Ex)
gearfijgz decmaizig the $1.11? fez” r::§s:=:¥:m:3n., and a::r’.r::2u’ss :3?
"mt: st Thig aargteai ssznmg fag' hziariég ~
wztcmrt aiaiiararazi; $13363 f:3i£e3sAri:1g :
3§n§&3%
Fe;:§1:3w:iz1g {ha suit 9:’ *’£h*;5*§iv-%»z,*:s1:«;ai:3Vi1:i;:ff’§s,< éé3;e:?§é:,%ii,.v:1€I1i:
baing tisereed by £116: :"'§;f_iai af:?;L£L:'£j_, appéiai beam
firfififiiltfid 133;' {ha dfifendfifiii "
22 The: §.’at.€:¢:..__ii£..3f:;r§a:fd_ i:-:3 g-;?’hi$:i1Vt;here are my €:1:iS§3!_l?.”f:’f
b€’§i’%?fi’éi’,}1 §’_.{z.23~;}:’*r {$62 gtatsfi; first and $115375?
22:. H. as §§<311Q*:?5 : ' "
The ‘:L’%::s2,:s:::3:::~’:;¥.s:%:t:3A.:,>€-:4′ :’::ér:5:.im f§3.6::ti aha: Suit :11: rgtzasiden
~ . A_ 3:@:f3}::E21g __%3:*%.u<:€:i:3:3;""t3f {E15 appeiiaxit ii} ragmct af {baa suit
beagéng Zkkzs) 11,! E and :3 sii;:.-.a.trr:{i in
{Em §':3:.;::é;{f'j§Ie:§:3r in Chiekagete flmgs Cfiflfiifitiflg sf twci
._$§:Q§3s..:15fi*::g;su:ing 3,335?' '.5: THE?' 352$ 312…?' 5:: ".?,*E?', toiaiigs'
" f:::,s3é:a%3:.1:'§:1g 'E111.-I?':1f sq; ft, {a;3pr<:xi::1a_t&§jgr '2Q 30, me':-:5:m}5
'§'§fi2:3 apgsafiant hemizz §?"§€J% 'L216 tenant irzitiailjy tgnéer the
fatheitr 3:" the resyondamtsmplainéififg and Eatsr Llflfifil'
Shivamma, gzémdmmgahar Qf $18 géaizziriifs, am'? fmilgmng
?~
/.1"
Lzzazifjr the Rant Act {sf 1’£.3!+.E:3 f-:€=9}<:i:1.gr, :;::=w;3;3_i:*s to 'm;=::
-..
u:1:;1€r L6 318:? £1531; Th.., f31’f3;«’31″‘ ,!:’éé3’e’.:i é_b_–§«’ ‘§I.lT1€3KV’i*:;?f}§§’§_VI’zi¥’H.€f7
sham 332$ fgIie*»;;?iz1.g Sflfliiilg 23132:; farce <3!" ¥:h€: .::<éé#;~'.f¥=%.c%:;i
the matter gs: shified £0 f;"i:.:%:2 f;'z327:9€:'§$§i:§f V' é
$53.3 s.3u&+3¥:£0:1t3r_§ bx.-grfore E2333 ;:{,:::r"E §"3}; '?§::e §31.9§.f:"t§§'f"–..
in 'iE!1*§.t Pefjtieiz N 4.}.8E?9;?'i2{"k§2 zzaégttégz' ':25,-22:5
:'e:::1iti:€:d is the Rémt €;*#3;3£rQ%ié:' '€_a:¥j§3§;¥;i;s: a gpzéii iizspsectian
cemducteri 9.21:3 thr3r<:'3fi:€3f-is §3'91;9s:s Fursuant 3:3
1*?'
