High Court Karnataka High Court

Spartacus Flat Owners … vs Government Of Karnataka on 16 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Spartacus Flat Owners … vs Government Of Karnataka on 16 June, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy
E}; mg, ¥§1é<:;§~: :'_'z::¥~.:?;":' ff}? §§§£:¥§?§.»%.r§:3:§\:;X 5:5? 
§.'»A"f'§éiI} M13 -'m':e: 2527* 2:},-m:' £33' 32.9%}: :;:;:e:;:a;2
BE§'€;3RE:

 "fi{37§'\»I'?%7:='*i,E MR. 3¥5sE':€.§3

"é»fRi'1' PE:T:T:{;'z~.: :~»:g,§2fs;3 ::':§< 299? Qi"{:§§%§f?~§?:§§2§f%" 

7'}

_, .:'w

2552:'; PE';E"'i"'i"}0?«E' z~.2¢;».::»$% is , " 

WRET PE'i'ETi0N  1 1:22;} zféiké <{r:'§:':'::;>:-z 3~'s:";:3253sgo?:;:z' 

BE'1"s>'€'§',E,E'=§:  %    f  % 1
Spariaczus VH3: {3e.a;;i¢;::: f:_:<_3*G.§}€%§T;§,f§'§£': « ..  V  V 
Sosziaty 1:;§t11§E<:'§* _V  '  '

33:3 &.  3.9"'.C'::;g:g  _ 7

4*" 'T' Bieck, .Fa}ranag3afi f ._ 

Bmgaiere  Lt?r§£}%"é}41 " V

By its E§s%;m:;~.ta:;}?"¢1:;€i Cféé.;'--ef 'EZ3a<:saL{:§1:'iivs;:

1.

.2.

?§%Z’?§Ti’i’I}E”‘~§

% {-,B3:’ $§:§¥s:.:4;A;-::”;i:;:§;at, ;:*g;:~s;:e:;eai¢}
‘%L%%;£;;-fi:tz;».T ” ”

‘{“i:;¥:?€niz::1r2:§§:_ :3? Eiaézzaiaim

E’s5};’;«S,B:_:i§:§i3zg,
‘v”i£§1″231:1&~Vé3€=(§i1§,

.A Bairgaizi:-fa – 56% {K}?

its S€5;’»f€f$a£’:«,-I’, R€V$z1m.’- Qegzzfifizfizii

V’ ;C§1i$fCs;a:1i:23§E.i1:g Eiavezziie Aifiizuzizgs

—- 21’sz1é fmggsgcéog’ f,}€::c:*::21 (}fR€g¥:§§§1’€§:’:€.\§3

C@::x::1iss;%:;>1za::* £2? Siamps

A}\:;a:;§:> E€’:”i¥g3§% §»”~1:T:%§)”::;’7. % T LT *

5.)’

?’m Ifiioar, Elauvery Bhavan,
Px3fig.3§€’;’i’6 – 56$) 5%}?

3. Additional Ra-gistra1′ cf CC’-0§;)f3–f€1€§’v”&3* SGCi€E§£:~:’>;
3, Aii A:*s=§:er Rsryad,
Bangalore M 56$? 6352

4. Kamat33s:a Lka};z;:ki2:,
M.S.B1:iiding,, Virihzmzt ‘\;’ea«;§i1_i,
Ba:1ga§e¢:;m: :§s;::::,:::s:i $23.; zézg
R2362, as pay _»4s..rJ”ze3:s;r€–E riaieii {;!’3,_%L’:*.7f..1?§€Z}’?.«”‘~.. ‘ V ‘

WEE’? ?1:*”§”:’:i;:a:;_}_;_x; 5 ‘{‘iEx:§»3′:”:*’i:€£~;

3g::’xv§3’;=ga;

;_ {%:’22.~s22i’esv;: §T;{,¥£1£.%;’§ai§%’8

7.£is:>;;$.f;:g; Sv::;cis:.:tj,«;.. ”

?*eE–z.*;..i§7?’-5S.vv¥Z3f:§i§’2e:::’:i%;.%~ Ré::a<;i
Bagga':m A 9»-3:2
Rep:'eisa::s:t¢§§ by its

_ ' F{:}1i$fS«2c§e1:§r§; –

E,Z>¢;IE=€i’iVi’£i”i}’¢:;’ Seereizzsy’ F§%i’i”E’E”Z£é}’?~£ E13.

