IP23 THE HIGH CGURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
mrrea "ms "me 24*" DAY 0:: APRIL 2009
BEFGRE
THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE CR. KUMARfi__.§i%§{,¢g§'§«Y T4 T
msc. cv:_. 500112999194 MFA:=§%Q7_:3f 2dGS’:'(C%=CE ; _’__V
BETNEEN:
Sri Anthem: Swamyé ”
S/0 Late Prakaéhagypa, ‘ ‘ ‘
ikgaa about vVES.T.yéa_rs:”1–:;;;:A_ ..
RJA Vishwaanath Na=:ge’na.ha«£.!4vé;~A_v _ —
R311 Nagar Post,’ ‘ % __
Sangaieare –~ 530?’ £332; _ ” APPELLAN’?
(By Sr; F,’§}:i,; ?s§ara;.ya::VfaTs’§va s*m§.’& Sri E-LS. Ramamurthy;
s’Wi3:’
” 1 . Mrs.’ R’e:’: u V ?~'”i*i§£%j%<L§§iéa
W/2:: P-'E-:;i<u._r§:ia§Rao N.\.f
_ _ Aged ab;3t«:_51 years,
7:333 ..1£§\RS”Residen:y;
.1_&7*h’s..*a;afie$hwarinagarf
_§_;a:””z.ga’§:35′;*e=-S65 $93,
U
2.
{A3
1! GM VarsVb.a,”
M}
Mr. K. Venkataramanna
S/0 late .3. Kariyappa,
Aged abeut 5? years,
M334, 6*’ Main,
Srémvasaniiaya, Lakshmédevinagar,
Nandini iayaut,
Bangaiore 560 096.
. Mr. Sheshe Gowda
D/C} Sri Bugge Gcwda,
Aged abeut 51 years,
C/0 Gangadharappa,
No.8/1, 1″ D Main, VA
Behind Hebbai Binny Mm,-. _
Ganganagar Extensicsn, J
Bangaiore 560 932.,
3/0 GM. Ma_ii’§i4a:ju_f:z%;._”
Ageé abeut 18.,yea:fsf., ‘ ._
45’ Maia; “E31; Antimny Nagarg,
“;2ad\jacaé_fi:t 5:9 tleffee Baéard mycut,
«ii
“!r!e,bt2.a;l %f,e’ms35:}?i–ura,
B%angg%£aregs:6s’k32*¢§.
.» Mr. Srizéffifaéiappa,
EL?/0 iaté V’e.nkeitarayappa,
‘ “‘«.l’i,»-Ag-ad abcut’41 yearg,
2 ‘§%i..:j:e,287§,/uC, Behmd G€}’%i@£”F”§§”‘f’3€3’2t Scheaé,
_ “Tr-‘£e’i:>ba.E,…?
” _3%2Im5c_’,:aiere S63 S24.
, M%§R.:v1. Meme
“Sic {ate MR Mehéte,
” .~ Aged about 45 years,
6/,
{,3
, Mrs, Snehaiatha A. Jagdam,
W/9 R.M. Mcshite,
Aged about 44 years.
No.6 8: 7 are residing at
M339, UAS Staff Quarters E-tIe£f1 baE, “.__’ ‘*
Bangalore–560 024,
Mr. H. Ramakrishna,
S/o fate H. Hanumaéahg __
Aged abeut 49 years,
N:::.KSO/A, Marathi’-!’$.£E!aya’; )1 % %
13″‘ Cross, Laxmi;’*:afavanapLs;*am{ ” V. ._
Srirampuramr,–E%a4{1§§§£-nreejS’6Q_O2;fi..f; .
9.Mrs. B.H.
W/<3 BR, ;VRang'a"t*:a_.;tf_f;Va'?w,,V%
Aged about 55 y'e_rs,. '=._ '
Nm.343§v, 3'"§..V_C'rc:ss;V._ = * W
Gayathrirxagar;.VBaz:ga%cr§'«;'§~S0 G21.
%.* .Sriv-':C-ii;M§ %-iarshé' %%%%% ~ «
. ,S/Q €3.94.' F433';-iikarjunaf
' _ Afied _a§'i'2Qfu»t"%'.?\l" 'years,
Efiaivvfi, 'zéxrithony Nagar,
A§j.aceat.ta;.Caffee Beard Laysut;
Hebba§”=§§e’mpagura,
% –giajngsésgse-see 024.
, SVr*i».§<§§:éshava Murthy
Sis iata Gevéndapga,
-Aged about 63 yearsg
é’\3G.25f1, 15: Cress,
Kémpaiah fiiock, ?a§ace Guttahaééé,
Bangaiere~56(3 903.
(J.
