants,<\/p>\n
 Judgzznnt Writers and Seminar Judgment<\/p>\n
*   , no lug’ her or additional quah\ufb01ca’ tion is insisted<\/p>\n
 ;un:ier19’73 Rules\ufb01arproznotionto thenezscthigher<\/p>\n
post. Now, by virtue of the provisican and the:<\/p>\n
explanation substituted to 1973 Ri\ufb02es by way of<\/p>\n
I11<\/p>\n
amcndmcznts in 2009, the pctiticancm [an the <\/p>\n
he) should possess dagrael Law degree 1 <\/p>\n
them: who do not posse;-as aama:;~cannc'{t; V’<\/p>\n
501* pmxnotion. The very fact   <\/p>\n
also challenged the crdci’\u00a3’\u00a7 ‘k:1.\u00a3.’ pr\u00e9rn\ufb01\ufb01an   of * L’<\/p>\n
rmpondentn ‘3 indigzativa  1’s53t_AA’3\u00a73;I.5id.ered<\/p>\n
for promotion.\n<\/p>\n
?6.   Prabhzz Patil
\n“\ufb01ned    DD “vestfxl right of
\n promntion cannot be.\n<\/p>\n
gig  promotion. It is argued
\nby the   fer R-1 and R-2 that mare<\/p>\n
 of  does not give a vested right Ami,<\/p>\n
_V \u00bb’   the amendod Rules provide for degree
\n  law :1? in ramp-act cf Judgment<\/p>\n
  same’ 1- Judgment Writers, the petitiomara<\/p>\n
 ‘A  campiain that, by virtue of the changes mw<\/p>\n
‘   ‘brizught abaut, the changers of the p\u00a2tition\u00a2rs’ promotion
\n are rendered T’ aaibke.<\/p>\n
I<\/p>\n
112<\/span><\/p>\n
177. The laarned senior comm-.-.1 for Rd and R-3:<\/p>\n
argued that, as there can be In vated  <\/p>\n
of the pramotion. mere cI’1a:’1G\u00a2._to  <\/p>\n
therefore, cazuznt be magni\ufb01ed    <\/p>\n
right. Under the said A’v\u00ab:\u00a7Lmer.:.\u00a7ed
\nRules cannot be  tn  of  14
\nor Ar\ufb01cle 16 of   _ When tha
\n   ” fof education
\n    and, as such.\n<\/p>\n
the  to tha contrary<\/p>\n
   any force in it.\n<\/p>\n
78. 14\u00a2-dfaw for the afcresaid submissions,<\/p>\n
__uEausa1;\u00a7 Patzil placed reliance on the<\/p>\n
\u00bb  in AIR 1971 so 1350,5119 1997 so<\/p>\n
u –  m 2:312, AIR 1974 sc: 1, AER 2995 SC<\/p>\n
 2609 sc 2497. (200134 sec 433 and AIR 1999<\/p>\n
V’ ”  2912. Hence, it is argued by the learned senior<\/p>\n
  Sh:-i Banava Prabhu Patil that the question at’<\/p>\n
 hniding the pmvieo and explana\ufb01on tn the amixied<\/p>\n
Ruins 2009 as uncom\ufb01tut\ufb02onal ear violative of Articica<\/p>\n
14 and 16 of the Cgzmtitutjnn deans mt <\/p>\n
1′<\/p>\n
113<\/span><\/p>\n
‘?9. as regards the griavalacxe pf the
\nrcspect sf whom the learned acn\ufb01ox\ufb01. <\/p>\n
Plaxljunda Raddy made   <\/p>\n
promoted a\ufb01cr the   <\/p>\n
auhzniaaion made is that tigeisaad coiit\u00e9iitii-n
\nmet in the object\u00e9fmg  in the
\n babcha Emm the
\nrulings    senier mumci
\ndrew   ms decisions, which
\n   (199332 sec 340,
\n(19\u00a77)3  232,913 1990 so 357,<\/p>\n
am   sc 1255 and Am 2006 so<\/p>\n
 In  the said contentions put forward,<\/p>\n
\u00bb’    on the point, thcreforc, w\ufb02l have to be<\/p>\n
1″ ._   V V <\/p>\n
  Coxmtitutisn Baruch of the Supreme Court in the<\/p>\n
 . ” cf Mohammad Shujat Ah’ Vs. Union af India,<\/p>\n
 repartad mm 1974 SC 1531, has heid thus:<\/p>\n
“Article 16 is only an instance of incident of
\nthe: guarantee of equality cnahrizlcd in Article<\/p>\n
}’<\/p>\n
114<\/span><\/p>\n
H: it gives e\ufb01ect to thc doctrine: of equaiitjr
\nin the aphcrc of public amploymc-nt.\u00a7V._    <\/p>\n
cznncept of aqual opportunity In   _<\/p>\n
article 16 pexrwtaes     ‘
\nan individual’s    <\/p>\n
appnmunent     3
\ntarmmation to thc  cf ‘gxfamity
\npcnsum and gives expr\u00a7\u00a7s1o’:1_.to  -id’-aaliof
\naquahtyyof  one of the
\ngreat socio-eoo\ufb01bn\ufb01c  (‘mt in the
\nPreambi\ufb01 \u00a2-I”  A  <\/p>\n
Apart {mam-;  B.<:'nch also hald thus:
\n "Ta   " tion based on
\n'\u00a3:;;_'nii.", ati::x::;\u00a71{:@rta:_"'J'.rn1i-3__ "ms nnt obligated by the
\n_   mum. a\u00a3Vthc\u00a3'*;i1iti}es afthae higher post, is m
\n V  sti\ufb02e tI]"I\u00a7"313"("._'-_l'__\ufb02.\u00a7. thrust of the equality clause."<\/p>\n
V ,  Caurt,  , on the facts of the<\/p>\n
" .   to hold that the mic of promotion which,<\/p>\n
  that non–g1-aduate Supervisors are aha<\/p>\n
"   'T\ufb01z._to"'b\u00a2 promoted as Assistant Engineers, maervm a<\/p>\n
  quota of vaca.z& \u00a301' pmmotian for graduate<\/p>\n
' Supervimra as again: x:aon~gradt1at:e Supervisors,<\/p>\n
}\/<\/p>\n
~)<\/p>\n
115<\/span><\/p>\n
would clearly be.-. calculated to cimtroy the <\/p>\n
 oppomu\ufb01ty.\n<\/p>\n
82. In the case of
\nD.B.Balli0}7P<I. reported in am 419579 30 T_\u00a7:z.<3.f mxiagg <\/p>\n
with ArticIe16(1), the Apex  held <\/p>\n
'18 …. .\/me pmgczmn gar u\ufb01i-f\u00e9i-\u00a71t;a_ 14 and
\n16(1) will be  Ranch 2:\n<\/p>\n
   md’\u00a7kmmt and
\n     in prefei<\/p>\n
    It is
\n true   autimrity had the<\/p>\n
 i2.t1ni\ufb01.i”*–. conditions cf service<\/p>\n
 _    “employee concerned to
\n  httefs eniployment without
\n  hpij\u00e9e, But, such (Excretion has to be<\/p>\n
