High Court Karnataka High Court

Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Amtul Hafeez W/O Syed Sabir Ahamed on 23 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Amtul Hafeez W/O Syed Sabir Ahamed on 23 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


§§%*’ 3%: g§:::g.:a;%.;:§§’:§37:’~:I;V’,s.g§:,:r§f§§ 5-é.”§E:§

x-Mmw-w:+«l

§%§I§?iz§§*5iés f§~'{§2§§§ ;’Z1%§” £§Z}*i’Z.3§ §{§:§E57E

i;%E$%%?§2L Z§§s$§;”E£§§é3;;¥’;; iii?
Z§T§’.f%?Z;§’§§ :s§*:i=. ‘ . A _

EEK {§E§E1§*E”§’§s;7{£?§5%’i§§§sE§%$:§ :§£f:§;:, .
§$§:s:.::E%;é; :§;%?§’:{;f;n€’_:§V:gf::–¢«§.%§+; ;%§€:éfi;%;a:?:*:–;,–~”
LEQ ‘§§§{T§§§§;§§§?f_ £fif3T:?g§%3’Es%;§§§ ‘§§:§::’;%2:§§;::*:
:_,:§@$s,e §$;»%g;§§:j_:§;%.:;§%§;%;:#=$é§~?:,:r;€e§:§?:*;A£: fifégfi

fig: .

5 , ,;%?§Ei-3%”?

éfigsz. ‘I

., _ 3% ”

‘ “h 4.

‘$3; $’§’E:g3 Efifiifi
_ °’§§;§,§:§;§§
5}? §§&%§§§:§
A , ‘ §§1i§;’§}E§§:E*§§’§ $?:§;”:>- §?§%§E;§
§;–.%:i’:a E%2%$§ fi;E§£%§;%
é:?$%§?$§§§{‘}3§.e§a $3,; 5;} $333?
.. 3 gag Efiéfifiéjgg §<§§:§s:"::§s$;
' « .%E§§§$3i;*§g

$§a§*§: 2 §§.§;a:§"::

gfiagggé

‘%§§,!%3 Ei E~E,%%§f3é§&§ § EEEE
5:2 E§E:§f£:§; agggggé

‘K

g, g §’;’=~i”;$’§”*:f§§§§§§§¥’§%

y 3};

§? $%Ta &,§’%5L ;¥’€3§ REE

‘EE§E£ §:;:%% 2% m% 32%;; §§%’ $5? gs.i{*§7;aa§:>§%:%

féféfi f{%%’Zs%}.§€E§ §;§§. f %§’§_%3f§»?§{Eé$ §L%;’3$f}§§§:’–;C”

§§:§:92§%$ ifié 3§§ §§a§»€3% :3 E}E%?EiE§§£;»fi§%§iz§1§E§§E’= R

if§%.Z§%Zf%2} & ;§:§,f%r§’i§§? isgzgizgggta 23:5; _§s§::2:%g;:.a’2§*§~s??§s; _ % }

%§:’:§%’7E is §’¥’§;’ée,é::%;fE3f;;*– .é::J$’§”%i:;€’$a§@%€.%; Qszmgazgff

‘§5%”§.$ §’5;:7Wg;:fé§ sémfifi {f%%§i2§§3$

;;;a$$%%§;~: §§g;,,%§§%’§E§§;%%_é3:: ‘£.fi:”:§: ma :2? 522% :1;

§.§§;:§:sm:%. 5.:avg:jggggéggjkjiggyéxgxg mg fifiéififiimi aa;%a*§:
$Z%*$2:§:sggf , %%

