.. E .. 'K '*«_V,_/'
1
us; 'rm: mm: C()'UR'f 01? KA R'§\z"A'ITAK_A 3;~s.:~zvns';%:.ép
i30r21v:.:33izmgar, . V '_ AV
Ba.:r:gaI1'e W 56!} €;;'=«f£._(fi'_;-- 1: j},.P::Eité<;sne1',
{By SAG-.Lf'V'i5:Eixf;iih:%;rh gag»: ,:
,--mg):
E. This St2:1;<3';:)if' E{;:.;f1'1:a-ti-1E<'2i"
RcvenueI)é'p21r{::I£:nE_ A S
MS. B£i§I_{j.§.§§g, ~ V %
- B2-'::7._,:}j:'é{};*gV.~ 5&1; é:; ; %%%%% .. ~
§i:3.g3_:i%::e:ii:3: '¥ _§;.':_g«<..é?;s~.: S€Ci'&'3§&§"'_'y'
_ frsi "i'vfi':»:2__% ezézggi 3:',
SEO; .__La:.<: £?*zEL1':a.:s%ev2zrz2§; R:':dL§§s
-- Ag::d'zib<'51.;i }'£3i£.3.'$§
. A €§0:p;=z.§:;1 R_<:%{¥é%:
*4
A ' --WiE:::--<§':3 G£11T'{§i:"iE":,
»Ba1n;;j21E<}r€«:--'Sf§€} __{}2?'.§
";%p§.é£g'i»'§{f'Ez:V'»V
4. K.F\?LBzibL1
S/:3. Lam: MuI1i§wa:11"z;g Raid;
zixged 21b0:§t 1-'?-2 y:;:.:2.rs;.
{'Pei:%iis:"::1@1'::'e 2 {<3 4 art':
R/at : .K.at'ha1ipa}}-':1 'v'i_11a§g;e
K(3:*:1m21ngz1i21 Layrgut.
Béagttr Hnbli
Bzmgalmfe South. Tazlukj
5. Sma. R. Ex-'Ia11ju}.z1
W/<'}. SE". Shi'varam
Aged about 48 yi-zarg _
R/at No.9. 3" ;\'¥:;in R<§::ci,----.__ f
SuddagLz.ntepaIya '
B2m.gaz1're M 560 (329. .
:1 A,_IVI,Srin:.s.1:§i-1'
Sz'o.A.N, £\z1;3njLt¥i'é£?}\'21i'ah. "
Aged 66 3,-e;u_~:g;}:%
?. S mt:. V-S hékiéihziiffii * '
\7W. A'_M._S'i'inz:t'E},_V ' '
Aggeid 56 ggétaztsy V V __
[16 Rfatt Eff)?" V
DE<'}. Egaztai .'A:."a"s:1:":2:2§:Ef2
gigs-if :ib»~tf.»:;.§ 'Z?;'5 '_y'€:.£u'5§
. W}, g-5;E21zE'§§$,__§'§§}£i
1.
».§};'<3.'- Lzziéi. A . M . r:;::'m::%;§":
” _ ‘ .’,’%§!§;i’§%{“§A’%.§E3§}§.§§ ééé jg::3;2.:’:M?Rfia:EG”Cnws
W_iI.sunG3rde11 -9 _ ,
Bezaagaaiasre ~«« 560 ()2? ,,.E{espc313d:3:3%__:;a” ‘ ” ‘*-
(By Sri,Va::1kz1§es}1 Bodderi, ASA f’:;>r_I{1 _ – V _
Smi. Sandhya P1″ab:,1hu for R. MLéra.1_i{Eh2-1;<;:1 'Saimzttha-1-
For R2 :0 E0) I
This V\z’;”€t. Petiti-23:1 is filtzd £E’P.dE:iT.vA£’§iC’i’€.S72.26 22.? 0f
the Constitmion {bf [n:;1i;1 witlx 2: ‘§3?’t'”‘«”.’i.’y”-f’.{§””i(E3\’i]fz,1£}.Sh th’:’5~11n_'{:Q§”;:ing _fi” for fur§he;’ m°d<::r:~; {his day,
the €é)LkI.¥f'E E'{~?i2;i{§€'3 tir:'::"'f"Qi'i<_)}2~.-*'§mg':.-'
' ' ' 'V_vQRDER
A.~'%.?.v"ri{ ;:)é1;§:ii{}';2§::f 21"-§:e:'i. vate Hcmging Ci')~()p€f§"{.1§i\»"€Z'1 Saciety
$11391::§et*;§~~e:'2§' zine: Indian fitiephenéz En<§us§r&es;, E1215;
'g::fés3'::'§:.a?s:,§"~th§§~;" §3e:i{.i;: fin” :;a;esti<;:1i:1g {he 1.ega_ii_t§; cf the
1'izaii"€§;;;1§%2§h~V.,_isshgzaééi by 11%;: Stem? Gm-'crn:n¢:ni: {:x¢:'éa<§,f:'$ gs:e;§:§f:S:3-t§§<):'} 48 { E E 01' 31%: Egg-amé A<:;2 écig E§*§’¥}«>’h
‘.__{‘§'<}:" :2;§2s:s:§*f ;'?'s<;:§'} :i;'1*: ;3:z’:ceca:§§;1g& in
$3
-4-
0? an i’3><;{t3I}£' {.317 1 :-.1c:;:.2{‘}fE{T}A of
YeIEuk1.z11t:: Vifléigfii-._ Bzzzggm” I~~{a:>bii, Bzirlgg;-1¥<_vr<3 Smith. T;-1.}:Lt*}::;4_';111&
Bzi.;:';ga=fl<'::'c:: I3és«:tr§<:t.
