_.:'Ȥ> _. 4
w. P. No. 1709/ 2008
IN THE HiGH COURT 0? KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 13th my 01»? NOVEMBER.
BEFORE _ T. .'
THE HOWBLE :31: JUSTICE gig, :3;siA1gf1'*:a;'r'a3§?3{:I'S§é«:;¢e¢xV
wmr PETETIGN No.1?{)§1 2&8' ~.
BETWEEN: A' " . .
Sri. Eiavis Josef',
S/o.P'D..Jose:,
Aged abeut 39 years,
Rfa.Pamki<ara11 H0216,
P.G.Ka}ai Road,
C'-helakkara via Txiéhjxr, H
Kerala. .E.P'E'I'IT§ONEf3
(B); 311.9.
AND; '
1. Syndigggaie _ . V'
_. ., b<I..:ij,é<.c§3:fpfii{;:: at Manipal 55
[0116 of its Branches
-A Kankmfxgdy in
' 3§s§9:1'gaI0m city,
V 2%?-:§pv...E3y?'its Pr}. Gflficar
-. éfljhiaf Manager,
-- . uSri_.Ti",i.D'S<::uza,
. ,' s.Pv!anga1re Auto fisgencies,
A. firm, Sri ffigmplcx,
Bytsqaass Raad,
Kankaxzadjgg
§v'Ia:r:gaic;re»S'?§ C492,
$1'
Rep. by its PE11'1,I'1t".1'E-3.
Petiuoiiei" and
Resp()11dem'S 2 ('Ex 4 1.0 7.
C .'I'. S:;1njee\i-"a:._
S/0.C.'l'.Naii'._
Aged 31 year's.
Cheratuu House.
P11then(t.hira Estate,
Triehur.
M . R£1j€1'id1'aI'J .
S / 0.M.V.Shwai'iathai1 Nair.
Aged 44 years.
Usha Villa. Oda.nur..
Dist: Parli, Palghat.
Prakash Rail.
S / 0.Mahalinga R213' V
Aged 34 years, _
Te j asvi J . B.L0_h0'--
Kottara Chowki. V
Manga10re_j(_3.
. T.A.Jo_10
S/0.'F.V.A'1i«t.i1011y, ' _
Aged 33 yeais, " "
Thoiath House:
_ Post: .E}§raV11a.akka1V;' T_1V'iV(7hL11"'. Dist.
.. M.1u;o~e,e." _
/C1. I?('r:11t_z--8_é; , AV
Aged 38 é:";,«'3';js, . ' V .
Méllaiikuiiill liiiI'<;;i':.:s§._ Post: Ka11ja.r1y._
_ 'l'ric1h"ur IZ)__i.s'1
., L06 Seweci. & LinrepresenE.ed)
WE-'.1\§0.l709/2008
. . [RES PON D ENTS
i ii Tlqizié Writ Petnion is fiied Lmder Artmiess 226 and 227 of the
_Ce'nSf,.i.iutic)n of India, praying to quash {he order <:1t..21.1 1.200? on
:I.A.V_1:Vin O.S.N0.358/2004 passed by the learned I1 Adcil. Civil
Judge {Sr.Dn), ME1I1gE1}O1'€. D.K, vide AIi11~A 81 Consequently. allow
ii " "r.A.VI by z1110w'i1'1g this writ petiiion and etc.
W.I3.1\§(). 1709/2008
This Writ Petii.E.on coming on for ()1'dt'E'S. this day. the Court
made the l"o1}owiiig:-
ORDER
The petitioiier/Delendeim. No.3 in O.S.No.358/_$G04VV’.o_§i§’
{He 01′ ll Adciitioria} Civil Judge (Senior Divisiori).
is before this Court praying for qLi§E1Shi_1.’1g’;i:h€’:”(}If_d€i’x__dé1fi.C?€.
21.11.2009 passed on i.A.No.V1; in “above[,..fsa:id
A’nr1exu1’e=A.
2. Though the 13et’:ii;io:1 “‘i«.=5 1i.’_ete,d. “fe1jV.oi”Ciers with regard to
deletion of Respondent. No.7’.H_ –‘Ie.2iri7{oevriFeounsel for the
petitioner for*i’imi1iC1iispoS§t1.
3. The brief fad. leading to the filing of the writ,
petition iiidy be 31.22:-.50.. 21$. 1.iI”:_dei’7f
The R:’Ci’A:’>.}.)()IA.”1d(*)11″‘[. No..1/Syndicate Bank has filed 21 suit
ag;e1ii’is;_1.””1.\(_I,1sV’.’PJi31,igai'(3Fe Auto Agencies and 6 others for 1’eeove:”y of
iiioney. Tiler»__Eiei7;>£ici23iI1i.s; iiied an 21pp}iea’t’.iori I.A.No.\-fl under Order
.R’ii_}e 1″?’ i’ead with Section 151 oi’ C.P.C {A1’mexi1re~D) in the
” suit, ‘seéekiiig pe1’misssi.on to 1’e~open the ease and reeaii P.W.l for
T i_.:he.Mp-u1’pc)se of fiu:i.he1* eross~examiiiai.ion.. The appiieaiion was
b’a3I’i1I1(%X€d with memorzmdum oi’ fae1.s. Respondeiit No. I /Batik filed
W.P.N0. 1709/2008
Objection. The Triai Court :’e_je<ttecl the 2-1p;.)lieati0n. There£'01'e the
petitioiier before this Court pretyirigg for qtiasliirig i1n;;)t1gi1e:(i'"order
at An riexure 'AI
4. On 04.02.2008. the learned single Jt1C1ge_e’i7…t.l1:i_$}” 0.C_o=..irt._
while issuirig notice 1’egarclir1.g rule… di1reei’.eci’ the “‘Fria_l”Cr)_ti’rt:h te
permit the petitioner to c1f0ss~«exani.ir_1e P.W. l2’–sL1b}’c2el:jf12C:>”the ‘result’-..
of the writ petition. On IE{.§=,’iv}5VC)11Cl6I1l’.V
No.1/piainmr/Bank has beei1~..,_;1tiiy<5é.r»§é:jt1 Vmh R.i5.'A.r5. R.P.A.D
acknowledgenient is available in -[the 01"eesird5.0"– 'iii the eauseulist;
it is stated that the':l§eepoiider1t_:}Nc».V0151;,'uunéaerved. In spite of
sewiee of i1c)t'.i::ee :_'Qi1"""'RespQnder1t"_'l".§0..;l/Beiiik. there is no
1'€pI'€S€I1.l,E1l:iit)I1. it
5. l,e21rrs*ecl »eot”ms”eI2′ .l’oi=- the petitioner submits that in
pu1’s1,1a’r1(>,eOf,the iiiflieriiit oider made on 04.02.2008, P.’vV.1 was
v’1″€’._CE1iiC«d’tl1″?d.:Ct’OS’S~§Xa1:’I1i1’l€Ct anti now. the suit has been set: down
for z.1’rgume&i1 t-<5' .0 it
6. it v1vot1}’el meet. the ends of jttsttiee to impose Costs of
1..:(J00_/3 ztiicl allow the writ petition.
in the result, the writ: petitiorl is alloweci and the
ifrietigned order daterl 2l.il.2007 made on 1.A.l\l0.V1 in
Efxwwfl/,.. –