High Court Karnataka High Court

Savitri D/O Appanna Jeeralabhavi vs The State Of Karnataka on 15 October, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Savitri D/O Appanna Jeeralabhavi vs The State Of Karnataka on 15 October, 2008
Author: N.Kumar & Dr.K.Bhakthavatsala


‘_ _, .,,.,,.,,,,. we unauai-.n:nI.:I::’u:1.rn.

….-»-£

!”‘a;-_’

§mTa@%wm@¢3uw?m§gARmw%a

cgmrumffifiwagzgwzgmgzxfianz*”

{}A§%%35?H§fi’??fi§ 15?Hi;Ay’£§$<9£nz3§*'"*

Pmaagfi? ~

,.,'g''..

amflmamfimémyfi

xi

“$?Kfi<w§§fiwAfi

fa;gU$?KX§Ei3fl£§TflfiVAT$fiLA

§a%éaAd%q:53§3g2&a"

B§mM@3N:'”‘

., ‘fig’ <1. fit: a" ::'§"*.a:~;:.1;::.'i:=§ .s:;:::vE.

:§:r:.:i:_3fie ?fvZf_i;.:e:’;::z*.fi {T’3m::’:’.:*§%V:’a..2.4:fE=:m€:,

8.31123 vi
Ag%:: 3%

_ V , §a€m.§;_35u’:.:sé: ‘.’Eit)I§'”:a;&fi,

“~~¢’5§§gt’E._Z*¥3T3C£3}.'{. 15′; jy’x’§%QE;ta.§’5.’::z:&z;**, :”;§3a:<'::S;§*{;1.:<:§;:z,2i..
K}. V _ fi'EE§;::$V::;v§:.:M*z,éj'w, _~;~:gf'.;*§.;::§s£m.z’a::~1 z,.§€i€?r§”%31}é3’§L’1>§’E§i3Efi,
‘ «{{‘;_ga:/:3 V»r’:§.§”)’I(.3*’3,..’:’§. ‘;f/J’/?-V Mim<:":; C3{ITfC3§fR:3'{I11(§f":E."3€;'

j _ A;V}3;;€:if%m::§':$ :"*»S:':;{ "E in 3 n:iI;x?3

»

V. .4 ”

«s». _ §;aLx::”ai.%:223;i I {x Ap;:)2:z33:z”:az 4..[2′{;:s::°a.Ez::1’%1§?z2>m
” “figs: afirzmm; 463 }=”;t’S. <.}::1′,§:~:;::Z’a<,a§::f32a

we

'_ ' "£§1«§;**;r»a:i'<% :1! 2:2. f£%;1Ea~3ga:"m;', "M: M :..1:'§:i::: E::£i§1;€1"§,
' ' 3.".}§S'iI};'33:}»§%1m§)'Li*".

e . .351 $3??? LE,;.~”;fi'<27é"§'§?%7%

{E":%§; §?E'§ §~:ij.a:'$:E1;:w:5'"s:i§:£»m E33 ?'v'§a§:i§;)z§a_t%i, sfizcém}

\«:,»~"'

/"'

ix}

A"':'*é'§LT2':

L ‘§’1’:&2 ct}? §{;a13.*2″1.a{.&.E<a,
%¥Z<:§_:::'m:j_§r* V
£3011:1:3i:>;é;i%.<m:3§'; * '
lE.%§§z:sV;t1::1;g.2'.

f:Ziz1E;:>ga:a;w§., V ;

w’f:3.i~:1:,m?:s;.Ei’:. ‘E{¢:z1g5j:;:.::’;:fi, ,: ” _ ‘
Agar: zgxbcsui ‘.;%Eé yr’:~:, _ ‘
Octrir: §~i«::s3_1$::*:1″::}E<§. A H . _

mm; sum snxwss
. an-mane -wa uw-wn-uvarvxz-wan:-a azua-13! mwuswa sis it EW'15?"""""l

am)

?*~§iz':im–3§::1, ; V _ A 4_ .v
xarf:3,Ez'aai§:»mag -…;s:,§z:1 .*'.'~y?_'§:§é3?._§}:}"/;"$:7§§V:i'}:.".E.3
5 Agf: ::ax£'2<3.§.3t;f_ijg K-,:::°:§.' . ' L

1 1i~ir;u%3.~:i%3'?.o§c:§;.=.

