High Court Karnataka High Court

The Manager National Insurance Co … vs Smt Marakamma on 9 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The Manager National Insurance Co … vs Smt Marakamma on 9 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


3% 3% gm}; cwg? $22′ mafiawgm gs? B&§€..§;éxi;§:3§E

Sgsmfi ms ‘gm gm my $319′ §§VER5B£§;’?’*§3£}§..{§’V~«’ 4′

§E§’®RE.

mg imgmm: Eéfi ._:°::s*rzcE

M A
ma Eias. zmsgaws, zmwggam
lmsafzmgfiggxwzfiggggass mg

-” v B&§€€;?%§;..§,5€LL’T%E -5%E§ S

BE’E’WEEf¥: é
ma ”

E§A31’§$§$&L aiisiiggiysrézta am am,

3.:-§,§G§€3?%fi§.L-._?v§3E§.%€3=E’;fig_.
fiafiéfifififig 3% $}R§1.;:H€:;E’-i::C:., gm”
RE€+ESE¥?aL*–@1<"?§fCi§3u SE23
Cfiixflj-'"E.;%Z}{§ fié.'-4égMI;§,RQ.é_Q§

E; ;?

mam; A32; 3

M ” ” 5 L 4″ — 3 , $:«,:’§:

_ “‘~«?§J;’Q ms a,
L ~’f§’§¥a’ $333 Max}? 3% ygagsg
ma: aaxgszgamm,
R; :3 §:3g§,ar«:: mmagf

Sfifififi T&§.§K..,

2′; §{§§§S’§3§:fi’2′., Sm KANIQAWA,
HQW 3:333 .ékBQ'{J”§”‘ %~§ YEARS,
ECQK £5? 7% H$S”I”EL§
1-zaaaggmg RIG r-iagamlsz
¥”&Lé-‘:QrE, Eifififififiifi Ffifi’;
Sfigfifi ‘f’:’&E.:i}}{ {QEEEER QR
Efima ‘mm Efiafififi 2&3. ‘
§{fi~fi1;’§a?E=-§§.6vé«} ~ «A

gm’ gm S§R,Ei§:’§&TE $3, &§Vl;;._}?'{“3fi R1
R2»-SE«§”%2’E$3

‘i’§~ffi8 MEZA; I3 §’B;.’§Z§ E3f19f’i3?72″ZRT’;’r}fE§;§;’S§;’Ij@EI i’?3{1} 31?
W am’, .-‘-‘£Qfi&§§$’E”‘ ?r%§I.;§£:%%%%§.,*r,;{;§;*m%.’:¢f:? mm awma
mzmg 2§.G’?.i}”:;;€IiI}L;8 Fgéssfiiji ~3§¢3;:?;2m? mt
‘§’§+$ mg fifif £3335; 313534.343 {S§;_.,B§}~—-£>’.’fi’§ mm’§’*1Q2s2’AL
MAQT, SQ’R:%§3;”v-é§?§$§¢I%§1§£E¥§3′-‘” ii’ §5*3%e§’E1’%$A’3Z’It3N $9′
Rafifimgg’ £:%?*:%,E~m::.%3%’1:’iL @552′ §% $3.3″ ymaga “E’§~$
mm :*;”}§’*’?’i€};’*§?3.’I’£:i’§}’%§~.”?E”£gL–..’?§a’f?¥iEr§’?=

ra2.F.g§rie;1¢:>”::k43;%72r;<m%§§¢z'$gjk%L %

mama

V ….. .. V

.§§sf§{3I§§i§.« $5 S-£3? i.5"§'§;§

%%;e,?k.:-:,:%s";gs*;;£3'§ gmrmag;

% ~ j S L % 2 L .REGIC:%§,§sL $§’F}€E§ 5:33
% % ;~..fif3E§L:%;X§ §E%§ Mfiafiafi,
_ ‘ gagggamggnsw am:

$33; ~&§;:”?RE;<;:<;r~:%:*E § 32* 3'33
§§;::§»::;'§:§§gL% gaga
§iA'Pi€}I§';§;_L'§1*€§§R@e.%€§E am ism?

