High Court Karnataka High Court

U C Madan Kumar S/O U M Chandre Gowda vs State Of Karnataka Rep By Its Secy on 7 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
U C Madan Kumar S/O U M Chandre Gowda vs State Of Karnataka Rep By Its Secy on 7 March, 2008
Author: A.S.Bopanna
IN ']'H'l£ IIIGH cm: W!' or KAI-£NA']'AKA AT HA?é.(§5i;€?§e:§T:-'V  .

1:)A'1'1«:1n'H1s3 "'l'I'l'E 7'!" nAY_g'.11%*,__Mmz'tjH' ::i0_z;r.é3"-  .
P£EI?'()RE-, ' é ' %

']'}I'E; HON'BL}'§ MN. v;im3{:'1(:i§:'-A  r.:(>:"§Ai%!1P:A,.  

wim' }'}'fl'l'l'I(i)N N0. 1.;{:;;3§;1';oa)5"(mvi§1;:|s§§-2)
Bl::"1'WI*$I':N: " '  '
uc:mALmm;11r.am2   V
3,10 u M <_:HAra1.::L2:é;_ c;:V7L)IS'.:'EE§fI(I:'!.'.'~      Pl=1'l'l'l'i(_')Nl'3R

 " .:~m* '1='<;jaR 31-35 "(:3 ERJNIVASAN, Awe)

  

1 ';43'!'§*!.".*L'? ~ffI?!*'   RV 3, F'-E(.3R.E'!'ARY
. ., 1)EPAii"i_'M1i}i5f'F OP' (j'(')~(j)PEl§' '
' D

V  2E;3AN(I§AI,C)l?tE"faiiii om

A   _ 'v*1fi?1E_'m}::31_1*;'Y (;{;JMlfiIS§%I()NER

'    "£'Hi=: 'l'AI--lSIL[)Al$:

~{_1}£iKfifi;"fi}P:E,I_}E'€ E}IEi"i'RE{;3'i'
(:m.:;jw.c:A1,u:2
3" . T1-11+';Ass*'1*c:<_;MM1:as:1()NER
' _'r'_:vs:~:m:e

c"_:11n<MAc:A1,:_m

i\§f._1()i)I(i%i§Rl1'; "i"'§Li,ii{

hri()<.)iT)I(;%ls3RE  RESPIJNIIDENPS

(By em; H M :=..-aAN.111raA'rH, HLZEGAJ
l

L

u

"3:



'iii; «::I.,
.1 as 1 V
 .2; r'ri=I*:.::-.' L. 3 '1'r;;n "1'111=: 1*1:<.)v!E.:1i.::~a'5 (_::1%'-':;.'xI.'«:*{.11<;;rI.\3- em! <'j:l+"'l'IiE

I{€'.i{'i'x:A'l'; £5.11 E3'-C.!IEI)l_JI,lQ]') (,${\E1§'l'I'.'-S 7ANIa)"T35;.11-I:i¥]3Ul§ET§l ";['i?iIl13F§3

:-: wRr'r 'P 1;'i'1'l'l('j)N 1:; i-'H,El) UNDER A'i?{i'i1I;iI..}=;S'Q§<';i fi; 
I!'\!€;'3!'l'I'ij|'!'§I.T§IE\! c:,u=' mung; <;yI.JAs11.'v::;i:i:.A:u;::, 4;: 1.)': 
IL'l'}+2['. VlT\"I=3E%, V0113 P031») UNl'3N[*'(3RC§Ez'\T3LE AAl\i'-D

{;=1{<-sr:1r1I':'rr ;! ma"1'r-Mm:«*:~;:;: if)!" r..:.n:.:-.:'rA§.!~:  »_1f2':*is»2=,~.

-_II.L ;':1l'»..'_

(;)_i_I.l'1'Si I ANNITEXII
(".3

I i Mr '* r":i\?.iL;"|'i" I 'I' 1* I'?
HI} I I l. \.J' A

K} 131.)' II I

IV.J. |:1iL.-

I»!

I a :21'.