2., it is; fbé.’ qL1::;11 fikzci E§t3€kiI1g the §r;3E.i<':wing"pAa'213?_é:_"~iv-
"1s:<;:.u? (I wrif :3)' e"ei'fz'<3ri'2:<z.'_Ezzf zzr2j;: ':2f:'2e*rV é2';sf(!;{»:':j"*()':=w
c!ir1%cz'€0;2 as :.2'ce€1maz{ fiz', c;:4g;;:;§f;.§rzgV._:I'2.e N{;£ffj<.rcz!z}5:I2,
cfe;'2()ZqT]'_'_vir'zg, rfze? fir}-zflffrz 5v.1'\fe9 ;Z'{;%f.;T{)}%i~z-zze(z.9m'ir2g .2'
{acre 22 gm-z.f£1,S' zmsier (}?;44'C'?5;'2{9()7 dczzezf
3,529,253.25: . 'A,,{..«§.x/;;'"5::?£§z.zI'§%~f§\j ,,,}§::;éf;;*.:?z;?' f;:;_3,.; rise? 2*'
rcaFf;f:r{J€':£é'e%2£.V V. ~ V «
F'e_E'ii.i{)'fiv.é,<:.pry..:h£:..p§€:.rnis€ {hat {he subjsct land fEgL:.ring
éra {he '§¥«i€héE1'a1x%i22V'i."sf§Qfifi– 51:'i«-M': ai At1nexureAA was s;ubje::E:
matterr 0%' 2: ;2:feE%:n_i_:1::z'§*~–,:}()&i'%'icz:ti:3n dated 2E%.§.E§85 isssuad by
{he Slime iZ?%vt’:rr§§’1:::%.:1; pxjapusiizg :0 acqziire an :a>s:..{e:.”;: of 5′”? £’tCi”f3S
{:*fl.;%i1::”§ Si: :’E§:é_$’«;’=2{_iE§2:g:5 :::”§s;:;:(.i in e:§iff”f V’£’:::_i’§f}.:§:1g :1 Eayaaz by the p€3Eii§.(}Y1€}”~-3{}C§€:t.}’ 539 {hat
{E23 é;=«:>;§ Eh;-2% Ezzizci 21:35.2 C£’£E”VC ms: si{z;~:s; smé
{§§5§§§”§%’l9i§§§?u§§’ :.::éz:’:n;g:S;: ziié :'”;é::3:’:_”:’%¥:2::f’$ <3? {.3226 %s:;s;:i.§:{},-1
W-
4. ¥V§1iIe the pI”{f1iI’E’EiI}2i§’y :mti’f’i_<:21ii:':~:1 ismlésd ::n,&a:*:1'
Se{:t:§:1 4 (I) of the ,»~’~’xc.;£._ it £1pp€£iI’§’§ wzxs; f’we<;1 by it S<:.c'{.i_<é:z_6
(1; n<):ifi<':21%i0z1 <m:d 24,i_}1.I986 and i: is fu1."Lh<*:_r_—§i{§§'1§§*;§§«?.{é§:;;E:« .
pagsing :3'? an an.v2u'd on 24%. 298?. it_i§;.».s1¥_$ the §’i:’r’aEé;;:s’ V
of the pstiti<::m":2' {hat in 1:-:-:m3s of the: }3b'i'<.)\zi*s,i[:§i1s; (:5 -S7i:.;t;ic:11"
the: Act 2;m;;r} “i:;::;:I:3d “ihtz State
G<3verr1mer:i:, evidencing i2l1<ii.I1g '§5{§f%§S€3fi§.SiC}vf§;'~{}f'_.{W0 pa:'c<3.1s of
.'~:':;b}'i?;_a;:i' ;:.::;2:'i:.i:z:'s'*» t1i§.§":§?fK'f?.E}.y'S',:}'§ZU.1Ti3«A sand zmothar
izmezi, {EH8 being ltiu;
paired of Iarirj n:1j;;3ua.:;uri”t’; 3’t}’.’ig1_1A’11’i;L$ af;d’i ggu ma of Phut Khamb
as pair the :1ii{i<:a:t.i:)z3
5..
iamd §€;;2te::fji iv: _’:§1«’::,¥ viiia
i_sé;1,1¢:d. ‘v’i.(f€–4__.z5A§T’.V£°:€V§i¥}lT{3’~rE” .;ii_,s1’1 thés being foilczwved up by ya:
E
. _ zzrézfiégpiii’ efficial IE”}£Ew§1§{}_§;{i}7;(§E}I¥§ Liamazd 8.?,2(}(}4, camy at Arinexure
‘E*-ffiéfi –.t.i’1e:-:~.;;>éiitEv<;§2?:',..in.<;fic:;1E%:':<i that {he 0SS£:3-S$iG§"1 af r«;L:b'¢3:;:E lands
. _ _ AV . ::~
573*".
L 2._i:§3%:23.:;~: in. ;§§;.§\<3.?;{‘}f.%€j}z3’x has been mzzded (}’.:’€:Ei’ to
‘ ._tE2:§ gée-xiii o’:1<:-:_"»s;a.)::i.€:£§;.
it is; in %_E:::: %}2:::kg:'<;u:éa§ 9%.' s;u.§.s2:d§:::g:; mat ‘{§E€=
VA V’ §§;?}:%i§s:’;::31’E*:;:s«; ;:§3?;’}§’:2:.2s;:E3{:<i E_§3.%.s.:s C§}iEE."§ szcsaééaéizg §'.:* a:gzz::5;§§%s3g :23? {E16
<
N-3
<:§a§mi_1°:5; H} be {he E»;:g;1i hrigir1z:1. §<a2thed.a_:' 022:':
Muizésam-.z;_11y Reéciy, and §I%2<3:r';<:.._ wirm claim ':nt':.:31":2:;i L1r1'<.3..e.f:::!»-
IT'i?pI."€5?$i3I}{fi(_1 by c0un.:sc:E. }~Z::spc.:n<E:é11t N'cs.E Stan: .
represténtmil by Sré.V¢:t1i<air:ésh E)<:E_d.r3.ri,' ic:z::"iv1'§=: ei4i':::{L11ei:
r:3spn..é<:.r_). ;:ii:;. '15'<:~§w;2iii' Qf "
the S't.2iié§ G<)vemn"2€:nt.
