High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S M N Shanmugam vs Additional Director on 20 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M/S M N Shanmugam vs Additional Director on 20 January, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


‘ :31; aw’: ; A33?’ M: §«<L§¥'s%8AR*3ER%é%%#.T%%; :~»§<';:'-.:;;=*;

_ …_"'§"a}~:E 43$?-§8'£"£*$'%..éT%Q%é <3? masa §RA\z;:~4e "re QUASR ma 33:22.33; €31',
' '- A " " *§"%–£E Wm' PE'€%T%.G£'~* ANS 3% mac? ma 9:'.c.s$~*~r::;:-emE:~.:'I are RETURN "me

EV "E313; 31$}! CQEERT SF §~i;'~'RZ*'E:~'~.'1Z»'%.K_A AT " 35'" LQRE '«}«x'.Pu}-ééaéééi G? 2953
1

333% YHE HEGH SSURT CF §{AR3’«EfiG’A3{A A? B&?€GA§.GRE
i}A’i*Ei’i was THE 26:3 ma; 9% 35312313.? A.

EEFGRE

ms HG%é’BLE ma. 41:31:32 ;«”;k.PmaL

wax? FETITIGK I~:e.6é65_ are at .2 1 ‘
9*;*9sE;*::::; V T’

ass 3% N SHANMLéGA%s.%

gazes GRAM ?H’§ERC§'”3§:?*iT’3,*._
%«é{>fa32,’A’Eé.$CK, –_ . ”

3% CFi’.C’»$3, 8ANQ§P.AL”a’A, ” .

msaaa, REP: SY:%’i’3 P&R’§”é«é§-R: V ‘
322$; SARA$§$£A”§}%A%s%%£A,V.-“‘ H V. .

gags gage’: 52 *:fE.€a§~:s,

I _ _ _ __ . ..:9;~*E$:”::x’;:~:ER
{By age ; 3 3; %;fA1*’::§;°;§’-zézzéggj. S¥i%L%?;é§’v:9s’xT:§;;;:AB*§*G+CA’37ES}

¥”Q:

‘E é’~’«§.}SE’§’§1′}s”~a§fi%_é. SERECTSR T’
{E?%FGRQE?;§E?4? ii}? 1é’a{3V%i:3_§}{:;?.§.3,.?i;..?5VR45s§..
‘e’se’%ARKE’§”§’é§*»%G; $Q’€'{“:R§~§?s%E£%’:£f{‘L'{}? §<AR%x%%?.%KA,
$49;-'éfifl: *3 NQ "3~"2',z%».%8£.-';§§'aa7fi'~;i'§s. RGA9,
§5:'3f«_3'=i{3~»,:-":i3C}RE~':.; ~

' . V ?:'~::".~. E'%¥«':E'C's'z";§»R
_ ' §£%Am':2:;£:s:':~ ::;zr= AGR3CU$."§"L%RAL:
V :Ag«ag£2;<.€;3f?::4<3.,_c;'s;vr. 01: KARNAEAKAE
._ '-ma s;s.z*:é_s ?%..?{.%%3HAV:%%\i Rags,
A as;~z@aL#3a;~?;5s my

X E3'!

RE$E"~'{}%~s*DE£~é 55

#%%§

W 9%"? 3'-'*'E"3'§'{éG?~é 5$ NLRB UNGER APJECLES % A948 22? SF
'2%;2;29fl$ §$$L§EB 8'? "WEE $388? RE%NBE3'€? VSESE A§'»§§'~éEXi}RE«C TQ

'§'i§i£ HIGH {,"£}ii§€"§' OF K}§i€i'€§;'f';§KA £51.'! ¥v".§3.§\E(f:.e'3é=€'r5. €}F Efififi

}T.'»3 BEE Héififl C'a3'i§}?.'"f £22? KAF;}£?A'EZ- ' .='*-5.'? §§A":§§€Z',aAE.€}i "'? '-32' .33'?-ii ".£:1é:§§ Q17 2€§{l'«2'§

-‘8

5.

