Sri Khajasab Aslamsab Giddbade vs State Of Karnataka on 25 January, 2010

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGAL_O__RE

[)A'I'1E)[) THIS THE 25%" DAY OF JANUARY 

PRESENT

'I'HE3 f~ION'BI,E MR. JUSTICE \/WGOi3AI;13\x'} Qfl'JVi'3 ;A'*AV . 

AND  AA % _
THE HONBLE MR.JUS'£:ICP3 1%.._S:E3OP5'x.N1§~§A.  V
WRIT PE'r1'r10N NO. 2353?/QC 10 {G'r»a%--;"RE-S-lim

I3 ETVVE EN:

I

. cc".

SR1 KHAJASAB ASIAMSAF3 'G11)1"3.:3zMxm; 
AGED ABOUI' 36 YE'/IXRS' '  1 ', 
occ; I~'1.Qvv{a:I'21' «MIS:RC%E-£_!A;N'F«.   1111 H
IS}-IWAR. NAGAR. ~15'? CROSS if; .
GIRIYAI, R,r:~AI:)';'30L13}-=i}U;:3._Lg_

I--I.UBLi 5.so«0'2_.4 3 ' ~

SR1 NOOR P~,l<lAiE'\/EADV A£31_3u£.wA1--1A8
I3/»\'P_u1-21. AGE)D"AI30.U'.Jf'€g5 YEARS
occ'; .._R£«:ir1R1«::13 'Ks. R-i1' 'C EMP1,oYI~:1-3:
KASAI-3'~--MOE~IALI,A, ow HUBLI

1iL»:I.:3I.1 580 024'

_ V"*",r{1a3i;3'u1;"' 1)VAL3Lr<: M1~:Rc1~i/WT

'ASAR Mo1Te=1m.1.A. 01,1) HUBLI

'  T1U13Ln_5*e~:0 024

SR1.  I N NAPPA H U C IWIAPI-"A HOSAMAN I

* = w.4f\G ED A130 UT 40 YEARS

QCC: CI,-EARNING SUPIERVISOR

 I31'. AMI3P3I")KAR COLONY. OLD I-"I1_}E3I,I

HUBLI 580 024
1

W



N)" H A

'3

SR1 BISIOOTAYYA SI--IIVAPPA HANUMSAGAR
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS

OCC: CIVIL CON'FR/\C'E'OR

NAVA AYODHYA NAGAR

N PEAR G I "I O D K E FACTO RY

OLD HUIBLI. HUBLI 580 024

C¥CCIL JAMES FJDWARDS
AG 191.) A30 UT 49 YEARS

occ: PRI\/'/-\"l'I*3 SERVICIEZ   _
Ei NO. 254/A. SIDDRAM %\IAG;\R
GOPANKOPPA. HUBLI 580 023

SR1 MANJUNATH S1£)1JANc:.QUI')A..RA'If1£.   
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS     
occ: BUSINESS. RONADAMMA,

COLONY. tr. BY TH   im«:,}«""S EC R1:-:'rARY

. ;fvI1.3HANA''SQuDHA

1], " 1:) AI\'1i3E£I)K]\.R"r'{OAI)

 v. 3 BA?*«l(3--AI;QRE W 560 001

  om-'i1AR1\zzx1'A.KA
'"R.r+:r->. 'mffm1~: I?'RINCIPAL

"~..SI.3.._CE{!£'i;'Af{Y '10 HOME I) ffII"ARTMP£N'I'

\f.II')'}g_IA.E\}J\ sOU1)1~1A
I)1';..-AMIBEZIDKAR ROAD

' «..I3ANGALORI~1 550 om.

' HS'I'A'I'E OF KARNATAKA

RISE'. HY TI'-IF} I--'I'{ENCI$AI..



