High Court Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka vs Prakash Babu Kammar on 29 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Prakash Babu Kammar on 29 July, 2008
Author: A.S.Pachhapure


{Exit 3:. yéamzgg–c.3 ee?V
£2; ‘E’§€%3:- E–EEGEE ciszgm’ 9%’ §{.a.RNATAs;2s5_ 2′
CEEQCEEE’? ggwcg AT m«§ARwAB 4′ .’
%”_’;A’E’E§D ‘§%~§§S mg 29% 339;’ Q?

BEF{)RE A 1

‘§’HE: §§{}N’BL¥3 §e1R.x§{}i’$”‘§T:E:{§.§’;, 55;.$I}3%¢$C}{A£4£v%%f’§¥§§’}€’ii»~
cagmzsqsgg ;%PPE{\.i…,«x§§5’Q.€§21ii%Q€}? ._. %

EETWEEEQ:

$’m’:’§ 55* KA§i£N’E’£x_E*’;z% ”

yr E-EALEYAL POLICE. – zgyygggam

gm»! $23?’§~:.£’;=¢:;fi–‘.:~+;zA§;:1:$§’;:”3–z_. :>:r;f::::»_§>;= _

APSE: 1 __ M
3;. E5?-153332; Bast?

g<:;;3::;3§ Ymgs, *
A<:";§£E£."§3.§LT'{}}"€§$'§';v

, $§%;A:=4§BA;%:";§;é;:«s::;*~g:;;r~§":*5; %;AL;YAL§§AR,

._ 2 A
' _ A<;:E::35 iffx"ElAf72IEf':, Ba,?$s:%~:";s«:*,;~:x-3

' " §}:,'% V§':';£Le§k' E:'}'§fii§.-§"?fi;%?'i E;2'%XE»%;z%?€E~Z;%LEYfi;Li{g%E3

W

€§E'::3'3~.T'g*'§':»?a §*.Sg'~f?;';'_.€}T¥

fig; $§§fi2*,'gzégLE;"sf':«<:s: 23$-'SA£'€T§~§ E<;%£*J§I*=:iAE,
éfiisi–:";3-5%» §_{E§2,.~:%{:§, $32133 aaagzzn

;%:,:;§<:: _?:«'a._c§§:§gA;A::gp;:,
' . *::£;3g;K::éAL:¥A;. : E£EZ1SPQ§*é{}§',§'€T$

" §$?.§{K:S§+:é.SE§EKE§M€ S§%$'§"'{, A::'::v.;

THESE £fRE§’J§§?€Ai~ A?PEA§,- ES FELEE} RENEE? SEC-‘§’§€}?€ 3=?”E% {E} 8:2

” ‘ – “{3} €3EP.C, ?R%’:{EI’§if,% ’30 {_”§RA}’é’? LEAVE; Ti} FEB ;3:F=§ E%P§”‘s’£.£’–*-.L §1€_’§A§§’€$T

TEE éL?E”}{}?:»’I§’£§*E’Z’ ST, 3.1.295}? PASSED BY ‘§’E§§§ {E§’«§§L JUEEGE, {&§;. ENE}
52: :.}’%e€l*7′{T2 EE§aLE”§;%L, Eifi CRWEENAL C335 N{).,2é8;’2{}G6e é&CQUE’E’E’E§’§G ‘§’§{E
RES?f3%5E3E§’§TSfA{f{f’L§SE§} E. ‘§'{f} $2 99% ‘§”E¥E:7; 5.}?-‘%”EP*€CES ?;’L¥,«”$’3CZ3,
3-‘$3,335, 50% 52: }.G’§-3′ Pjiée’. 34» (:3? WC’

Cr}. 3-3. ;’€@,521 ;*-.20e3:?,

mgg KREEAENAL ;a?9§:.a:, z::{;szv::§~s@ or»: §:::>§ §.§£;fi;R3.j2~;<_}.__i ~:1':s::$.

