The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Shri Kishore R Shan (Huf) on 17 April, 2009

 

£2'? $33 Eilfivii SQIERE' SF   
C}RC°{§IT EEHCE $1? §§*£AR§3§/AB

$5333 '7£HI3 afrem 1'z*rK my Q? fi?RiL L'
mgsgm   * A

TEE §mmr*gLE gm' Jasricggfign   

THE §§0§*§L§ mg J?£jS:if§i'g:§':¥.§JQ§'&1W'fi:f:¥'::*?;.§4§i:E§?§:!§ 
£33m. I'€m§>8.32'2§fl63'    
fig fig: '  %  L

E. 'figs éiemmissimtsar 0%" §1':a:_--~«._V  

Ti§%+:;i;: :_f1::}§}£Z3;:{:}}._€_IV§'{f£éz1. ikjférzfipfiax
{Egg}. €Z'3i1:i}.§-=§_g:2$pit:a},._ z'¥'::r;:E:;~€{ik_;ar Road, Beigaum

"2. T}}€v"§I15'LT(}I{iBfTEi"¥:" JO flécér, Wa_r€£- 3.
{B}; 817%, M; $€shac'I:ai3;A§v5ea%e}

..... fi.??$§;ia§sKT$

V'  - 314:; E-*:;;s'§;ez<:::;-umag '?R"a_§aram Ska}:

» §§vr:1i3?a1*. F331, __N:%paI::i.

H  :5?3i:f}ia$ara€h§§ Advgaeais}

. . .. RES?Ql§§E§T

E"-..V';§'..fl;; "£51553 "mfg 263% 0%' E5? Efictg Efiéfi arigiasg am? sf

 ::§~:°é&1*"{ié..t;eci Q?."§3;,'2§G6 pasgfid in ETQ Eézxx-'32jPa:;3Tf 3068 £32'

'f§".;*f:j éggessmsai Yam §§'9i3«~'Z€?§, p:*a§;'i:'2g to fasraénéxiaéa {E25

V' $1£§;«:~f<t;::z1iia1 qzgesiiagzs 9%' E322; am'; 3392? five agmeai 311$ 36::
.;3Siai€ E32: <;r:r':i€::rs §}8SS€{§ 7%}? ma E'§Z¥¥'§', Efiarggaéarf: in ETA

R034} Pazzjf 2fi§8 (fated {}2Eé3}:2€}G§ c9nf"2xm.i::1g the Qrcier 0f

 "  the }%pp:i§};a'{.€ iiwmmissiemar 23124:": canfirm {ha aréar pasmfii by

$35 imfifimfi 'T33 Gfiigtfif, Véarei $0.1, %'%P?=L



fiThi§ apgssal <::=::-ming an £52: haazfiflg "E§:z;1:g",
I§IANJUHATH.J, éériiverfici the faiiawixxg:    "

JflDGM£§§| 

The Riivezme is in ap3p€a1 %:a%:§1§.g a§g_:i'ii%vfi{§ VV

corzcrzzzrctzni fixadmgs of that  gxzaéssté' ?L}fi;' _;'§.'§é3v é.:é¥;3f3$i§":gV

, me? W 'C as @321 €:o1":V3:1'3.;:.--::'::-- u 1 «?{;mmV7 siege :3
9&1"; man E). f"fl'?:::g_tE$a;* §'9§~--Q{é, Tfifgc $z}.§}s;'§§:5:§_ia.§ 5;:.:%:$*::'<;":§'2s

=:'::§ Eawi arésfi  thié agéggaaé. 33% as h%f§'%."'f7é?i,§}{E€§':
' :3"?  ..'A%&s'§:e%h:é%' ma A§;peEia?;:3 :'%:;ezh:22"éf:;?.e§<; avers {T'fiE"§"%f?C§
  =.E;a:;§:f§%3:g ihat {E16 émtfimst réczfiéveé by $36
" a:§j»:§$;1ésse€ E3 Eiabie {£3 tax in '$13 zsurrtané:
' . 5ass€:$sm$11¥: fiffifijf Wham {E18 £~1SS£i'SSfi€ haé gm:
maintaigzéé my %3{::ei<:s {sf accaum. and E'€'.£1'€§.%'€€§
them amozmts £31: rzasszatfiiigai §@asi$ ami €316
m§3:<:3§1§3iE€ S;e,:35:r;::§ 0%' accagzfiiigzg xfimaziezi :23: E28

