High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Zareentaj vs The Divisional Manager on 10 September, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Zareentaj vs The Divisional Manager on 10 September, 2009
Author: N.Ananda


EN Ti-EEZ HIGH CGURT cs? E1ARf€A”i’AI{A 11″?’ 8a.r«zCgg%;:;:-§:eiéi~.{..,

BETEQ TEES frag; 19% my :3? SE§'”f’EMBE”:i?.: ‘ 3

BEFORE ;W*»

mg HQWBLE MR.JUs1*i<:.ér::~i§ A':%iA.%:;3é;

M.F.A.Na.334S–k_:€-Q? T'

EETWEEN:

Siffit. Zamentai

W19. Sysd Ahmed. Jan

Aged about 41 years I ” — ” 1 .V
R/£1; N::::?E–3_5,
fviysorrz Rcaati £:1tos:i;§fiaiominat;::ur’c1 .- 3 .

Bmzgaitzxre-$30  b    "

. 4 . Appe:].L:mt

{By Sriyfifiis  K1}. Bhat, Acivccatssj

AWE:

. -V V. A_ The: _i};:rIvisi{>z1;a1 kfiéiiaggr . V
‘ ‘Ba*.;:g:§i=er:’:”3V£§:%rc>po1ita11 Trangpozt Corpoxation
§»i,VH;Roa-d,’«§e1x;%ga_ior€«2?. …Re$ponds’:nt

V ‘ im. a, Advstiscatsj

Thié .a’;:»@al is fiied unéer sectimn £’?3{,E} sf M.”‘3.r'”.fiu::i: against

Y;t%1r=3 jz:cf~$?¢;:~r:i: and award datad ‘!9.0’2.’2f}f}’?, pssami in MVC
_N::a.:2182i’*3$06, an the we as f:I:1<:; XEX add}. 3&3 35 Is:§2%.C'I',
' '~ §'*.§€i?{§§3Qii€aH Area, Bangaion: ($Ci3H-1?}, grsartiy ailcawing the ciaim
" _ }.\.éiiiS:}:*z for cczmpensation zmcfi waking s3enh.an::*22r::e;":f. trrsf
* €3£§i§'E3j:)€f1Ssai:i{3i"i.

This appeai C(3tI’1i3.’1§ an for {anal hearing this day, the Cesar:

u V ” dfiiiwmd fhfé f<}E1r:s*.=s?ir:g:

{NJ

JLIDCEMENT

This; is a ciaimanfs aimeai for enha::c:1%:1iAéi§i;’*– .

compensatioxi. I _

:2. I have heard Sri Shripaé V.S};;a.ét:ji, ieafigéci »€fImj.;€fs;t:1 ”

for claimant.

3. As yer I11€:€5ii()Véi;Z_.V:”;'(3€3(‘?*I’C1%5″:~ é;e.fi~ ‘éixidcncs of PW2—
Dr.S.U,Shivaprakas.h, ciajififaiiai had.» s’ii§f’e1i:ki– fracture if left
Iadius and o¥5§1er’j;1iTV:41é;sQ§Li,aL?:(1TJ iIijufi€s§;’——‘-T’he ciaimant. was
mratcd in Vicfxiagéa _§:ic5s;pi§g§1;~«.f§t ft:-3 tixne of accident, crlaimazn.
was ageti $333611: <7¥:7}_ ..f§ii€ was a hcusmmlfirz. The f:'a<:t11m

was r<%:{i.1113. As per

:”1’V’3;d”€i’i1aC5€5..A”‘Gf éiiéiii. aft;er compiete treatment, claimant.

«.,».;;2pe««,

$ti3f::§*s– 1¥i:Si§’iC’E€€i movemerxts cf left limb; “I”i1c

iias asaesseci germanent physical éisaheiiity sf
‘ ‘

Wiaift 18331:: iiémb at 15%. mid 8*332’é« with refextncé ‘:0 whoié: body.

,

The ‘¥’rihu11a3. has awazxied compmzsation of

” -»R~§.71,G&C;j «« under faiiowing headm-

V E. Paén 51. szxfftzring : RS..12Q§,C3ff)f}f-

if, Medical Expeuses, C:<mve3ra:1ce,

Neuzishmcnt 8:. Attcnéant Charges : Rs. V-

ifi. Less Qffutlzrc tzaxnitzgs b :

iV. Loss of income during t1’c:atmc11tV’»g43eI:i:<:)<;i..::'Ré., 51 7;'

Total C'.»omp<?;1:1s;:;_1.t:iG1: ' R357; i',f)€%i}jf

5. After heazrixxg }a;11ne;iV””C¢éj2néei_ far Aciaiméaxzt and
having gone through t141″t’–# ;re<::3_;§§§.§}, ,,,;»f the opinien,
Tribunal s11c)uici'_'i1:_;_1ve :.':§9§2s}9éé1lci::i_" 'c:{§:–x1_13:a{*:11:s:iiIio11 under the

heads "iosspf snjeéyrfiient» cf iifiéf' ané "fniure

msdicaivv expénsc_$". '"3.Ti1.a1'éf;2m,_ f20D1}3€I1SaIiOfl awarcieci is};
'}"'1:1"3u:1aii;~'s m0<ii1'§c4§.':~:§$_f:jiiQéix?<s:'%

L P9531 Sufgéffififi' 2 12$. 2{},C*I;}0i"'

'V V' «ii . iv'£€:_£:Eic;;a1A e.;~:;:)enscS,"'{;'1)i1vej§ranc{:,

V ' v§'%§o1zt'iSh;:";é'Ix§:V 82/» Attsnéaznt Charges : Rs. 5,000} —

1:1. zagigss ci?:1%;:u£¢.éa;nmgs ; Rs. 4o,:;':::;:;":;,/.»

_ W. {#233 Qfeazizings during iaid up gaserioci : Rs. 6,<:z0<::;»

' Less; z<:§f—émmzitias fir. cnjeymcnt of fife : Ra 2£},{)OO[' «-

_ §¢'L F1I.ii1r€ medicai £3X13€1}S€S : Rs. 15,006} —

Tetal flompensafion : Rs. i,0I:"3,GG€}j —

I/=

6. In the: Itsuli, E pass the f01iGWi:1g:~

CIRDER

The appeal is accepted in part; Tfié’im§4a;1g11e£i”is

moéified. Cnazpensatign of Rs.?i,ii$1%i§ai

is enhanced to Rs.1,06,0{}€?f–. a1I}GiL£:35i_:
interest at 6%» per annustégf of’ fieiitiozii til] the
date of mafisation. The shall he in
the ra1:i(>1:1 evolvfjfi :tiV1’é: Parties are

d.ir<:r;:t€:d to b:::;si*- cGS tS_; ¥Z§Ifii<:t::f1's cifirccteé ta send back

records aiming \.jé:ith[Vei 'c:<:t§:fy —

Sd/-7
JUDGE