High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Flemingo Duty Free Shops Pvt … vs The State Of Karnataka on 22 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M/S Flemingo Duty Free Shops Pvt … vs The State Of Karnataka on 22 July, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy


= ‘§2:§s;3_ a,::VV

EN THE }{£«:}B’ €L’.{)U”£.’E’ (3? KARE”~$:XE’;’%.K_A ATE’ E=;’g;P%Gz’3g§,,{)RE
DATED THIS THE 6223″ DAY 0? .fUfE;”{, :2€}f_)§*–:

BEFQRE:

THE I~§OT:-§’BL§~i MR. 3U$*r1c§: Exféézfxgixfi}”iB’x{§§§;§1?.:§D§§’*z’ L

WRIT E”E”iTE’I€}}:~E No. 2 629§£:*§%2éa? <t3é%i::-i<:E:=s}

BETWE.E1\§:

Psrifs. fflemifigu 33;?” .F?6§i4.S::fx’1§{§§v ‘Li:.§
A Comp&£1§<' i'::+3éi:';;§:f1;;*z;tt::i"u;:;1:::ie}* the
pI't')V§Si;;;$tiS ..’23.::¢
TTS Endugtrégi A:%;s_:$.;_, ..L}¢iIE}€:,’_ ‘ftirbize,
Navi Mumbzaiw-93$ ‘?{i:3;. ‘

“B3.::: g.a£o:’: Entazfzgatfisnai Airpcxrt

V’ 8.317% fg:4:ii;::§¥-5.§§{‘{{}’*§ 7.

V -V zineéxk RF.”

.f..{By–Ifizifzglztdzzs Lam»; Asivmzaims}

“Rejir¢séixté;_d_ ité:

Lsmgaiionv Pviargager,

. PE)TET§{}}’-§ER

%

VV V This Siaie sgffianiaéaka,

Regregented §j; the Cen:;”:3i§e;f,
‘§::§m’£§§1c:z§ vi’ Lazgai E*>:i<;*%§*£§§<3;g§s3

Z

Gewsrnmcni. sf Kamaiaka,

Na}, Ali Asiszar Read,
?.B.N(:+.1'?53 Bangaiorc~52.

The Insg:>;::c:{0r Q? Lcgai 1’\:ie:imir.;gy:,
HAL Sub-Dix:isien, K.R.Puram, ‘
Bzmga§z.>rc-36. _

F»)

.2

3. This Assislani Cunirulier uf Légzfi”§’v?.2irui&.zgg_g?;’T
End (L-ircie Carporation Eui}di.:–~.–~’?.,. ” —

13′ Float, Minerva. Cii*<;i"<;;–% '_ V
Diagofiai Read? V,'v'CP1é£'a_::";, =
Bangalore-4. _ '

RESPGTQENTS.

{By.Shi4i’; }_””iéi.vI’;:*if’IvVi¥i3E:!:’t’i’fiV.,’,”!3?.{}:r;.§ifi{§§§é1i Adm-tzaic G-sncrzeglf}

=itz;¥=%-=?Hé<
5 'Tigis '\}$i'z"i..i,V I3"c;ii'iiuii iasviwiiesai magic: A.r:.ie:ie:~: .1225 and 2'27 iii' ihs
€3Q::':fi::iE::_ti0:; sf ' praying declare that {he Standards: sf

'V"'We§'ghi§Lgr1{i~i}.fir:s1:sz:z'cs Ami, £9733, Eht: Siandards uf Weights and

—{E11f0reemer;t.} Act, 393$, and the Packagad
Ci;§m?:10d.i’ii€;s R5133, 397?} s3;e:a3ing with %m;”;<*:rtec£ g;":::::;§:i: are mt

ap;;§iVsaEE3;'iei._¥}§c guards uf Ehc pc§iii<;m$r Ezvmugizi iirum afireaé mid
said at ~..i*.':s 'é'i:'{j; fies shag iocatsé 33 {E16 Emernatiszxai diepartum

ierzzzizéagi Ac}? EEK: Bagzgahms Eaiamaiiunai Aiypari & wig',

AA * This peiiéiun %1m-ling §3f.'3€:¥§ hctami 2:23;} rsscwcii :21: §'}'.é'2';{}Q£3
éggzéti caming, 9:: fa: §r£:z2s':::;c¢:':":e;§1.: sf arfiera 'this day, '$13 C9233':
.. _;ie§§w§<:{§ fin: i?::.¥Es2wi::g:~

%

GRBER

Heard ihc Czaunsci far 31:: ;:°re'E%i;'§anm"*_' 333$ iE*z:::; §"a.dim¢';:é:: T

Gancrai an émhaifoi' the respgztzaicms,

2. The figciuai backgrmmd _i_s_::_ éé£;~:V_i’:w;2§§_§_;w>; : ”

Thrz pciiiianer iS ‘£:£ £:{is3;f2§3éii1yV”iVi”:{:$u¥i*;’?§,§3’21iI:(i antic! the
Companies A::£,_ i’§f_56. :3; ‘«.g;;33siéia;3§ gf §’v1;’s Fiemingsa
Inifimaizkznai L§fi1.%Vi¥:;a§;1′}}£z§aé,

