IN *1'1«11: HIGH comm' OF KARNATAKA AT BA_NGA1:f)RE
DATED'1'HISTI-"IE 30'"! DAY 01%' SEP'i'EME3I§R'§4: A. N
PRESENT % 1 u'E'
THE HONBLE MR. 13:A'j:A#_1_i1;&
AND 1 .. , . _
THE HONBLE MIz.J1U'S*1.fijcE_
M.F.A.ANE).2$é»4{Z;iO'O"?'.('}\/N)
;3mw1«:I«:N: " H V' . '
K.SUKANY_.'A' _
w/0 LATI3 _r\/1..1w_a;PRA'1z:¢<\'s;"r==I'i,'%. ' . ~
NO.1QV1.{).,T.NIvZAE1J1«:1,1,,AN*1'
(13Y_sM"1".A S'1 JV-V.1':_)'*;"?. FOR
1>1'1.Q1«' I<is.s121~;;sk{g\__:\J';f1T1 ASSOC}/\'1'ICS)
~rfI§1.1}:(fii1j;3N"_1'S_I'2}§:I;"VMANAGER
I{.S.R.'1"..C.", A
K_I"L I3--QUi.31.1«: ROAD.
S}--fAI\5'I'I3-IINAGA.1'{A.
' AA I-;_-;A11\%GA1J.01zr2. .. .R.ESPONI.)Ij£N"§'
V[I'3Y I\/I /S.\r'IE3\-'\/AN/-\'i"I""1 ASSTS A ADV.)
'1'?--IIS ER/IF/\ IE3 I'I.I.,I*3I') U§\§I)I£R SIEZCTION I73(E] OF MV
ACT :'"\GAINST TI'-113$ JUI)GMI;CN'I" AND 1'-WVARI) IDATICD
Ié.i.O6.2006 I1/\SSi{3I') IN MVC NO.41.E3/1'2.()U5 ON 'I'l"i I£ I*'II,I%3 OF
'I"'§"IE PRL. IJIS'1'RIC"l ')GE 8: iViAC'I'v[, MAN DYA. .PAI1'{'I'I,Y
.'//M/_fi___M,,,
7
AI.I,OWII\§'G 'E'I'""II'Z CLAIM I'I'3':l'I'I'I(3N FOR COM}-'i3NS[\TION ('ii
SI*3I*3K1NO I'iIi\§}"I.A'NC.{.ZM LCNT OF C()MI--'I£NSA'i'ION.
THIS AI'I'EAI., COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY.
N.K.'PA"I"Ii. J .. DELIVERED TI IE FOIJLO\?V{NO:--
JUDGMENT
‘£’1’1c)1i1gi’1 i;h.is alrapcra-1.} is posted for ()1’c’le–;’i”s,
iLa1<e1'1 up for final 1'1cai*i_n_«_§~a'i"id_is7_4 c1i.és.p"<:-sad »<.fi7 5-3
follows.
2. This appeal by 1.116: (T4VE”‘§:.-1.VlI”.£’)1)>1E1I’1tf 1:3 .C:iE:”.CE_”Cf;Tl€Vd aigaiirisi. V
the i1n13L.1gi’1c:(i j1i1(ig117.&:’.i_E. 2-lritimé’1t1.i_gj;-fl'”c1.;1md 1Z;_6″_V2005
p21sse:c1 in 1 on the file of the Principal
Dist,ricii J Licigé V andya.
‘i”‘hc’-‘£’fifi’1jL.zi’ia1 by its jLEC1§j;I]’i@l1i. 2-{lid awarcl iias
fci’*::;~fi_1.117:1 of ?”‘1.10,000/- with ii1t.er<==:si. at 6% p.21.
._i'1*b_i_n 1'i:.k§'~v£121i;§-til" {.116 pCt"ii:i<m til} i'.1'1e (:12-11:0 of i'céa1ise1i_.i()1'1 :1-5.5
E-1g.E45,{§1'}S–.;Ei tlié claim maclc by the a.ppc=:I1;;;1111 for a sum of
'?5..QO,VOOO/- on ac{:0'Lmi 0i'i:1'1e :'njmfie=rs susiiaintid by her
1'1' if1'}c=. r0:.1(i 1,1'E1fE"iC a.a.c.:ci_c'Ic:i1E_.
