Ganga W/O Chipa Gunagi vs Gowri W/O Narayan Gunagi on 30 July, 2009

nu THE HEGH caum" as KARNATAKA  j
cxacurr BENCH AT oH_AawAa      IiA~    %

mm: "ms "ma 30*" DAY 5; 3:;mi, 2:253  4%  T

sEFc>ii§
THE HOWBLE MR. 3U$'F£CE E£,_!:\}':;..:¥fsifiz;€S;AM5C)§~§§¥§':!§1 was

REGULAR secemb }%.l5PEA§.L rm. %%g,%g[ 2991 cm
RSA caoal rgo;g1%2oc..g% z 3?A1'_%)

BETWEEN;

 

E.

GANGA W/if): c§'i':§A';G§%fis3:'*--    
MAJOR,;..%iASBU%W§:£)A  %  *-
KARWAR % % " L  

msamaak V   
we cH:P;m%ureAs:'%.A    
mama RJO"'HAEiBVVi}.Wi-3;Dfi:"
KAREWAR "

.% sagméég 
  s;T:ol's;:i+a:9;=, £3i.ii'-{AGE
$1.5.-;3 s'3R;'§ .:z,;Q zgjiaasuwam

MRWAR   =

 "'§"¥.£Efi'f'7.*3Ei':»@;S

, *s;:'§ C§~¥i?A G%.E§§AGI

  V§~§A3'€3R we HABEUWASA
WKARWAR

V "  539$. 2 T9 4 33.9.5 AERsEv€§}E¢x:Tii1EKES'TS§

KALAVAYI
WKQ RUMYA GUNAGE
MASQRE RECE BEHENQ '{§§..Lfix,P?JR

 3/"'**"""~



3

ssmm AS135 '(HE 3ut>a:»4Em' AND a§:::2£é§' '=Vi:3;a%'%::.:"§'
23.1:.19§2 mssss ms: §.s.r~:c.52;:9a4 mg '2";e§§,%'%£?~::.EM.MT%;:2§% THE' 

?'¥%L£NS§FF, K£§R'v*¥AR' 

REA gecwm camazs ma ma Hé;a.R::?s:@TA.s.:;a:x5%3%ia_T-£V§ée:.:f*E;ti§A§'§ '£§:é;,:.;**§. Ea thég 3':ség§*r2&s':t; fa? csmafiéence, tése

  ysartéelsgge  is tééeér siaiagg bafafe tfza ?':'§a§ Cam'? I

x  it §$ fiég tasa §f géainiéffs mat §ar;i§ fiamagg Rzsmya

  the twee was sf mg: Qmagé ware 3?$E€'s5:§';I' Qasitéxsaéérzg

 "%:.§§§é"%s€§':e§a;§a §$§?§S 3$ tfiaantga Qeszii Qasaagi éemg {fie eiéest

uénerrsfiar in thé ?am%§y fiéeci ?"t:«s"m-5? fiafase the iané ?r§b:.er:a% an

bahaif af tima famiiy 2%?' gfaat af aatwanzy régfits. "Féze ism

;,7L'W'v



4

'fgibaéraai véée Qréar éateé 1§.$2,3§'}'5 graniefi fifiii駧¥T:.i;gZ'*gfVw!:¥%%§".§?§%;;:§

in €'aa:e:1:' 9%' the Gem? Gzmagé. "§'%mu§§': fiza a:*§ e;%"V:'i(;§.%.t§%g;§

"E"r§b:.zs3a% startds is the rzgme sf Semi? @u;:réa:g:%} tE'§é"«§é;3';r:?§_': scV%1.§§§%eV"'«

