-!”»J’
This; ‘%.R§’ri§ §3atiié.:’tsr: is; Eiieé under fmicieg E226 azzéfjzfi’? {sf
{ha C:}§:stitu:’§:z :3? Enciia prayiitg {:3 direct e2~’3Eua§éaj-%:~»_:_§~§7V 233%
aszawer 5~§c.r’i§3%: {sf E336 patiiéasner ifiagigtez’ §’\Ee.::§i{} é{3gi}’:;%§..§§}.. {$143.
s;;2b§e<:t §3r<3§é;<;§i€m_aE E-Lthicg, Asteauixtaricgs .f{;r I_..,2m.*fg?'e;fs.Ta.§§{§"A3&3' V'
5.
Efiaacii Reiafiazas; {T§f £323 fzrzai s;£::11esig:§ L§.__§;§'{‘;”7§v– E:-ff»: ;i-‘2.~.. ‘
%§*séep%:;;’:i§e:f:£ ex-‘aiuater {pmduced heréwifih V V
“fhigz Wrii §3e’i%1:i:’*s c:::}1z1’i:3§;”€}n fefv-p:eE.§m§§:aa=f§’vhemiiing ‘m-. ‘
{}r:3up{E1§s; day, ihé: élasuré; ;:3¥.§;d§*iEz.e f{>§§i7:s_$i:1g;i
‘*{…….& i€;§iv’éi:§£:;1§%:;r cg7:zf:}:;3i£§:é=$§”_£{§B?vif’::£égre<: sceaxrase é1:ria'ag
fghe afiézqieiztfsigi je'«:;?§z-Hf""§i:¥{}§?Z§_{}i7}f§3 He gained E316 ;7Emi r::§§§:<?sz':€ie:1%;.~
asayiigzge §;:=%~fié£:; <j§7~–"§_,,§;.§E§ :.:=<'::»2::'se fa')? {he acziéemée §;::.*:-3?
' A;':%::{%s»;;;::§&:§ Eé £5: 23:: fix: s::§§3N§&s£:'€.s af gag :J:T.¢_:~:.
' 'A E
'f_§2’£i6?”;%§€§”, ii: Eiie <3" E§®3'£3.6S§i3§',
£%E£'§:$§}:§(vV~EE:-iggfifi :s::2§%§e:;«.::f§ rzzrzmeéjyg "'3i3m§7e;f:;s:é€;:;ai El'€§1%c§;;_ ;«'aa:§:a:::2'::a:2::js-
' .. :%E;:~;" §;.;é:;2%x§-*e§*sg 33$ 33:' §§€§";€§"'£ §§';§§a'?':.i€;;':s' Es: 233$ gffifiéééfi ii: iiéez
éé'§§1'7'e§* fag? :«:::§§}s<:i':;. fie; £33 gficazzagé 23 rzmriszg {Egg 52$? 3% :*g":3,;r*§<:;<.;_2
in ER 'iErm::;:"§; €{':§.'i}§§¥C}§'§€'§'§§ 2'}? §§:é: §aié 3§fi§§£::<:,'i. "'§"'§r:<:;*&'§§::z"e:¢, he:-3
::;;':;f2§§&é {Eur §'€"g'2}§¥}a'&'{§,{?§'"i as§ Eiis-'at éinwsar gcripfi; in $32 gaéd figzébjacé.
1:: $5.: sa'«za§:,:2,§.i§a:}:§ $23 'war; :2w:§§*a§$;§ 2.3, mayka i3%Ef£§. aii' £8 :f§.";a:'%<§;,
'sa
L.