 ‘  in accordance with reason and fair<\/p>\n
\u00a7:;af,;~i__  mt capricimasly. Be:-aft of
\nga\ufb01gsmagty am! faxrness’ , discretion<\/p>\n
z  into arbitrax-ixwsas which in the<\/p>\n
very antithest of the rule of law on which
\nour democratic polity h founded. Arbitrary
\nuztvmtdon or enforcement of a servxnc
\ncondition tezrmjnatrmg the aezvicc 91′ a
\ntemporary emphyee may its:-.3! constitute<\/p>\n
F.\n<\/p>\n
1115<\/span><\/p>\n
denial of aqua! protection and offend
\nequality clause in 3:19.14 and m m. C
\n16(1) guarantees “equality of   <\/p>\n
all cmmns irxmathers
\ner appointment, to :’u_1\u00a7n:i_\u00a3\u00e9r <\/p>\n
State”. Moreen.-er,  .?;;\u00a7”‘the <\/p>\n
undnrlying 8.16 of \ufb02iev,Gumera1’\u20ac3\ufb01u\u00a7\u00e9s  S<\/p>\n
the expressing}, ‘apge\u00e9\ufb01atmemt’ \ufb01ned
\nArt.16(1} will ihclu\u00e9dc ;_  of er
\nremcvai from aarvicvg. 3’_u%ief\u00a7  ”  ”<\/p>\n
19.     cxprwsion
\n‘n*;\u00a3Ltt:1r1*a_  used in<\/p>\n
 ‘$3 =   initial mattzzra
\n  ‘eff employment, but
\n ‘xp\ufb02    in relation to<\/p>\n
 “aprixar, and subsequent, to<\/p>\n
 ” the er\u00e9playmept which are mmldental to the
\n.   form part of the henna and<\/p>\n
_  of such employment, such as,
\n as to salary, incrcmcnta, mare,<\/p>\n
.. ,.__~g1*a ti1ity, pension, age of aupcranazmatimx,
\n” _p’r:omotion and even termirmtian of<\/p>\n
empbymmt. It is further wall mtablished
\nthatArtn.1-4, 15(1) and 16(1) farm partofthe
\n5.31123 constitutional code of guarantees and<\/p>\n
supplexnent each ottuar. If any authority is
\nneeded for the ah-ave arzunt\ufb01atinn, ne\ufb01erence<\/p>\n
:.\n<\/p>\n
117′<\/p>\n
may in made to the observation made. A’
\nGajendragadkax J., as he then   .
\nGeneral Manager, Southern  wig;  T’ T
\nRa.rgac1mri[AIR 1962SC:36}i:;1;pr:g}”_:.” ‘:  <\/p>\n
as. In thn Gas: of
\nreported in (199917 sec 2o9, fm.= c\u00a7xm:1mt\u00a7:;n”’23\u00a2\u00a7;;h of V’<\/p>\n
mg: Ape.-.x Court, cmazmg witii 1*${a;\u00e9”h\u00e9id thus:<\/p>\n
“The word   there
\nis m\u00a7:m.\u00ab\u00a7;ga.~ne gm fold, the
\n..  above the
\nstag;  \u00a7:f: re\ufb01nmmmnt. Article<\/p>\n
 l\ufb02i) empisyee otlxez-wise
\n“;,\u00bb:\u00bbH81h1e–  or who exzrxma Within<\/p>\n
t’.\ufb01c__zom  .9f’ cr;a1xjs1dcra11on, -\u00abE \ufb01xndarmntal<\/p>\n
 ‘ ” \ufb01ght tc..3\u00a7\u00a2”oomidcred” for promotion. Equal
\n  for pronxrtitm. If a person
\n eligibility and acne criteria but<\/p>\n
is”:  considered for promotion, than t’.I.r1ere<\/p>\n
” .  be 3 ciear infrac\ufb01on ofhis \ufb01nmlamenml
\nfight to be ‘considered’ for promotion, which<\/p>\n
is his personal right.’<\/p>\n
 ”  84-. A Damion Bench of this court, in the calm sf
\nCharms Gorwda Vs. Hg}: Court 0fK(21″nc:tczica, reported<\/p>\n
I18<\/p>\n
in 11,1? 2004 Kamamim 44533. has also held<\/p>\n
prim’ ts. ng’ ht to in conaidertxi\u00bb .f_:)1′   M <\/p>\n
Ct-nstitut\ufb01an of India.<\/p>\n
35. In the light of’:’L’t1_g;  am by thc
\nConstitution Bench  Ag:  a Division
\nBench of   right tar be:\n<\/p>\n
 ”   a \ufb01mdamental
\n‘izs :’:;t:;::-‘I.   for promation. The
\n \ufb01rorldng between 10 to 30
\nyears,    the Writ petition avermgznta,<\/p>\n
 are aimiiarly placed film the<\/p>\n
 \u00bbA  mt been promoted only because they
\n 2   quali\ufb01cation or Law Degree, and thus<\/p>\n
fi\ufb01a’  the petitioners for bcing considered far<\/p>\n
 ‘A  to the next hcigha past, has bun severely<\/p>\n
 The petitioners cannot be deprived sf their<\/p>\n
  \u00ae right to be cormidered \ufb01r pmmn\ufb01nn by<\/p>\n
way of proviso and explanation substituted by way of<\/p>\n
2009 amendment Rules to 1973 Rules.<\/p>\n
vi<\/p>\n
119<\/span><\/p>\n
Pug ts Na.-4 &6:\n<\/p>\n
86. The next point to be considered  ~  <\/p>\n
criterirm fimad by the proviso  <\/p>\n
um-eaaonablc,  terry, isfatikiraal and’ 1 V’<\/p>\n
of\ufb01rticles 14- and 3,6 oftI1e'(3s):i’in:titutj:5r!,.V_  <\/p>\n
37. The expLennatiVor;1:.V:”caA_r\u00a2:s12cct of The
\nmethod of   category
\nof it ciear that even
\nto     riagree or a law
\n  {m  granted and it is not
\nsautov’\ufb01:s.+;t\u00a7::.*V   prescribed to obtain<\/p>\n
  ‘thus it is clear that grant of<\/p>\n
% V’  \u00e9 ‘pegimissim is nai\u00e9g\ufb01mmatia and it is else subject 13:\u00bb the<\/p>\n
  Chiefdustioe and, as such, there is no<\/p>\n
 {if every parson acciung’ perms’ aion, being<\/p>\n
giv!\u00a7n _A’3~permission automatically because, the vary<\/p>\n
 ‘ . _\u00a2$\u00a7;_a1ana\ufb01on says the permission is net automatic.<\/p>\n
 88. ‘The second aspect is, the Circular at Annexum ‘M”<\/p>\n
dated 24.8.2610, groduced by the petitionem in<\/p>\n
W.P.Nc:a. 22155~84\/2010, pmvidtn the fa\ufb02nwing<\/p>\n
u #<\/p>\n
120<\/span>
\nguidelines formulated with regard to grant c>f