:7. The Coffee Baard Empicsyaes I-muse
miidin Ce-eperative Saciety
By sts ecretary, ‘
No.1/1, Dr. fimbadkar Veedhé,
aehénd Cafiee Board Buiédmga’,
Bangalore-56$ GQ1,
3.8. Sr: fiaregya Ewamy _
aim Ease Prakashappa;
Ageé abaui S3 years, ”
vishwanath §\:ag,anaha§£i,..,_’~.. V V
R51″. Nagar P051; V – ‘
Banga%0re~S§§?T) _ V Q; “E;’§PC3¥\§DE%\§TS
(83: Sri PB. Fia1j;:_ $r.5.§::;:,3.ag%a{d.§:éAi”é,}?§.dy%.3cates for
C/R4. is R_~16}”..- .
This %’?z§5c,R€?&/1.; ;S:£§._Gi~.:”_sfi’.;~Z%:.'”~~’L::’s féiaé under Cram” 4}. Ruie 5
ej1F..~’:.§je C :;€je__%:..sf uC§\}i§’««VF?sff_1o5_§;§e2dure praying ta stay the aréer
aa=ae{a% iE;{V:$.’2iQ§}’§’V”‘:fr§acte an LA. Na: fized unaer Orciez” 39
R.uieVfs*- by the resporzdents 1 in 16 in G5,
1’v.7j§”Ne.82Q9;.20Qfi.Q: ‘ihe fiie at the X111 max City mi: image
% 44Sa;’:gaie:*e £j§’:CH~22).
:?§’S’§?3′ Mésc. cm. is carmirsg an 1%? arders ézhis flay, tha
V , _ C§:§Iurt« énade the fesmagérzg.
JV
QEQER
Thés is an appéécatiarz féied anger Qr§er~4_’::«–
C95 praying ta stay the aréer dat<e_r3«~§..§,2,2§§§ «'1zr%é'd.é;_car:
m. M9,: fééafi urscier Srder 3g Ruéegz a%a*aT2 %a5q;?b”§¥L’aim?_
Respandents 5. is :a in Q5′ §\;é0’%_?%:8Vg?%Gg!¥g,EC3:G#S’.,:GV§?; £ks-ajefiné Q?”
the X32: Adm. City cm; zudgg at5a;£g;:%sj%:e (mz~t. Qf trge”‘a.§%;j§§Vca;%,Q§’2’;v_éppeééant hag
swam ta a:’%:,,afi?é<:';a§,é.?é'%:.3%éi:§§g.:§%éat Srégimaééy tééé éaad maréng
Sy. 3'\§0.i8/3 :*z'*z¢;.;._4a<;<-:-z,i¢2:4éVfig 8"si§s'-és 28 guntas at' Kempapura
2;£__i.§a;fga2, ':5:-:i%a:§':ia:*s§<a '§9~£'ce{b§.¥_;___B&nga§ere Nerth taiukg beicngs 2:3
age.__§*s%§r§':a.<$::§§a%:g.g§':;a_, am: fif whém, he hag saw E. age 13
::"'vT,__§;:n*EasT'.§§§*:ée§9'§€ig :*ég§§%erefi saée éead éaied £;.§i.§,§S5 in
_ _ _1£a;_sgf£;L;r hig fgtmr firakaghagpa am ha was in pessessign am
'1._§e;?':';.3§a*"§?':§:é:"i%:'~A_'af the sama by :3b$ain§ng revezéaa entyies én Sig
V'§';a-x£ é§Vis§"_"i§2sr%§'§g figs fife iime, "me gaié firakasfiapgg fiiéfi
:_"'§ra»a.%;?én§ bahéna' fzimseéf arm :83?' respanfieai ag his iegai
ééaérs ta gucgeed may 33% game. fie beaame abseisgtg
6/__
$5
sf « §?"':ji.§?"§Ci§GE"?,
awner $1' the Earzd bearing Sy. Na,:8[3 r*:':easfg.;_;*é"%:igf
gumtag am he is Qeacefui passesgéééé; a}r§;'<§ ,é':§T;?eiigr:§§:e:2Vé:.,V:;é%'xjiééé
saifi famed He farmer stateswtijat 's'fi t%2& y5é.2§3:f". ::.':§8§3 t§'2é*~
Special Land A.:quis§tEan _v§ss:TJ§a=:'i:_u:nétififgatéan ta
acquéfa the Earsa fer the émpmyaeg
Hmsge fiuiédéng Ce9:':epe:*a*?::.f%.%»..»*.é_$a§§§'$y,"."Sé}?%§Sara in respect
9? ianfi acres W guntas
gut sf 8 &§§&_$ vféiagef Yeéahaaka
E-£5255', 'éééig §?§g§§§'t¥ has {mi béem
acqasirea? 5:: am his name has me: beer:
_¥’§:3§&§fie§ ~§’§’§. t§§?¢.~;5 Qreiizreiffiryv and fEna§ natifécatiengg
aiaies ma? if’: tha marzth :12? **E=’é§r:.:ar*y~
the~~i:?;.fi’ resgenafent/sccéaty attamgtefi ts interfere
gaggsessma aw 523 £233 fééeé suéi; $5 3.3
. 7;’~«é1:?.i{. 3?.V?’§iS,!2§§S ageing: the Sacéeiy 352$ amaigsafi 3;’: aréar
égaifist Em ércgfsmciion cjréerg the 2?”