;3_p§3iia::a%i€ $0 Ehif a$$€s;'=;€€ as 8.{3{TE"?;E&3é 2:22:33 hag

fiat Ewen refiscieé in big a<:»::o::§1"£:;.,

$/



zié} %£'§:€E%:€:r figs: A§3§;€i§a$é: é§'&;€.E'3;93ti§i::s--   ta

§ag;;§.):"$c::i2:'€£: Ehc weiti 'msrcaniiis rs}:-'s.:i:::§m* V.%§v'éT:§§;€:.:1V?;___;é§:'tsA_

'mg: cauge titie Gf €118 as$::ssn"::::_1§  '~.3:.1.:°d<:*:§;"~a'3 §}{i'F'{fi '

mistake as  the <;:~;;i:frss: ¢ cf' fixes  {::f\z:._i€;r=ii€ figs b

fisgessizzg Q§i<::¢r ::o7n1;§:;3£a:é:)fi'».;0f~ Eiitefisi "1E5:;3:.£

hem} dame GI}. Cé;i3h_ b3.$}'$._ ' M V V ' _'

2' it 313 219i is"; fiigffiviiiffl, '§é1aé:'«-t.l*w"v.$::*»$é:5;;sr:££: is as:
ag:'"icu}J:"a11"i$t 22._n::§_ his iazjzgi x=2a:»::é"'7at:;'ii€1" éiairsé.

:3v-.§.__§€..?3;b_§.;9':";?!§,. pas 3€t;7':"::3?i: aids: Qf assmsmmzzz cafiééégzg :3p3:: E325:

' ,&fs:::es:;¢:e~ {ha tax (312 Em: emzirs iniarfist mcsévaé by him

"§)5?*éE1€ {3~eég€:if§3m€n€ an aififififiiii sf "iiha :;:cq1:.i$é€;?s:>§: fif his; Eazaii

Shfézfiafigizig $2336  § fhf: asgmgsfi fiéfié 23:: a?i§}§%i'38§ %'::::€<;s-Es '€Z§":£

".'3i'_£?);§\,}€§§é:'§".€ iZ3{:mr;3.§sséa::fi§°, 'w.E;.%ch sappaai $333123 3:3 Ex: ::".%§§{"}%%""%.":{'§

'".<:;€:{': ':33: g:'{}:,s;§;;§ ihai figs gfiifiéfifii-'i€Ei £3 T§3iiEi,§§Tfi§§§i§};E;E'}.g §§.2.§*: :€2;€f{?{'3?i%'1"%',§;

.fu:§{*§€:' ::§:::":a3.1'§§..'Es% §§}£'$f{€§Z§ £%,§':{§ i%'§§::'€§(}§":é £3 "E34131 §:£z=§E":s§{: 2;: _§§a};'

EEK: izggx :5"; 333$: {i§3EIi.§"{:': §'§§§ii§.'€.".'§*§EI 2"€{?€E§."€ii{§ 23; Egéazz. .%..:; §t:'2§z:§.:--«s;:.:::23

/,

(V



a.g22%::'§~:;¥; w§':.'%:_'?.%': fizz: {Ea-3g3€:.;*i'::":.t"::':§' i<";<;=E§; this :§1:_&%Ee':3* .§.;2"-.;~*: _:§x:aE

§}{:§{';:'€: $16: z%;:;g}{tE1:s:i€ Tz'i;%}:T:§:é:} w%';ie:t§'.2 a§3;_'2s::a§_ ~._'é_._{§ _';;_'§::_

I"{:jf§CE'.%:LL agaénsi which 3326 §:'€:5;s::€. appsszai  --§7:3<3%§§..  .

.3. 15%' 5 ifzavtt .E":§:a1*{i tizii €_T§"_¥"i'1¢i.",E3{: §' {ark §§:;:;f.,§;'.:"='_.§'§c: pe.%if'%:.§§§£%;[ 

«'5; it ig éhr': case of '€E?:¢ *R€v€z;i1:%_ iiimi t§i§:: é%S§S€iS§Sai;fii

 gm'; ;:;:a_'ima;L::i:;g  £1513 :;:::%:§{)':f,::§fi:~: Esjzzaiez" %'f{:€ Vm£:":;-'sag Casi; "basis.

