High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri S Ranganath S/O Sigamani vs M/S Megha Travells on 8 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri S Ranganath S/O Sigamani vs M/S Megha Travells on 8 February, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And Gowda


‘ma

I33’ 3’19 .%’1.:(T.LL_'{111c1’1I zmd e1\-va1″d._ ihcr ‘l”:’i}’)t:-mill I”:z5-is

eL\m1′(‘iL-=:c:i 21 5-;ur1’1 of Rs. 1.18.000/– L111dcr (fi!”I.’§.’T’l.”4(“,’.lV3′:I” j;I3€§;é:i'(IS

xviih iIHt’l'(‘.’§1 2.-1E 89/1VVi1:1’O”1’V1 i’iElT’1..*E’i3[c:-&.* V’

(‘late of dc-rposil as agz:11’I”1.SI 1’j:’f1c.”(‘.il«;.Lim -:11;-;1§i’«-‘_V.I;)§)” Il’iA:>

elppcrlle-int” I01′ a1 s;u1’1’1 of Rs.{3’.O().OOO /—-_ on £:1.’f.””‘._’.T{‘.) l.i’1.’l1 ‘:t’I)[;’.i’.’.}’]Vt.””.

iii} L.1r1’cs s1.1s£.z1i11c-‘(.1 by 1.119 “;:§;3:’»11;11″1r-“‘:1′; I1′;-!f’l’i(%
e=.1(*(.~ic:leni’. I-3<::'11__:_§ ziggffxficiyed ji;1"t'iLgv_i,A'x111c111. and
e1w2_1r(:I. eztppe-*Ifa11'11 f'1a.§:' ..<scc1~:i1"15___._g"
C : 1h :11 3 ('C rm-?1';.~i L ' Th _g'1':) 1[:V2.'f1(i"'i' 'V . am01.1 1 11. ea-1wa1'(i<*d
by that 211 u V
('.£lSL'. are:

v”xIA’hx(‘:’Hi3;)c.sflé.;§;:jAt;.»his..@’;;;i’ii1i11g that he was e:1gcc.i a11_)m.z1:

33 ¥’–:”..e’-11′:-3 .’;:l.’1 ..,t:l’1ct.in”sc’;’ 0!” a(‘c*.ident’, hale .2-mci l”1<-.'a,1f{l'1}-'.

°-\.=v(51*i<i1j:5;i" 2-i"9.¢&Me1<?I"1i1'1is1 in M/s [':It'(fil'€X [llldiraj I,t(I..

V' -..E3¢:1._1}gé:l<jSi=ajf 231.61 c.a_1'ni11g Rs.8,0E3I3/–pm' month. 'l"ha.i. on

19.”iTi.2()_{)E3. fill 2-1.bn1.:1 01.30 p.m.. {he etppcile-11’1i’ was

V”‘:_1’2=1\I(:r1li1:g in 221. molol”(‘:y<?Ic bc%z:11'i1'1g R<32gisE:'z11"i<")11 N.KA~

, ‘Q%’1>XAi4l.}7 on Tl.iIT1}iE.l1’ mad. NH4. whcrrl lT1c:- 1’c2.1(?heci

* -»Sf!i\-‘&1 ‘l'(:1’npI<: 131:9 Stop. at'. that time. 1119 (mx.-'or i’1:}’1(‘

3&.lI1I’.l'() Cal’ i:)ee11’i1’1g I{c%gisi1’211:_i(‘)1’1 No.KA–(J3~MI-$2588.

Jw/ff,»

‘../I

l’1ca(‘ls w1’1h i111.c’=1″vst”aE’ 8% p.2;-1.. f1′<')m lhc. c.i;§=1E.(' :11′ 2-u’1<:'} 2'1war(l. the zlppcllzzlll 11215 1_)l"('§fiL'_iiEC;(i–'{~]"1ui"fj

appeal. seeki1"1g m1I'1a11mcnt’ of (:<)rnpensat'i.i'r.n. V l

4. V\/c 1’1ave 1’10211’d the 1c*.21’1911ed c()i;m:sC1 ._:c’.v’l}3.!}~QE’il:iV}{‘1Q;’

for appCile11’1t.. 102-1n1c(‘I (::()1.11′”1scl ‘eippea1’i1’1gIL i'()’1″ “5»’e €.*()’i”‘1<i

1'€'.s'p()1'1(!(:'1}IwI1'}sL11'aI'1ce C<)111p'é3?1';.1y* and §;"~:.1Iic'–i1'11"i;§1..ag1'1 ("he

g11'<)1_.1 1'1(.1.<~'s a11{'gc%ci in 1"ht-'v i_1"1'~::%_111(J_1'*a11'1g§1111.111.,r3'i~7.;1ppca1.

