1?»: THE .r~::{;-31 <:1m:*r a:>}r- .¥{ARNATAf{A
<::;2<:z;;*r E§E€.-NC}~i 23:? {EULBAREEA _ _ _
[3:'§'{"E§§'3 'I'H'§S mg: 11% my GP .:a,%3\~é:e:'2:;{§%;g._ ' L.
BE?ORE mM _' » .
"SHE: §A:m3:,:2 :~::;2..:'z,§s:';%'2A'm .".. " V'
M ;='..:=.. N£).93 2 /::':f::;}TVées% {xiv} .
%3£«;*r-w
%a_*;'c';_:'§2;'gA '
\e¥;ij'};P§~'&;'2§{?sE§§--i, _ _. ~ :
A(}E'~l3£f.>3i '§"E3Z£;RS;._ _ _ _ '
§%2;*;'{1'.Ii§E§§,I,fi'§'{3'§,E*«§A§{V§ '§'é'aE,{E£<f;', ._ "
~
gig}; -Sm?" E§AS*§gV;%§2AJ._F3 ém'i;';<:_;"";;i3v., )
4' V ' A v P}":."E'ITi{'.)NEEP%%
_ a;_:s:A5e';:S:%:i'LiJ":;§; NARASAPPA
" ._fig.:.r::« zit). '
{.3 .JA:§A,
;xG----Ei3.--._A£s-:_:iJ'I* 42:} Yi32AE3S,
V {3<:<;: C€3fN'F£%2AC'F()¥2,
' .. }%?[EX'E'[f~é'{j}. '.?}~f3'~--«:% 1. ; 25;,
A if _:'s.21E%;EZ3If)EE?'i€;T'£', ¥é?AE<"31~iEJ 3%.
F"? é 'A
' Si} §%EE§§*§H {E *1} U {EA
._ ~ ,3 {in $3. E3i';§3A?€;':{}{}U EBA,
it {E-ii:-E} Mgfiuf (3 R , {}{'3C'§.: A1} R I {I U 1fi'E,§ E3.' 1 ST,
R Z 33;?' BA §.»§g'E'1'{E-1 VI §.4L;A{§-E3,
Mfifiiii 'I'AE.UE<Z,
§éifiE{'f I**iE,§ $43 E}! SFEQECTI'-584 E 2.13
F»)
5%'-"~;i{.4";§'ii,§§~3 E}§f§'§'§€E{T7F~584¥ I23
3. mzs; ¥3§*€§£I'~£*C't£i ?v§}%.NAGf§R
§§AL§A£} m.,L;AN:z: <}E<::~2z2:£:2A1, Ii'»%Si;%'E4€:'%.§'~f{_iE}_4
MmzW L'1'i1},,NC:,}€)3~A, 3 <
mes? E~'E,C)()E2,(ifs:AE€S PLAZA, ._
{€fE:?2S~§1§}EEi,?\§{3Y §iZ£)Ai}, ¥3AN£§--£;L{).R}Z~_2E
"; _ §€'Ei€{4P{5'§iI3E3NT$
{£3}: Sri Pi%2ASHAN"F ;';a--m, Axyyg, m::>._;'P§;;a--:i ;«'§;:;}.«:;%;3 L: §_'}*3{;--}._Q§?' 'M19? ACT PE'AYH'é{E~
"EB s:;«-2*? A-S's1§)E§ ':5;-ax ;;2m:":3.t~,-*:*§«::> 2:?' mo?
ms m*<:: N<}=2:.:.«a;,s::71:a;:a.s,sE;:;;_.§3Y«Vi:w: *s+x{;-.<:;fr 85 m'<::-:;§, ;%2A1<: E-{UR
'1"E§%§-&§--v.f§§¥'§3;§iffi?£T)M'£1§It:§, '<:3§-.:' *-§PV1::*' AD{\:§§SE3§ON, TEES 1:523,
"§"HE*l vi§{T}§;7,_F§?'§°' E_3:¥_§}i}1{f§fE_J'§?§£*ZV1'i3 T4§~§§.~:"1 F"("3'£,i; {}WEN{'.§:
' H1'-~._g_";}i*VI4V'D_(_'?;'_1;§I£Err3'1'
jT'§1is z§§:y;éa}..V 3.5 "v.1"J}9" {he ctiaiuiaxzt <:ha'iiez1giJ:3g {ha
ax&'2ifi3""paSs€ci by the MACT, Raichur in MVC:
'$6 iimpisgmici j':1dg::3.e11t, the Trtibuzmi has
f€~§§;f?f:€§€.§_ flikt' p€:tiiim:1 flififi by {ha appéliani harem.