“$18 axe-wage fiiéf the i’W{‘_% ‘mas; 32313:”: inm :-accauni and East. ___w:21,<;
awardaé 26 mariézz; £:mE {sf 8%} ma:*1«:.:'~;, 'E."%ze::§&§E:fsra.
fiiaci iiixés; wzéi petitiean seeimzg far 3. eiirecztima ii') éigé'1§'§'§ '§TE:§L?§'{éii1 V'
the aasgwer script fifths Said Séiibjéfii,
2. E iaava fieard the Eearnaii :Cs:r:};é::s;sE $929′ iijé
3. “F}’;a reiiséf .$x.:s::,%i’:’i ‘%7?”w§§§&”}i’£§?§’iia;”}é°3%§’.”iE:’§§:::* f’€’&’£a§E.%:iEi{‘:§i :3?
the Ei.I1SW6f€’SGi”};)fE.n .-:3;–_’f}’it?4._22fEGi7§S€:3fi~.E;i3.h}€2£:'{ my ihe 2″ taizfia. AS
“§’§i3’i]§fi€§€,i a% k2i1;:;s2 E:-1* {ha 2: ravaizgaizazz 6% firm 3.332%? &:§i::f§§§’§:~:;, it
ig w::§§7::;e’€§Zez§ $131; xvimsz éhe ‘§_,’szr§ia:$:*$§§°§_,»~= in fig ::a:§$§§;§m ‘$23.3 §}{}§,
.V§f:3*’§%’:;¥a& fgf Em femiizaiiixgz uf iim &.r:s~;we§” iacsépig, éizig {3:?::;:*’e:E
}a’Z:–3f}I}{}§ éiasfiei iéze éigzivfiraiig? §%;:2:’ §e2sai’§3ai§a;: sf ii}: éi§’§§fi~”=連’
E§£¥.’§§’.’2’§S €3s;’3¥3ifEiI’f3a’ iii: éis QW1′: r€:gis%ai§{3::2$. ?fh:;: §;ii’E§{§€fl§’§7§ {§£i¥1!§i§”¥
Eaassa §r:§*:€:rerfi gégifiss $32? ;”£:’s:a§:2atiim sf aaswar s;% 371.4 3′ E .E(}x¥?.Ri} (IF -.§’EC{}_¥}}.4.§E”‘ _»=i.:’§=”f%
ff} 65 351? ;.§’E€'{}N!)AR Y El} §3′”‘{)lr:i 3″§€?:’€ xi;’s5!} xi;’i5{)1?'<§§j.
§'Z4R.z'T{};§'}! %3;3:%w:§z; gzfggszgsgsgzgzzg ;:4.z1~z _
33-£3}, {fie Ekpex ifmiri E3235: heké tizzzituha' €§ELif}§j§{§i§;':%'%:V."§"}:§:§;R;%§ " "~
apgmayed for s;eca3:2éar§,–' e<iuc2zt§:3V
gcriptg 35; 63¢ game arms ;7:*g’};£2§béi¢s.%”§§§§’~t§é’e..L_§%u§¢§_’ ~…¥;r;_.;E§’£5§}£/i
N3. 52:4 T1: ()1? ;;:~mx::§L2:41%gf§’aé%gagéiiiaéémsszs 1; 9355:;
KL} 6!]. iizis: E233 ;.?:e_1d’§i§fi.:§%-..f駢§é¢:=f¢V’t§i5zé: fig me xiégiaé £232′
iazééggaaiiéégz 6:: ‘?%§%?§if§’?:é?.~§,g§§i1>€§ff:i{§’§-‘:”§’é¥$i’?§’ zexerépts E2″: 3:2 examifiaiienfi ii
fmiéaixss 3523; $733 £a$S§£a;: i§’;’E: ifméri £%§;E}§§€9;E§§’§_ ax ‘ta: ‘ihté
é:£”§ff€€f¥}€S§ (3% ‘ifié 3fi§¥%’€§? ififizégheé ix}? ‘fiiii é:?:ud€:;1§ G3’ 335 {<3 'iise
";:;;::";*é<:£§*:§§s <3: s<;i3E§s逧*§¢§§: cs? ¥I}3f§<£f~§ a'w'3.:'ée§§ éifiéfffi :30: afiae. Et £3
ff%,,'a';2**:i'j::_é*;*T.§'§<';i»§,§.A £3 £3 gzeég gzpeiz. ts; iéze fig}: fiaurz 3:: &ime:i' iizs
'E%s;::?::f§;§ $3 ;::.22?%a::¥§i'TVr22§.:'§:_$ £3?' mags iaarks $332? $138 mar;-:_§ a3.%5€3;%'d€£
_ ' ' §3§;' Eiié Eééilfif as any a§3$'i:a;$r3 21:" éémai ra¥3.§u::§§.§::3 :23? &§§:'i'iFe'£§F
igsisg. In §*£:3;2:x:g: g Sgzfgm Si»i;¥{§£Ef§£s§
%€..£?[i'§l5§'!{;-..§', 14.5%?) x§;¥fi3'E{E§ (1325? E??? 32-15? 23}, 3 §}%s;é:<;é:'::f:
E 'Eh
up
5
Bench :3?’ tiiisa Ceurf; has heid that sima {ha Uaiiversiiy hag :.”z<::nt
§:1"€.:fisideé 3 previsian far rrsvahiaiiaan 91' for re$':*
:”&2:aiuai:i<}n :31' retcfiailiiag. In THE SIECRE _
g1«:NG.4L, C61;-?NCII_. (JP Hzggm ~ mfijégfiémzfif
9-.'