'i'Tii:i-.54  E-'e-r:I' ii;ém,2 If€)I't'ii'[.2§g"ui§' 'fir?-»i31i:iiIii€im:§a'.Cfiirtssiiiig in
'[5' ($:ou:tpB i:.'l';i:+ (lay, i"i'1::.'_€jein'[:1-i:; 111;-.1xT1¢'::f_i::;. ibllxywing :

 3 %

'First _;ssr.i' iiiré}1mt is': .l§;.::_iEr1si3 izimté fluun'. fiéiiiilfitlgg iiir 'iHE4'ilf'. of

 

wrii: 13%.'. _1_','g'f'i"Vx =--1'jig'.'£"£-a"l":§ ;;,_ij;_: ~i.'g'_€i.:i}R§fi' '2"E.j1§;_,»i:i:(:1Tilm' «'lairL-fl 1'.Ei.i:'.?,i'J()].
wia'i1:IE:._i;%: --.:a'z5: A1iir:at%fi.agi1eggliiix:._fine 'p«*::tiiin-11 agrni alga flit': -n':s.'de.m

w'*h'ir:'E'u. F§'!:i'i_i'Jl"'I'§'li,'l#;.'I,',itt*Z£- éai: {i1i1'n'aa--:3rtH1i:~l'}, 1'3 {-3116 1+' in tilt: ' miiiivlt.

1p.
4»

 

a-
u1'
1-1
CI. a
-

A
.

|-up.’

-aw
Am
,_ .

c<n

t.¢L
$2

._1i*&'r%_f fiiviil: .jj*,:;ij'€igVy':1E:':' ::=:'m"a ;"£31i fifitiitjiiiimiil, 'l:=.3;mm{i ('1;-l'r'\'!t*L'i'l,I'!i'ln':'1'lli.

1F\fl"'?IifH'?3:j.i-n}: s.:a1'$pr:rai'iui§; fitter' iihia '.i'i',fi]}l md;-;1it::s.

3. l+i5sv.i1igg he+:.s;mr’i ijiw Tl’fiS]Ii’fvL’.fiV’t: I-ttfi’l’i’l€’.i] rirniiii:t.-sfal, I

.. :’h:.fir:.~: ‘[_Efii’I_lfiifi] i’}’ii3 W1-ii: 1)ii’§’i-Erffi.

J2

-1

F35: 13,15 mmzr’ :-‘-r__;\s L::_:m.« v::;:’i~:$;; ,\,n)I1.:; Ann
in . A ”

\

=1. ‘i’ii.c’a «rm-1:: “pliiz ihrrila ‘iny’ flit’? 1_H=,iii.ir:i1m’ ‘-l:*.¥..”‘i:i”-l!fi._AfVii’i§a}Jli.i:’-I

l’tmn’irug $3y.i\§rs.’.lJ£:i§-% «hf ‘Ik’i’n1:=1+: v’_iIl:stg¢:, (7§§3i’1Viiiraé§§}I1.”‘ ]4_?i’ar.p’lr’l’i_, ‘V

‘fifiI1:3*%gs=_;mt3 ‘l’nii1’k_,’ 1′ T.’lI’in’laiiut:-:gyalii’I’ ‘|*}i9¢.”C’]’if1’é;’ iaier-12¥fl.i1iiti_g’§ I x::{:1ne”£.’_i

g;ll’i’l’i’:’-J3 was 1’i’Ili'(‘1]’I$i:.=!i’fi’l By iifiilré j;at:jtii.in:ui’fi’ in ti’3;i1i$3’iv2eF:,.;mi.ttia)’n-. L

<:rb'ruri'u1i:'ii%e1*i hy flu': Pai_ii'm':i3: -(fi'§¢V'V'—"V–',V–IR'-:g?'t:ivP(' 'n'$g;j'i{:ilj§i'Il'IB mu}

:.;'Ill!)iEiIT, w'i1i{;i1 125133. :i.If1&i aria) Hi'\I':{1fIIiilf. nfiiiifi S11' 'i"'i'..w. r"\§_'np:;.fiiiii.