T §_m –.g21:ii§.iii§:.’é:;r_ §*::’,i:锑-sT;e3i’~u;:s’ “D:;iy–Fr§::s:3 Sfmps” 3: \£.’:§.I”i{.’3L§.’.-2

in£erz1.aii:3z:éi.§ggizgtéorizé :3 §;z.;}:Fa’ This *=.&-*:<,§s vzrzabiczgi by 133$ A§r;::ur§;s

«_ ALn1V§2'a3rii§{ 'e:.A§: §n(§ié%;"'{{§.1r;:.m§,:za§'Eer azaiieei 'AA?' fa? brasziijs} caiiing

£2}:'éerugittvrs'::§'vcg§t2–:;£§uL:i¢ £i5\:'§§}€,}p and espezziis such sirvggzs aé aexrcrai

*..55:irp:,2ri" Eemiaafier z:2£?-zrrcd £0 as 'BEA' fax" Esrcviiy} . "fixt-

EHii'1fi3i§fiRf$};'.:,£éi.I°}I}{}!"§$, ézzazhgaiing Eim Ezmgaiurg §n£cma£iuz;:§E

'i

";,§:::i;§ag:';c:'s parent caympany was 3 3-:§n:m3:at.f:;§ isigizimz file 2&3}

.. iiaii awaraiaé a iiccmss ia fin: year 29534 is; csiabéizgh ami mpsraie

Y';

Bui1:-§rcc: She 3: ai éhc arr} ya? ami £2: ?fiI’i£§§f$ Ecririinais :3? 3:3 zfiifizfi
., E

5

43-

Tim pciiiimzcr is this rmtugniscxi gazbgidiary in is-sans :3? Sat: iicezzzge,

auiixuriscei in Upcraic fizz: sheps.

The pciiiiumzr has uisiaincd a. Eifltilliiti unécr Sec£§z2;1:”:’§’§§{E} mi”

Eizc C-usiums: Aci, $962, in upcraitgz at»: 2: primie: §3f;3!3’£.3l€13£.§ §§§ré:2§i.fb;=;»s§3£;~:;s:er.b

1131′ Lin: siesta *2: cf fiutycis b11>uuhi §'<:n1~2z§§.112ad-"iU Sv<:«E:§''§:_} §ra?nsii' .

in iermaéionai passeagers againsi app§§§x{::(i' .E;E$:*ségt§' i:-L.£t"~?'.(3§'.££:j,% " v

Tim pt:iiEi;mr::r':§ piauzcr ::'§ E;:;s§ncs:§— .iS'=.§2§é:§d%: £56 azirpofi

prcnéisefirg ai i?1t.:Tji:1§e:'§5sa££L}:ia.§ drsparizgm and z::¢"r£va§ icrminafis. Tile
psiiiégrzzfifis «.:~.;§m_§3:~: "a:3:s;~:izQi:§.i_TVT"a;2§:..–~iwu uniis, ans: geiiéngg ;;:;;a.:&.:: is
mziguing, igéiazfizgaviiganai A;;a::;x-sfiégssrs afécf ihay flaws gzasssezd 22:1'; 9531::

suswtgzaaz "§;'::.:-:~.:£° r§'i;.e»_:_;;iE:<;%:" sciiing gmédtz: is §m.:e:s;1:2':i:3g i:1icrI2a§§g::z}22§'

g'as_sc1}.gé2t$3 .§:$%:;:fi3rc éihmy pa:-2:: iiqrrgrugii iha sugéums pvgi, Eézzncfi,

"'i.§1e.T'_=;3;£ig:_§=én_g §§a.s3sengers purcizase éht: gun-£5; after £32125: §1::w<:

6:35-sgsai v_vi§:e:_-fivusizéma Emniiesr am} gush gmxis aw ymi; bmugizi Ema

-~7§t§e§i:::k fizz: imzamizzg pasgsngcss, afiszr iha pzgrcimsz mi’ ggmés,

‘ §..¥?i§,3i.}ri iim game ism; imiia wiltszn §.§x;*:}-5 paszg £’.§1m:2g§”: a§§t::r e§%§a§;2i::*g

V i3§i§3’E:i}’::iI’E£;t? imrn {fie £:£,§.S§L§E11Se a;2§§:e;>ré§ér::s_

Z

\…f’a:

Ii is fixt: §2r{:1i§.iL>z1I::r’s r.:–:a.:~:c Ehai. file ‘1ra.t1:~::».1-::ii::r1f:S__:>,::”€

a

of spcciékd gs-eds and Sttibjtifi-i R: ska; figiigwing ‘E4?’ ‘ ”

‘M-v’

‘d Saie uf gucaeis am xmiy is ini::rn2;§I’é§<.§:i'é§'§
irm'::_i daacummés.

E3} Saie Luigi}; in f£}I”€£gl1C!§{§:CI!(;:§;W

as} is wines in be cz;r:sr:§t;:1″-‘s;*;i’:_-.:’sA’@.§¥%’V’v’ s.3fE’§¢.:-iais.

Li} T?&!13S3CiiL}§§~V,\§* issized {mm Em iéms

by $311: CTz;3£Q_;fg;.: Dé’pzz§i”13i;:n:§;”

it ifix’£§£)’£}.§C:?fI€3E3é”fi1§;!.f’§:!{f’~.§;é3V§,§%’i§i$3 :23′ ihe gyeziéésmcz”, izzsc:-fiat 2%

the ware,—§i£;us’ig1gV§£’_ g£:e>£§s ixuzsgfzé E1211: abmad magi

‘ .,re;j§:;:ii>::hme’n.i :.2i’g:;Q£.§’SAin E316 shag} {rum fits: swaraézuuxe, are 225,. 9.1?