EBAY, TEE C'i}U§'§" EEELEVEREQ TEE FGLLQEWENG:

&U§)G»%v§E:%%’3′

“€116 State hag pmfemfad

acquifial 9%” $23 msgonfiexzts f€::’;t, £i;:e o§1’$::z<:;:::sV.fi*-:31d;é:' S%:C'§im:;;S

323, 34:, 355, 394 ~§;.3:;<:; :::"a£m-§':::; V fs4_o:' §?C;'~

2. ‘E13 {gem raievafif €92’ this 333963.} are

as uniigr:

ea privata camplaint EQ
{£113 JPQE-§3’C;’:, alltzgiizg that 0:: ISAJZQQ6
aft. abeui i’E.._7§G;V z~”::’:;3;.4; he awn: E0 31% pe’=:,reE hiifik 0:: big

matégr C:§?{:£6& éhass. acausgd in ffifiharanca sf ihéiii’ fiammozz

.A _~;;;;:c{:;:.::.§;;,.%a;§’::;;s;e& 311131 3:35: him with the hanés am am me

afiiggr V’a€€f:1S€:i”‘VéauSe€§ izigtigation aizé that $36 gamegs

§1€§f§)§?v~.§Ii§$§§’€E}Ed afifl rescued him; Ea farther aééfigag that

€E2§:_. ac€*:=;a$:::d gave iihrea’: sf zéamgsr £0 213$ 13% and “a1’£im&’£$}}~*,

#33: :9 ma ?a§§{:€ Station. 311$ 33 {he 3?? was an

u éuty at Bhatkai, his sampiami W33 :30: réaeiveé

331$ :23 Vifitw Q? the pzaéééiaal infiusnca $11 {ht acmisefi, Em fail’:

$123: the: Paiim Wfiéiiié Em: gmpszigg” émzastigaiéz {Em mafia: €3Ii{§

am. A ;%é.z-3;23,.;T’:;§_.{;«:;_?;

‘ii%:m”€:f::zr’:t, ap§:’0a{i%3€{‘: €316 Es«’E2’zgéSi.raf;$ EE~’§.{§’,§ :é;;'”‘€%::1§:;;:.’=§a§.%:;i

‘aEIEéi’:3″ Ssciian 28% C31: The Saiil €:Om.§}3i3E?;~’Z é~.%::fe:’ré§i” ‘

far .i}1v€S€5;ga1ié0n ggtzd a cha:”g€s1:1i:e€,c.am_:’ {€)’ 3}é: §§11€f3″£Zi’g§fi3%3;S*§’§:’

‘aha accused! rfiapmlfisnts.

Eéuring {Em ma}, the ;QrQs%i2::i§,irm e§é53;r:2é_:1.€£i §?’%3!3. E {:3
18 am} $31 Eheriz” evidaziztsfiggé’ m;:;;::§£ér:%_”E’§§§::E:._E?’.3 ‘£9 ¥’.f:”§. The

giaiémfini; of theAactcussé.x$:€–§7e’§f€c9r:1€*{%. i:::«fiétr Secticn 313

8119.9. ‘§’h§j;V ‘tbig ‘V£§efé{uc§€”{2:§”t3?;aI émziai 3116; have

gm’: E58; 5a ::s§aff,.::%§:>f€%§ié;.5:_ r:f§?ir§.€fi;§$f’V The ‘§’réa1 {§’x:’:1′:r’€ ma

ap}3r€a3§;:é–“:£<32:: 0% tha'x:f:a€e§3}é".é..Q;: mcard, £iC{}}_1§.i'§:f:d {ha acéatussé

anti aggrieséeai {'33: figs: {E26 Stats: hag p:*€f€z'*§%:s:§ éffizés

2 …..

‘»T4′.<§:a§%e"~..h$a:fl mg: Eaagneé Gavergzmaai. gieader far

fif:'a,_$ i;<:te_, ."§"E'.%;3A{",.c:2;:1";:$::?; fer figs ;:*§sp@11<:%i:ms is abasnfz.