> ‘°r§spa:*2é&n%;/’$@§§e:g: E155 grefgrred EVWA ‘?j:?§2,?2QQS befara
6/.
{E355 Court and the same has been désmésseé ‘_2.–*é%:£§:§§”b’;3.[j–:cT?é’z:w_r
abservatéafi that his mama has mt §aer§’_n0t§’EE?é1fi’*.%V:3V.%’§%{‘3,}A.as*:§ ‘
6(1) notificatiafis am Award and a$”‘:.sua*:_’_h éeré
af fared $3 mthéng :9 Ga w§th’ ,S “~ag:resE””°§and*
aaauirea by Speaiai Land g.ng..:qz.u?s;é.§2«:§.é**§1v–.O?fice:j’§fis3*z.§ch} aeiongs
ta ether persrsms. His the praperty
ciaimed by the Qhich the other
yespaadents am'”e;§:V$$ié*E’ér.§?%1:§%3*gi§S He has csnstmczted
9 sheség aifi -the ‘A’ scheéuée prfiperiy
and Eat cut iffié and am; fericeé araund
the s:.r.:§j:effc§L’:;§g: There are no prcrperty nummrs
azéfi’s’§§~._§:§arz=,V;*rt%i§’§«:f.i§%:ior:’ 9? the afieged mumaries am
‘._I’f%f38a$ii.?’§i*€’§é§’¥’£S; :’j_}¢§éfii§fiCaf§Gfi régardéng éxifiiiéfifié 0? ‘*8’
_ 3;4r4f:é§e..:%e “;_=..uf:é;:sevrt%es :5 mt ferthaomérzg. ‘B’ scheéufe
‘._;;:?:’t3g§§’;’%:§{e§s “”_«a:’e mt §§§”§C8E”§’3€§ with app&§§am:’s pmparty.
” V,/5€’§*3.éfl%”ef ‘£::§$%”2§efz%E$ are mam is’: gm: mafia am attempt :0
‘jLv.:_”‘§<r1;$€::E< Q? the grcgerty 3525 have creates a stars; basea an
O
the faise am fabricatea decumants 'and flied.. §§-h§=é_ 'V$1é;:'§*§
against him and Respcncients 1? and
(4) The srder passed by theV»(':;<§VT§:'~rt btéicxrsf "tfée
appiication 9!' the resp:2f§éen::sM"'"'V_§{v;?j§ 'L..d;5rs;€§$S'%:":§§ the
appfiicatian f§%ed by %':AiVsf:': in sahedafie
property is csntraéyséiv i':£§'vL:V:§$:A;::«.aré§':."'§t the materiai
dscumerzts agperecéating the
faitta and as such aiiawiag
LA' granting agaifist the appeiiant is
t:a:fi:–ts.ja ry tg§§afw~.
{E53 §–§’:é §g§’?Véh:§2?%:’.§:£3t§3 that the iéarnéd Jufige has faééed
:’;.x._4;a’;:sg;>reci!ai:.eV ‘sghé reievant facts and errea in aéiowirzg the
{a§l13@¥§’§”a_:§{G§%”«A_« ef the respsndersis and diamisging the
. ‘éVp;.$,é§:;;a_f§%arz me by him ffir gran: sf iajanctéan am faiéefi ts
:LL4. ;.35g3g:>§7’ecia?te that he ms right, iitie and ;Q€¥3Sé8$§6E”} ever the
2/’
guit scheduie pmgarty and he is pgssesséara since fr:::xj:”.§g;ir:.flg
back,
(5) He Further statas that the an gm»;};:a5%sa;;eg%%:~a’
canséder hia right and psssesfisia’Téhgfesfieztfi <3? i;E*%}'e'Aa§_fa1.rgs?a§cii%
property since the said §I)i'C§9eFt';f _§.SVVV:Aa.$"f:*aVfi{':é.$i§"§§_§:3j:f'§pE¥'{y.
The Court: bemw faded ta cé':':$idé'r__§§%i§: u(.i¥'¢{.<j:;;.;';}:2£=;Vnts praduced
by him at the in£tia§.gt;asg_e a;§1§ tfs:j$ pmperty has
not beam a::;§:'§v%edA :i,5::y T S§'.es::§a:'.."'%;a'zg':d fixcquéséziarz Qffécer
far the benefxii.' gt' the._if?5' 'r€:5;§§r:r3'2de§":t/Saciety or any ather
purpose ne§2nA”;r$.as$ed in his name in respect
sf’V’r}%é:’§?§*f’péri9%,;%. ~.__T§’:atV:’Wi””§§s name ?ea§ mt been rzstéfieé in
tfie pf’;:=,_ii’;*%fgi%i5A:a-:¥{;_’;««..finAéwfinai natéficatéérms under gemefis 4(1)
‘.—af:*:é 6(1) 2:2? use :;a7’r:a Acquismn Act.