T3. The most in€pa>riar:t__ f’;–:iSpL ‘c:f that the. State
Gm-‘ern1ne.{:t E’:as.:::i’k5:_n {E35 §;€a:a~§1 th::£.fi;–h_e Sizafii has gaesither taken
0ss€Ssvi’::§fi°{‘;féiae Siii¥”s3¢’i’~.1£i2ads ii’:}’2″‘h;1ci ii hand:-;:d €)V€F actuai
§>::;s:-;:=:§:si{m cvf {hag ‘s;t:;i§j:éct:__jV1:zz:3c35: t0 the petifiioner-seciaiy and
ti1r3r€:f?:.–:ni’e, it ;;;?;3iV.z15; though the Siam G<)vci2'11:12ent has berm
aV"ifI;'";11{¥;i<i:é§.gfi' 'iE:f' i'i:;¢p<}xw'@?§"§énd€1' S€3C[§OE"l 48 (I) ofthés Act.
$0 c(::uz1tm~ has: warn filai «:32: baE*:aE.f' sf
z'€:s;§<s::<'i:;':2.%:;~.«~:3 Ear} $8., :~;:;b1I2iSsi<}§: of Smt. Szmdhygi E)I."E§.bE'£U.=
V§=.'3f'i::'§._E{'3€_} '{:'?un5;§3E ’59.? igézssgaé §T€$§}{.}§’lC§€EE{E£ is; that the :.’a3:_;p<'2:f;.<iz:2":3:.;«; am:
§-€;j::f§V;":::;:<:%'2 in ;3::. af the §;:::.£§;a i§1<:y ;':'::":3_;:%s"::3ei éaé
'Q
;u¢ 8 ll.
p{‘}$f5t’ES5§§€’}I1 at} almzgs and «’;”;’£;1I.”1ii3I’ §JI.”UCf:€:d§.figS bazfwe ibis CO%}I”‘{
;:>m«;>f<:vf*t§'1i::- is-mds havixig I.'<3111.;1énc2<,i in t1mirps:~;11.
9. 3. have hazufi Sri GL. ‘v’i$;hvm11at.h, 1.<:2ufnc<'£3§.:i1’1ié;i::§. f€::. ‘ .
the p<'::t%.iié.:r1eI', Stii V:3nk:3.Et3sh i}<)<id¢::r,%_,_' E:3;3;::%':'€:'§:i'A .';5'*xC%'2'\'_' §:_V
rezspcmderzi NC.-5&1 and Smi. Sandhya P’t”:1E3§éL_t; “iIT€:-;,1f’£f’:<=:g'i' c.:cfm.'nsé%:I'i'Af{$'£"–..
r:~;-spamdent N<é.s;.2 to 10.
1.0., $31 GL. Vis;.¥.i;wz111a3.i’E’1; -A V1:é::11u”i;::d c(>{1′:’:;«.;:3VE’ .f01f the
p§:.t;iti011e:.:* hag ms;-zdet very v€11t:An*;em°:;inr;§._S:’p§AiV§£éLi_ submissions to
contexid that the ‘:i:3_i.;i–n0fific;3.tié3n ..s§ bz1d in Eaw; {hat {he
Stem: C?’V(3i}é;iri’1§r1}:,-H1 <E3%g}%;;Ed"~;fi,i)'t ha?$é""<éx€rci$eci its pi)"/£33' Lxnder
Se<:ti0r1748'(E}0*f":ha:.,_}ix£:t§=:::fi:;:”G0ve:”nmc=:nt E;<)u§$se5;s;in of
s.:,:.2b§ec:_’§ §.;1§1.d${;’~Vz2sf;’ p£j:i*. A::11Euz’6m.E%?, 21:26 <«3%.-@321 i1'§€1"<2€lfE€.i' having
» hamézépgi <§*w3:' fg3s§:a::3.s.j__i_{;1j1 {if Ehia very kind in §’2w:}u_r 9f the
gxziiéiiiatr:’:¢€’:.’%:E§<i'i::ty :15 pm" A§'£E'i{.':'Xu§."é3 F in Ehif }"€":£'tE" E{.}{}»<L ths: Siam:
.§:éV{}j:~ié:"F;:f;{§'c.;f§'{'v{fem §:::v<2;" e:se;:5rcis;e fig p<:w6:' uraeziizr 3&1':-£[isi}E"E $8 { E }
_§¥§§é5 A33: £134? §§fzs::°::f§f§:; §.’§Ei’.i3 :’;s>%£E*§c;1E’§:’>:: s;u’.1′:z:’s: ‘fawn {MS E3a3;i.<:
§:§g:.g::§§.::=,=..' "
_ 9 L54
IL In aéditiiéfi Siii GL. Vighwanathy Eaarneii é’;€3E.’§f13s’3i 1’%::«’r
she f3*£§§§’f§i{}3§€I’ has very fiifééfigly arge-<1 that the Siam Gizfweifiz-I;i.é:.r::
e.:::'a§_d :39: Exam :3aiIaie.§afi§: embarked upsn :0 iss;:":::;1:r3<:2:ifi§:€§;::fi£i{%i2– ~
under Seciéaa 48 I; Z} of the Act, pariésaiariy? ;;f»:§,:g'?;'z:§_*§,%A, {(3. 2
{he antiquity (is? the ?¢1{.3q?1.1iSi'{i{}i'1 'vbéi'i:gA'§:f
1985 and fixerciging pewer <11-S.( fa: 'V
fircypmng the pfacmdingaz; ~;§i7ter ;<V$Vf'LA:2;_¥;ac)uI;2V5' §z'¢é;;r$ is mat
a béma fide: or §}.'°G§3€-1" exezgtésé but mare
'im§3Grta:1.i§.y .r.1;G:i.'b:ee:2 put on :3_€g ¥§je¢’iix<}%:$~._ if -it imends, ta iiifi igsue <3?