Tht: serrirl iéati r Tmnr'i v=,e2rT§A1"c*_va' 1-rr':~":fs'¢ the arwwirru' 4:-Ti' iihta araici lHm' 'i

§.an'.t_i izgrlfun I:.'lt;i{!ffI'$_1';'fii'3'<,i§F !%%5ii"IV]tiri_Ill.'3#1fi 1'.'31:*iii*'. lam! 'I'Iifii'|'3";fi§§t§ii flim

'Wild :in ;ii:i;ru'ai'a9 9'5": %if|.i{' Em ' }'v1i1~=11miii in flu': :m:~.ii:'m., iTl1re

I.-J-2:]~'-'.F'\-:';""gE :-mid ii-ti: iuriiiit :i'=1'p i'rr niui'r.r} the mnn1mi.wiIinh w:-1:4 flute
_ _ Z a. '# I.

‘.3-fl”,~–.1j,_,5,”L’gm;-$3; ;.–,~.-.;’i_Wf’l’iAé. h:T1’imt(.*r*: Hnuollm’ nf R’s:.i=’i,3?’F§]~ “Irma

“‘i7ufi:’i1 ,jgjiai:i” is’;._ iT_ist: m*s;i.wTiii’la:= ¢b\’U’Ii&’31i” of the I:-md. ‘i”h-I-‘:11-,fEw’m,

_ _. ,1.A_’.:._._. L.-..,._ …_.=…….._m .._r 4.1 ., ‘I-I – . –_. ‘ . ‘, .. ‘ — .’
vllflft:-I,llH!7 mm urn m U! uh: +.;’-uni?-‘ifiii, Ehe, Ii:-afik 5.5.9-3 ilfinfi =i

in “}”§é,fiTfi’ii”i$ii’li?i*? ‘wiiiu haw Hiiii fim ‘pwr’ps-i’iy was i.’Inrm’r:ni’h22’i’

E1:-n’1ivt’uwir’ hm?

I
I2

.*–3£’T.d’?’I’fl’EV’rii’i i.””:?u1_1?.1’tig§i_? rvi’ ‘i5.1’i9éf’lii’i_i’. t*:nt:n’ia?a in hm .ms:me._:a;a;’–1:5: ”

/%’:’i’aimi:’u’e=.s;–}$ um?! (I. –

S. ‘;;%!ha.–;:’:iI_ flii-.~: v;=4.v’-:1;-4 i’.E1:’r .]__)’t*-s¢ii.ir.:11;”#11-5V{i'”,1a:*3’m:’1e.n!.:a%11i; iv. ‘

s:.:-735:5: in iv:-we ii’Ia””ii3-i’it’t’l”.–‘:1′”f”‘§_-‘ ‘i”?fV£fd’i.’I’;~%&H!_?i;i.”flifi,_i’饒m€’i’IiIE:vi’t’iii.jv’5i%ff=% in the

flue: c.-imnulm.’ :1 :1 .

alas-sea’; :m.’.?-3::.”‘*.

‘p’:’a:=,:«*:T:5y ‘i’5.i.€’?V’g’?’éf’iT§f5i§i§i6’if_ {R =:. ‘um-i”. Ii’.f’lWHiF%f: in ‘_[_?’i’€’.:”‘6.*.3 flit’, fiataei:

]_Ii”H_”§’§’:’i’ ‘l’i§§iiiC’.’; ‘En ‘ii_iTit’ A i’i’:i-ifrlii’ ?4’ii’l(?ie im= ifhte fin’?-i? (‘pf ii, flute 1-‘aahziimi

‘iui.:ii’i:ai’.r:;’i Iry’ iii;-5V’§’:’élise’3?i’i2a’a’ isa wiflmui; mni.ia.-:22 firs iilite ‘p-t:tiiim1e’r

V’ .s3’ei&5 :ii’:§:’ .*¢ia»:.:”li. ifiw, 1s«=e.i.’ii.im’:e=,*u- 1-mule’! 1112;:-2 iihut the i’§{iiii’fii