.4
V’

§3(T>€1§T’£ arég, .2″/’mg i§E:’s V T. V”

‘§’q:Mft:zc1<i:§?;i'f::?;i, ' ' " '
DEES"-i.1.§4f§:°g§&if§;3Lii';._' _ .' ' …§¥3'i§$3:§:'{§}L§\§i}.§€3f§%§"}f'E?

.. «f5§'§;:2§S' l"a'fi$(3f)§§§é3l'$.{i€)1}v3 E+'§r:s;'£. .§xpp<~:za3 35 f}.£€:::§ 'i.3;i".i{§E.'.1' §Z%£2:::i'.iz3z1

'"8{i"3}{v-1:73;' 4:3:?"'*th.€': .fiim<§.a»1 Mi11m'§.t}~'V amt? €VT%z.3m';i§iz»a,=:1T:;h.i,§;= Act, };"3i"§?\j,"ii':g

{<1 ':~:.ut§: as§*§h;;1}; «:i23;i:6:o:i. ‘2:2.Q.i£€I’5Q7 Ezra (77% {$3 W 11 fm’ ;=2z:.”a %,.Z%’2_is ciayg.
*’§»:§€_%’M;A;E%i€ 5.} é.}::§”§*.~:.:*:§::°$§§::»w§mg:~

zfij if 75 €3″?v.§;%;?§.L%f,’§’.;’.’
“£’hi:%~; £3’§}’§3fi2′–L%§ $5; 235%” 3;3im ,:’§.a’i’.L:,z.a”:3i g;;ua:”<fi§.zxn;'a:a':€3%:%'aa:%ia°" —

iiitwr "_§':u2«:?§.g;a:M:2"a.t zaami .t:2;a<«°"a:"<:5; ;:':a$=:::::*3iTi villfiévii «;m»:%;g;~;e”3:

xx,’/,m –

‘X03 mm _
‘””‘”””‘?’-‘-=’U”‘* lam;-_2e as;

V A.?m’:_~a;”i’:>;;i1:{§’:V €;:sf am: 43-” ::2.;3fg3i:3§;;Lz’;2%. _§ia:rx»~.:”é bm”::’m>\;tu~:w:”;
‘._§%3′:+.–AIi,;?%i§.,§}{}£},?-~ fi’r.3§11 mm w’;1.i.::%;’: ;”:’é? i’€EZ’§(3é1?:.T7a{I§;.

” ‘ 3.”E 31$ 1″.§ftC€2E%E§»3f§f°§,i’ ‘iT.{}

{E:’.~.§::.D’:1.’§ ?5.’§.z.:ii(§.r:’:>fi:2«x.li, 1’€’jei§?”iL§£”i§§ ma :'”t3a:g:.:€::-3%”-..;%2’mf “‘:%s;3LZi:3M ‘ V’

:’::_:%.u«::>:’~;~:-sf §;_ZBI”4I.’§§’;3€fi§”£.}y” in ‘1″.’:1fi3f”)i ‘£362.63 1″:-:<;a:e_i1':%é§:.” a

‘£”%1e:: 413?? iihiit €

E5″§3,.1{1}?’:i.i1§,,§ in 2% z=;’iVz:mci:;a,,t*<§%,. %Ei1<:*. f"..2*f3__é?_ Vé:s;§;2';g:.'::§1:s:1'3€.' 5:»-3. _:%'§,1,1<:§§§2i:g 72:":

:*.~.;S;:»1:':x{'a:¢?:1'<E fiaszi: SW E1'§§;{'*Jéi§.;E1i*% I ;:~§*i:~::::W .%'i1§2;; in §<Z§.f~.";%x<i',§.i';:"',Ti'§_/L__';';':§.§'.""§.*§f?-Eli.

