High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri A M Hiremath vs The Executive Engineer Karnataka … on 7 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri A M Hiremath vs The Executive Engineer Karnataka … on 7 January, 2009
Author: N.Kumar
mm wuss or-' KARNAIAKA HIGH gaunt or mmnmm HSGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURY or KARNMAKA may COURT OFKARNATAKA HIGH c

3% fifi mag fiifim £3? §§aEfsT;%,'§'§s.§::.é, A'? B§sE€f§fi§.LGRE
mmm mg  W3 am my Jawamr  .4

§E§'éZI}EE--«

 

THE :~:aI€=3:,E; §s.m$Ja;3*fii':E€"' :4? A h 
WRIT :D§:*§:*z'~:£sr: §;:§g;_;3g:§:a§;2§:§%:2§;:k:;:g.gfv;22? 53?? ' %   

gazammgmm   «  
cmsszfifigmawg   & A  

axsma fiimm *   ; 
saxsarmsnwgagggaagg     -; _ 

saaxmm    -

waawgg     ,. pafiflafiag

{av SHEA'? I3  $:é§a5:fixm5m%
Mfaffifléfifi %  

REE}: L V
1.

£2m;:: :2’*:*z&¢§§ ggiémmz

% ‘rs:;aRr3;:;Tg;§a.%:§E£§aa£aMt2z Exam =D
‘VnV ‘I¥i}”fIf¥5,}§:…_F,R&I£a*’:~’§’ gmszeug
:Hm§2i2xTLgs: * 4% 1 %

szmegm .:§§s’:%1g:?a*r.

2. ammé Erm+§.§E.EE

— –. i .. 4.. _ E§EiR.§fv’.aR§ Hifififi
, §’.?E”E§ THUWA. ?F:Q.$:f:’§’ E333
‘ szmsrga

% §4ié.I’I$.§E§{‘§§ fififififimfi
A “~E€§AREIAT2%.KfiL gzgggavggz §¥§{%fi.Eé L
~ ~~;;T.’1Qi§’E’E=E} mgga; Ezzzamgs

3

§R..§.?t:§8El£¥KA§ K3333}-§

§.M’§€}f%.LC%EE« w 5% Gifiéé, 3.3 ESPFSHEEEWS

£3? SE1 33% R $ § fi§E3″%f€.”L$fif?E« FQR §ig§=~3} 1 _

BIGH COURT OF !(A&NA”Em(A HiGH §fi§§ET OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR? OF KARNATAKA I-HGH COURT OF KMNATAKA HIGH COURT OF’ KARNATAKA HIGH C

TEES WEI? §E’§TIGf§’ ES ?E.¢EB U333? flR’F§iCLES
2% AEE :32? Q? TE-E Cfi§§$’£E’I§TI$§% SF’, @312′:
FRAYHVEG EB Qflfififl ‘E GREEK BAKE-S
ET fi L Efifififi B? ififi RE?

mrzmam’ mTE;&;;?.;:.§:a34 C3?’ Tm .,¢”§°E’%’I’f’;GE§£R’*v.
mm mww -am mrgmarsm ‘PG m:s§1:>;§:»:%;;éa:%

fi % A % % % A
ma Wm %*1′:2{m§ . — ?:3§

?Ii’EL11fl¥AW §*EfiR§’¥€3’r _*>”v.Z’;’*:§’,A’V,Vi£3;’:R’E’ = *’

‘mm F’8LL$WmG:

V

?e§'{‘:i.a”zm has 3? § L
m km the mntract
awardfi xi: asf ST? Main
92? £3 mmnaa and far:

a w?if’A§§m3*i?3a13a:..it”i.§§z5.x§;:§$;:hi@ 9? fiznmw hi.

iaauad 3. awtzigm’ W flan dated

fa? i§:n::§.&:* frisr <:i*i.:*fl Wflfk af mfih wnrk

. af am ent; igmiufiing

k af £3 'iamrim in mxw gm ?5 af 2.??? yam
mxdar gackagea 22 mi' Shimaga mmicz. The

' 'gaefitisatmr was figs su$m$$fL1% fiidéar anfi firm mamas:

wag awardfi in him' an %.I§t§$fi3g The arfimv was

fiaaaé an 1?Z§.:72®®€z $2'; 253 E: 'I , 3% rmwfifiant –

flhimf E zlrzapamaé the aim mzfi aakfi fax' mafia?