ha? same, the €3€z:%tr:3i§;5+r,; :s:11e§:er29""i:§f::'a._;1:%:ix; Act, passad an
G_d€E§.' e.:x__ é_ij§::;é p1.8j.r:§ifi's to Effect
:1:5s:'es:;§é=$'g*T ;L€r,3§g:§_i§r3 isbfst «.$.§.:Q*,I3:3;,
4; Tiara ,_«:%Vs5§;:r;;$€%:a:ié::<f;i:%s«s%i§%ia#i:*:i::?E"s appreathaai $215 {fig}
a
c%r::22.:«'t§ b§r*'~fi1mg'§E1epre:sc:1: suit far the relief {sf gigctmemt
'Eh: &g3g::&E.1é;s3.:~é€fsndan§ $31,' cez1i:&3::::iL'2g in addiiicm ta:
ititefi. ':=x'¥;::_?£+ -f&¥%§féV€;_%1:aWé: €336: ag::§::t::-$3312: harem faiiad E0 vacgfs
Q 3.301 W62? '£?5,i.'.'8_§T".i§ mgsegsiem of €316 gait. ${I§I3.€€§,¥_3_§{ff
cisglgifsfi-. iéssuészg a iegai flO?Z:€3.€ as 1"'€?£g'E,."{§§'#3é. 's.111ér:.:'
' {E3 Tramafsar :31' Prepezfg Act and Straight fax' 313 gait
bsizzg z:i2:~:;*:'a3<:*.::i 33:3 ;"3;:*3__=g:€:¥_ £33".
)7
' I
is as {Q §z=-*b&thf:.r thf: finding cf E37163 trig} coma": :31': I§f3a§21=3–4
is tr,-2*a:r'rtr«::i the gméncigzilt-: ef rs;-2ss_j:1s.fiz:.a.t2. in V163?"
fiadifig I'€fJI.131'€§€'3f3; i:;:3: fhr: ijizjszztmiier in
ref-.e:::"tt'e€§ 1:9 earléar.
1:1 As far as the first Cézltantiifin ::::«’:{j’r;€s%3:1+1a<:;§§;,.3 ':3::;a3~. '
legxmad (.'{31}.E"1'3€i'l £21141' thtfif T_ 1318 tzarg
shaps are sepayatey 'ms tax is paid
s3e333ara§::1y in res§_rect:.ts§ fi%;=3 each «shag:
mggguygg CC.*1.1lC§ not
have but, an £216 ethsr
hafidi Ztiaarss apyroaehsd the frsrmn
unaziézc i:_§1=ri" Lrgcérgxi 1999 sand, as 32.1912, that civil
s.t3'=.,::«'1ij E§.=:~£cri BC? _§:3::~'é5s§¥.i£tt7;@r’£: C3′ the abmze $¥.3§3IB;iS$§{}I1, thg
j Ee2m§:?d .g:§:§flseE mfezwafl, E9 3313 picaadimgfi am: 1313
‘..]&é}*i£iC:§1ce on 1″€fCQI’d as wrsii as :9 1:133 é{}{31.3_fl1€I3f£S
‘ gsfizficed by the pariieg and cgniemdsd that the twezn
” shgsgg z3e_,1:’ze iraziggzenaiazzt, dififizzct, sagarats ztntjfiess hasgirsg
3-szpamie mtmicipal numbers ‘£323., 11]} and 13? and may
are s5g3arate1}; asgessed ta tax and gegaraie khatha
.9″./.
