High Court Karnataka High Court

S A Geetha vs M/S Pickup Carriers on 20 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
S A Geetha vs M/S Pickup Carriers on 20 July, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil And H.Billappa


“”§’%=€:?’~7 %~%:.>%»e*a:§ !%*§R;.Ji§$;”?’%£§ 2–%x3;:a_.%?§*»>;éa ”

?z§;¥§h?§§(3fiT.§a*i;5§{¢?S$*?§%§%!§V

§E”§”¥’%§E§§¥§;

:32

~. ziggeé afijeasé’

3:~s::’;’$;§;;:3§§%%:g;

%fi§;’::’;§a%:&__ $3; A i’é’.;–“‘é5:=*%§;§%%2 ‘ ‘
§§£%§’:a§$:§.%_..;é }’2j’§?i&%§”§:.’ . T

:#*;_&.§L;*2.§%E3:%%§%;§?;%_§”

‘ §-gig S.£§.»§;:$T2:z;’aiE?:E ‘
a5%.::z>;;.:i ‘§§§:§%;§.:%;

1 $:,£§v,.;37?;’?”§éA§’§2.f%v§”:’*:§€;;?:%%{§_§
£i;:*;2s~«;a§?:

1% ‘§%;f’§§

-‘Em gffii M

;é;*m§%_§’§§’:%§”‘2 Eififi 3 gaze’: ?E”%§§2i1«*§” ,
fiagé. $333 firs: agggéiaréi ;!”§’1_§§§”‘%$§’

—- .. $3 3:33:33: 53:; %’§§%§”‘§w
_ V. ;%%§”:3:’§ ;r§§,Q~§2;2.S;%’%f:iSP:”g%<3$§'*:,
§'§;Gff§'"§3, Q» §'«;§a§?I 2"" ?%':a$$.,
€3%§'%3%a§a§, §§§%§§§$:'&»~«32( H §?;3'£LL§%§'%«§"€§

5:3}; :'$§§K§<,"?§;§::;§%%;3i saigsaai fiagéia}

§§"»§§ ;

?~g§s’$,?%f;§.3§§»3fl§,_

Kgméaa §?’2a%:’E§Z

gézafigggrg §%§;?::~i fC% {E33,

2. Eéaiéaazaé §§”‘§$§.§?§§’§i.?& Cméggizga

Qévisésa 8% Q3?

§$z§§§ %é3L§$%, §<fi§'é?§E;§i£?§§ '    _ 

Eéew §a%%:é~="?§.,.   '  ,,

Egg éis Sivéséanaé§;Z~§::”:ag£e§*;” ‘ ;’;A.?;§;’%’;%§’:f%~éiEVE?%§”§”;J gas.-;:%: agaérggé age

éésgafgfi’ .:E;f§i:%§ 22»~€’%-«;73$§é gagaéfi $5′:
?%5Ef§’.§é.$.2§§§$;52€2§f§ fizz gag sag Q? >:2.;; ,$ga;.;:.:<gge,

_?é:"E§'£"§."';A 3e:&::;§a§s:eLs:§:g ggzfiagxmfiga gaééigs §%%gs1.s1§é§":g we

' E??? 2$§°:'";§$ra$§%.§§:§ am §§%§€§%'"§§ %?'§§"3§§'?€;f;%S?'?§*E°?i

* ;§§'~f:@::*;£§:é.:;%a§%§a§2»

~~ "":";%:§$ %a§;¥,& $:§§:*:%':2§ 2%: §'"i%%§'§i%§ %%°:§§ fiafyg f%§,§4:.;%*§ Eff;

V. ' :3%:*:.E.§%:a-*;a:*a<',% fie %:3§é§%ég%§:§:»«

;§é§_§§%%§%'§§'

?'%':e &§§$%§a:';i:s§ Efiifig a§§§%e2:&§ $3' as §;:§gr;§s;§:§*:"»a;§:fi

awgré fiaieé 22-: Eéfifié gasaefi 2:: §%¥S.?és.2§§§§2§§f§§'..':§?:

iééé féiég 3? éfia ?s;%a%§2' A2*;£%§$§';'{ fiiaéms '?'r%%2,:§3aa§v_;'_'~§SCA$§~"§¢»'E-3:};

§§.?'§§§§§%'% $§':*g, {gfiiaéma '§'§§§:.§2'sa%'1 ?%%' :§S:.%§<3%'§§'

éize érzaégni ameaé fifé Em §§::,%:;'_%§§ :%%'§: 'ééfie §:3§§–:;.§2§' aéfizaijfiéci

§€':§%§$§%,é%%$ 332$ $%:e§*e:f§:2%'._"%' ééaey"'-a.§é*'e;§::§§§§£% fig'
gméaagemgfié $27' c§:':°§;:%;_e§é*:..%§{%.{é§':.:. : ~