groigertées were gséatiy ¢u§ti\§ate5;,T~ and  <ez3%_§%::Vyed Tti§?.. i:Vhe7 

firstfiars referred to above, After £?:»:%."&e_mE$é~.éf"*iévanwfiii éiaagég
his two brathérs by game Néfi" éifia anfi
Msbafid and father ofpiaéniéffgv:i.A._Vf:§:¥'."f5;  cufiivata the
géaint scheduie §ra;_:;e'é*V*$;§:T:e:9s+V. §:'"%:'§1as~:.€%aé'v§§'$:ief__$§t§ved at that gtage,
the sacend  §\,;%:§;=eV§1%§;re' with the piaintéffs'
fiGS$€$$i5fi   i?1'§ W§§5a:'%:2t Sciweduie fiffifififiéefi
aéaimifig Ea §'eVV%a'~§ejgat:jté{*§jV' daieé :a.12.2%§ saéé :9
have fieaja. gxééfuiéfi..'.%§A"é飧aseé Senti §a.%s*za§§. Ea'; {fie
:t,;§v.E§c'iz~r%;$i'§é.:§§£é;*$;;. ';2iAa§ntV§§§s""'§%Eéé QE, §'%s.S2/'84- fer gartéiéan am

$=e§5'a.:*é5t;e§2€.§:f$;g¥s$§Z§ f  w
3i§§'"§Sfi§C"'i:§0€'t to if'! fine sait?   A '

5. Whether the piaérstéffs aregniiéieds'fo'r« i§:f:é§'§ée'~_   

mfits? _   _ % . . 

9. Whatésthe share afthe 9aiT'*t5__e§<'.i_§it?§é"$.§,.§§t? 1 " 

1%. What decrae or e:'éet""»:' .,,,,..V_% A'  

RE~€ZASTE§ESSUE:__    

1.

Whether fize s§é4§._ré:%%Effs’_: ;3§§{zz:__ hu3§:Aa%;§ :2?
zxéaéniiff 1 and éésaé-.A a:j:§s’ed:’5Gg§§%:.A/_’.:wS_:§:nag% have

j:3§rs%’.§’y’ .aé!e;2;.}é.:’jéé_’:’%*’:§””:¢;a3%€’ 339% as ssntenéed in

§a§:’«3 4.@f’ §%$E’e€t’? _ ” ”

_ §i?:a§m.} “;:£ss::;:_=:

fits §§3§§§t§ff§ gsmse that ifée wiié in
V $3; the pmzzésiang :3? we Karféaiiaka
‘A .._§;an§V. fiat arm 2% same S mt §§E”‘§é§§”§§ aa

fiaéfztéffs share? “‘

Eefgre tise “Mai Ceaéri, piaéntiffs axaméneé ‘kwa

? “;§§i’fié$S€§ a$ ?W~§; anfi ?’W~2 Eifié gar? markeé Exam :6 P64,

‘fie secanfi fiefenéasat axaminaé imee wiinesses as $%%’%3=: {Q

$%*J=3 am gar: markeé §><s.§1 ta $3, '?%2& "§':"%a% Cwr': er:

:,;i"7""e'"~""»

apweaiatmn of ihe fiieadéngs, araé and d$£uf¥T&§T-$3':-fy éx?.§§~§¥§%€E';

hem that Germ Gzmagé has as rig???$9..4§e:;'Léé§ti%..'jVt§9§'e:,4_'_p§a%-rgf'»

scheduie prapertées in fawn?' 9'? we sre:;'<:¢n%i_'déféTra~§én}f» £5' §§}_é'e§.§-Tsf

the bar under 5.3:. er the s<am:::}a*~:<:a La"m3 p;e§¢§5€vsiAa:.%v§ The '

"¥"ri3§ Coufrt further heid that piaEa:§f§{'ané"..firs§.fi'ef§3§§}g§;'zt are the
sasrvéxsing Eega% heirs whio""'~g{a.»;§'–. the estate of
fiéceaseé Gent? G;.:_;j'éa,::__3% a::3'§"".t§i¥£.*%:e?af':g;&..V%§§§.:'»"éL.2it for partiiéen
am§ra§ Siaimtiffa ta be decreefi,
Aggfiaveé Csztsuri, ézhe aeconé
fié?€fifi§f§i f¥§Eé§' éV:%%»V"'a;}:fi§<a§»"ééfara the Lawaf Aweééate Cam: in
RA. §«éo.~<%;'§ 3'; _'_ % Vv'T%':Ee"".AV§§o;'~§:}&;L::'géugpeiéata Cami 3&8? hearéag

