High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Zabiulla vs Sri Rangegowda on 26 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Zabiulla vs Sri Rangegowda on 26 August, 2009
Author: N.Ananda


– it R.angeg’:::aa?éa

‘=-,Ni–Za~ya;,: Ii stage,

ms THE HIGH caum 09 KARNATAKA AT 5ANG;§:;@éEfi’%j’% ~

mares THIS ‘VH5 26?” am’ 0? .{-%£;§GL£ST-‘_4’é{§_ Q’é.~VI.
BEFORE A %
“ms Herxsma MR’ J::sT§:c%{ELk%rsa, §;r§$_MiQ

MISCELLANEQQS FIR$.7fzAPP;EAi;§f4£§’;*8?8?gfi2{}Q8{MV)

BETWEEN: *

Sr: Zabiuiia

S/0 Shajahan, _

Aged smut 232′-.yea;r5,,_ ‘

Carepenter, ‘ ‘ %

R/Q Iéahénagar,

Permian Moijsaim; __

Hag:-:.3neS?._3″A:2Q1, ….. MAPPELLANT

{By Sue sudjhaf)
ij;é;z~gé:a: %% A
4: . S55 -3af’v&;uegéwcfa,
“=§gI§”?§?s§€?§°;’ ifiifi ‘:§;a’;$:’r§*’:%’:§a r;-?*<:f§}é_g:uram, Beggar;-S?3 2&1'

2. The Orientai Insurance
Cempany Limited,
Qévésianaf Gffice,
Ski. Nifaya, V ‘
BM. Raadf Has5an«~«5’?3 281. RE§~P<."2*§\§£;3ENTSv~.V…

{By Sr: Rajagepaian, Adv. ferV_R-2 ;

This Mm £5 féfed undeé? Sam}233:1; ':3? Mi! Act,
agaéngt the Jagdgment as-»c§__ Awaké' passes in
we NQ.2:12/2QQ5_c§1 g;y:@,mge (Sr. my
& Ami. MACT, H8§i'3§,¥fii¥'.!!Vf?%:}Jf£!§$' tfsgcéaim petétéan far
campensatéan faésifl' "3ain:§2af§:cer?'§é%§'i:'v sf cempensazéerz.

This MFA fiicmfiing' this day? #339 Cam':
aemreredzheffaggawéysg, %

.f ;uQGMENT
"{:4§:'§a*_§'..s:'v1%_'s$%::=:'f'.'$ appeaé far amancememt Q?'

:;&mpVes3§a:§§é'2..

k {fig szem gm; $.;~4$ samag Eaazrsed mssngei Far

–.:., : _VV:§ai’:§”:a:§.é_,V_a§nd Eri Raga Gepaian, Egamedf mungaé far {ha

V,j,.j,,§§9¥$.§V;g:*’3«r:V:e Csmganys g\). ‘

{SEA ageé ahaagt 2% years at am time sf’
Véifiécévdzgnas yéés a aamenzer S’; @:::c:2§3§:§@r:. Téée

§’~:a_§ véééi: grgémgeé any §Q§%.£!”§’2E¥’§§3E”;! evifieafi is:
L’ same. But the fast remains Q33: he was

.ff$L¥Siff£ia’§VV§’3 E:z”f:g by Q§”1fi,!$§£Z8§ iabeuez PWQ has depased that

{3} As per medicai regards and evidence Q?
Abdui Baaheer, ciaimant had sggffered f::i%aw:ng__Eng-;s§eg*.::j: _ J

1) Sweiiing & Tenderness right §eg a:{‘3i;b{Q’§f§%r:.ss3″«._m:::b.§_§éi*g

ray ghmws fracture sf tébia and fibuiafi A’ . ‘ ”

2) Ab:-aséan fight knee

3) Cgntusien angst

4») Abrashzsn right wrist

S) ahrrasien right e!§Q2é;fg_-.