2. :”§”?.ajé a§§e;_%§Vé§%a}%’ =§§..£,:§:e afié %§Q$§§§§”§€S 2

afsé Vi’§”é£g :’§%’%i§§s:iar=~§§*:=.§;”:f i%:é ‘::§’aéé%&%§ $fi,é’>s$*-g=*:;&%.§*’%:, E-“”»é’§”%§
wag é.::¢:.’g§§:e§s’§.§ ‘:*{%}e%r.§;§2a§”§%;–.,§5’3a’.. §£c:..:§a§%$::. Lam 5,8-.§§==a:a%%:
éiéé; 2?’? 332.. a:;3v§:§e:’§fi’~~.:?:’a%§%~%.gmmed as’: 23-éa2G%3 3: amzgé

2;~;§*%%e§:———-%%:§ éeaeagefi was ggaaagfiézzg £3 hég

V ?é§%a§?.::”%:v;’**:»;?”£’%&5 §:%a§°%n§ %”%§§§§§”%?§$§”s %i$,C%<$£»2éé 3: ;:*:§§%?gi&

§_§;§ée§?;§'2§ éafi géfig 5:2? 2% 333$ ?:'§§'%*:_ éieggaé fa

$as':~:%§$':f§%%%% am $29 gaéfi mg' fiame £2253? %%:$ §s"é§§§ fig

,"'§'§'%z_.:g":§a?§%%§§§3 %"§'*§%§ $3'; ?x§§~%~«€3§ 3% Em? Eémgg E §$§*:"§: %.;.'}§%§§§"§§

zegégifaigésrz ?£sg%%%=~§§§%é§'E §;"§%5§§E $3: fig firm?' 5*: 3 §'§§§"§

35$ ?§%§§§§§{%? §'§'§§?§"%§""§§%" garfia %' gm iééa §§§£:$§%§ §§§'§{':3£§§?§ am

5%

§§$§"%%§ gggifigi t%*:& %u%§5a§§%:% £35 £§:;*"§if§§§'"'% fig {E25 §8$§§$€§ am

3% 3 ;re32.,:~%%; gé' iézég aaaéégni 333$ §§%:'}%§$§§ gasgéaégsgé §?%;§;:g§§§s;.

am $3:-assd fig": 53% gm: fig': gaaaaézi 3? %;?:a éfigéié

ésaaggad $':'3,.%s2=*=g&%§':, the aiaémanis »w§§§$§é_5?%f{£fS§ §f§'€{§}?;§"'

ésaya ffigfi 3 s:§a§m geééééarz $%&;;m%z'2§ a:a%?7§'é§m&€§–::fi_L fif.[1'

?Es:2§,§§,§%§§5=~ ggaézzsi 1% ?'$;$$®a'"%§'3%"'§?L$s. {:§§§%f'E"§§

'§':*§§:.s::§§$ fiéées" &%sg%Lsai§s§: 3 ?';L§r'::.as~;;"'@§'g% 53%'*;f§«_VVA£§5G$%.z;'§'2%?'%i3?'%;'

§"sf§§$§";{°:§ 353$ $§§"'é§%"° :*a%;:é_":.§%§:2é; ::::%Ag*£$r.'é§$§1«%*x**»:*:;¢sz"é Eéag aiimggad
éiés :§%%:'?: ipeiéiégié é:":__§f%2*%:V *7a*a%§aE's*:%:;:?:a;.%;:;% 3 sags": sf

Rasggei§@§;g;;s~:::;k}%;;::e:gs:j328% §e%':' ?'§z'%:'<*:'z::":': gm: 22$ saw

sf §%'§§'iE§%"'1 éééé %i3£;%.i*E&%&:% £5 ~%:°ie3;a=§.§g.3%%"::n

31 "=;%§fé:é§[–agAg_:éé?'§§§ iéée ameééggxig ?:§§'$%2*: §'%$§?€

" * __ g§?é§§%fii§.;§% 'fzérze %§:S§§&:::**§;2$ea% as': 23% gmzsafi '§*2a% ififi §§'%'§€3%i§§"%§'

%;%;9;3%:*£%é:'§._%§'%%:[§ €'l:3§%§§"?':$ ":"é'%§am3§ éa §§°2§$$§E§§§Z§ gm fiégy as

ss§:%:¥z §e§ iai3s%§3;§.~;§**é'ag°:<:2;r22;%€*:7§ af $§§§§3e§":§s§%%an.

