High Court Karnataka High Court

S Robin @ Robinson S/O Late Samuel vs Shijul Kumar on 22 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
S Robin @ Robinson S/O Late Samuel vs Shijul Kumar on 22 July, 2008
Author: Anand Byrareddy


.v _ E . Sh»i§-pl Kazmar, 3’v§.:!_;::;r

},

1% *i’i”ii:C Emiifiiri {j()’E.}R’i’ (3? I~(A}{3.\E A’§}’£K;%. 5351′ }§:’%.'”\%

;:m’;:;:%> ‘mg; mg}; 22m} %1;>;w <33? .:z;;",':'/~£é;sa?§i

B}3;F(j}}{E:

T}–iftéi %isi.’:E’-£’}%LE%; Mia. .::.:s;*,:’::>:3g:;k:;%zx1g_ 3 2%s3<g.9kk%’z’%'{%:»m k

}’S;¥§l’}”\7’v’iiIt3l-‘§T-e’ :


S. R_<}'::3i§1  R(3':3in:;u:1  H
y/£4 yearg,  Lats S;=.:;:§---*eh;:_' ' V _
?vIsit:koi.e Read   _. ,    .V   

Tippzmagara  _    ,   

Tumiwz"      «.    AFPEE--JEIfi'fiT

{By Shri_:’-Faiai ‘Kz;:*¢g::wiia_; ‘;%__;i~raé;:ait:}

AN 31):

‘ – SEE Cfiaizzdiippa.

‘ I§:”::. } GEVEVZ?’

A ‘– }”‘a.m :=;:§*;é.i”~’%.{‘?3e¢1s V

.’ ?:~<.i = 'A

Eiasigmii ?s;»~;.::

KG?:iI<;0_de,~ Saiicui
Kczraia Séakz:

7s’.~}_’::z{i;g:>2″1.ai Izmurazaee
‘V-Cétnpany Ijmitsd

§{:;.mi§;.0de Pf}.

Manu3} Sans ‘I’wars;

Zmi G. H. Road

tn}

?,£322hik0de Agency
Cede Ne. 93319202

Keraia Siam

ifiy its Miamger ,

(Law Park A:«;:§a§ciaies; far Rt3S§){.}’fl£§t3″f}i N_ei’.*–_§ and.’3?:2*i;. I§riéaE€aiVEéi;,~_u

Aéx-‘ecaté fa: Rsspendent N0. 2):’

V

This Mi;s;::ei}::.z1c:um;,-§7i3″:sE}* :5;-;”1p’&;aE’ ‘ix:-.; I’i*§i:£i under Scciiun
1″?3{1} ef the I’&f!c:t£3’§’j’Vei::§c!:.§s..Acz. “‘a’:§;;:3§i;}s’;f’£§2e judgement and
mvaréi ciaied ‘i4._.°i’«.VT2{}*§”§’i’}V’_yam:-§::*(i Era ?v’§§r’C. ‘f«1”:LW§22f2{}05 am {he fife
sf ‘$36 4 ddii’§an;%1″_p.Ci*.Ié§. h:;:f.vgé’–.{.?’Se:*;§e’; E)ix:isi{>n) and Motor
Acc£dani5..CgEai’inA:;:”‘T’:’§:b;;z;sfi; .__Tui”n§e<..u;f?;§.:arf.3}; aiinwing Ehc: aziaizn.
petitien fin" c0':n;:.:jeg1satS.Q;: etc. .

‘F§:isA;:;;ca§ i;_{m41’i’¥3g'”e2§’i”‘ii’:§1″ Adn’:i:s:si<.:n ihis day', {he Court
éelisxered the fSi:gEl:;wing:»A._ ' "

“«JvnGMEwT
V ‘S’%11i”S.§§’:’§3’E;§;;iia, is ciirtzcied in iakzz: ntxiica Fur rsspnndcni rm_2_

2. ‘ _Thi&s_r;iai’31¢f’c(.>;né:3g am 113:” a.¢.§rni2;:«;inn, ivy <.:u11:e;t:ni ui't..::.31131st:3

Err ihe p'a;6;i'cs, its' taken. up ihr finai Liififitéfiii}.