ntgmtwrs arts givan 311:1 Lmdgr the c§rct_m1sta21r:c3_§_ the
suit itsalf rsomlé net have b<=:.f:I2_ mai:r£ai11c:'.=z:'i' ':3§3 f,§§':2.e
gfiaintiffs. AS such, the fizzding rr3c0rded*'-4':§i_g*,:!%§é"'
cazzrt is errrjzzsozjs and thsz Suit r;if"t§::;a::*.p1§ain_§fi§'s'4<;§;gii$;
have been regected en ti}: g:'0£:1j:{i-_V_0f
itself;
11, As far as thz: sé;?é:’;:1 ‘i:a_'{:=.::s:1cc:’:1e=::1, the
learnt:-.431 rseunsei. refexfrtcfg. fig; V “I;$a,ssed by the
Cgnixniler a firxding has
E36611 r:§cgr =§£;<§_i" .§;fg:;}ee::§i:13q,rs that 1:315 ¥;wr_:
shops. Z4' 8' and, Lherefere, when
the fi:1di:ig4_ ii; the: ifontreifsr ma: {ha $119133
i:::dis'id:§s;i,§§;_as&€:9 he mgasrgzfizzaent, which is 1:333
§.+§;'«sq§A:VA"?;;*;u"s;, the said findimg cf tile £Li<m1a'Q21t*.:*
Qpér:=2i:e$'2i$—- iffsz-§«:~% _§L1di«r:.ata in tbs! sexism that thfii fmdiggg
g has xfmaf: ami; refarring is S-$C'¥.".i{?I1'S £51 1-'!;§'§d 53 0:"
..j"!:?:ie:TL£€:f§3::f£ Act. ecaf 1'§3'E?'E3 and €11} {Em arder passerfiz $33; this
' cé-gzri ix": Wfit Petiziien Np; 41899,i2£':i;'22, '£316 submiasséem
'4 madé is that me ma} £30115": escszzid 1191: have rzzance: again;
,q;._,r:sc:-2 L 3:0 the: aspect {sf the mr::8.$Lm::m§:nt, asgect $31" the
zz1ai;':€:r in 3f'!EfS'§3E{Z'fi: «sf tbs suiif 3:13:23 afidé as 33302:, tile
2'2
fizzaiéng I'f;'.iL'.O§"€Z§8C§. by this ma} Gear: an it-3su<:=.~4 is tetaliy
EFYQIZEQHS and ::=r3:13€:;:.@::t£3:, {ha 3:_3ii: ref tins: ;:=1aa;i:':¥jfl"s
aughi ta have been fiigmigsaé aven on this 380?:-:.[ L" "
19' in gagpgert cf the:-. ahoarzz *3Lzbm§,$si;ms,"'t.,,, s5f_§?r:Q:2.éé:iT _ "
eoazngei for the a§:s§3é:}1a.":'1t ' .::f-3-:1%__s=:–ui1;«::t";::_.V -sf'~,:::
d.aCi$é_0113 :'=:1:2{::z'%:e<i 3:: {.1990} 2 _sr:::f.;§:2§ AER',-'LE?
r,;;17
gm ME: 3989 SC 21631; 1'42%~;%';'»T..,' :*:+;*:1r\:,::.t.-:< és;2':zs"'flsa ',mar3e 1:43
Sacfigrz ;'*{f3}{g} -sf ~-.§;::t, iééééé? 33:3 refer
tax the as;3e_t:3: jojf riff and }3I'C'i'fl3i'.E3{3S¢
"§'§.'3,”E§i¢V§1*.;;?c:¥’..2=r;.r1§§.’~ thsisa 510611111-3:1i;s aiaéo gr) :0-
shgvai mg: L?1&’$as.itv___§$_§Qer333s are imdasggsndent Snaps hamhzg
héé-3.3} __?:;c:.s tax segaraiciy bf; that iigmemirizm azzd.
33 £33: 3.5; ?f:;»3 é:€:3:1/
,. J’
i3
5
scar 1% 53:12 is§_:ue3–3″I¢i:'{:ff:V_Tr3Z,V u
this rsub:r3.1i$sic::1 made is that, it
tfizrzant takes 1:315 rczéspegzgitziiitfi’ payirag ‘the’-.C£;f§:23i’éti@n ”
i:.a:><; ran his own and,— @1129 dugcaimémg w9f1i'~::Z1 new
i;e1_1g§1t to '13:: proc§u3jét§" ::'c«I;–§§€%_ " »{3bt':a_i:1::e;i i:.!::e
aijiflffflfllli s:«.:fi:.c:3:'§; 'I:lr3,:05g,gE__*¥:VA"é'a*;:.._a"S 'iias: Sicreizflen big
19. {E,<3I1<::::r::i:ig;V-_»'t:0:'1::'fi.3.:::I: sf fights: grgrties, E5
"3£_I'1t?..VVV'1§'."f;'£";3.;V,"i";'é'f.'¢§' »-.ffllllififil also refer; xi $5,- the
Qbgaigxfafions 15%? {he §I('§£'11j!.¥.€ig%'.i'. $33 szzbmit that the ieazmssd
»'i::§fi:,1i_;;zdg:c:*«§::1£.s__ aisso zzmzaci 33216. int:-.<m$ist€:11: stand i:3.E<:r::1
T:;jf«; €:11:: éf:*r;%fe:1:§;é;%:t, sarhich is clear {mm Eihhe discazsgian 22::
-V ‘:5sLié:$-‘i;51*. 5%, which aye: :9 bag feunai at pr:1g:s:- 15$} cf the
.,:,:%:2;§3v:r ifibekg The rssfarrszi to by tiye :;z3;3;3r3§}:«:m%:’:-1:
crgu.¥i$&£, it is argzaed, Ezava me appiicatian to 3316 éngtant
E3336 and :-;:<;: also {ha deczzmsnis ssught tat} Em praezimzad
as asiditignfi evigigmca Cazmazt adxrmtgce aha saga of the
4%
a I
,…
W’!