'§'E1€z*z:§?::>§'€:, fi.';i:;7:s=;i§.:3.%f.:: ['§'r§§2z§;3:':a§,_ @233: as fiat éfigypeiéaitsr

{3€32n::':éiS§£G'13::}$?_wa:=f{ :"m:':'j.:§§'S%ii{ie{iEx; gmzzzézzig €313 méiaf :0 $25?
2a:~:s<:s;$é:-fay «E? is; ~:j2§§ss~';_ bf rgtzaiarmfs that §3§?h{';Ii iifgés: é€iS§§{"ESS{f€

E335? :°§::::§7%2:'é':§ ihif j;3{_z"i::::'.<:$'§:"E:': i::m;2.;;s~$"a2.1*:3, sis/mg ii is 2".-:€§{?3$1iE3i'.§ fig;

  §1i\%/;,é§:;»_ ..:§_1a._§ §:;:=:s'{£{?'::';E;a:* fgfizu", 3136 fax 3.233 K} Em §::2.a.3§.{%. ':33; Efzéziii

V §':ié}§Sa':?:i 'a3*:'A€§i'e:'* ;¥312':(}1:§2ii 9%" <:{,:m§_;$§;3::aiia:z2 .E'€?fI€.';V{':§§ %:)f;' 33%;}: :.12'§.2..;Z::~§'::

32:; §é:<:3':;:s%';¥:%'j_ intaréist. 3:} gezpggfi 'izézs i3'3$%f33 iraé: i'§§S'i$ :'§i§§::=::%;

u;:.+<;§§;_.. E'§«::€ §u{§gjf£1':%3fi"{ «:3? §%i§a::§:'as 3--§:%.gE: {'.':?a:r'i ii: 'I"if'§,§§L

" » ;fi::{;'25*:g2;?§}A§3;aLzz,¥,§; 5;'§£§;§?"§?=.  <:(,::§;%3:.§:§:{};%;}:;e 52;? {;"§{Z€};%E'.§i'

'A ';::%;<i

ii. E?"m'" crssmira, ?;;h::: Efifiafiifiéi {f'ii<2z::::§;€§ fa": £3.22? aggmssf:

$'§2%2'::3.s;§$ §..§"2:'.3;? €22; §.;E'_"£.€ :§"a<.~::i;'.' EEK? s:';::'%::r :§}é£E~i;':'§r'3f§ E3}? iézs

W,



K}:

Asaztfigézig £}fi"1z;:a:', 3:6 ;%ss:.$z:$;£3i§3.g {}§:"§i<:€:f in .i;§:é"

assagsm<:::: E32; .2."ic.2aa.'£; m6I}ii::I:€ii""é%:fef=. »$Vj«;.<;;é::::: ggf'

{»§{"f(3'C¥Ei,€Ti'§ as; mercantile $§TSt€$a Ei.§3¥*§€iVE'}§_:' ii;-, %i1;6"':3<3€ij§I'--._g3f=£36

s:§1"{3{"3I', he Ems wmgzgiy m%:;:%;'-{;3:€<§, 1513 "if '§Z§1€;iV"'I-AuET:5'%§S§§§Ef_§§i' xx:-;»:::SV 2

nxaizaiaéxzizig the 5:213}: systfimj' jjzgrtéér that, gg/2
véaw sf tghs judgmani    1;; Eéyéié
8%; vs. <:;vfflt«22"S$5:;§:{,g:.é;_V'   A_;vI;;gm
PRADESH {'§f:}E;£._§8}. :=A.;*r§  V 495; and zfiihei"
C0fi}_f1€Ci€d€.#é:§€f:3fg§.,.':;C?{}:fif;'§§*§%'i§  'ii1€€§"€Sf gaajg,-'ab}a {:33 firm
c:0m§ajf;'éV:i$éaiia:=«::ri:5.v_;;1%::%§:"  of {E16 §m%m:% '?m: Act
323$ {ski-3.s:=:"d.i3€ri§V§é;§éf§3.Er: a$s@§s§::r:s1;::.%: fflffif' azzii §E":£~s'~{~";f?:::s§€:§

ifiw "_?;"£fi1z::';-3:EV'2;*aV:'§--. gtgsifiééai is: gr3::%;:§:::g  "§"'€i§§é3§ $53 15%;:

    -----