: 3. :
IN TIE? RISE 66:53? 65' ,K'..<§fi}'s!A1"% A?' BANGAEQFEE?
QATEE $5323 rm' W may as zazgvgwgg 2§.m___
BEFQEE
'2*2=£ ff€.'Z1fJ*'Bi}.E 1%, wsrrcg gm zemzaa: '-
at. 2:. am. 54 46;';mr;% ....g35s.a;_-' " " " 5. '
EE'E"'%E_'?°°%'
auwtancmnunuunwn
H 3 mgzqmtsxz
ms :5 azmyam 5}:
AGES EBQUT 39
L-125, Rs: m:;:32~§'£
5"' MEIR', szmxwmx _ .
BANGALQR.E*56i}_"{§21 I PETETZQEFER
1 ;H~:fs;%; BA:&§'£.'~:?%»;§:3RE DE'~§EI.$§EfiE~¥'3{' ,%J€."§"§.7HQRITY
,3 E»..a:-:s:,..__;:a:s':*§;s'§:
_ ag.am':;:m*5ee 92:3
--. ma. fC'l'?2'*fl*IIS§IG1*€EP.
"2. --§*:%ji;?§f€ié:Y gzcxmaky-2
BE';:~3QE%.3:--.;QR.E agvgmmmm AE3"E'I~IfiRE"33Y
zzmma max @351'
AA Bfi;3v¥§.%§.I.{}RE-*5$£% 92$ RESEGEDENTS
{By 3:31 E B 'i.?'§:}'§;Y?-L; §§§'s§'._;§
THEE '$3.? EELEB E33'-mi-ER: §.?;'.'{"I;C,?.;E§ 22$ 5: 32'?
$3' '.333 §ZZ€3}*Z$'.{'E'3;.'LTTIQ!€ GE' Efifiifi PRE3;¥E2€K§ 'IS Qéffisfifi
TE-E SREER §'I'..§3.G§.2Q§? 33135 2%§'¥§£§°*E"§ Ififiififlfi BY
TE-3 §;E§§Q§~fER*~?'I'$ E'E'C., _
: 2 :
THIS PETITIGN (SEEKING :3}: F33. ?E.ELEMENAR§.'
HEARI§G~B GRQ§§ THEE EAY; ?HE CQUEE EEEE THE
Ffi§LG%I¥G:
Qfifififi
Fetitignax alaimim t$ bei§mg " €b*A
fiahaduled Caste, xeagandwfiwtfi-the ififiitéaiefi.
fax ailetment cf 3its3;\V7$y( Zffiiing }afi .
appiicatian dateé 12.li.3§GQ [Emnex§:g"ffi*3 in »
the fcrmat prescribed tar:thég2"'are$p$%dant-
Eangalcxe Beve1apm%fi§' E$tbafii:y ,{'BDA' fwz
ahgrti far _ VEc¢$$§i§§1@§§ §ea§ér Sactian'
{'E§S9; fifi$" 5h§rt§ @;reg¢ry; imdiaating her
mtal arm: ¥:.2,§se;~ and that ca
hez_h§aban§'hQ"fiafie fi.Venkate5h as fl1;G$§f~.
;¥_VRa3§¢m§§nfi#$§A hfiying cansidared tbs
's;n§ia1::.Tl¢,a;%;%;§zg;~*a3_.m;m:z Site §$«»:°:».i'??£C§,- aw" =3'
Blaék, in furflhaz Extenaian afi EEK Vt Staga,
'"¢;&gggu:i§g 5 x 9 meters ggwg} vazuaa at
?$€;?$Q!w and fiizacted the agyiicaat :5
"&é§asit ?5é,13§f" wfiile a§cw§nting fa:
'%2,§$$£-~ being the initiai slegseit, by
allatment lattar datsé §.2¢2Q$4 gfimnexure
53%?
\
: 3 :
'B'§. The petitioner an E§$Qi§t Qf thg
aliatment latter, depaaitad. ¥34,18§f- mafia:
twc= chailans .hnnexu:es E'C' & 'E'} sf *#%§fiu
data 28.4.2353. The QBA by endarsem§fit-fi&fe§"%
25.$.2$Q6 {Enaexure 'E'}vWCali§fi _fi§@$ '%h§ V
petitioner to dapaait afi$iéi5n§£_ $mm"TQf
£55;w:;z- towards bfl.l;&1L'.v%§%. sf" V::a}..;§aia_: Ehe
site, in r$3§ec:r_Qf ,wh§¢h Vthafi«peti§i0ne:
sutsznittad rm aismazfi §fiI%.V";%é".112.2ee5. It
appears; th§»§§& fi£§ §fit_fi$e§éfi{:f$r payment
tha dgfifififiafizaffié §Q§'?5§}?§Q!*¢ hat by nstice
datgd é,3.2U@? §§fifi%xfira 'E'; paintéfi ant ta
the fact"~$ha§:Ath$ annual insame efi the
a§$t£éi§fi5¥zf§miE¥ bfiiHg meta than ?iE;%$$f";
"§h§ "a§af§&ifi§ar was di5entitie§4 to tha
all§%mgnfi{ §hi5 was feiiswéé by an exylaaatimn
_{}$.g'~ fin thfi application at
§fifiEXfif§@ 3§¥ V§%&§§fi£EQd for EWS: aasking
gllgyxfint éf.§"$i§fi unfie: 2&3 categcxy,
'v '§§. .?E¢Qn0micaily weaksr Secticnfl $3
L&sfi§é&7}#n§a% Rule Eid} af tha Eafigalazg
fie?éi$§$ém% Authsrity ialimtmgnt sf Sites}
.u' £uE§3, "§§8%, aa a per3¢n canaidexaé ta be
b$i$figing t0 the eamaamicalry weakar fififitififi
"~a$ natifiisd. by" the Gavexnmani fram tima to
time; the tarm "Family" is éefined, ifli Ruée
2:9} a3 auch parsan, tha wifa at hnabamd, $5
M
: 5 :
the aase may fie af saah paxscn, ad the
chiidren, garants, sisfiers and, hzathars sfi
suah peraan, ané whoily daganéent an him.
4* The xatificatian. datad e.2.:9a§w ¢:
the fitate Gavarnmant prescribea fii;§§§f{¥@%]~
the annuai inflame fa: .&m_per$§§>fté@ b&_V
aansidared as halanging to E§S§"VRuia"§n§ff:fié
Ruiaa prmridea far aet7£.:_v:§;:.11g a1s«a;:%:._fi»!£}§s"«:._:'<:-*5... -'tha = L'
tatai numbgz af_ $itQ5 ing any" grgé far
aiiatment to a §er$&$ bé;¢ngifi§n%Q_E%S; at §§%
at th& v5§£éW9fi tag éitfi; Thus, the §3titi$fiQ£
having inéi¢a%éd t§a§"§he twtal in¢¢me sf her
famifly was mQ¢é tfian.?1l;fiG$f~ and haviag made
an "a§§l§%a:i$n fa: allatmant mf a site
A:$%§:?m§¢if§:" Efifi, in the light of tha
fietififiaifiéfi wa3 fiiaantitlgi ta aiistmant af
u "» $its §a:1??§ raservad far 3&3.
:5. Strange are tha waya fif the 53%, in
=_ méttaxs af canaifiaratian af an application fag
'alietment Qf aita kaaed an the material
fuxniafiafi thaxain, iaslading the aantenta af
Wk
: 5 :
the appiicatian. fha few mimutas af
a§p1icatien cf mind G?5E the cantenta fif the
appliaatian Annexure 'A' waalfi easily ézéaiaéa
that the petitiener was §i$entiéle§" "t§F"
aliatment :35 a site :9aerw&i_§9§W§fi§g. Thé,
ccnsidaration daes nefi réqfifiré :afiy,.ax£rfi#
fizdinary exersiae 3incé,§;perSan'withK@inimum"
3.it:§m::g,r mum have p«e:1:9§;{i°%:5é{i_ thé'--::ia;;:é: that
the petitianer %&$-'n§§}flé$z§tled ta an
allatment unfiéx E§§Wfia§a§§fiy.7;fié that as it
may, the~3§% Hfiying a hisraéhy sf afficial; it
ix 3fixpriSi$§fiflfiifi H§@fi hnatice the mafiarial
difiantikiifigv:§§A§ét§ti9ner ts an ailetment ef
~.attm§55iis.V 'fgaxaiazgg the asntantian= ef thg
L lé§;n&@f<$w§n5ei f$: EDA. that theta wag an
iaafifisxténaé ia the aiiatmest at aite ifi
j unaéagfitakia. fhis am y shawcaaaa the kind af
:f%fi$i3a$$ transacted. in. the BfiA.;§axti£ularly
'Trtha '§@rfi¢fi&l manning the aliatmefit gectian
",V¢aliimg for imediata zamsdiai ateya :9 revamy
tha aaid aactiem.