égsfgamesifgsv f:'~3me§"i%3_e §0%%cw§n§ mm? far i't$ ccmsiéereiieszz

.,§*£%§_;é§%:}aa% "vt_E3& jiififimfifii as?" the "friai Casuré: §§

H * §Aé3'sE%%v'§.§a§§%i$_-.a5§2.é'vin éeacéarénig ihe entire wéié af éeaeaseé
S:é:*.§i%'" §ah5n$§E éataé 3.8.i2a§,9S% as me? b%fid§§'§§?"

'V " €s,_ '"?'%2e wwer Agseiiaia Cam'? 9:: r§%-appreciatiegz af fine

%_e_%sf2't%"1:3§»V.":j°1r*s?é'£e:'Ea§ an regard Qasseé the émpugneé jzségmersfi gariiy

* a§%%§%¢%i§:2§ me asgeai féiéé mi Em gamma fieferzdani am éecéafing

8. Thég Qmxt by éia order fiatea §3.fi1.§=% re’?je7:’%{ éLé;:%,§h;e

guastiesz sf Eaw {1} is a Béviséan Seam §:”; véaw e€”.*;’_§’§’e

views taken in twa repertzed judgme:3:s”%”.e}§.’ \2’s.u

3QsEH?H mugs A949 QTHERSS {::..é; 2j::A1o3A

CL. aavasza ‘.55. mg §<ARNAT§%f,§£'-§&??$€;LA'x"E_TEI'B§J'E*w£Ai;j Ar~é£:«-°

GT%~E§R.S {HR 199% KAR 24,33} VAVa:i%$"L't§jé..§z2d§f:éeVs3.t Jégsrteé in
mRA§A99A GQWDA vs, j:§§.%9?A%V%§%g'";jt:»§%3*:$;;z:m~:%D mmaas (12.9;
1995 ma 435). fyhgg §§v§$_ié%{§+§§§:¢'h«.V:$*i;ia§~0«{;§%e§% dated 24.93%
hefid that in viefiE-£5-E-_Viaa?s»%_§eg§as*€¢£*i _'b}§:§§é Eemrerrze Csurt Er:
3A¥A:~aMA%,.ss,–_ 'E55364 KAR 3935) there Es gm

Gi§$$'C§fi¥} $3'«c:Q';*z'§i§c:"§%" :§§«é§faé Q25 me 3%: destarefi fiy tha

4.S;zpre:r;§§¢’C9La%:t is ‘%§A2t:V_;jii§§2g fig”: a§§ the gartéeg.

ieamaé cmmsei 9:? mm me aiésa arzfi

‘ ‘V p&a*;;:s:se§;: :F%*:g_éé锧§.§**.a§; aasgeai gagem’.

AA fifimifitééégs time séaéat scheéagia §§”§~§§¥”§§&f§ are

‘%§:§é.rVét¥5ea’§: §3?°§§S am eccazgaraay gégfita are grantaé ix favaar 3? the

VT :§?e’::£-‘zégeé Semi Gzmagé $3’ §§3e Laaé T§”§ba§:a§ aséée eréer fiatéfi

‘i§,%2g3§?é* in View af the Eaw éecisrafi by the Samreme CGEE!”§1

én :§;&YAM§\%fi;’§ cage ésiuprafif trafisfar af sgréazsiiufaé E3533 wéih

%;;?’\W*

15

accuaancy rights is $$f’f3′?§S$E§§& 9:253; in fazzaass” af :3:;4’é–&f..i§’t2’§:.锑?°’:é’§’§:s’~.