5. AI’t.gr. 2.1v2u11a.!31e on
file at ‘*1″mp1:;:{1″1(rcl ‘j u(‘1gmc1’1I:

zcmd zi1\f€é§1t’5(f!”g;.;».§vEs§%c-:51by it C1’11&’1’g_§(‘5-; 1.112-1:. 011
2:1<'.-<*.c)L.11'{1'.,M.1_I:1c– by the appe=.IIeT11'11. in

IP16" 21'14£'€.v'icic;r11 '1":,./is :".<:i'7(*1'1*c1′”ab<)V(:. he has I.a1li(?1"1 I: 1'c:'241m1c-_r1"1i'.

'=.;:1s"i.1'"iVp2§sjiVi(:r":In for &;iV.W}'4)'(il'i(_)C} of 14 Clays in {he I'ms}.)iIz.11.

._;1'i:dc?1"<.v§%::1«1':" St:_1fggé:r:"y, i1np1a.1'1t.s have.'-é bc:<:2n il'1f:5(;'I'1(.'(i. O11

21'1("it<;.11..11:1_.- (..*f :'.v'I'.A1'1(" i1'1j1I1'ic.*..s S1.l.'5I'i–til'1(,'C! by him. hair has

" V"::u1f'i'é21":9(.=1._. 'per1%11211'1e1'1i c.iis21bility. '1'hc'* PW2. l.,)0<'1o1' Ilaes

{he <ii5s2;1biIiijy at 30% to the Ieft. Ieg 211m! at !()'?/n

V. ..E_r..fz: Ehv whole b0('l_v. (Inc: 11:) wi'1i('rh, ap;')c1le'_111'i we-1110.3

Iimping. he ca1"1nr)1 sit (,',!'()SS(i?d leg; and sst:2.11"1ci for long;

jg

'1'}"1m'(*!'()i'C., is-skilzg 2–s!l'1.hcs(' fa1('E'(..)rs i1"1i() cwllsidcralion. \K='('

2s\\='z11'£i 21 s1..111'1 of Rs.70.000/– 1.1 :"'1(i1c;=r Ihi;-3 l'1Ce1('! i1':;~ai'(=*e1<1 of

R.$.b'().0{)0/ – EEi.\'VE-l1'd€d by the 'l'1*ibunal.

7. The ‘l’ribu1’1al has z.1w21;'(:1c(1 2’1. sz13 _:’1″1a of’

Rs. 1 ().()00/– E()w211′(is loss (.)fir1(.:011’1€= d1..s1″in_;g t_1j:'(r’–fjg;;1f_i_§>€i§__<.3f.

I1'1:1T1e.u”1<':c=%d. Ii ('oulci be seen froiig i',}'1f'3.1f(f('T(§'1fd .1 i"1'21I';=lT)(_)(%v£§:s.!5

112-155 2.1d\.-'ised Eaecii resi. fol' e'.1»'p;j1'iod"Q_i'"i.h1fcc.:.1 4..VVt,he .C,’c.1ti_.i£’i<:ai:e isssueci

by the " ':';’19c’. ss1.eni1’1.€_;§ that the’

;11′)pcl}§.;1″1E”– ‘\.v:1S’ ‘}.9.03.2OOS to 15.06.2003

and as ;’){::–i_ VEZ.x.P.l’ .._2:;ir_\;’ ot::”‘:.i1″i(r’¢11t3. he was ci1’a\.vi11-3.:
11’1cj._§gi'(.;ss séiiaw of Rs.8.063/-. ‘l’hc..=rcf()1’c’?. lakirzg all

.fi”‘H’:’Scr 1′;-x:j’1<)u1':':s~.i1'1{() (*(.)1'1sicie1'z:11ion. we a.wa..rci 2:1 sum of

t<.)wa1*<"is; I(')ss of i1121c,i c)f”Rs.10.000/~ awardeci by Em?’l’1’ib1.ma!..

8j”‘1’I”1e* ‘l”1’ib1.m2,1i 11215 erreci in a\vz11′(ii1’1g.-__2; at 921111 of

7.,15{‘s–. ‘l().(‘}(}O/ — 1’.owz.1rc1s loss of ‘c11nm’1i:ies. The s-uaid

:’1sa11011 21\var<,ie%(.i by I119 "1"rib1.m21l is jt12'1c:lec;11az'.c

J