:10:ifEca:i0r£" s,;:*:<_'i§;r x'Sec2:§§3§1.?i_.8 of ihe: Act? the natifisaiion arise
stjffarf-3 Eéfim me%%~y:.:;;:.%%;§§ having been iS§SE}£{i in viaiatian <3?"
— pz:f::’c-i§§::$ ‘:3? :33%u;?aiE jzzsiice.
‘T2. wasnsei ¥%?{§iLi§£§ giaaa $'{:”{>r:g rséiazzca 0:’: {ha
“.h§u<£g'r:3$~::£";.@i' Ehza Szzgrems C€}i;::'°¥: in {:23 sage Sf S2"A3"E
5f§;s;::r§:{§?;::§g;§;¥':' .i–§§§;'S£'£Z§$3 EfAf{§jfi;_3'*£' E§$§'£Q*§'E,fE§
.v , Supmymaé L
~ i{}~
A.S'S{}C!A.TI();"\r' VS. S1541 T157 OF KA RSV?-1 YAKA AN}? GTHERS
I'i;':p£}i"{€(,i in AIR ,2{}{}.I SC 43?.
1.3. (83; d.mwi_ng:_ £i[.tf3i1Ii.{.)I1 tn the c.x:.11m’:1zz£i<311_.–«'§;§' 'zhié.-' .
S;¥.§§,7sI'i'iiS$%<):": :3? Sri. 'sz"isEz\x;z1:1aih.; I;_ha:.I__f£h<;: gjézi%f£.'azk:s;::'§S;<:i:.§.€t;.;V
being in the p1’1 f 21 bté:1_<:f.'ic%;:'1*y fi7{f§:"' big:-11;é:1*i:f'*~.if._§i':i–:.
subjeci igmdsg WSFE $1,1gh1 {:3 1363- z1gfL;~z;Mé:”ed émgl ‘thy: ‘:;;:.:i;’;~1.ii’;<§iii<§n of "
lands being in Y€H£1kL¥:'é'.§i \s'i.'3.1a§;c3,__*Be'gu:" hobiig ~B2mgz:l0:*e
Souih Taluk and hendng ggzot ézténaiiutisid _s§{t3é_:;zsv:ét_i_a1E1y exsarz in {he
year E987 and z:g=:gh.<3; p..r:E:s;c*:::t"'Eei'11a:i:e;__;if<: ::<)m:{~:rne(§ in the
yeax' ?,()€§}i5i«;"TE,i*1e r"c;. Em 'w;i§f fm: 't.'i1t::St21te Governmeni to hzwe
issued i.ii. 12<:::§fi::é,i{iz'§i:..::1;1n 48 (‘1) Cif the ACE; Wifhfitii
evez; S}}{‘§\’E{‘§§§g the”-:_’:,~§isi.:r’ié.:*s_§f”‘<:i§' p1"Vi<iing am rt:m.ity of
hfiétfing ‘is; p'<-;ti:i}{'%:n<é;–f; in the above cited jzzdgment, the
Cant': h:::–:;: f3ff31'}{.:é{r{3I1g§§' <ie:p:"é:<:z1£&::;i {he ps'a:cii«::e :;:sf ::<;_3%;
:ke.gp"g:2§§ %:h:3 "b§:nei"i£%;1i'3:" iz2'§h:'m<3{i. '€}a.:’kimg u_§{_>r}
V’L–.i§é:;§§g; E;§{}V’§A§’fiV(_%’~§;iE§{‘}iE mdez’ -Sc:;i: =38 {i} sf {ha Ac? ‘Em?
wii§::%f2:2,y£;1’gLA’l§7:*ié§*n zzcquisgizéam p3.”<:.:<::te:{E.i::g:~;; é:E"§:«,-1: {£36 S§,E§S%2'$§T:i3
ifzmzfé; %2{:§3a§ $3.22: :§1ag.E:: figs: mg }§_’}€:ii?:§%’§£’§§”i §EE.$:i 3}}: iiwé Sigma
%”
‘ fim .%'”%;;E§}§’§E§é:’:EZ:E2§E.§’%’z2.3 sf E§:::r §3e:%’i§E”§i;%§E%,f-E’ ?:2:<'§. pgsrzigépzziagi in ms
WV! 1; Dr.
Gi;Tm:t1f11:31e:.H H<?n,:se.1e.ss H:.-irijzm .{€Z111pl:_sec$ As:;:’§ci:e:£é:”; had
C(}I’§’.§{E’, £0 b-ff: ::i§.<;m%.<;:§c'3<:;§ bath by {he Iezm1.<3<'i Siragie .§:.1d;gfr..;1T1:.:i {hc
Divis;ir;m Be:";_c;:h had aftizmeai the dis;r:1is:.sa§. but 112:xfiiiiié§<é3;;':;. t.ii::_ .