$38?-13 Q? ?si3CGi}i’%”€”S ANS $”§”%~iER RESGREZS SO SEEZEQ FRQM

3’e..%S$3’«£§:Z$S Piéfdfi 51′}? THE P:~”I”€iTiQ%~£ER’

‘:”;1=:sw:«”::”z” %’z”2*:’:e:: {2G?w’E%?\iG {EN ma PREi.}¥%1R%-éAR\” %{e;,z;5zf:;~;$’ ~

:8′ SRSQFZ THSS 3.5%”, “ME CQEJET’ %’s5§§sB’%’§’n:§ ?i-LLOWSNG:

?et%t%::’mef kw this peiifien has fa; *q_:;:~:a.:é’i*:.ir?:§

ihe seizure dated 20*?’ February’ 309s”;.«;§;.-ed Afirasj-‘;

respafident aside Armexure-C to wrfit 2336 ten
ééreat fine :°e$pander:t id i”~;;==…§i*_”.3;=;*1’A._ft§*z:f_&j Asmasnés
and ether recards _$av__$e%zé5’»f%i§rfi’ tféfae’ piace cf
Ehe petiti9r:é?;” – fr,

2. “?;§’3é’V%év«éfT’T’*t§}éz.der ufider the Agricu%”:ur3%

?:’c>éucaV.§Fe%3ri%:’ét V_:{F2agu%Aafié’§%V & Beveioprrsent} Act arzé

:.f J§-$32′; AVi’*§V<'é5%;*:j1E'*&–%{r'%:"e*;d; £3 Acmurri banks 321:} ifie

'l campieied up 'fie the years 2C£}5-

‘ ‘:”L’§6 3:€::’i~.. Afar each respéeiéxze 3$Sflfi’S$”fi&fi”§ year.

4.’§:’?*.ZV§3%§”er2:.i§§ any} jusfifécaiéan, the firs? resgzmndefiii has

‘ifisééiétaffi the buginess premisam fif iha pefiiimxer and

“é{fi’zéd the backs af 3389:; wifhmfi éssaifig any miice

iii ‘fféfi HRS}-i €_I’i}i.§i%.’i”Ui*7 i<Z.fixR§~éPs.'£:%K.;1 Hi' BA?éii§§.i,{}R;E *ée'.$3.§'-é;3.§éé:é:5 UP 2388

TEEEE EEESEE if.';C}§.?P.'"f OF §{g%}2?»EA?}aE<;% 3'3." 1";§£:~2GJ=£,€}§–3,£ "a?é§~'.§'«.'iz3.«z3»c*£;'::"s (337 3.3533
4
“E

drawing ism ififiahazar dated 29″‘ Feabruary 2058. That

apart, as mifié be seen fmm {ha mghazar hawks, the fiféi

féfififlfifiéfii has aficw ‘the peiéiéafiet’ $3 gem the beaks-“c:f

sccaunis, Eewfigem, etc. wifich $3 wfihauf aifi%§ar%%y’V.A::f’ ‘_§é§g.%_<;.

Téfierefare, geizifie as? %he bflfikfi sf 3ma@;;_iff:i*s._ '1.§I%d: e 3

Azénexuré C — Mahazar, as §"e'€é:~,:'re§s'$A T'a:eb':;vé__"%$'~..:'s§%,_. '

':.ss%%%":3b%e. Hence, '$'?2§'f§C3¥'¥éf' herein féét "ixecees;-fi%%*éafe§é ii} 'V

presafit éhe wrif peiitésn %r:vc_:f§iz%:”s3c°’3:

}u:*%sdic€%::m am czgrstend fh:e§€%?%7é–.Se§.%2iv{.:’r’e’Ljvéziégrsggrzed cams?