éwié’f;.;29=:%”:er states mat was smart bemw has faééead ta
V”*[ -» :f§f%*:;:§€;ié;%”-.t§i%;at the respmfients ii*:emse%ves have FIG rigfta,
£tVE:§}g’VVa_n§d %n%:ere$t 9? the suit schedma peroperty, If the
z/
injunction erder in favour of the respmdents §$'””e;§f5o<:j:eV1d z::c, f V
atand, he wiii fie put 1:5 great loss anzfii § §£_§s:a'mti3Ai–§:§§}–agr§g"'§Vy' :«
Ewing his vafiuabte rights.
(8) He farmer statesi .:Eha;:.vL’%;’e;’%;A:’3a;meVv.AC’$.%urt has
granted énjunatian Qrcfer in his
Favour by aiiewajn hoiding that he
23 in possesséenl”faéiitfii:§:ta_$;a:.¥.s{1;%*§n’fi:.:§f_ £a;”:a bearing Sy,
Nais/3 sf Kempapura vfiiage
and the said s:?’c:e;? mg .;t;é@§f§V:1:¢.i3’%zVf§rmeé by mas cam an MFA
R§Sp§.n.den:s 1 to 16 are aiaimirsg rights
§ra.:9*fi : *–.ifeSQC%F%QEf¥Z/fififiiéty’. But the 1?”
7 ‘A-ravsgs:’§fi:§_%€t!sgc3’éE;x,}5′ itsaif is mt thé awner and has :33 right
“4C?:’.§;~.._éfxecute “:’3§§:a deeds/aiict gitesfferm flay-«gut and ta éssua
‘”*.f–,’–;fi§5§é.$:;i§§§.’ qertifécate in their favaur. That the V@§”%§i35′
éSa{j:§%1_¢;t§ sarwegz miter tétie than what he passess. mass”
%,j,,%,,.4, ” t$e~.’:;9:§m-8 5*? the Transfer af fircperfy Act; the 173′
Q/’
suppressea this fact even what: fiiing his $u:’t %vsé;jv:.§v:’:%§ft§§§.%1_
gr; G5. 1?5}.5;’§4 against the léfifi”F’€’%f;§*;§F1€§é§§§._f:§:{§§éV§
Scam).
{:3} The averment gggafla in the
year 3.989 the Specéai had gamed
notification ta acres 10 Qantas
cut at’ the said éfamitas in Sy.No.18/3 is
mrreat. 5£3,’§,;.:;3′:§’ta;é.V’_é-§?__éar:.d aéss érsciudea me extent
a?’ 3. acre :3 :§z’:.;2.r::t.3s ‘s,:%;,’.i»A*;{;”c},;§§f21 §;$::””?;%§é§.’.Sui9ject matter 6? the céaém
mlafie b’,r”4i.;fA§:i?e app.Va§£1a.gV;:::§z§s iané, ‘me avermant that the
aV:p{>_e£’.§’ajg’*:%;”‘:;$ §:9§§.éfiy has as: been acquires. in tha aaéd
‘.’v».%a’:si:§f§§f2.tAVi’£:2;f:’ vV§’i3′ ‘.f1j3iESAé.J “%”‘hé §UE”f§”‘?&§’ avérmgné fiat the
Y-3ppeV§ian::¥f5j ..r:;3§:_’§’: e ?7as mt been natifiea in the preiiminary
4:arééé’..f’§»r%§§L”;%§téf§:at§Qr2 is $5 :39 canseqzgence sinaa a3 an ma
. §%§%’ G§;§f’é§if’i””i§%”%ai’\,! am féfiaé fiazéifimtéona éated 28.8.1§88
VV’fL”:;”2:3_i§;:8§3,1989; the saié extent sf iané was rm: standing én
323 name :3? the agpefiant mgr he was we magnet,
U .
‘¢I-
{’14) It Es further states that the g3urg§za3e:f;m’f* _
232., Sri aarzgeevaspa bag was as. i’»s’a::;2?21,%’ir’§3ég.a§r{$t«.$5};w
finthany Swamy Sis Ei3?:”a¥<as?3ap;.3a, Etije 3:pmiuia;'f;£..'E'i'e':9*€'{;'1..__a'sf;§iA
Em said suit ended in 5 cempraVm§:age er!-9.V'2.1§8j 9l:':;:2–c.iHb.aséfi–. '
an the gaéd cempramise V_en%3I,. was
recegnézed as me owréar ?c3"r..V:§':?2a' f%';f:;t;."€i"fi9i§.: §V:r:=. respect 0? ism
measuring 1 acre g'uni.:t a°S7:'a:§§év_:m§:é.fEo%§'Qas effected in
MR ~–2 cf W89 MR was efietted
amy an 25:5.1_§ASA*§§-':%:§§=r:&:ff:'e…__:::f 35% Antfzany Swamy SE5
firakashappa moi in the preiiminary arid Fina?
