IN THE', HIGH C()UR'I' op KARNATAKA AT BANGALOREST
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2£)(} £3 ~ _
BEFORE 'N
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSm:E"N;;z§IANQV;{V:V:' 'V
M.F.A.No.1098612055 %
BETWEEN: V'
The Oficnta} Insurance C13." Lt.d..*"" -
Gardcn Area, Shixnoga V ._ 3. . V" ~ u "
By its Bangalore Regional 'Office
Oriental Insurance Co. V
Rsgional Gfiicf: V _ '
No.44/45, Leo
Residency R§c»'fad"' " ,: V" .
Banga1ore--5€3Q (32193
Rep. by ,i.t3--~I")_e pq ':i';'!__23"1).z;>:g:er,:V' " Appeflant
(By Sr; P.B.;2aju, Aéimgatej
1.
'%~sr;'_G.N..Vsu_resfgT~.%
S/o.'*--5E3'ri N afij.u1g&appa
Ageti about years
Rfa: 'f:3.K':.§j~Iosur, Holehonnoor P101311
% _ »31aadrs';vg+;11i Taiuk.
-- S,-'0. 'Sri Praveen Kama:
Aged; Major, Owner of Apsara Bus bearing No.
: " "Km-16-A~8958, Ofiice near has stand
" Chamiagiii.
.. . Respondents
{By Szti V.P.Ku1kar11i, Advocate for R1; R2-Se1’vt:d)
However, this is subject to the condition that in
flilfi case {ha Workman establishes by acceptab3.§i»~.ai’i._
evidence that after the inquiry not only he ”
abie to do the work which he was pe1’fc*j::”fi3i1r1gViV: “-3
before the accident but he is $9: pable _rt<5'{:¥.o: "
other work, the 3033 of eariiiiig Capaéijé§i'Q(5:'§1id._bc.. i
assesstd on the basis of such évrigiéiice." . 2
In the case on hand, cla1'miiiii'iai'§i£ 1_1asiit2ai_l§A§Ci*ii:o iiigtabfish
that hf: is not abic to giiirsue ggainfuii aizocation.
Though ciaimant may not vehicle. thc
p0$Sfl)i]:Vi'i[y éuifi other gainful avocafion
cannot « ifuiegi ouii;' V V .,
_6,_ HaviiI1g_ircgéi1:1 "toijiecu1iar facts and cimumstanccs
"of case of disabiiiiifls as per evidence on
tigge opiniozi that assessment of permanent
vii:-3-3-vis lass of eaniing capacity at ?()"/6
iysrould 'ix? égéppropriate. The othcr aspficts are not in dispute.
A claimant Would. be entitltrd to compensation of
R.%;j.3,10,499/-, rounded off to Rs.3,10,5OG/-. The:
i Commissioner has awardeé interest at 12% per ammm from
the date of accident. The injuiibs suffered by claimant are
11011-schodzlie i;n}z1ries. Therefore, ciaimant is $nfit1¢V_::d,_'»Tto
interest at 12% per annum after one month fivmfiié' _
award.
7. In View of the above, I pass ihe :}j”oi1ow:ii1g:’~= V’ ‘
oRmE2_
The appeal is accepted in éawaxd is
modified. Co111pensatio11_fl’of R:;s;4j_f- awarded by
Commissioner forw_Work1n3n’$V. Com,pe:1;i’satio»11″‘i:-3 reduced to
Rs.3,1(),~SO”0,* ‘at’VVV–i§°A:» per annum from
29.10.2585″ the date of award) till the
date of paé§mé11t[ zfioposit; the i11sm:’a.11ce company has
‘_d€3§f_)’§L3.t€C1_ amouiit’ «i11___r;:Xcess of what has been awarded
_i1=’::1V”éin,j ~ shall be refunded to the insurance
of the award amount shall be transformd
j to “‘C§o:;.§J:nissio12sr for Workmen’s Compensation at
x V’ ‘::o~Shi§3og21v.NO1fice is directed to send back records along with a
–‘ of this order. 3
Sdf-em
3u&§9
SNN