A3 fig cmzéd he sééfin fmm the recemg; {ha iremplainfi

j§:': af this iziaififiné was fésd 13:: 1€éé4;280§, iihmzgfirz fihé

éiisxiqicfii is said its Exam €3C€211§"i"€:d on 13'4.2Q06x '§"E';;£

ccmpiaifiazzi ofisrarzi some sxyfiazzaiian far flag»: (E6333? in the

C€)Ii};§§.&§f3.§ @963 gm? say 311jy"'{%f:1':3g in his fi'§?i{§.fi{§{Tt3 bfifefés '£315

uh

C-3:}; A. 343:5: :.;":::m?§

{Baum Efé is; raifivazzt to 301:2 $313!: {hem is 3 (15133; ..,~=':r§-' :i£_iéi'}*:~: ,:':;._

Eaxigézzg the cmpa};§:1t 331% {ha Saié ::ie}.a§;V__hLas.; ééfgfii 4¥;x%§e;{–: _« 9

pmgefly €X§)§3_’;i}€T{§;¢ it is 0311:;-‘ <:%3§v.'5vi{%':i:.;§:§«_{}€"E"§'§?' ié

avafisfsle an mcem fm' a§pre:r.ia€i%Q;3L.. '§"}';Qz:gh.E;.ié 'ii; " 53:;-ji{,:i"a%§'~..

have sugéaifieé 'ziéx: éyzjzzzfées, '.222:-*:213 fi%3"1£._ e:s;§aé".3i:i:;:{% hf; ighfiv
Saizior 332$ %f§:»:~:rfi is f:ié::,_ mes:i:Efa7i ..£:vié::*:1<?e %<§"'s'5:':£§2§01"1; are
v'€*:§"$;§03": sf Q25 camgkkzzizgzazgii; '?~Ex:3 Jé3Ef%;é1",AA_':3§§%::' "_'§;£7i§1-ffi€S5S€S émvct

s;a§;}<}rE{~:{1 figs: $%%;rs%.§:'§.L' PQEEE, as fa}: 33 the

zsaasazafii azzéii a}f;'u;.s1<:."'is_ <::{3:::!:;e}*:1§"::?._. V"§_':'}1§:. '§3s*o$€<:*a:iian axamizzfiaé

P'W,4 :vjw§; o _ ::23.a'£.< ~?€§a,V: _ Acstisagé Eaéca/% afisaziliseci 331%:

<::a3mpZ$§3i:a3:z:.V1%£§€}: ':::%ia§:e§Ia%s;.~ E: is net {£252 case af fiht:

Cofifipgiaigzaiiiz. {E133 'V§1€A'–'§x?a:*3"»LVassa11§%:£d $3}? ;%C<f'i1S€{i ?'~§0..% Wifii

chV_:§§3;}a;;1_;_?9}k R?%¥£'$t»"'h.a;s__¢1zee:: '{Z"€i3?L€{§ as hsesiriitt and as mgaxrés

' 131%: ..,ab-3.57:3: baafing with the hanfis, 333 £053 ms': suppafi

~*:3::i:–._:se_€"é§:%_:z.__a}S',%;'é*:€ press-a.:~*1€%{3;1 33:5: fiaemfgrs, his widazzca is;

9?? ''f3.:::} Ei;_é:1g:s. fa preve 1:135 incidsnt. PW6 fig azjmsihar wim.€:ss

£10 @351' 5:33:53 that $236 aceugaé aagazzlisd E1313 camigflzaizgafit

:§?§t§§*«_.ihe cézagspaig afid figs eviéencfi assf PW,5 is §EE€fiE2SiS§€I1§

'4;§§§E1 the evésdagfazza 53f $53.2 51:15; 30 3.130, {E16 p:*0S&c'*.,:fim".:

" 'imaiad ?W.$ hastiig anfi is": {ha @033 sxaminaiiszx 135; {ha

£122. £5 2«;c},52;,g-'2_§;@?{

girasacutiam ha iieés Q0: ggrsaz Witfi mgagfi E0 %§:s:%.¢.;:g;_'%;;§3§s:¢:%.'a§i::¥.V

assault by {he {yzher acaiustai mzii ?,.§};i'$i'{§f{}}f€, '€'.ii:{§_~€.3;':§%.Z?§ V'

