High Court Karnataka High Court

New India Assurance Co Ltd vs A S Raju S/O Late Swaminathan on 23 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
New India Assurance Co Ltd vs A S Raju S/O Late Swaminathan on 23 January, 2009
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao S.N.Satyanarayana
IN?§HEHKH{COURT{fi?KARNATAKA,BANGALQRE

DATED THIS THE 23% my OF' JANUARY, 

PRESENT

mg HGBFBLE MR. JUSTICE.:§{';3REE§§f§AI§. fifigég,  V '

AND
THE I~ISN’BLE MR J::sTiQ;;:….$,N.%%s _’rYA§’§Ariz;A’;f,M§A
M.F.A. N0.44n£3.32g,30%3%{MX4%’ ii

<3/w M..F';A. rqo.,4.2 1¢2%/2:303 C WX
AND M.F.A .rm:1ss 15/200:3 c m»)

nmza. Nc.MQo;%__oc§;

BETWEEN; % ‘

Nmv §:§TDLaT%5jss{;:eANc:: C(“}’LTD
no 930.111, Mfi;HAL;AX_?yi’i-CHAMBERS,
No.9, M.G,_ §&QAD’;A4B;mx3;&L=0RE 1
BY ITS MANAGER ”

V 2 APPELLANT

(BY 7SR£——()’ MAHESH, ADVOCATE)

A%&%Af¢D% – %

1% A S’i%A.3’U
sjm;’ATfE SWAMINATHAAN
~AG;_E.’ 43 YEARS
x R,/*0 NO. 19, M.R.S. PALYA,
MNDIGURGA ROAD, BANGALORE 46

” ‘ma MANAGENG DIRECTOR

” _ Bhifiéviflfim. A» ” ~~~~~ ~ =

Si§1’A:S’»–§§9;’\§’

NAN:>:1;iURGA RQAB,
.% Bi:?E§§SCN TGWN ?OS*’i’
” BANGALORE 45

M13. RAVINDU MOTORS PVT L’I’D.,

N.25, CHORD ROAD,

09?: ISKON TEMPLE, , %_ %

RAJAJINAGAR INDUSTRIAL “S’i5BUI§B _ -. ;

BANGALORE 86 A j

RE’S}5*Q_ND}3N’7{‘S*..
{BY SR1 K T GURUB£i:§k’A.P£2AS.4;D,.A;::x§{)CA’i*E

FD¥%:’-R1… ‘ %
SR} 3 N PRASHANFH QHANDRA, ADVQCATE FOR
SR: A M RAMA¥A1%i,. .Am?f CATE3 F0183 R1}

THIS !\£E”A_ ‘_-IS E1L13::;s 1;/~S§y,:7:2:{:) 0;? mi AC’?
AGAINST i.:f11E;A;T’LJuD’ms:;ENT%% jAN}f}”””‘AWARD DATED:
2 1,3.20{33? PASs§:;{3_ fi”~§—.fj§.§”‘;;»–‘€,_’.{‘ N11). .1′?8O /2001 SN THE
FILE OF THE A.”1Z_)£)I;;.¢JUDC§§€*3, COLIRT OF SMALL
CAUSES’,” ME:MBE:3;~2, T¢§ACfP.g””BANGALORE, gs<:C:H–12),
PA12'r1;§r _ 1!xLL<;)W.zsz1NGe<«V%VM';a::Ira: I CLAIM PETITION FOR
coMPENsAT2<:)N«.. .

m.1«*,Au._rIé);z;2_:.g,:gAI&2%e»s)3:L%k

/o%«LATk3SWAMmATHAN
ACE-ED m01;T 42 YEARS
R/{LI NE}. 19, MRS PALYA,

APPELLANT
(BY SR1 ‘K T ‘3\_’U-RU DEVQ QRESP! D -, ADVOCATE)

ANS

%/

my sm: 3 N ?RCsSH’fit~IT&=§ c:+-mamas, A9v<)i::;§;éf§g~;;~%

ANS

1

A.PPE}gL25§W?

ME. A s RAJU
S/0 LATE SWAMINATHAN
AGED ABOUT 40 YEm::s5″

N019, M.R.S PALYA ”

NANDIDURGA RQAB 3
BENSON TOWN’ 963′? f
BANGALORE 46 L ‘ L

M/S NE§V.jNvDIA;_ASS{§iR;§NCE «:”;:<;:s:«'
90.122, 1~;e£A':j;;«;L,s,1:+3§: 1’ A ,.

R1E¥P’B¥’}TI’SV;T3RflSIG.NAL”?+’£ANAGER
~ RESi3′{)NDEN’1’S

(B3? S121 G.%§m=:E:%sH”; ADVGCATE FOR R2,

sax K “T qszeuggg a-_ Pmsmm , %§’§%%’0CATE FOR

R1)

mifs 1~2i§*A IS FILED U/S 173{1) OF’ MV ACT’

».;;G A;1%:~qTs+1?j’A%T’£–:§«: JUDGMENT Am) AWARD DATED:

21′.3′,_2.{}S3″‘~vP&$SED ZN MVC NO.1780{208I ON THE
FILE ‘ 01? XLI ADDL.J{}13GE, MEMBER, MAST,
coum’ v–£:)F*SMALL CAUSES, BANGALORE [SCC§-I~«12),

}?A.”R”i’LY_ “LALLOWING THE CLAIM }>§:’rm0:~: FUR
” e .Q(ZR.’I§’EN’SATION.

“¥. Thése appeais coming an for ardcrs this day,
SREEDHAR RAG J., dciivered the foliewing:

%/