High Court Karnataka High Court

Sarvodaya Education Society vs State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 20 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sarvodaya Education Society vs State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 20 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil

§§§ Tfifi §=§§§§*E €6¥3R’I’ $3′ ;:

§;”E”A§§,& fig”? gafiaggzéxgp

yawn mas mg gem may $1? 51513; geasé.’ ;.. A’

%S§?’$RE

153$ Ho:-$*3LE rsiR…3Us*1€§1cE $3; ,$;., “:*s,,as:i:%}:E.;.’: ” 4′

W,E1§e. 3..5′?G2I 29:f3§

§ . ”

23.3 :§o$15?03!2s?s;*3;9§ “§Fs*:nH«ra.%3m..==-.§-=
mp. §re.1s?e4;2oo9-£233-RE-§%EG~Fi’A ‘
wfi 1~:o.163er4;2*:);q:f9;E5E.:sL12r;.G~?}
war. i’~Ic.153§f£¥f2t’)€-§ ?iEi}B§i”-E§;IIg;§}}

BE’§’WE§§%’:

$2m:<;{§.a§;a; Ei§=ii;ca £iv;c&:,éj' VS§§€ié?:3;;-. _ V' ;

5% §::g;5.sie3:1°e:{i ES<:»2::i$§j;-1'.,:__ 3 V
§€a§3:*a5:se::€:€§t§""E;'§,: ifs S3<*I1%:fa'z'j;{,"'
Sm; rv:,G.1vgfi3?a;.r.;<~;z::z;a«:t_, '
Ageszi 38 _§;*éaIf3,_ V . "V
330.74, 21353 533933, A
"'s?ri:$11abas2"aii:i§;aga:;

§{;aa:;a1{:si;ip;&i}-‘a, ‘- ‘ ‘

.{3ja;;gg_«~;{e§gre;;’s;<~:;§,

‘ fig §{?é:g§s€e1*€c§St;}€.,°i’&:§;,

_E%&p::€:E§::ni:e.:{ ‘i§f;’ §iS Séesmiary,

Ejarfiafi Shah;

” ” i»3,gt:E 3? §,r€a:’s5 mg,
‘ ?§$’§;?G§{ ‘iiagar §,.:a2j§{:::fi,§
_ “;§1§”:i–§3§€§”§:%9’§E€§€ $3932.,
__ “§,”§?az2gf;a§<;:*€ ~» E§:"i={} €7}<%i§,

A §7'aé§,32?i %i"7:'a;,%E?:1;":':=§§ :»:;3::§ §:§:izz<:a§é.{';::a§

Sega '?:'::&s;:, 5% §%{-rgégféirrrfizi '§':{*:;;s$,
§3%:.i§}§*é:s§:t:;:.{«2ii E33? Eta f+E::%€:'§?§ar§?,
§{,§~§g§€&:zm[§aE':§

PE«TI'£'§fi§ER
ifi. fiR?..;E§0, E5'?'§3i $9

?E'FE'£"§$1¥ER
Ea §§.?a§§§, §5?§3f§*§'

Eigisziraéiozz Qepartmsnt,
i'vi.,S.;B1;2ii<£ir;g,
§3a:;.ga}ar€ ~ Sfifi G81.

2. Caznmissieaer fer i3ubI;i:: E;:.s’£m,2c:’:i021$,
Efiepartmem Qf Educating
Nmgatzzzsga Raad, ».

§a1:a.gai:::::re -« 356 G3}? I

ifiepzzty Dirscisr 9i”P:§.:)i§{: iIz,$%:;:’11»:ftia:;–:f:,
Eiangaiom North, ” _ V . _ ‘V ‘
Baigggsé-are ~ 569 062. u ” RES?Q*fiDEI§’§’$
” – . u ” « . .,g;c::::a:zsmre*;

{By Sri,R.P.Sa€jza11a.r&}?a21a–..$§’%}g§1;

Tézig Wzié E?5stiti§§:f:-:1.§S:f’1},éf:Z”%1::»:§%”:3’i’é§r%.1::’§&%g 225:» 5% 22:? g;.f°i%1€
{TZig;.ns?£im’£1?02:: 01§7’Viflr§1ie;I.V__§:’:§ra§*é:§g_ V*1″.@_ :°i:$i’:f_ai!1_ {E16 z°£3§}<3§3z}€;1is £1133}.
:3nf@r>1’é£e2′ 831$ __’§11€5.gm€§1f daiad
{}2,{}?’,2{}€?8 ef–:f}}_:6 7’if?’:3I}:’ “~§f~§er:c?3–. sf this C;s;*»uri: in 333223:
%fii–§4363}?VV’.£g@% g;§<e*:c;;::-az;f:¢:§ "£;LR, 2:393 E{A;%T€ 2&5; 2{3{}s{4;
Eé:7§’0f”§?e’:£§:£¢::er zmé zizersfere ta: quash
$225 :’€j€c€§Q§:’a e:;:’r£a:””‘ ::i:»:s.’¥::{fa§_ “_;2f3,{}2¥i.2{}{}9 éssuaéi E1}: the :3I’&
;i::3sv;§<;m%€::1:: visié' ;%Q':.2:r*§;i1rS~%§3 sic"

"5' §?;:3E%%:i0:',: <":af3g"z'§:e;:'gé::1; fin' PreE§m:'m€:sz*y _E£":=2a:"£?2;j"; 'B5 iiémup

é_.E:§,;=:5 s:§ €236 V§:1~f}}i£7£v}1i3€§.€ the f:}};EnW:i:1g;»

Gfififik

E; .V Sizzc-5 ;.i"§3EB§}.Q§}: ::;}:aas?i{:3:$ <3? Eaw amfi fa<:'.€.3 am glzavaivfizi in

§?:*ég psié?3?@::$, $316}; 31% c2ub§a€§, glzzsaré iagafizsr 333:?

_V :§é$2§:<;¥s~'.:§ir:£ csf by zézis aammzisrz azfiérfi

?€'€§'i}:G§§€§'f-§*§§{i7L2{?a{§G§}£§§ 'E3123? are ciiizaziéézizgirzg {ha

" f§E}i:"§(;3§'§§€IE1fi'§}.'fS .§$8§.:s:é E3}; E§:a:+5 '§'¥.§§"'}:S{§,"§€?i€}I"i&2 De§::€i:}; Ejfiérficriazz" 2:3?

#7,

§::«3:s:=;? £%§'3{§ GI}; '$3.3 m€'r*i{:=;. fig {§i§€:<':%iQ::: ii; 3:333 ififiiifiii is} 'i'.%3.315 ii-?€€}<." {mm £313 ajiate 0:' fiiizait <3:"<§:.§:f a”:.fi§’::§:”5:1 ‘

mjngisitzrafiefl. 0f ms §}Z€3’§€ffI”§8§$ an z’€»:*:a_;z’::$,._Ej fimi rfiééit £i;.3:..:::V’§E::_%::V:.3 ‘L’%:;r2 VV

‘$2836 {#3393 am é;37.3:a.§Ea;” is fiii-2 631%: “‘:?;:?;1a£”4.’§’§.*»Fa:3V{“£ T1111 A”‘3°%5:i”i’4: §3€€.’§§i§:%–é3.

§”§GSfi3§}’§’§3§§;2€33§}. ‘£21 ¥i€¥§’ {5§:§h€ Samig –‘€s:*:%€1’=. ‘

{§;€§;€”Z1″é?fiE§ in ‘:26 gvagsad; if: these {:=.a$¢;$”;§$ gzicii, ‘

4; E13 {E35 i*fiSE§K, $1536 wzit.[_§§>{:€:§i?ié:s::$; .AA«f&;3l§:G%§7€{§ $31 §}£%§’§. The

§:£22§::gfi€{§ €I};C§;{§iTS*::§::fiI1iS::a3″i’3j _{;fa2z;$};é{2V.=_V ‘P5:t.£*£:i<m€m $.Ei:a};§ 533%

{mg}: a;g"s§.'§}§<:%a.1':~':._"¥;1?@;;m2Vv:i=;'–%é:i'{g'a5i;é;:?': {)':§"'.'§'L$-"i5£f'?{i'4vit.':§ @9113 §.E§;s {iéiir-E2 <3?" :*:–:<?::§:i;:s§. (gs? 2":

{?Q§33fg~' {if %§'.2§_§*.;"~:=..3: <25 %%;2€:.ér ;*:'«;<?E3:T;<;§3 ii}?

i¥::pz~:1'i,i';fr}§g} <T'1:*a"§Li'i€2'«£§T.":»'zf3;_¥.'V'§V§§€§ E<Z:é:gE,§S.§3 £"I1€f{§§E.1Efi, '§'T%"§.€i iffii :'::s3g2<32i:<t§€:';'i.»

iééégizatfgé E, i3."%5{.'§ls.'"§ZT"i'§§" §":3:h§3?::' §:::$§z"ac:é@§3§ §§§?a&,§ {:$::3i€E.§::,:' mi: 33:21:?

i;f2'–~;?s;;x:sg3z’ia§:3 :”;$.

Sd/-r
Judge