EB£?CAfFI{)N VS'. Ar:4N 9/;s,»iz&1: 3f}}:fi'¥,£":f1}?;.'§""figgéfifit";-éfifxfifl.i'
Sci?' 5975), '(ha Hx;m."b§e Szup:5e§r_§:e;.4..fCc3z§ft Md A"é§j::at,..i:=:; the
abseflce if a statutory pmvisien,—-:*«:*}#2z.:;§&s.s.$meré{ –s::s.{ 'i;§7:'é a:1$*za:s::r
gcrfipts fiafiflfii be direcztefi ébjg/_T§i';e3'C{§uf:t_ % '
432;; " Iyiaé -bf€»T.:14é3€§_;i"<:s'i' hem iimig fix: }'3iI}'§s€€I' ezzéziferreci
fanfier 2§?.6'::s_f fi'§§'§:i3fiS§iifi§§{}fi {Bf india is designed it}
'~ _ affiiifiiiuatg; ihe §a§§r'; E€%~«-i3¥}i;Z}?G!E the mie cef Eaw, ané tr; angura "£13?
_ 'i§'§Va_as.»:£§:';2:f%ii.e;'*sgxizsé mrgazizs gzf éhe Siam aitad in acwréams wéiéz
§aé«s__. Ei V€:3.é'iLi3§::_;:V:he inasakad Em" ééraésting tha au'i}';s;;§*é?;i€$ ti; &<:i
-».c:::§ira§’;:,{__’?f,}- 33%. A writ eisf ffiafiéaifliifi éémsiing the iinivsrgiiy
” is’; -regikafizza the angwar scriptg cannot E6 ésguad as $316 exisfexica
such 3 fight and a Stiffflfipfifiéifig dzziy an the past :3f the
i.§i2i'<.:e§*§itj;: £3 3 madiiéan precedent fix" the iggziae of a writ" nf
mandamurts. in IEBVYQN OF INDIA AND gmyrzzgx 3:5: '%j{
KIRLOSKAR PN£U.mrIC :20. L215. (199614; Sci¢_;;53;; "
and :3 5:5: gyms :49. STA TE 01? ;&IA.H4fi§SE’}fR4 ,i§’1’tA3 };j} ”
QTHERS {AIR 2802 SC 444), the Aps;*:v:4__.C(3fif€._:E’ia§ heifffifigafii 1 ‘
Ariicieg 226/’22’? cf the Canatitutian emf Inetiié .§.’3I13’1C)’€ be i’:§$*ék.e6§
flog” directing the aatlzorities to 3-.*-3?’ Gfi7}i}¥:I”E£_I’f€ ‘i’a”f}:’¢:M _s.f:a111*mry
prmrisiens. In the Eight 4:? tha ai§i:\s£:::disc:;sLs§<;ri;_ 0f £1616
considered E-'§6V-F thafi"':$iv::_§:é;L_,tif:e:'e._:§.$ 'ac ;7r¢iv§.si0n far the 2&1
revaiuatiazxn 駧FB grams as €’IIA2VCE££QR,
%2>g £’§Z}’§R’ ‘ ;%i3;:§;~3;?§é’2.§*1§*:«* :3? .EI.EZA§ZTB’ S€IE’,§”s’££’E§ AND
‘ XIR SCEV SI?-ii, tim apex: C9321″ was
. ‘4’:ig:s£;_3’§;°i€f%i;g {he pgwer of tide Viazze-éihaacéiim” u.z’sXE2{3) Qf 3:316
“?x§.TF§’;V.{1;11iver§ity* cf B33331 Scéencas Amt. The facts Eeaziéng ic-
§:}§e saié gage are ‘that in {he exaniénaiinn sf B5833 Caurse: far
{ha academia yaw 2€}€}€;~{}’?, 35: maagaz as éiQ’?’é gméesita E32:-zi
Y.
