High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Syed Zabiulla vs Smt Aruna Devi on 9 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Syed Zabiulla vs Smt Aruna Devi on 9 June, 2009
Author: N.Kumar And Gowda
fi'~%&"%"fig%& §%%fi«§% fiifikim? Q?' mmmmm. MGM fiflimfi' fi% %&fiMfi.E"flE€& flifivfl fiflfififi? Q? mmxmmm flfififi mam?

 

§%._ 
3
Q
$3
§
§
E
§'§
%
E
E
ég
§
§
fi


IR THE HIGH COURTCF KARNATAKA. BAH

mm!) THIS nmaz my me' .1133,  "j%%_j ".

PRESENT

THEE Hozmmnm JUSi'fi€.'.E3 .3.  

TIE HOKBLE MR. JUSTICE B-$EEN1'1&"1'$"-' 1 ' 

Bstgrm

S:-isyedzabiulia, ‘- _
Sfofiydshafium, _ _ V
58% abeut34’Ye%a1’3» _
Rmfiing at
wash Road. .

(By a-iK.N.      3
 .....  ' I
' ?impmwmr,M/__a.  CO ,

_Rc.3’1;9f–v1 ,’ Rand Lmcea,
Raj, 3.

‘ ‘M1 3. Irmurarwu Co. Ltd.,
” Ofie, R954] 46, Lac» Comspm,

RESPGREEEKTS

: é “(By st: 3.3. Immh, fiat R-2, R-1 asspemdy
” , **’§**

This WA is an u.aa173(1)afMVActagajrmt the
ju@wt and award dt. 284.1-2006 paaseé in MVC
Ho,.%’9l2% an the % of the 185 Md}. Juége,

\_€\§.\/

was

H Sam figs again fin Wm sE*1ii”‘§@ 2:33

Rmaah Hmpémi, Ex: fig

wifieriz, the mm sustafiim fftgr;-tux’-3; {if ” *« V.

an tm glasses haewaa $?$’&’i&&:3.Ifi:’}ig5′

ma 25;’321§%. fsfifir

mgamam anfi 3%” . H
he pmfwmfi a o1a§m$ “§§ti,%%%.§t_: %-;:a:}mem&ti0:: crf
§Es:2S,%,fl%f_fV’ fifir in me
amizient zrsf flax: my aim

T§1g’Z%.*£_ r%%§’.$r§ti&§1t.£;:*&?%1¢r ssf fix @233? £135; mat appaarg

mi mrte. The 3” rm@ndm§~

mg fiiaé its fiamiiefl

m:’1te$ti.:z1g “aim aiaim mtitimn.

fiié. mt fiiayutg gm amidmt, mi’

– W;-ix _-« ‘UV – u _ ” ..v _ ,’,.u. . ,., E E…..,~_,«g QM” wmmmmm W§%.:$§”fi @5mv%3’§e..££%§ KW” ammmmmwég §§?%»N”°§ QQEUKK £3?” mmwmmwk Wfifiwéfii fiwfififimfi kw” ¥%fi4.M.€’%€$’%..%a%%fi WWWN

agfi ‘m fix Emrrrjf fizz. qumfiimrz.

tkm
* gym Eab=§’a;}.}.a

as P.§i.€~ mfi Em grsfluzzaé. E3 fieceumefiia §vif§n7&;§i.:are

ucwww u ww-wwuw “WUWW.

was an amsumt af gag}: by thm
&rm’ 1′ 9f fiw 3§’If’.’t”jf figtahiiwhfi

‘Z7. h’:wn.._$%riée%:§§& an rmwré

as Well 3.2; “€316 ” éficter whs Emtad “£113

I:?.i”¥ 2′: fif ‘$1 femfif. T1113

wafit’ amratémsa mxfi E23 was an

i
E
E
3
E
§
§
E
3
§
E
:

E
:

§
E
E
E
In
3
§
3
23
Q
$3:

§
§

%§,ia::_§i;*fs*:§:*. .:;§..a:g$§ amt: aficar Exmmwizz. éémrc £3

€i§§3’§?%&8§Etg ‘file §astgr Ea; fiepassad

gm» &?1£a’%i§§.’§;§=’ ‘:3 gm axtcrfi. 3:’ 35% ‘:3 a

€331 fim

3%-‘% ta fiw w}:s§

1;m§

93:’: mmré iim “E”:*§.hm};

‘aha: afarfigié

awmw Rgzgamagm igwmfls mm ma
R3,1i},€3${};~ zmaréa Ems mi am¢n3Eti&$§ Ea$?5§§$§g’~«

§§§3§::::3§:;%; «~ étswmfig
ix/’

E~% flflfififi?