-Supr:;:.mc C€j}LEI.’E he-xi c.><:<:21s%<m 1:0 z:IE(:aw..£b,;: ;:p'pr§§:i"<;;fi1_y":"':')'t'=%:E*:z?_ V
I"{3é3.§§(3I1 that {he bszneficietry had mt bezégz gi_x?e'3£1 azi'<3pp.22;’ki11g upon ‘S_éL”§i.()1″} J,v”th::_:’pefitiza1ae1*–é;€3:1r”-j.s;iJbj <':;C§?I21::;;i§§' \.é¥f:ré:_. proposed to be
aaxstgumzai ami \7"§'§.{'1E'3?£;¥.ijé'v'sfa':1".€}f gi3(3'1"'L':if§"{Li~:?1AI;.iL}'I:"l=.§If1_};éS})CCT of E acre 22
guntas; of E.z1i;{j:; _.z11e"'y::2:_1""':2(}H3' v:md ' thitt 10:: without m';$:ic:c;~: :0
the p€{V"§vVi'z':}::c:tf~:;£:7:'{;<ictjé<%;; -c':T{éa.riy fa.-=ithi.:1 Kim: viazcs 0f the iztw
de.u:’i in this d:-szgisitm and that’ it can.
. _ :zcv:3:t§b<: é;us;£21E;:e€i'–w£nV__I_2;w,
§s_:§,._€;:)7u-§:te.1"i_I:g suns, submis~;:=;i<sn 0f Sifi
'\J;–:§:§<.;':Eé§:%: '§3<i'«;ié:"'§, §_e:2:m::d ASA; with §'€:§'i<::'em:<-;2 E0 the mégingié
j :':3<:<)z*é;Es; iiézjxi ii isg :_1<':'i;' 2:5»; Efxéagigh i'.h:3:. iS54§LE€3 0%' S:3§:t;i1r1 48 {1}
. :”Z’EiJ)§§fi1£3’£ifL§£’}§”: mas; 2.z:it§3:’:::t z.-my c’:pp:’>:fi:;:§s%:§f;: E0 1325 §3::i.é§é<.§:_":£;3;", in
4
W 1;; L4_
pzftwceedingsz that tbs ;r:;::1’d is it §:’.:3.’§i’ifi”iOI1§£ to this amxfi 1′}.1£}I.’€()\é'{3.%”
it is SUbiT1.i{T.€3C1 that the sat-::’}£ Prz:::;ider1t of théi So<:ie{y' .hf¢:tr:£44_':§;~3t§
is§;«;a;:r:3c;i 2: "N0 ()bj<:t:ti<m {T<:1't_%t'&<:2t{c3' that' issue. 0_f7t.1t<'s*£':f"F%éE;tt§(.33: 'M.
i,'E§'.}.d€'.¥' .Se<:tin 48 (E) of the Act anti t_’b.at’,_ijhe Stittéé'”G’.§;sgé’:’:tf2′:¢:1tj_ V
having not tztketu p{}f~”.S€:$;$i()E”.E 0?’ the”1«sa:i;§ec’t 1é§1′:7.c}:fs,.titje
neither “v’€St.t3d in the State Gt>f§%.3r:1ttte1i’t .__n:;’s;{Ah;1d”ath’€:” State ‘V
GO”v’t31.”I1i”I1€3§Ts’t lost its p{m{t:*:.:.jt0 isgué :;vt_:i::>ti’f?ic21tic>r:’iznéitéi” Sctctécsn
48 {.1} 0f the Act; that the m;)tii:’i-::’;;:tTi'<'§1'1 LT'<;p.x;fiVt§:' 'xgzalid in Eztw anti
th€:1fef§e:, th:2re§~vi$”;:g§’~zn::’tiit ;;n£,i~’:thin degervea to be
d_i3m_issed¢
ES. Sifit. ‘SElf1.€:fi”;.:./TtE1’~.?i;£ibfi’i3: i§z:1’11ed ctattnsei for I’€3SpE’)i1(i€n{.
Nag. 2 to E0 “§1p2t£”3ft”ii}m .s;u’;2.;3t>:’ti1133: the EiI.1bmiSSi{){§ made by the
«..Ee211’v3§:é’::E ;A§;i:;’;..i,_tic*ettzi§’ G~–»:1:–‘–;e.:émt”;r:t«*:2:t. :5x{§VO{3£}'[{: 3.33:3 paints»; eat that
_th€; §§tV1’x:?_:it3V{fQE :§£%E:;f{3,_ is; “i-:>t:a;2t.::<_mti;.:’:” atttai that they hasi zztzvci’ East p<'}sa:«;es;:<:%m1 of thee Eands
" . ';«.;t:;"V1¥ti»–:'§?:iz'.-t¥; Elhtf ttctgzziséétésrtt §'§§°t":é5€€3i§§§§§§S §:22=:§:1_g mt Eitean ::{'::;<;:Et::i<:<£
" -ea/kit": azftfigf 23; §;i§f3E§§;:*.- {:95 25% §":r:”;f: {Ease tEt§'{§£3§.§€’§E§ {if Zt§2€;§§§§F;§§§t.:4E”1
~« £3 «
pI’£}C<3€di.I}.g;"§._ {here was; no €.){E"i€1" :;h§::e to the Siatc: Gm-‘¢1′;m1e11t
except tn {imp the: 2:<:qa:ésitir1 ;>r0c«:=::’3&i:1§gs in .:”es;7e<;t._{'3-ii'ih_i:§
€_E;{é2E'§T af Ezmii: that the 2:a::'.i<_3:_*1 is; 'jusE'ified not 111y—-hm 41’::;.:.[t:s .
ais in izgtw, §’h:3§’r;3f€T§.1’t:Z:, ‘LIrg€s; 1″0:’ :i__%s;::1i’s;:s;:iE”‘e:~.f:» ‘£f.’V1’e: _’wI’iL§_V V
przzéitien.
