mu
EN THE 1*-$3854 CQURT OF KAENATAKA AT BANGALGRE
DATES Ti-{ES THE 3% DAY 0? JUNE 2068
PRESENT
THE HGWBLE Pe’§RS…3US’?ECE MANJULA CE-¥ELLL.§E{ .:4:”‘._V_
fiaN§
THE HONBLE MR,3UST!CE §<,r4.K£sHAvA94Ar§AY:a§§;é" ' 4%
MESCELLANEGQS mas? APP£.a:,N}c.9e?4;2cQ§<Mv§j _
BE'W%.'E EN:
MAGAMMA
we mRAsRAJ
AGED AEQUT 82 ‘EARS
RIO 9.2044522,
ammo St. PAUL SCHQGL. % ‘ ;
c::—-sELz;<5RE, KA¥..YANANAGFgR, <
BANGALORE
_' *'…APPE§.%.AN'%"
(BySré.§R¢Af$3fi;GGE§1fiiN&,
8RI.PiLLARE;$DY-=,VA{“3%£$.)’-._Vj–A..,V V 1 ‘
ANS: “”” .
1 MAN; % * ‘
SIC’) LATE !%§;§R§¥;€2’sEJ3’%:¥U’«
R10 3ss,.
_ 3!,£SHVE’$.§_A!ARAiAH NAGAR
.. Amaze ceases POST
B&N%LORE .. %%%%% ..
A _ ” A THE QF£E1:ENf3’AL :r~4sz;$2ANcs. as aw
* 9.0 *%.z.aw0 3, SHANKAR Hausa
A _ ‘ ME_i<;HR_§ €::RcL£,
8l§Ni.%!ix§.{3§'2E
RE? 3*! ms 0éV§S§0¥'\EA£. rsszamaeaa
RE$PC)E\éfiEE¥*~3TS
r M g
. A' {Bys£;.mARAYAmAswAa§Y, ABV. FOR R2
% = Fifi-Sci.)
/, _
'?%'=é§S ?v3§8CELLA§"dEOi_§S QRST fiPF'EAL IS Fiififi iJ¥\éQER
SECYEQN W35?) G? EQEOTGR VEHICLES ACT R$A1NST._ THE
JUDGMENT ANS AWfisRB EDATED 2833,2605 P§§S$ED i¥\i_ EifiVC
NQ.8637i'2G04 §i\§ FHE FELE QF THE W AQD§T!€3¥\£AL";§i,§D;{:iEi
MEMBER MAST, METRQPGL§'%'AN AREA,
{SCCH~ 8); PARTLY ERLLOWWG THE CLAEM PE"f7§TiC}fKEv.L:"§~'~'O"¥i£.T
GGMPENSfiCF§Q§'~.i 8: FURTEHR SEEKSNG ENH.%¥'\i€VE§¢€E§NT OF.
CQMPEMSATEGN,
ms M:scgLm.Naous was? 'amssxi cégaxmléz
AB£Vi§SS§O¥\E 'mas my, , MANJ–UL:& c:~4:E.LL:2R *&
KESH1%'ANARfi\YANA.JJ.§ {}ELE"';:"§f3ZEQ ?'HEVFGLLOWifV'G.:VVV
Tbcaagh t:}*:e 'r#:.2i*tter Es fisteefl $6? §éd'?fi§SS.§$fi§ by consent sf $13
ieameci aowésse! _2{§::;)éaf'i-ng 6%§'jVvb%5t§*:..:5Edé$."':he mafia! was heard er:
merits a::é§<:iWE?$ acc'$§%7é°E%éVgEy.
2. ‘E’?$%3_ a p;:>eVé% €'”{§_e’d fie ciaémani in MVC Nefi63′}’§20%
on 25:25 cf V%’m§,V§ng§;T, Bangaiere (SS8!-é No.8), seekifig
7._ .efi’§2.a_r1ce5mve::$:fifsompensatim.
– 3i.fF’§fi.§”3V§.KA G3 EH
3
?583 came at a high speed in a rash and negtégent manner and
dashed against her, as a resuit, she sustained injuries. Et is her
fuziher contention that she was Emmedéatety shéfteé to Asha V.£’*~3’a$4::”‘:*..’:.1_f:g
Heme for treatment, where she took treafirnené as an §_zf:”:§sa%E§;.§3f’
haa spent Rs.5G,000;’- {awards medisines, treatrr%.e:fif,:~-é:§>’:é§efia:T:»ée ‘
and nsaséshment eta, §t E5 3230 hag’ cof§ite–:1i§on’i ‘:’i:e;.fc’-sV§*?s§”‘§’%u;asV”«
sufFe:”ed permanent d§sabi§_§ty af§e;t§.?§Vig;”.Vfutu%é capacity.
Yha ciaém petéticzn was cVt>’?1i;*;;§st;#3§f.’3:é;:§”-§Lf’§%§3′:’er’ sf the Qfiefidirzg
vehicie whéée the awfier :f~”:§m%:. }s§ehVic§§_§%fi§%av3.E§%:5é:i ‘iexparte. Afief
assessing thg “:!’r%b:.zr:ai haia that téxe
accident wag E€§§é~ riding of the motefcycie
by its ‘:$i’}’§.’.”§.:v§§fé;E2V§5€§. ‘#§§”Y’*.F3£;’.§%%a”£i€)§’E sf Rs.87.832/~ amder
varéeus kfiléafié am “‘i;-i§_a§’é:”1’1s:.i:”ea’ cf the motorcyaie ta: pay the
samejwitfg %n’é7res § ai.€5% ‘p.é:: Dis-satésfieei with the said quantum
” V’ af c’é::;§§pér;sat§r;sr:, thé %.§§é’i’r%éarzt has presented ihés agspeak.
