High Court Karnataka High Court

Bannuru Fisheries Co-Operative … vs State Of Karnataka on 27 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Bannuru Fisheries Co-Operative … vs State Of Karnataka on 27 August, 2009
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar


2:4 mg §~«§i(%i-§ mm”? 3? Kaawmxa #5′? 3;éN§;4;é3A§2%§% _

M553 “2”:-{:5 wag 27* §a#E’§»v€3_iF’£L£.§{53i§VS.”%«;Iv;?§43§’j_

8E?€}§1E_ X

“$22 %:-gm:-‘s§..§ :§é%R.§%.§$”F5§§€§v..§;’£i3,E-§24iE§:3 ,¢3;5:AAs.~s’%i%AV§;agéé%@{;m;a&%’

wgz? ?E’E”1′”E'”ET§°L?.%,§_ ?~v-RES}

Banaaum §*’i;=.:.§3%;’:fié:3 _ I 2
ijoweperatiiwv Ss::;z§ie;_:3;V.V§;’:{£§,:. _ V V
83:12 urui; T. ai*;:%s’;_pui’::’*f§’é;E2_;E;V_ ‘
§%e”f_”‘§fS%:}3f’€ E}r:str§:”:;’, ‘ «
R6″? 312$’ ” .P<2%;:%é'.i91:e§.'

gisyg S'1"§ 3% ,}
$33,";

}.~;–;;3§*,z*:t£ :3?” §éé2:*:;’:a?{_g;§:a

– gfiéééyfitéssfij fie finsimr.-23? E£12:~;b3_nd?.r3;
£s.§V:d*§E’i8E§s:}’ Eiaggarimetzi

” _ ” ‘§:;;- fimiéaékar Eféééhi

A §a:QgaEa;;f.”:”€~:3éQ 9%} 1.

2, “§*;§:.s°;E_}§.’:*§ct9§’ :31” Fisiiezjg

– 3?<i""F"is30r, ?scii3.1m Bimtis:

V “”~§f31sh¥€shW3.z3iah Kemira
” E32: fimbadkar veeéizé

Eaflgaisremiihfi £.}i} 1.

‘.2

ii», §}i:E:ci::s:” sf .%+’is_§1eri€§;

E{uv€m;§u_ fwéagtar
?\il’f;E;{};”‘€.

4. ‘§’he Seam? fismisiant Efiérector
0:’ Eisizmry’, Ziiia élarzchajgath
§’v1jg3GI’6»:’§’?’G {}{}3.

5, Afigigtani Bimcie: ai’ %*’:;ash€§3:; ..

*3:a{i<:~§ E3 (1153 Sanihe:33.:3ra:1a?::;3i§i;' A' T ~
Roaii, T. fiéazasipkzm Taiéik "

Evz;;sere Digtfict-E3′? 1 222;. _V

=5}. “Piss Secrfrtary
Eaiaxnataka <:<;~s§»a:r;.1£;iv¢ .A §'is£~¢':j.rié; . _
F&é;era£i£3§1{L{dg}–.._ _
NQ.3:?f B1, 1 Siagé,'§3fzi;§11S£§T;§§,E§;:FF§I$",§?}73.»,V —
V.i$h%zs$hW3.'I°a §'&2ga;i –'
Rfi}?SO§fi-5?? »§{}8.f '

2?', 'Ef}1e._f5?&cVi'¢:¥'¥:~z.i'T'§;rf"~ ' ._ ._ –
éfiémesa: '£Tii1<;w<3;<;':~*s:§<::%é'::1;".iT'*§?'f i$.'::e:~ies
::;m;;x:ra::i;e g':.:::s 3* '
3¢6:{§afia2";saiZi_;_. §3{g2:1i::.–:1:'11 §~§-:::%;;»§§.

; ' §§aras~£§z::3*?a '§3;T*':;;1i€
§E«*i;_:§":sr;;1'€ §}i§'§,i"ii.'.'..§'…«' .,.§€€$§021dmf2fss

"§:~§'§§"*3';§fi .§_§§1i%3a_z°amu, zfidvz, far 87;
.,_[~E~§ri .§{";v'§T'.V. "f~%:;"g.1~1dra §3'§'a$ad, fi€@?v: far R} ie R6}

*§'§i4i:s%2s2;éi fgfififififi is fiifiiii mafia: Ariicies 22%} ami 22'? 0%'
:'§;g"'{§0:1s'€ituti:3an sf imiia with :1 gragrsr is quaah time
{'mia:rnm§ni iifirder gassfid by the R63 datéfi £3-}§~'2§}i38 at

g A' '@=-§§1£3;éX£ifE-§'a§ mid {he Ggvammsnt Qrdzir daffié }I5~«?3;–f;2{I*{}9
r __§&$$€d by 828 R2 at 3Z§I1€Xu§'€~3.

Tizia Wzié §€€}§J§i¥3§’§. ceméng €231′: far praiimirgary iiaarimg in
B’ Swap fhia éaf,-3 {E15 C-ctsurt mad: $16 f{s§,?;0w3″.}:;:g:

QM fiER

Petiéianer has qu€§:’: 5%;

&r1z:exuz*€s~£%s’§ anti 3. éaiéd {:32 -:

:’i:s§@c:§a;s§j:;, in {$135 ‘a>s;3%§’:~..;;::€i§€§j:”::;”:. ihi’;-Said
Gfdfiffzé, 31$: fishéfig righ:;s§_’V%;§_k3a;1I1:3:’E1_§~$é:gg§er€ ‘T%”a;”1§<: and
Seehaiié §v§arag§:2éia:i:3_ii5g3.f.£§ are asgigksdf in

I'€i3§}€}E1{i{'Ei"_E§; __:'4e.§'¥*s1€;<:§,1ety.._i*?;%r Va,. '§*f!»i§f'i@€§ 0f five fiféfaffi.

