High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Nagamma vs Sri H L Satish on 4 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Nagamma vs Sri H L Satish on 4 December, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
'§'§~:§E{Z .§§§'{§:r"-E. i§';C37U'R'"§' Q3}? E{}§1%E\é7?:T'§£.§{£%. BY? §3§'§N§§?3.i¢{}§~3§':

Batéizi 'aha ééfii éiay" cf §.Z:€{:e:§:E:e<~:1' Qijiiéi
:BE*":E'{.3§%:%?::

THE: §£i";3N'BL§£ ME7<1.JE§STi€:  ';

E"13.7£%3E?¥ :

E.

S:1:LE<§ag8.m::?:a§   ,
Eififc} Mala§;r;}a,, gigztié a'b<;u%: *1 I. '§;'€?i"_.'s.f;':'2§e

Sr'; Eresha,   
fa .{¥Eaiap_;:2:3_? Aged ab:;_1_§._ 1-.1_ 3-':;a:'S. '

{S:I::c€ the a'§}§}{3H£3§.:'3f   ;'€}£§TL'§;£fZ.§1"" §§¥,1'~§"'§e»'--.b
rap, 7:3}; E135 marker azfazfi r'f;ait_Ii::'z:&._ " V  
g'§,§Ei'{ii£iI1 €333 §;pp:s:'if:an:§: N€3., §-V} " '

 arc": 1£'_f?§;v§3§::i'}sf§»{§'i'1§.'§§i§':%§;€§
z~'::i:<:hz;.3:z::'- £"r3S:'_, E§;i«2f;§;:s:~;:-;12*ié~§r:éé:f{,, .-- 

 V' '-- " " R,.£a;3§3€:§ia:":t:.s

  {  §?§fN,.§i'é.fi'S§'l §38.'iQZi & Jkasficiaiag § ?:fi§<"€}Ca§1€i8. }

 Va 33:; 2 V  ' » 

2.'

'  ;"f:':*i."'i..ET§.'}§'_";«'.,V.§:*§&'§:§S§§$
" S 53:: '"§'I;§;iz1gaiah3, Rf at £611} §_is2;a:;1a§'3.a§§§

E5Z;&i:"i%i€§ E%ii§;a::_§§, fr'§?3§¥§}§.g

" I _§a_§1311aga;:a "§"'a§u.k', §E€.C,€I"f;x:*§:::@:*}

' "'§'_E":€ EZ3§"2?§$§®I1a§ Esxianagfii',

'§'ha ffiriautai §§1s2_::'aI:<::€ £533" Liti,
E'*€<:s'%é§», Lea Séiagpmg iimmgsifix,
Regiéancjy fifsafi, Bangaimre.
¢ . .R€ES§3Q§}{i€i'."i"f,S

 E3}? 32% 'gffié é§§'°8;f-iaiié-§; §'§%¥'£iiE':f'{, ;'3;z:§€s::{:3,%,.§: £93' .E%~£, Z:



tmi

§;§'is::€:fia11t:@u$ §3i:*:':§E., Apggseai fififigi 1_m::§€:r S§'";'é3--35;§€}:';

§?3{.§} of MR? AC1: agaiszfii: %"i':«3j*:_1: passed in §.,sm;: mg. ::=t;,z;2:::<}:s'; i:j"::.1:§'":§)s:)i§ta1': Ama, }8.{§::g:é§E':;::§:';:i 

fiéfifkifig e31}'1a11ce§1:m::§ cf 11:§ié:r;ssa;€i§.3o*'§1f

This agtrpeai <:{311'1.=i1'}g (;:1"'§£}:; 'E"2é::r;'i:":g; €§:;é:; iiajg, ?;§"15'W§:2g':L_  j. " V' '
 &%.,",;f._a.§..J._.i%:r; a§%«:;:M':A%:a;::%  A

Thfi é:%jI3:§§{%:':$é*:.:i<:s4i§;5.'imékareiieié "E3;-=-' the. §2?L!--§,<Z,"'. in
  aaileti. in :;_u:=:$*£;é<:31": ix": {his
appizai  4' 'fiié 'v..<?V§2§:?1:1_3;i%:_f::LSs V' an the g:*::}:,1§":f.% Eéaafg EEK:

e::o1::;::§=:1::1::a'{i{2:1"a2$§31%:i:3{§T is {:11 E316 iazsrfig' Sfidfi: med zhozzgh

?ifé';«s3  fiifi {§§C€'Z&S€£T: was iakéil at :3g;§{}€}f « E363?'