in f:hz:*. gchsdulrz to that Qiaint, it is alga; Stated the
EWQ rshatgps am _§0i;r,=:¥: ingida wif;.1*1 3. deer; The c},1gh ii:}1.(‘_:8;{‘L:1:;,’1;’zE.i:?3-:’?.’S.’
trzf the: parties 313d. the :§:§3%.1§3z1r€1i§er:3.?f_ S 1:113
gchsdtzira ta i:.?::.a.:% sx,3.i:I’;,-..é_ :0 the
:11eas131’eme:*:t Q!’ gash. aiso azésaas
in hgsiding 2′:-,a4:h shag falls
sham: 9f 145 »
‘§f§*:a:% fa: i’1_¢ amfififlant refzamici ta
ififl. .:a3’ ;ie3:;r:z:=. ‘:3’: Aifyécfifzi. arici 31$ dgcrgfizezzts 21116.2
‘§,*:aa.z*£:ig’:z_.:;”£a1’§jg}51:Q ti2:a *:3r%i§e:;4″‘bagged by th& Cmztxaller 3323:?
V. “p,..'<;;V'Z"3a:15»-."§z: "é::1«J_¥3:ni'¥:W£§*:'at ithr: flmiing gglmzn is that, Batch
-§:~:{h§.2″s 1:1§§~@:St;f:§:s .i§ess than 34 sq. mirési Tht: Saéé fmdéxzg
sf A 3125:. _.f3::§:{t3*::§§=&:r ammo? ‘gm fazunti 13:; he @3f’§’€13I’1€i333.1’3
“”–__ “3:}§=:r;3_1.1¥.éa:.. {he 9:313; admitted facts. as revsalad fmm ma
gflieadings and 11112:: $’%’:§.f§f.i1IE-f:€ «sf aha :;3ar’¥:i<:*<$; B1115, 'aha
2 ..q.-:::@$téc=:_: 1:3 §§:i:=,.e?:!::2:-::" the 'base shs:::*g:3:~:4 gm fizterfimked 35:: as
Bi) €::3n$%:imt.e a premises measurizag nmre than 14 sq.
Hltffi; or :10: T2243 apgeilant has Qfaced raiigmrzaat on g.
)7
35
m_1n3be:” -f éacuzxzezzts 1;::a1*t.§ct.:i§3.:*1′;, the khaahat
Cfiitificaie axtracis 33¢! 1:33: paid §::~2Ceip*§.s, to c033t_.e<1:ti«..?;§:.;sLt
Each -'S3£1€'}"§3 as gsrzst 3. sepagate mymicépai ~
1111 3111:} 13 rfirspscaiveiy, 3_::z:L f{}:1<%e:f€:fcar¢:%;
2"
ssuit is not maijmainabiez; z3;’§:A ‘sa1I§3é’
€’;ri-3335105 0:3 racers: alszgs :’e’:%::é;§$ i:hé§1: the: tém .2133″ ‘
inttzriinlied by a cemngon ‘,.f;;%_ 131% A’ :*a:,.1r3§: at’ the
::rQss~t:xan1i:1a§:ie:1, admiit J3. Lhat
these :3 3 cgxv-;§:.2:::Vf§V;’s:sn EWO snaps.
