High Court Karnataka High Court

Muttaraju S/O Veerappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 24 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Muttaraju S/O Veerappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 24 June, 2008
Author: N.Kumar
'E

{H mg magi CGURT oz? mmaram M   ~

Eiatfid this the 246: day e¢";,%'u'm;~«, t2%;i::»a,  
a13 V. ~ -- 1~
Pv1€3f;}g:a:1}mfi::;§}i;»'_ 
:..s:aga.3--ifra1~uk 3:;  " ,
R3x::mnagé1°T.LE}i$'i:ict -. 

Rrsvaziaasiddapggég .. V. "
$30 vag:3«;afta,p;;»a_ A. . .
Aged aifwmgtt 38' 3:r:ar3T-
1'v'£i:;tag'£s:1ah,a1iiV--_¥?os§: V
'A iifialuk ...... ..
' V . iézamazxagsirv. Disfiict

' ._ "E"-r_iayé:1i%1a 

fa» f°¢il1i1i§»f$1}§g}a
Agfid .43 -_*;é:a1*s
E~{oa;ur'g_

 _ Vmotaganahalli Post

Magadi Taiuk

"  V V' "F?>:e2.m.a11agar Distfkst

ifihimanna

S] 0 Fiigbayyappa

Aged 538 yeazws

Yaliappanapalya

Tippagondanahaili R3551: 



Tavaxekere Hebii
Baxlgalgre South Tal11k

C131i::11:;aj{3pa

53,5 0 A,§:{¥3a3ryappa

figrcti $5 36313
Yai1ap13a:1a§::a3ya
Tippagoaclanaiiam Post
Tavarekere Hsbii
Bangalore Sflllih Taiuii

Hamafina

S] :3 Anjanappa
Aged 4'? yemis
Yefliappanapalya

Tippagaszdfinahaiii F*¢j>.s.a.:~t _  'V

'i'av3rtakerc:-; fisab 

.3ang£~;};§:»g;¥s"::':/:£:pJ.:=z;1j,«fa~ %   

Ti;3;3:a;3::31i€1a_:1.'3,11ia1:1iV_P€:3jt" " "

Tavarekeré Hobli  "

B3.fig8lOr§ 5:'g #VSvi.11']f1":

'-S3§im:;.::h 

, <._Sj::v %\«§a;%ig7é_mda
" z'é;gé:<f§~3E$ 
._ ''''f_:3;11é:3}j§a::iLa1§j:aIya
' T:§)pagc:1:tia::1ah$L8i Past

'i"av.~a:eke it Hobli
Ba;a.g3§o;xr:: South. "§'a1uk

* V V«Jayaramayya
 ' =$*'~ji§'u3r Timmayya
} Aged 48 yeafs;
TV '2'a}.§a'§}j3anapa1_'§:a

Tippag0nd  Post

5-)



 

133

I6

1'?

. Eultfiyéiz  a
[:3 'C156;

Tavartzkelt: iiobli

Bangalore Scauth T3111}:
M21z13'm1a.th 
55/ 0 Mttcldalmanmnayyzaa

fixgeti 23 yttars.

Agalaktipjfia

Néiamaflgaia Taiuk

Bangaiore Bistfict

Bashasaheb
,1 0 Daaiagirsab
Aged. 55 years

Ya]1ap13aI1apa_:'iya .  _  - 
'k"i;:~;;s3gni1r};.qfi:*a;ha}li     

Tavam§{_£~:s:'e»v ' _    
Ba31gaiC:':: Srj'z_»1i:.'£1 ".--":s*~:l:f1'i'-5.": '  

Nt::;3fiiI§éiki§an  J

Sf #31 Pya1°1:s:-:3: _»  "
AgefiI.274_yéa.t'$" "   
':'aI.La.;3;)a:;;:apaiya"".' .. " 
'Fi1;%pag01:€iana§1911i*--Pc;2}i
T§ivareke;'e"~Ei0?)}i '

 S0i1£*h.T.:«1;i11k

" A Rgui. 235: yz.::{z.§az1's

" ' L¥};a.ag;3}=:3re; South Taiuk



=3{;=;3la§3p3ja?§apa}§?a

Ti;§;3i::ga3:1da13a1r1a11i Post
Tavamkere I-iobii
. . . Petiticneers

(By Sri Ashe}; 8, Pat}, Advocats.)

The State of Kaxnataka
Repraiaentfid by ifs Seitmiiaxy

\/



U1

{)€.§::a§'tmt:nt. Qf fim.in::a_§
Huahandzfy aflci Fiaherit:-3
27%;? $ Br,1fid..i:1g

Bangaiom -- 560 C30 3

The flir{*:e;:rf.01* oi' F'ish€.::{i:::3
iL'5i:'*ktx§--, }

K Gfiaad "Q  2
B.-;z11ga}s31'-a --- 1360  V'

The ;513S.i$fLlI1ti'A:Q_i!_'€C3§§Z}3f of
F:iS11!3I',i€':3 (C§:'a:ié,~4§) , , 
Depmhneglf ;Fis1:u3i"i¢:§* "
Bagigélfirfi  3 r§3:;iji;: Diétficii
i$t";F'io<:z2; C'+::;%;fifa._ §£:%:§a F'aci*c-.:ry-- Bfidg,
{31z}§E)<3i3._ ?'€z;:i<:, ",'?§é111'g.2%_3,:5:?xf: ' 

T316: fifisiafaxzt 
Eisitgziefi (t';'hj3€i£:~iI}'

