High Court Karnataka High Court

M.Naganna S/O Doddanna vs B.Thimmaraju S/O Late Bheemaiah on 4 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
M.Naganna S/O Doddanna vs B.Thimmaraju S/O Late Bheemaiah on 4 August, 2009
Author: Arali Nagaraj


:32: ‘mg §2;:{§:§ GQEEEET’ {gs §{AI€§”%;%T£§§;% xix? ”

:3;m%::> wig mg ism” 33%? §%;é.§%;;~zE%ST’ ‘%;;@:%3<~; 'V: { 7

BE§'{:;=E{_E:

372$’; ‘.E_~-§€;}E~E’E%i.§:3 2v§E€, §§:M:3’?§é$§§;a,§2A:i %;a;g§<;g:m.;


€;'if%IEvfi?€z%L gé§i:?§:;:': E§T§§:;%$€'3_8 f'2SG9

§g:*:*w§,;:5::~«: V     '

iii iééagazzxaa, §  ~ V .
é,§f{:..§.3a<i£ia:};1a,"'   
fzgazi 553031  §5fi.¥}'7:§'S3 " '
§%ifa,?¥ia;§i£ii%v:a;§§'i$.  
{}{3i?§'{§Eé§;'<3.?€ ;%§é7:;;§;3;,  
 *§a;=;:§.<g *   " 5* 
'?m;";::3;<u:* 1Z'}i';§2i:*'§$;:*::,'  V 
Efirz: $52 §.3§'*l._V

.. %   ,3" E2aba§§;";%.;§;.ts,.:,«}'

'*9§«s;fi::%'*; 

E: 'T§'£:i::.;%.::2afaij;é,::_, 

V " iE§;'<}.§af;{: E%§*:é;~::3-:§.aia%;3

'§:€:?i|{}s'1_E'§?{.}tEf,E~'}:A'::N$a.. a,§"

" " 'A 1  ' -i~"-Eiza 'f£}€%'§"£*'&i"i§
 ' §?:%s€'riLE;§,z2 weriiéxzg as
4. " §i§:*é3;:t_:E":".Eéa1';,age:tr in
 _ V?{}i%'"s§"i CG~Q§}€§'&i3:°éf€2 fiazzk §J€<i.,
  V  e'E%:iz*:;2.; £}i:3£:r"i{:§ '§"'m'n§~:u:*,
 girizz: 572 mi?"

,, ;E_g3psé§iaz:'::

H, E1'Z'€$_§'3{3z:<§e:3§



“{“§:is.–“; iiriiléizml $pp€aE ES fiiezi} E38 E§’}'”8{~’-%-E 5:)?

£111? 21:, _3:”a§,,2′:i;2g {:3 Sat afiiflifi the <.r;'{i€,:* daiwi '2s:*'§.§;'"§s.,T;;«'?_;s';';E}4'§L%T._V
§,'::as2;€a:'?; ':35; <:<:.~m"¥:. GE' §:<%{§E§i:3:'::;:E {':i'§i} a:§iE{§§*5 {S:'.:§?3'vgM1_.':a–,;%.;:%é7i.
&'M§%"{'E at $3353 in 2:'; {Ti §'€<:;,'?€42;'2€}€'}:3 233:1 c::az'.':=;g§,€;f%','* "

a{:<::2Sa{i _{ §*é:§§30::<§€§:r:L

'E'hE$ {§.'ii%m%:':a§ .<%g:;;_:sea3 itaézzzézig 5:': {:5 «%§{%;;i:3i:asé{:s:?:_3;'.§'é§s*

siiagzi, Eizaé <:x.:}1.:::: Eflafifi é;E'1c;': i"{;~»§.E{;V:sM;_::§g;%:_~::’L =

‘- E”:G2.:gZ§’: {£213 ap§tta§__i$ §i$t=<:<;fi Eb? ; '{§{é?%?8§'%?:.§f}§}, E2

E3 mkaazz far $11183 £§%3§%3 s%3;1;:«':s?.' '4 <35 33 E? 3

Effiakfsgaiifi The };£:.:-2:.f;ia'€t§§ ';§;;;:s:;;a;»::4% \-94

(.:{}§E}§}§&§§§E§§"E§..__. €";::§'é..:.S_«:-*r<:§fi§° sf :i;i{I{§;"é.i§_§f;§C:E§;L–»