A iimtas s:§j;:«s:ri!is{?z~:1ii_i.’%3§i Efia Cusiegmfi ¢f}§3:’i;:£2:i’:sX The prsiifiiéjncr has :19

ac<:::.:~;s Egg' ¥;f'::3::..'~'g;3;3ds wiiizuui that ksazze: mi' fim {3r.§s£::sms Auéhoréiitg.

_ ii is: suniezzéaai ihai 3:13 zgaiag §}c2:z2 Ehs §}i£§};'-*§§"t':fi ghmpg

iéxa-aim} at {Em arrixaai icrménais :95 EEK: énéamaiéenai airgsegri afti fig}

iht: eeaums £3? irnguri 3:15 am: I};é'§§ Emtai mics es' Saks wiihiii fim

Siaits Bf Kamaiaka, There: is as iémii {.21} i%:::.: fiééififili mi' gsgmig éiéai

Q

6
can be said in cash passenger. This iE,:ri§z:::r cznstzrcs ihai Eh’: gmzgifi

purchased are £1}? salfmcunszampiiuza arid zmi fer …:és~;$aE;:: or

disifibuiiufl. The incoming pyasscngzzr iznpg:~:3¥.s “‘:%:¢”11..j’g-<;u;::%g

pursshassd. _
The sail: in rsspeci of gL:’2:;iz2g._;; £hm:;gE1 rm:

Cuséunis Fr'<;ni§»é;r ~7'iSiz1eié~:«..¢'ihcy _vv<_:uEc.§ haw massed ii §:,'v::§l;:"é:
cnirarring 'E¥:;<:"Baz§y¢i}s;.:§:a:;'i§s;;xg:§;"« "i'"~I::;:;::f{.:4:1<i"'.2a.:§§en 59% is aruimiszg asssn fiarsw smith
, 3 V 5 w a.« p % 2

V' '–v..gm;;:;§:-E' kg-2:.1r€:'v~–£f:1:.: e;m::ii:*?}; wiéimué. E352-inning; pari :2? EL:3<.~: "magg uf

_ gs:-s;g§sT.1£%£i§._E3:§;t'VA' ..i%:#:.+..;:{§LzI1£I:¢" anai Eizuz; ihs imgmri 2-amzué §I}f.:i Saki :9

be ;:é§m§§ei:a§_ 3:5 ii dams; 2m£ cm:-gs ihe Cagséoms horziérazr, {mike

bcéxzg .iaia{:r10:z§ui'iE:r: ¢.:{:«:mir}a

in iizis §a{;§;g2":,2um.§5, ii its: :§§§r::g:;§ iimé am 26.9Z€?€§'?.i§2a

stegzoné r£:::~.;p<.:s:uicr;£ £3 saizi in Ezaw §:§spc;:§se;§ Eire Eizgéfa-«Frag SE29?

HI§§e:aicd 33 {he §3spm"§ur:2: T€:'"§r1:3.2"§:3§ 22%' BEA agzaé Esizrémzé a§§.;'§:E,

3

packages ‘a::ia§z1

int: zmpufler 3 aciurass apart imm mE.z2c:r ra~:q:_s–2u:,mr_;m:.>. ‘¥.iI1€_{:z aha.

Siamsiards mi’ WEE vhis ami Evittasaarits §?2:s.L:’£T<,a'-'r:ai"~ {§ZLxs:iI§im§i§§':;:s"}
a . % _ « , . I

R3335, W77 ihcmixzafiesr rs£}:rr§;§_ ?i'=;–»._::z3 €.i%zév-'E3'2:;;§%;aig;:a:i=€*;;::11:ig3§§£iéiss V

Ruiss', £233" $3?-:vi§:¢*_) azgci ux1dcr..i}A:'u'S'§;:n£i2;r:;§s–v:§;:.z§§::1é’=§?:é;:s.x«:-zvmg gzéiaizxcfi ax;

uilécrigiging ‘frgskrziéxi’ha*: §}e:i§E:§i};2I::”;s: r::g::rv:si::1r;iai.iv& £9 p§”:.2£§:2e_:.z:; iii:

gackagas 2i;i;,__a:;:_§ 2,#:§}m1..r’c<;££Ert:zi ané xxzuuizi bf: migizxtzsi £2; flit:

. _ pé:§£§;»§':§–5_f;1t:r'3 33$: é.'-"li'i£i*£}_(:§:'g".v

' ~. «' -_T§1 c' f§%:-iiiigificr has}; Eizcresafém" ra£:s:::-df éis s§_;k;;a:§§::2ns in wriiing

— ;m¢§ in ysspsaté eff’ the inspcsziiun and afefcrrcé gcizure
“.. §3:£;§1}i§::§ éfiués ai fist: gimp £32 £312 deparium :c:r32:i:ra§ aimiisi zmi %31E:

— §.g1′;;i”i'<;3 58 impuricii ggmés as Eiésy haei n<:t=*t:r %£:.3:r:e» fféifi £3? file
"gzyiasg sf guuég" wii§2§:"s ihc cuunérg. The rz:spm'1rc§c:2i }:a:s%s'mée: has

" igmared iém sams ami passed an €s,»m§r.::z" éaéaé c3.§{,'x2G53? 322$ ha;