3%
appeared an& ant (‘if WEEQI11, 992 :§t’:.:dent3 were éeciared faiied
in éiffarent papers. C321: uf ihe 9% siudenis who had faéied, 436
Students: agpiiaé far re-téaialiéng af their respfictiw ag1;’$ £=;;er
Ssrfipts. when 313 pmcesg sf re~t{:taIiing was
campiaints were filed baibre the Chanazelier a=f’_.i%&t..4_ji;§nix>*Téf§”:§<ity, "
Hmfble Minéster far Madicai and Hea1:ha§%
Ciham:-slim? ef the UniversityV':Q'n_V b3VI21a.¥f' sf V§'}:*i.7eA..;.?a1j§1*;:'§':s"v
Assmciaiian, COIT1§11:1i¥}if£g of £:12pr_(fg5%:rV_argd undezryaiuéétiezz of
answer scrépfs. Fiaving 9fegar;i tt:{. t}a§"'::aE;i1'e_ ef eampiaints
receivedffiié §?ifes3fs:;z% §”e::’:’:*g¥%xgi’%£§§:£a¥ii€;r;f2*e«-93%aai’ia::;’z’e««3:x:a:’:1inafia-:3
of answer gzzriplisu ‘-{3:’:ffi}b;锑¥§;§a§s£s m–ver§fis3ii0;’1 rnaéa by the
Cammfiiiag, E365’ i}T§::7’\:éfsit§.-* éééiaraé raviseé raszzlts 0;: 2.2.206?
and s{j§fl:.dg3::£3 mjif ‘:3f#4i3é sfaésmfsfi wirm Ema appiigd far’ rs»-
‘-,§{}”E’i§§£ig: ‘i}»§:5I5’a’i¥:v41(~,7gi§:{33;&!’${?i ‘pasgfi. Tina efsieczgiim aazzizicii ef the
§§§§é%é§r:sré%j;%’ é;:3;§2;:'{;§%¥e7§ the aaticsn taken §3§g tka Vic:s~–C§2a:’;$€§§a§,
_ ‘F313 Exieééggi -ififaparffneni did :23: agrae with $313 aeiiaész (:5 fire
‘ ‘-._V§??’is:$gChéz:§%§§{}r. Eéaéxvwer, §ea:rne& ;5«.fi’s-53:33:32.3 Genera} epineé
Vé’§§_a€ ?é;§%2€~;;?’A.’éa:.::§3i(:=:§ {Eff}-’13 ‘x?%aa~{L”§’;a§12eEi:::r §3e:’rz22’fi%_ng :*e~va§u2i:i<3n
.(
CK';
:3? answer scrépis was that in Eiif»{§{}I’&€1i’}C€ with the p£m;isiit;»a3siT.:;f
iaw. in View of tha ::3pini9n mi’ Eearned Advimcate Cic~:–‘2é_«1’z:t.1; ‘€’..§:§:”
gileeting csaf the Executive Ceuficii was £::§11var1ec§’-«($31
269?. The \?iee~Cha:1{:ef..i0r inf2:::m1ezi._oih§:r :i1aéfr:hé1″s_’_}_uf._
Executive: Cgau-mi? thai re-v*a§uati{>nT_ <3f:..aTn;*;'».rw::r' .s.'c:r.é;5i§i .A
csrdereci beeausa if the pressure ii*ei:n1'v._tI*ié::V_ S?u€iéf§i$"¥§.¢f1£§ 313$ V
faiied and {hair parents. The Exec.gfifi~x;e Cu3i§g
