High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Narendra S/O Mallappa Gowda vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Narendra S/O Mallappa Gowda vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 February, 2009
Author: Jawad Rahim
IN THE IIIGII COURT OF KARI\IA'I'AIE'I'I'I*I«QImI'0. IQIIV1'~/.2oo%3~.,,I "._

BETWEEN:

Sri NarerIdI-a.  

S / 0 Mallappa GI)wd:1--.._ 

Aged 40 years.  -    
R/a W.D Salian C<)m_;'2I;--:I;'I'c1.'   ' 
KI.IkkIkat.1:e, ,    _,   
B2.I(ia§§z1be1:i;I3,vVi}iéIgci.,  1  
Udupi "I'aE'I.Ik      ...PETI'I'IONER

[By R'E_1l"1L.Ii.fiéiifi,VA_d:\=7()Ck?!,i'E?'II)? Sn' K.M.Na.t:£1ra 31 Adv.)
ANI): . %

'i'l'1c;jSI:;'3:.t:e of K;-.II*I'Ia-It2-Ika.

  R€_pi"t?E§--('§1"}i:i:'(i1 by i1.s"'SI.;.It"c
V P1._Ib1i C PI OS er'; 1.1 1.01',

H igll. Cvc.)I.1IrI"'Q1322-III} a't,a.kaI.

 I3 €1.Ij'Ig"aiII'f¢_.'_  ~ ...RESPONDE2N'1'

(Sf?  SI:bramahmanya Iifihaa; HCGP)

This CI'l.RP.  filed 3/8. 397 R/w 40.1 of Cr.P.C.

 }")If'E'l_"\A_./"T'i1'}(_g to seat'. aside I'hC'A."~.p'I'0A$'€(?Li'[i()'i"\_V '

€xami.1'1ed in all 10 V'-*ii.1'1tés:§cs _Aéu2c1'«_j p01"().g1t;1--g':ve_d'015

d0(rL1r1'1€nt.s. The {F1211 Cm_;}ft': ac':n"*.

cviclcnce as est,e1.biishing the v0' a--1g'e1--_i r'_d1As'f the accused

and Co11seq1..1ent,ly C0:.'f;i§*'1A.(?1.c:.ff 1'g.i117i 'by_ if'1*1§7 judgn.1em. dated

81.03.2005

. AAgg_g’ri<§v.r;id._*by¥.t,his'yvéxs in (:1'i1'1'".11'1'1al

appcéil N.5′:};’.-“,J1d1<* I a11pp<–ta} 21150 (tam(-? 10 be
c1is1'I1isse*€i. ]\_.'._2;'c'lVI;V1'}..S2fAAb(")Ih=.'{.}_1(' j1..1('ig"1'1'1('.l'11S he bc-.f()rc* t}"1i.s
C(}"E,j§:l'1'V.

«.”_E–.;e(-=7é3T:1’§’1t*c1 co1,.u1sc~,i for the 1.)c?i.it:icd>11<-zr would

('i()1{'ElE:§.I}t'd'V P.W.1 who ]'1au=. lodgcd the (*.0mplaint' is not

é§11'1"eye wimcéss. P.W.2 ('rl21im$ 1.0 be the pill1'0r1 ricler and

éig<%(_'o_:'c1i11_, they were: 1*iding f’I’1e:=’ 1’1’1<)1:_01"(éy(:l€~:

towards Mz:11'd1ge1_1()1'<0'. Elm bus ci1"ivsii.e

dim(:t’i()I’1 }_)y 1′ he é1(_.’.(_fL.ESC(‘] (i2::Sid1c(_i 221Lg§z.1i1d2.:~’;t’ E”h<r E"-"('9 \.vi'1c:m,.1sc*c1. I1.

is fu1’ther n(‘)i.i(‘.e(i that wi”1ilc~. <')\.-'(*1'1.21l<i1'1g a;111<)1'.1'1crg§?C.'ni(*le

the E.1CCfl1SC-"Cf had t:ra1\re1'scd vomplc-nxcly t'.(:~~~-1;'he. __'xiighéj

margin of the road ig1'1()1'ing_'§ the (.)1'1wcé(')nj.ir1g'=ft:}'érffic., 'J'h'(:._V

2'-1o(_'.1.1s(-'.~cl has not dispu1T.c*cl E116, oc'c,1._11j.~e4i'1cb_ ()–r "i1'1¢;j £1:-}r".i;

that he was the driver ()f,1"pg* vcl'ii.<;jlG in €._g'1,'1"£*.f}"i',i"()11._V§

Contem1'().n of P.W-2 E:ha1' 21 Vvfaillion on
1:11 0 m<_)1,()r(:y('rle cIri\IVcA*:–.r.1..V:"E:3_}/lj'1 not disputed.
the .f4(:t. had suffered
i1'1jU.I'E€/S i1:1_. ta if; in the hospital
s11]3})(;»;*1'.s__ his t.est.i1n(my that he was
with hié 'QtI1§fi'":&%li'L§Ai1 oCCurrC(i. In ['ac*.I', he

l'121,$3_§11i2rde e1 t*j2.1!,_Q_2_g(:)ri(v'z1l st221.t.em(r1'1'1" that. the 2-1(_'('.used was

. (iri,\ri:1'1§,;' at -hv.ig1'1_ -Speecl in a 1'a..vas filddé’ by the-‘: E1(.’.C1.1S(;’d in cr()ss~

exaf11.m”‘aAf£T.i(j11 only to 1’1eg_§21I’.{: the 2111c-:g__§a1ic)1T1 of 1’1eg1ige11ce.

‘I””l’1e:zjcé is no s1%:.ggestior} to this witness about: {he

dg_?(:1,1rren(:e or about $110 1.1 1’1for1′:u r1a’i:c’-*. dcat.h of Hameed

and in_}’u1’y I0 Sl’1a_1’ic-;:f. A sp(_:>t:. MaI”aa1za1′ £SX.P~2 is

})1’t:’}f)&11’£;’.d afim’ 1″:*o(:1’p1. of t’i’1c=~ 1’i0d of 0110 n”10m;h a1_’1″ff1’1(:e Lmder Sc(t1.io1″1 337 and

respectively. The fine ar1″1mr:_.m. $h:ei11″be paid _t..”Ti’:.fJ\]Vé2.,f¢.

With this 0bse1″\r21tion.’i’;h_é-.pet;itimi _V”dié’;V)6s”(-:’cl of. V

The: accused shall b1fVé:’.._t.1’1e% 1fVia1″”C()L11’t to

__…~

Sd
Judge