xlegrned counsei appearing fer the appeiéant
v’e%3;e z’:€es1ti3*’.V’Vé:’;§E:iénded that me Tribtmm éaas net awardefi aay
cem§er.:$’lat_§o:?: icwards E3523 0? Ensome d:.z:%::g ireaimeat and aéss
A $633 future irssome ifiaugh them is sufficient mafieiiaf or: fecerfi ta
2′
/
“:A’r”§i»::’.;’a:*A£e that téae agzpefiant has Emufred sermarzani ééssabiiétai
‘”:3ffest§?”sg hes’ f:..:ta.:¥e eamérig caaaaity. He aiso sorgteraéed that éhe
sampersaaticm awarded by the Tgibunaé under various heads is 3§8£}
on ma Eawe: siée. Hewever, the ieamed ceunsei appearifig fa:
gespandent No.2 sai.:g%3t ta augparf the judgment of $b§…’Ef:=%.§:;:}a%
am conterzdad that tfiere £3 $20 grouraé fear en%’sar’+6;e_é’:§’e:éi:_*V~:’:f__V’1?:§3e”« _
mmperzsatisn and ‘me compensatéore awarééé :§’.2’«~’}’—-»’§’;§”fé.vV’§V’¥”§t§:i.§¥7%&§ ié
31:32 and proper.
Sffhe Tribunai has recordgd a fi§vr3§iigV_§hat t»£r1 §:;v_+A.:;1′<:'.c–%<'$e%V':–.*:*,'4'.*'s.%'=:-é 3"
cine to rash arsé negiigenfi %%;~£V:%A%2g $%'L_:t§f§;£%'j.;'*;r*§4£5'£?':';".*.%§c:%e;Vin questioaw by its
rider. The saicffi findEng"' :ii§as€::1:=, _§37r.~aI1TaAa”i:€:..§i:+:;% éfi:§t§ed far any enhancement of compensation? fine
“?'{%b£ma3 %éa%§:ss§:arded the compensation under varéem heada as
‘ undér; ..
A 1. injury, pain 3; suffering R3. 30,€306f~
H Medicai expenses Rs. 2,833»
3, Loss cf future amenéfies Rs. 25,QGQf~
4: Corsveyance 8: E’i0LiE’%Sh!’:’%€fit Rs. E€},OOG!~
u ; Total Rgs 51,3321″
‘F. The easiéeme as retard cieariy igzdicates that as a yasuit of
the accident, the aggeiiant sasatairzed f:’an%we af bath bess”2es__of tefi
mg agar: fmm me abraséerzs ever we ieft heei and rig%1§§:;r§§.’–.4_:”?-he
agmiiant is shewn to be ageé abcazt 85 yeam.
8. Having Eegaré to téie fast that the a§pf§§§–a;ni A_[$*aé§&2″é&
fraciasm 5? baa bones ef ieft iagy she r{i:}iéi»:ha’:Ve”beé?f:–j§:%$&;?=,§§§EV$§’di«
fee’ a geréad sf S ta 8 weeks. The_§afa§e:;’sh1é. $33? u§:’:i11f*e’;’,i%V;e::%§z;?-.tVir3ie”: cf R$,38,QSQf»~ zmées’
the head–af,§;§g.’:;§}’, %:5%’a:§A§’2v.a:v§ :;§§§€f:;ar§:*;-g…%s’§an the Eewer aide. in any
view, —-u§2zi:e: thés head woL%%d be just and
grapes’: é§;;x”_;or§%:éi§£y:4″§§fe ‘:ie:§;zV%gfince the ccmgensaiéazs unifies” the
h@3;€_§{%fiV}’asz7§:, pa???’ sgwréng ta Rs.-4Q,9fiQ:fi mm RSK3G,§09§*-.
V:’§’%1aaVL’C:};}”s§ §;»é§4éi>~=.s: has awaréed Rs.2,832zi~ under the head z¥zeéécaE
A”s;2;3<§é_;:ée'; I"'-'_x§e:'.T';:;é incééraed to sound 9? ihés figure is Rs,3,5$G;'~.
'¥'%':e5'"avsza.§*'fa?s-§f:§§*' Rs:25,§§6.«i~ tevgaras Essa :3? future amenities. in fife
Rs '=$'G,QGG;'» tmszarés smweyargce am nsuréahmeni age j%.£8§
agéafi. ;€);§'{}§€f §"§3'e"§%'i§ regayé is the facm arid sigcmmsianaes sf €%":e
_Hs_ci:–§3e am there is as aaape fey enhanaament 6% compensaiéafi
under them fzeaés.
sasbstance in the cantenéien 5? the ieamed ceurasei for the agfieééant
in this yegard.
‘H. %n *~.s§ew :2? E319 above cfEscus$%<:23Ati,'i'§:a_a;.:»pe:a% is' 'a§i:;%~4~éa£ in
part awarfiing compensation sf R$.?8,%:C'Q{;'-aT$f 'agéifzgi
The Esta; cempensatiors 93' Rs,?8,§{3Qig sF§é§£.__c&r{;{"§_n€é§éét"é§ 8°16'
pa, from the éate of petitian ti£A¥V—–i%€:e'L_*–déte:_ of diepesitgi Baiance
ammmt after deductmg thé'ai'mc:£Jmf§éiA§eé3§3:%_€¥&ép0$Eteé if any, $§*%ai§
". ;%= < % 4v»
be deposited wit%j§.z;f–«s§_ig%1t;~Jee'k3.':: $;e_'fa;' as sfssbursementgmouni
is concerned, .tE1'€2'c$i§f{é:§i;Ee:r2 gi$;é::z ayzieéfg» .T€ib;L§%%ai is ccnférmed.
Sdf#M
Judge
Sdfé
Tdge
é<;c;':'m;*