£9) 32% $iE§§'¥3§S§s$§§§'? éf étfae §§§§'%":$§ aazgfigai

§fp5%;;:2é§r§:':§ gggs' Em §§§$%§%§%'?£$ és %;§%:a%,§%"2e irggsmg 5:? Eggs

"fiasfiagafi iaifififi éy 53% T§'§%i.§?"E§§ ég §§§"1§§$;%"§:' 2:3 3%

{£323 a *:2;:§§§a:"%.a 2 gm 3 %'%é%3%'% §'?'§§;?E£é§"S 3%; i%*:§ %%?:':% 5:? §$§'§'% at

%?"§@§§" 'égifiisfif' 33$ 3% §%"£§é'§€':§ i§%'¥§?fi$ €533 §§ §€%H;°§

222$ 3§'*%s%%§€f £3 §:23.§§s:;::a§§ 333$ ii: s§§:.:i;;:'§$ g::§'%;:a.fi§fa«:*§:?:':«:%:;%,VV"

3:3 amazérgi '=3?-£33 gagazafaégfi igzszgzég '%§§§s!'~–:°;%" é_,§$%§2éa9;

?§**':3:a%a:::'§§ he gaéméfigé E:%2§§ ;i%:;':«§§

€»fi%'?"§§$f:§$?;§€3?% may %.:z§2 §:*s§:'éV§::.%.§§:::i§§"ai%;§e?i

6 23%? $§§§:§§;_;’ 2% %e.a=;:«:%s§:£.§{%;~-u§f:$§§ §g:v§3e,a;v:”%§:g faya

3% §%$G§”§£§ §”8$§§§”%§%§?§§~§§’E$g%.{§%;’%:$%T§: §:;?21%€;§”§§;%.3%’é’;¥ égsiiar aiég

£’}’?3?§%%%”‘E§%¥I.’§ 3§°f’:§§§§%’: _’;§$~’3,:?éé3£§._b§* Qiaéms “§”?%b::r;a§

$3 §i%§;§’3’§3§{fA,?§I3;§§%é§3§TZ3«’§$;~.§’§§§ %3§:r=g2:*’~:é§1 $233 mi é§$§i§§$’§ i%s%

g§:”:%%§%€§sé”:._$f iéée:’§$;%§::§§–..%§:i.;§a,::%$$% aggaarééég figs’ aggeééaiéia

?;%’%§§’i§’%% a%a§&.2*§s;az§’L’ fig éééga §§§%;”%f’E$ “§”°:’§?§;:§:a§ %:a%ga§§§

:;§a%;?:§§é§*i$:g?«§«”§§$§ :3? :$€ég::;§%§:.§:§*;’, & fiegs Q? émse

§.%?a§§%§§nf éfiafifizsgasaia

‘V %éf€:%% h%:’§::§ %§’§§ §%§§’%’E§§ $§é..§?’§§€§ §§§%§§’§§’;§ €35′

“%.?:§_ §;§§*;%%§a:*2§$ 82$ Em éégiiéefi gamgeé a:§§%§:*%§2§ 253:’ *i:%’:%

7 E3z:3;1:::”§?2§$ {££s:?§§*5:?:y $523? 3%? §§§%§§’E§ érgia magéégggzéasz 13%

:’%’a;§% §$?%;§$§*:§%§§2g $3? $3??? fie ifiiififiééi Egg aféar ggggfzgé

gegagai sf ‘fie _§i,,§d§;’?’;&%””%'{ aséé a:;a;&s*§ §:>§$§§fi $32′ 2% i::§§&§§%’§*’:§

“§”:%?s:;§’2aL Eézé 32:3 rgagagiéen $33? agégég 2%? 312:” m2″23%2:;?<§»:%§%:.i:§sf*:':;_

E3 z;%:§2;m;?%§§? 53.2% Smflfiféf azfigarfiéfi 33f; 5% ~

$.33: 35% gafsgséfi? –

8:’ 525%? aazafasé §:2%:*;:ae:§.._§f %?;;}é.__’;§,V.’é’.iEiL.i§§%j’%”%.é§7″:?:;V’A
§’i’é§$$§§ by iiwe Céaémg ‘E*:%§;:%’§;”§%_V £:’§§§§§§s-,= éigfiaai “fie
émeawaé ééasfi §%%§§ .%’$><_'».§§§'§é_s§r2$ §§::;%z§%§sg his
@933 §%§:'§§§'£'E$ as %E3,"2§§§§§'-.-« E23 ma saéé
§$.é%3$i.E§,5~_ #i;<:§L%?;§;k?gA$§§;fi; g: gfifigfififiim

$3 é§§a§$Ee§~..§:.xéc>..”*; :e;%*:a E333: ézg? %*:s%’$%2§:§:j 3% asaifiegi

$5 aaasifiafag? %;%§%;'”i§§§”% 2&3: ifie §§§§§§§%”‘%€ %é§,,€

say 3 ‘Six’; 3% §;gs§§.:%g:§sm ifisiaaai as §gA§§,;:t2%sJ%%”.,§;%g *:s:gzgea§;::g&&%T

‘éasg sf aafégggéézimi §«;:m;’§%::§§3:, %;~;§5a §;§%,%e%:1;”s:”%’:f:§$1

E’-‘§:%”*§é’§€§$ 1&3 $1″? §$¥E§$§”‘{§i.%§’€’§.

