High Court Karnataka High Court

Dastagirasab S/O Maidansab … vs Mahaboob S/O Abbasali Walikar on 16 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Dastagirasab S/O Maidansab … vs Mahaboob S/O Abbasali Walikar on 16 February, 2010
Author: Ajit J Gunjal


IN THE HIGH CGURT’ OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT GULBARGA

£Q)A”I’}§:-If) “FEES *m£e: gem IDAY «ix: P’EE3I{LIA_}?¥2.Y’,

B ETEF

‘I’H;EZ HON’}3_LE”3 MR. JUS’f’IC2E~.._}fIfE’.Cij?%§*;f,53;i; A’

ORE)

RRA. NO.,869 <jE"4–%:;.00<i'-A. L V

BETWEEN

L DAS'£'AGIRASAB,, "

5/0 MAIDANSAB KUKANUR, % 3
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,

occ. coomg,
R/O KHANAPUR,

TQK SINDAGI, Ii-151$ K

:2. MAKKAPEERT’ ~17 1

8/0 DAs’1’AG_rRsz\,B’:<;:;gf~,M'UT§é';– _' '

AGED 40 YEARS,

occ. CQoL1E."., A .7

R,/O K_HAI,'}AP[,IRg" ~
ma, sIN:3A1.3:;' 13:31": "B:'.J.APUR

3.V’;$.KABARI3A;£5F§v.?i§’
8 X0 £’)AS’.FAGI’SAB’fI{E;§E<:ANUR,

~ AGED!) "35"':€'EAARS'j,
mifc. C€}O_L-E %
M _°~;E_€/£3? E§_EiANAPL_I'R.

“‘ *§Q;–. $;_N:)AGL— ::>:s*_’:”: B§JAPU§€;.

4.V”‘g:§%;_éa§*_:”; :–§§«:§sz:A E<;T{,ELir€j%.§%'€}'\§§5 £32?

H E9-'{}E€

. . ,APE3EIi.,LAN'f'S

%g< .:. 1 x"

L:-3

:*e1ie:_f” sezzcughtt for by ‘t:1f1<: p1air";i.ii'f one 'f0:* c1.e.’t..i f()’I’ izljuzlciimz. I1″: appea:”s3 ci21ri11g;;–.__i.E1es

C{)L11€”S€? 01′ iirial me pE3.iz1i’.i.f£’ m2.11<:«::s~s an ap;3ii<:;1z?:;.§_)'i–.*. iwi::;.E}:

order E3 Rule? 1.'? of the CPC to a.1.n<311{.': the ;3r:§§yf§:'v

SC} as {=3 ir1:::£ud<.-3 the: relisrf 0f p.§s€$s.1«<)_:r:~;. '~I'}1{§*:::_;1:ii'<:%" is':

§§ram:ed. Herzcze esscaniiziiiy 1111.9 -.S'Ui1i "ov;*1e'=. ':_1i)I"'

d.ecI21r2.it:i<m of tfixie and for Ej(j'é§VE%g%%SSi{}.I1.. . V

2, Iimrirzg the i.hTt$v'AA1:)é{fEies will
be: mferrcd ta as t.h<:<i_r {S@'Lm';.

Sh ‘};’§;g_; is Sy.N<).43
H7€¥&1SL£Efi1'}g: V E{ur21vina} viliagt: in
Sirxdazgg .26 "me: 'p'1aiz1i:fif the 522%?

pr0§Je:’i,3x’*A iléiflfiiiiy hiss fa-€;Ez¢%1*

éibbfiséiii. Waii’i£a;f Eiliifi durizxg” $1153 §i§’7e3.i§m€: he was this

.<3*s?a::':_€:'_ema§ E3f:t= p{3s3s3e5a:~<s;i€}:1 <:ri"1g'hx:: gzziig. lanai A£°t'.9ss.;€:ssi{m of the

‘V ;3r<3§a73"€fj; fig. is; big {E2136 €"h8;'i. éhe <;§€§€§.'2dz3;:'2i 1'33)»: E135

_' iéizad is E:I*1€ <:E&%§'%:"::'1{§2'm§: §'*£'<:;gE ami :=z<::;:€3:*<Ei;_'2;;jEy he

Cra::%21t:e:<:3 2: {E1156 I11:,.11::at,i1’1 €E”1{‘.F}-‘ N0. 187$,/A 13y 21:1″{:€d22_i:;ing

the €I1€LI7i.Ii*tS i.r1di<:21f.in§,.g; t.h3.t: the p1ain.t:._iff hmi»; exc"r§ {1'i:£%L'€iT.

Sam: dcéeci in fz1'x–'<)u_r (3? the 1%' d€fer1.d2mt';, as <:s:*;. '

iii): 21 <7:0nsiderat.i0:{1 of Rs.22,C¥QC3,7¥."-.'1'}1c _{:.:;.x-s'e:i._Q1""–:%1«:3:'g

piainiiff is that he has not €3Xv€(?i.I'{I€;':dt1§if}1 a Ci_;?a<:'L;.v:r2 i;}..’:t€3″*S_i.1idV gale
deed datzeci 28.6, 1983.E}eV_ £ijg;iV:§f§.ie:§:f:?:ci’fiéiéséfisian to
the defbndzini. it: is his’ {(3 be in
possession. No.1 fi1€S a
Written that the piainiiiff
indeed from his fame:

:«3.f”r.er hag de111′<-zd that the

pi21__ir1§:.i–f,f is £TlF1§'<::V.,<}xv§3.'£%'r ?:e.:r1e:i in pssessi0§1 of ‘ithg-3 pmperty

t:L:r;_ {é’§2:iI§§edV” 51;; 211121, has; 213550 éeniad iihat, that

ff1L1’§fi2’i’é1’E1€}’£7:4:’€:5£§,:§y}¢i£1S b€3€”:.I’£ £:.r<-rated Ffiiffiililijgf amd ii: is; fgilfiflx

Suzxi. 2.-'::*:__<'i -<.:a:f1b$fi:aI}<te is-3 iihéiil iihey wmziéi Eizfliéit up 21

:$p€:ft£.fi{? ihai. {£19 pEe1i:1i.iff}1a?:d ezggréseai £0 53631 the

.¢ m'%\§§§ %$§§k?é§W§ %$'& $4'z%'."-'\'*

agrméd iii) pL'11"Ch.':1S€ H163: Iaraci far 21 532116 <:<ms§.€}i:-3:1"ai:i::)_:1 cf

Rs.22+{)0O/A and the saici 5,-sum was paid iii} Ii1i1:<:s;' "E{é%:xf;.¥::vr;:

the narmz of the (ir3I?;=nda11i; Neal wa:~:; ::;%z'1i;éé:I.'i<;*.(i.TV:' I"i:L- " 3;:1<;#;;% 1 V'

}:"€3¥="f:'.I3E.1f:§ r<:3(:0:'<:i.<3. Thii'. aIi.<31"'r:2'a;iie:%'–« .d€%.EE*.z'1_.:::;_€'~v 't[h3'i'–

de:fé::":daI1t, N':::s.E is in p<)ss<3ssi0'réfl_i*–_fhe s§::s%it.’~ .p’r0’§:e_£ér.ty’.

since: 1971 to the 1§.1″1<:wv1e~dge' .}fi}E1i1fiI,.i1;f;'_: igiaey
have perfectted their tii.E£;t b*_s2'«V':'1'iii\%.<J:é:a*j§:'<,:f'V"ppss$§§sVi'0r'§vjzmd the
suit which is fiied by by 1imitat.in
EI”kaSiT£’L£(;?h as 311;’ fzcét _f.}'(>m t]:1<~: date-

Gf di$p0sS£§ési;.:%'; , V" '

T113 V -Judgfi an T,E"2€:% baais {ref
pie21diI1g;s'ha:3 f1*21_.rfic:":d= .;i$: many ass '? issmzg. On the

:1':at€§r§'§e1'i'~:.s:~m£% "éaifzs §€:;'::"':1ed trial J1.:dg..,§e has fmztié that.

;}ia:1'}'i.iifVh~3.s pmved his t:.i€;E{–: a..m:i p08-?3€SSi{}I1 (}V€;',1"f1.h€:';

s;§ié%'~–.VEaréii7_":1:'i;7§"fzzriiimr mi: d«:i=f€:r1{§z7z:1'é',£s Emvé: fEJ'!.fi{i€§ {:0

j ;)r<:<$é;e .ji::%'1.:;3.{:. E";E:& pEami;i§'£" E32155 ssoid the Emit: Eanéi in thaiz"

..fé:vTc;:.;r Em' 2: sum <3?' R$,22i,€}{}(}/A 9:" Eb? §;E':.:2 zmafiaaxx .§%§£,h:3:*_T

Vv:VéfE1FIT:€?€§V i£i:*§.2"~:};. L§miga:*s, E-{£5 :»is:;E}mE§:»%; ihaé $221': E';Z§f:<;'E.§;;":g_§;ss

:3
{}'f the: pIa..im:;iff 501:1 i.h£: i21z"1d. in $0 far as the 21c1v<;%rs::%

p0sses:~3ie:1 is £:c_3::1{:r:%1:*n<:ci, the £e2,m'1e::1 £':ri.:«1i J'E1d§;§€? has

_h§3'1§i mat: the suit'. is well wit.}3i:a'1 ¥':}.1£t time: 2;.:1§i»~. fh<;é

d<:fk–2:1ci21nt:.«: h.a.'v<-3 failed to p:'ve: that: iiI:1<::y' hexvé .

the '£.itE<»3 by adverge pos$<3$:3.im1.

5′ Learriizd C::3u.11se1 a1ppe21.1fii2–g”f{)r theig ;1£:f€%r1cE.;1§f:r

S11bII1iI,S that: incieeci no d0c:L:i*I1:§:1ts3 are p_f€3d€1ce}x;i before
the i€a.r’1″:<-:d trial J'udg<;{_ f12=:g21r_di.'n_g Lth_e,és'e::_f!e. But howevelx

she would co:r1t.e:1d t.haV:V_fT.'h.§: ._fi£I,V€ perfected

the tiiié by I:)O:i§SE§:SS§§(}I.1 ifl2i'§§i1*:1}f_)i'l E13 pOSS€SSi()Ii

1::-5 Esau;-ghi.¢ Shii.S'LIbff:i"i;.$"§:ir':'e:J;,'"'sA3E:é;1 the amezxcimexlt 'e.v::1.s
a,H0wer:fé: £2 yézirfs axlfaggdy ciapsed. E~§en:::€ su;;it itseif

E3 barred Eimii;2L§§@:":"*–2§%*:;& hezzzte the {§€§"e:1":da.:";i has

p€ri%3e;;':£i&d t=h€: i§;f§§3"b y e1fd*<;,.-*erse p<:»ss@:3.3iz:.,

3 “V53;-_Efl;:;*;é;’;2″‘;iV<3–:"i €.'f{}1iIES{'3§ é.i§}p€'3;21§'i1F1§§ fr- ihs: §}§’c1§.§1’il§ff

S3.3:;[;’=”§}{§i”‘f.’Ei. .ijfséc7}z;::§g€:ns%§1.E; am”? £i<=:;?:1*e<'3 p2"z::%s2<ecE by the

" -'}.~ ¥ "'r.a'