16. I have _peru:~;<3{"} {ha ;j§c:§~s,§¢{%’£E”iiit;1 ”
to the f§13bE’m:S.”§i(}§’3 made: z1i.§h_e b;12″;”‘ é.”;-vzriiei’ <ird<:i'$~1§'»as$ed by
{his Court in ihfb e:1_a?,iie.:' 1°c72Ls_1icib:.i':'x»irrii_ §}i–?i"'1_':'»3~'.*'r'»fi€5315 I'€-3P€3nd33'15'5
chiming Lifidéf-I:'~vE}'1¥;§IviE i_n¥_t<3.z§m<}3 in §n;a.;h§s%;;¥2999~3(;:r€}d’:.1<;a2o{_ at ;3;r2v:1::X'u:i:: Im the: E}Q::§:§§§.{-}§2? §'£{3Wh€"3:§T§f in {ha <:a7e:.:.rs.;c
'=1:é£' e?2,f<iEe:'«. is ':v.~;'§§i~::._Vé.’:f1~~§5z’: §”%C%E’ it is»: ifiéficzitiid ihai {hat wréi §7€-§§'{§{}¥’3:’3§’
¥§ra»’2i51:’ .1′? §§{3$:_
§Sf§}fi, if’: fact Ehc Lfaiitrf’ szééught far by pé3E’§ti{§II’:£:I’
§___Eé:é .r§5<;§:n<§$:§:;<~; aim} :s;:;';m_:;:: <':%'h2.':.§'s'; vv';::«: :j<:::':§e.& is '$121:
-.:’::§””f€;:z’_ ‘:7~,;'”:_E{§=; gim aha? ;;:::’z>u§’::i iifzzzi 22; :’§z:>.:”j; mééaé’ a:;=2:”s:”2@§ E36
sjéx
~m1.4–
g:’a:1t<%:<E E2": §'a2::.1:’ ;>fp;*’ix-:=::1t:z:§ in writ. j1,:1’i_s_-;&ia:.ti0rs w__i_thut
e>;;m1iI1ir1g thii’ ‘fz2<:tz:z1I. 2'iSp%i3;.1,i§’;.§i
{hat ii £5; not 2: fit m;1′:.1::’3r “for €X£1I’I’:iI’1Z1ii0i”i in WI’iE. jE;’.I’.%i.§§C1Vi€3f’.’§.{V3’§;i “i;1.§_if’T V’
a Ifizktfeé” [(3 be exzmnineti by the g.i\2i:E’tii”}’:;W«. ”
not iiead tea the in1’E:r:’:1a<:<': that; .@iti1;§1?JE:i*:.¢A.
p<)s;sc:s:;i_0n or {hat the ff:Sp()I1d6I§I.S""g{€iTC net':
17. Ii iié not I1C;?C€?;f§E§;2’£’}T_’g’ fu:”aher
merits; {if the mafia”, ‘v’::§’$i<3n of the
State Lt§.§ ir~s cieafiy
i11di<::1E<:d!éil*i'ci::§LicedEli' f._ht:»._::'ec<:e:'dE;"";iI$<1 I'ns;ofa2' the iegal
p::i%:i01:”*._i:;” ;t<71'1{:¢Vi;a}:d.%$»{;'<3}:s§: "fi)1* ::":x<~:r<;:is;ing {hes powéss" zinikz"
Scctifln 48"[1_}" sjsf fl'.€-'VA{3'iI.Eéf'(1.€Ii.i€3CL 21:; 211.30 the vestizw of the
\._4 V . . c
$'ub_'jgg:t."};z.nds i'r;.__£Eé€ State. G'§:s;ve>:;”;.”: afsffihe §;=:£iTd§ are :20: t2:k_en, {he éitéés of {he izmd
::i:”:*s’:;-%:}s;–v.$;£’i~:§fé~:?§::–._<:e*:.r~:s*;.<=:§'$ a2*s<;§ :E%:':§; havézzg hem ix §;}€3.'.s7f§i3S§;'§§£_}Y§.,
i1':t:£'e..__%i§V'é2i%_"_~.§__m;::%{%€E.§:":":<»3:':E {<3 Ehe: Sm: G<_3ve::1.m::n£ in §S§Si.§§f1§»g
::<;{if§.:::::.§,.';_é:é .uéé<§::_:" S:1 4% {T if; {if 1;%§:;%.§%:<E;"2*:wi::g '{n':»m_
u :
‘J1
I
21<:qL1isi{i<;m pz'c€.€Liings mart: 5&0 if the. I2-ind (§WI1€2″S hawe no
iwbjeciitkri for i:;$L:e:: of 2: I1(}{§fiC2E[i€’)F1 Llngier s:3I1 48 ‘t’_4€’}f::;§”
I8 E:z:§::~§lu’ as the ‘Lxdcrxzzmt. 0f’ the $12 r’c’+:mLii’t~.ii’i ‘ ~
» z: . .A _ L. _ T
<:.:1:~;:3 of Siam: G0w::"I11:";<:::t }ic}:.15;&:.F::s;s.__4H212"i§a:if"=_§€;1";§3'I_yec:$._ V
Asa-;11 is C-(“}§}C€I°U(3(L the f2Li(‘.'{§.; uf”th2:i;._Cz5ié;<: ci*e;ii'§.y'
{hat ibis Siam: Cr(3VcEi'i3I3'ii':r1E: wa1s–.,;f1";'<:–uw'i1.§r1V"*ftiéiia " fitirs 'V
intemiavns than trying to :'a:;¥..c;:§'caaI:A..:'¥1'é=:=$_§;~*;?iéi'i_.i3é3r1r2'i'i't"':;c'}2£_ght {G be
a<:h_ir:v<:d in i':w0ur of M'ernb<3fs «:3?'SEi1tt:..Ciz§i»-E:mmezii Houseiess
Harijgm EZ1":2pEye’g”~;[ 9’§_\s;s<)::_i;1t§()n~':;1:id fij-if"–wh:}VE§<: benefit them was;
p17<)p<}5;23,';i"b§? 21ut.i*if§iirit_i<:*.3_"m f<)1_9':fi' 2": layout: and to mrve Gut
sitas to ban {ii:::t1'ii:m1;?:t:i t*_ members (if that Staécz Gtwtianxraem
I*é¥1;zs;{:EaS3 Hiaifian’E31*np1€=}yéé.s As:;0ciati<'m.