nQt;§F§cat§gv_§};s7, '3"i*2ev.v., §§f:atifer £5 squareéy gmsered by the
Jflsrégféieni_a§ %?2e..,A$~:;§re{:*:é Cam": regerted #2 RR 23$? was
wa5 fiassafi an 3S.,i.1§§§ by whiah
a»2§;%m:A J %f V198§ was lrefietcteé iii the Rift am?
in the Awardg we same 9? Sézré ,&.n€§3§::~g'
Q9 §3§'§k§S?"'%&Q$§; iéée apgemrat ?'§%:"%§{E é$ féfiéiifié,
the $3336 3:' the 3§§€§§&§"%% figs mar; duiy asquérafi,
" Pamsaf 9? tie awagfi aiaaziy éaaégatas the said Qasitéang
Q/,
{:5} The conténtim sf" the ap¢'éAi'%a5:§f1fzmat-: h%é} ;f3.i*Q§V§.?7'€3§'
has not been acqufreé in the sayérj neétificétéon i;s–%:hé%réféé'fe"an ',
absaiute faise statement. in G5.
M27515/2094 by the aggass&;g$k%Lk:@ak;;§’s:A%gm éaééeiy and
gassing of the ardesfjby Cram: Es a
matter’ af recerdi :1′”T%cre :G gamtas of
the appe§£anj;H§ f.a–V$.V ghe and acquired by
the S¢e<:ia§'. _La1_$€1§$A'v';¥3;'£§..§%2':=§f;'i":;:5'—«i:':'??'%car £5 Encsrreaiz. It is
reievant to s':}zE"c;–*»r}f':feii%_9i':§%';=5ff".A§§': §§fg»ééiaént, thé appefiant hereifi
mg. categ.;§r§Vca§§y acquésitien $3' fang mea$u:*§n.g
S'A§=:<;;*§s§;'«ifGV g.§§:.:a§f'§n__the arderg gagged by the ma? Cmsrt in
in paragr*a§§°é-§ 0? tha csréer, fie
'7:§;eta'§V%s sf ..;a€:r;e:s 'm gurztag acqaséreé are cieariy mentésnefig
baa mat been chaéienged by {he apgefiant. The
€$_:_;;%t éaiga afiserveé éhai: the aapeiéant had rm aiaém
'TfLV4j2ra;§:§§¥;<saever an the acquigitéagr": Q? ianfi 3? § acres 15;} gumtag
Qy"
and the acquésiiécrs sf 1 acre 19 gunzas of the p!a§r29:éf.f.___hac¥
rmthéfig ta as man the aééeged scheauie gzmperty.
(163 in the suit flied by the r\feis ;f2’5:’2A:§je:s:t
appeééant has taken aitagether 3»§’J§§’13Z£”é’:7’5/:”;*:E’9aZ8E”id:S.EI3.fi§i’§”gv?£fi.§3Z =
the award is passed arziy in :’es§1i’.<:'=.*=é’é”j_%;%2e éate 0? 44:1) arsfi 5(1) rmézifiaatésna The
‘ “‘*~’.¢?i}L:.’%§ va_’§§3c aasewé that the certsfiea mpées 9% awara
..,,.j,_ §;f%a§.;§e::t suit and
cbtaénedi as”: Qi”d€Q’%”i:£:”..’.§1;%7%’§’i;,f’z’i:fi:{i_§j*1%_¥%’§’V~.afézég&;'<tefi% fif Eafifi ané raaafiéng
S :3? ma gwara makes E: giear {fiat the mien: af 1 acre ES
z/
Qantas sf the appefiant has been acquéred and.. '§2Q$$éés'§é}*s*: *
has men handed $3.38?" is me Ssc§e:.;m;*2r:.'12i".§¥ i§'§',3;V"
éorztentécn that the appéiiafit did r;3°a:7'.é§éci£tevA%
';5\i'.'Efl¥"§"!€3}' mar M has resaéared cc:r2:p':'2{:s.a!E§a..r;'§sTja V%zé§é":tae'%* a? 'V
triai. Hewevér aié thev:'s:%avaV:2t' 'éferéifégd £;?e7{3?é'at«.=;; 9f the
dscumantg have been su%i§"§E;t%:§$:_d" f§:%é;s'.=j2:'_:V:;*»*:;é;'§f.§;c3j_a*3de:*:tS ire ti":
tréai Caurt The ;f*,;p4';A7#x£e;::V'3§a;1*§::__%$ ;;§%§pe.?f§€i."%$.fififférerwt from the
prsgerty {he yesparzdents is
éfiésrreit. we respenaents have
fifl right; iitiéFa,::'m §:'*a'ir.gie:§;éA.~':~.;;%*if:;4':":':$~'.r:LV"'sécsrrect. The iayaut has
bggn farrgiféd by the Respendersts 3. tg :6 are
%fi'p1fz3é$:é':,a§% ;2 §§f:.;&§§$§§fi af giteg. 'me sagafsxte gage éeeag
':» _a:*e eaéezriiiedf"%;*§_"_v%§'2e;%'r9faazmsr. They' have put :33 mmpaund
Vfisaifis ané' 's.héésf'én§ we cf the respméenis (Respandent
«:.?~é§j.$}V»§éa!T$'«.g%$Q aafistrusted a hzsase and resééigzg therein 55:"
' '_*?:~§2_gf7§aA§;t ffiuf years. mat there are rm fiéfifig raaég ii': we
< '4:'7'A8:'{'4:*f.:'I:{g§';'ia§i¢,§§8 gmpérty. "$33 arder passefi by the éeamaé
fiévéé Easdge is a weié reaserzeé aréam Tm Eearnefi Jufige
E'/
'7?