Exzen i:.E1.. placfid 9:: record
avg: is a comman dear
Cgflne{§§i§§«– 3:16, iiiis is flea?’ frem iitze
..r.~..
cantaiuts ” ‘i.”¥iS§3{i:f3i:i'{3éI3 rmmrt EX§P~–;3 at pagsgei-45:.» sf
3 V’ ….. .. V
‘V €h»;’:i ‘j:;er}* egidance of 31:: Qarticg <:»cs-,f=.;r213s aha
€xi3;§fic¢.Qifj'..-5:15 dist}? cargnficijng Eh: "saw §:h::3'ps¢ E:.E'E«i1
::::.*:::sIe.V__2§:1.:?:1€1*' than $15 appeiiazzt gné, in the caursa =33"
T."E:§$,_c§5:;:ss~@xa:§:i§:at*;9n§ he hag giamd thus:
"it is 311% that theft: 13 a deer §}6tV§?€E3€:€1 the
£ws3 Shzgzgsi {garheduie ;3r@'g3€:'ijg»-'}'''
%'
4
i
T%:g:::s.z:e:>3:ۤ it is clear from the: acimitteei facts itseif 1:113:
the t.:=s;e:> shaps 33$ Lflififiiflkéd and :::o:znec:e:ij”€:§j”-4.r§;*g§:
sgaotfizey ¥;x3z a commen dear,
124; The giainijifs gaak $;§€4;’.?;111e:1t~»ef 4i:§1:;i%’_’a¥,f:’:2:’é<;=:3gME;;j:t1 i:,,_§E?hi2 2
has baen firm tenant in 1'f:S§)€3C€'.OfA_ i§fi3 TTé:«sg:s –. sha';_§§s._.£::..
question. Iflerely §:,x<=3:e::z3"é~?.sar:V"i';§%35:é:"..iV:,1£-6:: ;§h<_;:1c;ag ':23-€;£éi*:é:3:';:3"rate "
mmzirsipai 112_:m';3{~.ré3, it. .3; 11:29:-":2';~–.;:2,rr_fi;;13c1( ta; ':a§:e.vv vista;
{hat the 'EEEJQ Sh-QJGS :a,§a:$:';– iézgeéisgr 59.13 3:33; s-.h,edt_l€
'QI"'f:'.1";{:i'§§E$ sQ, intr$; in fact, the
dgsczitgtign _ &.4§ié;ag.3 r3 g::e;;;V in 1:316 schxzduifz 3130
ragagjrfifi te'E;2:é "§:::§ré:<i:1 1:0 better appyeciatss gm
case :32? t.§1¥::_:;3* rfiég zigzd .:f_.'is ag zzaciczrz
fjyaxznci; Fi<::st;.=r$ facing West,
‘A ea§:h; £s%§?;i;§_2 maasuxing 13.9′ .2: 213-3′ zmzi 12$)’ :2:
‘ “;*’I<'?»}«?_ :és3,%sr,:s€::i::T'»;s:t1f«;}r_,si:";r:rc_*§ imside xasith 3 dag; in
" mgastmfilg :21§..?§'. zazfiz {about 2!} sq,
bsrsmzdsd as f@§£<::w:s :
E33? by : Bhamslari Maggie};
West by : (Z5h§ck”p::tCt:’0ss, §a$:3£’i:};§:se:
E*€<:::rfl1 by : Building eaxzngd E375: Sang
Shivgkumafi and Sri 'gfmezj Eéuzzzar.