AA jL :2. " F'a<.*f$ in b;:'ie.f ::~;i;at'£:d £11. n't.1ts.h.t:l1 firs': ihai, the
é=;p'3::s:i11a:r;E' E:a:%:{'&i:': aiongf witih. E1521' h"us'm:s1:d Pmkaskz wart:
;j'§:i%§:":.1.i.:':.g {ram A11z::1:r:$§iw':%.2" to $1611" néitivtz place Bzzfiaigi
.~ Vv:%i'1:«1g:*. 03:1 51 ;{fi{}I{)F(_?'}'{.?.§,€i= E-£1133::2m{i (sf 213:: zappeilatzi was
{Ea} iné the ;;::2'(?*i«'<::1:: wE'3.F:I.tt Giriia was a '§}i§L§€)I1 rider wi'i.'h her
E
v-pu
-
ix ‘\
\..J
flxmss year Gici $01}. Vincsé. At about 11.30 a.m._u
m0t:)1*<:*§'<r1e C£~1Ii1'1fi'. near CZ'.hik.1<ahe$ar11i' OI3..V_'I Q§;QgEii§1Eig;I1i"–
'f~2a;i<:h':.1r mad, one J.Nara£=.imh3, ridiijug «;}1'r;tcit'C=j;_§:ie.VV<:;i"ni€
from thrzt cappasite iiimction. in _msh"an€}._ m:g1igc":ni"ma11=n€'£A
anti xjiasheeé against. the mot€;rc§t;1E.af in
f§'ac:t.ura} injtiries to Prfikaésh '.::if:ti'*. fie' effiauding
ni1<;s't;ors:%y=::1e b€i1OI1gf':€1 1:0 thaéJ Gouda.
Initiaiiy, the were taiezcn
to Liz1gas.uga:::;'”{§g”;vé}”3§1i33%1fi:§};§s’;§if’aig,_: same gay, mg},
was “‘:’13Q’i;hur for ueatxnent. In
{}P§€’.-C EvI :’:n_;;g$if§_.3E’,V ‘the complaint lodgtzci by the
a;:pe:’i}zaI:ii.. ‘2’z <_¥a5~:t*: "w :iSA.régif:}:'ier€d against the 13* I'€Sp€)I}d€E1'1't~
' 3:'§:it:3:'~i:;f 13:3 n1c;t.é3*:yc1e'.aI1<1 charge shed was fikzd. agairasf.
him. _V ¥.,I:.'€ha C':–:'i_m%E}e1} (33.36, he has pkadeti gtiiltgv and has;
'i)t?t':'Ii1-.31} 11::§.7:3';:;r:_<i',~ , ' ' J
" }'-'£pp€}}.a.r21: 311:3 hm" E1 uaband fflfid two separatt:
.<:1z»1.m:._p::'§_it§<)ns criaimirlg cc:mpe:1s:c3.tio.*{: againat £116 ridezr and
— {§§?fIi€”E” mi tin: m{:ah:)rCyc}e implézarséizzgg the Bragzch Managér of
Eiadéaj A}1iaI’:;§ {}<:r1.€1"a} E:':xsu§a;:1Ce {iizzzlxparzjg §..zt§1., as the 3"?
:*cEs§}<i).r:.é.}t311t
1%
=4. Beth ihfi claim petitions WETCB n.u1I1}:3::;:€(E a3VT§*»–§V*'C
§'%os;.2M~ €35 '23_5jQ'7. Efiztsfla thsse ('.E1S(f',S were
90111111011 ezvidrance, wa$ rficmrlet}. ()i1 }Z}€i1E}lf 'a;§"pcl}.g,:1''{_ '
Eleraixa, hm' hnsltzanii claimajrzi ifij'f'flVCz:'N'i?,211:;'fQ? "—§V£$?§,.'
cxa,1:1im:(i PW}. .:§xs.P1 £9714'-1___i§ wériw; t1'Z:€i;§}V':
2't":s;p0I1dt:m. N611 ::idt:r of the '}£§1a;«i'it(:i':Vf{3xpa11e,
:n?:spon(l€:r1t3~i.2 amd 8 tgxe cl.-aim.