,{ E}? ‘$§’;:=§.Sa€?.Bié:a.i_,, _s3_z;§ve{:3,:¢}

M ‘

:

” E g Siam vs?’ Kmrzaiaiza

By Sifiéfiftffizifjy” is {3’¢j¥Vs3§§§11€ff}§9
§.€;.’=¥;r”%3!11.1£’: §3’§:?1i3é%I7§f§1.é:f§T¥§

6

{A£§£§§ti9:1a§ i3§}*!t::f’E1!I}§3§1i :’3s_x:E’i£a><::a1ie f¥:v:_' R;es;:E<}§2s:§:;~::t Ev? '§€e§-;g,2:}5;::é§é3~;::

E'*~:§-S,B"e2§§ei§ng,
Bangaicrre -~ 35$ GG1

2; §}iS'i§'i1.':i Rag§:'~:t:*a:'- szxzci

ifieguty Ccezmnéssiéaner sf Séarzzps

N<;,5€}* iiiizi ?~i«:2.2§,, –

3″ Fktver, Chara}: fitmei, V
§§a::g,a§e:::’:2 iJs*§}a:1 §}i:’§.=:=is.:i

Bzmgaitaret

Aciéiiiunai i:}é}”*é:’:¥?§!!;€1§i. ;§s:im:a:a£é§~«.’ €13 §’\§a’.2.§ 2:-53:?

Re$§senaieniE'%Ca.Zi}     *

S;'4'' ¥3&y!.I'.2{
..,, __, .,. , g V

This Wzii Fetiiimt  zigaziasg' 

€f;:»:1s;iii;:ii::::1 air’ _£.:::§§a: ‘§3;°a;yi&§2g _:;2:::r. . gym: {:3 BE .§}3\?f}{“§VZ {fig
:30: £’€:tg11i§l’i&» pzigfigxgiiit GE :-‘:i?:_:;::.t;1pj;:§;_:i§»,%

.-:;a.m’i§ 22′? :2’? $32:

XESRET ?E’17’3″i”§iT,?i-;

EET’€%»°’E1€i2g

E; ‘s:E;ir.§’sa;_2 Caymeraiivc i~§<y:;::;§:':g

' 'rd , V.

= Sr3£i€ty’E;.i::cr;E«3ai,

. *A.a3n:a*éfs§;§ra:ié-,~.§’€»'” Main,

‘ A E’a?i’a1§:<:§:t.*zJ.r1éx-'e 5" Seerstfirg-*

§:72§£'§a§}2"3éss3i C;:a<w;3v:rz*a:§xre Eifixeéixg
"$::»i:ifiy Limiiséi,
; _:~;o-2§s3_, W Evfain.

Eviaiiesizwamm,

Basxgaicera ~ §€>T€} {EH33

its Cizief E.:K§3$¥.%§§’%’i.¥ S£3é:§’t3?”{i_’i§’}’

8

Q
‘+

3. Pan:-SE2 szpartmszxzi Cooperative Heuséyzg

Seciaty Limited,

NM39 4″‘ Main,

Exgiaiieshwaraxzq,

Baxigaiore — 56%} (303

83: its ChiefEXesutive ;’ Secretary

4, Sh1’iCE1itrapu:’C«;w:g:ex’atiw Hc:;»u:-;i:2g

Seciety Limited,

E’»€e;>’é8, 1?’ Cressg

Ma}Ee$}:t.va1’am,

Bangai-ore —«S60 655 L ‘ ,
By its C’5:2i¢:fEX::w.:tiVc f’ S$e:r€i:1.r;y’ T . . X

(By S§1t’§.S.€r.Bh:ELi, Aévaerate)

AEED:

L Ka1i:a3;aiga– ” R’

M’.S.B1;i}éi§§ V 7»? .

Baxigaieie . ‘
Byits Reg*i:5Era.:’ _ A

‘~ 2. (3rQ:2c:3;::;ez1i’of-Efiiaiwzataka,

V’ A ,§vi.S,§Jé&£§tiii1g,
\r’i<i}1s;:;a~'{er;tdi2i,

. -.§~éa cu}:

‘ A its S§c3’¥:?:3i*§i, Revegxixe Qepazistieizi

— V 3. ‘?i2e~~ cf Co-«~3§)e1*a£ive

‘ .. S0€.ti€é?zé’&rs in Kamatakag

V ?s2é::.§,?§iAske:°Rx3aé,

V ‘flafigaieye –+ 36% CH3}.