$6
18
fiauth : Shep latagad ?.3js; the §§1:3i.=”1tifi’3 to _
I-£63191}: Stssref’
:25. Tmsefere, it can be said fmm thei _
evidence csf £115: partifis that 131:3,’ »twe .:S?fy:;z-;§}sv,, ‘t£”:§:sw;-g>,;:
individgafljgf meagums 14333 that; 3;._,’=”~§~ «3:;;’»._;:11;if2::, fé1ke.f:-4:;
toggiher as such; ‘(ha $11it.”é3C’3*1;’i:{§¥_116- {,1:*5:u’:i§5€:s,§._’1″:”;.€3£=::§L§1’r; r L
mare 1311331 14 sq; mas; AsV_g1:1:3.h,’ v:_?1e ié:-mzged iizgdgw. of
the izriai 0:31:11: 1>z.>’a$ _§£1’S.§tiiit:*?j&’V’v that {ha 311::
premigtzs masagfijyesklé-;_sq€;
AS far”a:f4″ c{;i1tz:=r,f:*:i<:::"; C€3£§£€:f:1'13iI3.g the plea -'sf r…':3
_§u:%ic3J:f.-3. £3 — fitsding cf the £3@nf;,t:::sl§z:r 3.53
:06}: the gz-':§__e.-i€:a.:*j.. :aa*1__i;I1; §s3 "jg.3:4@:i1:Lced at EIx.§)~ E, can in :33
Wa3a..%:afi£5-cf: t_§1£:" cf the ;;:-§a_§;:tifi's EVQI: if the said
:1i'§;1*::<:i3;:1;?;. i:t.3;;.a;:%3:: mtg cgnsigiemtiené All that is $?:a.%:&d in
'5:i1;.'r.3:'dé:; '.é::::?7 Cflfiirflfifif is that the we 3210135 taken
g é.:1c13Z.¥;'*§..r§:;§;V;ta;;§1%;'fizzawzasurrs: 1333 than 14 3% £12133; 131$ saié
.f::1éi:j.:g is in :10 way? inmasistsnt with i:h::: stag:-::£ Eakam
' big the glamfifis tkaamselvzys, But, it 13 '$1-sir Cass
" thai bath, am;-: Shays am igéfiréizxigéfi with a ccmman dear
mad, as such; taken tegethar, the 3:311: ";::«z*:5:mit~:~::€;3 Lhtaugh
t'3=3IE1%,'}Z'i'E§fiS sf *£3:E='£3 ghggssg in afifictg. mfiasmrag mere than
it».
c
:35
14 Si} mijrgg As -:~=ue:’Th, the qusifisiiezz :31? I83 j1_i{ii-:I.¢¥J§z’3; _L€:.:iMg
madziv apglicabié $33 {ha $3.36 an hand 2:130 tings :1-::;:!’:.:
113?, Agar: fmm this, the ieamed r:;’QI:H:=. ::’-;-.i:;=.1 *
1″€S§3{)Ildf:I1_’5:S is gist; right »~..:*-:.;?43:n2’i:2′:’.i’::’1:’:”,s:’é,”*T7(,i;hgi’;. V
pkaintiffs am entiiltszd to £3.15 011$-‘$%.::.§’§ ‘”131 Ti’*e’-:–$;;;*:a:%:<:t?i.
S&!}3'lf'.'. ($8.118? :3? action and. bx-'_ ?3:mT;2_1::-: é:,Sfi;3:*:iéz~~, E1"'.._1?ii3£«3'3 3 "
3 .; .. Z :5 .v 3
33-21301": k entitisd {:3 mar: ¥;Ir:21té"'{;:*§e3_:*€}§::=ff'i1*z rsésnact {sf
£1123 gamma cazase :.::»f actééjsif '31'i*;:};;*.:'i's%.,1::_ '%;iI'*»:3ii -er fl3"1_'§i of $3.013
rslisf and 33,3 §:ra$s::, Lhareafers,
haw: r:34::;_s,3._.g11'*i_ i%:::9:.;:,~§.=;§V€:<:fl¢:r.I";tsV$::t' apmiéant herein in
§*=5:s:_3€r:i:_ 9:7 ':;h.§:€ 'ii%;*«::'V"Es:3t am: :0 him. 'i'hc:;,’%M::v:1″1:’:Lé’ sagas 813d the @2530 Shaw: @3230
I:”:2=:&fi!:§:;§V man éiexantzsgztssd :9 sash ether with 22. commen
»:isf:t~;r_, it ‘«%2szas;’;”‘–.;3ot nezcssasaszxr far ‘Q16 plaimfjffg :9 gm:
ef firm; sjiazstzngnt. <3? £21453: apgiaeflazzi:
'V fr=:::::::' ajaéiig 93%' '£Z:"}€ avg ~':3h€3}3$ let: out to £313,133;
_ _.A~'§':3:" €336 farageing 3"€:aSG§3-'3,., E 331: of ma "Ji.f?E%=' that 3316
V..,;ii.é<:.i$io1":$ mfesrmd %:.r:.s by 'iihéff. Learned f§,'.G1lE1i'«€i'} far itfia
V' appeilant, §h13I'€f€!§'€3'., ammo: in szray E1519 the cags-3 of
ihe afipefiant and. $361: the decuments vsmtrtliz $316:
%
l*~.'}
(:3
agégseiiazxé: wagztg Etc: }:3§'€)€3;i1~!;'E€< E33' :3!' :3_<§::ii:.i:3n::§
evidence itamzazst 2.11:2? iactuai aitzgatian
taste} :;§£i;:2€::.':1 area cf :12.» twg Shays Egaiszg
gm:
3:}; mus’ The fzrxding rt.-:2:*.:*:s1».”::”§:iEs:§.,.§_3?_’,s«’ iiéié’ ” “§::4i;,:,a.l.