5% SiiS€fi§i”j¥fi§» 3:55 ‘ ‘%s°’i§-a.b§&« se€..§éi§’9-

5. ‘::r5:%£i*-:3; ‘T»v4EV_?:*:=’.2*:.::%z*”:7::’~::?.P’}§’1}.E§{§55 Q? 2{}€.*-B
5

pmpeféy and t?1e§*e £3 any deviatian, the safi aufhoréiia

have every rigfit to make {he spést kzsfieciian and se.%-2&5

the bwks as’? acceafits by drawfifig they ?v’:3%”aa2;%i:§%*f”¢’

greased further. Therefere, rm arm? as suchfias fiféeln T

aammifieé by first respénfient in difjawifig j;{§°r.§é ‘1;

and seizing the banks cf ac:c’:§:.:r’:’i’§A.v_37$”sd t%»sé{“§_a;we_}_2′

&}($¥”C¥$&§ by tiw saw auffmréty is %_a;_?£h%§i”£§§.:é I’ reéévsnt

§f’G’v’iS§G5′?S 0f the Act and. Ru~%e:-=.i:{.,’ ; °?fia;fé§,fire, {ha W???
pegmn fled ms %__’fie’i;%’i:§fiVi% e:%-” “%¥3h”_%’a_%§”‘;;”wa-25 éssmsssea 3%
§”nés:::ar2ce§2sed 7..

8. ij;*a%.e€_ir:§i*:e;~*:§:;f_§’£*a:g_:g __%ce3’med cfiafisei agjpearéfig

far pe%%%§sne’?__ a:’;é” %%5’§’cé .–%é’2:rr*2eé Gévérnméfié Péaacier

_..a;?p§ear%:§f§’g” €411′-r resimfiafignté ‘i am 2 irzciufiirsg {Em mahazsr

AVizfyémfizigzi..f§’§:§a:;fm_fiexure C, éi emerges that firéa firs’:

ffifififiééfif 5E}I;?%%arcez?zenf (39% 3% {he Defiartmenf cf

-..___;3.{:_§%ci3§t%;::.3§’g_ ?’x38¥’kefi¥”i§, Gaveyfimefif 3% Ksrnafaka,

.j8%3?i§8§§i§”%fe has mafia 3 surfirise xéséé 2′ Spa? Enapeaiiim art

“–..’2f.§g””T?Februazry 292308 and fnund same variation in

‘{‘}§,E Eiiififé %;f{_§{jj«§:’§” £3?’ i’2;§*;§{%*éi’;E1=3J6{%5 33%

EEJS “§§}E EEESEE C$§.§}?C§ C3?’ %R}€§’~.}”;”».§-; A? 2 ‘=’~E:IL»’§L%3R£ ‘%’uP.}~EcaV逧{23 GE? 29%

furzsfiarzéng 35; fits’: rmpandent as Eafarcemefif 333%. “§’*’r:i$

aspect sf five mafier has no? beer; whiggsered

pé§€§éf”§€€’ én fine entire peééiécm, except ta*§<§r:g.$'_:§;5£:i§§?cj. .

graurxé fifiéi, unéer Sectians 68 am'; 25 of'%§1'e*

figs? respanéerri figs rm waver td":.s<e'§ 2%e"t%i£2. _'{;'-:i§ s;.:_§

Acceunts wfihsut Essuérsg ::a€i:~r§'~..g§d' A'wiihczggf _!£f§iirc§§-gig
mgsporiunity ta pei:§t%c}:*:-&§"V;—- Thg-**;é:;éj§;1""»gr.§a1 n :3'"iakssén by
petfiianer ctatwnai be acne;-fé:§'Vis:§%2$f%$'§i§ab§a far the
reasafi 'that, ifisrst cafidascted
surprise s§§ :§ Efiaks G? Aacaufifs,
the gaéd "'Céf*fi3ifi diwscrepaneies in the

maéntar23neé":3?"tiié'$ér:*3e.. :].Thefe%§re, the said éuihoréty

–v%”I$s s(}*;§g;§%1i_t_”fmj° fifié’ ‘z-‘&§ei3.;;avn’£ beaks 3? acmuréfs in arder £9

