High Court Karnataka High Court

Honeycomb Associates vs Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes on 16 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Honeycomb Associates vs Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes on 16 December, 2008
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar


rrirtlo 0,4,1? 113 agqexea S1
SQHIBJJ IiO’§1I1.1′”E3’c] qmos AZQHOH :9q’:1 19:11 ppm; 071 :;1zap1zoc’£s;;u’ ;;~I;}i’3._
139319 03 PH’? V”9J1″¥X9UUV 9??/\ 80051-11 139399 U0¥1’E”-%3’1.11~V¥..B__’£4i”3. V V
p£1)[I3I”1d’£II’_£ zaqg qstanb 01 31::/Eezd ’emu; 30 [I0″_f1R11E1S£IOQ.§_;)[{‘j[«_ f ”
$0 2:52: ‘£>1i:m 95$ S9Ii>¥’l~I’v’ Japrm 9911.; SI I10%.tm:a-cl mm SILIJ;-._ L” %

.LN(EI G’NOcI S3211 3

(df{3:i)H r{iH9MSI30§9=§?£iS 12*; ‘::wis% 5&3 x ”

‘mfiatfiqpueg

‘1’=’z”\’BIB2″§lI’€}9I 9,.3I-I9’l¥.LVFiI{i’!-1–I.9}”§.. ‘(B>f€$911J¥3.TI§I}
ssxlag, [I-3.*§_4:’)’;:;;atm’z1oV:§) jQ_V.:;{§uQ1ss1u;{t;tI0;)

._ CZNV
(‘sa1B’Jor3§V;:j€s;:;p:;13f:)oe~isg§} ‘S /;;\*g 1.13
g’3G§_91§’-3Q§pV. 5¥3!–§P§93i’WV ‘m-1 ‘us 543)

E-1iE{I\{OI.Li\L7.§::{j’:v _ ”

_ Jagxjmdj S1; riq p:91u9s9.IcI;>;_.;

‘ A ‘om O9§”910I’93T-T98

_: A 2 ‘Jefiemfvfea ‘X3018 mg
, ’91H;s:a’ré%–n’sI1puI’8I–IUBC:c1na:> ‘9I /e:1:’o:~1
_ . ‘$;:21″{31:)0$sv qtu03A’9uo1q

K

V -V(s3§i’*.1;}ss®z:}LL8QI’0N N0I.L1.1;M.L1am

% aI§ari251§:g va3c?{pa:§i*1A:«1s”AU CE{:)I.LSf1P ‘aw C§I’IEI.NOH (E{I–I.L

i§{k’:lO.fl3EI

9o0z[‘é{taIav\1:z1:>:F:i .tIO LHEEOC) HEEIPI (HHS. NI

‘U<3?1if19d 1m-an Sm: alogawm 9118 '1JTi0'() sun riq

paugmexa me; go uo;i1$9I1b f3I1;:A'Eaq no 219951 ;{{tI0 3: mq Ieagidxg» . ~

30 KpE9I}_'I9.I ;§.1o:1n1e1ss 911:1 3I.i§fl'l'3Al?s' no 219931 1011 S1 .x9_1.t_<')'_A1f'3;g:.1:-:;«d_T."~

3111 pm? .'zaI1o"_t'3,%_t;;:)(i sq; go 139.1:-m:£; 911:1 0'1 V' 'V

9: s9m:.1oq'1I1e am fiq pgnssg u01;19:)gpI1=,{1_:;_9qj1 ;;¥:L{j"–;3ue "

pm: %17 19 pagmou exam 18:11 sum}; 9:11 pyosz :1Bi§1
s1::)r:p.:d 9111 I30 _;V_/x_ go may go’ ‘._;§(V§o:)§’;V p_QQ ‘1s..j1:gpun–s:ui
5.119101 SEQ .z9LI_1:;{1 p’jA¥1,t§&§.'{L:>sm10;)

}_Z)8[I.IBQ'[ ‘J81{{)[fB.ITi}N’f…IS .Iqf *5

‘.I9uomr;9d ;)[}3″z'{q .I9’£.I(){SS}_IL{I[I{O()
9111 Sq pessyd .z:§’p.;<5 .'_9m 9:13 niq pmrgdo
SE' '%<_;'z:1 113 .10 A9,_4g_,1; ';<$ 9:..a~31§:.1 JQJJYIS prnoqs .19UGE1!1ad
315131 ziiq Spifiéfi :I§§q::A§§i§.t\zs."'o'3V Se uonsarzb QQ1 :10 13V X8;
peppy go 59 uogaag Jzzxpurx tI;1ta:)1;dldva
S%’1″_[: :9’IL.[;i siq pQSS2§).IdX€~) txogtzyzdo 9:1″:

V A r’*1r?:”pz%é\i.’«?¥¥~£33’¢ SE ‘é~a?i)a ‘lav X’3.L P9999 QUIBA Bwzvwefl am

.. . if .»jL*>.’és:1o;s’T;.1d.:d’ JQDIII1 .’t;;{e9p 32: SI own .1au0m:’19d gym

H3030

Z3lI§.M(}flO_} am apem 3.21103 91;; ‘flap
S{{fj;= SjI.I1.m91{ zimxxymqsjd .10; no 311111103 II01_r;1:’1;>(i sgq;

1310;} s§p;;{:1 Aiq ‘;QU p£;fe_..k§;410:}:1f1v:
am xiq suop aaq A'{U;o meg ;9§;.§o19x.3§\\ ;>’q’1 go
938:} 911130 Sixzmg; :1IIeA:9[9.1u :93} Q1 “[‘3u11qg.1’L
.10 3141193 .’IO”f.I2i–?d1″”iS apt; {EaI;znq;.IJ,

am J()I1E 1.11101) 31151;’ .’.1;9£¥oyss”gI,:1u1(3’_) 9:1″: go
uogrgdo 9:111 Qugeufix €t1é:q.$ .IQ[IOI$S¥,¥j[I'{I£()(;) am
uoy1″e*Jg§m13 .13§9Os12qz;; s:1g;{_V’V”t:1();;1.$:;>;*”¥:’T£} qorzs; zytxgtmazxg <31 mzau
on S; A_;3puzHfi:SQ:.1_§1Ot{3113g gwH9dd,3 gm '.9?
mafia} Vzégnfijaq 1_;)9sg:e.1 S; uogtzsarub 91.11 uatgm

psutzjnr-fits; aq "–.T§O13§§Qfib 9:11 mq p[ot.{s:9.rq'1 9:11 123 IIQAE}

A.VV{1e§g:11"41:_:§V';1t~h:s'¥§ié._ »;i$1:{1 0:1 z{3,.I:~.;>q;{ fiu:A.I:)$:;J ‘passuusgp

s”;V.’:I0?13f?3§=?d. __1~§_1m s1q1A’:.’:;:>u:;};;’ ‘@3130 :)”E.1″.1 50 $1g.I9tu arm £;)IIIIL’fE£”X§)

AV i3~’1v”.};34;;~Ij’g{–:)ii£g:’_A 1QI}£ _’IIIB 1 ‘J;9:;3,e'{If£ am 50 MGM. Sm”) {If ‘t~,.