;..:;
has fauna that the apgeééantg have catagsricafifiii’
that they have nathéfig to G6 math t%zé.§; 3SV 1-:8
ma acquireé Er: Sy. §\%e.18i3 f$sf,t%j:e ffisrzféiatéan
faveur gf the Caffee Beard §-iaa.,2é’a5″:'”:»sé_V”v’figciéizgé, €;e§’ the
aweééanzs are the aE§a%:teé%;[‘§3g:*:.§§%%§é:§9§__V;§’§*me ‘fiéééé tarvea
thareunfiar. > Ab ‘
(3.3) :’ax§’$$ fauna? that the
afifieiiafiifi §:§???3$ in 9.5. wa.1?5:5/2%;
has ca?tégGri’¢’a5’i%:i_Vaéééfiigiéfi the defendant therein Le.
Cafieg Sgcéaty :3 in sasupatmn $3’ an
ex9:’e§:f*:t’»§f”:SA a;§”§§s-v”:::{‘;%.§gas:3’::a§. Yfié %a’~,z-mt is aéraaay faméefi
€53? the acquiréd §and S the afiégafi gm:
~4..’.1’$-;?”:i_ie:d;:§e p:’5§:efiy§ The appaiéaszts have aéga fiategarimiéy
they haw 53$ sgaém an me agguéreé Ema éza an
$i~T~§%’£§;{§?:§ a? S aaras 3.8 §§.:r’zt§$, “§’ém§ara§*y §§””‘:§%.§i”3C€§§?§ i§
“* ;§’§”a1%¥ta§ in favauy Q? the gtiamtéff and agamsi t§'”t§ fiéféfifiafii
dgaaégtya Sefanfiagnt gaciaty gaméing disgasai :3? ting gm is
U,
fix.)
hereby restraineé fram farmérsg a éayeut an ‘L%?}{:evj§€é}$?§e%is.r§
séda éf aaquirafi ma rr2ea$:::=Er;g EZ éV{:{‘a’*g;.=s i_G-:’g:.;”:’::a$£”‘§ n:;.
réétraérieé fmm interfering with we péacésfui pasf.<:.;é£fss§a:'%} ai?'s":é'=
enjeyment ef the achedufé prepéi-%:;§1:"by The
gearneé tréai Eudge has passed
ii? 9.3. 1752.5/34 whicéz nas";5ee§« by me §-*f%g%""';
Cam: sf Karnataié'4%f§w%§_§3::':t%j§3V'E':*fl;§1e present suit;
Adméttediy their resgemixse
SCi":e£§%,%§€"Bf7_jS§*€EE'sA%#;€§wE7?§-_:%'?'§§'a%ié?"'a?;f:§€3§§§ %'*€a.3. Yhé Ssuri hag
aim fcumé t§";i3?I§_'_'t?3Vfé exacuted in fawur 3% the
p§a.E§2:Effv_..§f'V§ef$:"zéaé§f _§$§_Q:.3 «- Sacfety are mt c§'s§§§enge§,
3'§'€s.%__ '§V' a$§§§a:vA'j'§$:~?::'*:.§'%\f;r*%:s*'_:g admiatad 3:: the guét ma: tha gag
§ffiea$u'rf%%§'g' fa ?.~:%$ctefi{ of S acfes 1:3 gimtas %S acquéreé
_ '_j~–¢';a4r'm_Q% n"QwV1"*:u5rn areuné am canterté the iand is mt
'._'_'3£:§a§§:;*éé;"ya "flee Cam": has airway faund mat the agpeffant
T§%r*s1. *:%zé %wréiiefi szaiamerai fiiéfi Er; the $r'§Sé?"i*%: 35.3%: éa 9.3.
V' "'§'~§§.;82G§j2§$5 have gieaded a aifferant verséan fmm the
'ax;erm&nts mafia by them éfi tfiair giaint in Q33.
6/
1"?
4″h$>
§\!m.3.?53.S;’Q4§ Certified mg’; 93′ the award pmé:;§a§-.g}..:gs
to séwcvsg that 1 acre 3..1’g:;::tas was aaquireé _%*f;:§”i§;2§v?:%’§éf?E.§ ~
awarfi was gagseé is that éxtérzi: am ,g4ens;,>%$’%””é%:§v§’%’dv’_’a:s:aL-9*; °’
passed in mspeci: Q? 3 ages 39 gu:€2:;as;’_’_’tiiétaE§;z_v”i%.. a<§ré§_S«E3.