\nan pumua further studies by the ca\ufb01icemf
\nHg’ in COLl.t”E.:     ‘V . ‘4 ‘V<\/p>\n
“1. The
\nCourt who are  205′
\nmegzeea\/LL.B;LL.M;3\u00a3aaier’g <\/p>\n
by attending
\nacqui\ufb01ng
\nshould  e;::*” Hozfble<\/p>\n
the c:h1egf  %Jwic\u00a2.  foliowing<\/p>\n
 i}_ _A K A’ ‘\u20ac319;  will not adversely<\/p>\n
 . L   %\u00a2;+1’\u00a2c:\u00a3’%%j:;:;ge;=xij:w:\u00a7r;: am in part1cu]a’ 1- the<\/p>\n
13oiir:3V'<3f'ws;i;*;1dy will permit than to<\/p>\n
   tixttnenormal omcial hours;<\/p>\n
    that " """  have passed the<\/p>\n
  igieparumanmx mcamixzations prescribed
\n 4%  post heid by them.\n<\/p>\n
,.  V At one point oftinne not more than 10%
\n‘or the amma;amcsa1a vwrldng in a
\nparticuiarcadmshallbepertnzitbed to pursue
\nDegree’aILL.B}’LL.MlMaster’s Deenmxhma
\nas atawd at SI.No.1.\n<\/p>\n
9}.\/~<\/p>\n
I21<\/p>\n
3. Perrniaaian shall be granted on
\nbasins of seraiority at” the o\ufb01cers\/of\ufb01ci_af1wi”‘d\u00a3’_’v:…: <\/p>\n
their mapectiw: cadres and the
\nbeentit1edtcprefe1’eImev” ‘””‘  ‘  ”<\/p>\n
39. What is clear from <\/p>\n
prescribed in the circular  g: 313%
\nnot more than  of   in a
\npa:-m’:ula’ 1′ cadre    to pursue
\nDegree] LLf_3afi315,M\/ mg and
\n  of seniority. If
\n  v\u00e9j\u00e9onjunction with the
\n   puts a maximum of 5<\/p>\n
ycara   as right\u00e9y submzlttad by<\/p>\n
  ,~.:=rJunael Shri S.P.Shar1kar, many of<\/p>\n
\u00bb V”–‘f11Ve.,V:e:1.~2.p\u00a7<:V:'j;=za__<',s will not be able to obtain degree<\/p>\n
 ._  ali, as 10% of the exnployam per cadre<\/p>\n
'i\u00a7\u00e9'o;ii4'5I V.r&:q :.1ire me:-rt than 5 yesm ff) obtain deg-cc or<\/p>\n
 "   as the case ntmjr be.\n<\/p>\n
 90. As far as the sm\ufb01wha are in grzrup C?-‘~’ tategory or<\/p>\n
emsn 8D&a and F’IJAs are cnmmmed, as airaady<\/p>\n
mexztjgneci, many of the employees fwd moved an to the<\/p>\n
‘X<\/p>\n
$22<\/p>\n
next post by way of promotinn in tha <\/p>\n
mixzixnum quaii\ufb01catian required far a Gmzg\ufb01  ‘<\/p>\n
mm :31′  appointmcnt is 7′??..Sfa_ 1} ar{i”\u00e9iix-:3′;Vn\u00e9$’t  K V’<\/p>\n
SSLC.  F&, if an emploj\ufb01e   <\/p>\n
passed “N1 standard wants  pursue a  w L’<\/p>\n
he would require    for
\nPUC and another  and thus mam
\nthan 3 yesaIt’5._WiI1 W the goal in
\nobtaining    V’  Lhx: expi\ufb01mation
\n   and subject ta 1%
\n Words, the prascxiption of S<\/p>\n
  ‘  quali\ufb01cation sfwuld be<\/p>\n
az\ufb01qt\u00e9ired’   arbitrary, ur1z’eason.ab1c and<\/p>\n
  lacks ra\ufb01anal rzmzus.\n<\/p>\n
..  apart, ths pariod sf 5 years starts from the<\/p>\n
 ‘A   permission is granted. “I’hat means, 3 person<\/p>\n
‘  “min obtain: permission alwuid join the milge on the<\/p>\n
: my next day and camplene the ccunse in five years.<\/p>\n
Joining the coilcge an the very ncxt day of ebtajning<\/p>\n
permission is impoasibln because, admissions are mad:<\/p>\n
I”\n<\/p>\n
.l’
\n..\n<\/p>\n
\u00a323<\/p>\n
fmm thc dates noti\ufb01ad and within stipu\u00a7ated_.’p\u00a2\ufb01}_:$d:<\/p>\n
kme may tale: more a\ufb01empts to  <\/p>\n
Fer time masons also, the pr\u00a2ap:fiptio;’1″\u20ac3f’–3,\u00a3;\u00bb;sz::s.V ”<\/p>\n
obtain the required degrees 73 <\/p>\n
without appiication cf  Such.    v<\/p>\n
the explanation under <2   z.=.   the
\necxnatitution.  .. _   '  _ A H<\/p>\n
92. me Apcx   cf TN. Vs.
\nP.Kn’sImq    Sec 517, ms
\n taken note of whiha
\n  ut1i\u00a7:;=-5 the validity af suberdinate<\/p>\n
Inga’   ‘V  t observatiorxa are noted at<\/p>\n
 1?’, 18 and 19 and they are as<\/p>\n
    the rule is valid in its enm\u00bbe~:y* ?<\/p>\n
~~_ 15. There is a. pmumpuon in favour ef
\ncormtimtionality ctr validity of a subordinate
\nlaglblatian and \ufb01n burdezz is upon him who
\nattachittnslmwtkxat itis  Itisaiso
\nwell recognised that :9. subordinate begklation<\/p>\n
124<\/span><\/p>\n
can be chalkmgcd under: any cf tha fo11owijrg: “f._ 4
\ngrounds:  V
\n(61) Lack of legislative mmpemmg
\nthesubordinate 1zg.as1a:sm.ur  ‘   A: \u00e9
\nfb} Violation of   7
\nguaranteed 11zn31ax’tI:-;ee.(:’,ormtV:if;;’tia’:n   3
\ngay violmm cf  gr
\nConstitution of.India,.–~–   _  .. .. ‘2<\/p>\n
{d} Faihzre ‘t\u00ab:.~…\u00e9;:1_:1A:fr;\u00ab:o_rr11   smmm under<\/p>\n
which it is ma\u00bb\u00a7g’T’og   of
\nauuuprity  .the’\u00a2x:,ab1′;\u00a7ng Act.<\/p>\n
re)    \ufb023*”A3l’ v1aV’\u00a7t?ts.”VVof the ma,<\/p>\n
  .’    <\/p>\n
Z ”  ” \u00ab .V  ‘ ‘ \u00bb  uizxreasarzable-
\n x:;a\u00a7saV(\ufb01’c:V . the court 1mg’ ht well<\/p>\n
    newt intcndcd ts<\/p>\n
. ..  such mks).\n<\/p>\n
 .    considering the validity of a\n<\/p>\n
 —  Legislation, will have to oomider<\/p>\n
Vtiig-ijj_  object and scheme: of that
\n Act, and aka the area over which<\/p>\n
” agfsowczr has been dclagatead Imdcr the Act and<\/p>\n
then decide whether the subordinate
\nl@\u00a5Iation canfcxm to tm parent stamina.