4. In %Ji’icfi.hc E? 01 it. ?{‘,as(‘. are :~
The 2.1p}.)e11;-1111′. (..’Ie1i1’11s to 11x? 2::.gE’CI ab(.)1.1t. 34 ye’c.11’S.
tailor by prcflession, gctt.1.i1″1g income ff m(“)1’e I’1’12u1
?5,000/« pm. She vvas hale and ilealthy prior _1-,9 the
aeeide1’11.. When tI’1i11g._s st’L.)()(i} thus t.1’12::.t’ on
when the 2;1.ppelIa1’1Ee was 1.ra\.rel1ing in i’,1’1c:’l.(._§’211ij1i)e’2~:i*ieng ‘
Reg.N0.CAQ 9475 with j1’ie1*”< A_1'–<;:i21;'é;i\A2{€é.€i<__ V
Channaraya.p21I"1'121 to HE}-SS§'i1'}. The ;<;;;1ici (:2',1_1f 'wa's
driven by her h1.1sb2md w1'10 'Vf1;ip;3e11s'i.:?' be.'{:1'1é;()wner of
the ear, slowly andeavL1tioi.:slxfi Q11 {the Iei'1 Side of the
road, near '1'.C.H. V__Vc_i()i.}Ve;-.'§<_:* ()–f'I~. "t::}_'1e5 outskirts 01"
C112-:1'1Vi:1211"ayaV1j2iwi;e;'1.gi"e _t;(mfr2—__ * ilicr KSI-"{"I"C bus be;-11"i1'1;;§
Reg.N0.K'A_13/ F' 9_é}4aL::1,VrAi1.»cea z:u1(.i (.12-1.sl1ec1 2,1gz1'111st the ear in
\vI".=.i.ii;11 'ithe 211'3}:a(;:Vl}211&1é.: xx.-'a:5 t'.1"a.veli1'1'1g and eaused the
';ieeiVci'e1_'1"r.e '::1_1i"c}__ on 21ee0u_1'"1t of w1'1iel1._ she s1.1s1ained
'ge1*i'eV(')1.zé';–7j–11_j'::zries. Em1"1"1e(ii21t'.e1y, she was silifteci 1:10
Ge1'1e.1'éi1..Hospital} at HRSS2111, where she I"0c)k I'z.'e21I.111e1"1t.
I'(5r9"a period of 25 days-3 as i:1;.e)a;at.ie1'11' zmd 1'he1*e;1l'"Le1'. she
S1'1ifi.(';'.(1 to NIIX/IHANS. E-32-11'e1gz-1l()1*e. II. is her 1'u1'1.1'1e1*
e21se that. she sust'2'1inc:*(i in_1'1.11'ies ml the 1'10:-Id. i1ips, rig;']'1t.
sl"1ou}de:" and other ;11*'t.s: of the l.)c_)(§_\_r. S116 has spent.
llugc sLm1s 01" n'1(.)11€y t'ow21I'c1s medical E"XpE'11st.'S.
C01'1vey21z'1cc. :10111*isi1ing' food emd z:t'.t"c:11c.iz1111 ch£1.1"gc?s.
The d()('t1':()r W110 trc-:?atcr('1 I 1']E' 2–:;)pcl]z1:'1t has 2:sscss"(:–d the
physical disatbi1i1.y 10 Elle exlem: of 75% t().¢.._tjJ11§f:'fi5v}1'O<ig;r
body. 'il"21l<ing 2111 t"hc'-rsc 1"eicr\ram. f221ctors._ iihe v;i§Tp1;)ne11é:1'1[1: "
filed a ciaim pct:i{,i011 bcfc)1'c '['l'1Ef.TI'ib{,i1V'1E11 ti.1'11c.ji_.Ve5:'.uSc5f(?1:i0iA1
166 of file I\/l.V. Act (:l21in1i11g compC';~i1se1t_io1-5.; .:¢1gaii11s:t 'i:E1<-fa
resp()11dem:s. 'l'!"1e Said ctléiigfi' pe1;iE;'ic)11"ExétclKpolnc up
(:cmsidera1.i()1'1 13elb1"c__ i:'he .';F1'1':}'_)L .i1'1_§.1'1.,V "v_'1'1'1c 'l'ribunal, in
tum. has allowed 1'.}1c:._,$%a–i(iv .ci.:;in 1"=V1'3Ve{iV1;-ib1'1 in part and
awe-1rd_c=.c1._ cc.);'ime;1é;api'(:a:-ji'~01" ?.~'1..!.0.000/~ 1_ll'1d€I' c1ii'i"ere1'1i.