§§s3.{::§.ié3%;% fiféé

Q

ES; “§’%§% a§%2§:;s2%..a:w§;i€.*E:*s:e:§.. ‘f:§e%~§§?§$

§§§%a%%arz’ E3 §:%a§§@a,§a%%”a¥§;5§* ‘:%..:€é3§;~é$ {.%_§’:%§a§”2§e§:’:a§:% fm’ %?:e

faagam, $23 3 :§§%’:._ %;?§%:’:«:; 3?$ 3% %;§:§ iémg 3%

figgééé’§%§€%§&%§f%’a%%:é%§’a?§d~»%§’:$’:; egg anaé gffsagiiéfifi 53? i:%%§2%:’
§§%%*a%:* 2?: 3 %;§:2;*§;e52< faaé gag: 353:3 §'?'§§§? 3%

a'2:§a§'§ 3 §.%'.*?;§fl;%3?';§$%:%{,%;% '§Z€,§'§*é3?€i% €933 $2' Ewe 332%

a§'§§%::2§%%:§=;2'. ,§§$$s;*§%':f':§§3é, 32$ $@%%r:*{:%:";& :fi:$;'§§;§i':fi§~ %;;§*-»zga§'§i§

"%';sé%§ §§%'%$%%§:'*§ §§°"%$§%§€§ §€ %§.§§§Q;1».

' z as fig: 3% mi gffiééiéfifg ':%:% ::§?:*§§a:*:a§':%G%:: %f':

'A §"¥?;$§$§£ Q? €338 Egg $2' agiaéé' $3: {ha Qiaémg "%"?%@:.,s:2a§' $55

"jégéi 333%? 3% gases :5 §%s%sa§§ 3 mm $5 §s,E§§§$;1»%§2asa§£$

' 5%-{Egg G? &§:§'%';§' 33:8: iaéégég %§"§%$ $§§'E$§@%?§§l§Q?% %:%2&

/WW

Eéa é::§$$§én§%;*, asgeaé féégaé $23; as §§.§5&%%f3§;s§s

' § * ' 1° ;g ' V 215 'I -T I
:3 3%:-%5e_:;Z3:~__% _

23% §%$$§3§ fig ééta fiéaémg “§”s”§§a.:s:a;%M§:2 %:’§v£;’?€§1;j2;3;§§!2§€§%_u

ég §°3iE§’%§?§ ??”§%i’:>§§’§§Q¥.i §”:§§€’,;§§§”§§ gm: i:?:._e §:§§.f.%.:~§’§§3§?%;:$’~.a§%::% §*%fiA§.iE§§4:§§_A«

fez $2’3fi’%§$;*”E$§’§§§’: Q’? %3.?;ZZ’;8{§§§;’».~’ és

Rgia;?aea§;:; mega sf §s;ja5ik;§§§:E::,::::%a;m gaségéeéfi :3: ::::e
iiéaégm ‘%’:%?:}:s?:§%v ‘?%2eJ”‘–%€5é:§: ‘;s;§2%%:’a:v:’25%§£*;v% géfiaéazgéi is azsgayfiaé
aiafig aégéiéfi §:’£se;:e§% &%:’§§€e’ «:5%::’2?e’£%§L..§€%%’.§§’§t §:2:*2z:§*:: §§’am ‘iééé
figie $5 §e;%%%E§a?} $3?’ ;?%§%’$3¥€%::§’§:

T. “s’–3$;:%e:r:§’é9?§2%~»’:”%2$;§mafia $:§§:%;3a:*;;é $2

fiééaaséégééfi ‘:§%§;§§’i€VE’§”>:%’-$$;.é &§”%”:G:§;?°’§’§ égfafa Eézg “§’§§%:::.::”:3§

“¥§%§§”§?E §§§ §”:%;’ §%;@.§<<;;s §*:$§é'%"%;aé§§a: "§'"§°2$ §;:*;§z:,2§'€:%:3§2s*%%§*;€: §% %E%"':%

§.é%f:;%';~g::;¢§<§.§§:?:§§:§:3–s%'§§§: is §§'"'% 25% gaiigz fiagrze %%'2a:§ C§§§?TES

Ea §§§'§{:i%§: is: figazfig fig: *:§3§ %%s"*é'E"';§§ &$$::::"&%z':g%§a
& '%
S -3
Judge

géffi,
j*t3.§§§"

859