High Court Karnataka High Court

V Selvaraj vs The Union Of India on 13 August, 2008

Karnataka High Court
V Selvaraj vs The Union Of India on 13 August, 2008
Author: N.Kumar
    ' 'iIWm)I'1\I aaxxsnn wot mama ma.

 mmvmva;

avox asanoo nova nvnvna  i
aanmswoa 1:m.z._  .1;  _ 

)i£lO'IOfi£3 'I? a;mxm.a'.1.«::m1    

.1!3.-l"~I.'-'¥.mI=3fi_8"'13._~LI Afi *.33§. : % 
 .«xo%a,.:.wnv.:.£s%m,;}V  a

£DQ103fi"¥'8EfiH 

u-u-nun--an

)  %  = we 59!
 V    % mmmma
%  * %jA:*r'rar§1"~ao.:vaIv.x.vnv:mo om
%,  mvagzmunssmsoaoud

    "aavw.99moavfi3ev
aanavaanoa mun

 .....   

IVHVATKTEA I

u-nu-u–can—–u-uunu-nu-u-u

‘lmfifilfifl

3301138

9003 JSHEJDV :50 AVG q;EI EH1 SIHJ. CELVU
fiE0’IV{)HV’H ‘VSIVLVIIHVH .10 LHIIOD H911-I $4.1. III

..t…

2:69.313] m.¥\’u’a..JI1mln.:\z§..r\i an w\%fl\!\..–LkIf§Rl§ »..m:.xu=n..nux.;n:nnn_.nx ape. nsaninsnagu «am… 4…… 3-

..-Pa

‘if! no swam ma ms» izsxmm £I.€2I,E.L{?3;!§V’¥$§1§*.Z}g»

‘mvaamm :10 mm EH3. m2&1m;}afi§r:.§§;a
av mmmn qmmmm £3 gc::;»:%A%.m%% qfégéaax
seam-on um mum :’mmsV%iu.z#._éaa:smm 333;. mwnh
0.1. mmvm vmm ac: _;2a”.% w::: my
955 smaxmv mam umzggg -Ts: 5:::i.i:.n§.¢t’a;§:§§a mm

210.9: £3.53?” %3.§:«£33§i;%’ms;-tax’ ‘smw % mm
a :3 am mv “HZ’h*’fi”‘d’RJH¥&Id
H N we *=m%m fiu’r’a;t§mmmaav§*E : mg .13}

‘ j*~.1;i§i*IVm1Hfi avmix wflmva ma
Hanmvai an A5 am
9% ~§”u’£-W;’EE§’£:r

mm ARV a? 1:»

“ems ‘flI”‘X ‘magma

on mnaaaa Iwrm S 3&1: Q

&II”L’@fkI»«
I-:EZ3{}’IE.’.3E{) V smm fit} Mam
.»&®FO’I’3¥:§€¥ ‘$

%% .:IO &Qx§.”£I’IfimI£I Aifléfifl 33$ fir

_.z…

zammmma am awn mam am, ‘fin _£:i 1i£g:;%

flnmsmfiwplmtwmnmowypmmmuqmumaau

zmwodm us’: can ‘too: Km was new -mm Ia
at 3° P°!-°’1 1’ -=03 sasrzrst rm “hm «hm _
me on mum: -Irntwm. ‘>ml’9.l. gt; j

93-ash .fiw.mI°I~I 3° osmaxsrfis A

1° st rm zI’wu’£s so k%

W11 W0-E en amrmxoc
“WW 5’14 3” mm
“B -30! 0.3 90EE”fifi ran; app
tum [XII pna%.1 .Iap.m
aw-MM K’mI5°-usownao
199.13: at flnmaptmmja 13.3,”; mg

9% ‘scarce: was ecmvzt
L _ °-‘-?=n~1wwodm me mm mm 5:1 9096606

FIT

-6…

fi.l£\§l..I muwflwmzmmna :#\ naiawamflan alts”: r….!’\¢I..A¢!:\_.¢’I.:\l\..l-Ax sun». .\ian.4\nu. aiacmnkq ‘mg. ..g .. ……..

