W
1;; HIGH zgmrzsw {:32 £«:ARi'~¥ATAK% 32;? BANGALGRE
QATEQ TEES THE 1522: my :31? BECEMBER 290s: 7
aazmms: M u
THE }i{}§'~a?'BLE MR, iu§§.;STICE 2'; :3 8€.::R;§:*§2:\-EA' %
WRIT PE'I'§Ti£}E\I EOE :3e§:4f/':.L%
;P,8.E'«3ff}.:2«aé'._':%;<;é§
Sri: ;:z_a;:;;;;»;1:s;:-2;:z_, ,3 - -
AND :
A1} ?}:s_3€:~':as;-.: _?s1§i}}:"??§'§:'
.....
;~,r.z«3x;’_,-‘ab AT 1~iC§$._z%BU§%C.a TQ
* …<:;:§2*:*2-:sx;;:z;.:2f-:':’«””?’z~i’1;3: <:<T:a?~zs'mi;T§:3N 0%? ¥?~§£}EA, Wi'E'§~i 5; ?{¥£G?ER TO:
v " i3{}A.f3_H THE IMPUGNEB A'%I.é"sE€D DT'. 30.12.2063 BY THE: FEES'?
"A§IJ.{3L.""_.LA;?3{2U§? CQURTP, BANGALQRE, IN ZIZ).NO.43,'99 V133
.A§J;~:+»2~:«.=
This Writ Pei"i'i:icr:1 camilzg 911 far hearing, this day", 813
' ".V{:.::t"3'l11""£ mafia thc foiiowing :
and therefore the same is not sttstainablc in Law. The
management was befmt: the Laiauour Cou1″t and had opposed
the claim of the Wnrkman. it was eentendczi t}1af ‘tI1e
appointment was cx:»11i1av;:t11aI fay the pcszjod ri_x1dicate§£_»i§1’_’ ”
appoini:n1r:ni: order and since that}: was no 11em i’,-..VVth2§_[‘V:3»zé111aé —
was not rtnewtad after 06.16. 1998, :rl[1}i;l5’IE§I}1é3’gfi3Hf;f:%i$7.;’2§;S’iii}
.fac:t paid tht wmpensafion as the $3 a ‘V
and fl?e€I”Ef:}I’€ the same: (Ices: ‘Iii {ha
light «of the contcniions zgrgad ‘Lab€§i,::””{‘A§’f1:’t., the
Labotlz” {1:m::1t.1s1Zi:r;1 1~3’_::: the pmstmt case, izmasmuch as the waxy
i11d:E¢:*:ai;e::i by the; Labour Couzit would imiicattr that
CORE’: to 311631 a f;ttI’.1¢:3I£i$iOI1 based on the fact that €113
“1:c1*1m’11at:i911 was udfhelzt any tszuqzziry 21:11′ cha;’ge~si1-32¢? 1101′ is
.E
4′
it a termination wifhizi Srection 2(r.’a0}(bb) of the ED ‘is
c0:1t::ud.ed that ev:3:11 though the. workmafl W83 :1v;4:b’tf*–€11Ai:fixt1¥ééf§*~ ‘
pay;fi2e31t of rr;:t:’e11C21m€1}t C0m.peI:_:s:a.fipz1 ii: df_fl1t_*:_ V
ap:p0i1:t1I1en.t being <:ro:t1t1*a4::tual £131' ..
management has t.':101zght it fi%. i:0"–..3ga};' fhf'. §-:aameT;'V_ !ZA}§3's;;3:iVt::*–*f11e
L»a¥:n:::1.z;r Gcmrt rgotitring £13: V1235 c0i:1:3._ to wtmug
mncitasion?
