High Court Karnataka High Court

M Ramachandra S/O Late … vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 30 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
M Ramachandra S/O Late … vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Its … on 30 November, 2010
Author: N.Kumar And Nagaraj

31′ TEE Egfifi CQEEKE’ Q? -‘-513 Es’? §f:Z’§G2’s3.QRE

mmn ma Tm saw my S? %%”%’%?E
Pas£§T
ma I—§$E-锑B§;§1 §am….:’£.:3:§;§§’; R1K.I.:%’§»1;é:2. 75f %

E3 2;§::.§Q}._V

TEE Hayma gaggaggsgéa :m§,a. é;g;: ;

WRET £??E&L EEG .

.mm 5 ‘yak

E’ é
s§§.$,§,EH&Twa:a¥§22%R

mfg. G43. Baa’: aaA;$,, mg Rig; ‘
Sri: E 3% _

‘1’hia writv
this flag the xr§e;§.’7umé&t§%g_’ith:e fa

% — Q7», Qa:i’_z2 3333 T

agaigmi aha mflgr yaaaaé

éufigfi ma Em iimééizgzé em

aréaaf wssfi $3: fig

‘ V 3:

W’

iii

:_f’ ‘ as wzézéé fig 2:25 éffifitif’ pagafid kg 312%

‘E..3;§E§$§f’ Seszfian

-i2x;33:fi’I°’ifi £2″: £1 §r§

2:” gafarm figfg Efifié {far

V” géafifiiéfigitzfi.

3, E% $”§§.§§@$”§ . 3

é ..& fig? E SW; 3 ref. .,.

Efi gzaflgiag afig Eazgé

_

n *:;:$§;?g . with gm mmimg 6%’

bazagégg $§a§§§.?§;’Q %ifk@ Eé g1.m€:&3g ifzath gzifiégats

at Byamrayazmgmm ‘sfzikgeé

Kfifili Tfilfikg ‘: =-r 5

aim Snbéi.

3, it is :19: gm dimparta 2é::§%

migmm m a»mn%E§§gT gmg k %

fiafiisr 3% death 3%’ :=-;:;
=;nhm’ta§ trim gait .;$s:§i& file aafi

:21 1*:

in fawm The grs

22§m,§?’1

um: ha me}: flag

rwgmzifiafii =

mzfi an Eaaae amfi. he ig

flfifiii % 333.3? fifififé’

m%eir:c§.m&:fi:E1i}m§T$:?2*’1

V finéfg 22:: aha gym? 1%’?”§»”1?§; E’: 52% 3;

“~ILfEE:§§.¥$Tfi:;aV”§;::i as amfifiaé, figs aaifi Emmi almtmi wizh éfifi

an tbs agyimhfi §a%§ 1.3g1.§?’4.

K ‘ ” — “*:3;§i;£c& x isgugé, ..r::

Raizfizrma flat fm’ gm: 9:” §xz: fihiiaa;
T ag mfiviaimm far

agpfisatism far fimsa mmafiis whg haw mt

a§p§:::.afi§1′;$ wifiriirz fim 1% yrezgamfifi §:°$z=~_

awuwrgy g km filaci m agpfiaatiafi >

in §’ar2fi §§$;’?~§x.

%.§$a?”?,?2 ifi
9§:s.2{§-3:3 Em fiieci an in
Farm ra§:2’~a ta age: :s;vp%:m’3;:§ 15 g1.1n%.as.:

Ea fim aémwzz his mm,-B 3%

{Em z:~m*1§#V aif E1235 migmézm fir:

zim a§§§%§::§§tim’: filedg Em smzghi is

fif 3&9

‘V ” amazsfimagi wag aiiswsfi fiififi Emfgga

tiw –

aggarai, fiifi

11%. 9f cbjmtmi ms mngaatiszg ihfi fi $3″ ‘zim gafi

$11

5.’§:E$%§ {Em &%E3g’i;*i§.m: Emfi g syn’:

izzsgwéiang fingfiéi 33:33? _:

Qfifimfiffig’ {sf T f

/

V’ V. ” :~ .. :-

aéjnizifi kiwi awmm ‘its

msswafin af the mg 21:’: qzzfiiisezz. 8% aka raga 3:7;-‘–¥;:hg

EE’§f£ gnfliw gram :9?*s~»*§3.. m 19§3,~–§§ to

wag $3 ®fifi$”L3§a§i$f%. $2’ ihg larfi as a. ‘ in H

mmfi amfi su&muent “£3 tkig

afarmaié; fiaszmntgfi mg emf: 3:’; ”

aka firm n ‘ 9%”

Eamacharma, the aaiéiézéédg aha

fiaaéxtajséfi crarzafizmémn tfzai tiw
mm i§”=q;m&§*fi?$;i” –~ étgarzaiifiifi Iami 33 $23 131%

agwfifitzfi it mafia with 122%

érgafii Eiarayamgga. Em

wag a Eésszmgryé. §3″§l§f’ is ggawfiygg afizé m

in pasgmatéifiiz 3%’ aka iazxé £3331 afar

iimrafszm, Ex is mzfiiéififi Es grafii: Qf that saaié

‘?§&2’§Eam§ fiy mflar éatafi

2- the

23:11:13 wage gafiafi 33:: f&’%%”§§f af’ fizzgasfifi

‘ &

H VV}§i2?c;&s§§am::%;£ét& Ezig maa. The

fly gm mmag Eaimfihamim ._

in §§§m; :sa”:§k:3::g2fi$::% ‘

Karmtalm fi.§§v&%.fs Tribmzaé. ‘§’1′:fs; K V’

‘§r£h12xm§? by a fiazaifiaraé m;’:§er§

3:}. :a,::a.2a::@5, Aggimw
mserm Writ ggfima :a*gk,2:§.ka2§%ii%a*~a]$% wggé fiflurt
whigh a3§$ mm Es .A/_i;..§,v%””‘_v_.@2*t:1a::=g1°” éaiezfi
m%4.2§m am gzmsnt

aéfifimé is iafifi.

fig §§:¥:f§.;’ 5s.:n;:§:i: mzzmaé a§§e::.a2*izg

aréer

fag’ §j§:::& _ agggggangg ‘tha

” Size fifiuixgs £:$§fi*§:_:£:>?.Eé ‘Q’ %}m
is 33;: SE: aagfirfiafise with kgan.

‘ _ éfi rag’: imam aafiaéami g§.%§r’:z;zx.§ty m

fig: qizaagéan was mi 3;

at ail In {Egg iii’: a §mm%;ir:g by

hm ‘bamnzséfzmai

“”§’:’i’§maE maid mg: Exam ‘&$£:r$§;_L

itx :2: s ai:;h§::* $2: $215 aésziéam $37 wéfimssm rawzjfiéfi

in Q35 e:fi*;.z.§§» fir mi ‘Elm %agis mf fa ape:

Whizsb was axansfizzetafi. in

Wfififififi _th¢j”_’~~:§;:-<%$§i¢:1T' '

wiziagh gyms fiar mrm§x'5;$rafim'._:: waé: aa$_:::§s:'3;. $333':

dam, m, an §.,$3;,§§'?'%s, wfie%;}f::::=r'__.i€; ma m;;m;;5§% 'm;i;%~ A

fig aim c§n%d@ thg apwliazgi' §§§.? £03'

gag: 92" ému -.

5§r.§m£?8;’ 3f; * ‘§§§y..I%’a .?’8«;’ 33

meaaxmizzg 3% Ex’: fmmn:

viilagaig a

a;’§_.:’:.=;a_;%:’~: 3? .

fagmazr W§§;_%i?a;,& ‘@f:'”‘%z§m rfightx 341$. whc: fiiié mt

avaii ffém smzfifir tiim ficts E: E3 anly by

Efiféfiw “”” Hsffia &? gm fimi fimg fir: ‘SE16 firm”?

ifi

V _ mt ix:

‘E*% gaiai agglizaatimgzz 3:6

af ‘fix fags gm? fifi apgélznaféégm

§r’;:§3*§’1§m.? mg aérméy gm fim :m mpm: fif am

§’1;z’*’£%mr:, he %% $§ ‘fiat

VT ‘?-;% wag fiifié ma 1.§,2.§1§§% in §”~&$@:;et e?