-:.mp.m in spam: qqqm

W Mao Wm M mm M on gum” ‘E ‘I! % _

woozloots WW z.ooaI6c-ass’-on’v’..-1-H tr; X

cm 54 pound -w-we 911130 am an no

nu» an at wsmdi-9-I M: an 5:1

am. mm.” W 1″ My my _
‘mm mwnwandds
W 9% kvézma -5 ‘twin am an
mqaxndoa dank: pomm mnmmoam
M, Wuam mm .9

_ } 1 _f.’2€9¥!§i3PF99°J<5WlIl3'1P1°°¢3Jn°3!§u1¢aogaqa;
'wnamvvq 'W ms is 21 -uasmdva-wprm
.m§naP'cr4I«u um mapuadw: as an 'éitmw
"*4 mum wt: flumwmxtn mm

H'? V-9-TMWIIV 'W umuqurmm pawndm tmpao gm;

-9-

§..H%lI.J5:vc…l3.I*m%..£’s.an afi zaamfimsm sun.-.e.:anm fi..m’8\4I$.wwv.wn.umn1

fiqfiwfiwoziwwm vm

W/”\

W-mm m we: on mud am. we
mu Kq parent as names ‘A

P°”‘.”-1 WI} Pfihfltlzaz .19

W mum M
an zuvpwp pm.
an my :33’.

-5 mt: twbgmfiqd
3-mos om
ma:

~T ==m fin paw zoociaoeson
étmims Pm wlzzv-as ans

u’-.

$.E,£’§§[..l nrI\l’&~l’E”$-¥Ai\.l?eal’l& !!\ se\.i.a\..e’m-5. saarxraa v..a-\uu…nw…u.a-ns_.,2wa am. manna.” ..m…..

uwwwnmmnnanwmwmumavwrimum
4°I%°’l1P°¢!I3°-34″{W°FI1I\F330’E’1W’I”9°JY%
potum puq u Sq zuopnodsm Wgmp

‘mow Mndcrwn prewar mm .;c- man em ‘. %

“gm Wu mgmgpu flumm
an Inca mam! am me an in

-mmmd mu. ‘v~w=mnns.*
an-It-mm -It on
‘3-WI 1° M110 W

nomad 1f”4?A_ L’ étzxftrt zuomodsw as ‘W

me an on vow?-up tr-“mm
V % f .mm.m,,d M auwmodmdmm

-Mn-mad mam; mm -Wm cu mum
M5′ can on arms om liq wmm twnmarp
mm mt: -woman mm: man an 10 mam!
pwmo:-Mano rem-wad cm at’ ‘Q

mnaumamrsxummw seam nnstmmmm zzmaan

‘»’X//W

Klladoadpaaaqnqgugamnsatgzpnunapusamuoqtagz

par-owes cm: on pm moaonz mm uqggo
=4 #5 “W39” 9-1: was pm me mad
«=11 w mm em fimmd-um

0% Mmm PM can Wm 0: fifivdgxd
‘II”‘”°’ *1′ “H mmswd

‘:fi.mIo.td posuq ma up _

“II J” 9*” am my punng
ms firrytrsmsv mam: am
‘5 as ‘Eta iwoctoim P-room war mmm

imwvétqvtiv FF”-“I” at P59’ P?” an an

wt Wm W-woe aw mm

V pennant sq; an .11} an 1:; -,5

“-I1?-“*1I””JF'””‘§°’U”””‘”°’P”5″I’5’lP’1’

V _4i#IW-»– ‘F WWWWIWWM om mama am 9u;amxpq;m_
5B?fl'”! 1!! IMP!”-=1!” me up so uapm
VP?”°’11’°’3°@°-‘°iI1P139fl&9I0B:CI9-Htxaopvnsagclenn

-6-

n.J’\5bJ!%uflQ.§\ll.(\!’t If\ I3&.§fl\%U-B skfhfilk

Ifilfillil-Iiaptxru .13: nzapuado gunman; sq;

Itomm Wm so ‘Kq zumm tuuumqns

1- W var-mrrs -In %% %
oq Kan: so mu can-seq
apsmoq my mum: .icv :°’4″5A.V% “°9″~”””‘.’ f”:’I==i3″- ‘ ”


  arms
3'-'3    :13: pegnadu
  acne; Bram
   .....  was aqua
A L  It) ~-I-om spun.-an
     mwuo mmmwn um mop

“W9 “ml: won: mmumma _;o wad»:

…fi’t…

I I.I\iI…lfi:&..Jfi&l’::ui!*§s…e%a.i.- ash l\s.a&.ao.rs Iruanmfian

pwauzm Kim: qqqmmmu;q m; _’
Imam peqaund on an 9 amass .10 (V-I32′
magma-qua ya [:1 magpw-qua go

cm mrammuoo mruaaqgntt)