‘n–:.w-;ri.v:zi;v:s;: z’:’ui[iv.¢.1-fir-i.i.ér%:% wm_I’la-3 lmva: ii-na ha eewi:

6’5. ‘I’Ei:a+’a2+fi,vw:, Te;—:r’ii’TEu*.mi’ gga’v’iirg;’ imn i’he=; wéiia’fi:ii5.r mi’

§’rff#aa=’.’i’wis:=§e uf iiaiz ¢i=i*u.~vi”l’m’ a’!z’i=i’e.=-11 i’@.ff3:.fJ’,{fi)’I 5, film nrasiaa punt fiblrfli

B3,?’ ‘u’l’a’:e ‘}_¥?ii5iTi€b7’it?i’ ma éfirrt ni’lu_=;r 2esap:=ar:f:-1. chi” iiiw Tfi’lHii’i’.i’

rrrpim’§.fic¢1\t:a”1. A51 :m.1::1:ziwr.::’i 4-‘z’lmi.r-21., the ‘pcti1’ini1e1’ V:–‘-‘iE-Tl’i:Efi_i )fii ”

-5,3111: I’}i$iHi=.’t’ of tfiita imufi, ¥1’fi.li{;’]l. ]lfl{}”‘{?E€j1 :§.i1r:fizi;eia=.=’3 “2_»ff flu: V

(7=e;r–ev’g’ri:1-aafiivte I5~’im1}::, he ifh-‘2: writ! 2111?-:i.i<is3_r_1; "'fl1i: "E!H v'c_1..;' is s_=fi' I

A :h:)

fhav-3 nhis;i'u.e:.l im: 1a:.sa:iit:a11':ul _:ii':;g:111tf'in 1'-.5.-_«1}ir«::¢:i':"«.;_V)i*'v–.i:]ye$ saridv. '

p11aiysJ;ri§a- z:::n«fi uni: uni' ijhij :5-::i1:1¢e_,____nut'i::_'1* 'aV1_r:1r1U1wi:ir1iTi11gVFflua dues,
'rs '}i:;:'€m*.a'r;: }::~.i.£-3 "égaitiztsi }'_:::;'é.'s_?, 9.: tiigs L.'.'.!!EI' £:=.r1.-Tn 11:25
uni': pzwrittt-zixiii imn' :i_1s'a:':c::"f1:r:)_;fg1fi:3iiifi'1»::i5_ fiiii,'i'f?F;1I_fji*. H; "r iiiiqi"

flit: T1-!i1$_";flfl£IZ|'i"~ .x'.1r};5.Ti;i" Iuael i:&T1t:'1:v_::1f'iEf;' :(*:-xriizitéiii the: (:m'u_:l11Si{)1.I fimi:

flue, 'i.?ii'(T:i'I[!-?1'I;"~.V£'i!:3.E'!'§'s:f:'.: 1&9} 1:'iii3v:§ilUt been fiflluivecl by fllfi

Bm":E:.:Il'n:a:i; 111V1'i'E.s'aVi::;;1:i5.I_1,rA '§.'ii"f2'"i'?~s'_'v¢i§'=.';'."i-1:1' fliitf 51:11:}. No dm1'bi', aguin.:~;t.

€116: ut:iEzj;1i ,i';i_'l-ifmi. '"'é5§i{:' " 'I'a'l::ai'lrjla'i', the 1H".fitiiiIIi"lt";fl' Jami

'["t1'i3fif':T["'1'n';'-[-1 {"119 ":fi'EVT'L',%i'. 3,_l.'I:V:['Vi'L..§-§,"5:-I. lyiefoita the Assi.~st.uut (.'x'1-'uiiiliiss,-.::i{1rm:1'

V ' 'iR7l§5'ii.?:ilziiiitiiii'§',Eg[{i'!iEi'iZ flea: 'g%i:i_ii;imu:r in Vitihf 0f the rnfittr dmfrd