6, 0:: belzaif crf flu; :;:§£;111}s,e1 Steaks fez)
justiifie’ f}?T:’€”‘e:?§1’5Zq’;–;.1A:i’?;’?§”fl}€é”‘§£-iE)£}1.T£I’ (T431121, The Labour
€3r:>1::r£ has drawn: _f{3 i_E:.r.g: ‘=::~g:V>:1.=p3.”:.fgs-:”£r4>:1 that skim, the Ines: was
a_va.iZa§3§c, be re,i11sf,:.ated is the said post:
. V. & ” Viz: this ?Ja{§2§:§ii)1111d, a perusal 9f the awani would
“”iI}¢iE:;g:_:.atfa: :%i’t;:;=: i.a?;1<1r111* (I'ou:rt. has referntad to the Evidence
fandafed bath on ixhalf t:::f the maxgagcment as. WEB
. as $1113 tiégfliman, The appointlnenf €1!1T.'i€I'S warm marked by
who hat! titxamined hixxlmlfi Acéxardingly, the
._ ":,a§.;:ou1- C-mart has mticgd Ex,w1_ dams; 95,05, 1995
u i11cIia::aij::1g £113? the appnzainizuezgt. was 13:13: a pezicd of sgix
J
J
manthg and therrsaftcr fizz: «:1cr1.1m4::-11:3 at Ex’W,2;f::3 1 ”
alga noticed to indicatt: that the ‘:%fis;s.VVVZ:*§§ing.,V VV
C£)}1ti}}T.I€£i finm time it} ijgneg Jlabtidizzé ,§:i;%3 ”
doctxments, the Lab~s3t,:1′ Cx21:1″i V_1_v3::L*¢:.;$3V €?0’IAi1=SV f.t3
that this bmait: 111ade isstxfvecn a1v;;3o§iii.a;z%:.;;tVA5{v;§r{i£1*s is
asritificial in nature agzsdv th:: View that the
“msgmituient had W.-:’:;*1«:t:::I Th¢f.’1’Cf01’€,
thtze fact that had put in
man: thaf} V:%I §C§V’::§f1Vi!!:I’€if’£JT€ if at ail the
S€IViC!3S WWI:*Jv’iE!§A same wotzid have in be
made E33I’A”}§a}3ne:1Vt_.«V{;fA “f§f§%1nf§%:i:;€i1me1:t cc>1z1pe11s:a;t:i0:1, if file
appoizzfzzzamt résaas ‘:15: fégfilar ami if ii: was made: withmzt
i’13Ziz3i£*§1ig3.’i:3I.1é’ In $11!: jllfifalif case, the fact tlzaf.
‘:.£?f_7’,’fV1:’¥E’fZ¥,1(,”V?i1I§i’i€t’_£’Zii. ‘€3€>?i:pens.ai:ir311 was pafii and thmfiafter
temi1é;3ai.’§c::;§ \£¥”§§$T131ad€ is mrzsi in urlispute,
” fiowavari the q1.:z:3t:i{1»:1:s that Wgrzzld a:.r°ise £12111’
.f<:.:9i1Si:ci.aj::\3ti0:} £23 as to whether firm w¢.:::r}:1:1a11 w0uic:i be
£9 raizxstatsmmtgi the If-fitilffi Claiméti in this
Ci».
rfigarati, €125: V2223? d9c1_:111e12ts w31:’«:*.h 2135 {men 11£:fi¢?&d E}:” E516″: ”
Labcrizr C0111? wcruid inziicaft t11.:::t»
;:sef3ii:io:1gr has 110?: been mafia by i;1dic:a1ii1i’g’~é:113§?’V1{§§I’T’,f§’;*€Cl££A1″?ff fiirzf
Ti1emfr.:::re§ the said ap}x3j;2$me11£__%.%€§§fl,gi*V:;§n.}y.be: as
tfi1:1pora2″y in Ixaturzz, ._t’I11’s nzattmgt, the
reiief liflfid not be i:f&.i11set?V;$:£=:1:.r.:;fz.t 13iSp€€T’f, Bf €211:
ggattm" has by $116 Hazfble
Szzprema case of SEETHEQQEKM
£N{) Qjég 'V FARMERS TRAJNING
u«:$TzTL:i*EV,V_g:2{:-ea i$;11t1*s:-£11 the 1~zcm;’3:»3c Suprezzifi
{T~9z11*tA.was of £113 ‘vimsé that in such matters in lieu of
“:’ei11S’t:aiz?§i§As1:Vi..«a;::p1’c3;i§i?is>1t€ {‘3-0I11}}€11$éEii’.i€I}1 is; tn: he gsazzteci,
‘Sit;:: tm& C<:»2,;:*f, has aim g:ra11tc:ci {*e3mpr;r11sa.t.1'c::1
vaiyfigfig fiitrtii tea Gaga Re1}=ing 0:: the said jzidgment Qf
. Véthe I"i01i'1j_)1& Sigprsms {'I'4::111't,, even {lag Dévisiml Béttzl-:17}: 9f this
"{5'.4::a:,:f{ to wizirsth E was a gyariy, 2'31 fiim. case cnf
._ '°Km§?§,SGMASHE}{;'£R&£;iH 355:.-E E}{EC;¥.f'f§V?E E3'-ZGI§\EEZEZR ('gag
"a%'\I0,56§3:{G8 3,11 02% gxsafiaaa; $3.33 awaittied cexnpfinsafian
ktzepizzg in View the: facts itzvelvexj in this -saigi " ' .
aspeacts would indicate tizaf: @1343}: wh£:; Cam})xe:iss:§ié§;3 tc:.}3c.