é%§..7=%..E’¥’E*

% % :33; 3g: §,,%%,}iEI$E§§;% swam? mm 3

SEEB:

1, %§”‘§. ;”E{§sE§’:’a¥afi%i.§
‘Mm zémrgayyag
Nam? mam ABQUE’ 34- ‘fgafia
ma: fiGRE{i{}§;f%'”£3RE,
Egg: §E I mgmaa,
gr-; *:’:é:,m<:,

2* Kmagwam

ggmzmrmmaé

rm?! mm Amuw@%%;§*,aE&a§% *

mw: 3»: Tim E-£GS'fEL:,,_ A

Hasa$AL§:;, Rm

mmgag §~§G$AEE3<§:.LE

'::m3:§% I

zamim
BEA§§*¥G ?3e.E{&+.i31.§}fiaés§:%%}

% ;22;«:amre*m:m*'rg

(3? gm s.%E.§%§g:;%:§;.f:*§: S%i:§;":%:3¥;; 9% R:
R2~=SEE€*:;'§§§ –

%3§~§sf1x§§:.;.;,§ ‘:s’;7éfl;E§§ uzrmgfi 3EC'”;E’E£%f€ wag}: Q1?’
2%? 4;&€::*2:: g§§.;§§s’§’ ‘z’§~$ JUm$2ssmE’r MB fifiéifisfifi

.mgfma%:2&.$?,2$::s%%~?a;§ss£§ 3% ma §€§.E§.8f2%’? er;

mg. @122, “at? am Jiifififi {3m:z:~§; 2 Jzsfim

s;m?:*:a:2rz;%:;%%TL %:s»§s:§’:; sgmg; Awgmma g

€§f€3%§$fi’E;’§¥?$;%Z7E§}E§ GP’ R$.§,Gm;’~ zgmamy gr
5%,__ R3. “§fi”€C%§.§ TEE mm €33?’ PETMGE “”f’§L§.,

Mk V’ . ?.§:”§*a$;’§€;’fE’§” ”

% j ‘ iamgggam gm

: §tA__}._’»:?j’.:””Ei”‘§:is”§E»Er§’:

A mxggaa
” P¥fiT§%§§.é5s.§,- §’§fi§§;AI§§§E Qfihfi §

E§€”§’§Q.§g§? 3i’%QG*é§
E¥G°?£ RE§’RE$Efv*’:E§ BY rq’

REG§Q§.2%.L I”%§§{‘:E§,

§.&”Z’E§§2%-E: $3., Lrm,
Rfiamfiaa aizxzmg am — –

§ #144, §»€.§,R:3§>.$§
B£§Gz%&%3s-.§& G31.

:3? 333 g.§g§R:s§-ma saaam: g1}§:4§’ 3 A_

Sm Bzswswa, % A
33%? .&§E§3 ” – ._

2.; mma;w:x&;.§§z; M 1. % %
sg$kTm,§;xg??ag%*%%j§V%L%%
R’m fi«$£’:f3fi§§i¥T?%i% mm
CQQK 35 HQ}[§5E3ig
Vfiifififivg $33′;

-§ T;%..IK;

Q?’

B E.a§:=€ffi€.§ i€3.E€£»§3;£-§~%§

y magsmfiiazgfim

gay; mv.§ my 3:

L E3»§z?;:@i%g§;;f;§

x ?£ §:$s1sg,mazsm§L mssmg gamma’ 2:23:13 as?
‘3£::.r*§’¥ aeamstr 23$ mmmm mm Awgm

– masga §§.a?,m::>s mama 35 gm z~:g.:;g;2m*: mar

%A ‘M mg 332* am 3
* Hmgzz mm, j-1.-é’
% gmmag- mm
‘ mm :3 ?E*’E”£’fi§E’ mg

gsgmg am §..§§i’E”I£32§’AL
Q g saggmfisazisx Q?

gr §% Mb mm: m
ymrfii

3?”;