\nWhereamieia dhactljrmwrmiswntwitha
\nmnndamry pcmvisinn of the statute, thazz, of
\ncourse, the tank aftkm court is simple and<\/p>\n
2″‘
\n.\u00bb<\/p>\n
123<\/span><\/p>\n
easy. But wlmrc the eantcntion is that
\nirmonsistcney or nan-confcrn\ufb01ty of V~ :
\nin not with reference to any specific   M<\/p>\n
of the enabling Act, but x:avi\ufb011-the ‘;:’;;-ii   \u00ab
\nscheme of the parent Act,
\nproceed with caui\ufb01gn ‘beg.-.’n\u00bb.   ”<\/p>\n
invalidity.<\/p>\n
\n\n17'. In  \n{Bmnbay} [P]     Cuurt\n<\/pre>\n
n-arm-e;:= tp  gm\u00a2\u00a2% ” which a
\n  as
\nfofibwgii V     V<\/p>\n
 H  ”  Iogn\ufb01asiatinn does
\n rice; _. degree :21′ immumty<\/p>\n
 isx’  a statute passed by a<\/p>\n
  V’ Icgi\ufb01aturc. Subordinate
\n  he quastianed an any of the
\n  on which plenary legislation is<\/p>\n
Z M addx\u00a3ian’ 1′: may atst: be<\/p>\n
 on the ground that it daes not
\n \u00a2:or;fimntot}zestazuhsunden”whid1itismade.<\/p>\n
 “‘It may further be queatzloned on the grouncl<\/p>\n
that it is ccnttrary ts some other statute.
\nThat rs baoause subordmm Iagnsla\ufb02on must
\nyze\u00a3d to plenary Iagtslatzon. It may also be
\nqueat\u00e9aned on the ground that it is
\nunreasonable, unzxeaaonnble not in the sense<\/p>\n
126<\/span><\/p>\n
of ant being reasonable, but in the <\/p>\n
that it is manifestly arbiu-axy.”<\/p>\n
\n(emphasis      <\/p>\n
18. In Supreme C-eurt
\nAasn.v.Union of     ‘.\n<\/p>\n
the validity of n   <\/p>\n
npen to quesfmn if
\nConstitution V      or
\nrepugnant to   of the
\nlaws of the :\u00a7.:*rV-_”  or
\n   authority
\n    furthnr hcid<\/p>\n
 ..    to be declared
\n  marzifestbr unjust or<\/p>\n
 %  ..\u00a7;jr’k\u00a7;.1\ufb01’ageaus or ch:-ec’ ted to be
\nuni\u00a2ut1′;ozfia;_e:i~gnd\u00a5*’]or vinlative ar the: general<\/p>\n
‘ ‘V  qf lngfw of the hand or so vague that<\/p>\n
_ .   be predicbed with certainty as ‘In
\n T. :1 ‘4s;fh5it~.[.it’_;prol1ibited or 39 urxreasonatzhe that<\/p>\n
  be: attributed tea the power
\n\ufb01ieiegated our o\ufb02mwiae disclose bad faith.<\/p>\n
A19. In Shri Sifaram Sugar C01\/ad v\ufb02ninn<\/p>\n
of India a Constitution Bench of this Court
\nreiterated :SCC pp.:251-52,para 47)<\/p>\n
“4?.Pow-21′ dclaagatod by statute is Iimzited by
\nits terms and subordinate to its ohjccts. The<\/p>\n
I27<\/p>\n
dclcgatae must act in good faith, reasonably
\nintra virm the pawn” granted,
\nrelevant oonsidaration \u00abof material  5.11;
\nhis daciaiorm, whether ;M’% aQ  V
\nlegnklative or  at-Aq@5ia#i1j\u00a71d3ti\ufb01I;   A’
\nmust be in harmony   \u00ab.\n<\/p>\n
and mixer laws crf   <\/p>\n
‘reasonably
\nenabling 1egis};g{inn’..’_VA   “Moun\ufb01xg V.
\nFamily mbzmtimg   an:\n<\/p>\n
manife\u00a7ti3.t__ xgnjslaa   or
\n   ts:\n<\/p>\n
    degree to the<\/p>\n
 ” \u00abjg;-5 ti~.?.\u00e9_”bbj:i\u00a7-zcts of delegation,
\n   gay, 4f3az’ha.rnent\u00b0 never<\/p>\n
 ir1ii5nd\u00e9:i~. t<':c "g,'n}a. , \u00e9iztt1crrity to make such
\n  and ultra<\/p>\n
  p'.-_a-%%%:md Russel of Killowen, C.J in<\/p>\n
% *  9:*s'.\n<\/p>\n
(A; ,ua A%(f) gnaw that, in the mum case, the grounds at<\/p>\n
T 94.\n<\/p>\n
Vs. KTK Khmnalcarcm, reports-d in 1989 Supp. (2) SCC<\/p>\n
_  iii”-u\u00a7e;Vv.JoI31maon’.<\/p>\n
   clear from the grounds mentioned at<\/p>\n
A x ‘(-b), (#3:) and (1) are squarely am-acted for the rcaaom
\nThe Apex Court,i11 the cane efN.AbduI Basheer<\/p>\n
128<\/span><\/p>\n
344, has hsaki that where no consistent po1ic\u00a7r:’f”-Ufa;<\/p>\n
followed in treating the graduatzas and  —<\/p>\n
two separate claaacs, in the abgacnge of  ” ”<\/p>\n
in respect of conditions and izmaaenm .51′  f  :” s\u00a2%.$\u00bb-a\u00e9nf<\/p>\n
graduates and mn-gz’adL’*h_tc\u00a7,    ”<\/p>\n
arr} norrgraduahs ratio in   is<\/p>\n
violative of Articles   ‘mfcorxstitution of<\/p>\n
95.   are both mm.\n<\/p>\n
g1*a;mat$~ _ \u00e9;s:b’1*1a\u00a7r\u00a2:]}  working 11:1 various
\n  Vim’ :iia:J1x:ho’ ‘ 11 was made in the<\/p>\n
past  Vvtlriig-2y.’4’\u00bb*V:-fci’\u00a7:_”_.;,’>:”om::t;e<3. to the higher cadre.<\/p>\n
 Lapart;  quali\ufb01vzwatinn and law degree is
\n a  mapcat of feeder posts and enly Gmup 'D'<\/p>\n
   ,AV.:'v.':'SDAs, Fans, wan: Assistants,
\n< A  Judmt Writers anci Senior Judgment
\n AA  are now required to possess Degreeflaw Dqree
\n   and, in this regard, refemncc can be made
\n tn the Apex Caurt dminhn in the case of State ofMyso:-e<\/p>\n
Vs. Knsima\ufb02rfurtfg, reported inAIR 1973 SC 1146.<\/p>\n
3..\/\u00ab
\n.42″\n<\/p>\n
~ I<\/p>\n
139<\/span><\/p>\n
96. The Apex Court, in the afoz-maid case <\/p>\n
that division into twa classes of  ” V-<\/p>\n
wrvioe belonging to same oadrg .f\u00a2;_pu:p6se’*  ‘<\/p>\n
 ‘ in promntional oppcvixftuzajitg-‘1  <\/p>\n
14 and 15 of the Canat’i\u00a5;ut\u00a7on Va:  <\/p>\n
\ufb01xrthaer held that P\ufb02wezr to.