5

heid Ehai the gaméis rsferrad in i1e::”::i§§ abmus uughi he Exagér been

afihcd wfilé: <iE:a:I:§r:»3i§L:»z1s uf iizs nzzxne amié aciéircss eff §'§iéi"£%§:-gigégrtcy,

nwnlh am} 5-'ear {J§i£"I1F?L?K'i 21:; wzfii as qzzaniiifx ar':{..§'i_"§1c:'xa:.é,' in'

vimiaiiezl of ii}: ?a;s.:i<_;«.1ge:.*-ii} Cgynunnzéiiiiés' «Rzi–§«e:-52.;;:.;:(§«.;::;V':3{}f<:i':§;é,: 7

azzzcisx firs SWM Aug ami ihn: psiééiiszglicr %.xga::§'.."_;_-,§}ic:(i ':q;§;;~m."':–.g

casmgmzné Q16 Qiiisilc-(as.

E3. is {he ‘ca’.§:?(.)E3t’: a::_ii§:.n Q1′ fi:;i:: “:-:<*.;'.V_1;<_} I'2!*.;iA rcsgymzdeni zazhissil its

sun am to be t.:ha:£e:1 'ed in..iii$'gm$c:j:i %%§%'E§'ii'<§€;.~–
E ._ E A _ 1 A L § V

?l_'§3sAV'{§:3tz5i2'$%;§ iificzj pgiiiégyzlar 3&1':-.:_E3'.r"éEE:;»: f'§:£§<.m7z:a.::

mnisznéis Aavzg lfiiivxafx :"

Tir:3.E i.§1e:V”g«z._>:.3;ig suit} E5}; éhc miiiémnmr aw 2.243% é::2§:;vu=ri<::;§

_V:~:, Ti}; tivefiniiiun mf aha: €$X.§??fiS§$%i}E} "Empmé" in Sssciéun 2{ 3}

géifiigtz' S'§¢"Ei%§:–2§§:§ig figs 2-mus em 51¢ :§siEz2§§i:_§z2 uméaz" St:§:iim: ;?,{?;f%}

Q1' iha {:i::s;i2:§maz Assi. EE2 izziarprséézzg Effie msa.:2é:2g ::»{"%:::§2:3:*E°'°, égm

k%[1~;:

1

.V;:p%::;2w ififmgri ima 7&3: ihgz gags zgf Qzgraéze 35532 233555;: Z,im:?z’g:zf 2:2″

gféziwrz ggfffisfézz, _»’ii§’}f 350:’? SC 33, Egcid iizai fiat: émgxisri 53? ;_.:z,2z,”%a::§:~; zgmagg figs £:E.§i=~3§.{,’§!§§Ei ésirrizzr aézré am

3

‘H;

{‘2
{hm mixifig 13%” E32: gL2£.3¢.§:~; wiiix Eh: mass; getéaxis wiiE1§z1 §E1e._s::a;::1iry.

In ihe cast: on hand, in1g::-uri 0%? gargds is §:0rr:pi:tE§:;”E:§;__£:r.;’§v;~:»1_i

iemzinai, w%::::n E_§:r.=.- §?2:!.’:§S€:flgt3-I” purchaggts fiat: .g;}.ia?z;:zr_–§:s§>:«1:zV:”:;§. cicetzze 3:.

ihmugh cusiazms ané brings; ii irzio £ E-3:

Esrznérzaig i§”xe:- ggayués am newer £’2’rV”:;::§’s;~;§’i_s¢:’7
as {he Quigeing pasxenggzgr f.22I<:; e:3'a:iv…z_§_{7 §inai£3, <:w:1:
befurc £31: 23311:: were c§osa;fr:«c'i_.'£E; :'L..§3%:;*»f;::e

I1 is a:{}I1.§53

br-;>::g§i’&vv iby inc-;§1’sé£:<:g 'pxagaagiigcry -are aaim»; in ihr: cuurgzg oi' .é:np:_3ri
gaai 331;: :1:_rE'*:;’£’7E};fg; <~._t;;3,r.:ni_} .r5«.~_L:i, IQSTE, {Emrz:§nz:§§t_:r E'§i§}:3I'§'€;3€.§ is; 22:;

'3V§Xf§'vi. {E;d§E.2f<:ar§%n.£ni} Ad, 55 " §m"e:x==§§3z'_} fits said Ania 'gppigf E313 iE}§€iI"~

xéégidsaiss 1-:i:'i§;§.iI:§r;:–si3ix: S%§.i*£:é; rmpeciisrsigg me; £5; cigar §i'"§}II: fix:

¥_,P?caI}}§1':&3 1.i&} {hm S'v'sé'§'ei Agi maxi xvii}: Scelégm 3% §;§'§6§'$€.3§ ami

-s

Eran”; a §”%3.i§§§§”‘ sgi Smziimz 33 {six Size Eaéivsz” 351:3: Tiétz aaissg

u :;~;:::i:::§ fin $12: saarse <3? émpmé €31?' sxperi, éizrs; £r2¢r::;a.e:-§§m:;~s gig;

rm: zzu-mséiiuig 333% Eviihén the Séaizz. Efiaziéagmc is; giasegi :32: figs:

rufiing vi' E52: Supreme C'9:22:"i in ;fi3§;i;§5 gfficzrmgiggigzs vs §.fi«:z'1_.~£§.s;*§1,rcg,:' 1'