" The appeilam was 83:: egiefimaxzi. Eacihre the Fvfuitsr Aszcéiiesniza-;

'€3:::in1s Tfibunai (hc§':tizaaih:;1' rei.E:m.:d En as 'the: T:'i%mna'i' {Ear

brevity) ii": 1"t;::~;pc:£;i mi' a c;}aim Far a:n, as a rtzsuii 0!’ a

main? :;:a;;:i.&::ni. At {hes siagc ::E’adn1is;>:i:;rz, 33 £54 p<:«é_3"–;iz:d g$i;§. ":}y;'£§w_g

Cuunscl for {ha appeziiam hi:.'n:~;e}i' ihai; »£}!i.:',«_¥"§:: x-wfas 1V"si:i* Qéviziisnggz {:33

b£*:haE§'::v£'i.he appefiani ihrtmgjz a nn':£ii c§:+=-«;¥ §3.;"a:iiéi.i:§fi¢*r ~.:«1 n<,§ Eh:f:::

razsuiissd ii: 1%}: Triimriai awar:ii't';g, pzéiizfiz ' s_t.;fi_as '–,u§i(3cr ihcfi

cnnz=*::nii:_:anai heads; of uiaim, IE.,;§':'§' i:ri_fEi'fis;._E1ac:§<.g%(}'urIii ihai firm

pramtzni appcaf is _i§};:_d. *

in vies? u,£'"~.i§i'éé"'=a.a;iz§fi§fiit:<Li v..G;ifCt£,I1IE£[&i11£16 ihai no msdicai
fifkltiiiIi£,)I3'f:3'§"'5§§§'E£?%.V'$fXP:1?'}'3§%§E§Li?!§'§1V(§ '1"rib£:fi£1l }:a.\2§r:g awarded zmniinai
amounts uiititzr E.h¢::* yeizfings"ssggfwrsiiiizxrlai heads carxrmi be Eéuiied.

Hmwevcrr, if the a,ppsI'ia,n{ u'{.;é:ss hariimur' a tnarkczd eiisabiiiifgz an

::ia;r.;u:;'r:i. c3i7'i1i.sVVVinjuries whiczh are said to has st:rim:s, ii wcmki yai

;3e;i:.:sai§x§:~: "'E»,£}»V &3'I:§'§'§§~;'}:(.it:'£' that ceisc :3? i,Im.:: a,ppeI}::.t:;i fin" an highm

amuufié :33

iczaziing the tsvieicrsce :::i.}c,s§2 %;=r.:§l.:«rr: ‘ihc Tribtstzaf.

4. V€§1i.ic {Em Coumxi $1.3: §.E’::: r::;~;pe.>z1Lit::ft.i..,VIf¥2ié.:71$:;.. ::s;:.§::r%s>::s’s.. VV

ubjmm as; rc:gm’ei§~; 3:132 e:n;::gi:§et*aii:m[mi”;”:;:né;z§£§[ if’i§”:.£::’¥’£”éé§.E’§.t:§Z3§’.§»

térI3.¥:)iz: {ha a_pp:.;_:g”2§g:;-z’a~:.;’t3,i’ ‘_’i:2;_ iiugl £E§”:;E. >

in:s£.a.ncc 2121:} we[:.i.:k§._a’§2;:_.3 :4-;u§”3:j:3§_i:.’§,§3:g§. ‘iE1′.§:.r:::;f)jé:’::¢i:tr3i. w’sm§s’i he pm
is u11I1.::a.::::~;saa€5y §;,2i;x}S;§ii*g:s .aiiV£j’- ._ii’1’c..: 33:. vczsieinuct amai Ehaé he wuuiii

hays in E:’£§’3i«iF”?,§3’i£: I{<:;11';§L%'§1'0i"i:3.it:¥°t:si .i§'z cam, ihc zzpptziiafni siairgzici

saccscii in 6sE.a.b§.%;;hi.i1g "E. {er 3. Ezighc? ammmi {if

£.i(}'i.Hpt3IfI:£?:i,I.i(.)¥i} akmi szmtiiii i~;:»uE3miE ihai fin: a;3peai ':36 rarzjtscicci 3% the