~ .% gm’ SEE

rm zezmmm,
NA’1’I§HAL aaisgmreca $3., Lmfi
B.E*§.R®fifi§ $§mz3:%;.3&.§

RQW RE?F$E3E§i”‘E’?EE 33:’ F333

RE$Efi2€A.L mgmag,
NA”I”‘IGfi’§:L aszsmmzzcg ca, 1:;m;’, *

RE§§GE§§i.L amm, am -‘: .

cexsmzyg #1445 z«.;m.m2,m, %

B£§§AEQE§;-5;$?Z3 091. A ” _
g§??§;§;gEfiI*%”§

{BY 319:: ,§,§€.§é.’;.RIS§’-EA.

35 $ –.Wfi§E’.»”x?Pfi§ ‘ _ ‘A ‘ .. ‘ –
§§?’§ ‘§’3:°£..'{*-5S,
@C£:v:s%iL”E°§IC€,3′};*I’3i,1″{ET’i§ g
E5′ Q §¢;’:”1%; E-3 11:’°LL&3E,
V. ._§:S§C3r§.§§B T3%§,i}K. V

;- , Hmagsfiaiam

‘$§f€?§§Ai£?f%’i:§:PPfi;

. % ~M%V%§§€;:%?MV»5€35§;§ a§§:.:’§f’ ‘$9 §

‘ 3a:§:<:;:;;s: Tm I~eE§3*i%L;
. " * T&;§3§e:§

– _ §$W§E§ Q? mm
gamma §aE§§&.§:g§gM§§§¢§
EE$?Q§§§E3f§’E”$

SH? fifivsg §’Q§ RE;

9/
E

§:2§w$E:§@§§

ms 1«a.F.A$ is Fmfi EEEBEE SE§’§’§Gl%’ §’?g3{.i¥_;j-«;C’§?
W am: aamm Tim mmmm
mA:*m§ 25,::?§m$ Efifififififi 3%’ agm r~m.13,a;£2G;;o7′:*_’r:s§:~–T
fim mi GE’ SW3. §é3’m§E gsfimég &§§.A:3§}:’§’i:m1aL~< ._
Eefifif, fiefifififi, £E?§;RDfi€G §g_.£{}§am?§E¥843x*IfE€f}I€

R5.E:,%§§-= mm fi'¥'§"EREE~?'I' $2? §%;%.;-:..

3&3? :3? fifififififi T3,; PA’!I!g$13€”§’, ~ ‘

Es§,§’$a–,I’§$, KW 3 3

fim §v!F£~I&GER,, ‘ A
NA”3′:€QHfisE.— E§*$i3R&K§EVV_£;?§.,V; z,?1*z}gg«V _
B.§§.RQA$§$I-E?5{;§{.}€rA;’ ” % %
rim: R;E?RE$E£5?}€?§z:33 :3arjs:*s _

REG»§E3E%AL::’2§§i§.%§§€§§E§,”‘–.ij’*–. ‘. A

§’fi”I”§Qi~I§;-L §s;gsi£:¥K.;s;:szc:g- ,c’§.««§ L’I*§, 1,
RE G§€}’§§;i; ‘€§.3E7f§’§$§4’; 5;
C’33§#@L§;3X§, –

ggmga;e;’%§»3;s§:;::«:,)§::.y%

_ :3? 9+M§5;§§é1$mg%s%;g5m mm 3

3, A * ,3
aggas ;<;:s;2¥£«¥.aw&§
" §<:3§: fiflfifi man'? 5: Ymmg
§$$:&$EE€§Lfi§RE§

Q ' * %%Rg§ 2;m.*:*E;<';A§3E m;a§§§
V' –. Tfi§.§.§.§Kg

%% % 2» iéagmwaw,

gg S Kméfififiwég

F3'Q'€€f §g§§fi AE@§'? 4% mmgé
amzé 3: 'mm E{§§iEL;