°T'¥'}.'€if§«' em': z:xi;:";<::.;*$ .:3s;a'1<;i%"'1,::2;:*;§:::£'V':;;'Ef;:::__::;;a;i*a§: ;3i'a':<§.."g;3:i*amf:<:'%:\§(:':?:x =*%<£1?$

a;j3§:»@iia;::[;§;. '§'Tr::";€-;:»§r _a;_

'a*31+ '%?»= €'iK:*'2§i{§. é;j?£.1V1:{'i §i§;ni§i'§§§§%(3§i"€3 2:.-ma £"§~"€-3* %}f§i3'§i}*£"?§'§£i&'ij"3a'{.

*§:fi";€a _.if;;§%:i'.i:;:f€éif§ 7:.§_g§_'L:a:*';f%.'.§;é3;:i{ = 1'}.{:'.£t3{§ 133[s«3s.~<?z~iL3,{T}i;%{1~,' -~ 3::

TE¥E£s.E§€f3$Z%_{§{}.5; tg;§'»;-§'si3–::a37;a1′{V– ii 2:u:;1″‘<?f::–; :i§;£*'I3 g1.i:*3,f{:«:i'~; «sf .§::1m% 'i:7»s:1»:.mg;§1Va§",g; 'H32 '€}3;r3 %."m':z;':ifa.j§¢'

'%f'«::)§,3..:'}:';a:f~i }j:2.w.'_g,3i’ fg2«m’*:é2..:ia:1:;;, *;§”3.xc3 €:r;*:’u::§aE’;i»:t32;’1 mi’ m§m:s:’~ss «::’.?z2ii€£.a:*:’::3;L
. f*«.;;:3z»::.:’:’ £i*..;j:s”7:’j: M2. 1*¢::»::pi;:a(izi:x”:’::§;

“‘;;jf1jis_a.#;, %;.,’§”:@:*c: :«m*: ‘§”?s”2.>'(} {3.m3g%;M;i5:::*

” :é:m :f§..V»_ iESV.T’V’zu”‘1{.i ‘:.h«:’~:*j,r 5:13:22 z::m*;”é:?:{§ f:3Z’1(§ ?:isz:I=,;ng_:g w’:’$iT§fs fiiifiiifli”
‘ E: Wz3V$ ;–:e’§;i<:i'ii.&*:{i 'Ii 11$: *:§i'::;i:

1″%:s¥5;p€:<%$:j§ '.'€;':-.7!"fL'.E3.&'§'§'i¥§€'i,§7}<'§§.E§. in me: t':v"i{§.~e::a":+::£:,

2;; 26321;': <13'?

“£’7§.”‘:€:?;”i::i”‘i’vi;)’§:.)€i3;”‘£lffgf ‘{;«:;;s <:i%:~:<:j§$az";g;i;3 mes: §::;a:em arms:
?:,.':<:::m £125' <:7§':T°Jir;Tm.%:r:.

“=;;.e;> 375:1-<:< §1['%s:11'::}<:; mi; we3'%'§ :€:1:»:' €t<Es.:::a
§gL,r""

13:3. ‘i§’1%”g:: ,”v:%:;1;’°rr:s5:f;’i <;?ivi%. :._§LE<T§,g{3 .=~z+;2:":;.:+g<f:£i§,. in g;.z'::ii{ "_gf;: _V 'im. '

33% g3;:"«:;':.;m:i fi.£a;:;:i in {@253 ;;2<~r:%:ia'iw::"::.3 z':._jé"2x:«:i:*:a:% £s;";m:é WTz*1'?ue:§;:}wi::§J ii; E?2<?i!i; 1'?i§;'i<:i
sr;:2:aV.i§§<=2z*$ {.:?:1:§&im::a €i1′(: :=-;i’.z.;:d)3»-“:ing , ;%4%3.:”§’;-;T;:I»{1’%.,-*:T3;{?«i.”.:_,.!’-is .:f3:>>’i. ;§v'”‘E3{T§’i,§.}:.i”‘ff{‘§ Est)