1
I

SI€CRI.S'I'ARY TO D P A R
VIIJI IANA SOLEDI EA

DE'. AMBICIDKAR ROAD
BA§\IGALORFI 560 O0}

4 Ti---{I43 DEPUTY COMMISSiONI£R
DI IARWAI) DISTRICT
DI IARVVAD

5 'mI~: HUI--31,: Ii)! iARWAD MuN1C:1':">'AL. 
CORPORATION   3
REP. BY ITS COMEVIISSIONER  _  -. «.  
H U BEA. I)IS'E'RlCT IJHARW/,\__O "  .  RF3SPOL[\' O:::N'Ijs

[BY SR! ASHOK I--{ARANAf*IALI.l.v'V}Xv{_;' O
SR1 BASAVARAJ KAREz)I)VY--.------OA«). "

'I"HIS WRIT PE'i'I'I'iON  I%f'i1L'i>jVO A1-'mew 226
& 227 OF T}--{I-32 A€ONSfI'i"'i"U-TI&OI\E I'NDl'A PRAYING TO
QUASH "rH:~: QREDER/I.=££'I7I_'I£.R DA'FE3DV_ 231.2010 ISSUED

BY Tm; 3&2  R£?;Sri~O~N'OEN'r A if; COPY OF WHICH ES

PRODUCED i'AT _A:\.%N'I:xuR--£%:;vA:--  V .

'I'hi's ;"3r:%€:it'i(.>._i'«1'  On for Ol'd€.'.l'S. this day.
V. GOPALA._vGOWDA'vJ;«fi_-~h1e1€ica 1' he foifowing :

ORDER

‘—..’_’l’hves’ev}pet.it.i(mers have appmachecl this Court

V:§eg2ki1’1g,{‘v..fOr issu21n(‘te of the following reliefs m’g.._{i11§;

., /I \}aj»j–c3L:A;s f21c:is and ie;é,21l (_?(:)1’1t_<ri1Ei

-E

lsszac £1 writ of (‘e1’t.i0ra1*i or any 0t.he:” writ
c;L.:a-15111115.; the order/It-:tt’er dated 23.01.2020

in N0. C].A.SU.{*J:13:RARAA.2010 is:-;1.ted by

the third :’cs[.)0nd€nt. a v0p_v of v».=’hi(:hV

pmduccd at ANNEXU RE~A.

ESSUE a writ of nt1amda1r1″:us or a-lny ‘<)t£'1:L'aVa'b £&=rit'* _
directing the I)epu,_t.y 2Ciomnii'S$"i-0:"iéf';.___ ~

Dheuwad to ilmiait-21__i11 f).'t!b!V'1{" }')~._='éiist’ingH_V_g5a1._ and 26″‘

: Ja1!_”1L1afy.x(3i’.0cV(:;’y’—yezt1* as usual Imseci on the

:;a1′}Vierx’ p:5act’i€r«éi’_.’LVby the President.. Anjurn21n~

Ejli.

£3~1:%’:-cm. Hu

A ..?)A’E.C3I,ARE. that the power exercised by the

.”~..Q(;\§j€15fin1ent. in dir€(%ting_;’ the Dep1.1t:y

.’C’0§I1£T1iSSi()I1(‘I’. Dharwad to pC1’mii the

Comnu’ssira2ti0n. Hubli to hoist. the flag; on

26.01.2010 is ultrel ;)()\arcrt* Lt!-l(:1€’i\

the (rude and without jL1risdi(‘£’.ion and CE1]”:]101.
be SLlS1’c1iI1EEb1(‘.

(iv) I)ICCI,ARI*1 111211 the Govc’1’1’m1en1 has 11};
power to direct flag hoisting in 1’e.spe(?.€. 0:7
placie where it is not a pubkic “lL'(_:”1.i(‘)’I’1 2 ”

deems fit to g1’a_1i”‘u._ in “thev _£’é:1_s;”.__”an:I”

(I’.i1’CEII’1}S1,a11CCS of t1’1,(‘…(,’Tc:1’E3.C. .’ ” –. _.

2:, }j2z*;>,§v11g7.;”eT-1_ciyWfileci writ petit:ic)n No.EiO3]6/ 2010

}i1)(;éI’c5_1f€ ‘1″:i’1:”e.__1′)ha1’wad Ci}'(_’.lli1, Betlch, Dha2’\V6ld s5cek.i11g_§

cez*1″é’:—i:’1 .-fiiii-:=’i§’$, the vsmhus f.’acrt.0r and Ieggai 0()r1t.<:m1'o:'1&s

"*._é:1ei\.Iaz1(r(%d by Sri Igakshlniz1araya:'1e.:. Eeartled (lonmsei on

_ B91712-11'f of thc pc1"it.i():1cr:*s wl"zi<'*}'1 are c't()11t.r(')vcricrc;1 by the

\k/

{I
}€E{I'l']€d Advocate GeI1e1'a1 are not I'€:'({1.liI'('d to be

aclx»-'91-t.e(.Il to in this order.