R<:spc:s.::d<:n"{.s did gjmt chqgsfii' {Q Driving
3.iCCi}Cf: acataii of €316 €iI.i$:u?a;1¢{¥”§’:r1l§.é:§* ware Inarkitd as
Exs. R 1 511%} §i%27f-wit1{f1::ia.:1$$1ii.
:2», ” ‘Tif1e’«::.§ éi}:ifm. *’F”3t_§_5:i’:;uii2:} has rttcerdtid a. fmdiflg on
ths:-: i;;~3.s,3e 3x:§a?j11ig=.vi:) 3:316.’ 2::c:tio§::?fi::i€: mzgligsnce of thii 1.5′
.,;*::3§3:1:f1ci.{?i1″x.t in 1.11:3 V”‘:*iégativt:. It has also held that the
.__<:}z;;im7a¥:;f:.a: vc?€:37§2 . not éntiflcii far atompansation as the
CE:§.i_:z':a;1i.$. }.1'a_\:'£: seat up :9: ffalsa €3.86? though {ht-1 [I1()tE3I'Cj€C1€
r_"i';z:Im'1gi 11g. ti} iher 2*" r6S.p0mi€r1'£' was not irivalved. It
x}.§V§'2V}{§"~ fi'}éfi£'f. {anifg £0 fast.f:;u '?.h.{f §.i::1bi}i'{§; 0.1": the 3" re:=;'po3'1C1e:1f.»
hgxsuraniré {T§§.i<.%:t 2:. ::.?1n;a’}ia:’:t. is; icaciged impiictéztizig the 2″‘ r€s§)0nciex::’£~
a:3wn£:1* {sf the 1TfiOi€31″‘C”:»V{?i€.
ii. in suppori. of this finding, H16
mat. am I’€:f€Z”I’€?.(‘i ‘£0 by the ‘F’1:°ibu:;:181
appeliant and ism” husbami w£:n=:_ l1o:,?V4§Ji.’§2:ai:§;§rs..e£1
Gve:*r’1ms.I3t Hospiiai no COB1i§1$:§§1T. w?.;;1s’* sthe
(:0m}_;’31ai11t was kydgad c:;;iE;:-,3 t;§5%:r;§ Sfilfléd “Q OPEC
Hospital, Rajcixur. It ._f’i.1I”;t.j.V;.f.ln}|.’I:.%>I’i:V the cIa;ima11t
Czirija. who }1as._.vE.;3§*%i:Vg§:{i step into the
Wifnfififi ‘X;’a1i:’Ef>1:;«._13″a:%: _:Ie;§:§ €Vid€'{1C€ who was
E£I1C(}I}.S(?i{‘;’Li§§._’VAV;%Vé.%§:fi%g I; ‘§;1TI€””:’:p<Zv)v}'§i(.;€' '"'€.aI$e to the ilospital at
§§'.:»§3'.c%111"1§;:"-.'1t"£43' thfi fact that the name of the
ritiez" {sf the 13,f1{)?.€)i°CI:&"C1t':A.WaS'_."'I1{}t 1fl€t}T.lfi()I1€:{i in EZXPI §:mf: the
2*€g;§:s,€:'aii0ra 1:':11;9:%;s:::' 0'? flit? tI1€3'i1iT}I"C§-"€.Z1€: was 'i'.fi€.'iHi€}I1€d. T'.'t.vx:
'!':"i§<3:1'1'z;1}_Ap:a;<3{:%:;§§as itstzlf to heid on the basis of 'aha abeve
i§;:gt:":{i<:»11%f¢i2.*§:g:C:»:§:°£é that t;':3.£: a9pcHza§1t'$. int.&11ti0n is {:3 get.
