Karnataka High Court
Sri V Suresh vs Sri Ranganath on 21 October, 2008
as *mg WEE»: z._:§*§# {:39 §{ARNATA.¥ TEES TEFE <2 :5: my 0? O{??(}E3;§2.J§;..f3éT§{}8«.A T A; "
333023
'1'}£iE: E~§{}N'BT§,.E MR. J{;sT:<:£::~,3.s:%%g§,E:i:s::\,:;;§::?:¢1};%
293%.. 3:60. 41:32 £§2m:§1 %' 1
BETWEER': n ' %
Sri '*J.$1.:resh, '
Agad abeut 2§.y::ar _§:, _ 1: , V u _ V_
8/53 ism 8.R1.4..'s;T:e1*13:%%;:59_;_z?;am;.:s;€::. §}@z_§:§j;1, V
Rgat, :"§*'-E1 Crcissg'.*é%'§;§é§;ya:Lak'$§*::i1§V..
La}:'O':,§I'., TSa;g:~"i?:é1: §:1;r.r;%;;e_ '%?%}1iig€'," V
T E}asa:"a}1a};ii, %3_a:1g;a1o_r';§,i{}31}; of E3.
1_§'§4,5§{)/~. The appzzailamt. aggrievaii 13}; {ha qmanium 5:'
M.)
(83; Sri M. £r:.m P{>mi1a§}:2a, Zaé:%.2T. fa; E 2}
T%EE$ E»iP§% E'§i;E.§} ii-',5$ §.'}'3§f£} *3? %~é§'\/' ACT :§{I'n%§§'€S'§" "§'§§'E; z}£?§I':{§?£§§33';~§'T V' 4_
EQEEE Awéfifi E§§sj'FED: ?',S,§€@§ PASSES EFAE §\s§¥{3 3&3; $v§59,5§i%0{§'l'¥[{.>§}é '§'§~~§§i--.V ''
ETELE C3?' TEE fiififih, JESSE} Cifiifg"? €}F;~E3§'%'§$:L§.« 3'§§§?Z§%f:%7é§*L'%?..
?%flC'§X %'v§E"§'R{}PQLETEfi;§~§ FEZQEA, §'=£;%'§'®?r§AE,;L 4' .U§\§E'§7;
§SCC?:f'§,'=3€3.2§}5 PAYFLY ;%LL{}¥s'§§§G T33 :"$f3'l§g§>;§E¥§' §3§l'§'E"'§" E*'?:T3Z%f
C€T}E*«e€PE;NS11':TiQN ENE} Sggiiéiéii} §NE§1%,E*§CE%«% }3{I'€T~iI}F CG§sé'?,§i3'¥S§;3E'E{,'.§€;~..
'raga swag; csjraisxm my 9:32 {fiE?§§3ERS;' TEES D23, ...:i:i:;1§§3:= . %'
BELEVERES TEE} §'c>:,LL3%;::;~E@: .
iggn G,m"§%;g4
This appeai is " .AA_'§};f.;*:§zz1a:1: seeiiérzg
enhancement fif'
Briaf ' .:8f€'.:;3§'; §'O§G¥VS:
2. appeiiamt was {:E'{}S§
§aI1ga10f'e--'i':.N::i;I«:§:i*~.»2% Makaéi E3223 stamcig 3 {:39
bear*i::;g_v regiéméfiar: Nz3. 'ii}*fIEG 1818 331116 in a rash 322:1
ec1a'i:;:i";7:V% in MVC N0.8§$C%g2{}€}5 gaaéiézzg
,-4,-E :'/4
cazzzpfinsatian awardefi by the Txibzznai .¥za$ p1**a:;f<::§',::~:.s;§' €:iE'j:§?s;.é
agpeal far enhancemam of Gf..)I}fip€fiS8;t1QI3. .
4». As "$§"i€I'€ is no :iispLz€e-.___r€ga1L:°§:§i§:g '§:€3{3'%u'éy:4_ §njj'§;1:'§::3"'L,
sustaimed by the appefiam. in :;*1§}:3r f?o;:1fi"a1cci¢§fie:<1t am}.