(4) The c§a§:7r;a’n: ss»..:.a;_.S If€;;<;-:.*la';*:g§":;§«':'r: Mangaéa §~mr§éng Heme
at Hasggng ,"§1;'3ie f%f'a£?::,.2'r&s Qgeré reduced by wan reéuctéerz

ar:€§AV_%r:'i:er:2'§% féxistgésg %

N Cgw QW._,g1A,,

resardg, I am af the egpérmn mat mg
" ?i.. §:t§.sf*::;:x&–::§s:§£§§%z awarded by the Trémnaé Lmdgr the head at'
. V._:"%«€Z§.$S"*€iffuféétfiffi awnings' §s madaquata in view 3? the fast

the Trémsrzaé has taken §§"'§€£'s§'"'§"'§& ex?' céaimant at

Qermaaent ghysécgé disabiiéty sf zcjaémant with re§§'re:"2r§;éL:"'ia:' f
fight sewer éimb E3 25%. ' V
(6; The Trémmai hag a~aya;rde§'.'_ gmga$az»;gfi

Rs,1,.2@,?1C1/- amder fgiéawmg !2ea':;§$:;"'~. V.

1} Medicgi exgansas V
2} 93%;, injuries arsé 5;;'§f$;r%ng;l§""'§:';

3) msg a? future ga.?m?__n1’§VQs’;’._V ” » é1,:G4J–

4) L933 ef a:2″‘::e1::1§wt§:3{*s,~Vé’n;§I:::e;»n;céggs%é’e%it”w
Er: fife u * ‘ Rs. :G,,GUG,i«

S} Csnvayanceg ;f;§:_s%r§.«§Tr:.r%éé’;:::_4fa¥”§°2′;V’éi’
attendant charigesvv _ : R3. 5;§QGf»-

6′: {F-:;:’s*::;;*e :'{r§e:d§:a§ 53:: gfifsefdaes
3 ._ ._ A A E
mt carry .3r13<\ir_§t'e:«;fesi:) : Rs. 8;€aGfi,'-

RsJ.,,,2Q,?1§,f~

V .3} 6%: §':.§aJz7%":*3;g3 marneci cm/gnsei fer games and an

E

-”’\j. Q ‘”é€La

a:1da:tAé£3da%1?;”.*<.%–ff2a§Trges : Rs. §&,§GGf*«

?}'1:'§;;c§9.é§».:g§f gr-.a.«rn§%2g§ flaring éaéde

-. _ “uipi p£”:§r’E’Qt”1?_.” : Rs, $366]-

» feta: Rs. 1 , ?2,4«4§g…

Rsalffifim/~» per mmth. in my apinisnf
has tg be taker: at R$.3,QC3G/- gar mQn:§§€:
awaréed by the “!”r§b:.ma§ :ewar§b$_”§as2é=.
‘futurs; meéécaé expanses’ :5 gigs i:éé§:éTéq:;Vatéj ‘§:j%§,sna!

has met awardéa any ‘$35 sf
earnings wring iaéé up Qer%;3_§_f’_A:.VVf§§§%e’§iQ.%§\;.I’._’jgémgansatiea
awarded by the

1} Medécaé axpensfég 35,,6§6/-

2) fiairz am — I Rs. 3Q,QQQ,f=-

3} was sffasturé~§é:<rg§§'*:'g$" . R5,. 5;,34a;–

4} was sf a4;;*§e;*:%::§es énriénjcymeni
….. ;

R . 25,G§G;’~

U!

5} .C@rg§fe’}fa§%2f:g€;v«..gé:::£;=f§$?i:§'”:’:e:”s¥:

?’v}_;F;st;; rg ::’1é’§e§.%{:Va;§ éégganseg : R3, :5;,Q§§/4

. 4 4 ¢ . . . . . . » . . . . . . s s a = a . . : , ,1

?:_\!_s;” H

{8} in the raszsét, 3 pass the fcs£%av~;§ng srder:

The appeai is accepted in Qatar. The M
ég medéféed. Camgagngatém sf
the Tritwnaé is enhanced ts Rs,3..,?_2;4$sQ:4′–._~;§:§th .»’§.:%§t§rés§§’:;é;*: ‘V
6% per annum fmm the gate mf””‘:;$§’=r,;;»§t§;ag’v.: ‘iii? ‘:2?
rea.E;sa%:§a=:’%:$ rm gaymentfgfia :5? the
ratéié exzeizzaa in the EmV§sgng§V§é4§§?é_; directed

is bear theér mam. .

‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘I