IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALQRE
: PRECS E£:"\!'l" I
THE HON'BLE MR. JUs'_m!:.;; N.:{'§"i>'.A?r:a.""'
:'>m'i'~::':> 'E'I~ Ms W; 1: 2 1_;)m-" or 1):"~:<§9.._
THE HON'BLE MR. JUs'1':¢E._B.sREEI----{jgj; ;z;§g()5
B E'l"\-'V ESE N:
1.
iii _
E'{a.1;cia E.-.%;\?f.§_;'1.2__I'11. j'
W' / 0. z'1'12"7"ia'~' S2-1. lit,
Agogl"'e-iE.)4£>1__:aVEv-9:34 yg-a__1"*s'.-;..V
.~NE-'l'i«fi,I7. '- "¥:.-
:_5+;/0,19;-:»_--a_u_:V §.:3;.§i')'.«._ '~___ _ _
:7\g_{é.*§'1 21$ >01 :.Ef ~ .1 9» ya! rs
Ye1.s*m i I121 Vi 3(jg1g_11":
1 ' 'DA/<3.lsam;-:i'I.'
' ,f\_.L_;.3;('-xi z:1!')('.V
. E3/'()x.'iS~I1'1t'U1, E4 _\4-'0;-11".~s_
t'3{=°*'é1? 1:
*~ SA/{0.Esr11a1iI.
A';,2;c(Ti aE.')0ut' E2 _\,!'Gi'2.11"S'
F;12:;;1I .
S/0.Es11z;xiE.
i\;__>;d 21139111 E(.)_\_,m; '
10.
S11:1E')§:)1:.
S/<'1.1.~s111z.11}.
Aggcci 2123011! 8 _vc'-'e-'11'.~s.
:'5\l}1('C1'L
I.)/1.1.Is11'12.1i1.
i\§{t'(.i ;1i:)01.1': ("S _\,'(?a1'S.
"1'.(T}.&$11a1ik II')1*z111i1'11s;1l11?b. "
S/u.('.3e1i1J11 Sz'1111'-E.).
:'§;§c(¥ '.1bo11! 73 _vc;11'ss.
K}11a1ma.1r1.11'11": E555-121. 'V .
W/<'3.SI'1;-111-1 lE')1'e11':i1'11 Sz;'111é*}::)v. -
i'\§.{C(i e'1b0111 (SO 'Vz.§x21:'s.;*' ' '
{'1'I'1c-' 1'1e11'1'"1c <1!' t'.l'1c': f'c'¥.I'}1f"' E"'f)§' 1I_11~.['--
2"" £11.);'xtI.Ev.21.11t i.,'1V_v*.$ii1_1.1w1_1 «V
as 'I'.(f',«Si'11- jjk §1:i::1'z'1l;;1i1:1.r'i S'z:-1I"1"cii_3-- ..iv11§7'f':'1:;1(i
I"1s_111é--1il zu1u:i_ e.kp1)('.__1«--ie1;n15a V
. "11-' int') .§:1,1'c 1'12 1"1'11">'1" :--.+1 1'J1.J:'13§§('1 1!'1_i'(i 1')?'
E 101 :* 11z1.'1'{ .1:'."i1T2_'-1'f' 111'1'1'11.1'_}1'e.--.--'_1* *
é.'11j1("i 41.3.12.-1--1'(I'i:1:11V E. 5'; up 1301 1 2-11 1 1)
. All eL1a1"<* Vlv'</ £511; "'1"}'1:';p1:)e'111e11'1a11li \.="i11;1§gc.
K21 1'1'12'1.s';;"1.1'1.1.1'1dm1:1 a 11 _fg11'}:3(%i. 'I"'2'1'1'111<..
Iioie--:.1j f7-)i_.<st'i'1'1'1_ ---- E563 10?.
... i7*1f.)})(.']le;1 1'11' :4;
{A1711-' E511.I?i;f$§eA1;,§L'ssl'1\\'211"211:1pz;1, 1'\(§\--'0<'aI:_%)
" 1.} .R;'11'1gga"11'z-11').
S / (1.Vv1'1l~;21! (.'r5E"1\1-'z'11'e'.1 1 1.1.