8

33
ancf Ca), 51′ 99?} :5? SCC.’ 468 – w§”zz::rt3i:: ii wag Eaiai éiuwxa ihegi 111%’,-}”¢§}=”

hmcausa gcographicafiy ‘d sait: iaimzs piace £3 at pdr1§s.:u!.::_:1’= ihsr

naiurc oi’ iht: £ra.r1s:»3.r.:Eiun ti-;3»t-:3 mzé (§{‘:l§2′:§€;-E fmm iégi “£3-.3::;a::”}5z::«.§”£:rT..:a;’::

gait: in ii}: wursa cf impori U?’ r;:x~pri:.-‘ .

it is wnicmicgd ihaé §z1v£_’ A VP:aé:i<;ag:.:;§'

Cummudiiies Ruhr:-3 in regazpcct Qfsoid' :{}'j:5vv'§i'1£2 i',}€ii§§§;€.3I}f:!° is
miscunccivcé as; $115 saié' ';&?*,;.:ie~;~;_, f:;1.z%.m§fi}§{,..»R'¢:§¢ é anei Rain 35

WUu§€.i 31£Ji 3§fpp'§§.{ i:371iE9:c_ cf §,'52@£§§.*i-;31r:e-1" :«.2.:~: §§}€:§ 35336 am: he

a . i§cai £:»1:i'g«:éa:? Vzm1z}::”:é;”é§gi para: §§?ma:§g,;E2 azmiezzzzg £2-auzigi fit éfaréaéaé

17.

V as :m::=::ez%§t::”.;’.”~V

it is*V-Vgszfiiixndmi ifiai fine g£.}{.}£.%–‘:~Z mid E;-‘ Eféé: g:>¢;:i§£§g3::::r'”r.;2rr:

fireughi iggisa ixxiéa ami iiepi. in war V~§wu>;cs zmiitr fizz: CE£..’_~’.§(}£§};’ ami

~. VH’}, _ ‘i 2 4» 1:1 : ; 3 V = 2

..-;::;:1§:fg.2i {xi Czzsiemg 5’-‘:z::m2r2i2es7 ihc p>€:1§§:31f:m” :25 mgi H} a 30:.-;2§;g.:*rn
ii; ashangc Ehfi pa:e.ti»:agi§:g. The grzciiiémécz” flag my £.?{?§1§.’E”{}Z mwsr {he

V mp-aegiaagézgg. rfizc éngésifingza 23:1″ i%1<:: ::2uE§;:3!iiéa:e 'Lu cumpiy xaeéih iéw

6

\_

‘ii

prmtixiens of the Ami am} Ruitzzs wizcn iém 3231:: <i:s§%2ic £122’ –‘£ hi: £5 4_
mm iv #– the cziiiisgzacm vw.}:fi<§ be-'""feve:2ic:.& §;E.*m§':1v'.c:w;rrx-nT
, F I ” é , _ ._ _ ,

beisimzss umim” 3 caymsiani Vi%:z*t:a’£1__ £55 ..’:’+€I:;£§v!.§f’f$ ‘f§}§” ‘g3§”§v€:g::L§

ceénirmaszniigten uf Law.

4. 0:: the s;:i§1<.":*§f1'*.{i.'2::z,z§'»..3:,, Haranailaiéi §.i3:i::
Acixmcaic {3:::1§;g§ 2z;cS:§3:ax§3:1{.§€332i3 £0I§§§I}E_£§§ 5:2»;
5£}§§0':.3.;'S :- T N ' A

avers zarzxigsei by {$25
gyrészzzésgcs Eucaiegi ai SE15; wiiiiiii

the Siajéui "P";'"1;»*::.::§;:,z¢.*,-15*" éefixiemzi 22§;L§:;:r €326: S'%'€'?x;i fiaci §m:.i;is.§e3 a

"'w:a.2V*1t:~I5s.:§»:i;~g%: 'Lg: mihzzr xazhsraz gazsixiis am miaéihzéicéu ii §Eg§§L;2=v:~:

=i.§mi' a1:y..'§3r;t£~p§i:t§;:§;<i azgzmmefléiy rssqaimez {:3 gang: :22}? 22n~::z'§(§2:?:s.'s3'§.~*

zim;.:E§;2.ra£i.g:¥:§s Vr=é=qu§:"e:§ zsncier {Em S'§%ffi.»'E 21$: ami ?2:a:i–;:-ggiigi

4' ' * _ C:::r: gm: ifiémziiziei is

” “pr{3i:;:-:.:£ Eh»: érziemsfi «::§:a. £;{?¥1::Zi§I’!}*’:f§’ wiéiéégé fig: Emit: zaaai azzzjg gsswais

Z

i2

uffsrsd £2.31″ safe ~~ w}1c£hmr inside fine prr:rnis::g’~.g3f vihws }}3Ef’:jL3r’

e§:~;sw}1c::°:: which wuaid .§a§§ wiiizixz” §§’1é”:§¢§31§i:EL2n a>§.p:*'<§z1f:iésv::~; '

wzmizi rcquim Eu cunfissrm kg i.EzVg:.