mafijficatiam $3151 afifiiiflianaé fismrkza, '?%§e- §:zvc§:;iti:.:aa::f gave.
a. raprrmerxtafimi sigma. 24.$,2%5

exterrmien ef iimsa iiilé ms aha mhmzgas

in the main' texfiseru E5 aka: z

asi:1ma' 12$. 3% rcm;mz'3.:ia§§

mum" ta. Rfiwnémm 5:';

mzara west. as :12: ;1%;é;¢::2~.~:.m»:s=$v.%%_;;a:. amt the
warhg YE}? were fiszmmziirev L
Emcgwg {%;1€ra¥§%?; far fmséx tcrxdws
as par kg’ $15 mm? pafitinnm

ia Cféigitg

3. fkci {Ear}: aéatswz cf

the a§%’£:*z7.:::z”3.3 $.21 flm petifinn

:hg%¢:;m af gm gkiaimtfii ‘§’h%% ggmfically

figwnmrzm anmfi irztca

is a gist and §ar@5i mi tha stigma}

mfi zk gatifinnfl wa$ humid; in mmmyletae {he

. wax-E: az Eh: 232$ aswgfi’ 36; in the: 53%;’ “ml

fiaémifgtafilyfig iim fifi mi aziszimplete

fig: wagfi wifizin tim s€;i;2§;:§a:&§ téma, ‘$1815 rmwrzfimts

Mm mum as m.mAmm mum c_<mR1' or KARMATAKA HIGH count or mmamm men com' or KARNATAKA man mam" op KARNATAKA mm: c

far axtva £a§ impiifiafiaigm

YAKA HIGH £

Wm agramfia is my Ehfi £21 tEmV–f£»:3;st sf

rs!'

E mwé Kiwi Ea ths wrtifim fif ma
42:»-s:~a

erwml tmxder

_

vsifiaéx way iii ' V' ~..

yefifisxwr, fiawfiwr, fiw the i

war}; ‘§’mr:§’@r¢, €335 §$$§£::3§gat.::;sQ’=%?”§:*e ‘e.é::x”§$”t§’aai::a&§é1% %?

rm»cir1& the user}: wifimut
aarld callad far mntand
that fix actign 5%’ the
mntmct argfi :’::;:j axafi miid and

$2 $3 clam: that the fiispum

is zmiy fifii ‘regaré~.V_%9é’ aaiifiritiexml war}: ¢r1t:”u$ts=& is

aim §fifi’§:fiZf?;AE’;§’

‘éwvfmrirs, 21¢ “waniaé faasiazicszrz sf farm.

1

‘£mafar”aaA13%tmi ancsi msmant is mnwmad, fifm were: mt

far reméémg mi’ raézm in sther gamma” ‘E”hae

V. was aim paaiéfzémafiar éié met mks 32;: th& war}: at

fiwmgh thg su§§§5:m:1%afi*

manure Lutmi 0!’-‘ K&@NATfiaKA H3634 ‘f€_.Z$’E:.:._iRT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H16!-i COURT OF KARNA

gs im 3 gm: and

parwi fif thaa miginaé agfiamsm whfih gmviisrlem far

ef the mflfififiz whsezz fix agnfiaamr §a& tn

NATAKA H16}? 1

Q?»

-:- sum; if; aacmréirg in him tmtc tmr: 7§§’§f}&t ha
anugizt ia. mw ggema m aha

Zmyaugzwd mnéar mtfiimtéang sit :23

yam» we £21 tim mg-my pram.;a1:§’Vab’n”14,._v§1a§fi ”

and fix: benefit sf 4&3 gfizgra _ ;I72%§:f£:

mmsm mm: be awe §§w¥$.g§ 9:’ a ¥a:r§’3;- k f: T Mgflg mm

flim Ccurt.

In that kL:%:1g::¢: fmrzi my mm:

in this mi»a.~a;;’%f. is dismisasefi.

Sd/’ %

‘judge

_ ”

nun uwuxl {JP BWQNATAWQ MGM OF KARNATAKA I-‘H65-I COURT OF KARNATAKA R16?! COURT OF KARNATAKA HiGi-I COURT OF KAR