_" f3fif)€_1i'tfI1fi11t €i'£'F.is}1:E?I*iees
. V "Ba1ig§¢2_1oicr: (S£ml,}_z)
  IS? --¥}_'Vi£';».7s_:'t. ice F'a<":toz*y F§}dg._,
 Cubfiiisgi P;;:..,c1r.~~
" A 

iéfighua Fi$heI'man f3t:3--Qp«erai:ivt5:

S<;:$£:;it:fy Ltd. ,

" *N<:;.36{)]i2, W F1001'

V' » _ Gudlasha Blrig, in Main Road

' 'féshwaiitiipur

Bangalare --- 560 GQQ  Respondenta

€;o-capamtive fiociagty registered under fim:

Cx::~::’)A1;;=;3%f:a*:tiv_:z::~”§g’§*e%’;c::;:etic?;s Act with 95? membgm, meat of them
j;- «. _1 3i::;>}Q::1g 3:§¢3h5{§.11led Cams and Schwdirslcd Triba. The
mdrtr gragzting fishizxg righirs has ham aantcd 11::
taking ifflifi cxxmgidemtign the. mnsfimfian of the

__ §:{)B31I1itt€¥t3 arid 1:315 I}fi:£’$¢.’3;¥1S who am bfiflfififitifi by the acfivifias

“1
f

may arr: fishing in the said {an}: and thai is their Qrcdy S€}”£13f’ia:ie;$:”i:p1:rt:1y on 3. queafiacnn ofiaw.

_ _ i§ r¢’§;3{:::1{§4ent has eentemsti £ipp€é1I’&}flC:€,’– and

H/%

of that sz~:i<:i Sangha, Timtijg C0-:1i:e:112:i that '¥ThtEi}' haxra a prefenfzntial

Iéghf 2,1:::u:§¢:1* tha sciimme, it was C{}}'1i".€?I"1d€d that Eh: ggiifiagfiéis

havfi 13.9 1€)<;.'11S sfaniii ti; chaliezigs thé=.A_imp1:gi'1c?€E, {irfdéizx

:31: the g;;v::n.121c.i that. ntzifller they gf*a§iiiatt:s; u

fomnaii any" assxaciatia-n €11' s:;»c.ie§§;a._V';5£»:?::?01:rfi1_§:,'&_VViTt'is 'éjgntanded
the fishing rights warez: xwégpféndfint 0:1
£§~.4,2Qi}'? Whenias Vfhét fléarly aftfir 8
monihs 011 4, 3 .'£1'1 {$1.6 11:3-t cmly paid
am«;::u:;.ts 1&g2fn'i3;§v"::.Ei they have: st:e::cTkr:*.d
7.2099 :'i;si:"'gee§¢:;;: 3,2<maa fish 3:61:15 02.':
29.8,2Q{.};7v'iI1!' fins: pmtselacfs :35 1:i1s:=: Crfiicera of

tbs: :3€:r:csI3.{3. :re:::po:;1ci5::_iT tlggéaifinfint and BWSSB in a{?COI{i8,"(}£fi€3

«=x:§2it§"1 __?i::":;;1ci"ij:i¥::%':1.z:?;….__.$ti;3ul§§i€{§ in the ag11§ztm§:11t dated

__§:avr;: givsn a gtatzzxgent showing a«:~.:u:_~11

an'1é,n 1.::.:–ts VAiTI;i vihi5s mgasd, Thay have, ptirthasééi fishing

–:fe:qui§_{i:~::<_s fishing .:m:1::-3% iieg:-ins; bnats, fits" casting a $1133.

_. '1"h¢5.r:E:§b:°e, this Writ Peiitritylx fiifid Izyaaxiy eight
'§IZ'iI:."¥?'."ViVvi"}";!SA"a.§"i.#Ff?'3:' g;ra1,r2i: czf fishitxg rights is iiabir: to be rsjectegl Sfikffly
"fits glwrnmri c::f delay anii latchris, T 13:.=:refo:':3:, ihezy hava

n "amlghigi far difimissai 0f the: Writ Pfitiiigstz, Q/I

2{"i0'?5 T};1ereaff.e13 I'E}§I'€S€I3f?'£ii{311S War-are made to the
who Elp:{3I'€'.("i{%1i'.€{i thsir staiad and xarmtai. a ltéttetr to V.
a:1ihi:vEe5 ;
tbs: giant. of leaae in {av-zmx” of the: 1:’¥v:1S”§)VLL’!i1£§.’J§é:I’fi’i:’:: 91″;}4.4,2QQ?

wa$ Wfill within the: material
01: 1*t3~,<:r-1:21'-:73 dist:.*.1-omzf immagiiafigiy of lfiasfi, 1191:
only the sixth "-';*..I]Z|::;;?'.I'£11¥1'f.S due ta the
(':(3vs:'::*r1mti':I3'i. ggicps ilfji liars: the fish
S€¢3'4:3i1'J;1g:s*;v'VV}"L':A';"qTV1f'15i2.§ cost. It i3 nearly after
six II1(}Z(11.L}:1::-'.-E?'\?\;};%€%§;4l. g *t:;w1'1 and they were raady for

li;.a3"'srt5:st,_ the '}§ctifi’p,5 E16 isé {i§;:gis’;im:ai.:aly exxiiiileci to the {TFO}? which i3 new

‘aTva[i1aT’fiiir§ tank for the year 20{}7~G8. But, at tht: 521.1311:

_’if’_It’.1fIi€’;.”iL}T;.!:*’.: :fié1t.€.:’ia} 0:1 recorgi ciiscioscs» film 1533: in faxsimz’ 0f the

._ i3i:é.ff1?; ‘1’ésp0:1denii ia (Z’C1¥1iI”‘¢fi’}%” 11:; 13W, As is clear’ frag; the Qrdar

., clear that on e:s:p¢::ri111ent.ai basis, as a spttciai case fl1:/