,2»-

3. ‘CF’f§ a’a¥=.:3:é’:;é;it;raiie:33 mi’ Efm fassés magi aircaazrasiancest {hat

;%7z_;i.iur:: it: i§:.t:: a§’xpc§EaI2i havifig miééziéiisehcd hire <.:a:~;e;: bciizéra ihc

V' "f7%fé§?3;:r1é;_¥ i332 Etzaxfizig <;:§g::,:ni ¥:':mi§r.: m’:§§:”t:§§.»=

“‘-_fi1e__7Ei3u3i :.:aI’E§1.riu11ii§-= in iemigsr gnatgiiazsi cviaiszrue in S1i§§§)€§§°§ mi’ E125 e;-faith

%

5
wf”:i§t:, ii, is; aim.) Em he E-mpi in véesw iitai 3.33:: §’e:=;p:mzis:I§ wuzgid 39::

{mi ii; ha,r:§:-fiéip and §¥3i.}€}§!’;a”€1″§§§t§§.1£Lt3u E97f»::t’rs.:é:z_ 23 :_:€.:»m§é§.i:;1: ‘é:§;uié:1_pv;:_;=;cv;§

‘S

Eizai Sim 2£§§;72£::§.Emr2£ :~;E1ai§ E3233′: win: .22 §’?é1’£”§ mi” iE1;.e%__ é1%:§«¥.éj:;2.::_i ~31-‘.__)V§’ _

é.:e3:zI§§t;:::sa€£e>:: éfgzai mat}; Ba ::;.wareicai %¥1…§f.1%i,’2~:: EE~n:a.3§£:i*” £:s§’5~;5–«: ~.%%2=.

An;

, ,.

mm eff R:s;.3 i’}uu- in 1%}: ¥’t:f.~;§}{?§’i{i$f?i a éiiifliiKi;i{:??’§’S’§’£§€3’§”E§.§§£)3} »v?§};=. ‘if§é–{6

Triimnai as £.§i:”&:s;’a€§i_ E”:::re§.1.::…%:*::}_a.%’z>a:.V –

6. 3719;: ap;3::£%eE §:5éT'”aEEc;V:z;*;:si1,;_ V ,?§’}_1″V§’~.¥”?fi:E.§:iv€§”‘ iEi mmazzticzd Ea: ihc

‘.Fri%m::ai El}? a=3}”€¢s¥’:1′}§;a.;n::wi<i::z"£:vié<m %;viiE';f iiimrijg in me :a;.;;;i2¢§Eaz1i in

is;:§3dt:r a;i;i%E,é;.:z:;1i Vc::~"'~,»::i:;§.¢Vr'?.<.+'.é:{'r§sA;§§_§::_<,;é; in éiéc appcfiizmi pafsirrg :.:’!s.;=.,i_ (sf 2-m’}~’ é£:m::,1ié %. iizaf. ma}; Em 2:%sv:»:.:”da;i arm’ éiarihczgg

.._i§1<:: a.p:§}eE§:5£2:i. S§"2':i3E"~w3'}§; iimxisei ézzimet.-;i Eé"mn iézc z.i:«;é€: ué." zmzami

t_;.3?égi:i:.:5g§§§,a_r*:;:z"§':;;§;:fz:r:§_ $3}; §4§';<: Tré§':s:.£t':2_2i ééii Eiza dais: an? ziispémai in

ircrfrz S Eiifrsé jVi1'g{;;i:3z2@:1E.,

Sci] 1"

Judge