E3?’ ‘i§*%Tf§.§.Ts§.,E§§§%§»§ §§;:<§g:f*§::$§"%T gm gwaffigg éém

gamggmaaérésfi fif

§.:::;¢§:5'$é;_§5§&.: é'%% gay fiiééééém ?;':*":3§i:: ifrzzz: fiaig a::af gfiififififi

fig §;sa'§:§:3£ai:{

V' . _ 223$ $.§§&§}a§:%., Efigégrfigzizfi 3&3 iaéifiia gfééfiiéiifi

223$? fiéfimmi Ems; Q$ §%%&-é an arm? £33 gwggéérg

aha aiémgxzzégafiggé E23; $éfig 3. ;%iZ§%i% a:§i$a:%:%i§§;3§~ zsgéésgizi

''m*:** A

figa

Efiéfsffi ékiéffig $:i";%;§? {sf @255 333332? 53:' '§€.%'§§E€'lf

§j%§'$$§:§4 E1': 23% aéfimm 3? £§§*:m°$ yamfi :"&§£§i;§::§§:§

ygfiris 5% gm' §X3:,§;§§.3 Ea Réfisiji fi $3 ;E§z§$§§:;.§$§:%'3§%a $3..

wage éfiégfiffigfif' an aim wgffiif. $§ Tfihfimé ;&.$%$<»:a;.a;:-:3

§;%£g:$§:;:+r as: ::}a::% 3:3? af" fl;::&§§i3<}§i$; '.

mmywngabffigz E”:%.fi $5 ‘£3213
ézggfzzifii E133 s3:;*§:a§%%%;;i._..’:”%»;:%§’§:;’§:P§::_ A 23%: 32%?
hggkargé ‘gag zjzérzfi fiizégm he Egg:
222$ méma-éhrjg Saw’ §”i?»§§?;:§:!.§’%%
33$ @;§’:f:§g;§itAV.%.;:.v

§% §i£? Ezaa mi fiéfi

$.fi}?V:s*§§3:a:*%?;T”‘%: éfiaéé 321$ sixgfiééfzfid zha §€3$*{:’.’;§’ whs

V’ §a$iz2:a%§i..A’-:«.$m’:;z:é sfi’;%”‘:;.}’*§§”t§m EKa§’3.Z?w§ ii’? amt: mpmwg mifi

;:'<;;:3g:s 3,:~§§$:*%,,as '?:3 gwggfi -%§§%';Z3g::%ii%'§§=~ téwgrég

Qaggmfiézy ?;§'§:_':iI*&

335:3; Q? arsfi Eacéz Q? §§.§f£E.é§$'§ ;- '

£3 32::

V $,, ma Emwi §Ef,3£,§.§’%%fi§ fa’ éérie: aaéméig

.V __:E§1a%E: iiiftafi i::§a2§m§ wag fizfimgézé §.%§§:”fi 222% figagzti ma? {Em

?fi%32:§mE 292.3% 32:2: gzmgiémza E33333 gzési afggstaagéé fig

K

$32»

:i€§a%;§?;;i::;° 3%, :if.%€’.’:?% 33$ %E”:§§$ ég 2:6; gym? $3? ‘%:§:a€.:f§:fi1″%c§¢

fiézma iéiza :%::§z;3*:&zi hzmfiggfizfi Ema Em: 23$

gama £3 c=$::,s%;i:§&m:§ 323; mg “E’:*i’%:;::3;3:%; f3? .§?:¥E~f:§”vv§§E.3;§§T:&:%.;$% 9:25, V’

§.§fi§%t§££%§

giga zafizzwfiiiig
afiimz ifi §§:&E:’:;’ 3; %::%£%E:§’§$:§§ fi§:f::*e:.:2:j, V’ ‘ ‘. A. V
fix Eiamré Efiia “$§;:§V§a:§
§’:’m:; §’.§f%” i?::’:Z§ ‘iéza gcgeéiififiimf
Emg fiégfia 3; §z§§g2:r;_ V §”:%;,3;§§’§§£1£i it

is §°fizf’éé;%§z§:- Eifgéat Egg: ::wm:::§§a Eifizzmm
§3fi?$€’*’;§ ~:f.’.::4:§ 23% Eiéfiiéfiif: fimigzz” Qza segfi

%’.j§;€¥§§3§:~ fast? *::*m is £22 an

;a§:§§°§»i’?i3′: flag Egga 2.35 :32″ fizz.

_;°’§ i y?