{3<)r33¢c;é:e;:15§:§§s*;'.tE1§cfi__§1*ay:t:§* Efiiififififif 355: gm: sf

p<:m1'i,s7$*§.a§:"ii€: =:f*aj:~.=:}::*£§d7. ' " V V

" éa:::2 :'§–€.aé§;ti9:*: sf {ha p<:'€§fii:1€3’* 13; mg’:

2″::=3*§’?e::.;1€i§:z:%.’ _§’*%§{.?g.’§’:~§_§s*+$§<'«:€j¢ is rsgfgiezkeéi EH": 1:}. :§_{}<££{}€§2.?

_; 'aim; s%z:<: hm :19′: iayaesi afisr regi$?£:’3.tia:.:: ai

af fiiizzg 31$ ag3g>ié5a’i§£zn £92′ gram’: sf’ E63366

3 fi$hi};72g righétsg ragpazzzfiaiit §°~éG.’? ES 119?; enéifiieai

‘£{§_ ‘ ihfi Eigéairgg righés; aha: {E23 a§$€”:’va’%;§§: mafia

{§’:;s;t£€z1g ‘éiifi €3{}{}§”Sfi af fizéi Ezfipugzfiié {;:”ci£:r$§ :”{:gg_:*§i§*;g

fjlgéiagefi s:_:§~E€aS€= by ?§’§;€ §}€£§'{i%’§I}€§” faiaiifig £9 iésiiifig

xw

ML-15>

rights if: favaur af {ha {bird fiarty is faigét; ifzai. if reaiijsi
‘ihfi pstitiener has SL¥b~i€8.S6d the Iisiging :’Es:1 ‘§a¥ei,1r
cf the third party. the CQI1C€;E’I1€fi auE.h0:’_};ti€é-éiaaée

Canseiieci the iZiC€IiCf3 §’8.I}.’§€(§__3Zri’;1 aha g:é€ii’iCri§3f”&:a::i§ezf_. K V’

3. Bath ‘ihfi SE1bI£1§SS§;{}'{1S:1._A_ 8§;€ 1{i§;’f”AiA?’.{Z’-Xi :«£Z_%it*3ffiES, ” J

£’:ia”:;2ss«3 of Armszxure» i1′ ~<t_§1=a {}=3§{€r:; fi:.¢r:? €;ir{i'ér daéiéci
28.1.'2;{_}{)f::, eleariy. reveals— ?;é"§{1a€"-~£§36 S-:§i<:iet.i.e:§ cajmm: get

'aha fishiiig z"igF;':{s '§;i;£thi31;a;;1"£€ ,from 31%? date of

:*€:g,:£$?;z*'af§iéf:;:1. VJ*§?;i'hé'-.s?a-.i.d Ciatiée me: where says that the
apghiiéatiazi ::V.§:i§.:);<:~i{_ T'§:§" _3f"1ied by any ssaciety withirx same

3263:' fféjm 'in: '<2? registraiion. What is impartgztfi. is;

;<:i§,i}e 3:15 :10: fizz: daia <3? §:i}}§}§iC£:1'{i{J=fl.

V " 'E-:.';€:3s§f;§r5.{:é{:%*.§fi:_i";;§. Nofiwsaciety 310 dgubt was regstazfzd <33":

__ E§' ,3 but was grantsd Emacs sf fisémxg mighia

'*':$:*:.3ne fgzwr (:5? 2:3 fegistraiigzi. gmzaxzaramgivi 3% pasgseéi

' . 5, E Liéééiig ;3*$.;";§i.:3g iiifififififi is {£16 gaatéiwzzer 2:3

rsspaci <22?' Saehaiéé §i§a£'é§gQ!;j§§§3§fE&§}3§§§ Eanii 333$ '§¥J§'}$E"'€3S

mg: §§;::€:;*;

paiiiianer an ;E;Z.4.2{}{§9 Xffidfi s%;1r:sxur€–»S* ‘Q1113, ii is
ampigs ciaar ma: €:.i’;:€ iicerice was §’ant.eé :12″; .fa~*a{G:;§ sf tbs

§}€§§”§i{)§”1€I’ afiaf Oflfi yaar 0:” its regjgtratiitéé ‘ ” “= V’ ‘

4, ‘§”§”i€ Daguty i};”§.é:¢:t’§%* bf? §4’fi$h;:r§¢5’S.

$222310 is the zrsmgzetsnt §3:uihéé1<*:'_ij§'.f£0 grg;::'i%c€::ic$ '*réia:i13g

Es} fisi1e:{§z rights, {%.f:ei01'*a.z: ';is?s.2{§,'{)£}:€;}'A iibsiééa fem} on
facts, has fu11{i”3lfjj:at_.””:iie’ -§§3*;}i’t.iQ:1re:’~iSvéCiét§f which was
‘$316 fiariier graI;:$,e€’~ Barznmru fiaggere

‘iT:;.1*ii:.,§Efi. i’a*%zi:;zir éirif 3 §:é::'”~’sm:{ by name 83% %%az1ga5wa:n§;,

é.

0%: fiizéizxg 0%” facét {“:&3ffi’1Q?: ha fighiifz 4_

§fzz$E’i–£:d =.22$%{§.€A’§V:i”2:%§iS wrii ystéiiafi. $18 “v”€§’f:f fact {hat

‘*.i§§:§:. _;;;%§:i.§§iai:£%2°*—522:3 S?;}§I}=~»§.€3;SrE3{i ‘jag fifiiiarjg zéghts; asségmzéi

” §{}”v.§iiZ7§’ §;::3f§E&2″* in favour {iE§’S 8%’ £5.43

P6