IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT
I_i_)A’l’E3I) THIS ‘mI’:: W DAY 01* 1rr«:1A3Iauz\Ig:&=’;”2′{‘;1.QVf _
I PRESEZN’l’ :
THE HOIWBLE MR. .JUsi1fIcE..:$;;vK’;arh.T’iL’
AN-{‘_’_)
TI-IE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICf§”v}$fQSREENFJ§§SE GOWDA
M . HA. N'(A}_;_.’1″O_S)9V_4 Q19″ %2&o§;m»r1
BE’l’VVEEN: V
l Sm: L.I:’13 é: _ & 4_ “” ”
W / (:>.::- 11;}; I*£-ri;«:.»__h1’12-1_p.;_T)L:’i’;. ” V_ ”
Agcéci Ab€–;~,_1_11;_f_34 \-‘c;:1,;-s;;.j ._
Z2 Klzm .K*.TjiV’_VLtsl’}3p21.l;.il’I”1;;. _
I.V§)._/ 0 La 1 cj h 112-iv ppié-i;
/-\_z__;–;>c.§ Ab(>L’:I_ l 5j ‘.%’Tt4’é}’:::;.§..
£3 _K1.1n1 }–V’:..1z*.i;j}’–1i.l’1£1.
I’)/’Ln. K.1’i:.§j:A1.:1;1ppa:.V
V. __ ‘ ~.Ak:_:’\-,§;£~*..A{‘I Abou 1′ 1: Z””Y’c§”.-11″s_
V V2’-} ‘=§{‘L:v:fiV.:.E{‘..[lV£’1–1,lms}11’i,
_ Al E’/r)? }i:’1v’vi’;=’%}1r121;’>1..>z1.
Aged’ ;»”x,.’_I;:'<:;['i,.: 1. 9 Yea rs.
‘ .»\.!lt a3:..1’9V }[{(“Sic’ii1’1;__§ at C/ 0.l.)0(.fd2;1ial”1.
AA ?’~§(}V§'{54E-L ¥{2;i11;_{211:e’1El’1e.1p12r2.1 Main 1&0;-‘1(i.
V’ ‘. _.§VIe1___:;”d(!i Rtmti. I3:-1|1g21.l()1’ev-560 079.
ii
(‘1
1/4″‘ as pm’ the (:i(=.m’si()11 01′ Ap(;~rx Cffm.n*i’ in Sz1_r1z.1 \»f’cr1’1121’s
<'a»'1.::s'c. Fz_ml'1c:'r, 110 SLlE')i11ii1.(I'('1 1lT1e11._. ihc 'I'1"1'b11M1H1é':1 i':~;:'also
not __jn.=sI.ificc'i in z1ci()131i1'1},2; the mulI'i_1)1ic-'r L" T'i;r;* '
('()1'1"(,'€"I 11111lt'iph'<.=1' '2-1pp1i(.%af:)1c.: "prjxfl I.I.i1c._"e=:Ik':;*CS'e2:i(i«
dc-'<'isim1 is 'M–'. "I'1'1c~1'cf()1fcn héfist'2bn1itI'ci;_:jEA'E:l"1é=11.';ifivxew
i1np1..:;,_§'1'1c(f con1m0n j1,.1cig1ném. "-zmd z3Iw2-i'1'd7 péisscrci by
"1"riE.)1i1121l l2'2»1b1’f’ tfszr.-p.c}’:€i_:31_1.é?y as well as
l.II’1d(.’i’ (‘(.)1’wc?I1Iim.i2%i’}
b’. AH-i’:j, V’ I:1’*s-rz1r”i1′:i.”g. “i–.Iiz*n~ gI(*’z’1r1’1(;>(.i (“€)lIl’lS’E-‘I for
appcllz}’1’iI.S[;”e;:.fi.<:jr <?""c;11'*u'fi.'1'}«..A_'p<31'usa.i of the _jL1d§_§me1'1I. zmci
e'm~'21r<i }.;21sssec'i'by"._:'iVIT1t}'~._'1";fib11nail and z311'I':<=5::' i]'l()1'()t.]f.,{]'1
<'.-\-2.1.1L.:€11'.i01'1 0? ._ i.l1cT' ()1*'1'_é.,'1'I.1e"1l rc(..'01'ds ewe-11'la.1blE:' on file.