\ncan mt be    gmoonstitutional
\ndiam-iminatia;2_ in  (}o1.ren-mxaxant
\nman”\n<\/p>\n
pexbsorm-‘  mentioned above were<\/p>\n
appo’uit4=;i”‘L:na\u00a7t:r recnsitmcnt Rulm. 1973 and<\/p>\n
  by insisting upon possession of<\/p>\n
  A   quali\ufb01es’ titans, which is impossible<\/p>\n
“ta bcs. eic;’2′:1\u00a21:ed”‘ by them within the pericsd prescribed in<\/p>\n
 .%  exp} nation to mm’ and in the Light of z*eat:z’ic!3′:3r1
\n”  by fire: circular at Annexure. ‘M’. ‘I’hemfore,<\/p>\n
F mtw1tha’ tanding the sub:::ums’ inn made by Ieamaed senior<\/p>\n
counsel Shri Basava Pmbhu Patil that, 801115 of the<\/p>\n
empbgyees are pursuing degree} law degree courses, that<\/p>\n
3\/<\/p>\n
, I<\/p>\n
110<\/span><\/p>\n
imalfwill not give mom to take. the vim? that the’ <\/p>\n
and mcplanatian to the amerxded Rules are   .<\/p>\n
vwea of they being asrmtrgzy,  H  K V’<\/p>\n
disc.nrmna’ ‘ wry, irrational and thus if<\/p>\n
98. Further, it has to  <\/p>\n
having a basic degmg. on\u00e9”c.\u00a7;ij:\u00a3\u00a7'”t.._9btaiii”‘1aiE degm
\nwhich will have the  5;  The Apex
\nScmjay  (200911 sec 610,
\n T ma}   ‘  through distance
\ned\ufb01agtaqn \u00a7\u00a7\u00a7’r{\u00a7m:g\u00bb\u00a7:sity system of Annamelai<\/p>\n
 fa  as equivaicnt ta Masts:-‘s<\/p>\n
  course. The same is the<\/p>\n
M 1  Apex Court in Annwnazai University
\n ._  A   us. Secretary ta G-am’; Informa\u00e9ion<\/p>\n
  Depw\ufb02nent & others, repoma in (200914<\/p>\n
 .. VT$cc”s\u00a7o.\n<\/p>\n
 99. If the a\ufb01aresaid pasitinrz in Jaw in appiied ta the<\/p>\n
case on hand, Senior Judmnt Writars carmot obtain<\/p>\n
I..awD%atte1xii:Lgrag’I11arcoumeandtheywi1Ih.ave<\/p>\n
131<\/span><\/p>\n
to \u00a33111 back only on open univeraitias or correspo:id\u00e9;i3<;E':,,'4<\/p>\n