B}-‘ Eta; ?;€g§S1§’£§1’ R.E$?{}:”‘€§}EZNT$

{giikiéiiifillai (3-e;:vem:ne:1i Aéanysaia Fm’ E{ti’§é}3*t§§”§4§€§Z§ 331:3

Rfifipfifiéfinl 334::–3)

%

LR

>¥>§§>.’£3~:i1.<:§:;~2:'5a"' "

Z?.€}6-2.{IrQ6 as 4: ;H»–'&m1e:<t.:r::t ~»~ D, etc. :
WRIT PE."fE'1"If§}35§ N0: 2_'_6_;E_i;'2C§G?:
B€'iW€:€:l"lI

Sah Eesmian Aparizzzezxts _

Cuopcrative Hrgrusing S<3t:i.=:t}<..IJi::1%§ed," '

219, Raj111&}1a1'-Jfias E§s1e:11s§imi,_A "

Bangalere M 55$ 939: T A 1

By its Manager a2::£'€3§:iei'E:iéci2{i'fve " 'V F'E'i'I'§'Ii'.7iZ'~iEZ-R

(By Shrig 8.6;..–';E§§3gt,5€;%§éf»*0¢§tg};- 1;."

Ami: ____ _.

1, (}»0:ré::’;22}1e:1§.0Vi”f<;;ar%:ia§a§im_ «. ' '
';\si'.S,Ez2iic§§22g,,' _ "

\r’id_§1ané”V§tL€Lihi;’ _ 1 ” ‘
BI8L§’}gz1iCr:’e “- §6{3V€E;?i1
itsL’5§ccre1ary;. R§:ve.;i-ma .I)e=partme;:t

A “1 _A » ‘ ;’.§V:aI’i!;;if2l3$I4&.VA:’_}i.3.§,€7a};1l§siT»:.&,

” ._M..s,,ja:;%;:;3§ng, ffxzidhm \;’eeéhi,

H Bf3.IIg2§§Oi*i*..~ 5 6§ (30!

‘l;¥?g_epr»:sez;’£<fé;–.:iA by Rs Regstraf

Z ' " " — V Adéitiézxai Reg} strar cf

' "Cg:-operative Sascgiseties,

= 1, Aii Askei' Roasfi,
Baxgalom ~– 56!? (352 .. . RF-S?(}N§E:"§TS

V' B}; Shgi Gawiiiarkxéev C. {.5 E331, ?1€§Vt}€?3iéi'~ figs: R»-1 ané 2 3

5

fix

This ‘s?€fit }’t?:’§,§’€i.f343§?

per §*¥.3f§n€15i”l.§1’€ — I}, c-21:11

‘4

“;’.’i”1cse Writ Peiitiorgs £2t)II”1§§%g 0:2 V§13§*”§3-carizzgg *I:§:}i.s§”«.i$:€§g’, :§§:3i’3’f§s;i:.1:.’i: ‘

made 3313 felktewizlgi –

.;r2:;;:;§ %

Heard the cozgzmei f:31§’.jE:he §.¥€*i§’i’§L*£i§.*i’SVV£ii}.§i :E:r.~:: fes;gx<:«s:1ier::is;.

Thess;-. p~¢'iiti«.?§2§ 23.3'-:5.— éiagesesi tyffirgi 131%»: .:1i&. “€§i:;»g:€’§}–eg”éi;fii«*«.~§ §§§€3u:i~:i§1g §:§:}t:§’r.?=’£:rci-4 ‘s:*«ag§:M[-:i;s::§’a:di
unéarc €215″‘pms,%;s;;;.3;;:;§%A: 5? u:§2;§”-Ka;’-r;i:i§2;i¢:§:¢ {;’i«;>–e:°a%:i<x%s;+ Sen;-ieiies; ;%.s;'i§

i.9i§':}.

,, “R2.-2; zzzexgibmfg efiigasge mwieiieg §:a”ve:: ;3c»<:2L.::s;§ ihéizi' resgaurces: and

»e§'es:*:é:é _ éweiéiigég tmiis fer §:a~i:= szywsa use' sifiez' imwsiizg e's'ese3.<::c£

agyéritzzszéfi; '?j§t?{>22.¢i§;:g ‘is; the s.~i§3a:’e:’«; a§§e:z»:§¢:i §f’% e§§?¢:;*:ié::g szzgiz

%:z’a.:z:s=f.:.~r Erf ::%:3:’es ami iiaéivery 3,g3a2i§::e::&a: magi &€}<Li¥€?EE?§%3§f§§.§§¥§g iémese

g.

3%}

F’umu.-mi £01313 Smzxe this agygmais we:-re: tL§$§?€)St3(§ af

amci the «;v2*§ez’ ofthe Eel’-11t’§isZ:f3 Sizzgie imige was s=:ei:~a5:§<ie–,

4. ‘§’i:::”.=:E1:1;si: <1? 3&3 arg:3::2eff:§§’;& ¢7e;;2’u«:1:;é;v«§ in; :§3;:~”:«.::a,g;¢ Vf:¥§4L§V fézaizgi

that, in View «sf 3:3 State €.}<,fi§e§":::":}ei':€ Eizwizxg a:%;:s_::_s:§'e%«;ia~:§e;i %;;%;&i.