H®$A§§iLE;; R? S} ‘

M
I

g

‘aflififi-E9 Eiflfifififahg §
Sfifififi Tfiiiffi,
{€3’§§§I€E;§ SF’ ‘I’E.§se*fl’-Q ‘
EE;!§Efi%G I€a.%§&~$§,g’ figwfiiéeé}
Kfififi}

:3′; $3: Sgzsmmmsa, Ama, $33 ; * V
R§~$E§’%’E§§ * ‘

ms %§s-Fag; :3 ymm ‘i;:2§§,ER $B;¢’m2§: :%7%3{k:;km=> k %

ms Am; aaams? Tm ._::;rzm1§m1sz’*:*%M ma gyms
Sfifffifi 2@.G’?.i2€.”ifi8 P§;;$SEfis,-3″-5%’, Hg.139ma:3*i ms
‘Fifi m3 0?’ CIVEL J¥.§13§ET_ {S§2fiI3:%;AVV%éa,?€§ &Bfi§§’I€3£§AL
Mi’:-CT, 35.33338, fi..§?£sR3;§IC}_ CTE}?¢iPEeI*3’S&’I”3GI’¥ GF
Rsaiflfiflg _ % §5a%*I*E§51§;E%sf;’%.afij;*:%§%’5V;?.;%a{V–M

‘zmsg :e”m% wmma “§’E-§§3
ma: ‘Eéfi *:’:a11«: Fc::Lwwmc;:-

5 by the: Ensumzzae Ciamgasay

that éudmem

g§.§?,2m§ §a;,§§e§ hy aha aémés Jzgéga

{s:~;,§§§.§ mgr, fiarak,

2 § . 1 1.1′ .3: :2.

&Lm§§ by time a§§e§}a.m’£ fig fiat

333$ mmmit tfi an arm? wfififi awayizzm’

‘ T_ 33 {am flwi Eiafiiiitgz

53:: was af fig: : fhfi iszczgmad am

K

irxmmfi ef {Ex tmmslfi in tempts; wax

§¥r;}§r€fi~

G1,? Eéwéiéég whimh wag mm. mfth an

rashaztid %}21gea:1tdri*%% asftile érfm.

3′

– -:; gamma} £33′ tiga a,§3§é;:}£2§ii%:…§s’t;?9T:1*;i°{;e;*§;T .’

fimt ‘Kim mfick, whémh >

£3 an A5: ;:>e}ic§a Hg af {km
Suprefi flaurt in Sat), Ltsri.-,
Vs: Sigmlmraxg’-I§..V, as cm isms
33 29% in the mm
at” vs; amt: Kama am
sthm KER $153, whewa Elm

guagegaaagszé §§%$u§::-mg <:a§¥ur: mg, mg Qmzrt mad that if

V' :33 5&1: thm aim Ezwasraram Samywzxgr

§'?¢?;..i:3§.– ~E§;_j'§&E& fie my

mwwfia yillian

:"ifi;?wfz€§r as ifimfiw fif' thza wézimk in %_;%w izfissiarxii

gsfiéy pmfizzmfi Q; gm e £ as

t.-1

313': *£% ia an fiat z

it siaaw mt mm {kw rifik af' thfi izfmm sf 13:25

% m}:§£}..Efi r'<

§

4; E haw Emaré fix

:3. Qlf

rmgegfisenta is aT::$¢:'=::.

5, 1:: this whit ifif fhs §u_£§z:1?%i§:i °’ ‘V

the:-2 minim ramrfis §¥§3i$}’: is _ V v

iasufi in 2 af hem:

mama’ ma which is at a “liabflity

snly yasimyfi izagaai :zrmj£ %%*fi§éfr t§;’;€éf-Efjésféx ‘zfifétige mums. of

the: 1 am afimmé and fifm

as far as time a§pa§i1.s:ani:

V ia 3;:-e._§$mb§§ 3-5%: asides

a fiswsit 23¢ refunfisd tan gm apwzagss,

salé…

judge

2.212%

z ‘ ;_… ‘ff-w a-.<~e4'-"Q".-my

Ear Q13 apgafmnfie Leamfi m3.;,ma.§M

mmzaai ébr tfcxe appeiianfr' E