course and the dag:-ae of Law obtained by  '<\/p>\n
mat the requirement cf      '<\/p>\n
ansended Rules in mm" of the Age; <\/p>\n
prongunccnmnt in Guru  Uniijemity\ufb01.   Eat<\/p>\n
the aforesaid reason; the    are in<\/p>\n
the amnnaatisze.\n<\/p>\n
man: No. 551.;\n<\/p>\n
ICE}.   0f the e\ufb01ect of the
\naznmdca   \ufb01ubmia\u00e9sion of Icarned scnior
\n  Patil that the amensied<\/p>\n
mks:    ~L*:\ufb01’:c$i’.*t from the date they have been<\/p>\n
 sutatimtirng them in the parent<\/p>\n
‘   On the contraxy, the oonttmti-on of the<\/p>\n
H  is am the axzaanded rules cannot<\/p>\n
 the exiauxag bem\ufb01t that has accrued to the<\/p>\n
  ” ‘ The position in haw reveals the following.<\/p>\n
 101. The Apex Ceurt, in the came of K\ufb02\ufb01angc\ufb01ah Vs.<\/p>\n
J.Sree’m’1:asa Rem. reporwd in (198313 SCC 284, has<\/p>\n
held that, where the amendment dispenses with tie<\/p>\n
13.7..\n<\/p>\n
original prowriaicn far oomidacring 1.13.03. <\/p>\n
U.Z).Cs. for promotion and  ‘<\/p>\n
promotional chaencw cfthe.c1igi}:sl-3 :,.%m.:a’;   K ‘
\na\ufb01acted and they were supez’c\u00e9c1ed;’_’_’\u00a5:w}\u00e9;V <\/p>\n
respect of the  t1i\u00a2*- .;)r5sta%
\noc:cur1-ing prior tn    will
\nhave to be \ufb01lled 1:55   unamended<\/p>\n
102. In;    .s\u00a7:gh Rathare Vs.
\n  1 scat: 505, the Apex
\n  cccurring print to the
\npromm\ufb01ag\ufb01an V<:$'f.  Rules of 1998 will have to be
\n   the old Rules of 1988.\n<\/p>\n
 3′ case in the case {sf mate of<\/p>\n
L R.Dayal, repomcx z’n(1997)10 sec: 419, it<\/p>\n
 helci that the @119 which fell vacant prior to<\/p>\n
V’ .amenc1znsen1: cf the Rube would be governed by the<\/p>\n
 original Rubs and not the axrmnded Rulaa.<\/p>\n
104. In the mam on hand, it is not in controvtarsy<\/p>\n
between the parties that most oftha pmmc\ufb01am effmted<\/p>\n
‘.1<\/p>\n
133<\/span><\/p>\n
were in respect of the vacancica that arose
\n t. Even a perusal of the records   ~
\nthe lcarned senior munml for R-.3.  IE?’   K ‘<\/p>\n
most of $115 vncancm-.5″ at-we prm’v:r  ax’ :j <\/p>\n
of 2009 beixrg brought izzwfghrgge. g<\/p>\n
ms. In view of the  xasg a\u00e9wxg   Apex
\nCourt, rm   of being
\nsomidered fc_-9  p1’O’Vi$\u00a2 now
\n    Enut, on the
\noomr’a’rjy–,    “me ‘  would have
\n by;   under the original Rules,<\/p>\n
have   that pcrscm who are promotacl<\/p>\n
   mnended Rules of 2009. In ather
\nA ‘ V:V”*word;\u00a7;.A  c\ufb01bct has bear: given to the
\n ‘~  ‘   and that too in respect of the vaca:ncnsa’<\/p>\n
eif\u00e9\ufb01se prior tn the mating into farce of the<\/p>\n
V.   ”  Rules of20G9.\n<\/p>\n
 105. Atthfmjunctureitnzayalaoheuaefialtoz-eferto
\nthe commcntary of the ieanxad author N.S.Bindra on<\/p>\n
Lzlrm Interpretatic:x1 cf Statutes (311 Editzinn) and, at page<\/p>\n
r’\\<\/p>\n
134<\/span><\/p>\n
?’?’6, the lcaxned author has obaenreclw
\nrem-oapectixae operation is not to be \ufb01ver: to  V’
\nas to impair an cxiat.i.ng r7gh\u00a7.;er  ‘
\nthan as Pe\ufb01\ufb02rds mattaer of
\nwlggg’ h takes away: or gpax.’    T’
\nmin ‘ laws 0 AV    or<\/p>\n
 af:’;ae\u00a7f1’g_=;3. uc_iisabi1ig must<\/p>\n
be  be    rennaggtrve<\/p>\n
esanawdu<\/p>\n
ix:1p1ica’t:x.23;[\ufb01:.   the learned author
\nat  a\u00e9fects subatambm right is
\n Vto’   unless ma\ufb01a retrcnsp-eactive<\/p>\n
ei\ufb011z=3z’_ earpfmsly’ sir  necessary intenclment.<\/p>\n
‘  amended Rulcs have: {alien away not<\/p>\n
  of the petitioners xmzier the existing<\/p>\n
1\u20acu1\u00a7esjg$fi’973, but also deprive th.-;-zm of me bene\ufb01ts of<\/p>\n
V’ ”  up, time” bound incremexzts and senior scale of<\/p>\n
 as ad} of them would have bee;-xxx eligibie for<\/p>\n
 pronmtian but for the amendment and the axnemiment<\/p>\n
by way of proviso and cxpianation is, thcrcforc,
\narbitrary, ciiscrimixmmry} irratignal and wleiative nf ttw<\/p>\n
9V<\/p>\n
135<\/span><\/p>\n
righm guaranteed umiezr Articies 14 and <\/p>\n
Ccrm\ufb01tutzican and hence unmnstitutianal.<\/p>\n
1303;” t No.7:\n<\/p>\n
:08. Coming to the jugTs::\ufb01cati\u00a2m[“~:;r  gramign A<\/p>\n
ordem, even an fhcts, it ix
\nbeicmghilg to Gmup.  d’iAs:iVii,e:t $3oa3wa
\nthe degree  and some
\nof the   petitioners are
\nalso % Tu?  by mm the
\n ;&’pmisa1 ef the records also
\n   a\ufb01criai, the reqtzi\ufb01nmnt of
\ndegzmwg\u00e9’ Quad as one tima measure.<\/p>\n
vIf\u00a7{.;\u00a7.:;z;:}1  be  tn one employee as a<\/p>\n
\u00bb  I fail to understand as to why such a<\/p>\n
H 2   not extended to the petitioners, who, for<\/p>\n
 f\u00e9\u00e9aaom -\u00bb mermmical or otherwise, oculd not be<\/p>\n
 ‘A  enough no haw either df or law dqree<\/p>\n
‘  “Mien they entered scrvicc several dccadaa ago.<\/p>\n
209. Apart from that, as most of “thee pmmotiorss are<\/p>\n
givezxagainstthexmcanxzieswhichamsepriartotlue<\/p>\n
an\/;__<\/p>\n
136<\/span><\/p>\n
coming into force: of the. amended Ruleua, the <\/p>\n
who are entities! athexwise to the said  ~<\/p>\n
have men dcprived of their  to’  _for=_  ‘<\/p>\n
promotions. Far a1} that-.  <\/p>\n
to the persons, wimse ord’e;\u00a7_1fs.._gf pi-oz\ufb01\ufb01tion in
\nof service   1.;pheId in Law as
\nthe said. prromotio11I 9_-r!=2:._i:1  fundazzcmntal
\nrights at   considered far
\n   the prcra\ufb01ao and the
\neupsgnagti\u00e9izkg  of 2009 being held
\nto  unraassnnable, irra\ufb01cnai<\/p>\n
  “of   guarantee conferred<\/p>\n
   Ar\ufb01clea 1+ and 15 of ms.-.<\/p>\n
 11o.. _\u00a71 the light crf the tirgunrzents advamed by the
\n  senior coumcl Shri S.P.Shankaa.r, it becomes<\/p>\n
 natszaasary ax\ufb02 inevitable to wganaizm the procedure<\/p>\n
followed in brmging out: the amended Rules of 2009 into
\nforce. The dra\ufb01 Rules at Anne.-.::ure–C, which have been<\/p>\n
3,\u00bb<\/p>\n
$4’
\nV n<\/p>\n
137<\/span><\/p>\n
publiahaad in thc. gazctv: dated 12.5.2009 <\/p>\n
the very first paragraph thus:<\/p>\n
“In mrerc\ufb01se cf the   <\/p>\n
mm: 229(1) and (2) m~ m\u00a2;e,.m:m;\u00a2n;%fa  ”<\/p>\n
and all atller
\nin supersession of all   113$’ <\/p>\n
the subject, V<\/p>\n
.am:;a_1or  so far
\nas   ” aliowarnzea,<\/p>\n
 the method of<\/p>\n
  cf aerviea, the<\/p>\n
    Emma and pensions<\/p>\n
A   __H1’gh Court of Kamamka mm
\n1  to as ‘t1m3ervice”.”\n<\/p>\n
\u00a311,   re, appears \ufb01bm the afoz-esa:d’ preamble
\n AA  the gsractts mti\ufb01cextion that the approval cf the<\/p>\n
  r af Karnatnka has been obtmm-rd” . But, the<\/p>\n
 Iearmxl seniaar mumal for Re}. and B-2 dist ccmoeda very<\/p>\n
 that, in the objectizsns fled  R-1 and RE, it has<\/p>\n
“r<\/p>\n
I38<\/p>\n
been stated that that dra\ufb01 mics did not see the <\/p>\n
the day as they were not approved by the  _<\/p>\n
Karmxtakn, At the same time, the gazt: ”  9 <\/p>\n
mt-.ntz’:ms that the appmval\ufb02ii of<\/p>\n
Karnazalm has been obtaigmg.<\/p>\n
112. If the dra\ufb01  g;; \u00a7:i::g piibii\ufb01lixgcltiin thc
\ngazette, are to be  coma \ufb01rm:
\nforce in view cf the  Ciausa Act,
\nthe aecz_a:\u00ab\u00a7   of 1973 Ruse…<\/p>\n
If   qumticon cf bringing
\n  Shri S.P.Sha1:1}car is fully
\n   that the procadure followed bath<\/p>\n
‘  reg;-:=r:t”\u00ab\u00e9$f Ruben an anal} as that: amended Rubs<\/p>\n
 –  ;;\u00a3  in mmonarxze with the well established<\/p>\n
 :51′ “law and the preoepta and practice that are ta<\/p>\n
  ”  in respect of amending an\ufb01ct.<\/p>\n
 113. In the light of the a\ufb01ormaid discussion and<\/p>\n
anawcra to the points rated for 0-onsicleration, all the<\/p>\n
writ petitions are allowed on the foilawing terms:<\/p>\n
139<\/span><\/p>\n
The proviso as well as cxplanation to the amended<\/p>\n
Rules of 2309 mquiring higher
\nquashed. as being violative of Articles 16 ~
\ntheCana1:itutior1and   u
\nThe orders of prornotix>1r1;s:.Aan;’_”y;r <\/p>\n
W.P.Nou. _ 4ssa.4?\u00e92%;_V;ao1b,.    in <\/p>\n