€§3;€S€ Wimafisas as Wefi ii; <3?' z:c§"E§;:eE§'3 . ?'LQ f3€_':gI'§'§"§}§%lT£?§;'€é:i~~ '§f.§'1*E:'

vazgien sf PW.2. ?Ws.é 311% 2?} t}1é7::_x£}§::'::' §§§?€} {?}s'i¥»§5e?'§L?.iv1§::S';'S;fvS~_

am 313:'; Ems:-£36 313$ fizey {Ea §}{Z%§__":T§3'";T%'5§§01*;.'§i Vé:§:?::–.;1r";f§*s;_:s::§'c:Vi§:'%"§@;ai. £1; 'V

the circumsiazzares, fi'X{?{'}f}{ 3f5"3§.€fH<?L._=;§f E3'§J.'2-,: §;%§:$z*€ ES :29
€.v}1d$:1{:€ a: gig ta :?0r;'Q59§§a§:' %. vemian {If 2%}:
{2i3m§}}§iifl&E}.'{. 3 4.':£:'j5::.:<i::_ am eééher {ha
aiiesiéng .:%Zfd" ;sa§;eV:.."g§73'E::'a;.*£2:~:1:&*~::’%, sf éiiigza Wf.§;iE€$S€E§ 3§§€§;
{E1611 §£$él__*::};$ “§2.z3e{}ing mtg) firaxasiaésraiéckzz Ehf:

fact Efrgai a§s:~¢”§;;v3–.aé1§§;’-Igf 6 flay; ix: Eségizxg 211%: <1o:f:1p1ai21'£

anf;i5'?'§g'_§;', jwha is ga,i;<3,»z:"; $35296 335$}: assauétfid 33}; "$35: a.<::c::;:s€{£

.i:3.;8 3135:.' 53i§§§ai:E€d fizs ::}:3§a§;' aad his €"eJ"1E{iiii1€€"3 is :10?

;c:€£'_e3%§A::«'§§23a:§2 § §§v.2;ffl&ZC§§8} §}ar§ic:.3.§a:'s §'}:" 25333' 9&3: aésimesses,

.'§§:_'§zéé:f1. C:;aa;:::*i an appmcéatémg <3? '$136 maimiiai ax"; §'€€f*-€}i"%'Z§§

wag affiziza visas; Eiérzaz €328 p§'QS€C'ifi§{§IE has faiifizi €33 §3?;'{}'ir'€'§ ft}:

» §g:i3?E§ 'tzeif?-*$1:§£ reasonahéfi fieaibi. 34

(V x
~.'.4 2

mg. 3%, :x:,5>2:§>’gG<§?.

21 A3 §’figa«1z’:§§ {hit E?z§§§}€f8i agaizasi :a<":{gj:1iE%:§i, i§:Vé::; wé5:%§j

{:rs;%;:,f;3§é$§§et§ §3:*i:':Ci;_3E.%: :3? 23.2%: 33 iaisci s3:3's:<::1 E33' %'£':)l’£V’§3’€Lf’,«”:{:§;1′,-‘ff ,m: a::s:’§;2?;::<.;Vi '$37

EEK: Tzéai Comm 3.331123%. ha {£31si:1:1"a3<§§§V,_ fi1:«i <.::3.;2t;"{«::z, ihaé ?;:zf€%::i:£*:s§i:{r:€§*–;fa£V:i9:’s5;{):: 0;?’

P’§%?a2 ::z–z:3.z1sf{ bs é’i€’€;’€pZ?_3§. é%31{§ $§E€f€’-Céifiéiifli €:\%:3v:z:…’§;:.€4:»z Eecgézzii
View {mm Eaakégzg is t%:é1″a{t’:-$,”L__§;é:» «?hs::’é:*§_:°c:V::;’s::n’€53.::c:%?£;, éhsifs ig
as magi”: 3117: $325 ;.3fp;;§€éz1 ::’;;é§é 35:. géiémifisséz.é%C=:r:3:{%i:1g§§°.

Sd/*”

Judge