awaztigd, t§1em is no shzaight jackétié fcr}f33::,i}i.§=:":31'1:;i' xf}1:é7
wqmid .i1av<?: {:3 be t:It=.i::*,3:*;:3i1;1:::d7{:x2I;:. _
zalreieacijg 11e:si;fct:-:.'::}. by 3115:, the after
fcgrllowzhg £11143 pmced " 31:51 i:§é:*:<=:ibre 1531::
we::r:"kma:.1 wizaifld 124;? be e:::iti:£fe:iVV T5: the
axial} £7, 'tilt: El¥i?'a;§é'f§ '5'}'3flZé'£?"§Z1:§"§'1fa§Tf3_{:iiEIiif «r-.{:Vfii."s.'1212§i:y csf SEIVRTE'
aim! 50%: }3a<:33~:ss?a5ga:3. {';f';§§'§}I:3.'1:-:3'i:..;iL?if'.- S'lvl§§i«Ei@:I1:€f£ZI,
T116. qi:§é'.ai33Ta:_}i1aZ:{:i;§§ii%'1*3:113.;A%i1’ w::r:’1<;é11g as :51 {'.'-I.1€1"£}i$'i". f§_:rr 't3r:.c3
Tm: ciisggxztacix P':;;t'i:?:::::; £1123 length of
15.s»t3:;é”:.i§:’f:? 2% ycitaxis in 2:11 fmm the date: Qf .fi_rsiT
appé3i;;tzn€:i2it_ L’ ifirmjzzaifiaeraxiz, Thmzgh the i:€:”:1§:;*€: Bf 1:113
V§’$E§3«?¥33QC!I’fiEi’}?é%£p;3$CI?;_’£1iTI_£1€3.1’§ is shaft, thfi §l3r:t 232:: be c{:s12sit:}e.’1*&d is
V’ fife: managemezlt is a g-3vez*;1m£::1t corgpaxzy and if $216
-~. “”¥’€?{?l}”:i£I1}§:3}i1 was €:r.217:t:i::}1:et:i S€fI’V§i{f’€, 334:. wmziti have had icang
.
S€:’Eé’ii(“f.3, The 1iI}C€’L2’E]I1€)I1i{}E1S Itmcrval in suirlz. an cvfint wotzid
lxiizimattely affcitt the f{lfi,iI”€5 Si3I’V.1:{“.’€S gf €315 wcziszmeizl smce tha
313631? 1’21 1311031 amploymezlt with tilt: Impr: £§fCGI3fi!1?.1é’3.3211Cfi
ws;u:3s:§ 111:? 01:33:” &fi’e.t:*t fhisfr ;3:1:=§!:3t:1f E3.I1}?10}?Tf11C1}ii, 1)1.I¥>§’4~$’pV!§*i:’;§’§;i§’:–L!.’i’..
e:”&f1:e:r Gpprjzttlziitiag wi’:i<"ri3 wtstxid haw: 13:32:: «';3.'¢?£'?J3'2:T£.§.Zi.'ll5"4f,1:'?_vV1}'!'§:¥'_1§""' u
that p¢:1:i.os:Z 3334: would havr: beiaexz £¥:;:–§g::s::c:
Fu:*¥f21e1* if is aissjx :1@if:£t:t:c3 that air 1
app0i.:1fmt3::z::i;, £316 appfiizgizzzszif s5:%13V1:1ad'eVQ1;
fialmy 2:35 RS51,I:3(}{}f~ 1361' :I[3_€3."!3{'}1 "€126 iszag Cciimztiad
fivym $3222 in: :71:-.:fij:'::4;;$:§ ij;-.1 5:132: colissiiziatmi Elllltkliiflf,
Kazfipigzg 4fVi1eS&v._é;&:}§i~cr¢f5«.._ Vii!' vii:-:w 3.:1¢:i also n:3i"ir.ji €32′: Ht;sI1’b}e S1i}3I’€ii§2f? €j?ar3111*i: 331:1
%;’11§ ..¢7§Vi%§ic:.s1i g’BEI1(‘..’I.;l” “” “Qf £13333 {T:::11:*i: i1I:!i’:i€”€!§ suplza {E16
iihiflyéfitlifiéafififl ii; ht: §:>*«7é:i 121: £134: preaent vase
we;’as1A1Z<-,:4i_V hi'. £5.51' teaf Es?sfk:iuki~ V£V3:’–,_’-:!I’I'{§’, .«
interest at 12′?/E; thematic: i’I1′,:’::'((i’_¢,’3Zi§TI’C?i£._ ics fhg: taxi;
;E::1:Ef3Late:d by the ‘WIZ}I’k1B£’1I1 £91” 31o:1:¥c,<§i1zg3_1ia1:ée.g§f[tEit: tziszjriieiz
Wiih ti}: abovt: ob;-§§:=::I:€.ii駧s §3i:£:1:c£17¢:):1$, the
p¢::if;ii:ie:rI.2 i_sia11:_i i=;1i~;S};;;isa:3;:i . 03:14:13' as tea xéosfts,
% sd/__,
%%%%% judge
. £33436'