1*§’§:’gs:’%’ :1§%:§:§g§;@*§:$.3:§§:: §%’$.f£’s;i§§%-Lféi zmfiéfi

§ :§&§§;}§ §.:€éI§%;: af fgmyfi érazmmfii, gain mgfié %:;:§§&::~é;;;g§ gag’?-5:5:

.§%,3;§:i2m*’»— §’I§§£7§§.i?»§,: %JE§%§§&% azéii éigahéfiiigg %¥§*%:E’1:m§ ‘élhé

j$§§§,§.i$2*:g$ fié” 33% §;$£::m%’2 figs ‘§’:€§:.:2’fi§ gwaydfié Eeaéé

‘ ‘ -‘§:s:§§1§%::g§_:§:::§2 ggiitkzii iiiizrfi 3:”; ? ff$§a:*$:*.;:;fi €§§ iégfi

a

fisxsazm 32% jffié w

~

* $§’:f;4-..;3£?éé:§:é;;.i:”:::2§E fis.:«:::-ragma ‘§7%§.& __
” g – ag éjia CB{E;)€g:.&..{¢& 5;. _/(LFP(,giW,fl’__ (er/ffiffzny,
Egg émiémjéraw ‘?§’% 5%}? éfiée fiwfiéifi amfiazgzifi” arigam

:3?’

:3 E$§3.°Efi’§’§§%§, a&:E%2§;§e:*&?d%:zg” ”

izagiiaszé $a§::%*::f2§:ié%22 :*:3zs5é:” 32% ézzggafifi ‘ €;é=”:: ‘é:;i’i%f;& V i:,&3!i%s

£3? §§

rig $;§%::=J§:’:;%§ Egskéizgg £3: ‘;?.;:,§’*, ig V’

Egg; asgggsgg m”.%,:;§. Eméia :32″? {£29 waféii

fiéiaésééfiirzazi Ei3?’§2E€1’€§E§fi%:é %:«9§’.:;§2§%L;-V ”

Ga §”§fi?”§%;’3¥$§ t 3.32%: E? §:é§;*§§,§:*:

j flag “?:*§’b:::;§.% 5%: ma
‘$3-32$ :i”§%E!:.§fi’£§’ :3?’ Efififfi iézmg gig

grafimg ?.Z%§.i3_ ‘La E::$§.5::* grgi 5:§%:§Z.fl§s2E 33%

mgfiifgfitg %:f§%:,%°:;§.~§”§§ ;$;..;%:*:;2t*;:-:3; 23% iéérgzé :.?”§€?:§TfE§§% §:*::::’z.: %:}f:&: 5323 :3?

y;

mg? 3? ‘%.:%w gmfizazz 332$ §€’§§§i§3’§%? fm

z;i%:’%i’:%$§§” ‘§’§3fi §%§i.?E§i.?:’ gzézfi; §:§§§?ZE.;EE§ .2:*§:§3&:*2%{£ $3

*3 aééagfi :§3:§.2*§§”gé? ?é§fi;fi@ aztzai éfiafi §£§ié…;%m§
%raWmir: %
» 2′: 3.3 Elhtfififiiiffizé;

§§§:1i:iw::2:: fig :*%”§;:;i::z*&;% *%:::::: fiézt :9;:”: :§ §»$;,§’§§fi% 327% iiifééfiifiii $3

‘{

{:3 CLCEFWK 5%-sa.¢§ \f?:¢§. éf… \ 4
C~’ :54′. V Egg’ ~ H. i “£1 06° Li” [.1’\./’§’.:3_

45,. 35) 3, §

*3;

a§§§.:w:.§i: %:;:@.;§%3:*’£ ‘%:fi”,%s;*:: ‘%’:”§.%:*z* €32:

&%”§i§T:iT§T.% mg: 3″”é$tf:.i%¢

€;3§;:::& 5?;’E “7fl”§§%.’t’.§;’é§?_i §.,§.§%3§€§* €$’§§.S§””€ ;r=’$#:w,:”:::,*x§;§§,–A”i:;:2fl;k ” ‘

%

\ 3UD§E