wha w’0:z§§ be eniétfiad is ciaém §artéi:§¢z:…::;f4 ia2:§” afV’;*é:;£.«’I,:’;i<§§: .§;_;ff's;£*3a?::sf

having regard is the definiticn cf' t%§eA fz;§_§'r'z§%?;: 'as_VA':.:§:~;%:éé::§ear§'7§\§<

s.2{12} azzd joint famééy as %:}g:me¢% fién._$'.»2"{f£:}f'}"~V.wa'f: %féeT

Kamataka Land Refafms Agt. "¥"§':j;e;_:"%_"A'si'_aE'v~.§w.r;t"§'n:,_§$sA,L§ue§grr%er§t
had that daaeasad Ganté G5:3'r2;: '§.§A ?Qs.aL s}:.»:~e;::a '4%'é–{_:'§%§V'i::_Vexecu%e the win
§n qaestiars Sn favoursfi t%1e:.5;=e:a;*:éi§'3:'§Vc§e%fe_fi$a:§.§".§V%§Qxiew :23' the bar
under $ect§aa Lwssar Appeiiate
Cast: heéfi Vhavirzg the p=awe:* te
bequeath piaént scheézfia gmgertées in
favazsr sf i%§'?:=V.V_L:fse€a r§:$ "§§f§fi'e%é:*§. fiatéé iirée C$'urt$ fiefifiw
£amm§tte;f 'a§3 nfié égéag fate the q:.:e$t§or2 '¥'S='§°?E§§"%&¥"
$V%=%aiV:r*:g*.i *;$ a %e§' a % h&i.r' af éeseased §$:2ié fisamagi $2" mi.

in §§3e:§::$tVa¥§%§9fv'fa§'fsé;j Ei: 'Es; mi :2': §§S§§.fi'E& that fihe fieaeasefi Qanié

__ "'€$::;2a§E z%;=a;§ mi .:%;rlarf:"§e§ arid mg ésaueiesg. Eartha? it ig mi 5::

""-§"%$;3::'éé,, {fiat éiéere are na garvivéng Eagfi fiééffi as spezzfféafi :3

»_'"¢E§é§$;§'{:}. é§ flag fiaégeéésée is Sastiara S 3% téae §"'§§!"¥§§.,f Suscesgim

_f?f§;f;§fi§:'E?'§$ isratéafi tfzai they am the wife 3:25 chéffirmz 3% éate

fine bfsthar 9? fiemé Qamagi. Fm: éefersdfafii csntenéa

S éézai fie is {fie bretfier sf Qereté $i.£§"§a§§. Secené éefenéani: in fie?

i7\§,W

11

wrétterg atatement conteafis tfiat she is the sister cf__Ge:”:tE

Gunagé. in VEEW 3? these révaé contentémzs in tha:’. bE:éL;a.§37’§vr3g$

befara tha T:*ia% Cmsrt, as issue E:-2 framed ts fifiiti ‘u*s:3′;s:c;’:.é£f%a:.. t’§3e?’»

iegai heirs whc have szuccéedeé to thVe”es€a&te~’_§f ;fi’i:e§:;sé¢%ieé”.i’fié€3t§V ‘ ;

Gurzagi. Wiihsut examining this issliée,

cemmétted an iiiegaiity in pasfsézfi-._VtheA.”érr}pug$1’-$锑:~.§ié’€}g:’%:es’2ts.’V

Tharefsre, the questécn affiaw N§;.–{–3,§”‘framed a’bcx»’.e anawefeci

in the affirmativa.

11. ‘fiae i.4:>f%i<3%:.¥' '°t§§1éi'§%i.%:::é_j'§Q'i;ew that seisraé

fief&r:da:*s*1: '-¥_s fc5st.駰;£~':s§':'-r§aiz,§"%*:2?§§"—- a¥r2"é therefesre, she $3 entitied ta

§§%:e§'Ei the é«.«'°:.ta*%";§: V%.%';:f.'4V:;€'gfe%:*§:_53'3;eé Qenté Gasnagé is ééiegai and