heads. f'1'1';<: £1;);5é:1i»;:,V;'i"§L. not being sa.11:.isi'§eLi with the
q11.Ei{1t.1.i;11 of(f():'11}3e11s»21t',jon 2_1wa.rdec1 by the 'I'ribLma}. has
V p1=<:scn1fcd « V 1: h appe al for e1'1i1a11(:cI11ct'1t of
'«:i()mpen sin: i Q31 .
,4. A1″t’.c~:” 1′:e211’i1’1g the Ica1’1’1ec.i (“.()E.1]1S(‘.l for the
;ip ‘p..eil2.1.:’1E 2–m(l 2.11161′ gc..)i1’1g i]’1roLzg_3;l’} the 11-:1 zmd (l(>(_’um(31.'”1m1’y 0v1’dc1″1(“t(‘r on :'(=,<:()r€'l
2-Incl other m221tcri2=1l on me. 1.2_11<.1'I1g into 0011sic1c1'a_t'.i.1’1 lthc
‘C .».E«—-»~*””‘°’A
3353.000/–. (‘()1)\-‘t’.y2111(‘TEiT. I’1(‘)1.11’iS1’1i1′}g.;’ food 2-imi z’:111cri1(Ea-ml
cliairgcs at ‘<'i0.000/– as z1gz=-iiiist ?5.000/~. loss of
income duririg, t"1*c2a1i'.1ncri'ii". f.)C']'i(')(fi1 211' '€9,000/~ [?3._()"OO/ ~ x
8 mciniilis] as e-igziiiisi. '\'5,000/~ Efliid
(?'3.000×12 x 25/ 100 X 16) i(')\v2'u*cis fl_ii",i;,1'}«':fj'?'vvb'
il'1(E(')1'I1C. in all, the e.ipp<-21}:-.1111. Gf¥11'_1:fi"if'.:ff::'d_7IUI
as against. ?.I.£0,000/». 'i']_ie cii'ii1ai=1(.:CdT,<§ti1i'i}){é1'i$§3a1i'ii<w1'i*i
comes to ?I.,63.000/w with 212E'-ES?'/Ar_'i' 13.535 ironi the
daiit-3 0f1.l'i(: pci:ii;i0n {viii"if-'3a1«i:sz',1i'i(51;.__
6. For the f01′(3§§()i.!1.g’=1’€£1.S01′}.$5Uiiiilgtppcall is a.l1ow(=:d
in pa”zji.. -Ti irj v1″vi'”.’1″‘1″),1′,i}__’__-:I_’IC’.’C.’1
ju c_igii1c31’1l”. 2-i1’i(:E award passeci by
the ‘1’i’ibi’.ai’_12iI_iii 2005 is hereby modified,
axafiirdiiig (ttiiifiieijisaf.ion of ?’1.63,000/» with i1′}t.C1’CS{i at
‘ _E$%_ p..,a’;. ‘ii’_1’ ‘t1CiC1iU()I1 to the (t(),mpe1’is2ii:ion awa;11’cEc’=x:E by
‘ihC51’ribti’ijiaE};
,. ‘£,”l’ic 1’CS}_)(‘)1’1CEC1’1I~C()1’]3()I’atU()1’l (1i1’C(‘1.C(l to
Vc1VC”p..g>si1. the Cl”1héf1I’1{.?(}’.(I1 (30111pC11SE’1U(‘)1″l with i1″1i’:ei’c:s1 within
i’?0u1* Wf’;’.c?1{S fniiii the <.'1at':e. of 1'CC(?if)1. of E:1'1c copy of this
j L.l(1gi11E'111. 25:1} (:1 am: rd.