High Court Karnataka High Court

Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Sukesh @ Narayanaswamy on 27 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Sukesh @ Narayanaswamy on 27 January, 2009
Author: C.R.Kumaraswamy


E

IN THE HIGH CQURT 0;? KARNATAKA AT m§%:s;:3A:;e1§E,}[ ” ~ x

DATED THIS THE 27% DAY <5}? M AEfsf'L:?;«'e;,I§"«.'. Ef 2::§:;:<:g%%%%__A

BEFGFZE

THE HONBLE Mkmjswrcgefi: R§g:Lm§A;éASwAMY

MISC-ELLANEZOUS F-'IR$'£f' }'3S;i?Pl§}A£g_ :~§€;~;..1§§23_ 0? 200? {we}

BETWEEN:

(}:*i<az1ta1£11su_r%:;11<:éé"(3<;.., Lt::'1:,_,
By its , V.

Ns::.~.:2{), Ja}ahzaJii-.iC2=;§0ss H ‘-
{311<1kk3.sé1f1<ii3.3;i;i:? 'T: " '=_
Bangaiirres-V568-"{¥5_f";% " _

Policy N£;:,20.{33

Valid §1:'0::r-2.5.(}2"{o"'}.A;5,{3;3

(II}Sumj1' Gf ()3 B3'"5'?'82}

'V " 2:3 vE§eg':$:d31"'Ofiice
r. NG.v<–'H»~~4;3 , Lctg' 'Shopping Complex
'Resid'€:1c§;'t_AV}20é;d Cmss

B'arnga lo:*e 5o*~a:)"t:2§ %
33;; 11:3 Regogzggijmanager APPELLANT

' {,8}; Sri': ,I§E3-.Aru:1 Pozanappa, Adv}

K __ Suk:/ssh (Q; Naxajgsanaswanzy

S / 0 Subbaiah

Aged abeut 2% years
N0203, II Black, G.K.V.K.

Bangaiare — 560 055.

C’/’

sustaimzd grievtyus injmries to hand and fiactziré M

leg and either i;1j:,1ries 1:0 ali over

he was sfxiftsaci :0 Govemment’ A”Bag»€})afli,«. ”

firs? aid was given and then VI*1g*:._§;-{:15 s1″}ii’?3;=L§Ci’

Hctzspital and then to x:::cr;;:~:a.;#£é;s;§i:§:;F%.Banga1:u~e§

6. Respgitxcienti . _ Cmmpaxzy
has C€:I1tenc1h_ed§*–ii;1 :§ $u{1ii;c¥er:

‘F1fi§.%_ petition are: all
c§enic3d. ; It ._th<é Vehicle in q1.1€st.io11 was
izzsured

.. 'F136' "_§301:1n1issioz1er for WOTl§I1€fl'S

V"._V(3€;::1'i§)<:1";s;ati<:;i§"'* after considexing the eviéence ef PWL

$16 PW? ~– Doctor and alga taking the

j1c1aini:'¢az3tV"'V.i:1§:£'§111e as Rs.3,£)U@/4 per mantlz and taking

x V' 'Egg #5 20 years and applying the relevant fa-'::tm'

aiad assessing disability at 80% has awarded

'V V _ '4 '''V;<:;(§:i1m;1sati9r1 ofRs.3,§32,560/—.

(Z,-V

W-.3

Easpifai with surgery on (R) leg with iII1};1 l.:'§I}tSV,: V'

He was acivised abselute rs?-u:.a;1f1d _'i?j§lG§i';V 1.1:';

after six weeks and was on ffiilaw gig: V

I gubmit that on";;f;:*32*~…;'ecéfitV

z'adiGlc:g'ca} exazninaticxrl 1 0'? Q I
faund the faflowiziig"disaj§il§§€§§_;\
E326: lici are _ . . _.

C,aI;’t:.§§iaS€ ~ 2 VV ”

$3 .(i;}__§%i§’_§fji V ” V “” H

\E”.ali%:jS;”1%’iti:3 a. Iiiéfim

:43-1″?-‘~>-*:-*

T€;:a;fsM.f’.t: wéfik Fasicr aliélftzzi,
§}i.f:’ic1 zB?,j.;*L. V3it..gvii’:}sS leg and to squat.
‘*13::’fic:::;:.~y”;n fiiinbizig stairs

T433?’

Sli02*t§é:t1ii1g’V(>f (R) lag by 1.5 cm

– wg,szing%(r2) leg by 3 ems.

‘ Scar overzthe (R) knae of 6

‘ ”C1I}$’eiii’;<:i ¥:3i?€I' tha ankie <3? 4 ems.

"I'e§'i1de:*;3ess *a:i£"11 irregular thickeflizlg of
TL (R.]'v}.€;g

' . Z;2. Ragga sf Mavemantsz

Right knee — 130
At ankie —- LiII13i'iT8.f.iG1Ti ef temzinal }ZI1(}V€£I1€}f1iS

Muscles Pawm' – G4
@/