Vs3:’i’::’.;y “E91$”.s§:?3e§: ‘;3arficuiar¥y far *:he period frzarn ‘E53 Aprii

.. 3§«# ;§a%iuary ZQOS aicng with the iecigersg saie

§:sar::ifif:.baek, Fcxm-35A eta, afier seézérig same af

~§;c_)§7j§:s éf accounts as referred if’: the impugneé

“‘-§f§a§1_ézar dated 20%’ Februar $68 Vida Aranexure C. 3319

if’; ‘E35 5165 ijifiifii? U?’ E’§.fi.RNA’§L%i’v*’.}*.§**:’::».é«€3iis5 L}? Efiééé

r
$3

2% ‘E313 EH3 if'{.;’51_}§3.’§ 1.2%?’ KA3{}€2’2?AE«’L2% 5?? B;’=.2*§£’i£-2L€3=§3_Z ‘a?e’.P.l*E<:».é£}=:%3 CE I 29
{D

{Z

535% ¥"$3SC'¥"i§§"'ig given fer geézuré cf 'the *sae§:$ cf sac-3*:::§.:ri=:s,

"ii'§§$ fisnnexure 3 isjust and ;.'3§'0§f3é¥'. % dc: rm: finfi $.:%s.§.%4'_e'§*§*a=fié:i

Q?' éééegaéity :38 such cemmiiteé by $119 first f$$§§–fifié.fs§ Z

seizing the bmkg ef accmsirfis afier' §%§3w§§'i§jj.hfi3;%%3za%' smgj Vi' I. f

find way gead gravfids as S;£.iCi"¥,i'fiad5 fi§:*_¥':'i:3}: %%r2,»"§;:sjg¥§$i:3fié:r V

is interfere iii the émpugrvéei Gééésf find f'i"zéT_:§'xa'£3?:?':3.2ar.
'¥"heref¢re, interference bVy*«.t7f'?'3s_ 'jagsfifiabie.

7. ‘riavéng regsré §C1r’§§*’r’£3« ijf’.’2cV’£’:~’,:_”ar§<:.i 'ci;;fi:it?:=sst3:"3c% :31'
the mag, the wréi pé§é*i§_:::} :=fiA§e%;i Ejy' gfietééiiérgef is désposed ca'
wéfh 3 d§¥'6Cf§€'§f§ :*e%f§;i;§;fiijc;%e:1tV"»fi{3" verify the seizeci
backs; cf é§f{f§%e ';'s§é'ii%§c;?§'éf'finder Mahazar Vida
Afinexureifi 'afzd Same, if the enquiry is
cempieied a7'r3;'3 "%f §':'£;% A§;et '_"g:*~$mp%e€ed, to cenduct and

cersciuafe' the s2m'e.,V_V_ éf{er ésfférding reasefiabie egpsfiuniéy

I- fé'"~%§7$"*~§efé%§Anfi€2+§j 3r2dvv"'{éé take agapragariate decisian in

;§t;:.f.e§*:ifaa*s":::§:§v«§f§i%§1 as ehqsedifiwsiy as pcssibie, at any

._ r3€e,"'J§ii$;;¥:§n 'a{~"L}g:: é§'i§°:ci 6? three mfinfiis fmm the @336 sf

re5ce§§tu6%..3"'*§;u5p*§ af thés fiféief.

Séjg-IE»
F:i§&§§

V ‘ V ‘ 2 =

Ea’ 33$??? _F§E{%§”i C'{}iji{‘E'{}F §'<;Ei§'?.;"'*é?s'i'Af€;.£"L A5' }:§g51§\i{i25.L{3K.E '*.¥y}'VE*ée.飧€§§ Q}? REE