V U ‘§}’g§$s?’?;§

‘ 1% gamma gzmé fin §aE€3k3i3fi§;§ an

ameziéimami agsgiimafisgg wag $2353; :3 imiufifi am Law

?1.

– $:$.§%§§?$§’7..% m%8 1% § whégh if§%a;$

impfimfifiaibk. Thgmfare; has aufmmita ‘iémi

fwazfiéfi by 1115 auiémritgr as wafi gs itha

gfudga an fim Egsfi gsf izmémza”

awmfifirg fig: mare was ,_:f:$ §§:~:r?§:§2a3: agéiga

92% $ tad mfi § hfi sufiéaféifg g

agifia fifififi érdsra.

fin M &:>:j§J:;r%§, %

far figngafii Ii? §1’§;;?57.:r%w:3fi$§2t mnteziés

figsztly *§%ei=%’_1e:”.§” aufikeriiém mm, :32:

a§yzm%§ti;.’§§:2«–.;;$§’ Q33 remré haw :*%r§% a

£2; § 31% amfzafig $3 jfifiiclfii

agggmfi. fie fzzfiim mzitmxéafi iha Em

‘$335 :m§;~*$:’:;§i3::?. flaw 211% was -:..:.

§:’%s§~:%;;:ifi.r’§; E2; smfig wfiiwh if: Ezha mama af 3535

fiw iafid. §wr

” n.§f:i§j_Aa%:3%§1t$£ aiaifi. Elam: fiféfii’ 23% apyaizztmi data,

‘ ‘ f’@g:*f:i’5 whiah Egg ‘:3 Q aaaéfifzsfi ‘§.i:{§§fi§ -.

fim maafiféal

??*.e%

fig aafifiaég 632$ aufiwxéiiaai an agpzmiaiéfizz sf tfie

aftsmaaié &2s§:ia::s::%§ fihfiy §§&%% gragztsafi ‘figs Eafié; whigifz

fig is-aggé mad. miéd fifi m sass fa? igziasfgragzzm

In Law; 31% ix ms pm§.i§i§nn eifimr far M

Farm §’a=&?’=-5. 9:’ $3; amrh

ant;— «fimk ::;;§ $;§_d I W

}€’.!3.t’.Z§i’é § Ezumhum wkcfih left

thc Emrmd murméé far $3
smzlihanéaé %ac:;ai.2§$ fiifi.
hfiffiffig Eta is mt §aba::Q:§w–A. fix
Agsfimm <$«a2;n§z.":3',§A2;a:%§'_:§a::e;*;3f:~VV' .. azguiry arfi

'1':§:£sai' éfiédéfime Efifih af fig

— czfiéwmramixxfi the aim?

witfma, g:§§»*i’é%\.}§a:<»"{3T'E::«. 33$ thfiffifgffig tha

gzfiaaéurai

..§'m* rmgmfigg ha gzgfibmim rm

é§.§;%§5.§'zé:** 2% mafia flixiie

fii fiffii {E15 .

H ” ” iha gain: 3%: szfimaa far @212′ wmafafian 3%

” a

_’ fiw imgsawfifi figfififfi afa i

ma

Z . V. ‘ 4’ ‘ ” , Z

B? 113:: Kfiflfitfikfi Lam Rgfamm Em: $33 gyaggz:-é

with figs awwafi géjémt af garmkg lama $3 tim
£213 knit mfign 5:4? $3″ thfi fie’: fifiirigrfgéa 1 M
aypsézztzfi flaw; aw E” né; in

it ma xiii: tin mid,’ fzmarx. 4’E’,— *§’f% I?;’%>{7m”