CO§'§1_§,1'€i}.'i§é?§§i';i(;:'E'T:.':.fi"{3EI: {ha §m;ura1}<:m the mat.e1f:':aIs an mean} that
_ tf§;_:* z§(f£:i<i{:2:2t o<*<:m'r(:::} an 3«6.2(}{)(:%. It is ffifif in tiisptfie than
" "{';<;tt§,;: €}i1*§_§2:: tbs": 3}')pe1}a;xT1$ _§iEEf':l"t?iI1 2-md her E.zusbz:2I:~::i Przilszagh
héfii SI_':fi:E?I'é."'E{i fr:az:#:.m"2=;§ i:'3juI"%c::-:§. T§1£}iigh {firm}-* W€"3}."€ initiafljy'
mks-:.2': '£13 i,i.r;.g¢:::%:«;u§:1,;:{' ('30v:::r1*:a1ua4»acs¢z«.+.;u%
::§’\
{$.15}: v:m”€ Shifi.é’:(i £0 €}F’E’:”;C1 Hosspitai at Raichiiifi’ A4
{reat_me::1’i,w21s giazt::1 10 than. 13: is {.90 1:1:111c1?1.4t:”v:V_§=i{i that ”
mt: appcliam. and her h:1s7£>a11.d whc;:;3&rerb:% i:;jV 9z1st’:::_t’:::–_.:’i”-
and ssufferirig Shcmld. haw: : i,3″1€t
Lingasilgur fistzlf when (1€3(?”£'{5iT:V$:,;e-V’E3éV}:S€§~ i.Hf;£fi ii) a
éiifiérarat ho:=;1;3£tza§ where fi§afi.%1b}e. if
they havti giv:’:11 prioyity anti than ta
k:«:i.g:’: tht: {?Bi31f?}éi§;t?i:£L_’§I}£:1’é; ‘i{)§§’ no exception
couici be takéié V
_ §$ ms xytxaterial to Shaw that {ham
was. 211$-” .£_?£’:r’§li}S!iGI1 the apptzllani. and the ‘L2?-1°’
ress_p0fi{?;r:1′;t.. ‘V in ‘.f2:iCt, tfis: QM részponderat vvim had fl:-rd
‘~<_:{atié–rii<e1:;'t. m1" o't)j<:’;’1S ts) the Claim pefitiaxz has remained
i’:iZ»:{):§’3_1″”fE_f. ._ ‘f”*I£fi§”‘Z»1A:t§Li3_}L{1f}§:i is mattie by thfi IfiS11I'{iIlC€ Ccmpany ‘£0
iéaii “:–1:}.}»’ ‘t:£%i{:ie{n<:€ to shaxv that thfiffi is such 3 coliusiotl
'V 3.")€:tE'fi'.'{";,t":Zf3 4011=.;;(> ifiasis {(3}: {ha findizag rfictorcicztd by thfi Tribu.z1a_l that
‘ fit?”<1-(,§1ng)1ai§a.'f: 'W83 ioiigtéd as 3 H3311}? of collusion b€i'Wf':€'.I1
= ..§%.';Ei i”:{if%:’1t i”i{}t'”.’:£’ of iht’-3 0ffend?n’1fi v€:’h.i<:i6 has;
Km
E1213 ;m'£ é§{§€§fi:{',€fi{§ 91:23' éiviiifizxéiii, in *f;}..:.€ a%:aS£a:":<:tf; §'}f}i' ' cgf
em}; <§:s33;;'?:§§"'{3; GI" any <:«i}:.1e'r §Gs$ ifl{.""E3§'."{'€(;1i$ fag'
§3r<:w:.:s§:€% <32: fizzé kzsasig sf €136 ava:i}a.1':«1é,maf£$::%§;;§é-_0£2,':%:::~t;r«i§.._
E}: "§'1:':§: Tribainai .h§2'<;§ "~1§:§€fifI£.£~i§i:*;?1?3§f fig ihvé
<.t{3m':§i;§$;i{::.1 fix:-3%' {hast é1§')}i3€t§§£:i°é".,i%:'L€'§-.,v §i},!:S§}%1fi{§;:: T_ eq'11.::&.fi§*
<.:~{}:;E:',%E'312'{£:{§ 'ii: 'i.he':- £5iC{Tf§,*.;.?.i'f:':.;f.i.::j? §i$}:{:}'~;§T§b"'é}i<}I1 §"i{§t3§'S ami
E335 :'°€a:%1i3:;g Ehfri ::3.0¥,:g::é}?<::§€ manzzér Eifiii
hsizitéi ptémzzafiifci 'i<,'-§$£3:£.:§3;13_w;;2"§ '£5;-'E:S ézriiifieé
flag" i*3€}'?x6 cf :%,§<;,,!~.
‘§’§::i$ ;>”:§:j;_§:”(:«:§<?h':'}e%i':'V €.;E_1i–':«.?:*iE}i:.::_aE. £5; éaiaiifg %":m"m'3€::;113. Them 323
mg imafiéfin maciét' V::éazii"._ :*i=.–%gé3,:«'§§;£::g {?G§}§1"§§;}11{{§1"§' :1<::g§§gi:33C€:¥
%;%'%:§,%€":'-:%'€:* is"s'::2g§;£is'£fi:§'–._%;fi"EEK: :1. E’€1E1’i€§’:i in
. _ EEK: .»:;2£§;:”:»«i1:;vaEvm::%;:3:1V§:_ 1:}? . $33165 §t?::.mfZi1′:g V€i}1:§<:r§»:? arm}. :10? a=27§'£§:
:;:'ég;€g.§"<'§ fie, ihé'~.c::mi::'é';3u'£.m"y ixatgiigfi-:%:..1C€: on $315 }{}a:"~E Q? flag:
;'§.%.?;§.;~:;_1i:<airj;:.a:;1% i:::fEf 'fE§}£%-;:a§§p{:iE::zz}i., '§;'§.";.e.i*::f2:k:'§:, "sA2'}":5Z}c:: Eiaiéizgg E23221.
»..§:<}m};:s;:§:§§§:;:i9i:'3::}. .2zr§1m1§1§'; €§§:'£.§::;'"fiaim':t:} 'E;j; EEK: 'E':"i':'}§.1:§aE :22:
®_E42$.38,%:?-i§};' ~, E32 §,§':.t: :¢§'.:i§§mi£:, 7:’: £3 £0 33:: Efatéifi. tizai {E36 fimiigigf ;’€<::{;:'{§<=,{%.
— , 3%:-555:3? mg (3053 Egééé £§’E.{}1″§£ 3’E€g§gé3}fE{i’€3i is iIE§3g£»§,E asxf
* -»z::g§*:1:i§s’§::s.§::3a’%’3§::. ‘E’%:::§’€:§é’3:”s5%, 53:’ fl’§.f;?: :’:::,»3s;<:s§'§.s :<«sé*2izi£:af§ ::3.%}<}i::§:;3é:?a’:$sé§i;%a:;:”: :§}2i}=*§”:i§’§ié’f if} fézfi §}§:’§§§§€}T£’EfiI’ is s:§.z3?;st:a;*:§”:m€::’§ éfiléfi
E’? 4.
:21″.
‘J
‘_ thi$_~’fi’;{1g§ne;1t. H’ ”
fixed at R3..38,6:3{)f~« pajgabie with int:3}:::St at 6?/2:.
the data of acrrridezit fill the data of }::>ayI11e§:’i.
a<':<?0rdi:1g1y aklewefi in part.
12. Rsspoadsnt Ne:;.3-Insxirarécrz ‘*{_)<.3mpsi.i::.j; 'is
anii Sfiveraii}? heid iéabie to a:£1.brgI;t
invobeé; in the accid£2ntv3::r:}0;1giAzV1g' *..h%:-.fL_»?F1& féSp:;r1d%31t.u7zas
iI1S1"11'"f:d 3:. the time 0% ' ~ ridsr of {ha
fl1{3to1'Cy:t1€: }'€S};}Q}.):,%:1i?Z:ii ':';Irivi3;1g Iicenzté:
at the. ':i3:::1€ " V
13*, ' i_:1:'§:\s_3:.:#:::éV'::::=; <;:.1iz° vweéké ;*fr{3::._:1’.7t1″1e date of recezipt of the crcpy of
Sd/-‘
JUDGE
T1,
if//III’ A»»:>m4»w