"'~?E__ia: i__ire1i.iin~nmv= iflueitezifiiri' p'1i3l'en'i=,fi flu': :nev:i-éaiml

iuafa '£113-é": It.':ji'?€Ji'..fii'i flit? ifiifiii n1 ihc: '1)i:i:ii1u1.1t:i' "by" u1u1'it:'r :'::.m=;i':'

._,*'__,K_- _.-_, it _ _ _._
3i'q'–~:fi'-11-i*::%.¥~%-2: £,}€i7i_ii." {:a":=::::e1.-1-:-a::.;::t::'. 213:: !}2e1mi.g,r '._."'Id':!.:!.!!}.-EI§}%%,|.Ll«!–!-_I:!o-.

[1 . 1

'~?.3:.:5iK){§. '§'l.'u.-un1'tg'l'i flit: A:-:s%i::i'.uu_1i. C-(3il1Hi'i§-t:-'§i3.fiIi,'Iif'i' and the

§l')c'p'uzi'y ('?41a1v1ru|Ii:<a:4'inaijt'::* have faker: 11011:: of the ifiviiifiilfifiil put

flr1'i'.'l'u 113,?' fllii ggfiai ii.-1(r1';.:;:1; fili? fl-act '1't:Tlil¥1'i1'|S t'}mt t.i'w_e elsiiir: ififlllfl

(i

hingfi,==z nu flit? fémié ilmt 111:: Ievctmle H'EIt.'.~A4i'i:$)'il',ii73VH"in}?!-iifiii '

]"I1i1If'f–ii'_¥€Jii":i3 in 't?uV'L';!';~'£t: i']u: 'il'I1f?'|.!'€'?ill'i,!C rmiztitt:-1 on flit.-."'gi't:1ii";fl flit1t V

:-;iu'(:ié 2.am.::i1t'lii1g' in i'1n:':u1, int". 1i%(j?.]iI'ifii!t§liiCV"-E!f' ifhfr; t

tlniierl 1F).2.f_?.{J01 w::i:=.: nut. 11iétv"=i;:y tli(§"BHI11§ Vib'1!E'.A"Ii"':A:i:~v ..i3,:i'Ein.gi11g'. . L'

the '9-:ir_pea':'iy' in mile,

E}

i . :"1.'=; Aa3i1t':a_1:i3&""' m'_sifi-

L1i_1::t.im:. i)’iE’tf!i:::3’fl¥!\ ;-nuri’ .i;’I:}: Wqigifiglixttfijiikni” iiim (:i’i”i’fi’fi¥.i.’l’ is in

“Em ib]’lo1ve«l~.Iwj;—t§§.a_§2 1’7.’-iib—-iJ3’f’1fA§i:?’%!li.i’1’IV(:’. Bfifilk tin qiite-.=:tirr:u: ever’: if Hm
said :§’.f.’TiI*(.’:’I’.”l’ti’Vl’ iE’V..if§’1¥i§’.jJifli§’i.. _’!nsu.’r’ar as flit? Si’l’ItDl!’I’Ii’. being

1ti:{rr>v:=,1t:d_ ivy iii’:-tj i”a2?H”n3ej—.._¢_3iifl’ aim) a portinu of flit…’ mmmnt

1:-t’é;E:;gv’;’_3_ui:l in»I’1ui:*t;%i*:«:is;%rl’.1il-t: i’)W,I’l(3’i’ is um’. in di-:+jp11i’ur:. ‘l’l1t: only

.. , An_1l..i5i?&%f_i:i’;:ifi i37l;.i.,-:f:’E.:fE.r1t:, is $154 in xvlxetlltsr flue C.’-G–1)’p’cl’t–ii.ivr: Bmllr;

‘_fihe_=. }}’_iii’_{#:’fi§,T in sale was 1t~.qI1’i’1u3fl in i’i’rfl’l1’sw the

_a.i ._.

fin: jrzikititiuiy in szifitt amai uz.-4 ii’: ‘w”i’ zui , = ”

‘]}’§ii;’;l’1 iixllsvweti Irv ihe brynnk am?! that xviriiiri issave to in:

5s:’i:a\verrLl by the 1:»:-111%: iifielil AS smefih, lilac ‘l’£ih:~3’ildH’r at the

fimi: imaiaiaira: wuss vi’ the v,ritaw’ tlrmiz flit’. pi” ‘.’fidIl’ft’ has not

‘iat:a:1r1 .5[-:i’vi’E()’1-*1ri3i§, ‘me: :’.~.1′;_r[_91’1ipfiilikt gritsirif-r11i’:t: Séiiiriétfllji £153.?-96; ifnrfijn.

gm iiirze ‘I”:_12E asailiiaa’ to :i::s==1.1e: amii 7&4. ‘:m”” “<'i111§' 4 his 'ilncv .'1ré:'i:i'i.i-trxi .rfwi'vi:-w'r.

tflfifi flat: 'E1a2.aii;1s: t.:u'm.*e':=.nia'-;i'i z-and afi'm5'a;vrri3_siflefiii.;g

.i'i.i:f: -1 .*r£-.'{i%' ~15 iiit _

fi):~ifi'a; by fliurim ::2;itirta'iii llfatée 1.-1-'r:V:_1'ie=,%. _ in flit':.;7{s.:ng:.ii1efiii5:ii'"mléé 1v:ay '

Iiizws-r': $353.1: ai.§_i]_'13'iif;"i}J.Ii1f§ ;iii* 'i :2: 'p .V

filfi smjat: .I1:-as 'E'rz:i%'u. .fi?'[§iii5é€Ei'§~.i:if7? "i'§.1_'( 1_u~'nak.§i§'- 1119i'. Tli:)1,ig1:u the

'E':v:'i1.:«;iTiair:a::' .I.§3é:e J£f¥';#fl{'ji§7IE?ij .]ii'm?a:a1.I1ii:, film z.ajp1rcliai.fi

:a1uil1mtii._v sh; :;=:.r*%'?;i,'Vi gm" ij'§i_c. " ieai%.r1a:.2'l m:1i'i"ur1Tiiy Liam: no-i:

Vii flit'? ;n1&aii::1' irni: hm; a'ml_1; 7I_tc:_':11

i,T'-i'1i!,lE%'§5:.V§.i'3li3§3- 4'

g'g1i'iifl:'::i 133! film iiafi. il';:i:§; é'a'*-.i_éi'.i9t:1' Tliizii 'in:t:iz'; iisestiiefi by 'the: lvmik

s-'a_'I'1t'E..' 'i*in§3 "y-iei.éiizi:.i_z€i* .hzi=_a"1 :.s.i:Ei.:.%€i on fire eairuie, in vimv -uni" flriw

'l'}s.e:'ai":.iim2 1:11:13!' my iihis; g11i'r'l1i.'1ii3,, iha': e'r':flei%: dz:.i'fis'i.

'H..';l.i){P:'¥, '.l':%~'}.r'i:%(3{3-='i- saris} '!'i2.C¥!{}{}.'f3, ur}_'2ii_:l1 um iu1pi_1g:1mi at

i'§ina:::~e;11'u.'t::awF!; 3*} anti'? F :+"a'm Q1131-:fl.it%afi. (':4)'ilfla'di[I,'lt?i'lflj?', flli:

1::

,’E’f3Vi:Ifl.!t? cmiiu-3r__ wliiath xarasa c-;=.nft:1n=.(1 in tl_:g¢__ _i’:z:;1nia “ui’ tliw

u
L

La

>-

.

1’i’heii§-v’ in fin? fijfifnii 16151. 1 $11_s}i1tij;i’:it3ic”..

iirifirra in ‘flu: ‘l]’IHi’i’l1t*I–I’ &ai’ai:t7«i’i eiiitiiin: if tiit’;3r_ t.€I2a.=%:Jsr3Vi0 iilifiziie

fliI’i’lj(%I’ m.-iimi in flit: :t:i’a~…ju:r:°.

….. .. « f[.m,_§’q§