High Court Karnataka High Court

Hanumantha S/O Hulgappa vs Earatayya Driver In Ksrtc Depot on 11 September, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Hanumantha S/O Hulgappa vs Earatayya Driver In Ksrtc Depot on 11 September, 2009
Author: C.R.Kumaraswamy
 _ :79, _§:§}*¥i;€£i?i>§.:§%?;V:§!§%'§ §§a::I;m:a§:§;3.,
' _ "3%s;§;::,§:§W"'§a?:;§}%:€. :§I'€--§E':§;g

 .. f"§"'::§.:§§" T£§fé§ }§i;t?st:i»;fim€;  __ " 

Ex}

E-§a:§g&.§r§}es %§?;>:_§§::§aéa;,.?::%§:35«  
,s5§g€Ei§ a<:§:»a:§§;§?if :§:?"a:§3§_ 

  Eéasigsgjggéé  
figs-.:§: ?§i}:3:;§; f3€§g?$€aLfé3§»- V 

, §§§fi§Vfi§&§3 fa V §"§&Ei"§§Efia_%:E§§33,
v:~i"?%;_gfi§»::?_A--:a;'§:u:a.:.:fz 12$ 

«.5-

Eaxl-EE a:=§;:':"a*=::<§L%;{%§:',:.§§ 9%'
¥§§§38{§{§,€.:§{§§i, Sfiséigafiaa

 §:"§.%§}§: if '$3

 

gééyg §s§§°§§§%%§

€,./H

'/-




'§'§i2:E§: ;?%§§3'§ §::§}'2*::E:::g <33 §:;:r Exaagézfgggg, iézég {§ajs;'_.€§':__:€  

§"§é:%§.i'%'€E'§§*i§ €312.56 §§§§E9¥;:§:2;g:

 

fizés §§i$<:§§§;2§:§§;':§g ';?.'§§*§'i ;%§§€aE_3;$".f:E§:é £i:;¥§fi§'» §%§:%<:%;3E¥G~:; "

E?"£§sf§} 0%' §%§'%' fiat? éigfiififii $5 ' §v%::§g;§§%:§a§'----gfi§.T§:%a7§;:f{§ §$.:€{E
{°?§{::§;»§:§§§ géaggfié £3; %;'§°%;f$  §:%:%"f:Ej§£ 5%' {E25

mggéggag {}§'i§=.£:; :3: §;§:§2.;'  2% §%«:;é;:::*'§»;::§

§a§a:::§f:'::.:; §%"'§§§'_§*T%}:i§'%,".%'%'§7f§§i;§f:"i_§}.€ ';§_;3_E"Q?$3A'§§;9?iC'i§'§i,§§§§:'.?.«€:B3;" aamgéfingaiifigg
magi Sfiiiééiég§'€i}§a§$€?:??;3€i§§3§._§i%§; {::;;§:§;£:::_3$g?é@::
 égfiiérfaié  §"€§€E""§?£}{if€ €93 fizéé giaizgg

E33; $5525:      

;;;%;  azzg-$225 4:33? éhé; $ §;¥§i E31 Sim ifiiéaimg '"§":'é§.":2:maE £3

 V:,;€;é:£§€:";i*A:L '

 k.:%§:.__}~2'2i.§Z%§g.§§§2 §.€€63:S€§§ €iflar § §§£§3;":':§

i:ra¥?,E__Eé':"s_   zaéffiz Efzéia" §}E§S§&§;f§ e::§3:ém§;§2;% E313; E, 3'1:

 '§{.,§4,§f"§; '$123 %§a.:§:"*:;§§"g f'*§s:§=, §%%E§'~§.§5;'§2 §§'{}3?;§; .§g'§a$Ea*,i3§ '£9

"?'§§fié.E{fif§;?£§£Ef§'E'§§", §§§§1§E"} fig:  @233 wag; §m;'¢£--{§..§::g an fiéagfiéé»

 HS%§§§§.§§2§":";.§§§f :€:3:2=;a§; at s:§}{:r:.§§  §3§%é 3 §.a3§':°§i 'fiaaiéizg fig. 

" «»*§;"":%;';'§é§ fjffiflifx fig: ii}: €§§§{§f§§i%;E éézécatiigjm, magi €fi&§::§'§§{"§ agaigggé fig:

§:3z§::~;e '§'§:&% ';§;:}a§$::':§;g%:r$ $313 931%? "$2,313 Sfigfififiéi émgéziéeg. "figs '2%?§$'



_  M
 iizzf ::{:m;3§:::é:;:zm€: Siiigfififi §$E'§a;.;:_; 

E§'%§{Z{f1§§§3§T}éf'§§ ii; %f%':i:" §.§;'§z2:'zi§:$,

as

zzsrgaé 2:335; £jJ€a?{f%,};.§_§€'§§:a§§§:s "§*I%:§é:§;"€ .§3 .;;:::% *.