meirkmi aa Ex$.?~i $3 38% fir; Eimif ai’
we com} anti émizmsntgrg !5″J’is*.ifii’}=f{»’§ Wag ”

fii Tha Tfihmm} an Qgmséfiréfiéfin ‘V

dm::§.1m:::ztar3; mriéenm an

“W %L;’Ll§;2%WW” WE?” %§W€N%{W’»%$’ua% M” “5 “i .’– w,’ ‘ W – v – – – ‘ — – . .
3 EWM %;§&f:,1W’;§ Q3?” fiflfiwfififlfififi W”§§§.:&§”‘fi %W%en§%x.% W? Wwmmmwm §”%3EsvM £.,m.3m WW wmmmmwm Wfiwfi mwwm W?” fimflmfiifififi Wiww bu

mrwama, rmuriaimczai mzfi; attanclant

333$’: was an inmme tax aasmzsee,

retzzrm have Tiamrz §md:.:mi §?:j;€;Emt V. :

cf tha claimant wag takm at ‘$3553

unrim trsaitmaniz Em: 2. V’ ::~3s1¢§i’¥:;’2*ia?e’;v.*¥;*.,§§x_§§.3i’z:r:51″e.,,: >

the fliburmi. hag awjazdfi. .–‘ ksas (“if
Emma fl am: L__:§~f Es=§§i°},Q$3j-
mwaréa» ” §_;c:wm&s fiztzxm

mhk 1 €..g $2′ –.E-“{$g;i’.’=- was

awarfifi aa

saw me ia =

8. efifigiisfifaf {hag agzspgfimits asaailim

mxfigfiaé tint Elms alafigai Ema

fif R$wsE.!%,?3§§!?gwg ‘aha

%§§}§img=.mm3$az1§m§&ré&

9’»’2«u_m:r- .w.us”‘w.« “on n«

Rs.}.~%~,Q§$;’- which is 3:: 2.233 mm: am. ‘am éegfig

sa@ariaa11_’,r éepmaafi the diaahiiiiy: _

R$.2Q,€”)f3Gf~ mwardfi §i3.ab§;1i’tgV .

awardaflR3.5§fi{1flf~« mwmfia

and Rafifififii =- iwéarda >

atterfifazit chargm he
submifis tim: it 51% 3. f;’1§’i:*:;.;:aa$i*:«§§;:f*’

Q £315 magma} far me
mfimfiaé yasaeci by

tha f$_’:§ V&2Eme§w::°§?.

1&5 an z’%rs§ almrfiy

fizgt ‘§§% t wag a Thzmimaagamm, Ha

–:;%a% am fix data af EEK am§Haa?ca.aar§’i§§’EIx°sx§: *?.he:__ u ” ~ 2

him

raw Kim,-wmm ma” wwmmgmmamvm Mmm &;’@§.;!i-fi*:1.I$: WE” mmmwmflmm &’°W;..W§ ¥w.;%;}w%M’ $3?” W%WfW3«2″;§»”é¢%’$l’§’2s= §*%i§;.;%:’»9E*v§ filfii”? %.m.%§%a”>E’E’;a’«%%:z% W§£E»%% ??é.&¥%Wfi%”E’fiKfil. Ewfifififi

:wm§5ifa:;:é::.$si:§%, anti» .g3€51:’§:+;’1fi1;-&;,:2f: izhagw, is aw: 323% Esrxwez’

‘ ‘Egg iflfiflfig – mfifir the affirmaié Etamég

m iim mature af

‘ ‘

Ema: fmzzf zmfizézs firififi :23 ymjszimé ta

wfirkg gm awmfi §a,,28§€£$f~
ixeatmfizzi mfieé.

1% fimugfi €315 fiaatnr Ema eiégmaafi ‘£333: £13

£3 i*’§% firs Eézé whfiia “:%,a:»ii§;’§ it ia 53:3 @715 higher

fiéfifi was mim $15 é5$fi§3i};ii§: a%, 13% :3 23% Whfifi %

smmmm nmxmwuz ‘H>>d*4’i?-‘~\”«’4..<k «WW .\ «LNU4 ..

mmmfi asf thug . at R$.'?,%§,f- and agpigizig _V

mltipléer Q? 16, £8: '§;§w£r3a'§mm is 33%

we smrd R:s.L34,+m;- mm: £l*1 ¢bA}13aadiz:g,;";$§i:';3Jé"&~:f%a;:s» { V '

sf firsacarmf §:fi&§fit§.

3.5. Ham mm
sustaimfi mid trmtmmlt
atauafl magi: after the
Ezlmnverxzianw .»::33F«'<'%?;_ amrci
Rsasmag –

15. 21%: the ‘
ms gm msadhrafi

mt gmfififi ém gwazfiig

fig: agiiimaia film illfififfi mfibai

L .V2%§;§g§;é:3;u, ‘§3.3;1$ gm gg azzfifflaé far

sf “”R§;3,§?fi~%§w $3 gkbai mmwmatififi with

$3 é% psa, fifim fifi fiam gf gefitiwfi éfi $33.2 date

% 545:5 figsizmatrzt, Hagsazg 2% gm fizk fa

M £@ZZ?'<i§m' €$§7 %»';»<52.R§'"&§?&T»%;%€ié% €£;"li%%A¥iEi'%E"é"Ik§E?;'* mmmmm WEWM mwwm wg" mwwwmremmm maeww mwwm wn m=<Ww.W.

ifififififi

12$ sggfii E a§1$§§?'€§ in 13 $1.:&§it';i¥§.m'1 Sf

fim awazfi fif fix "§'r§

3d/-

3 % ‘7″”19e4%
Sd./~

tum of Ra.3,37,4001~ with intacsrwt at 6% p.a.. es; the
enhanced oompenaatitzn finm the date 3%’
date fP*i?m1t. Parties to bear their own wffi : 7 ”
Lr

gag E63; figfigfixm. NWQ $m.M§_.w 1%: 3 EWEQM x§x §§§§§_ %A..V Efiau zafi .§<.E§_§ %u;.._m3$u EQWE §$;£Z¥.§ mE,..w Emmfi