W.P.Nos. 11797-zxazfifzoiq,  H. J
\nas K in w.P.Hm}}”22:5.\u00a5;s2’2’1.5:4[291o, Annexureg-
\nc, :3. 11%-5\u00bb F inkMvi.P.Ncg_.fkssce\ufb01tsiswszz2009 and<\/p>\n
Arme@ %   1337249\/2009 given<\/p>\n
 ”   whoac promotiom
\n  writ petitions stand
\n thc quashin\ufb01 of the orders of<\/p>\n
 1  it is aka netsessary in the inter-east of<\/p>\n
 of the High Court that no hardship is<\/p>\n
” _ &;aused from the point of mew’ of emurmg’ the<\/p>\n
smooth adnainiatratiozi of the work of the High
\nCourt and hence, the pemcns, whose; promotions
\nare now quashed shall. howevsr, be pernlittcd to<\/p>\n
continue in their rmpectivu posts as an incharge
\n~”\\<\/p>\n
140<\/span><\/p>\n
arrangmncnt, til! the pmmotiom arc ma;i”e  in
\naccordanrzae with the 1973 Rules, aftm  K
\nthe cases of the pdtitioncrs am for\n<\/p>\n
iv) As regards the relief  “E33:   u
\nW.P.Noa. 22155-22134;
\nrestriction fbr  Writg\ufb01; pk\u00bb: ” A
\nofAssiata1:1t  of the
\n    mine
\n    relixzf saught
\nis not   it is left
\nV) The aeqan\u00e9  Qiisrected tn redo the
\n  to all the: posts in
\n of 1973, and necessary<\/p>\n
 ‘*a.tcpa  vs’;-dg sha\ufb02 be takcn mm’ cight<\/p>\n
  dab: of receipt of a cspy of this<\/p>\n
   Sd\/’I
\nJUDGE<\/p>\n
Qihxavrz csg:c1\u00ab=\/-\n<\/p>\n
141<\/span>
\nOR_D_ER OH BEING SQKER TD
\nVQ :\n<\/p>\n
13.1.2011<\/p>\n
pctitisonars in W.P’.N<:zs. 22255-2;_a1a+[ Q1010  T<\/p>\n
the memo \ufb01led for    .\n<\/p>\n
learned acmk;-r counacl  for
\nR1 mjd\ufb01ai    ._ <\n<\/p>\n
2. CIaz’i:5x:atinns   in respect of<\/p>\n
i)  sen” m’ r Judgmant Writers to
\nh\u00a76ki_V%Aonl\u00a7Vf .f._’34 ;.*g:”s\\t\u00a7’..’L’of Assistant Rcgistrars d’ hers<\/p>\n
 ‘me rafib’=\u00a7?.:V1__;_;,.<\/p>\n
A  4′)’  provkiad to direct recrntitmcnt.<\/p>\n
”   ccxmpetitive test at all atages of<\/p>\n
  only to stenographic cadre imtead cf<\/p>\n
 promotirma on seniority and service records.<\/p>\n
 3. During the course cf the subminsimrn made,<\/p>\n
learned senior oounaei Shri S.P.Shank:ar submitted that<\/p>\n
in rmpect of promotion to the post 131′ Assistant
\nn<\/p>\n
J-\/’<\/p>\n
. I<\/p>\n
242<\/span><\/p>\n
Regstrars, the ratio of 2: 1:1, which was <\/p>\n
1973 Rules has to be niaiiitaixied Zaiidj. esfeii’ <\/p>\n
amended Rules. same ratio is rnaiiittd\ufb01ed. TVherefoIi:. ‘i:
\nsee no need for any clariiicationiin 1’eg%1ifd”‘to3 reivijo is<\/p>\n
concerned.\n<\/p>\n
4. As regards Vconchict —  Veoi’z11ieiLiti3}e’.v tests at all
\nstages of p;’od1ot\u00a7oi1-,’_ir1 feepect of ietelioigf\u00e9iphers cadre is
\nconcezfnedii iI~  devi\u00e9tjori .f:\u00a5\u00a2:in 1973 Rules in the
\nprese11’tF2O-()9  .-As such. no clarification is<\/p>\n
required exien i11.t_his <\/p>\n
 ” 5′ . fa.i”~.a_s 40’3riv’:’m2iat.io provided for direct 1’CCT’i1it1I1CI1t<\/p>\n
1   judgment writers and senior judgment<\/p>\n
wa:ij;vers_.-ind’ amended Rules of ‘\u00a3009 is conoemed.<\/p>\n
 since”  the direct recruits are not made parties and<\/p>\n
 f:.,;1fdf;er, as this court has directed the second<\/p>\n
  l\u00a7’\u20acSI30I1\u20aci\u20acI1t ii\u00bb \ufb02fineezad to redo the entire pmcess of<\/p>\n
promotions to all the posts in accordance with old Rules<\/p>\n
of 1973. in my view, no further clari\ufb01cation is necessaajv<\/p>\n
Q; 1’esp\u20ac:Ct of the same. \ufb01f
\nK. I<\/p>\n
I33<\/p>\n
5. In View of 1:331: aforcsaici \u00a2ba\u00a2rvatirms, <\/p>\n
taken eariiar, therefore, does run  .<\/p>\n
modifmation,  _ =
\n Asa –\n<\/p>\n
ckcf –\n<\/p>\n
 7<\/span><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Karnataka High Court Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 Author: V.Jagannathan us: THE men coum or KARNATAKA AT ‘ v Dated: ‘I’}rm’ the 148*’ day of\u00bbIDe.<m A 'V ' BEFORE' THE HONBLE Iv!CR.JU\u00a3\u00e9'I_'ICE v; SRIKHAI-IADEVAI&_H ._ 2 AGED A39 ‘:45 a10,LAfrE F{~.’1I.AIAH. sax :3. ” ‘ AGED AFSOIJT […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_lmt_disableupdate":"","_lmt_disable":"","_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[8,20],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-190227","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-high-court","category-karnataka-high-court"],"yoast_head":"\nSri C Sudhakar vs The Hon"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India<\/title>\n<meta name=\"robots\" content=\"index, follow, max-snippet:-1, max-image-preview:large, max-video-preview:-1\" \/>\n<link rel=\"canonical\" href=\"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:locale\" content=\"en_US\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:type\" content=\"article\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:title\" content=\"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:url\" content=\"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:site_name\" content=\"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:publisher\" content=\"https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:published_time\" content=\"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:modified_time\" content=\"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:image\" content=\"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg?fit=512%2C512&ssl=1\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:width\" content=\"512\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:height\" content=\"512\" \/>\n\t<meta property=\"og:image:type\" content=\"image\/jpeg\" \/>\n<meta name=\"author\" content=\"Legal India Admin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:card\" content=\"summary_large_image\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:creator\" content=\"@legaliadmin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:site\" content=\"@Legal_india\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:label1\" content=\"Written by\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data1\" content=\"Legal India Admin\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:label2\" content=\"Est. reading time\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data2\" content=\"92 minutes\" \/>\n<script type=\"application\/ld+json\" class=\"yoast-schema-graph\">{\"@context\":\"https:\\\/\\\/schema.org\",\"@graph\":[{\"@type\":\"Article\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#article\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\"},\"author\":{\"name\":\"Legal India Admin\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea\"},\"headline\":\"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010\",\"datePublished\":\"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00\",\"mainEntityOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\"},\"wordCount\":17601,\"commentCount\":0,\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\"},\"articleSection\":[\"High Court\",\"Karnataka High Court\"],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"CommentAction\",\"name\":\"Comment\",\"target\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#respond\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"WebPage\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\",\"name\":\"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon\\\"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#website\"},\"datePublished\":\"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00\",\"breadcrumb\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#breadcrumb\"},\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"ReadAction\",\"target\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"BreadcrumbList\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#breadcrumb\",\"itemListElement\":[{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":1,\"name\":\"Home\",\"item\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":2,\"name\":\"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010\"}]},{\"@type\":\"WebSite\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#website\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\",\"name\":\"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"description\":\"Search and read the latest judgements, orders, and rulings from the Supreme Court of India and all High Courts. A comprehensive database for lawyers, advocates, and law students.