  

§:3L$%§§§€}i§}{§§:§§.  E6 '§'§";.§ I§'%3S§}i'$IE{§%3-f}\v;. 7'

E3525 <§§}§:;:§:E"§§ §;i%3*;';%'§§:':z.g~--...v-  'V 4'
 ~'§*%:Vi:¥T§g2zf;§:':;.§&fit§fiA: '§--=3'€:§;;"§ E22233 §°:"i?$iz;§,' {;§;§§:<::%::%::: fiiaéiiiiifiifiiéi $5.2.

§f§§,€? ii'-§.a_é§i:$ %§'?;;'i%,7§§:a.;152:s;§"'§::§%:§%§§;.g %g%;g ;g:r::g§gz:.'§;e:::%: <2-:3 figs g<}.::s.:"iT Q?"

§€<:s;§a:;§2:'§a-';3r:'§. §'*€.-atgxé --» {E-%*i%sé;_;:* §"' éégéaa msgsgzéagii wag §3f:<$%E§'f;{§

1a»*'%.':; 2, §i:"ES§_}{i%é§=..§fE.§T§:(§:; iicafis 23:33 3333 ;§}{}§5i<':§a" 2%;22;$ ii: .'§}Zi:'€3?: 23 3:: $326

' Viiéiiifi :2?' aaitiééazgé.

AA  %?3%:§§§{,;§.::§;§:::*§ E'§=:3=f_§ E2253 §EE§,s:% {§i:z;1E<:§;i{;:2 3%:a§&§:{:3;:?; ii;

--  {Kg '%*€;.sé; "§"§é%3::s:2;:Ee TE6  ém fig ::xs§*¥i:i§z:§;%.. '§'§::i §::§$é.3:*a;a':<:::

"  é.::§3:';:§§%.f:{§: 'fizz? agfcéaéfifii ?{}€}Ei géaéti: aim': 32:2» mg}: 3_%'i.€§.

'§f§§'i§§§§{:';'§,f§.§ {§§§'é2?i§.2.§ Q3" §°3i"f§%_:£T§Z}3!§{§éi'§E'§. ?§i}s E.

1.

<1' §7§:$§;€;%;§i:{§:"::§.":§ ii; iézér iiiziiémie '?§°E§}::_§E::£§V..§::e§.:§' ' "

¢_ i§€:;:;3:5:s:£§;z:.§;;.:r3«§ §€:3xil:i§,%1"§{}€}:;'v~ :§:=9s;33%:f£€: mzéar figs Emaaé fiaésizézai

'::';a:§:»%2~;*:;:r;:§§:v:*:;:,;'~V§%E$}i%,§}{Zi§§~ §L{}§5§2'.'~§§"§;§ 33% :3? {Tf{éi§S$§'§§§§§:fi 33$

'V §»'f3.§§%§§§{§$V;9 ég a::.a-'§;::°z:i§{§ 33 2:fz3§§.};3€E§?':§:»£i§iZ§@§§ aégrgg aagéfiz éié%

V ""§§?:'§§°s::§':'*$a:§ fiais agggzszzaéi

{E 2. $2 5 'SE35

2?. '§'"_§::::% mam 233$ $'§_§§j%S§fi§:€."{? {sf 33:6 Eézgzéézag ass'? iééa €7f:Eé's3;fi::::*a

'§'§i%EI}:3:%::§§ fig as uzzaéayz

2;

‘E”E2.i* éifi-Ea%:_:;::4?;: ‘”Z”§*§%§m:§;E §§'”f§€§L €E:zi%,’.§§;t:_§:a3§: »§3;:-‘~tg§,§.g%£:::;?:”~

9:” Eiéga Es:§§’:’~z: E235; éégk.%~a§;Ee::»”:*»;€:;i;;=:;;§”‘~-;;%f%i%;i:§”
%§%éa.§’*’;:’;g ?%§z:;a§*§;’§§”;?§»J«§i”§i§€%v %:§§_*§v€:” fié§..,,5§’:§a%;i%§s§:€§
aiizgca ” §}é§E?sff 33$, s;%§%§::’:_;g;§’ 5%-*é:’§€::::@w “§’§”§:»:

§3€gé;”;gf;§:€:a $3 {¥::’:é2?:’::§* 2:}? 22:5

Ezaifi gm? $35. E€;f;:fj§’ i§..:?3’f%$f::*§

8.; _f::%%’§ zzééfisé’ ?§§§i§§3§ {:%§.”‘€;Ef:,%: {if%?§{§§3:§}.C€ af Efiiéflé hag
§iE§§€3S$€{§’§_§;.%£j:’ .%:é.::%;:3::;i€ ‘:7s:§°T’§&%§TA.:§_§;::fiea:A:»;${§ 3″: R3, 25%; ~ gsfir {Ea}? aizsii

£=’i%3£3E”§§{f€§, {f{3Z'{§§g}iE§.§$3,§?§G§fi E:{gé€},€}€§~§,§w i£;z%,:~?§:’:§§ fissfia <3?

;}§;€}{';{}§m-~.V."L:i::fi;%?2:§z§§ ESSE :2?" figiaéfi, E33 3%}; 5: 3:53: a?

H 71}. ?~'$z:E:i§,1g a§g§.:§§:::T2:§{§ fix %3§§4€§ '§;§'§§ séaéggzsgzég 313%

33% 3?': *5 3 E iIf§}{3ié

4;,"

sgggzgfz EE:;,;’§;i}?i}{;?§ — ‘§{}%%?§§;§'{§§ §%;2,;’§:%:.m§ $::'<:§;s::§::s§ €Z1:::§";§§{§5:"§:i';~;–€§£

5E§'€§§'§m%;?E"§{ %;§ $32: $3 figs Esaggééaé 2}}? '£225 diéfigtiiafiééé :.~:?i%3e:.3ffG'§ V.

$§:§§§:§§2g €335 giszzé '§2e:.g§}-" §7§'s.3m §%§:§§:§§::":2:" 'ii;

2%;Z':§:rs$ figs };:«2f§;;:%:a§};z :§:§:;;s;; ‘.ji§§C§§°§”€f§§ _ VL

(f{é’i§’«i{ff;;’:§3F:(f%”i {*:%:a:’°§€;€; magi fizataééafiééiyv €:'{§€§}§:£”:§v_ “§’E1€} .§a3:f§’§§=;§

affizgazfiéé 5%? {ha §§§§§€E§&§;fS _ n;*:<;.–:;§m§%§ $3: $325

{~.m;;§3<3§;§:~§é:i::;§.: a§;g;.r{§§§% z.:;é,%f§;<::£:%° "j'§" r:j: ::§5 :*a§:1§ fiifiigfifiiifiéifi afié
35533 ajsf éffiififfi $52; Ei;§S{7%_ 53%: éiaéiéifzg ink:

asztmzézfi Eéwm Sjiaéizagzag
hagggaai :5 ::;;;:;’:;g§_ag§é-:.::.§;”T5:;ifigzg’ gggcgréggg figs Emma

{.’§%’§§E$§3::§. £9;-I -§[“;:’%~v_Va§:;§f’fi§§;:::*:;3.. a§::s:::%3.§ 33} Eémg 335% gigs fiéfiiiiffi
Eléfgéi §§§§i€’§§§ ‘%:;z§§:e:g$i<:;$f.i&§i:iz.¥;_ {:5 fifiégia E'§§.§ffij§"§fi{§ £2 23:1 :56

39:3;-ma' si:§;€:§'=.g: – my 'é§§§:§z3..i;%;§ séamaais am fiizééfitzfi fa:

aiiéziéiéggissi s::Q£a§';:%ig:$3;%§§::§: $3? E€$§§§%{"§§§~ §§*;a§é:$§ Ejégézi

?§E.";€}'%.E§,a»?3%~ET§%I§ *i}:';i§§:'E, "§"§;£§%@§{:§§e, €325 samgemgaéégiz amfiuzfi 5%'

I 333?}? Eiégégzé '§'§§€:;a§a2::é {}:':§§;} QS gzyazfiafi

E5}? fifgé "§':éE}:§§:.é:§ ég; fiE§.§T3&§E{3fi{§ ii} §$,f?§§§3'{}$f~ §§%z:§€;£g

$£:ars:3§.2%::: 5t§:"§X §§'E2{;:.:s&§::§ {§:*§3z}¥ 'E'E"2& fizzégzggisazfi. {:€;2m§:m33a§f*§§:%::

%;:j§;7§§ ifiififfiai 3%; 525%; §£:' :.=s§:,§3's3m f.?'%;'j'5£fl iiié aéaig {$5 §}€§é§§Q':'E

.«-'