{?ri§i,1iJ€?:’%.rf: i§%”:m::i:. T3’;:»:::§”: flag:-2 :}1;;x3;w§§:i;;:sf3’£ in §T§€3?’§T” m;*§:E.<=::':e::<:*:

E3315; {§i'2'g'}{}::'w.:;&:L ;:zi’v_€:;<;i;a??:J':E. mi" {£34 a<:.2'e$ 3'
g'z%:;"::¥;2:1s.'~: f .3L.:esI3&i{ «’:::%f: j;.fiLéf.§iu:L§ia”‘1g_§V i;:’;{§é::'{§a: . ?.:’§.’2§:*:v’£§3;3é’i£§3,m.$ 3,21% E:>€:f:m%: £:E1i:»3 {3o:.m’..

J3. L~r:£a,2″;”::e:::(3i V:::§a,§:§;§§€:Z»j. ” %__;E”:s: :;:;g3;3€:.§§Ez2a:”;%;:; ézssaiéigizgg $216

ir3’1§3aig:’::c:aiE Vi;L:*§:%.&s,:fV c:ts_r3.i.é::f1éiws;._’.?’ih:2:i: in ‘e.i.§;1e: piétzaziizzggs, ii. is raw,

_ §::«2::1:,%.:.§m?5:<i~ ;»xbz3:;i."*;1'"1§2H .E<:ga::§ of E%%::s. iE,f:3{§;i.i}{}{}j«~, itms: 22312:: <?:"s:§.a:i+.r::.:'1e;:m

am-;'s:. ;2é<£{'§;f.i<;:r:<ji.'§:::s~-:;}::23:é: tsffszxsfi ::2::_":z:i 0:1 ilémii %:zi g;1″m23:1:;:i, am:

§_é§¢~:a3;’é:;é;:¢;§ {f:ia>9i.iv..;_.§L:§§1g£: W:-1:3; 1:03;. i’T§§§§”}’E in .:”%:j53:a:tiz”zg; ‘§}f:a.~:% ;”x:~:=e;;u{%s34″§. £35

_;::;>§.’:::€§E2:e\:”1é:v:§. ” Wéa eiezts mai’: ffirasi 22:33; :~,;’:.V1%2s;’£:’,zi:z.’;_::ti=: in z’..h»{:’: az:.~;§_{§;

‘ 2 ‘ = ef:€>;¢3i:€:;’:€§<:«§f:'.

‘f’§:z:t $§7*€C§.§§,&7 <::,s2::«3:%: zzaatiéa (mi; §;.:€::.%'1":a:M'<: ms: m”‘si i:}3;32’%;.

“”;i::z'<i¥.:.~::" m «:3j=:;'iV:,:<:21%:»r3 1.3%-:% :":1i2":.{za* a:t"§::.§'ii::'1;z"£::":, ii. is; i.'§fZ€jf€':i%Se':K£f$?' ':0 533623 am:

p:'<s§3e3:"£;3.»;, 33123; in 113:5: fE':V§<§§i§,"1%'IZ?€3, §°.Z}"Ta<'~1:*; {::2:.:s;e ::'1a::3e;t am: ws_-"£5; :'V;§m'€.' *{,E":-:3

..«……"..v. -xswwa vvmmumx 1.95 fl\!'*al'k§V§"%l.9"'Va5%J""Z ¥'Eé3.;F§"§1

' .3;:%:;:;3j;f:'}i'£§;j £.;3-A;

Ev

215%’ gaggaeiiaizi. Emati E:a<;m*::exw3<.i 21 §{;3:;a.373 {§§,’%;3£}ii;3′;’:~ §°;=;r;3 s”:1 :;3’f;::{A ‘

‘§:%s5a:’:E; 311143 in d_i:~3<:t}"::r:1'ga2 ihszsz ié'§é3%.,'i$ is:§:a:'L:,_"%;§'?:s<:;% jg.%';'i'<:_3f§:3{~’§.\l In fmjz, ?;§.i:m”e iii; mm n’:m:=E:”§,2?;_% Em 1%’;-‘:s;;>ifi:

A .

2~

.§.2=’:3 :::t.%.3j§ iiurzi %7§_E.’§:~i§’§. W’}”fi.£:”i§ z:2:;m1″;=m1§; s;a,{:%;:;§;:a3;ME.§” tI¥’:,2sf3_ asaaa; 2::§21″: :”_’§z;1’*:*;et: ezn”

w%§im%;§’;s:::’ iiim §§3aia1″:sjE«; ‘§’::»::~; V_i;§t3;§§;~i§ ‘3£€i’_(.’§. ssgagar”_;:;maié:m;ii::1g:~3 §<:r.a.§" ':'<:a'::;.m%<3.:*§;

€33" '}""};':att zag3a.sf:, zizar..¢f:1iE<;£;:–'t:.:s, :§;:*i::. s§m§.::'§.'f§Ji:'1g; 23:: §,;3§"§}';".'i"ié3.§T"§7

;':":g;:.:::£. E*§a1:i;ii§; ” :g’:§ — f:E.:..?i- §:E”;»:§ <:§.2:és§$é::a;""§z2 *s,?«;:*§"3.iz: 3. §;":§§'.'{i

*5;*é;:%aV:<2i;};i"§1g;, ii is $2.31' 1:3 1.5;; '€;.§':£;f.~:'£; ii.éi':'{_~: é-::<:.hJ.z:3;;':<:§r:2':'a w"a::m§.zi {::=::;:aa£ mi'
VE?£§s,;f3{E,{'§€iE{i}j« §Ti2'a=:%:e5.};€:,:;i1.V '%?éfE5':r=:I: tiiae i1:m':§§;fgr m;w::s£~; "£;§"2.fi2 .§z~:5.:z":(§ in («tars

ctxmmt. ‘; {Em t:€’1§:’§3f€3, ggxicayzifz 037 §a”~:¢%:::’£ :,a;’;.ij§f:é:” ;;>::m02’u–33 £11?a.T:i-§.;§:m§V%a;:; 533?’

V’ “fi”.1’é3 “f,”Z£§.’§’fl.:ii.%§¢. >;i{:s-s%;mi’:£:3’$”£%§{i»<:§ tva:"ér:: <':3'3.i.§«v:§_*’ILc,_%:a i:’§;’3.e:’:i§’ ha.§:’;b:;a:’2t.§:%~;y iii; 3:}; :.iii:ff:?”iE”>§’I:a’§.»I&€3;€”‘£{fs,:”, Em:

All

‘fig:§_3e?:1f%2m.V%;.:§’:.w<22_::l«:i '§;§:'2.z'i ii: <:§.?r§§Ea:”;_:*§w=s:: EE”i$f;’: {xii:2z.:2z”L§zi;3″: 392″”
“«%i’E:::i§«:%i’§:¢:’. E11 fkgai, M13313: im: .;m:a;:’§<&:¥;. a:;§'":;.§f_1é: §}Z"(7}§Z3i*§§"'§i}/', %?v::s;:"
'""'wE":;=:;a3"aL 'ihstr ;3.:m”‘1.5:3,»~” ii’; :50 ‘ix: :s;§:’3:;i;L:g;g; fr<32::"2.

"'V.-am: m23::*i,-22:n.2e:’i;z::;r:.<:<:ts3., «am:

1%/"

¢:§;z;::;. as’? f.§mm:. V L’

_ . A. 5 g”

‘ ‘ $.33?’ §¥ §*{£¥.§?’s§é’5§§§fi§’§§% iiifizé G?

ug;:’;s:+r:§. (}?'{‘i€f?£”” :3.s:7:<i:s;e amt s;'z.:fi}:=er i'z*::3az;?:..a.

5:0 mwétt. in 11;} :.§:=; ap;i1€:a§.. E'A:i¢;'-.m:~.<a

Iaflgw

Sdfim
Imfiga

Riki': 2.

;a_.z’:M},:-° i.*;*:§:’§.;«:’5:”M xT§i1§:§’i§?’-.iS ‘