§Vfr._iI':;1t <:as:;c~:x on ihree <;<:as%<3nsw, pzfesiimimiry
'fi§;1i«%T'iE<.:é3E:§£ii2§§V %1;§;':i.-Exam ii-;.<-;u<3(i am{ Q1'
Em: {"3¥;'§%1<21:;'ii:-<3*{3zu'}i::r EKEEG zzgétifémzziiawgzs ind not bean pur::.z_;¢<_i by
._f'{':-§?T<';_wé:1§' zip mi}: {E26 é:§s;u::=:- 9%" Saicéiam £3 {E} :.1i.i_f’.zziééaétx §3″§£3″E.E
“*1
T. ~45 R , -“S i _
— {Exam <52: §§'E{:3 5:3' <'}:::.:;;.<;§@:: aim bégiéc {:<:%'zr:2§1*1:?:21i fézaé a:<}m{': mg)
4-6 {(5 A-(
with 2: <:i::n3 by abs 1;-zgzd wI1€..;t~;. “Fizz: _;:*£;i’i5I.a;b.1e
1.’€€is’;’}I'{i?é sfevitziircai that {hit Stair: Ezzaai mt 2-‘z<:t€<,i iz1__*;:«. b(j:1':§'?:"'f7iL§'i:—- ~
manner Ea ishzuingg the x:vi:h<;ir"zm;;1§ §E(':)$'§§'-i:it;::}.{A'i(§E1£" bu.V!': é*'£€€ 2"£é'i::.§f;1ni'..V
1"t3C(§i"dS we1'e *x.xz'it11%1':2E<:f from the Cf<31j;<:; iigd E'h::£t' it. Was;
such c§1"<:.umstan;:r£ i()o}.e1?”m’e
a’*:mbaI’E{i11g Ejp{}:I14f€’T witlfiir2iw’i’i1g”‘f1f§jmi'”:z«::.q{1.is;it’if’V:.he*i3zi::’;d3 < jfthé'~S'{3cVie'€V'y. V
28, Such i5'.~§ :'E?(_.):i'_£hC__§i1;E3'dii{}{E in the pra-$311: CEISEE, the
zzc:;_uisi{i:;:e%:<§.i::'gS" i%!;1.v:2 been cmrcfuded and the
A_ g%:v§::1>:’Zr:;:*{;§§f;t’uP2:1vi.:j’gé$_§g_ued n<){i.fi<.:aiic:::t. {}f 034:’: pa-Lrcei of Band zrécsmzurégag an
s:x::3;,_r£§ 0? } ‘i:i._Cf:£f 23 §§:L:.nt:a.s; :3? ‘mad, as ii ‘W213 E’s.,m<£ 3:163 :35;
"-»3ubmi:tc;§1~b§,:' the ka:;:1':'§e<;i coagzazti that there": w'¢;':: c:1:;<{ru0s;x*i’:3Ic~: fm’ {he f”0rm.;1ti.<.3:1 of the sites«: 33}; the pi3fi§'§{)I1{i*I"+
:;0c:i:::§y.
21. Ba: {hat zipmft thfif jL:.dg_men§ 0? tbs: Sup1″::*m{: ~
my (§§3iI1’i{3EE iieithexf can be C(}i’i3§§I’%3f3,*d €ii§'”£i »:i¢cIa1.r2:i%:§”:i'{iii’ §éi’Va%5_:.’1£’._V
as :3: diSCf:”:§’l1if.1g .;’21i_%(3 iaid d(}we*L whic11 bi1i;1sA’ ihi.<§'C_1i.1..f,i%;)éi’»
the pI.’€:m..i_sc that the SL:pr::r”n€: C::;–.u»%i’-Més 21 S[§.§.3{“;i’1:£)I_””_;C{L§?V.1I’!3ViVNil} the
hifZI’E1I'{Z’h:~,»”‘ ()1? 0urjL:dis:i:;t1
22. A {;§e<:1.az'21ti()I.1. L:11gi_é'r._Sc.r§_iin. is i11Ee1’prete.d or
the rmeiznillg.asitéibzzfxid E€?.._E’i'”:-£?:__ wj1d “ben<:":f'i<.:iz:11°j_,«" i:%§ 'Chit debzxte
per :56 iii; the 'iuv::)rd ‘beneficiary’ is; :10: 3
ESEE§.I§.,it£}§’jg’ .::*:>s;;’,vr;te.:£;’s;in’._f{mr1{§,~.–“in the Lzmd Ac{_;u§:~_;i_§é::.m Act ané
£hezf:;::f§g}r§:..,” in 1h::”‘;::>1)_:;;:1;<;: of the ward 'be:a€f'i’s”»._<;:%é"–.;;z£:"'%5:33'2:27;: néacie at evzm :1 éézzciéag is gi»-'£3113 it <:2:m<}t be
_;:{%3}$i§"z:e:§;E._;£:ev V?;':».§ié:;:Ezz.m:i::_3:; f;;:f 1:5′; {he zzsapéact 02?’