'"1.!"i

'§"E:¢«*: ::':§;§;;){;t~E§a_:':5'i*V §'é'{i€':2.%,:':'~–.L:ax:':a§ %:§'":<;: :C€3E1'E§;}§é§§§.'§E§.§1%i 2.2"}, 211/

_ '2€'}»*§'%§ $33.' AE'.,%_§<-§ fééé-: £22' '{§'E€? ééiafizeéi §3;€§{i§'€§{}1"§§3§ Qfiivi}

K3 wcigéi §;§§_f;sZ.'§§"Ef:1,'}-..a§§<§ ».§i's';E§"€f: eat: S§§"a {h£::§*ei;':a§%.€.§' 2%-':§'{:§*:*<a{§

€223".*.5§'r§é;«A§s,32z;ii"V.§7<::* 5;%':<::r%:.}; Er."-if: hag {:fs_1a§E€a:3:§§e::§ as 3333

e§g}§:3:::af§" iézééj'2.::'§gI§;<:§'§:. 332$} §*d€«::’° ziakzié 2$.$:.2€}{§%-i §:=:aS$séd

‘éI£’:e%;-.§;3i€§ <:21$€: acigzéiiizéag '33:: §'{~:r;~=:§}s:3:':<§€:":§" ~ a{?€3E.§.S{'f{§ sf

-.f€;h€?:’~:;}fi”{é1?:Ctt §,3§:::,§€3r §E§{é«::€f2z§3′: E38 Qf §*€§:g{:E.%.aE>§€ §i’7iS’€3’E}§E§€’:f’EE$

“~.;3%:é:§

c_……§”‘\—-.__,,.

iiéézpaaitiofi £3?’ .;3’%3JL 3 sag)?’ 0?? ‘Ei}.’}i€}”E £3 §%§;%.’33iSh$<i ~§;é:;:–»

{:{§L1E'§, bf; 2116: 2::a:*I1as:§ {';{3'%,,'§.Ii§.%=EE§ €01" ma 21;':§§?e3§§:3;;;:§.L-'" 4 .

<:<2m;;:3ai§2a:':$% it amid he: seam iha:–€i"'1<:'.—{:s:31:;;:3}ai£3§:%::. :3;23.';~3

gm? siiatesi Er: $133 €331}::i1'3,afio:*:-i:z1-$hié,f_ fa:-:z as

(33:52 E13 Eaiffi. {E16 Said 8Ii1{§§.§§1E'*v'§5" ..¥i;§"y:*: $,::=::z.:5::::T§._: "Eggs
Séaifigi E21 Ezés c§"@$3~exa:*§2§;1a{i9f:' '§}:f:a§; "::?saf2 '22§E%';*;"Eé'fis'{Z%§, he
Em}: "E3718 Efififififg' amé; {:2}? éiiifg' 's§é;2:é;"<'§a;;g~. j§f:1::" zgbtaiizfisi fiaiit

{f§1f:(;§_'E,i{i E17: {L§§N§{f_i%§i.L3,f3§§'§_'. §§'a%:2": -:31'c':7'_i:z.s§€;i<§.';j' E: is :1<:=':; :55;

€§i:a;3u%.{~: ~=;:E*:*'T':'~ §f§?1§Ei§§i§§'£i.§;i":£§1"'i€;""EE€§$ 39%;. ;;;:'@£§a::$::i gay
f'm'é'.%"2s:::° E:3z%%;§.§:*:z:{:s:.: ..§.e3C{iEE£€fH§,€i3"'§' $23' $3}, Ea}

§?;E:i}€$fi=§3E':i3:§€='1§ff -Eaéfg .¢:i}§:€;:::':*cE0;:": ma": figs: 263m 333%: aaié

323:§€3zi.§"§:. Q11: '#3:: 8aié"'?s::E:i1:€. §?1§§':f:fif1, .38 ;:';Zg}':é;§§:' s%3$€:**J'€{§