Ehfiffifeffi, cm isguez-4 alga d’i:>e$7._ Tlict ~:fée;;i::i;:€”
in uarfarencwz;
Fer the afQ:v:rsai:§._4_i*s3a3c.3::33; is; iialsle i.-:3 be
éiitsmisscd as iackéng thisv Ehfi learzzed
:::eL1ns§:£ fear ‘4fL.1’1(饒:;i:,v~’LL§.’*,’I3i’:,’::;3;}a£’!5:*}&T£’VV. 3é’1;gE:f”‘:3-5:6 3v*ear’3 time :9
va:.<:3.i:r: _'i:?32::_ 1*-:§1"§z;3._i:l.'2,::=_,_-V,~V:~f é:;:(1….§b§5*t gezgnd that ii: is a
c<3mmér::is.1 ;:.,=£g::é—- srach, the appaiianfi: I'ii'IZ§'L§i_–'-'.,'t3S
SQIHEE ?;i:n}%:':L.__4?_£: _fi_1V':é:1 a!i»:a;4_i1aA€$ §.3r€m§$t:-':; for ?::i:(:;; This
– -5;:,1§.§;;§:,is1::§i:3:1 is i:s–;:spr_}§_;§d by the leaynfid ::m_m.sa-3} -532″ the
‘_r§:s’;3a::s:*;:,i_V:3:i::;:Vé”E,27;; crjnteandigzg that Lhezggh thg trial ctésurt
%1’g.£s”2;:,j£2r&:: -3f§’:r%€:’e:. :;’:r;:::?.:.i1$ time :9 tiara aggygaaiianig new 139:3
than €:}:§’:*mV years hgva ;::a.3$$d Siflfifi that agpeai §2..am7:”:g
w~ ‘pr&f:.=:r§a:5’:d ‘me apggeéiazzt azzié mareeverfi the :€::¥;.i_r:=:
% buiidgng is a tiiiapiriateqi comditiesgaz am; 2: may fafi at
313;’ mczmaalf: amé, thsraforeg 31$ apgtzeimz/1?; is .1391: e:3.’E..§:§e{i
fat? 3.1:}; fL1§”£’_11€X’
k
39. ‘F;a}<:i:1g mete 9f the abmre szzbxmzlaiomaz :1:aa:i:*¥:€t
three menths time from “irfé: datré {if
and hand over vacarit. p<3:«":sessi<;:':__
aisa 1: ;T»:%,';' :13 the always fif 211:3'
abevtz mermened ;:«::::fii¢uffi._ 'A:2%4.I;,'«:,::e1§a1":1;
alga aha}: fiieit an r§:rit:h3Z:'; Ewe 2-zrecziqa from :'€;:=,L § ;'w;:c% 2 ar,;:pa.5'17£a_n: sshaié 33,30 depesited him bsforera the zalairzatiffs ta ebtairg the filsri fil'-E' additiomfi
svisienrsa, i;_¥’m€:*£I::s::r::, 21:3′: s’:t:.:<}ive for :.:r::xnsidr:ra!:im:4
Sd/,_-3
Itidcjé