V' "pa1'1"iL'{.11é–£'rl_y1" ..Ex.P12W¥ Salziry (3m'I'iIi(.re1.i..c of cicrcez-zseci, we
':1-,:..1'E:1.)!"fhfi'=£501'i$?E.<;3£%1"ecl xziew 1'.l'1at. 11119 '_I'ribL:r1e'11 }"lEEiS slipped
1'11£<)'–.;1 :s_r._~.ri()1}1'.L; error in ti.e':'1ki11g 1.110 1'}E.'l ..s2:3l2'11*y of 1'h(-
'A ("1'~:;§(.*<=-21s;(?c%…e1i Rs/IL,24 I /– wlwll. in tact. U1-0 de(".Lt2::1&'s<'('i we1.s
g_.§m.<;s z'1111tl”1l3; safazjv of Rs.’7.24E3.9() {r(‘>m’1dc’d
-n.f’Ti’7.i.(.) R:s.?’.250/–). F’u1’I 1161′. it seml 11ha.11. t.f’1r:. ‘I’r1’b1.1I’1e=1l
E
also c1″rccf in e.1(‘Ic:’si(‘:>11 01′ {he A1′)(.’>< (f<_:t..::j§ '4-i:'V1*Saria
Verma's case, reported in 2009 ACJ 1'byv.:;§L1T<Ti;)¥-g';'*_
m1.:I1:ipI1'er, in 1*c=:;_g'a.1'ci1i.<) the age. of "i:}1"C' {"1fi'(3fLI£1;S€.'(:f 1:3'-:'r.i_:V1"g_;' 45
_\;'c2;z1".<s. is '14'. I1 is also i'1ufElT1m" 4.7w’ardS’ 1_.1T1′(*~;je1’§;g)1’1af 2;m(i
fix/ir1g: t?XpCI’}S€’..’,-3 of thérv.gic:rcc>:ised~;1′ {fie VAa1f()rcse1ic1
dc-=:ci:’~sic):1. if i.1″1:’er. I /4′” has 10 be’
(:Ic->.(:it1(.’t:::=v=:”(§.J “If ad from film ;___g”1*(‘)ss 1’no1’1t’I’1ly
sz.2!21:”y– , of Rsfi.7;275()/–. Iht.’ net :’1’1(‘rom(: (.'(.)I1’1(.rs 10
‘V.”‘Rs,§5′–_;”£:33?’;f3C3~_pe1′ [1′()1.:1’1cic(i off to R5-3.5.438/~}.
1Aéiqpii1:g§”{:h’¢: i1z.1…;’1£’ip1ict1* of ‘ 14”. {her loss of de;3enc.1c11vy is
rcr–{:fc_1′.c:>:’;_}’}i;’21VL€§~tiA 31. RS.S33.13.E584/~ {ix-r. f{s.5.4i38/~» X $2 X
u :£1,£f&’1il’}S1″ Rs.4.4}.480/– z:1w£u’dL-rd kn}-‘ ‘E’1″it)u1122:I(
” . ‘t’2»iaVki1’:g;;f 1’n(.3m’hl}–‘ in(“‘0mc~ at Rs.2.8I30/- and 2=1cfpr.i1’1g
* :».min;)nm~ of ‘ 13’.
V///_,_,,J
6. f*’nrIl1c-‘r. the ‘i’1’ibm”121l e1’rec1 in not a\va.1j(‘fi1′;g
_just’ ‘.c:i’s-. .T}Vi”:.c’
L'(,}i1\-“€111i(‘)I’13.] }’iti’£.1(i.’>’. H()w<-:?\='c:'. 21 511111 oi"'LRS..E'i}ZV,(j}(T(}»/'f V'
2:1\-mrderi 1.m\.-'arcis Ea*e111spor!a1!iQI'i"' oi'. &ci.(j?a(:i« %§s i.’a ‘jUSi and i*<:%é13_1″fc1’c:1(‘(:~.’ I-{e1\4-‘ia’1v;;;j .V”:r it-b1<'1s and
vi1"cun1st.a'1aces of t:f'1~<j_ (':2-115%."fwgf"-._rcc1e1'éi'1i*ji1'1e the
(.'(.)I'"l'1]f)('I}Sa.1'(i(.)l1 m'a(.1er {he :t()1:£-{"' as a’1.;._§2;1i1’ast.
Rs.2U.0OO/7. loss of lo\-“ca and
aif’f'(*c’*!i<:ji"} and Rs.E().OOO/~
E\1\,-*2:a*<.l._§:,'-A i 11: 1211 .~
I1’1..1″l’1(* 1i5_7;’l”锑t« of the fe1C!.s and (*i1*(%ums!z.11’1(“‘(rs of
ihvt.” (“é’1};£?T§ faf’i~e1Ift'(,i e1b(‘)vc, the E1}’_)p(‘.’&11 fiicd by 21;’}pc’3ila111I’..<;
is; z1E.}_o\.=x{_<»v=~cii .115 part. ?-"I'1'1e i1'11p1.1g:'1ed cr.48()2/2004, on I:.l’1c* !\cic’!i1.iona} J1..:§ ‘I’réb1.1112.1i–E3. (30:.11’1 a’;£’S1′:1a2l C47a£1.2F_5<:?::s.
%