2
2;./'
: '1? :
6.. fidmittadiy, aliatmané: wag mafia on
5.2.2
$€}4, which was feilawed by dzsep05:;t3.~-.__az1<'i
thaazraafter by yet anrzxtzhar erzdzaraament
year 2836 éamaading gaymezzt sf ?5§,.'?L'§§;"
actiazz GE Ems camwt §T¥';};'§:"'”.T_”:;>£:–.w’§;a§2:fé~z:.j:.v”‘eff 2′..56,’?OQf~’-
in additi 02! aéfi ‘ « fyéa $2 I 2 $ 6 6 t c>w&.3:ds
f112.3. *z:’af;Tus ‘j;;:ufA ::*E;h锑:3i-ts§””‘}.”f:3;%= BEE; waka 1213 frat:
its ‘T’:1§:5é–.,:’:7ge.ar 236% when natice
{:’%..r%.r1$xu,t e: ‘*«. ‘E’ zs:z’»=c:%$”~.–:?i.aa1.zeé¢, ffillawad by the
“‘~..v_s,.*:a¢*:i§aL§$.t.:.<::sz: Q.\'f ———- agite 93:14:31 the xatmsn ef the
aiated 22..l2¢2§§§ by amisgr fiatefi
ifirmaxara 'H' E .
VTM pat§.tia2°:,er’s Czzsaznsal auismits
A XL_”‘i=A}t;1fi%*;-..&a§:=_=: ::a:i.ae§; a Eaazz aigme bfilmzging ta E?§5,
‘ nmt yaasasa aim réqzzixed. f’ar;§3 ta make the
payment an demand an paymeam: {:25 intexeat an
tlw aaid law at €213 Iifitfi .a.
8. Having canaludad that the petifiianex
wag act fintitlmi ta a aite xeaerved §§r EfiS
aatagary and the a§pli¢ati¢n itself 3§§ i§é§$§f*
t; be zejecteé, the queafiiéfi «is; _w§§fl’¥s.}t%g
%3az tha lags caused to t&ei§éti§i§nax.m§fi§q
petitianar is mat a fi§ry* §ffi§ug#§V7§ér$§n;
gming by her Qc¢u§a§ion,a¥ a’§a§iié}”It}9ccu:5
ta my mind that tfi§ 33§p$fifl§§§f§$a.woulfi have
ta be aaéd;e§;fiit§ §§%bi;£§ylt§ bay intezsat
an ?5é;iG3?%fi§%§@$ifi§§Vq§;é$.fi.23Gd iannexuzea
‘C’ 5: “i;nds3x damanfi graft
dataq:,3E+12%$§§$ g%r%$J.tha said dates upta
tafiay, a£”–4..§1-mV%:at~§=5: 13% p.a., and the said
*= sum i§¢5ir9e§éd~t¢ ha ratainad by tfie Efifi ta
h$ a§C@§n£e§*£@x against any ailstment sf aitfi
fiafié ta {fig yesitianar in any af tha layant ta
_be ffixmgfi in futuza.
x’ .§, Sri Rfidxagaufiag le&rmed Saunaei fer
‘?=£ha’§etitianer gaints cut ta finnexura ‘A’, ta
a §§nten§ that tha petitianar hafi mafia 5
xfifiuceaaaful atfiampts in tfis past, anfl that
M
: 9 :
thare are inatancas wheze ailatmént at site is
mafia in tha 3″ attamgt. if that is 36; there
shmalé be no diffiicuity far tha §$§ifiiQfi§K ta
rfispsnfi ta any invitatian. fez al1Qtm$n%f.éf fl
sitafi in fiutuxa and if Saab an apgiisfitian ix ”
mafia, tha BB& is dir§atad ta c$flSifi3rafihé’§ama
and aliat a site msasuzing é x,§ meté£3;;§_th$ ,
petitienaz’
18. In the reafiitg :h5Vfirit_pstitisn :3
ardaréd a¢card1ngly; It=;3’fiééfiiééa ta ataté
if the arm: a3,:¢¥::s:1,.a_$:t.~;g~~«.}§;_:«;,g_~p.m::;z::me: wsazzici
be liafiie 36 gay th$C§$l§fiéé ammnnt, if any,
towars the $a§fie ¢f5tfi@ éite.