&mwzh°a.r5£fias if fifi vaeswég
mg: mzzfarraé a $21: sfiiekifi fer
gzazzi sf amuwfig yficriwé

urafiag &if:’E’.i thc Ps~.:.*-€., &

*:*:§%§um;gs§%¢¢;:g;:§z~g§%ga:J$ ‘tanarxt 3:” {E33 zmé

wiizéch

“:$:fa–§’?i’§;;§§_ t?1_$._§’:§€§§S§§m&§§§§ haa men Qfiflffiflfifi

rigfittg in rfipact

a right .%:i:

I- é§ E113 asségfififfism. gzéfifiréggm
gush & wizgaiéifi @h: was :::€z:1f3:”z’&§

gr’: $373; %ma:25a sf gmmrty

factgza 332$ éiéz mt exmaiafi 32$

mama aawam 39: $5 as miftigata gush

$15: ‘$8 easfifizzfi ‘aha ‘tmrgefii af fag: $3 $11

Efiazémxiz “?’?–2% was E3: tim

‘ fifiiffi mg:-: Ezné vgsafwfi with

“‘” “1

‘ k “‘ _:. _-f”,.;:_’:j;i_’

Elm fiaaraxmmrxtg tht iaaékré mafizm is mm

axwyt tars afiaim mmgmafinm. finéasa $15

at: $;§§§%’§:§€T3éf: Einégg tltm fifig 21¢ ‘4 2

aacugaafi ii: is :11’:

??~£ gmsfiiss fag’ am ag:pi5zc«ati§§’;.,..iby wizia %

gfi mg gmg gm af tfi

pmaseribaé, is mam $3: a’}§f2§§5§¢«é:iq;nV§3€::ivf€§%*’VL:”3:;é§§;f;:%isf ths Earxd.

.~_-_?’i:m§ 32% fiasiéfiiant aiaztiwriaedg
afiiaer ufififii’ an mffiuiry am
gran: u fim pawaer ta
gram susia. sf ffim ififififi Wfiiéfi ma
‘aesmfi . wider fifitian -$4;

Eefifiaix i?”§-«fix awfiulé iim

n £3″: gufiiimz figs Vfiifiii zgriih gm

fiwmimmgiir ggzzfira, fim

% : :3«:%§:g:; as? 325% mm fir: am {ram 9% §i’$S£B§£:”:’fi

‘=§§;;5:,,{E;§§?§*§a 3% $33 33 gg, $’Ffi§.Y’E Q}?

. $§fl§.9;’§’AK&, BY yrs sgcagmmg §E”%e’E§i.§E;

‘ ‘ ” §EF§.

mg 23 gm 2&2 iéfifi 13423.

Q ‘E% &:1q’iz::irg;’ titzai. éa mnémyfiatfid iiiidfif

$5 $3 tomfiy nt fram. 33: mmiyy A-

£:’1=%Ei’i::3E§§§8.§:% uméer fiwtiafi ‘??~£,: .2%’u**§I_”

uzfiaer Smm’ :1 ‘=%-331% 5:’: was Eméfi by §

fer gag}: $5 mnfsrmant af .
aypéicafima ‘azfiém
Qamifisimzagr $3′ @3132′ afiijécéff fitfiffi 13
£32’ ‘Eha {if
Smtfisgiz ??-.fi5i;é af mzé an
s&fi3§a§fi;;§1%§”V1¢f $31’. an $2Quiq* to
$3 gmzztefi mid ‘m5I’1g a;

tazmit 53$ an éaim Such at: eriquiry wax

gf éfifig mmé. Em’: £5:-* the §’a.:.::*® $8

sr:E§*Ai’E:_r*
H *§$é%<:e§ as i5»a#:3*%w£E1az* 31$

sf fix

$557. mgar _ [-

Ea gut fix aafimmpiiahfi

$21 Wafi iii aémai fmfifififiififi

ma fix agwigzimfi E it is

_4’z1:;i;as tinzfimh fix aéaithariilm are is kmié am ¢z:§*:.::5::§; €92:

sf afinfermeni fif gg_-rs réghfia on iim

pf zhai 211$ apgi tsmzam an ihfi

“??w?;g ‘Em erzzqaxiitjg £3

agigwfifiztfi @3225: mg iim smug! was far azzazz

€35 §aat:;m af thaa a§p1imnta ‘m?z:z:g 3. Iawfai _

aha agzairztmi data ami was in {%uE:i%&t¥x§:;”as–:.::§I1’V'”f;}&V u

a§m§mt:3§ mm is mi m be %:a%gs»=;m§ zizfim

pram: anguig, $13: it ss1*1::s:.1},é3jq._VF'”a5i*V’a§ Va
faaz, fim awg @§ ‘t§1aa;__ in
fividfifié Ea satisfiz arr sf 312911 3;
umxmiusisad fast. %._f§§ww’ fiat it

was an §§$:¢:’:_:_::§;:fl? ihafi Witéwut

wafs_§”‘”a§fl mmnt Zawfi%’=’ in

p¢s&¢a$%3zi:* iazifi am ézha apwéxaiefi

uéam

~ .f”§’§:§g«.L§r.a:$§§ z::m1§;i$:§$ra is 3m ‘aim maxim? asf

ghmfifi Exam

3% Smm I £3 31’; 318

Sgfiésg $3 it @133 3 ‘mg. ‘§’EL*a agfl 3%

‘ MAE wégéfii ahmfid ham

$3 $’€E$§} {Ex sviéazga

is rsgazaéffii “Efi ?% ghéfi
%yE}”:g§.§p§i$m*£?§g%:gwt1%@i:§E:imég mzavmzi fiat hag

mkm gsiiaszm aimafiyk §%::v;’@:§$§3g $2 ghauifi find a géaesa ms
jg ……… ..


\--f



   A        

I'      '

~i:;’§’m@sg2§$::ef fififiifififi

§&Ee: maze mf Tim %§fi $3?

M.

wag afifml rmra as vmzirg af 3.5% Ema £3 ifi §av@_:;§_ <§f_

the State % 5

ramrfi, it agaizi Emma 9. €3;ise§sz;2%a=é_,§a;z:f:§*2*_;.5:C»:=§:"

31:3': Withm am agape mi' an enquiry'

af fiw fast. if 'éhssfi 'mm
thm is fizz imwssity
ward is fiw thirci '~»'%'%"}'3;$§}.$3." thy:

agzpfimzzt Ema: azfi
cziltitmtfwn aiata sf
‘V35: 1 . 1 3 K wigs.

EL mmpa, it i& c%a:’_§
‘V er ?§&§§& $3′

3? the §fm§er’i§* at

ha%& 23%: {Em Em’: it

i::; a mzfi i :5 vaaifii ‘{¥’§’€.§§ tha §fi’% fl£s

W 4*é§*.1锑 ms»$r: why £2″: Etfirm E%I@a?wfi. fibzi, fizay were

Thfi .§:§$§$$§f1t

afi §::m;&r§?’§ figigéifi 13% gym,

3% as fxfi £333.’:

Wfifiififif the iazifi Tm igzzwaizisfia is 3, ifmiagzigi; igmfi; ér 329::
ii-..

L,

in the absfinmez Q? $3133: ~

E23 zfiiémy wmfis, gm amqu-3% was not is {ma €223: ,,

the agplzmmfi 2: W83 the tenaziat fig thsa Iazfi M

aérmfijgs ‘mix with am iii. “$15.

aanfinuaa ta @ in msamafim awn %v:+§e:«~.%..-5% ‘V

firm fsasistam €;”;:§m,.:’ni%ian@rV9 1
hamezg in the zaznqzzézjri wigigfi tim
‘mtaagug deasism 123:2 L f in ma
afgrmaifi guagm;m§5k%L:%% % m~dm<= my aim:

fiasixstant     mreiar Qf tim

   wag as tha mfiar

 

paasaeé. éfiizfigfi mkw it $16.33* that

fixia iwgt ifi mind: £5 we aim

fig Em’: wan: ta mmzmzié $2″:

‘ 553:3.’ as ii may afiwfimfiky

” ” ” I 5:” .: ‘E”‘i*:»2i:*af:§f@§ iii firm

ihg. am §ffifi’%:i£:?fi§ Eaafara :13 and sathsr

$§ 222$ afétsmaizi gfiifitfi mfi

§i3. Z’:if:a.&:– 3*’%§2;_ m;%$ it fag 3%,}: $23′: fgém

‘ wzaiga £3 afinziawtasé by figgisiggii

V ‘€§mmm§$$é$2§§r $3 2%: mzzfarméty wit};

; §x§ia§:3a& bf; rm §;.;ag:::mz $5 {ha §iv;gi§;:: fimak fir:

‘3’: 7?-“A31 3%

‘//”K-Vi’P>’)\\–v)’////.Vo«’5~’«)€.–‘\\-/v,:vnv,.–sN~~,:.m,. ,.

31?; a§:;§::%?;és:.:*fi,.”fi:§%’a%_ ‘K333 E3?

fifimifififiifififif am Eafirfiy sfiiaagéiia.

&f€}E%fi% gags wag fihfircfamg fake Qfdfif pmazsati 51$

mg. awgzwi Ea $§,:3*£&i21waIé$

E2? ‘§32’g Em m: a saga Whfitfi t?-1:€$’ gem:

iilififféfiifi wizléé. any qélfifififlfi af’ a’§?;§;s*g«_ ér $5%*;”r’:§: .2321″

qsgwfimrz 3-? E3953 W§mr1
®m§:*&%:§:3£ {Em iifiiéiftf
tizeér mkfi as fim enquiry
mfier fimtitsszi 3 iazsggnt
$33′? ?.§’§§% maégaxg $3 mzmt mzéi
flag; Qf’ ibis fiéazt ta

mmfiaw §?it%}1§–§§i&3§’1 V§$rfi§z%;*§z*8 aatwaaéiie %:,%za game aztfi 3%

_..:E’;s azzgggzggirifafi a;€*<5m:::i*;:;c;:f:s§. in amcfiffiazéce: with E33? mifi

'$3.-"§*.'§3}1&:.fim..z'z*'iiI'2.'?.im

.:*af$:"&§ :2': 2% &fi mfiizziézztifg fit

gage fmé?' é ma aggfii

Er; Em sirfizzmgarmag; €313 § i '?m z

'§§?;:\«5:.««:§2"a:°¥;a§° fiawmi by thfi § gfiisgggia guéga, Zhfi

tifi &Es3'3i;i%t

,§;§wiEa'g:§

£3 wnzazéfiama

2
§
?

mm: by fififiz aha yariém mag Exp: a§.:sa§:=: ta $6 .
bekm £113 £3§%:§$%a§:£’£;: Sammg” fiigngr, ‘§’}3£: M
Qammgaiamr aimiié fieaé firm ‘_§’;:&§-:3;$”1*§’é?.:« 3:”

Qzmk ‘ ifiié fizazzmh af ‘(Elia Saurtg, zmfi ‘V

mg? {ham halé an exzzqzgiry sm'”:5:§*%§f_;»,.%:%Z:a”*§,
wid mzmz-3: pz’$viai::1′.1._ Amsgsamaie

épwmfig is 33% iha afzaer

” fa? file then, pass
a§p:*$§*r§a%:a $25-=§§a:_i:”;%’$.1a%f§.3.::::: ahaii éméfia $23 sage

an fzzziiugmmfi by aw af

£¥.E’;.2*f=~:s%é,se§2**asa;i:.3ffi;:~:.5s fiiia ifiamri £22 thim afsgfiaif.

Sci?’/-

JUDGE

Sd/~
HEDGE

Kg

” “‘ A¢,%wx;www#m+wwm,w~«m4,W.,.«,. – –

~