{ha iiahflitjgs sf {he EHSti1*:~1if1ca'é.C,:3::'§.s' '%=§.%£f;ei.5;eIVj' cemperzsafaiaiz
awarded by _ I316: 1:?_3u$: zgzim gape? 35;? is C335; fez'
e:1i1311Ce:x:;¢n€:. ' 1' '
$. AfYZé1'.._ /fm:a14i.ng ""l§a;3f}}1ed $012336} far {he npazfcies,
perL;$3.;ifigL..tk1€.V }¥_»:ad;._Vg"fi1€I?fi:'i C;f the Tribunai, 1 am 8:' ma view
V. lfiezfipgnsaflfin awardeai T9}: the Tribune} is €;1*1 the::
%1 {:as,:s,i¢«_;_5si{11é"'¢{~rajs;, Ex.
? 26* PW' 2 D3: G. Gopaiakqisima in big evizzirmstii has
%
he cauié ilfiiiiifilifi 1:0 mm! am his wsrk ---.si€3§i'§é _
capaczfg arid strangth and he £S £0 $;£1};{'8}f*§{}S$ 2:: $2.33 "
fuiure ear£'1iI}g$ at ieast to the '.._gx¥g¢:3£ 6:5. {i§§€§*3E>§1§§E§s5 E256:
$ufi'€:'s. Ef 15% G3" di$abiZityV.::a:..:se€§" .f: é"§he 1
fmmd :8 be on higher side for""§§3%: §:1rp%{;s;é"'ef;5§;* é§kir:g (.2132:
{km futzjm £033 {sf incizsgxie, «..'~.';?:':~,-:(3 " ef V%:£i$a.?3fiii}?
caused to ma p<a{'E1<:L2£ar}:\§3:z1n ?)u'3"t€i}:{€¥Ii'--é§EZ~. m_S:§;31EKy atzmssd
1:3 313 whole bQ§:§;'.!8;_fld }{3s§£i§7.i:3;cé;:§§e can ha-2 *em:*Ee:s:{§
Gut. The e:=E_Narfi}§.?adV _fa;.f;1zr€: 1059 G?' §ncm:=;:e
on the §'*o1ii:;»:£ 'T.1:}::'5a%: {%"1£:, has as: exanzézicfi %}::{*:
decml' fI'€§ii§ K t§;a;s:'iaka :fi"s'::*éa1:mez:i, T336 ap;}:;:':3;a;3€:
hag exémizgéd . G,4'4VV"Tv{;§%t;e§§a}ak:"is%1:1a an 9:-*:"{E"§G;::»9.e1§%s '$0 }€s.56,1G%/- (10% of £133,213) /- rm 2%
X }Q;'"§._? Gfiaer respects {ha awarci af 311$ T?§bfi£33}
. :*eI11ai::€d___ i- undisturbed. Tm: appeilant i$ antified fag'
enhaxacfid camgensatierz of RS. 56, 180/» 2*Q":_.:§*f;'{%:':?:%_'
R:~3.$6,{}{}G/ - with interest at 6% j;)¥.§'if>v23'.jZ1E}'in};'?';I}ii:";§".:t.'3fif;'§"§; 'i'fi;:';€ ' " =
of petition $111316 date of acmai u _ é V
8. Accordingiy £316 appaai. ._g}}0§?i?§:(i The ,
award of the Tribmfzai is fa. a:%te:1t.. 'F%1:::
respondent Insuraz1€eV{17§§:i:1;pa5;:3§i'_>"d=i;;§{:?¢d E10 {R-:peSii:. EEK:
Cempemsafian 8.I§3.{}i1fl{:,-%i?ié1f§:”‘ v_ Ewe :n:>z?£,%1s
fmm the dam
Na’ _o_:j:%é:*._é;Is5 a;:<;$'i£;:*-V. " "
sal-
Tudqe