7%" liilcx S1'1111\.=';1..~s21 R210 'H'1s::1";1:1(*C (30. I-1C]..
2"" F1(')('):'. Door §\E().(.3--E..}--~ 18.
A rt 1 :1 {"101 pct .
(}1:..111i1.1}" (f,'i1y 8: D:'.'~_st:"i("t. V --
A1'1('i1':ra 1'-31':-1c.k:-$511 S1;1I(.= ---- 1322 ()():2._. . --_ «
.
H.-3)’ Sri.B.C.Sc(>t!1e1m:’112-‘1 I{}4.I_(5:..{\spo:1s(.’*(:’i \vi’i”iu1_iM»,/(;_ <1a{i.€'_d'€5'}–.71 1}2()()E;)}
'l'I"1i$ MFA is Fstmi.'{J/:'3"' :1'7;.3g_LT1")."_';;i'_'Mv Am a;__{aiz'1.~.s1
I110 J11<1__a_;'mc-*:'1:=.A:'1('1 g.\\'-\'=a:i(f} E\3a.;«i'»:,§(i: V'_1£§"."1;'.2()()(T$ 1:):-15:-;<.'(1 in
§\/IVC N().22f2'i:')(}%£– (.)I"i_ 1'1;c—~f:'El(E==.<i'E"f1"}1(§___CiviI .}E..:('1§_.{c {E3:".I.):1].
Mcmix.-2' A:’ L;*t3′:1i’}’)é%:1s:i.’i»f§>11′ :=1.1is(1 “;~5L*t.*i<i11g__§ c-*11h2=u1(%;’__1 1’01” §§vu1’i1:g’. 1l1i..=; (1z1_\’.. N.K.
PATIL. J_._ . L.l_pl i\\.»c:1-xii T?’1′{¥–§f()l}1_3\\:i1’1;§:
J U D G EV? E21′
fi’E.}is V2-i,§._)i.g’,t’éI1 by the (“M111″);-111159 is di:’0C1.(:t(:1 2–lgéxizlst
ihgf }1:dg_{I*t’:.;:’t”11 e.m(.E 2’1w;11″(1 (:121¥(*(i 16″? J2:1.m.1zu’_\;’ 2005..
;.)21:s$éé;i3i1″: ;’\«’1.\r’.(.,7.N<).2i3/2(.)(.)5i, my 1110 C3:'\.*iE Jz.1(.};.j
{S_r,E3f)\?::.}. EV{<.*n'}i.3c=-*1". 2'-\cic'!it'im'1e11 EVIot0:* A(t<*i:’1E (312-1i1’1′::;s
.._..T1’ibt1n:\I. f\’.{‘}.f¥’.. for ;-:Im1’1. °’I’1’iI:):.1:1:.:E’ } 1’01”
MMHWWMMM
J
1-‘*1’11’1z’111(‘(~1’m’1’11 01′{‘o111pc1’15z-‘1§1911 (>11 §’1″1(‘ ;.§1’111111(“1 111111.. £111’
(‘1)1’111)(.’11$z.1{1011 111′ Rs.s.Z3.37.(.)()()/~ aw;-11′(1c1’1 in 1”;1\'{.)111f___111’ 1110
<*1z11111z'11'11s ass z'1.<_{2-1i1'1.<;1 111011' <*121im 1:11' 1&5.18.()(}~jI'z1..1:{'1–«1§';. is
i11e:('11'q1121I"(.*.