3. The i1’1terim prayer No.(b] is that the pe1it.iI_I.1’f:ers

seek for a direct:ior1 to the respondents to periiii-IL. _”‘~t:}.1″:j

President. Ar1jurI1arI~E3~IsIam. Hubii to hoist’ V’

26″ Jz11’11.IaIy ZOEO at Idgah v-i–‘vi’ai-d.arI V

No.17-4. Ward No.3. Hubii city mi

eariier practice in the ends L>.14″‘jIWt’:ic*.é.u_ ‘S-.iAI1t_:e’V’i1I锑s21ici

0rgaI1isa1ti(:)11 is eIlread3{ bef0’1’é=, ‘Afhé””-CiI'(?l.£i’¥’:””B’€I1C?I’l at

Dh€1I’\N’£f{d s(é6k§IIg sa1n1Vé”I*eIiI:3i’. this wrii pe1.it:i0n

is not 1:1.211I1’1t.eI.i~:’;Ieii:¥I¢._’iI1 “iI1vv. The 19211-net} Adxrotratc

CI(:’i’1C’.If’ai iI”1Vi’t’_'(,’:(,_iv o1..Ir e1t’i’i.c=.I’i1’i0II the d€i'(‘.iSi()I1 in the case of

‘IPRCAPESSIONAL WORKERS TRADE UNION CEN’.I’RE OF

I.N’I)_AIA-\Ij;s..j¢%.’I}N.I§iI.N OF INDIA AND OTHERS (2001 AIR

KANT IIc~Iaj.II’I6sI of mm com. In that case while

VééxAe1n1iI’1i11–g,§ the m21int:ainabiEity of a writ pet:iti01’I of public

Eitigalzion filed u1IC1er A.I*1ic1e 226 of the

“C{‘):I’1S1ii’1.lT.i()I] of India by 1.ht’-2 p(?Iil1iOI1t’,’.i’ the;’cin

Iv

7

(%11e.1ilc*1’1g_{i11g the (‘()l’l'(‘(I’i’l1(‘S$ of the Clostirc of the miims.
This Court 1na”1cie an observatitm to the effect’. that the
e1gg1’ie\rc?d party who has already filed 2:-1 writ pct.it_i0h

Ca1″1|’1(_)t’ Cha1l€’I1g(‘i the ssante under PH. si11(.:e»~.¢’ the

pt-3l’.i1.i()l]€?l’S have filed this writ. p€ti1li()I1 in 1t}.i:_L”‘f(}i;U7!_’:'(fF.{:_x’._

public int’c~rest_ litigation. sc’:ekir1gVtAh>e. 1’elité’I”‘i’i*1–:falifmitiof

An_j1.1man -13- Islam. Hubli and it. h21s;’fi1As:{d ét._writj }3ét:it..idi?1i_’

before Circuit Bench of I’)ha’;’wa1jd seeking the x%g’:’i§.r.,s:in1e

l'(‘1i£;’fS as prayed in this pc?tiiti(_).1:i1.i”v.._ ‘

h’I’i1″t.}§15is (ifjfhe :rié1″‘t’t{c:*r. we do not find any

publité iittc-.i#c’St.–of’paibi..i_t”‘injury or vio1e1t.i(m of Rule of

law Qi.I_hCi’ z’ii’f’ciCt’eci’– or ‘\’/”i()121t’.ec.i. The said Al’1jt.lIH8.I1″E”

“isAla’m€’is§.A”aIr&;=gtdy the Cimuit Eiench at I)ha1″wad by

-f_”iIirj.gV21 ;5G1:it;~i()l’1 seeking ctertairt reliefs Similar to the

rcrlicrfs 21}-;~ ~;1.1v;;:y(?1.isir1g.§ the private interest”: of A11_;’t..imem–E3–Islam.