High Court Karnataka High Court

National Insurance Co Ltd vs Sudhakar on 9 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd vs Sudhakar on 9 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
iaififi}-Essa I 

Earth are raiding at Sxfiam Eévag
who Campeuz1d§Ye.yyadi
fiazsgalnrc - 8
3. fiesfim K2, Pneajaxi
Sic: Nami Focjaz-3;. Ifiagfer
Rica Kamlalmd, Kmha;i.:i_

   
(By: Sri, Afivfsr R1}     

This fifific¢11an"w2uaf 1First%s¢.;:pea1 is fixed
undexr aectian _1?T3{..1) git'  .°;§3"t.',L'a._ga.i1:;s:t the judment
and award d:3.te§%~' _13';--Q£€,fl'0D?.. waged in MVC Ne,
1329/2093 i O§V1'i'V»,"§§1i'€3' --.fi.1€- j"§?f*t§LZ€ :fix- Additiezzal District
Judge, Member;-~I§1ACT_' -411; n,L., %;m%a1m awarding a
:.mmpans;§i'§t)33;  1%,: ,.7fi,.?¥3G/-""§vith iutemt @ 6% PA,
frem thetdate  realization,

This aiispséal  for a§m:£.$sic;>n this day, the

_em.1rt gégeiivgamé.  foflfitmng;

_VV_ 3JUDGMEHT
 '-- AV"E"i':<;$}€1éi-:--3_  appml came up far 8.dI1'1i38it3I1§ it

for final disposal with the censcmt at'

I   mfticzs.



MF!§.Hs:, i 

2. Thia apml is by the inauranca 

chanmgizxg the judgrnent and awaséi  

13.03.2697

passed in Mvc. N3,1g29,mbyme

Motor Accidents Claims

3. The ;.m.2oo3 in
which 4. \’Eha accident.

Claimants daughter of the
decea.saa».’%i’; 1 its order dated
13.08.2Gé’?–‘ a campmzsafion of

1 AA _____

VV%”i’;i?:a:3′.’1:.V§§rcIcr of the Tribunai has ham

% by ch: appellant on thc grounds that the

A yrg:i::af;:$iiar saiscted by tim Tribunal is 0:”; higher side

the age surf the ciewaaad at 65 years, The

3′

REA Na i

appropriate multipliar wauld be 7 aa a.ga;ij1i*1–$’i:fb.V:t1’1¢e

same, this Tribunal has takan 9. S¢¢a;'”;ci.§r

clainxants are major and mat tfié

deceaacm, Claixwt Na?» ‘ £3 flié . v

of the deceased she fcrr any
campmsatinn. Hcnéc”‘#::’é;¢§:;1 ;fa§eI sulcamittccl
that though placed before

thc Tribunal, 1f7&<$5t»§!::';¢cn censidercd.

5., fur the respctndent

– 1;l1a;t’ “fi1…..:Jrdcr ts prove the: aga of the

identity card and Ex.P 19 Elcczzfion

ID been pmduced wherein age ef the

tis shcaewn. aa 54 yeara, Acizordixlgly the

has aaleczted an appmpriate multiplier

‘ “”}iéii¢¢, them is :10 arm: comrzzmm by it. Smondly

‘V

EEK Rm €%$f2

it is submitted in respeet of the claizxzanifg fine

fmt patitianer has Ewan ¢d as

deposed in 1333. evidmm: that j

hia mather abcrut twc: yesr;’m.xa.gé*3_1:’& *

a. driver cf the &utorfl;shax§r_ Ezgaf. the
same in View sf the was advised
by the doctx;>r<'::.1;:§1at érehiclc. After
dismnfinuéfiffii' 'L '1' he was fully
tasf mother. In respect

of mfitimegs Neg: :;§L*L%%5?x;bm;tted that she in her

~__ h:a__s that; though she was married

ittgidaw at an early aga and thercaftcr

3he'A'U%&3v_'.~d;¢E}'%3Ef%'1diI1g upwn the deceased' Under

éiréfxzmsmnces tha petitiener I and 2 are

4'.'_f1ifij{d1épending an the decaased and the same has

V cc-nsidcmd by the T'ribunaJ.. Hence than is rm

K

5&3. Na E$#2

error. The 'Tribunal has alas taken the of

thus: dcsczzzasad at Rsi2,100/- pezsr

higher side.

6. I have to the
contcritiarns at the to the age:
sf the deccass;-xi: placing
mlianac has been takcn as
54 aim 031 the basis cf

the of the cieceaaed shtzuld

;a}{érx«as.«é5 ymrs. Wham twa ages arc

prepay metlmd vmuld hr: by relying

: an dacument like Electian Card as Ex.

A’ P–9. This methczd adapted by the

is just and pmper. Seccmdly with regard

csmsntiacm takan by the appellant that the

<

3&2'. Na 18fi&

pefifioners am major and nest tha £:Jv11

thét dammed, by looking at t11e.V_1? a';.§;c

ciaimanta it is net safe ts 'V T

depmlding upon the deeestifirjgl €.'«JVi'-I'2'§".E.:'!'…V

adduced an beha1fof_';11e he
has deposed that he 1?i%:s.fls_% avacation
as a driver bt§=:.faA§t;%§fi.%;–t\a9i:A_:a V' the death
of his was fully depending
upon daugfiter who is a.

Widow also depending upon

–1,;;f1:=.: c1e5*z;¢3§;a¢d, two evidences are sufiicicnt ta

. r1fma :. c1;e;:mpm1aa1:2Tm’1, hexcung that thc

: ‘v ‘ clafiéxxts dependants

“7”; I de net find any goad reasons 13:; aflaw

‘ ” apwl. Accamingly it stand dismissed.

Y

hQ’A}3&1

8. The amauna in dcpasit is m7

mansmmcd to Mamr Amiaexgm

cencanad.