§:’§–::§5~:%:g z;t%:'<§;;.-saciéziaz wiiia 2.: diacaiirnibééé r:n'i»:": ;:<:<:<3:":;iE:"sgg {(72 S3
%'s%'{}I”1C1 in
tir1r;: ‘v’€.§’}* first. §3ar::gr’;:ph of:}*1e ‘jL1<.i§,g1";"::::11':'
23. 1 .fit1<;¥ {E16 d::r€.1m:. Cu1’t_i’S »:”_:§:_”
bz-iscaéci an the Ht’3Ct3SS§.t.:y’ :2? {ha State {‘j{?é1′:’:”:33g_3I’;§’ {«j0 1″11.{>:’g”A
the <;z:est.i<)n to wheihcx" the bgzaczficié-=.1'jy 'i$ <:11{iti1 e';iA is be Eiééiziri'
zmd 23:5; 1:0 wheiihtzr the pfi§ECi§C3f€i§ '£)f"I1&,1{EJI'EiVf j_L1§iiCi2 2,1E1;;'af’fiaé;–. p:.*0$~=isi<')ns of Seciion 48
( E) of the Act? it could bi: i»h21'i"~it' Vi:§f;e–i*£he1' imziudeci 01'
exciuded zztc.
, __ji;=§:;§§;:2§:3Vi:-L :’:::;”i§£i:§r§:r§ §:;as’;e:.<;¥. on no c<':+nt<'::~:t <31? 0;": :3:
;:nce3s’i{:;1 not. ;:rr.V;?:1LLzt}i0_:jf{‘;:’in iazw, nor can it be C .<:§<::<:i_d<?:::di;…_Jwiiich happens ':0 be a bi:1di_r1gi
» , §i"€C»:i x;fi_;_: xsv «sf I’:.h<:5 Eéiaiiiii', E am of {he opirmin that
.§§"iE3Z"'_€;3 £3. _::§<i:§§:.:'–%.:;arat§<':»r2 9?' Emv 0:' discatfning mE:é Eaézi {fawn in
“i:h§.»..1[-%§::*;i;Tse:.i_’f’;’§VVV:}§°j’£’§é::§ Sugtremz: €0:;.:’I: reiécd upém by the iissazaimaii
<.::'_}:,:.:'::s;<3E i:7:;§z"_§t,§..;$ §}eEi%.%z:«::a::z'", vvizéch can be ?;aE<e:n :12; :3 binding
i-1%; . —
– 1.9 w
pI’C-Cedfimt that @;’11<31'g:;:s §*.'1fo1n {his d<3::%;&;i:.1 cited stigma and
Eh<;3r<3:f('m::, {his 21:'gu:.nez.11: CL1E"§I}(}E be £;'1L'C€p{€d.¢
25. T%aLIgh Sri. \5ishwzin:1£h. SLIbI3’1.i.IS tha1i_.fi§–e *
{Ef thci :’§Lz;tm’:mc: Court hzzs bt’f€I1 f{?H'(“,3’»-‘.–“‘!i3′(,’i .?:>y v§,;’éx-*vI{:*:”:’:,aIV’ véi::’E1:;€’;?..
Bwcfaes of this: Célilifi, E am not ve£’§?’ i1i1g3_:”é§seci’as -311 i:E1″6,, .f.=1.:fé;V’€’.
izigtzzzaczé, r1{:ithe1° any iaw is (§€C}i’;1T{;fé-:lf~~I1()I” az L1-1’$CCvIT11:ib]L§’1,fé§iE(3 is to
be ffii:’i:.”VV Nothing
further foilowg if any more “T-judgithséynIs;~«..;1’t’c’.i’;?e::iédered based on
mach a: pre;n_ise3;’v€t:%§[11-~theft? is; 1’I{“)xSiJ§ChvI”‘E%,ti§}..I3K}¥° .2: dsicfiairzitioxz that
can c:(>r> :éfi{1Lit.’€-z:Lv5b_inLi’é:’fiV§; :;i’,1’£}§G:*ity,._
26;fx4′;’em:.:§:?; (E1? i;h:: “‘pr’é$e:2t ii’ cleaiz” from the
§’:::~::i:<;»¥.%:a: évhs. V:3{'§'€Em:r hm} aim k: :3 <:s1'tL1£1it\; bc:3f0:fs;=: tint:
1?:;s4,z<§' :xf""3§::«:%:§<:';§; 48 { i} :':0ti.fi<:z2ti:::'.; am for {his 1F€3£1530r't 3.§5.£(} the
:E.:1_§;5is;-5s_,_if";;gz§s'};1v.,;iizitéiciiinibie 0;" Eaéd z;i{'}w:2 by §'f'z.%3 Suprfims Cz:.:’E in
. EEK? <i:3<:is—-i}0:1":;é}iec£ LE§}0§E by Ehé": C€}3_Ef}S€§ fog' SE16 ;3<:£i*£§<'m is no:
i »;zE::°:,:;i_:::;§ E0 33%: if;-2<:{:~; (E? Kim §3:*<:s~;:=21'1t <:2z:=;{: am? in {he
gig
-20~
£:iI”iZ¥.1i11f§t::ii”§i,2{‘:5§L, there %}c§:2.g 220 111_€2*it, this; writ p<::_it"é0:1 is E.iz:b'i:':
to be &i:e1.:ii..%s;ed and i5; 2:1c<::m;ii11gijg éi:;'n1isse{i.
NG*'3"'