Qantas wag aaquéraé fer tag §2.,i§s*-;;::~;;e 9f"'f'"s:__§*;':'2V%;'%g '§a'*;eu:'
by deféndant §\§a.3 by i:%'2§,1–$pec§V3'%**§.§:r':§'-»;§c:j:..éé'si+:%.m'§ Gffécer.
3% £3 refevant ta mate that iiréis"c't;n§§$€én::;éz;é;,§v:*;:i__ Q? 1 acre 11
guatas £3 9? fixrc§_s?s_g-gggvganizfi,' 52%;; S§é?é'_:;%y;a§g';3§§a and cut sf
remaénéag a£:'é5s"'VV.I;f*~9{ '%g§;2":*%§a–s'gergéraé swaré is far the
faifawirrg:
Ewamy Sm ?ra%<ashag§a {a§pe§§as*;:)
3;: ; 2'}§§; 5; .§{:–%;{3§;;:§Vé:varaju sge Varadaraju
' -~ K. .E'§§.{:jara§u Sf" 'viarafiaiaju
_ 4;-_;§G -V..§u§§gya§wamy Sis Safiéyagappa
4: 3» figgthasaygwamy Sig figmgyaswamy
%%%%%%A%%%3m%mmgag cf the ma? Mags is gages an the §§£a§§fi§S
'-..3;z€:;?.Vé'%é a gmgér §Q§£"逧a?§€"}%"2 $5 Eng §€.;"}Ci§%"'%""':€;'§Z§. 'ma trig:
€/
Cmsrt has fauna that the Resgcndentfi 1
astabééshed Qfiffia fasée cage am théféffiffié &?s?'s§E';.s§f3éi$ '
pagaeé by the tréaé Eudge is 3 weii :%:eré%_é;é§T a%2'~:*1_ ";+§a$§5'g§§/.i
9:63;" am requires ta be L§Q?'}e?d. V
gm} : have héard %t§ée :ears:e&LAé::a::Lsez fisr the
agpefiant and the re:s3;§§:L;f_*séef§_:s €535}?i:i':«é:"E9a?i_§5:§__§\§i'L 5%}. 12369,
(2%; "';fI*;e._ .A$%*:}:;s.:f"é:.__ '~§£..逧§_§t.%.§:°3 I {ma a£'§S&$ far my
caméderaiéars : s"2s§_%%:e:'?i's2:%'E.?%§a.. ':é:§":[f3§$§g:*:eé ardar diegarzzés its be
si:ajggd 9:' éfxigi air :§2§s":3tf;a§ge 'E'
''{–2i:;. 3?9'§A3<.::'?c:«:1{s:«%;::.=.rf'.i.i:e the abmse Questiere £3 as under far
fa§£m%sz';-éfzg geafiégijg:
@335 ::Eze.–“c§§’2ten§%9:’2 Q? {ha Eeamed sazgnaai $9: 31%
‘ Tj §’§;§¢i_§a§iéi”–*a%’éat the gait Stfiéfifiié §§””GQé§”iTV éies Qi..§iS§§% ifaé
grsgerzyg it is the carztentian 5? $3 éaafaaé
“‘<, ¥§:.'*.3L,.2%'A:.sei far Rasparzderztg 1 is 15 if: aiattees} mat gait
K/'
sshedzfle greperty Hag within the aaiquéred
amdégfiuted fast that 3 acres LG gag-:*:'ta::.Aeu–}§ j$'1v',;2§r-éé 2:8
gzmtag Sf Eané in Sy. §*§<3.i8f3
Yeiaharzka Habii, Eangaiare N<§r*t§§§'V"""ca§u£<V. ms%%::ee%;<; :g¢q;;;rea"
far the purpase 9? f3;'maE§'s:;.=f3_ es.»;ag~¢s.;%:%%%%A%%:?s&mg éefendam
– Saciety. We apgaiéant has flied Q5.
No.17Si5/20.64 see§i~§j.’g fer?” agn*:.érd5’eif”‘§§”f”éffiénctian in respect
3? part and Kempagsura viiiage,
‘:’e%aé°2ar:ka :’% -ieizéég. 4’85;-§a§§feT “i’:Esr%%3 taiaskg In that gage,
Temporary Enj’i::3§*:i§f: _§§’.E;grs:§3?’tefi in favour cf the piairitéft’ –
A_:*%:!f2s:2;{»»<§1§z»;f;a;7m§; a;tnT:§v'a;;s_«.)::ga§r2s%; the aefandant -~ Sagéety.