Ii is £,:{}nif:I1(.§t’:{.§ Ehak lhe E{:§ §::2iI2*.?z1:s:5 an
argument ihat {he I1.”c!illI”*.:?;::’_!;ii i’h€.:–‘_fi éhc cgursa :2?
impart {gr cxpori and xAsL:t:;§a§w-ziigt. Qiiiser ;i.r:¥_e§’-s’;2:§.«:; £31′
inim-stats: net aéémcisd, $29.,
is on :’!::”%ifc’i;VE_V;r;..§’s11ic:sr,:: the gguzig are keughi

ihruughihe s.::,2.si£.§:ti’:;._.ét:V:g§”‘E_;ff;*a par: :2? éhs HEQSS £2? £2: g;w:>&;~; Ehc

£121 ri it; fiV::~§_’ gum ‘§.<::£e,. igfiiaii 9? Exams. This arwunmné may be

«_ rv,:§e:Vf;!e§;zz§V£__t: {Em :;<:§::'§.%.:.%:i;_..as'i' 33:: €fI-La:§::.§m:~; Aazé us" a Saks T2.-.3: Eagw –~

appiiczai ii) figs SWTVE Ac-i ami Pm:-§mr;:s£i<.:» '£§m»'t;:3§cr -~ £33.:

"§§u;£,_a.;§:§ iéiasics sit} {mi ezunészmpizsiu any sxgzgpééezz Q!' i;::s::~:zz"2;%Eé:3§'2

.. _fr:.§m a iiaraiiam it? 3:22; anti ever»? wmig 2%: am; "Mi ef fiat: Sigéc.

– . % ..

This {Ems désiéfiuiiun wugizé ii} be érawzz :35 gmxés sgszéisisée 32¢

Cusimgm; Barricr amei gawés wiihin. £3 an éiizxgaxzgz ami ayiiiésiai

%

c-iasgiiflic-ai§a>n in mspca:-E :35 £21: aggiicaizéiiiéjy’ LE? i§”2::”p;i2x*§:si;>f3;::A ¢;>f,E§1r:;

pciiiienm’ 8131 éé idas my £.iL’!fiil’§}i mxrsr ifzzs :Js1:;i éfrzzit

Iw’: ba pussihvfs far ii is rewpacizfiigét’ceI21:n:ss.§§&£fy’§s 5:2; axcuss iln”
non-ce.Jrnpi§a;na:-c with ih§:._g5£a=i am} I§i.:_z i»:::g_.v_

5. B}; w:»:j,§ (sf rc§ 3§y,_. ugaiiiijmi §<.:{f:* the peliiiwmzr wewid

wgziczséi :

Thai”§}Ie p;1:L:£?§¢<;§§ng:;.«are uzzéier iim SW'I'vE Ac; am-$5 zmi iéza

SW31/I (E':1i3L3:"ar:m:::z'i}. A£:3E:.,__ "7§'§1:: i.r;~.m:s..a:s.:§is..;:: gmi being 2:32 ézzén-i«

siait: £i?:e:3Lr.€;a§iu£z mf ihz: ié§1£}§'} 2%; Bmgaigrra z'%.§z'p<3§§ vmiziii Hui

"1'::':z;4§é;::" riaigzrtz of ii}: irazlgaza:-iim: as ma ézzémmsizm: 33%;-

:i.:'fak§I'iK¥$:&:§£;Z?.£V£§!':f§}.}.?'¢(;?€'§7£Es;§ saics in €32: azezarsa sf imgmri and itxpéjfi. in

r::sp?{é:.:E i'§:–:'é.5 gmuds. The go;}ds déxpiaycgi Er}: fim psiéiiuzwr

«.g:a”;’:Is::.;gi She: sa£b_§z::=..:i maiécr vfzzn §:§im—:f§ais :22″ izzém’-siaés gaia.

ii is Gwfiififléfié €33.51: fin»: zmmig azggai in Smziiun 252%} mi’ ihe

3; I 3

Casimrxzs figci am} Seciiem Eii} 9? $26 S§’%3§:v; fixes: being icisrniécagg

ihs: ca>:2§e;2i§:3;1 ihaé ii was mfg feimrazxi ssrhméizsr fin: azommziéiiéésrzs

5

>..:

M

invuhrcd are mtzani Eur sale in ihc: cuurss: of impézri :.?er».;§«:p1£;.3:=’F. fig’
nui jusiificd. Thfiftt is nuihing in:’i;l?iié.t”?;.:3; in §i’1{iiVi3;;L’£§f:vVE§1éii fiat: 7

fcgigiaiive ézzicni was diffisrcni and ihaivaa é}.£f£Ercnbi Weir; ‘L23

ht: given Eu» {hrs same wards. “§’}ié:L.VVj1;s3gi:eiaiu2*+; {%»z;;+3 fa§§}f avmrr: cf

{hrs inierprsiaiiam 0? £32: t:§<;:".§cs:§i£3nV_:E:};?' §h:: S'~;1pr*::me Cm:r¥. {as sari}!

as in 1963 in R5. The Bi§$ 'i<§VVama;:é "3i'§'z-j*.::V§?:;a 'ifasiems Aci, .33
1' 965 SC 3 'j;1j:sa%§xcnV:'– Aih}: f§§V1\,z'f Ac: zmai SVSEVE
{1'3ni"i)ra;e1nz:1§i}V£5aa£j _ H<:fie2;"'E§*wA_V$am;% inicrpyciaiiofi mzgizé Ea} be

gécepicdiin aha 3b'.3:::'1§;¥éV#:g§L".2;zzfg%§;v..;§:»§"f{*::2"t:r;:.:=;;' ifs wemiing.

