High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Siddasetty S/O Late … vs Kumar on 19 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Siddasetty S/O Late … vs Kumar on 19 December, 2008
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
Ii'? 'fH}i HEGH COKERT OF i{.z&R_N;X'I'AKA AT
GALORE .....

DATE-B THIS THE 19"' BAY OF DEcEM3153§{ 2098

BEFORE

THE H0:"~E'BLE MR. JUS'f1(?l3:»wH1,?Lt;i%*;§1§I.»§;§;'R;;§Mi-!:;§§££. 

M1sC1»:LLAM:0L:s Irmsr ;&;I>1>:«:;iL  _ 

kjgg95§:»i%xqk%  -

BE'I'WEEN;._   

 . '-    
S50 late? Kafin1é<iaa€iij£;-- ., A  V V-
Aggd_VaBcaut'52:,YamjS;,  "  
Rffit Eieiixiizaragéile fiifilgéige, . 
Nanja31ig:,1d   é  '  -. ' ' '
MY'3Qi?;I:Z £:sis":a1%j<:'V1"§,%  ...APPI:;L1,A:~€r

Sri  Ma;i..§;'ap;3a, Adv.)

%   

1
1.

qua. hen:–a—Mun .

 ._    Majar,

gw 

_  Fé_tEi'er name no? knaswn,
 Bfiver oftha Aiajancya Bus,
" .  Mukkadahafii Viiiagg,
CHAMARAJANAGAR T & DES?

Y.N,Vijaya,

S50 Nan}:-mdaswamgz,
Aged about 27 Years?
Owner sf {ha Anjaneya
Bus '£~$o.K'A-10-818,
Yeiandur Tzgwn,

Xxvx



1%)

CHAMARAJANAGAR {)1S"E'.

3. The Oriental Insurance Co. M6,,
Chamargianagar Town,
C'hama.ra_janagar District, _
Represcntad by its Br311c§.';E\§afiage:f«, , _ _    .
  

(By Sr’i.Y.K.Sheshag3§ri R2tLf§,’v’;3€;§iV’. Q3} _V

This M.F.A; giwizeii u;1a¢r.k%s¢cm;n% 173(1) of M.V.A<:;t
against the jucigmeat ahgi'aiva.§d»'daftec§V'i,3}';{39.95 passed in MVC
N0.95f02 myths file. .c1 f'the.Civfi"'.}3.:i1"gs::{'Sr.Dz1) ané MACT,
Nanjangud, .';"–2§m:!y aiiowing :h¢"c'§;;:.i-1n' p"$£.i?:io11 fer compeizsatian
and seeking ez:&1a:1cei'nei1t 0fc.9m__p£:n'Sa;fion,

""" :E:'e.Tr1fz'i2'zg '.c'§:5£"f%:ar {}rC§62'S this the C0111'?
dehjveriwd mak1:'.;;j:%A§:s«.,:,;mg;;j ' –

¢5tDGmE§T

. appsai is by the ciairnami seeking fhr enhancemezrt

” . H if C(v?f¥i.fIii.f§}VA.’E§:’E;iV’i1iC¥i3 being not gatisfied with the award passed by

Ezidgc {S1″.Dn,), & MACT, Nanjangué ix} MVC

” LT1s.:;;-95:<32 by cardsz' dated 21 .9135.

2. 0:3. 2L2,02 when. £136 ciaiznant was returning to

Hemmaragala viiiage krsaéizig rim: bags in tiac b1133<3c§<: cart

around 7.38 pm. near Baéanavaiu véiiaga 3 bus be9:;'§':3»g NUKA

EC} 838 dasiaeé to tha cIai2:1a;3{'s bu%.ioc}<: cart

£0 whisk, both the émfiociqs susiaizzed g?§€;Y_}'£$.§I§i'=.§?Ej.¥..EI'i6§ –.2*;r2'1(i.__

became uaeiess and the cart W33 a}$O,§:{}l2'£1t)§1t3i§€V§§;' '£§2i';3fj:ag¢dA :.::f:('17'=_ .1

the ciaizztaazzt aéga sustaific-d__ §nj1ir.é,c§ anc3'"§€a3._v_VV§*';s:p§ta§%.séd.

Chiming CGIfi§}€I}S§.f.fiGII fiiad. The
matter was C{'i?]€*$S'£é§..§ .V:¥i':}:'sé', E:E:*.§ f§,i;::%x'42i'2i.%1i:é2;;'§:£:<fjn1pa:1y aa {he mmm'
and tha {Eras ésgues
were Trifgéizai Eaafiizg hefid that the
acgzidérzifi§$é%;s éi§j;c A' figiigezice in" the has in qz.:e:'~;t,é0n
awfirdéfi 3 Rs.2§,SQ{}:–. Beifig 33:31: satésfisé

Wéih 'E}1€§"4S3§§I6:_:.73i€ Acéiaffiéani is be%§)1"e this C<3::rt_

. %;%Jjk%;%;%%:::§}ga:d.

z iii. The Tz’§bz:na§ E133 awarded Rs.2,§{}€};»-‘- ‘i’:”:=wa’rds: paizi ané

VV fiééfférings, R3.i2,,{}{}0s’» “{m=var&3 Sass Csf §31:§§:1£:ks azzé Rs’7.{}G€}:’~

iawarés &amage ‘if: 816 sari’. Acctzrééng in {has hizarzmd Ci31m:;&:§

fer the appefiagzt eaciz bufiiycic cagis m<;::'e: than R:e;.2{}~–2S,i§){}Os'–,

W'

The Tribuna} die} 3101: take into c<»1;si&erat§exz the said aspesfi.
{me in the aceiéezii when both this baiiacr-Iezs becams usehizszs the

Tribuna} vmuid have awarded :~";uhr$tan¥:ia1 cetaipczisfiiicézi';-VT

5. Having heard the CflfiIiSé§ ‘fi3:1_t%–:a¢e ieggéesiézre’ pas*i.éas}

anizther Rs.25,900,»-=”‘- w{>uidVh¢’ “fig.i:,;§.iv’:3:5:%tfl.£'{§2§§éa&’d$
thee: injurias caused iii: the arié useieés.

Sims the ciaimant ..§_:%§$§;1€2t§:1i periezd of E2
days he wcmI<i_bs cm me 32635 my
pair; azzcf the cart £3 czmcemad

the Q_E€§vif7§¥2}$.i?} fV"'3';:'€}:jL_i!:V gsfiiiithcr R:'«:.2.0£'30s'"-. Thus, the

czagmzz~m;:e;-%2¢.«s%.«:»,;:zé:;§aa ya Rs.3?,O€3{}:'- (3%: and abm-'6 What

has beaénu Tribunai with 6% imercszt §mm_ {ha

V_fc17'};~%f:aE ggcfitiéih«€§.3_I__.dep0s§t. The Insurer 3333?} de:;30s.é§ the saéd

V V

$3 3 éeiaj; M21'? days; in preiérrizzg the appe3;E.

Th; Kariée £3 cnizdmieé. Hmaisver. 2%? the £633}? perizyd fiée

V <i§=3imant is rm? ezziéfiezd far izzisrasf. The axnmmi in éepmif be

3}?'