E33; iiiéjggsi" £33 impugzzsgfi §z.%a{§g£:3€:§.{T§ ht: hag E'3{}"{

§;s%:§<:§r;<:s:§ %:;:;{:;;m;s.: 52:": {"{"i'-CG§'€'§ {<3 :~;§:aaz: :ha':i 342% iiaté § §"§§§{,

-w__§3;.m::§3 :3? :;f:%:;:§éé§; €531′ Esizzéizzg ifias: SQEEEE $8 %,§’:s::- a€:{::_:$a:3z’§,

Q.-., ‘-.i’?;’E’:e {§€?§B1%.”§{‘:-if <3? ?§.§€i a{:<:2.:$<:{'§ is; %:§z;1§; he ésasi

"§.ETI?g37:"iS8C§"§%3§i§: %I;§ii..7i: Qiléi' *'§'§{a§.jg%§;€:Sv;a:::fg, who azgsié fig} $1E§}§}}}f

" " "E'::."2%..3;':;<: "§':<:E«:'§ é}§}§"}§ia§i€;':{€§S ii; 3.33: £ii§{§'i.§$€'§{;§ 212:5} '?£'1':{::"::fs3:'e he

¢—-.!""""\-\/

had is:s:_z€=:i a %3Ean%=: askzequé €:z::2 the said '§'2";.%g;3§e$§iz *

and ha :2:;i$L§s:1:3 C§fi1";f§;3§§ '£8§':§..

§r"€€:fé:3'i"%:'1g? :0 {Fifi 5-mswga $€ate231r3::£:«A:;i':e:

§'€C{}.E'{§€€§ $3? $26 '§'riaE Qaégré _ 15¢ §;'12..__2ef}8;§~,_ %fE.'_:é""§':'iaé

Caurfs E195 righiéjgz sbsegfigfid ' :€§:e.._ $23.5
séaiéid Ehfiffiifi ihgéii "mi: kféavfii :9
him. it $8 $326" §;{:f.§E,?.££§ "23.€{:'a2.$<':.€£ in a
czézzaéizaé <:=a$»::" ETEEL3 éafemte b€_'§<"QE1z:i

_:*€::r;s:”1a%2}.a:~–‘T:%:;§’:T3Ti;iT, ‘§;’§*:$’=sf:s:T§”;€:”‘*haé::::}, *EE”i€’: cmazpiaiizazié

E233 €33 §~:ég:”abE§$Ii’a %: “~:€ “§:ab§e éz3a2E}€:, EE: :3

itéaéaz’ :%’3§3,{ $19234.::{;m;2i;3§::a:;%: E<:a_:~; §§{}§; $S€.a§3E.%.s§":€:<:§ E33 saga

" nmagfg", E'§'€::.%:;3_§i ::_a§3&Cj%'E}_¢"v—?:,{-:s'§:E:§{i 'i3<":s§f£ :m:=,:th sf fi}.G§"i€j;=-" azzd he

§–é;:%:':§ E3":;:;j 'iii? i:3:";<«: acczssed am} $2215 ascugeii

g§§¥§;:A ;;~gm 32115:; 'i:f:'&*£a=3:?:§"::s: 'E3': q'%,§€S§ji8E"§ €3zz;a2°{is regiayfiafizii Gf

éiéfgfi $a%::§~é:}2:2": fiiéfiiéélfii. :5 is figs saiiieié pfi "{'3§:§£3§f: as Eaiéé

5§*:_§%;::1 _%:E€2:¥bEe Su§;:*<t::':.:=:: €f';s2z:?%f; ii: 'éhé': {':3.$£"": <2? §*{?'é$§'z32a;

-._’ ;}a2’2§§2z’d}:m’: Bfiaz -::s=~ §gff§’a§§”:c:g Eegaxde §eg:;=0:”§.€{§ fizz afi

iififig SS 1325 §;§”:aE’: _;::§*€:s;z;’§z:p£;ic:z3 za§:(,?;s:’ Seciizisn };;f?é% sf’

.3′? E fast s’£1s«:§i Eiszaézss $9 $5 yaisitgé :;:3fifi;=; 3&2? {E13

c_._s\-V\,

::*:m;;3Ea§:’:a§2″§: a§;E.:3;E:zE}:§.h@s; {“ZXiS§’.fEZ;§C€§ 05 Eagaéigr

::E:i’Qi: 3:’; 0:: {ha {Eats 95 %:,E'”:s;§ C_E:<;::;:.3.z*: in :;§3::?§;€.§{';:'i;k j.%:'=: E;h<§:

-e

§:§5~3§zi;r:i: $3353., ::%::’1 £253 §::3’€:$’::::2§§:é{§:z ‘ %.:§”«.{E:*-swig:’–::t€;;;=ii{%;*

$fi::E;§{§;;}. ‘:£%€% :3? 52’ E .;%.€:%, ii”: §a<;<};z§5" 9.?" %;§i2f§'-{:c:z:;:§.3§&§.§3:§3§:'?;},

saizé ;:§*{–&:%::z,:z1:§3€:§9§:: 3392.5 3:33:35; S1:é:::§€$%f2:iE§";;°§:1éé:;:€:-iisszi'fig 331$
a€:<::.2s:«::£ hasssd {HE §"2§se;' ':};*::§§§3¥;§:%':§::::g:é"~.g;;:":{§ aha: 54;:-w32":%':

S§.8.?,€:'_§I3€§EEi ezaf EEK: ::s:}:I;;g3Eaiz;:a5;":j{;

S15″: E?’ i§f}:£:’};}.2;2i3i; ._::IIr’.;%:-… i%,:z3:V°:’:€:e:j£ {§(}§.’:E”§Sfi§ ;?E:’::’ 332$’:

z%;§,:g3z::§§a,:[:::’i’= -~ <::i;::i2':;;:E._ga5;§g?';a.::éiV%§':.§3 _s*§.:§.§s:a§ '2.:§::<'2:'": 22 €§i"?7£'-ii-§§{§'§E a?'
'$35: §~§:=::e:i?z'?é:fE§: 4' %§:,:§;§'e.:§§€f: _{:i€.'3_"§§.:'.%i in $25 sags": <1? Kzazfia?

Exfiarzg' «»a;*3~ :%J§;?.;:2:$e§ :"§:_§}§§"{§:zii in §§.,R fififig §{&§E

§:$3:Z. " 3% §é§":2::§A_. <:§{:»w';: £2": fix-3 Saki C8135: éézzzé, :E*':{-*: §s:E3':,:§i?;aE

<25'-~[§2:"€:_53xs:é§;:1§§§'§§":_::t"a:a:';:%<ar S§a:::§';§a:"} 33 ~ 3:? E3 3? iisgzssig 3E=iT3§L

;*é:§'z,:§:*2::*: "%.;';iéijg»=':f2=;":d Ef{i:s'";i-%€}';E§§§}§€ {§{2':§%::s"?z $522.33 ;a;£::§€i’§L¥1%§:§:»;

4 g:r,ai*{:%§gé;’§3.§€: Tnzas :19 %:§’*{::3;g§2€: {:52 E? 2{“:{:§’*:§ “ééfg ‘é§’:§: ,;32_C:::”a::§:_”~:{§,

_’.EZ3*;€:%§’:”é2.;ég3Ejg*;§”:ig iihit §§’§;z”§{Z’§§}§€”i :31 §l§E{‘3 ésaéaié sags: {.8 Em’: fa_5_’;::~;

–._f<,%;§"'€,§'i<ir §:;:'é:$a:§';{?: §:tas:«;z':":, E as}: {if {E353 {§{§E'iSi{§€F€{§ f;}§}iE}§{}IE éézaé,

'figs a<:<:L1s6z:§,§:{:{£ §3Z'{§S1§.§EE§}§};*(§I’} §’E’T2:§;é.

M

{:{;*…:E{3 ‘E:a’2;t: Eareézz i”a£$${?; ilfiéiiif S:§<=:c:§{:sn; 33?} sf N Is': 2'i%§f§i._T§;§:v

favmir ::}f fizz: C{}i?&'§_}§é}i§}8§E§;.

3593? éihfi }T’€i’3E§G2£S af2″‘€sa1§{§.; E326 9’,>;*:<%S€:1%§ 23;1s":.if::<1§E i:S V'

digiiiaéssfieéi as Eeirsg sisivaid <1? zzzazfi-.:§;."'.. .§"*3{? {:3§ii(i€i:* 133°} iéé"

QQSE

Rim}; "