High Court Karnataka High Court

M B Kumar S/O Basappa vs State By Rural Police on 28 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M B Kumar S/O Basappa vs State By Rural Police on 28 March, 2008
Author: R.B.Naik
I...\.a|.r\nI sru nu-um--um.-1 .

IN THE HIGH CUURT OF xnnnmmnxn RE Efiflflfllflkfl

DATED THIS ms 29" Im or nmzcn, 2oo_a »%+%:%M '%.%

mmma; sic nasaym
as mam; v._r;:m=;e5,     

STETE   
cz~1ImasnLu=n,~ nnrnmsmtmn

-BY ST$IE PUBLIC ERDSEEUTOR. .. REEPODENT

 V ' em: 51%;: mm;, "ia'f.'£GP]

 ._  Is 211.121: UNDER sac-rron
:ag7£11 AtiI>%-401 c11.p.c. muurxma TO 331 ASIDE

7 -THE ant-zR."'DATED 1o.e.o5 Passnn ,5! 'mm 9.0.
 ms-r ~ £::r% com,-.1-=1, cs=.m.-..n.e.a.:.-'J1-., m
 '%kcnL..A%.No'. 11103 mm cmsnqunmr saw Asxnn '1'!-IE
 L?n11nn%'%L~narn:n 22.1.03  1:ring agricultural land and

..::¢¢x:auctor of the van Sudhukar and

ggégngez Ratnammu 1:110-::1% due to

Ah-:,st1_1__I:: .

.-iu'

uatainad by than in t..e accident,

V'  :.;'L_;_I_j§uria:u .. Q Q, 'U,__

-1_n_n.ric_=1::;on and sentence paauo§1..V7b3:f?._V_



nu . ..u.._'...'-..... ...r.... ..j.r....r. . ..-. . _.-_.-- _. -_ _. _ --- -._ - . . _.__.-. -. ._.... ..1..r.._1 . ..._. . ......... .... ...--.... ..-....-....--. . ..'.. . ............

1I\uI\IIlI\I \lI lIl'ILl|n'I-nnluulr-I II

3. The prosecution in support or its

can examined Plla.1 to 9 and got 

.1' - ------- = A.;' 4-'
'::::"s*a11i*- in 'x:.':" -er": hair um"-.'-.firen by th-

putitioner haroin in._ a  §ur;§a_qd.  'wl'4e1"V1§ 1:11:
vehicle _,r.'.-am: mm:  and was
negotiating   patitivnen:
suddenly     a5 neighbouring
<:c1'1ciu»;-;i::r$:3: "  . jfgtsaa
dun tzp' nth;L'ir;j11;;.iofi-._Se§':;;'§ta.inad in the nccidnnt.

c}fin5'?1'?1T:b-é"'_~v.,§;fi§v'frost-mortom axamiznation on the

 .doad""'-bocii.a'a':"" oi' sudmxan and Ratnanma. ms is
;I;ot6'.'x..'. Vehicle Inspector and he has deposed
 widonao that he impacted firm vehicle

J  :44 mt gm; am: In c_:1_1m;t;a;; agigctgg 1-I9

lizhe PSI who on receipt of intimation from the

<2 n.' 7'k|.
/M<A--v~.eu-u~------



'|u\I|JIl\I vn nu-um.-u-u.-...n _..--.. ._----T:  4 A

 arm": 2 9.3.:-we 2-.'e:5i.=...i:~.e-.=.~l. injuziege -.o1_'.'11:Lg

huapital wont to the: hospital and recordod the

gt-l_l.i_=§-,.'l_L,t 9: injured and registered a. 

conducted spat pancthnama   u  
vohicla involved. in the a.cci<:i9nt::;T..:' fim- £s: t hg& 

owner or the vehicle  'V

wow the potitionar;'fac:cu§§:£$;'..:_'wyg than
'I.re1m..i.e1e can 21;; :;~1.:é  is the
Invafiiiqafiim 1'.-:'a.;T';";'i.ea:*~v'..v:...j'  ti?" th-.5
ir:voa?:igatJ.:_c.n:£«.:. 2  from the
ovidencg H   ~   clear: that the

potitioimn_.¢ij§§cév§_ 't1§'e vnhia1e in a rash and

negligent}  in speed and while

I _._e_u_:t_:l_g his latt aide, no

ID
I'?
IS  
Ir!'

'=_enter_ac1_ Vinjé¢y the neirgihbmirifiii -6:1-zultuzal

: 3é_sa¢eV1é§j1£§"o at the said tact, than vahielo

 V --t0PPi'aa than conductor as wall as -another:
K sustained qtiuvoua injuries and they

 to the injuries and in addition

is elicited in  firfififi-iiifiit'Ii'fi"fii"':. ta

diabeliove cu: discard the evidence. \



.. _._--.-- _.. ..... .-.... .. --...- _..... _ - -..-_- - _--.---_'."'-.'.'-,-_- ---. ---- _. _--- -.--... -- . -. ._- - -_-_ V--- --- ._ _.. _-.. ...._1 . ...--. - -------q wan nu-nu-u-nu-uu-n sun." I 'flaunt: Iva Iv-1n.IIl-Iual-Il\l"| l1l\7I'l BIUUKI

accused, in ordgr to avoid a; impa¢t"wi#h tn;  "'
amid bus, had to go to the @Xt£€$O l6£f'Hfl§QVfl 

or than road and as auchf 'wh:i_.,1_.£nt-.. dc1ng',:'"s§,..V_,,gr$o VA

vuhicle antexod the_nnigh§&u®igg égtifiuflfiurnl

r
I'

     =1f3"aié'."vsi§§?;j*éati6a ha-
hoan put t9,fi@fi;;ga£gR2{i #fifi £hh} huvo denied
abégt Vgn q§fifi§qi§ fl%fifiifig}V@ntho cppoaita
diro¢t£9n,-- 7$fi@s, fifha'3a:gumnnt does not

support £hg'pqtiti§n@if&@cuaed hsrein.

 i}; Fe; tfi§"fdrngoing reasona, I do not

"2';';:i{1T_" ground to intortora with tho

hv tn;

o;¢e;wo£_¢§@§§¢t;on and ggntgnca pggggd

an-an

1.

… ~~1…Q.;~-I ….- n’………. 5.1…- 4-‘.1 1 ..
Lofi t M’ “f L’ J.UJ…l..|i.l’W.J..I

“8} Tho criminal Rcviaian Potitian’ gg

kmv/5

‘aflgi
fig?’