ii is"'«gs:;<::r£ci(.§_ ihai cerziexziiwzz as ihc: dc:f$:zé§i:}n vi'

"§::2;:2:3§rE" §;2~m.§mr ii'1£:-Cvggsiggzns Ami was fast ihr: aaiae mi' fixing ihc mix

£38! ezms”-;:a:i3 £2′: ii}:-2 Eighi af

zizemi éflézi’ grass ibr carnsideraiinyzz in {ha fizzrderz 355;? ;%;:?i?.5..s

.s*2~.rpr».:.’? was 613 meaning, s.:§im@r§ am f3:2:zm.i in Scszéigvn E? of

Aéci ami mt»: smsiigrgg E4 ané 3§ iiicrwf

Ii £3 cmsiengiaé £ha§. amdsr firm SWTVI Act imgmrt dues not

.~ ‘mean iim gg;>e.xi::«; mcrciy ¥::’~t:i11g §:z’:3s,:ghl ink; the ::<:uz1i:"}=. A5 ibr

instance, gcmés which are said by iim pt:£iiis3z1¢.:r fmrzz iis §}!§£f;1~'fEi'fi

fif

$5

shop at the éitzpariurc lamina} wuaki have in be Ezfgéigé as

impmirsd aiiheugh ihcy haw: uni been ciztamai EixgéitghV'_~u..§:z§ig3fI;s_.

And {he gains xvii; aim be rcqasirrztd is be 1"':.:'§§7¥§:£iE§;7e£.'§:..'}',€:'5L§"§!E3 'g<.:s;2';f;3;'3,g V

wifit the Packagcé Cuznnmdiiiszs §:u§%:;:; ::_fv's:z–T'ifi1'vug,%§z"é.EéV' :V§;?cam'iE;1j_ziI<:

fizzefi impuried. fnauihr as Lhrs"g:{§:-1_b:11i:§c§r§ iiizti ma ii._:u.:'é_i’A.g;!e:i.Vihai {he peifiiitynmr

being rtsquircd _§;3 §s-c:ril)zj;1n ;§§§:iga1iQig:s_«im}m’scd upen impurbsrs

(isms nisi arise w§3.;:–:x_ii:t: ‘p’¢:{i’i§g2’:1¢:é” is. ma: an émpurécr. Faeiaaging,

9? fin: goeégig is v§3sy”‘§§zr£:AAr:::-;:=3é:;;%;i§*.fc zwlanufaciurcsrs arr packer ei’ Ehre-

googirég ahead, iiéi:—§3t;;E§ii: RL£§5$ presczéibm fin:

“5:5;2§”§<2£§A3 :is::s.:§:»,;ra£éu:1s Ea} Tbs: im:-izigisai am Eiizg giaskags.

R2336 55:18} si§pu§air;::e éirzsczi inééxiiégzai siieksrs s.:&:52m:§ Em

V afiixcd fer 'shs ?%iE'§&}3t':- ofzzzakéfig £31: <iw;;ia:g£é<.2§::: §€:3€.§¥.§£§£3t;§.A

Z

$6

frlagias ? pmzécribcx ihr: (§§§§}$§ES§L}:'§ of £326 é.§_F;1.'}p§§:'s,«'.. '§";3.;i'§V':~':;-.v§;__fig!

which {issciaraiiuns am is be ms"-gdc.

Rtz3:::s 8 and 9 spcc–iiEs where §.§’£a2.: <'§£:;é.§§T2:':'::2i£'é:zj: 'E3 is 'cVFV»"E_°lF'V:'i5"§§:g§A"::vV'<.l:."€1(v§
51:: mannrsz' in wigich ii is 1:3; be'E::_3:§.¢.

Ruitss 1 3 and p1’s:;c1fi–§’:s*._. “§1:_:#i?~.4. _ ihc «:;_1s_;v.s1§.29′;’j,/ of gtmds

cayniaéacd in 2: gzvdckagc are {absaié3;:’ri%;§é:;§_.v”»._ -.
Apart fr;2n2,ii’i:: E1E?(3\’f.?~, in ir;i’*,;’35:’,~jsv~.Qf Secfian ?2{2}(z*} uf ihc
Svvrfxzi {EnfL¥rcc;f:»:fi’i}’§€3§.c-i§{é§:;<f§2v.. ':73': EEK: Cm:ni:*y can amsmi

ihc: Facskzaggarzi §30§:i§f;<::Qcié,§§¥3:3A_E13r£§+.ésg. The peiiéienzar E1: iis zmrmai

w

€."-L§¥.§;£'E:§t'2 emf Eu-sinzxtz-25 §;a%:ii3g.::§ 'éfiic: ggmiis item": abrggai 21:2» firiumiaaé ami

i§:r.:,_" .'<i;_f§ §§i£:I1~—.E§:1nspU§k:& fififiiflf Cusiumrg 5.-:u;é::r'2;i3i0z3 is

§l?u;j;%–'§:ré£:»_$§:si';:;sfVziizfutzmi the €,2U¥.§§}iI}". in £§1<:- zxwmi. 9%' wgryéng Rsgifig

ax I";:gar:§:;: ;3é.§<.~;i~;ag3§z3g by sack Siam, éhc ptsiiiimmr wuzfizi re:-{;_u§r¢ 5:3

" '-21:-passii gggqauzis, {iii'£%re-ni§}r' fer cash shag}.