:L*':3<3'§{-T::;f'::E::A,, " ':E:::3_{:;%:1§§':$;:1s9;:%:: mgggizgii: is have 3936:": a:§:23;:'s:§;z:?:{§_

_ §::a¥ié"':§ €'¥c5g:3;:'*:% is"; $15 E§?.§'E3§3{E_§§'€?€§ 'iiafiée givztfi in 'iE'}i"§

 ,s5{;.§"1&Et;d::Eé" 3:) {£15 Esziatar vgiizisias £91, _§:';::'~;@§'a:*' as $526

. '_.€'3f¥{;-i§i§)%31'1Sa'{;§€}I1 §}8_'€_;'3§}}.€ in 2.1 ;:e?:'£?tie:§ fiieii u§":€iei" Sfiitiimi

j .  ' :u'--;3~A of tha Act,

2. Tfie E$a:"*;.i:a§§ {:a::3as€§ far {he a§:3;::fi§ia:'1?..& ;3ia§:i1":g

§'€.f§:i8:§"i€:{fi 13:': 3 i}§a.«*i:é;§{):3 ET%<:.:':<t7§: :i::§%';L$§0§: {:5 331:3 {T:(}Ei§'§ ii}

 .

;}

?xfE.E%’.£¥A§?{§. ;’-E:{}i:’:EEéj2{}{}€ia :=:1’1$a’:io:1 $5513: is §3a_’§’ab_E:::–.2¥;Zt3;é%;¥€§” –§;.E%::. ~

agfi :3? $316 decsasfizi {hives Iii); …$?§€:€e{i V’

F:’S.£3,8«’€~.§{j1i;’9£Tijv« Eess 3.j3, Whie:::_h <:1:?u::'1£;§:$'*TiT4s3 T§%?E:=3,_V;?ET.,:.3é::a;,é}ii_':;&

and if tbs: £:c::I'B;e:1t§911ai a:1i:2:}:=:3; is .:'4::*§_<.it:«:§ Vi','if1VV'é§,W§,§E;'zIi'E of "

§€':s.i§,5€;}{},!'~, tile}: E316:_.CO1};1'§)f§§'}f£»§EI.§fii'1.._gfiifiaQ'L§.fr}§§Tiii2;fi€%i"§ 233;:
§~?:s.4,€:i3,:"§U{}]~' Thsz afiaijyi' ai3;I:%'::§;11€:';=%i:r§1*::i%::r{:, 3:3 £33: £326:

i{)"§5.«-'€i' Sifitfj.

3. iriavifigu .,iii’f:z_€};:4A_3V1″a:iV” Eta ‘aii30£fé:V €fi’e{:€: this isamxegi

ca’:.:.11s«:éé.,_ fax’ ‘i:h<i:";:§§§::g§é_§Eai':€:$"';:%::{:§ ?.i'§'}€}£1 hea1'i1'2g {E16 iézarnfiii

cminsei fé';1__ 37%;'-;2 V'i:1$:;1":a1:§}:€ ifioxigparijgz in $315: sags: j<g thez: ".":"'1'i'§3'L1:"1aj§

'i€f$.'2V,'§.§f%';'£?{}i}[ »§ the Eiéifiifi ";5.?§.§§ E"13;V€i £13 £36 §1:<3<.i"§_f§@=:§

"'£f§53,a §:gf:';:s$f§:'zé§r:%". $33.2 Em ezziiéiiéiii £33 E€$.5%§€;i}%:C%{}€T};' m €93'

j iim :'i::;%.'-§.$"'::s«V:":s§ Elitffiiiiififlfifi aiiifii 33 {E18 siaim §3€§§i§{3E} wag

"..f§*?§3;¥:§§";..1:":dt:;:' Sfiifiiifiifi §%;§Z§~»;% 0:" {ha .§2£E,':f,.:%{:§:,

44 '$15 appfial is agiiaawazwzi :9 331a: 3339226 :»':x:e=:z2:€'_ ii:

" m:E':a3'::C§:':§.§; 353$ {:0::'}§j:£::1$ati0§': 3111:3233: 353$ {ha E:;::€:.€:.:*§:s%.

' :

:;3«3,j2’ai}£é% is 21%: éffizé; a3:z<'§ %;%§€–: €i@p::)§i.%1 Shaii Em fig ;':§:';:'– 'Rim:

$613115 93" {ha 'E'§ié%3u':3.ai'

C}:{'{": f u