Ax':::':nz§i:2g Ac: 6 <3'? 2¥3i3§ Wixfiisi §121V€* ;}:'*£2:%§¥s3€s: 0:: 12:4: gar’: x:::”‘i}:c’a;-: ‘ %:.1;iig;;i::s §éi”§,f:1éV g2sres~:::*1r::.i
3:3 seeiszixig fie i!”!}§3{3$#.:Z’- {>11 _.~;_:-23;:::A%i.j.::*é;::sa¢::ée:2s §§§’§(>§’ 12;)

€)}..(}4.2Cn3}. x¥ij¥§1e::L:§§u:’i3i£§cvtim1…é3.::t§.2%$§1;t§:i_E.é§,{f§iEegaE.

$1′-£31: the :;:£.”§1vé%”-§1a3:zi;”E3_:é”{4′;>i;¢r:r§::é:::i giévacaie wgrzéiii seek in.)

a:0nte::s:i firm:’.:.s:1yiéxii§;5;t::11§i§_:ig«iii: z:fi:3«;:2ra figs:-. ifiiyésiesza ‘§?4e:2:::§1 j:2c:§g:+:1r:e:’::’,

–‘ V. ‘_ %i?§3§§_i3§’§3’«:.¥’€2i $’~ ;§é.sp@sé:;§ ..:;zf v%¥’i7f.§’?;2}21’E erni<::=i.:2g :=.,":§;:”: figs: mafia ::t:z~;::2:i;:=3_;:§;’ a ::e:€:;:s¢.:: Sizzgie Eszcigé 4;}f§3″i§:% Com? 5:2 3 S§EJ£§Z¥S$(§23€§’§’£ .21′:a§:i«;:z”

izézg : yééag tz1§c;£~.:: :§E «:?1:$}€§ §§:e:’af§::w $26

X1′ £re3::ié;’;ii0:2 iiéiai iiie 5 Q?’ 12€}s’3§ §?«,=*”é.T:s§,’§§£fi Egave g;:;*£9Es§£§£;:! asgzzé :§2::*:*¢.i33:2;: iéezit E.a:£.¢:’ yiazg gyflééis {f2;32::r: %.5é{s£’:§£§

§1*£:,°i?s~.E= £2} Etna fi::%Es::v«ges:§ 332:1 iihai the 3-‘:21:-“§_; 2m3::§a_i §¥:~S:’§?€’ $12 %:i>e ::;.’;§:§:3:’é,

Q

‘H
his visw s;,»i”i%:¢ Siaié: havizxg :;:s.:»::e:.e::ie:;~.:;i ‘Liza pizsiétfiirrz $22.: :’?%.s;=€ 5:?

iii}? waiazid ap§;:§},=’ gyrcgsp-:c£.iaiei§; fi*s:«:n {)1 .i34x2i3i3i azmé ibis Ezavészg igivseas
i’es2t)I’£i§i:r&i by as §3’si:i§:”si:.:~z: i~.§;+m:§1 safthisg (391121. azzgi 32::-? :’%-mi:-.21 e»’£’ §:§§%v:g§e

Eusrige §}£}§{§§lg tea ifsse s;:amiz’a:’§:’ izavitég §:ses::u ,<:&t–:atsic§£-',2,..~§;.*:$g2?%:'" as :§.";c:.

1'¢t:~<;yspa€£§ve effizact -.1»? iixa: Sectiozz is; s:<s3:1s:e2"§1e<}1. i:E':i:"»:_.,<C§'t”:’i;3£i§’§. ggzgii j%:§:$:_ :2;:E<;;a:::"if:;¢§_:3'E;§ré:
the said Divisiem B3342}; wmié §3§1ni.:_h«: Siéis; ('§r3x::=:':3z;i:::;;:t§' '

.2'-Xi: *:’ciit:g§§;, the periiiiamss aye é§§§g§w¢.;é.

§.:1r:é§né;;?::5 5 XE? .33′; »7,’§3{>, $2 S;§é”3{3€}? qaassixeczi.

:’~’i:’_;:2::%:»;:§1’%: -;« ;§’§i1L4′?\f’;?.v’?%?§J:;§_§3E*if2€}§3? cgazasizaéi.

nil

;=’2::;:e.é§<3,::*e;,v:– ":1 in "'-5«.:"'§%',._'.:""~és:,»,,i E52: ;'2%f)i}6 :;.,sa:a:';'%:a::i§

r

.. :'*v~'k:'i£7i819£E,T:¥é;:V='F" E} ix; ':?vfi?. $01262 E .:'2{E%f'§? {;i2&S§¥t$€§.

.» "mac
rm":