" " ffiuic 2(3) whisk iisiines rssé:/gii gait gzéasc .22:':<.§ §m§ia.:3i.z:r:: Eizaé

= ..§i'«:f: price: is it.) be indicaitté in Rupsssa §*"§:}wzsxra:z", $22 gamég am

Suki agaégxgi Farfségn ifizxzrancgzg iféxe grins in: zgzzzriisai in aiagiiars -~ Eh:

6

E7

gziricc indisaiaai in Rupees wmgid alas}? can :4. daéiy b§1t~.’§$~7’*;§E’E72£%I§Z£>££ITi§L

of éht: exchange z’:::!.r.: fiuciuzxiions.

ii £3 s.::.m.{cndt:d £ha£ for 223 mi’ lhc: a’E>uxsa—-:*fi:$;::»;;§:z–>;; ih-;:>r’¢ é:–.._

phgrsicai irzxpmssifiiiéiy in ihe: méiiiifigxcri-Eigiixgivgfibig”£13cfizzgpigf 5wiE§i’*~_ .1

this Ruicti.

6. On iimsgc aixéai c»tm£:::2iie:;:1:s,.uii is ‘*’.~:a::.::n’ éhziéfiéésc §t’:§iiiU«§1t:I’
operaics Duty-free S’?-3c§}}sA la: 2; ‘$I§1t’3″–. ivnA§€:I”gnai§2§:,;::’A :7£”‘V’ifA§é:;— BIA. Th: zmiai s§}:3p3 gm: a:Lt.:~;§..£_>21’2.5

Etmndiizzci “%=sz:az1*r:–f%1é§assé;s aigiiaiiz firm meaning 5.3%’ S:::.;:i§0:2 38 :3? ihzrz

-2-w

Cu;~,:’:T.m{13 z’3;£:E,:. _ Ehé g,{;:1>d3 :§¢.}§s;.§ are hrzgaghé fmzig afirazaaéi azzd am

A «.g3aL§La1g;¢;:;§_ci.;zr1m:><iiiée:s. 32¢: same ma; 73:3»: miai msigz in igzier-

;1;Taiié:rn3E~. i3:{§'t:V£§§r:~: wiiii i;"avc§ iiué:-Lm1sn§;3 ami waif»; agaégsé

zgppruz-%e;§'f:;;1é:ign §§Ei!"'.!"*:f1€.:}*3 T115; gmsfis dispizgzasi arc 'i:srs:;;:g§i:£ fmm

:.:w;:ie9m;:«:_ §2a:n<§cei w::1I"§~§:s.}z§$€;:::: smei at: 33330233 2-figéasig am gwé. aziaamei

AA E;¥;3:<_§:z_;§':1t zezesagmgaéigm. The §i'§iW$§I2€:£E§ argif firm gsuds aé aifi éimcs

1;¢:~::ain:.; zm§§§, éi ési Es; :;.;_:§.$§é,§?;n:a§ xa;E’;§:é;.E:::§ aim gsaéggycg ::;§

6

i
L. ‘
saitzrs in I):zlj=;s-frt:e Shups in which ilarezign gmués; 34§*{:.._$’s;3;§zi is

iszcuming and maiguing and Emmi: izaicmaiium-ii pa’_é:§£i23g’5r§”

dislimz-i and .:~;t;:-parade Eypc of iragsagiigwzzs ~.–‘-5″§’§;2:::’_ga,$Qe§$’,ar:r ‘Q.

:;cpam.£¢:: c§:»::.=:«: mi’ gmzcis as disiinci fyizm ~:’fiaS3_ £5i’_gu«:_uii»§L”ag§i:;¥.:{£3
Ehc: gerztsmi yubiiu within Eh»: £v3€.}_!,£:I’Lg§é§—§.&ra§3;* om§:::~:£a:s:: «sf

Leg:$ia§_im;e–.u ‘ ii. §Z:§§’&3§5J3,_E§2’££:i EI21TE’}? ‘%3_:§§:::~; fiaalzcgi e.i’§§§~:r figs 23%;:-vaxzé
Ac£ is aquaiijg Vin;-gpgziiaz-af_b§a::.. .J’

mjrii §¥A€4.’:V’ii1’£§i£._’_zf1;’;’§;S as:<:L)rdiI:g§}.r aiémxsmin ii $5; L§t:¢;i:i:;§;:iéi2*:§S~.§£’Wsigixig and Evicaszirc Agi, i€3?€’::, £31: Séaxzeiarzis azsf

_f&1:;:é§’_ :\?it§&EE.£§’€.i=S ifinfarextsucni} Aer; E935? and {fits

-.,Sim?.L§a7i’£.i:$’1~£:~§:$ ‘éfaighis ané E’:/iezagzgrésa: §f”}§1:»,§;:i£§s am zmé a§:r§§§:.:a%«§: ii: ihr:

.. .,g.€§0&:; gsfiha: pztéiiiurzm” ikmugfrzi .§iE”:;:”z2 £.3§§am* ,r;:st:; izgtgaiszai in iiztgérzée-rzazséégnai €§€3§’.?E£f§L§§”ii’ izrzzzénai £2?

2

fin: Bangaicrrc In%€m2:.i.£una§ Airpezi {f:,xr::~.fr;:;,;azc,-.’:3E§jgx, 13s.I”2!’i{I”f_ E39 Q

:21;