2. “1”11(* z;’1p;..)c*-11;1111.<.s 1 10 8.–<%1*;1»1111 1151 E')cj11"i*;1:.c,.;j \\1–*1§"sj.i',z-.11'1:1
v1'11'1c'11*c1'1 zmd ;1ppo112:111.~'s 5-) 21111.11.' 13f)"c1:11111'1__ ~1o, 1'f1.g:;'~..1v11V1t?_
p2u"e1'11's (11'(:1('(%c'21Sc–:c1 SH. 1..~'s.1411'1"a.1.A1'1 S113). '\*«.-11j1('3. (i*i.g~E1"'i11 1.1117
1"()2;1c1 i1"21ffi<"' 21('('1'(1c1'1t 1* 1.1111 ()§.T'("1'1E711f:(T£1V ?:.1' 2'11)o11'1"~1:~()£) P.1\/1 1111
1)’/”‘T–()4–2()()41. (‘”)1’1 I’11c’1S:.11i'(11(:’1.1{111;’* z-1_.1′:1’1-1f_i».i.11″1′;7. 1116’ (i(‘.(.’Lf£’EF5(:'(“1
12–ztc I.._\ve:1s:e Q11′);'<{1fdi'1.1;§f1_j%~<"1\r{:'2-1315; Rz:111z11'1'1;1{1121ge:11'
011 1'1v11.%{"'29ig:j;»f<'1c.*1§:f:-I 1"W;11'1:.~.11 '11'(V 1'<'etc1"1c.'('1 E11 110111 (11
§\/1i11'1£'E111{1i§%1IflI]:1i.fT$i*1{?$-' 1\/T1.11'$.., ;.~1§ 111211 1111111 1111" ('11"i\–'01' 11 by its c11’1v(-:1” 111 2.1 1″z.=1.1>21sscc’i 1531112-111 $2113. 1-19; 2.1 1*w.+1111′ of w11i(.*11.
1″1(;.-»._s11sI…;111’11.>(1 1.’)1c-*1-’11i1’1;;’ i1″1w§111’ius.s 11111.1 S11(‘.(‘El1’1’11I3(“‘(1 to 1111.’
s;.111’1(“. vxy11i1c-.r 1.11″1<,1c*1" 11"c*e=-11'11'11=1"11 111 1111-' 1i(J:=:e}")1l.z.a1,
3. 011 2-1(.*co1.11’1i 011.110 (‘1cz1I’1″1 of 1111? c1c(‘«;:*:.1:-:.c’~(1. I111″
.. _zi’1:1’3}.11-111u.1″1t’:5 filed 1110 c’1z11r111 ;)c1’iI’i{“;1’1 1)c§'{11″1′ Shv ‘1’1″iE..)1:1’1211
<1
8. in 2-my :\E;:1ic):’1z1li:_z;oc1 0:” S:-1uh(iz.1k>(i I-%21nEa. {ill tI’1c}.=’
2-mz’1in 1n21_§(.>1’ity and 2.1 sszam oi’ R;ss.2:’3′{)()()/_:.__ \\-*E1’11
p:”0;’)m’1i(‘>1″1aI'<'* ilIIL'E'('S1 51121}! bc iwpr in E'ixv('1 §"_V)Vt.";::)_'<".;sji"t._in
the neu11c of Ehv first z1}')1'):'r1I;:1m in 2.1:"1_\;' N-3:1'i(;iJI21V}i;:'c%L.l.
SL'.hCdt11c:=1*iud-‘(‘>”I”i–‘i.\jc -V i’_;’-‘1’écw;-115£(.> b
b}»’ z.’::’1()E’.1″1L>:’ f’ivcr yc211″:.~’;. willl lVibvi*–I__\;”. 1’c>=s°o.1’\=’:-*c.i«. I’V(–}_ ‘£’i1V”‘s~¥.V
a’1}.);)vIie11’1t I0 \v£111(i1″2:\.v E110 ‘}’).4L>”Vi’vi'(b)(]i(“&’1i’-.if}?£:?,1f.(fSI KL)i:}Wall tho’
flxcci deposit”
,.
Fhc 11-‘Ina:-1i1’1:’:’1g As1:LI’:1; e.1.1′ “. RS.2=Ii-.é%(‘i)()/– wifh
p1′(.:’;p<")1"1i():T1a}–:.*'*«i;iE.–c*1'¢:§sE 1::-';1:1.:Z.'111'<«. }'.:§'('~ "'1'L'.1_§i§1SL"(i in llu.-'c_)t1:' of
é11.)p(.'1I2'.ii'i{S"1.,..::f(") z-11:'§:'§.'iV' t5(;:1._{£I pm}.)o:"t'i<)n.
(f5§f'i<"e I 0 1': 2 , £- E'\\f& i"1»»'('§.~." éE("f("()1"(§ in 54'!
-“I …..
JUDGE
Sci/-~
JUDGE