_.§ er%;e:"§-:s;{. V :1: is :*:§:"%f3&f_ saw as? sacersfi fiefanéanf: thai she is the

fisus*ééV:*:ake::E1 _§¥' fieceamd Qenté $s..snag£. Ever: stherwise,

:g:~:§asf"T?2.~éE§s§i§s' §};aw"§§§s£§;"efi §8§i§§"!'§&¥' is mt a:**:t§€§e§ is érgéfieiéi the

é;s%ate'$f §é:«.§e;a5s:aé ?t3Sie¥'"$§ faifiész -E-§'§%§pEf$F§§ iize '§§%"Eé§E'§§ 8? the

;é;;_§§é?§Eaie C323': is éfiegaé arm gewerse, Eianca, time $&€%¥"§§

-€i§{‘i–€é’:»:§§e}s’3§§§ Ema: fzamefi above is arégwareé En the affirmatiase,

‘ 32′ it 33 fast the cage es?’ §éait3t:%?fs that they Seam

éscceeéaefi is the efiaté af damaged Semi Gufiagé as ‘aha

I2

szmzivéag Eegaé heérs ursder Ciause (2) cf Sc?:ed::i.6{ 8I’

Successien Act” Cm the ether hané, thabA;;cntenti*o’s3.. ;;:i¥’a::én%:A§fi’$ “§*s=

that they and deceased Genté Gunagi :a*,1(c:e:’:sf;.*:!:;*;.L’ist:é2_,§?.$%::.ét’-féwfgéiy

eccupancy rights are grantefi to .tVh-3.eEc¥ér”.v_r%%e:f:3br3’rV ‘égifvitfig

§.e,, G&Rt§ Gu:’:ag§ and the eccupar;f%;.V”fig.§:’ts $52} favcur sf
the joint famiiy {sf the tbreéirrQt–%}aVer;;; ms § s fhe specific
case of gfaintéffs, ting Triai any issue ans
has net ghzers arjg §.:§:Vi§:V..é’?r’-E*:’:;.=~Anc!, the Triaé Ccurt

prwceeés ts ‘§2£’3ir§i:éffs en téza grouné that

giaiiztéffs é’-sjd ._f%:s§ ‘{i.-2=;f¢:’e~s§é:”2§”-aré -the sufnsivézsg éegai Fieiffi cf

deceased §é%”:*:§::Gzgéiégfi’f%”§*:§;>*§%¢:reg the imgwgned jfzéégment $1′

the T§§a§ ¢:;:bas:ft is i§é;’:%i.V§ i:5@ béz set aside.

:fi?;«=:2 reasens statefi abmae, fim fsééawérzg:

* *v”-“‘ $a§£g
{E}-«.._ “j¥_fZ?3’e.v:z§f~§;§aa§ am fimss fibjeciéarss aye aééaweé.
{SIEL} z 2’?’§i:’e Emmggnefi Eaégmefit arafi §&C§”‘&&* fiaieé
3§.:a,2a§: gagged’ if? Rdfiw §*és$4;”93 by me mi. Céaféi

jassége isr. Sm}, Kama? arsé the Easégmerzt arzé

13

Decrea dateé 23.1232 fiassed is;

by the Munséff, Karwazj, areihereby _sé§:’ _

(%i§} “me matter is remitteé ‘£o!”:.t%’s€2§_’_”T7é ia’%’*fi$~§§*%:’§é:%\,4,_f€e:;%:

éégyasai in acceréant e “*:§¢it%: ‘iavés afte:% ;éi§o–x;;§§%.s§g %a::; ‘

spgestasnéty ta géth i%2Ve. §art§a»s a%§§~ e>;v%i5edé’:Ea»a:$%y
as aossibfie an”§g7§[r:. ‘a_:°:§é:.é%?”é:§”s€:’»”r%.,aft meg” that six
manths4_’:¥”o_;m §i:’9f”‘<¢'~:-fie;"a§'L,_{é€e§§:1.v'é? 3 may 5? tiwés

eréaé" 44 ' '

{W} _.€:}€'fi 5é7é7éi,'i é:;§§s'fi_§§:§i'§*." V V

33%'? . "