camaiiéd the win:-Es: prncés:.$.’::*;f f’¢2″:-“s;’.’E§§'{i:¢’:i”i1;1F§i’§’. FC€iiI1g aggrievfid,
the: 3m<i€:n'rg é;fi'd. :h§i§¥f,4i};aa'i§§§ri'$ ézhafiéizgeé the said mrfiez' of the
§?i:~;<:3(::;§'ix:e"ifififiuzfscii Caurt. The iear:1&r fizxd §)§T§’s*./Bi”
V1§::.:§§;t;’9 32(2) Bf the Act it: appmini 3 mnzmiiiee fan” R3-‘
é§eriiEg;;1EiV{§-:€”‘§af :;§::§fé.s’1gax2ar gerigsig cf the gtuéanig, The Rsgisgirar
-V ::i”‘:E*;%§:” E.§:i’§s;3§’sE;§y {:§§>;’*iaie améian raiating K; the ziffairsg the
Efiriixssrsity, wiziczirz é21::§ude§; mnduci csf a3<a:11inati£:r:…;:_i;~;r:;. ";f1r%<:x
Vice Chanceliar is 'aha CQE1S€2i§)Ei'S i<Z€€:p€¥' zssf th&.V§jfi'%–35@3*§§'f~§',' :3f::is K b
the prizazsipai emcziiizfe amd aeademiié <3ff_i;;§c:i {sf t§1 e' 'Ufié.x*5;jfSi§fgj.:'
He £3 entrusmd with the respez:£:ib__iiét}! ¢jf_d*i;era1§,»é1€f;§rx,i::is'tré;iéC:'1':
{if acadesmii: as 'ififfifi as nen~acé;a;iez's1iVs affa.i..::$. "fine Vim»
Chariszeiiar has right 'I507::=égAuEat&j_ ifhé=. v:§5afE:_ arici wnduct ef
afficerg and aihgr' w:rnpi:::§é*5e12e::. c=f"£§r;'c__U1é;%\2.§i'*§§éty. fig Ems 2330
emerggémty piL:§*¢r té$V4éaa'I'»..%éé§th a;fi3§9ur1t€;xxgaré S§§3.ibé§iL§?::»*eVs~..i§13i:~"a 3i't°:2at§o;m caiig £3: imsnafiiate
ac€i{:a_; he Gaff '£.«a}<e's1u::i?}§' acfisn 33 he iiainkg i'ifiC~BSSai"'§»" thgsugh in
§§3;e:VL'§§0r%§é}a3 figégrsa he is fiat ccsnzpetent E9 mice that ac'i§€3n_ Susi:
2; '§%_.j§;:,2a€iéf:..}f:aS :2;;%i arisaztz in the case an hand. 1:} this caga {fie
qzzésiéegi' is'w;%§r§1@:h§r the 2% mwaizxatigérz £3 pemniggiizie 6? wt
V. 'Skis aagéle éazryes :29: aaii fig? axsraigal mi" e:*ne:*g£:32c.};' paws? '$5; {$18
'§ib§c'éA Changeiim ta §s'3:flE xafitk gay Einiszwarai gituaiien.
R 'Tharefera, ihe éecégicm reiieé am by $336 .§e=ar§':€:<§ $133333} far iha
pafiiia-net E335; fag') a,§?§'?§'§{3&§§(}§'i €11: tha facts atsf ihég $355.
K
/
5. Them is an :’:2&r”i’i in this wrzit §>eEiiiigi?”:a1i d” .
a.;:–c;a3:”éing1}:’ éismissed. ‘Na mats, ._
Bkpffis