\",\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\"},\"alternateName\":\"Free judgements of Supreme Court & High Court of India | Legal India\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"SearchAction\",\"target\":{\"@type\":\"EntryPoint\",\"urlTemplate\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/?s={search_term_string}\"},\"query-input\":{\"@type\":\"PropertyValueSpecification\",\"valueRequired\":true,\"valueName\":\"search_term_string\"}}],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\"},{\"@type\":\"Organization\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#organization\",\"name\":\"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\",\"alternateName\":\"Legal India\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/\",\"logo\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/sites\\\/5\\\/2025\\\/09\\\/legal-india-icon.jpg\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/sites\\\/5\\\/2025\\\/09\\\/legal-india-icon.jpg\",\"width\":512,\"height\":512,\"caption\":\"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.facebook.com\\\/LegalindiaCom\\\/\",\"https:\\\/\\\/x.com\\\/Legal_india\"]},{\"@type\":\"Person\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea\",\"name\":\"Legal India Admin\",\"image\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"caption\":\"Legal India Admin\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\",\"https:\\\/\\\/x.com\\\/legaliadmin\"],\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/www.legalindia.com\\\/judgments\\\/author\\\/legal-india-admin\"}]}<\/script>\n<!-- \/ Yoast SEO plugin. -->","yoast_head_json":{"title":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon\"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","robots":{"index":"index","follow":"follow","max-snippet":"max-snippet:-1","max-image-preview":"max-image-preview:large","max-video-preview":"max-video-preview:-1"},"canonical":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","og_locale":"en_US","og_type":"article","og_title":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon\"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","og_url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","og_site_name":"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","article_publisher":"https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/","article_published_time":"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00","article_modified_time":"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00","og_image":[{"width":512,"height":512,"url":"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg?fit=512%2C512&ssl=1","type":"image\/jpeg"}],"author":"Legal India Admin","twitter_card":"summary_large_image","twitter_creator":"@legaliadmin","twitter_site":"@Legal_india","twitter_misc":{"Written by":"Legal India Admin","Est. reading time":"92 minutes"},"schema":{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"Article","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#article","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010"},"author":{"name":"Legal India Admin","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/person\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea"},"headline":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010","datePublished":"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00","dateModified":"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00","mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010"},"wordCount":17601,"commentCount":0,"publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization"},"articleSection":["High Court","Karnataka High Court"],"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"CommentAction","name":"Comment","target":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#respond"]}]},{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010","name":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon\"Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#website"},"datePublished":"2010-12-13T18:30:00+00:00","dateModified":"2016-05-01T08:45:18+00:00","breadcrumb":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#breadcrumb"},"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010"]}]},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/sri-c-sudhakar-vs-the-honble-the-chief-justice-on-14-december-2010#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Sri C Sudhakar vs The Hon”Ble The Chief Justice on 14 December, 2010"}]},{"@type":"WebSite","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#website","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/","name":"Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","description":"Search and read the latest judgements, orders, and rulings from the Supreme Court of India and all High Courts. A comprehensive database for lawyers, advocates, and law students.","publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization"},"alternateName":"Free judgements of Supreme Court & High Court of India | Legal India","potentialAction":[{"@type":"SearchAction","target":{"@type":"EntryPoint","urlTemplate":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/?s={search_term_string}"},"query-input":{"@type":"PropertyValueSpecification","valueRequired":true,"valueName":"search_term_string"}}],"inLanguage":"en-US"},{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#organization","name":"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India","alternateName":"Legal India","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/","url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg","contentUrl":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-content\/uploads\/sites\/5\/2025\/09\/legal-india-icon.jpg","width":512,"height":512,"caption":"Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court | Legal India"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/LegalindiaCom\/","https:\/\/x.com\/Legal_india"]},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/#\/schema\/person\/0bfdffe9059fb8bb24a86d094609c5ea","name":"Legal India Admin","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","url":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","contentUrl":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/4faa9d728ed1af3b73d52225c7f12901ac726fe6f7ea0a3348a1d51f3a930987?s=96&d=mm&r=g","caption":"Legal India Admin"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/www.legalindia.com","https:\/\/x.com\/legaliadmin"],"url":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/author\/legal-india-admin"}]}},"modified_by":null,"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_likes_enabled":true,"jetpack-related-posts":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/190227","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=190227"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/190227\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=190227"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=190227"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.legalindia.com\/judgments\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=190227"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}