…?n 't%§'é§: s:':iT:–v.§€a'~%§$~§§;'::§ ardered that gendéng disg95a§ Q? the
:: <»…__g;.;%t, d7?esfé'n7§a:%: %?+_ .S§¢%a%y is regiraifiefi fram farming a 333/»
.. '_fjz::';.;4t".;m thr.-2t'v'é%sgesi:err": sicie sf ting acquirafi Eand am 3353
*._'_§e«$t:*é§:?zg§'j_§;"Qs:3 interferéng with the geacafzfi psssegséan am
V. <3?' iéfia gcfieéuig firefierfiy by the Qiaénfiéff –
'V'T;fis"s'-*2.fié'%$ny Swamy, E3: is aésa made cigar that énjunstéve reiééf
gkanteé Es mt agpiicabie is any §f we pertiens Q? S gags
E/'
19 guntas acguired under 4(1) nst§f§catéq{:_":V §é?;{édV
22.8.1988. The iaarned ma: zudge whéée a;spo%ia §r:g%k%af%%m;%%'L
$36.1 far Terfiparary Enjunttisn in
Qbserved that gréma facée £2: appears tIr{a:t"t*§t2ere T§:s'.%.a vt:g:;:estEm '=
as is where exaitiy the we5terr€V"%'L»§§fQ'ur§da%y'..%§f S fires 3.8
gzmtas ends and where e:«{_af§:t%y Eauffiary sf 3.
acre 20 guntas wouifi beQ§i.!'?.» =. fiefendarzt –
Society ta shew' 2.3 C_ é1e,_c§::Vj§,e5""'§:a'r3"d is a gar': sf
amuésétém Tgr*«é': ma Sfifiééiééé ianfi for
f<3:"m§ng a §ayu-'~'m;3i… ._':'i'"~§:1éV.:_"§.?ear:'":efi Eréai iudge has aim
Q:£:$3_rv&§§fi#h§§ :f_evér§'ue. …. mamas are in the name: 9?" the
ggaiis"-;:';ff {=' As't§5§§=g{Sar¢amy zargcerrfizzg téza ééggutaa %§;':§,
§;s5.f§§'§3A.3cmntent§@r: af the ieamed mange: far we
«–:.'§a_:§§'$?Vf..§ant t%':§fi~ ma mag gregarad by the Smciai Lgng
Qffiaar is mntrary ta we maumarét £3532
'§'{fit.%§f%_§a%:§9n. The Czfsmmen sréer §a$$eé ma ink Riga: am 2
;fs§§,$2Q§f2§QS msgazeg that Qiaémtéffs ans'
(:'/
aerenaanz Mai 1:: the said saris, s.-azfza has z":'§:%=é§~
N@=.1?§15/2064 hava taken ééfferent stanas
suéi. E2': the mini zzarder it is a§s:;é"'i's":':EéA_sc?;3te.s.':.*
:xzc.:?51s;2Qa4 is pending befo:f_e_ thea 'f:A®'_.:;t be §;:=;s.5 and
§\éa,82G9;/2835 has been £§:;bbeS "'"é{i'::%1 as', :v:::£%;?*k5%;S;2ea£; kk
as per the arderg §as3é ::§~._;r':_«"?9?§:§$é';__V§$§'a,.343f2§é8 dazed
3.826% by the Caurt mi ?rf_§ ;' :<;':éx;*':i: '§;._'Séssicrrs judge,
Samgaéare and ®_5S;__~;':.4§§::L_1?V§§.;Sfzfiééisj-Vétr'ea%ed as mam suit.
Q3) iffiaiéw ifitey are in pagsessiers at'
the gait sshé.-315$ ',2::V2¢ég:§ ;e1*r*::,¥,"k'*;.,':LV""Whethar the piairztéfi is is":
mggegafigsgé ':<_::;F.t%':et s»;2§:_':"is:§h§e5:@:zie pmaertgs 3:' reggggmenzg are
ééé'-._§ 0§s é€ss§v7é§L:§§. the suit ssfiefiuie gmgerty ms': hé
asceftsaééed "'e:r%'_a*y._ fuéi fieégefi triaés 'merefcre taking
*._§§"::€: a£c§':2:§§ .$f"a£§ agpeazg 3% the gage, Ea my xsigwg tiééa £3
4: §'r§é..f:;%€ %Ti?-gefiaegtésfiaé sage whare §fi€&F'§&i"&%'%C& zagmsia serve
. '4'V.'j?§f§&'."§1'§A*éi5'?;*!';éASii 3? 'iihé gartéeg. ?"?2e:"efG:*§ I Q§€4"EC§;" :55 §§!'5!8$
; :§ }f':°:§;':?z§§r: gtgtag gaze :55? 5&5 d§5§G§§E $1' me gasizg
2/
(24) En the reauét, E gasg tha fa*:i%:§%?%L:f§¢g'A.:j–.
Q_3__§§;§g%%% %'
1;: ms Mm C212, soameeg is if: m%
2} Yhe p&_rtéa$ are dire{:te§g 9§{fi:'.5-Eggg;:_;';a::;§§:*:. §§$?;»;ss gigs; %:§%% the
fiispssai an? the suit, V
655 —