-mtwod mm mm W «n 3éj:5 ticw’~*s%

an Il”I** % :ai=a%wpsmu
…. _
In em ‘W8!-1

A “{1} qru-qfl uummnni_ ‘ – may Jinn

mnmuxmog mung

X amt fiwwrm-vzmwflummwwm
‘gm 1 was an [E]
E ‘WF«I°1P°’¢199I
Imr am am am tr: as atrrxtrs cu mm
cuonanodo an _;o ms .10 ms flagnanpuoo

…£’:..

mum in mm cm In pm-mm fiuomm
30 mp» we tmas pmmeoq
twat ‘v umms :0 (I)

* ‘ =
wt was
pimmwintu
*3 cm 3! rm

J0 aw: we on ptmm

mm; 1: .32; ‘flIflI!l.’.lDI_.’I§tXI}’ qgam

AA aq nuqc 109.3911; uopaxioo

Emu ,pop_r.n-nix! Jinan gay u_t[:| go
azqqao.tdfitru.wpunopuma[:uAuv(a

1pnqt;;a.:a’haadn.xmuunaq1nng~1Eamas1uq.
pmmammqqqmammmza ‘umviomm

-91….

‘maxim Jnqzo Earn 1:; 1:: afiufiucnn ‘qq-qua

mm: zuomumog) mama zaqz go rmoxddu _

zrwtwm ‘wv an In atnw-was was was 3-» a A

30 can 1:13 we mammmwg Huang

zntmm am IN!” WM °tn Mam’
:1 ‘-9599! 19° -Wstrm
P99993059 M mm mm
Jan £fl_’I.Iim ,arsrIna[
go mfioq mi” go mm ‘npmas
mama :11 ‘aeuiqdxm ‘mpwq
‘WU mm M4 -afinma
ma» £tdk%%vm1qfin -émn amt fiumrw :0 nmou
as; It 2 ‘Iv-Wyn mt: xv wadw us
11! wmwdfl firm am W: -90; max

V up may sonnet;-qua an .m1::m.nnauo

vvfiibptaq ‘mafia um sq 1:0 mm Kq pammueo

pmugzzx firm 39 qmdear 1’1; Jizgminz Ind

Imago w am M-can xouawaq

v :0 mm wt: mu -*9!-mi 6 “cums 10 la)

uonom-qns ’30? filfl 30 flififihflfl M11 mm fiiflfifislfltbfi

wtz…

9H W P!” ma may Mam Imam mm fimk

wmaaeqsnu 91.1: qomzddu amuse) ‘am; :3; ‘=4;

'lama 1113:: an In 'am: cm W    A

mama an was new  

'mm mm as  fiumzzrm
an mm nu ma   mm mm
Jun .19    qsnn 'Er:-grq;

Juno ‘:5’ gay man =mod.rn.cI
mm was 1-new firm £1;-man!
Imam! :0 mm! W 0; comm

I13 uamao-ans vmmnd mm “TWP

A “H? #09995 ‘m.m–“u 9°-mwm mu-arm

no om;-1 pwomops mu m: pmrgemoo
tumzag am In {mamddv muagnamri
/ituo pmm-N is 1! pm WW: Baum. . .10

J” rxvrlznmwd mm #9 am: ‘MP-NJ. ‘Ir:-amp

tunmuz ‘firm ‘zqfip £219 10 WW] fiumw am .1r.:_;mw.::1

«zz-*

//VI

wmxaqmu rm: uodn azmuo ‘3-ammxv me! we _

1’ own 9-1 “mm; Imam “axis: an M1
‘mm man: an In ‘mmvwm ;¢%::-mm’
PW” -“”°FlF1°’1 “III ‘magaaxg any

£n.:oq:mu fitoqmms J0 mana
was wasted m vvayrmana mi
xmamms fixrpuodnum wsq menu:

“I ‘-nmw-m $43?-W am

ac; jqfinot av museum

jug *n.:@.za;u’ *3” guy

amaxdns an ’em ppnaxoga am

. In}; my “Wt! palm ml :5 “wind

V . not can cuoguaguao pm,-3 gpqmma I935.’
3? “Fm 1-W0 Wmdns Hm ‘rm an ax
%%??W? Mm KIWI-mv an moms mm at zwmq me am
:3¢1BIm.flum3Jn0O°m’-W536 °’I«|’I3′-‘1°1I’-I 19¢-‘F°9’I0

-53-

s E §%§R..§ <|ra§'\'UJfi'5o-£'%§'\I'u-U\i If' l\ifl"§f'\"§ ZEZNIR I 9.I\IInn¥I$eW3..l3.i$.3\R Efk iflfififi. E l.f\§Ii